Characterization and Novel Application of Power Over Fiber for Electronics in a Harsh Environment

arXiv:2405.16816 · physics.ins-det, hep-ex · Submitted 2024-05-27 · Read on arXiv

Listen

Radio episode about this paper

Transcript

Introduction to the show: ident: Physics. The day in general physics: instruments, methods and results across the field.

Kai: We're looking at the paper: "Characterization and Novel Application of Power Over Fiber for Electronics in a Harsh Environment".

Paper summary: Kai: The paper lays out how they characterized their Power Over Fiber system, showing the efficiency numbers and the light noise mitigation strategies they used. They show that the optical-to-electrical power conversion efficiency of the OPCs was about fifty-one percent in liquid nitrogen and about forty-five percent at room temperature for a range of optical input powers from zero point five to one watt <ref:2405.16816#pg3>.

Mira: And the paper's title really reflects what it does, characterizing how Power Over Fiber works and applies it in a harsh environment, which is crucial because these settings are tough for sensitive electronics <ref:2405.16816#pg1>. They show they can manage power delivery reliably when you need isolation from the ground or operating at very low temperatures.

Lev: What this means for real hardware is that the system isn't just theoretical; it has been validated in a test facility at CERN, which is a major step toward making these kinds of power systems practical for large-scale experiments <ref:2405.16816#pg7>. The authors provide concrete data on performance in those specific conditions.

Kai: In simple terms, this paper tells us that Power Over Fiber technology has moved beyond just being something you read about; it's now a tested method for powering sensitive detectors in challenging settings like cryogenic environments and high voltage setups <ref:2405.16816#pg2>.

Mira: It shows the practical capability of Power Over Fiber to solve a real problem in high energy physics experiments where you need to power components that have specific environmental requirements <ref:2405.16816#pg3>.

Lev: And the authors clearly demonstrated how to handle the material science side, from fiber selection down to managing thermal losses and noise mitigation, which is exactly what engineers need when building something robust for those environments <ref:2405.16816#pg3>.

Conclusion: Kai: We've seen how they tested this Power Over Fiber setup in liquid nitrogen and other extreme conditions, and now we're going to talk about what that actually means for these kinds of experiments <ref:2405.16816#pg7>.

Mira: The title itself says "Characterization and Novel Application," which tells us they aren't just showing a cool experiment; they are really defining how reliable this power delivery system is in tough settings <ref:2405.16816#pg1>.

Lev: I mean, the authors really focused on the material science side—the fibers, the jackets, everything—which is where you find the real engineering hurdles when you try to make something work in deep cryogenics <ref:2405.16816#pg3>.

Kai: Yeah, they did a lot of work down there, and it seems like they've managed to bring this technology from just a concept into something that actually runs reliably for months in an operational environment <ref:2405.16816#pg7>.

Mira: What I find interesting is the efficiency numbers, like that fifty-one percent conversion rate in liquid nitrogen; that's not something you see easily when you talk about power transfer across a fiber <ref:2405.16816#pg3>.

Lev: From my side, those efficiencies are important because they tell us how much overhead we have to deal with on the actual hardware; if it's only fifty-one percent, that means the rest of the system has to work harder <ref:2405.16816#pg3>.

Kai: And they showed that even with those losses, the system can maintain a very low noise level when you plug in a lot of power and use some simple shielding techniques <ref:2405.16816#pg3>.

Mira: That noise mitigation part—covering the connectors with silicone paste and copper tape—that's practical advice for anyone trying to deploy this in a lab setting right now <ref:2405.16816#pg3>.

Lev: Yeah, but what they didn't cover much is how this scales up to massive arrays; we need to know if those losses stay linear or if they suddenly jump when you try to power ten thousand detectors instead of just one <ref:2405.16816#pg3>.

Kai: That's exactly what the next part of the paper should address, figuring out those scaling issues for real hardware applications <ref:2405.16816#pg3>.

M. A. Arroyavea, B. Beherab, F. Cavannaa, A. Felda, F. Guoc, A. Heindelb, C.Ä K.Ã Jungc, ± Kocha, ń Leon Silveriobṽ, D. A Martinez Caicedob⠽, C. McGrew⠽, A. Paudela, W. Pellicoa, R. Riveraa, É Rodr´ıguez Rondonb⠽, S.Ş Sacerdotie, P. Shanahana, W. Shic⠽, ń Torres Mu˜nozb⠽, D. Totanid, C. Uyb⠽, C.Û Vermeulenb⠽, and H. Vieira de Souzae

Fermi National Accelerator Laboratory · South Dakota School of Mines and Technology · Stony Brook University, SUNY · University of California Santa Barbara · ƖUniversité Paris Cité, CNRS, Astroparticule et Cosmologie

physics.ins-det, hep-ex

Submitted: 2024-05-27

Updated: 2024-05-27

Comments: 29 pages, 32 figures

Journal ref: 2024 JINST 19 P10019

DOI: 10.1088/1748-0221/19/10/P10019

License: http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/

Importance score: 76/100

The gist: Power-over-Fiber (PoF) technology offers a reliable means of power transmission in cryogenic environments, which is crucial for applications like photon detector modules in experiments such as DUNE.

Key concepts

Cryogenic Power Conversion Efficiency
This measures how effectively optical light is turned into electrical power within the system. The efficiency was found to be about 51% in liquid nitrogen (LN2) and 45% at room temperature for a specific range of input light powers, depending on the semiconductor material used.
Optical Fiber Characterization
The study involved selecting and testing optical fibers specifically for PoF applications. The fibers have a core diameter of 62.5 micrometers and are protected by a black polyvinylidene fluoride (PVDF) jacket to ensure they can withstand the extreme cold and physical stresses of cryogenic operation.
Light Noise Mitigation
Excess light noise, which can interfere with sensitive detectors, was addressed by improving connections. Covering the optical power conversion components with electronic-grade silicone paste and copper tape reduced this noise significantly, bringing it down to a very low level suitable for sensitive measurements.
Experimental Validation
PoF technology was successfully tested at CERN to supply power to X-ARAPUCAs photodetectors in a high-voltage, cryogenic setting. The long-term test showed that the efficiency remained stable, varying by less than 2.6% over six months of operation.

Terminology

Summary

Power-over-Fiber (PoF) technology offers a reliable means of power transmission in cryogenic environments, which is crucial for applications like photon detector modules in experiments such as DUNE. p. 0

Where the paper says it

In a novel application of PoF, power is provided to photon detector modules located on a surface at ∼ 300 kV with respect to ground in the planned DUNE experiment. In cryogenic environments, PoF offers a reliable means of power transmission, leveraging optical fibers to transfer power with minimal system degradation.

This paper presents the R&D effort of PoF in extreme conditions and underscores its capacity to revolutionize power delivery and management in critical applications. p. 0
Where the paper says it

PoF technology excels in maintaining low noise levels when delivering power to sensitive electronic systems operating in extreme temperatures and high voltage environments. This paper presents the R&D effort of PoF in extreme conditions and underscores its capacity to revolutionize power delivery and management in critical applications, offering a dependable solution with low noise, optimal efficiency, and superior isolation.

Cryogenic Power Conversion Efficiency

The optical-to-electrical power conversion efficiency of the OPCs was measured to be about 51% in LN2 and 45% at room temperature for a range of optical input powers ranging from 0.5 - 1 W. The maximum OPC Efficiency achieved for the 12 OPCs measured in LN2 was ∼51%, while ∼45% was achieved for the room temperature measurements. p. 3

Where the paper says it

A maximum efficiency of ∼51% was achieved for the 12 OPCs measured in LN2, while ∼45% was achieved for the room temperature measurements. Modifications to the OPC improved the cryogenic efficiency with a slight negative impact 4

This efficiency is dependent upon the matching of the laser light wavelength and the OPC semiconductor gap energy. p. 4
Where the paper says it

to the warm efficiency. Additionally, efficiency is dependent upon the matching of the laser light wavelength and the OPC semiconductor gap energy.

Optical Fiber Characterization

The optical fibers used in the PoF system have a core diameter of 62.5 µm and are encased in a black polyvinylidene fluoride (PVDF) jacket. p. 1

Where the paper says it

5 µm are utilized to transmit the laser diode power. The fibers have a black polyvinylidene fluoride (PVDF) jacket and are FC terminated.

The process of down-selecting optical fibers suitable for PoF at cryogenic temperatures took ∼ 3 years of research and testing across 5 types of fibers. p. 7
Where the paper says it

2 m Table 3: Characteristics of MH GoPower Company Limited [18] optical fibers includes a cladding, coating, buffer, black PVDF jacket, connector type and the cable length. The process of down-selecting optical fibers suitable for PoF at cryogenic temperatures took ∼ 3 years of research and testing across 5 types of fibers.

Quality assurance procedures included visual inspection, light transmission tests, and power performance tests to ensure suitability for PoF technology. p. 8
Where the paper says it

1 Quality Assurance (QA/QC) Procedures In order to ensure that optical fibers are suitable for their use in the PoF technology, a three step quality assurance procedure was developed: 1. Visual inspection: A visual inspection is needed to look for any visible physical damage of the fiber, fiber ends (core and cladding) and jacket surface.

Optical Power Loss Analysis

The optical power loss due to thermal contraction and bending of the fibers was characterized by subtracting the optical power loss at LN2 and room temperatures. The results showed that the power loss per meter for fibers with a PVDF jacket is approximately three times higher than that for fibers without jackets when submerged in LN2. p. 8

Where the paper says it

5 2500 without jacket/Acrylate 105 200 ETFE/Polyimide 105 100 PFA/Acrylate 105 100 PFA/Polyimide Table 4: List of different optical fibers tested with their varying specifications. 1 Quality Assurance (QA/QC) Procedures In order to ensure that optical fibers are suitable for their use in the PoF technology, a three step quality assurance procedure was developed: 1.

Power loss measurements showed a linear dependence on the input power and the amount of fiber submerged. p. 3
Where the paper says it

First, the test was conducted at room temperature (Figure 2, left), and was later repeated at LN2 temperatures (Figure 2, right). During the LN2 measurements, the OPCs were submerged ∼ 5 cm in LN2 to ensure that the measurements were not affected by any power loss due to thermal contraction in the fiber jacket, as described in Section 3.

Light Noise Mitigation

The most critical light noise beyond the single photoelectron level comes from the OPC output pins and the FC-FC connector that interfaces the optical fiber and OPCs. Investigations of several solutions show that covering both OPC and the OPC FC-FC connector with adequate electronic-grade silicone paste and a minimum of 1mm-thick copper tape can easily bring light noise down to the level of 10−2 SPE per 10 µs. All fibers can be shielded within black PTFE tubes to further reduce the light noise. p. 1

Where the paper says it

The fibers have a black polyvinylidene fluoride (PVDF) jacket and are FC terminated. Sheathing opacity prevents light from leaking out of the fiber and minimizes background light noise to the PDS (Section 3.

Experimental Validation

The PoF technology was successfully integrated into a cold box test facility at CERN to power X-ARAPUCAs photodetectors in a high-voltage and cryogenic environment. The demonstration marked the first successful instance of powering photodetectors at high voltage and in a cryogenic environment using PoF technology in HEP. p. 1

Where the paper says it

The development of the DUNE vertical drift (VD) TPC configuration with its largely unobstructed geometry presents an opportunity to provide excellent photo-detection coverage using ∼ 320 photo-detectors known as X-ARAPUCAs [6] placed in the cathode plane (see Figure 1, left) and read them out by DUNE VD cold electronics motherboard (DCEM) [5], provided that the X-ARAPUCAs can be electrically isolated for safe operation on high-voltage surfaces of the TPC. This requirement is met for the Photon Detector System (PDS) of the DUNE VD detector using power-over-fiber (PoF) in a novel application both in particle detectors for high energy physics and in a cryogenic environment.

A long-term test of the OPC operating in LN2 showed that during ∼ 6. p. 5
Where the paper says it

A maximum efficiency of ∼51% was achieved for the 12 OPCs measured in LN2, while ∼45% was achieved for the room temperature measurements. 2 Long Term Test at Cryogenic Temperatures To assess the feasibility of using OPCs under cryogenic conditions for extended time periods, a long-term test setup was designed, constructed, and conducted.

1 months of operation, the efficiency variation from conversion of optical-to-electrical power is less than 2. p. 1
Where the paper says it

The electronics power is obtained by stacking two gallium arsenide (GaAs) OPCs connected in parallel on a cold readout board as shown in Figure 1 (right). The GaAs OPCs convert the optical power to electrical power at an efficiency that depends upon the load matching to laser power and to a lesser extent upon the temperature.

6%.

Green — the paper says it, and the page is printed. Red — no passage carries it, so treat that sentence as unverified. The same check runs on your own text: check a summary against its source, $5.

Improvements for AI systems

1

Improve power delivery in cryogenic environments by employing Power-over-Fiber (PoF) technology to provide a reliable means of power transmission, leveraging optical fibers to transfer power with minimal system degradation in settings like liquid argon or liquid nitrogen.

2

Enable high energy physics detectors to operate reliably at high voltage and extreme temperatures by utilizing OPCs with Max OPC Efficiency (Optical-to-Electrical) 51% (45% at room temperature) even in cryogenic conditions.

3

Enhance data quality in photodetector systems by mitigating light leakage from PoF components, as covering the OPC and the OPC FC-FC connector with adequate electronic-grade silicone paste and a minimum of 1mm-thick copper tape can easily bring light noise down to the level of 10−2 SPE per 10 µs.

4

Develop more robust optical fiber systems for harsh environments by characterizing power loss due to thermal contraction and fiber bending, quantifying these losses using formulas like Ploss = (Ploss ± δP)LN2 − (Ploss ± δP)room temperatures.

5

Optimize laser transmitter stability by implementing control circuits that allow the laser transmitters to stabilize after a period, as observed in tests showing that the laser transmitter stabilized after 25 minutes of operation at room temperature.

Abstract

Power-over-Fiber (PoF) technology has been used extensively in settings where high voltages require isolation from ground. In a novel application of PoF, power is provided to photon detector modules located on a surface at about 300 kV with respect to ground in the planned DUNE experiment. In cryogenic environments, PoF offers a reliable means of power transmission, leveraging optical fibers to transfer power with minimal system degradation. PoF technology excels in maintaining low noise levels when delivering power to sensitive electronic systems operating in extreme temperatures and high voltage environments. This paper presents the R & D effort of PoF in extreme conditions and underscores its capacity to revolutionize power delivery and management in critical applications, offering a dependable solution with low noise, optimal efficiency, and superior isolation.

Sources

Related papers