Development of a Cryogenic Anti-Coincidence System Based on Scintillating Crystals Read Out with Kinetic Inductance Detectors for BULLKID-DM

arXiv:2611.17089 · physics.ins-det · Submitted 2026-11-12 · Read on arXiv

Listen

Radio episode about this paper

Transcript

Introduction to the show: ident: Physics. The day in general physics: instruments, methods and results across the field.

Kai: I'm Kai.

Mira: And I'm Mira, here with Lev.

Kai: We're looking at the paper: "Development of a Cryogenic Anti-Coincidence System Based on Scintillating Crystals Read Out with Kinetic Inductance Detectors for BULLKID-DM".

Mira: Here's the gist of the paper. The BULLKID-DM experiment proposes a cryogenic active anti-coincidence system based on scintillating crystals read out with phonon-mediated Kinetic Inductance Detectors to search for WIMP-like dark matter particles with masses of 1 GeV or lower and a WIMP-nucleon interaction cross section down to 10−43 cm2 Pruning redundant reasoning tokens The experiment utilizes a detector consisting of a stack of 16 silicon wafers instrumented with phonon-mediated superconducting Kinetic Inductance Detectors (KIDs), to be operated at the underground facility of the Laboratori Nazionali del Gran Sasso (LNGS), Italy To reduce the residual background arising from γ-rays, neutrons, and muons, a cryogenic active anti-coincidence system (veto) operating at mK temperature surrounding the main detector is under development This veto detector consists of segmented scintillating crystals read out by phonon-mediated KID light detectors Veto Concept The veto must operate at millikelvin temperatures and detect particle interactions with a threshold below 50 keV Dense scintillators containing high-atomic-number elements increase the probability of gamma-ray interactions within a compact volume Crystals containing nuclei with large thermal-neutron capture cross sections can further improve neutron rejection Scintillation light produced by particle interactions is read out by an array of KID-based light detectors consisting of ∼ (2×2) cm2 silicon wafers instrumented with one or more KIDs, providing a large sensitive area matched to the crystal faces Using KIDs allows us to use the same readout system as the central detector The current layout requires between 30 and 60 photosensors to ensure efficient light collection Crystal Selection and Background Simulations Previous studies investigated the light yield and scintillation decay time of candidate crystals down to approximately 20 K These measurements identified bismuth germanate (BGO, Bi4Ge3O12) and cerium-doped gadolinium aluminum gallium garnet (GAGG(Ce), Gd3Al2Ga3O12: Ce) as promising materials BGO combines high density with efficient γ-ray attenuation and an increased light yield upon cooling GAGG exhibited a high light yield at 20 K and contains gadolinium, making it particularly suitable for thermal-neutron capture Monte Carlo simulations, based on the Geant4 toolkit

13: , were performed to evaluate the background reduction achievable by replacing part of the passive shielding with these scintillating materials As previously reported in Ref.

11: , the BGO configuration reduces the γ-ray background by approximately a factor of 10, while a GAGG veto configuration reduces the neutron background by approximately a factor of 12, relative to the reference passive shielding Table I reports the background rejection efficiency as a function of the veto energy threshold Millikelvin Characterization of BGO and GAGG We tested (2 × 2 × 1) cm3 BGO and GAGG crystals coupled to the KID-based light detector shown in Fig.

Mira: 2 These measurements were performed in an Oxford Instruments Proteox dilution refrigerator at the INFN Pisa cryogenic facility The assemblies were mounted on the mixing-chamber stage, which reached a temperature of approximately 10 mK during the tests BGO exhibits a clear 137Cs photopeak with an energy resolution of 12.9% FWHM and an energy threshold of approximately 90 keV For GAGG, the corresponding values are 49.5% and 130 keV, with a detected light yield approximately half that of BGO These results point toward a mixed layout with an outer thin GAGG layer (thick enough to efficiently capture thermal neutrons) and an inner bulk BGO layer for gamma-ray energy containment Two-Module Prototype with Multiplexed Readout To test larger crystals and demonstrate the scalability of readout, we assembled a prototype, shown in Fig.

Kai: 4 The assembly includes two (10 × 2.5 × 2) cm3 BGO crystals read out by four light detectors facing the short end faces of the two crystals Validating this connection scheme is a key step toward extending the multiplexed readout to the full veto We first performed a transmission coefficient (S21) scan of the complete readout chain, confirming that all KIDs can be addressed through the interconnected chips The prototype achieved an energy threshold of 122 keV This is sufficiently narrow to accommodate the approximately 60 required resonators within the 750-950 MHz readout bandwidth BGO seems to achieve better preliminary energy resolution as a result of a higher light yield in the small-crystal setup The larger prototype shows all five expected resonances and reconstructs the 137Cs photopeak with an estimated threshold of 122 keV These results support the feasibility of a cryogenic scintillating veto with multiple KID light detectors REFERENCES

4: D.

Paper summary: Kai: Moving on to what this paper actually claims about the system development, they detail the design of this veto layer. They show it as a segmented layer of scintillating crystals surrounding the main detector stack.

Mira: And they specify that these crystals will be read out by approximately thirty to sixty light detectors, and each detector is based on a two by two centimeter area made of silicon wafers instrumented with KIDs.

Lev: That specific readout scheme, using those KIDs, is important because it allows them to use the same readout system for both the main detector and this veto. It shows how scalable that readout architecture could be.

Kai: They also discuss the requirements for operation of this veto, which is that it has to function at millikelvin temperatures and be sensitive to interactions below five hundred keV.

Mira: And they explore different crystal selections, noting that dense scintillators with high atomic number elements increase the probability of gamma-ray interactions within a compact volume.

Lev: They test Bismuth Germanate and GAGG for these roles, finding that BGO offers a higher light yield at twenty Kelvin, which is important when you're talking about energy resolution.

Kai: And they also look at neutron rejection by choosing crystals with large thermal neutron capture cross sections, which is where GAGG comes in handy because of the gadolinium content.

Mira: So, the material choice is directly tied to what kind of background you are trying to reject: gamma rays versus neutrons.

Lev: The characterization tests they did involved mounting these crystals with the KID-based light detectors in a dilution refrigerator at Oxford Instruments Proteox, reaching temperatures around ten millikelvin.

Kai: And they report some specific performance numbers for those materials, like BGO showing a one hundred thirty-seven cesium photopeak with an energy resolution of twelve point nine percent FWHM and an energy threshold of approximately ninety keV.

Mira: GAGG has different characteristics, showing a light yield about half that of BGO, but it also has its own specific thresholds and resolutions that they measure in those tests.

Lev: The prototype they built was a two-module setup with multiplexed readout, which is a key step for showing how to scale up the connections to the full veto system.

Kai: They validated that connection scheme by performing a transmission coefficient scan of the entire readout chain, confirming that all those KIDs can be addressed through their interconnected chips.

Mira: So, they’ve shown both the material properties and a proof-of-concept layout for how this whole active veto system is intended to work together.

Conclusion: Kai: Looking at the paper's title, "Development of a Cryogenic Anti-Coincidence System Based on Scintillating Crystals Read Out with Kinetic Inductance Detectors for BULLKID-DM," it really captures the essence of what they built here.

Mira: It’s about taking a physical component, these scintillating crystals, and coupling them with this advanced readout technique using KIDs to create a functional veto system.

Lev: What this means in simple terms is that they're demonstrating a path toward actively cleaning up the detector environment at extremely low temperatures to significantly lower the noise floor.

Kai: They are proving that you can use these materials and detectors to reduce background rates, like from gamma rays or neutrons, down to levels where they are relevant for searching for dark matter particles with very low interaction cross sections.

Mira: The implication is that if this system works as well as their tests suggest, it makes the search for those one giga-electron volt WIMP-like particles much more sensitive because the noise from the detector itself is minimized <ref:2611.17089#pg1>.

Lev: The paper shows feasibility in terms of testing smaller crystals and building a prototype with multiplexed readout, which suggests this could move toward a real hardware implementation on a larger scale.

T. Lari, G. Spina, A. Acevedo-Renterơ, L. E. Ardila-Perez, L. Bandiera, C. Bonomo, M. Calvo, M. Cappelli, R. Caravita, F. Carillo, F. Cescato, U.,  Chowdhury,  D., ™ A Crovo, ℳ A Cruciani, ℴ A D’Addabbo, M. del Gallo Roccagiovine, M. De Lucia, G. Del Castello, D. Delicato, F. Ferraro,  M Folcarelli,  S Fu, R Gartmann, ™ M Grassi, ℴ V Guidiℶ D L Helisℸ L Malagutti, A Mazzolari, A Monfardini,  T Muscheid, D Nicolo`,

Dipartimento di Fisica Sapienza Universita di Roma · INFN Sezione di Roma INFN Sezione di Pisa INFN Laboratori Nazionali del Gran Sasso Institute for Data Processing and Electronics Karlsruhe Institute of Technology INFN - TIFPA Dipartimento di Fisica e Scienze della Terra Universita di Ferrara

physics.ins-det

Submitted: 2026-11-12

Updated: 2026-11-12

License: http://arxiv.org/licenses/nonexclusive-distrib/1.0/

Importance score: 78/100

The gist: The BULLKID-DM experiment proposes a cryogenic active anti-coincidence system based on scintillating crystals read out with phonon-mediated Kinetic Inductance Detectors to search for WIMP-like dark…

Key concepts

Kinetic Inductance Detectors (KIDs)
These are superconducting detectors that measure energy by sensing changes in the kinetic inductance of a material. They work by detecting the microwave photons emitted when an interaction occurs, allowing for sensitive detection at very low temperatures.
Cryogenic Active Anti-Coincidence System
This is a veto detector designed to reject unwanted background particles like gamma rays and neutrons. It operates at millikelvin temperatures and uses scintillating crystals to detect particle interactions, effectively filtering out noise from the main experiment.
BGO and GAGG Crystals
These are specific scintillating materials tested for their suitability in the veto system. BGO is used for its high density and gamma-ray attenuation, while GAGG contains gadolinium to improve neutron rejection through thermal neutron capture.

Terminology

Summary

The BULLKID-DM experiment proposes a cryogenic active anti-coincidence system based on scintillating crystals read out with phonon-mediated Kinetic Inductance Detectors to search for WIMP-like dark matter particles with masses of 1 GeV or lower and a WIMP-nucleon interaction cross section down to 10−43 cm2

Pruning redundant reasoning tokens

The experiment utilizes a detector consisting of a stack of 16 silicon wafers instrumented with phonon-mediated superconducting Kinetic Inductance Detectors (KIDs), to be operated at the underground facility of the Laboratori Nazionali del Gran Sasso (LNGS), Italy To reduce the residual background arising from γ-rays, neutrons, and muons, a cryogenic active anti-coincidence system (veto) operating at mK temperature surrounding the main detector is under development This veto detector consists of segmented scintillating crystals read out by phonon-mediated KID light detectors

Veto Concept

The veto must operate at millikelvin temperatures and detect particle interactions with a threshold below 50 keV Dense scintillators containing high-atomic-number elements increase the probability of gamma-ray interactions within a compact volume Crystals containing nuclei with large thermal-neutron capture cross sections can further improve neutron rejection Scintillation light produced by particle interactions is read out by an array of KID-based light detectors consisting of ∼ (2×2) cm2 silicon wafers instrumented with one or more KIDs, providing a large sensitive area matched to the crystal faces Using KIDs allows us to use the same readout system as the central detector The current layout requires between 30 and 60 photosensors to ensure efficient light collection

Crystal Selection and Background Simulations

Previous studies investigated the light yield and scintillation decay time of candidate crystals down to approximately 20 K These measurements identified bismuth germanate (BGO, Bi4Ge3O12) and cerium-doped gadolinium aluminum gallium garnet (GAGG(Ce), Gd3Al2Ga3O12: Ce) as promising materials BGO combines high density with efficient γ-ray attenuation and an increased light yield upon cooling GAGG exhibited a high light yield at 20 K and contains gadolinium, making it particularly suitable for thermal-neutron capture Monte Carlo simulations, based on the Geant4 toolkit [13], were performed to evaluate the background reduction achievable by replacing part of the passive shielding with these scintillating materials As previously reported in Ref. [11], the BGO configuration reduces the γ-ray background by approximately a factor of 10, while a GAGG veto configuration reduces the neutron background by approximately a factor of 12, relative to the reference passive shielding Table I reports the background rejection efficiency as a function of the veto energy threshold

Millikelvin Characterization of BGO and GAGG

We tested (2 × 2 × 1) cm3 BGO and GAGG crystals coupled to the KID-based light detector shown in Fig. 2 These measurements were performed in an Oxford Instruments Proteox dilution refrigerator at the INFN Pisa cryogenic facility The assemblies were mounted on the mixing-chamber stage, which reached a temperature of approximately 10 mK during the tests BGO exhibits a clear 137Cs photopeak with an energy resolution of 12. p. 29% FWHM and an energy threshold of approximately 90 keV For GAGG, the corresponding values are 49. p. 25% and 130 keV, with a detected light yield approximately half that of BGO These results point toward a mixed layout with an outer thin GAGG layer (thick enough to efficiently capture thermal neutrons) and an inner bulk BGO layer for gamma-ray energy containment

Two-Module Prototype with Multiplexed Readout

To test larger crystals and demonstrate the scalability of readout, we assembled a prototype, shown in Fig. 4 The assembly includes two (10 × 2. p. 35 × 2) cm3 BGO crystals read out by four light detectors facing the short end faces of the two crystals Validating this connection scheme is a key step toward extending the multiplexed readout to the full veto We first performed a transmission coefficient (S21) scan of the complete readout chain, confirming that all KIDs can be addressed through the interconnected chips The prototype achieved an energy threshold of 122 keV This is sufficiently narrow to accommodate the approximately 60 required resonators within the 750-950 MHz readout bandwidth

Conclusions

BGO seems to achieve better preliminary energy resolution as a result of a higher light yield in the small-crystal setup The larger prototype shows all five expected resonances and reconstructs the 137Cs photopeak with an estimated threshold of 122 keV These results support the feasibility of a cryogenic scintillating veto with multiple KID light detectors

REFERENCES

[4] D. Delicato, A. p. 4 p. 4 p. 4 Ahmad, L. Bandiera, M. p. 4 p. 4 p. 4 Calvo, M. Cappelli, G. p. 4 Del Castello, M. p. 4 p. 4 del Gallo Roccagiovine, M. p. 4 Giammei, V. p. 4 Guidi et al. p. 4, “Low-energy spectrum of the BULLKID detector array operated on surface,” The European Physical Journal C

[5] D. Delicato, A. Acevedo-Renter´ıa, M. p. 4 Folcarelli, G. p. 4 Del Castello, M. Cappelli, L. p. 4 Ardila-Perez, L. p. 4 p. 4 p. 4 Bandiera, C. p. 4 Bonomo, M. Calvo et al., “Background of the BULLKID detector array operated with moderate shield on surface” arXiv preprint arXiv:2605. p. 402468

[6] M. Folcarelli, D. p. 4 Delicato, A. Acevedo-Renter´ıa, L. p. 4 p. 4 Ardila-Perez, L. Bandiera, M. Calvo et al., “Energy calibration of bulk events in the BULLKID detector” The European Physical Journal C

[7] M. Folcarelli, A. p. 4 Acevedo-Renter´ıa, L. Ardila-Perez, L. Bandiera, M. Calvo et al., “Projected sensitivity to light WIMP-like particles of the BULLKID-DM experiment” arXiv preprint arXiv:2601.13766

[8] C. Bucci, S. Capelli, M. p. 4 Carrettoni, M. p. 4 Clemenza, O. p. 4 Cremonesi, L. p. 4 Gironi et al., “Background study and Monte Carlo simulations for large-mass bolometers” The European Physical Journal A

[9] P. Belli et al. p. 4, “Deep underground neutron flux measurement with large BF3 counters” Il Nuovo Cimento A (1965-1970), vol. p. 4 101, no. 6, pp. 959–966

[10] Mei et al., “Muon-induced background study for underground laboratories” Physical Review D—Particles, Fields, Gravitation, and Cosmology, vol. p. 4 73, no. 5, p. 053004

[11] T. Lari et al. p. 4, “Developing the cryogenic veto for BULLKID-DM experiment” IEEE Transactions on Applied Superconductivity

[12] L. Cardani et al. p. 4, “Final results of CALDER: kinetic inductance light detectors to search for rare events” The European Physical Journal C

[13] J. Apostolakis et al. p. 4, “GEANT4-a simulation toolkit” Nuclear Instruments and Methods in Physics Research. p. 4 Section A: Accelerators, Spectrometers, Detectors and Associated Equipment, vol. p. 4 506, no. 3, pp. 250–303

[14] G. Del Castello, “LANTERN: Characterization technology for low threshold cryogenic detectors” IEEE Transactions on Applied Superconductivity

[15] J. Montgomery et al. p. 4, “The CRS: a scalable full-stack control system for Microwave Kinetic Inductance Detectors” in Millimeter, Submillimeter, and Far-Infrared Detectors and Instrumentation for Astronomy XII, vol. p. 4 13102. SPIE

[16] L. Ardila-Perez et al. p. 4, “The RFSoC-based electronics readout system for the BULLKID-DM experiment: sub-GeV dark matter detection with MKIDs” Journal of Instrumentation, vol. p. 4 21, no. 05, p.

Green — the paper says it, and the page is printed. Red — no passage carries it, so treat that sentence as unverified. The same check runs on your own text: check a summary against its source, $5.

Improvements for AI systems

  1. Improve WIMP search sensitivity by developing a cryogenic anti-coincidence system that reduces background rate in the target detector to 0.1 counts kg−1 day−1 keV−1 using segmented scintillating crystals read out by KID based light detectors. This system allows for background rejection and enhances the ability to set new limits on the WIMP–nucleon interaction cross section in the targeted mass range.

  2. Enhance dark matter detection capabilities by testing bismuth germanate (BGO) and gadolinium aluminum gallium garnet (GAGG) crystals at millikelvin temperatures, as these materials have been chosen for their properties like high light yield and thermal-neutron capture cross sections. This characterization is crucial for optimizing the veto material choice to achieve a veto energy threshold below 50 keV.

  3. Improve prototype scalability by demonstrating the successful operation of a two-module veto prototype with multiplexed readout, confirming that all expected KID resonances can be addressed through interconnected chips. This validates the architecture needed to extend the multiplexed readout system to the full veto configuration required for background reduction.

Sources

Related papers