Cavity optomechanics with a suspended resonant mirror
Listen
Radio episode about this paper
Transcript
Introduction to the show: ident: Physics. The day in general physics: instruments, methods and results across the field.
Kai: We're looking at the paper: "Cavity optomechanics with a suspended resonant mirror".
Mira: Here's the gist of the paper. Cavity optomechanics with a suspended resonant mirror investigates dispersive optomechanical effects in cavities consisting of a plane-plane arrangement of a broadband reflectivity mirror and an ultrathin, suspended resonant mirror.
Kai: Dispersive Optomechanical Models The investigation begins by examining dispersive optomechanics in this canonical system using both an analytical model and finite element method simulations of realistic structures.
Mira: The authors show that the magnitude of the optical spring shift in a Fano cavity is the same as in the corresponding broadband mirror cavity with the same internal loss, despite linewidth reduction observed at short cavity lengths.
Kai: The analytical model for a broadband mirror cavity provides an expression for the mechanical resonance frequency shift, which is largest when ∆ = κB/√3.
Title and authors: Kai: Let's talk about the title, "Cavity optomechanics with a suspended resonant mirror," and who wrote it. It’s focused on how these specific structures can be used for studying light-matter interaction at the quantum level.
Mira: The authors are Trishala Mitra, Gurpreet Singh, Søren Peder Madsen, and Aur´elien Dantan. They bring together expertise in physics and mechanical engineering to tackle this problem.
Lev: From my side looking at what they built, it’s about realizing a specific type of cavity where you have a high-Q internal optical resonance on top of the main mirror structure.
Kai: So, the real point is that by putting that suspended resonant mirror in there, they change the dynamics significantly compared to standard Fabry-Perot cavities.
Mira: What this paper shows is how this specific configuration affects dispersive optomechanics and how those effects manifest in both theoretical models and their experimental results.
Lev: The paper sets up a framework for understanding these coupling mechanisms, which is important because it tells us what the physics should look like before we even start building the hardware.
The paper's summary: Kai: So, to summarize what they did in "Cavity optomechanics with a suspended resonant mirror," they first looked at dispersive optomechanics using both an analytical model and finite element method simulations of real structures.
Mira: They then reported on experimental optical spring measurements using a suspended silicon nitride membrane that had a subwavelength grating pattern.
Lev: The key finding there is that the observed optical spring variations qualitatively match what the dispersive cavity optomechanics model predicted, but their actual magnitude was more than two orders of magnitude bigger than the model predicted.
Kai: They conclude by surmising this strong interaction is caused by photothermal effects and they propose a phenomenological model to account for it.
Mira: This means they are essentially combining the standard dispersive linear coupling with an extra treatment for light losses caused by imperfect interference between the incident mode and the guided mode in the grating.
Lev: It’s interesting that they are treating this as a separate phenomenon rather than just ignoring it, which is necessary because these extra losses are significant.
The paper's improvements: Kai: One improvement they suggest is to incorporate photothermal modeling directly into the system simulations to predict strong optomechanical interactions that go beyond standard dispersive linear coupling.
Mira: They also propose enhancing the analytical models by explicitly including a photothermal force term in the equations of motion for cavity optomechanics.
Lev: If they can do that, it would allow AI systems to more accurately predict those optical spring frequency shifts when extra losses limit peak reflectivity, which is what equation fifty-six describes.
Kai: They also suggest upgrading simulation pipelines to handle finite-size grating effects using finite element method simulations, including things like beam collimation and finite grating size losses.
Mira: This lets AI systems validate the coupled-mode model against real experimental structures, just as they did in section three of the paper.
Lev: And on the experimental side, they suggest improving data analysis tools to fit equation fifty more robustly across different cavity lengths and power regimes to extract parameters like alpha which is noted to be considerably much larger than one.
Conclusion: Kai: So, wrapping up the paper "Cavity optomechanics with a suspended resonant mirror," they summarize that linewidth narrowing at short lengths comes with a reduction in the optomechanical coupling compared to broadband cavities.
Mira: They also emphasize that those strong interactions observed suggest Fano cavities with suspended resonant mirrors are promising for quantum optomechanics using membrane-at-the-end cavities.
Lev: If I had to say something, the key thing is that you need to account for the photothermal effects because they are what drive those large shifts in the lab data.
Kai: I agree, that extra treatment is what bridges the gap between theory and experiment here.
Mira: It shows us that these specific geometries are viable candidates for building devices with suspended mirrors at the end of optical cavities for quantum applications.
Department of Physics and Astronomy, Aarhus University · Department of Mechanical and Production Engineering, Aarhus University
physics.optics
Submitted: 2026-08-03
Updated: 2026-11-11
Comments: 18 pages, 10 figures
Journal ref: Optics Express 34, 43849 (2026)
License: http://creativecommons.org/publicdomain/zero/1.0/
Importance score: 70/100
The gist: Cavity optomechanics with a suspended resonant mirror investigates dispersive optomechanical effects in cavities consisting of a plane-plane arrangement of a broadband reflectivity mirror and an…
Key concepts
- Dispersive Optomechanics
- This involves studying how light and mechanical vibrations interact in a cavity. When the light frequency is slightly detuned from the mechanical resonance, it causes a shift in the mechanical frequency, known as an optical spring effect. The paper examines this effect in complex structures like Fano cavities.
- Fano Cavity Dynamics
- A Fano cavity has unique light transmission properties due to interference between a broad reflection and a narrow resonance mode. This interference creates asymmetric behavior in the cavity's response, which is reflected in the optical spring shift, showing an asymmetric profile.
- Photothermal Effects
- These are extra losses caused by imperfect interference between different light modes within a grating structure. The authors propose that these losses, rather than standard linear coupling alone, are responsible for the unusually strong optomechanical interactions observed experimentally.
- Optical Spring Shift
- This is the change in the mechanical resonance frequency caused by the presence of light inside an optical cavity. It describes how much a mechanical object's natural vibration frequency is altered when coupled to light, which can be used to measure mechanical motion.
Terminology
Summary
Cavity optomechanics with a suspended resonant mirror investigates dispersive optomechanical effects in cavities consisting of a plane-plane arrangement of a broadband reflectivity mirror and an ultrathin, suspended resonant mirror. p. 0 Cavity optomechanics with a suspended resonant mirror
Trishala Mitra1
, Gurpreet Singh1
, Søren Peder Madsen2 and Aur´elien Dantan1∗
1Department of Physics and Astronomy, Aarhus University, DK-8000 Aarhus C, Denmark
2Department of Mechanical and Production Engineering,
Aarhus University, DK-8000 Aarhus C, Denmark
(Dated: August 4, 2026)
We investigate optomechanical effects in cavities consisting of a plane-plane arrangement of a
broadband reflectivity mirror and an ultrathin, suspended resonant mirror possessing a high-Q
internal optical resonance. We first investigate dispersive optomechanics in such cavities on the basis
of a generic analytical model as well as finite element method simulations of realistic structures.Where the paper says it
Dispersive Optomechanical Models
The investigation begins by examining dispersive optomechanics in this canonical system using both an analytical model and finite element method simulations of realistic structures. The authors show that the magnitude of the optical spring shift in a Fano cavity is the same as in the corresponding broadband mirror cavity with the same internal loss, despite linewidth reduction observed at short cavity lengths. p. 0 We first investigate dispersive Fano cavity optomechanics
in this canonical system on the basis of the analytical coupled-mode model of Ref. [25] and show that the magnitude
of the optical spring shift in a Fano cavity is the same as in the corresponding broadband mirror cavity with the
same internal loss, in spite of the linewidth reduction of the Fano cavity observed at short cavity lengths. Unresolved sideband regime
In the unresolved sideband regime (κB ≫ ωm) one retrieves the well-known expression for the mechanical resonance
frequency (or optical spring) shift
δωm ≃ −G
2
|a¯|
2 ∆
κ
2
B + ∆2
= −2G
2
|c¯in|
2κR
∆
(κ
2
B + ∆2)
2
. (14)
The amplitude of the optical spring varies linearly with the input power and dispersively with the detuning, and its
magnitude is largest when |∆| = κB/
√
3.Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Fano Cavity Dynamics and Transmission
For the Fano cavity, equations of motion are derived incorporating a Fano mirror mode d whose coupling describes the interference leading to the internal optical resonance. The steady state transmission of the cavity Tcav can be readily found to be given by a complex expression involving bare susceptibilities. p. 4 (27)
and ˜ϵa is the dressed susceptibility of the a mode
ϵ˜a =
1
ϵ
−1
a − G2ϵd
. (28)
The steady state transmission of the cavity Tcav = |
¯bout/c¯in|
2
can be readily found to be
Tcav =
√
2κR[ϵd(0)G
√
2γ −
√
2κL]
ϵ
−1
a (0) − G2ϵd(0)
2
. 6
In the vicinity of the narrow Fano cavity resonance at ∆d = 0, one has
ϵ˜a ≃
γ
κL + γ
1
κ
′
F + i∆d
(36)
with
κ
′
F = κF (1 − ν∆d), κF =
γ(κR + κ0)
κL + γ
=
γκL
κL + γ
TR + T0
4
, ν =
2
√
κ0κL
γ(κR + κ0)
=
4
γ
√
T0
TR + T0
, (37)
resulting in a transmission function well-approximated by
Tcav ≃
4T0TR
(T0 + TR)
2
1
1 + (∆d/κ′
F
)
2
. (38)
As illustrated in Fig. 2, the optical spring displays an asymmetric dispersive profile, reflecting the asymmetric Fano cavity
profile. If one ignores the asymmetry of the cavity response around resonance, though, and approximates κ
′
F with κF
(Lorentzian cavity spectrum), the magnitude of the optical spring shift is found to be maximum when |∆d| ≃ κF /
√
3
and the maximum optical spring shift then reduces to
δωmax
m ≃ G
2
|c¯in|
2TRκL
γ
κL + γ
3
3
√
3
32κ
3
F
= η
2
|c¯in|
2
6
√
3
TR
(TR + T0)
3
, (40)
which coincides with Eq.Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Experimental Observations and Discrepancy
Experimentally, the authors use a highly reflective silicon nitride membrane possessing a high-Q optical resonance to realize Fano cavities with lengths ranging from a few to a few hundreds of microns. While the observed optical spring variations qualitatively match those expected from the dispersive Fano cavity optomechanics model, their magnitude is more than two orders of magnitude larger than predicted. p. 0 Experimentally, we make use of a highly reflective silicon nitride membrane possessing
a high-Q optical resonance to realize Fano cavities with lengths ranging from a few to a few hundreds of microns,
and measure the optical spring shift as a function of the input power and cavity detuning. While the observed
optical spring variations qualitatively match those expected from the dispersive Fano cavity optomechanics model,
their magnitude is more than two orders of magnitude larger than predicted. While the observed optical spring variations qualitatively
match those expected from the dispersive cavity optomechanics model, their magnitude is more
than two orders of magnitude larger than predicted. We surmize that this strong optomechanical
interaction is due to photothermal effects and put forward a phenomenological model that plausibly
supports the observations.Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Photothermal Interpretation
The origin of the observed strong optomechanical interactions may be photothermal effects, which arise from extra losses introduced by the imperfect interference between the incident mode and the guided mode in the grating. The authors combine dispersive linear optomechanical coupling with a standard phenomenological treatment of photothermal optomechanics to model this effect. p. 0 We surmize that this strong optomechanical
interaction is due to photothermal effects and put forward a phenomenological model that plausibly
supports the observations. INTRODUCTION
The coupling via radiation pressure of the motion of flexible ultrathin membranes in optical resonators has enabled
fundamental advances in the field of cavity optomechanics [1]. In the weak
optomechanical coupling/good mechanical oscillator regimes relevant for this work, one has
δωm =
1
2G
2
|a¯|
2
Im [ϵa(ωm) − ϵ
∗
a
(−ωm)] , (12)
δγm = G
2
|a¯|
2Re [ϵa(ωm) − ϵ
∗
a
(−ωm)] (13)
3. Unresolved sideband regime
In the unresolved sideband regime (κB ≫ ωm) one retrieves the well-known expression for the mechanical resonance
frequency (or optical spring) shift
δωm ≃ −G
2
|a¯|
2 ∆
κ
2
B + ∆2
= −2G
2
|c¯in|
2κR
∆
(κ
2
B + ∆2)
2
.Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Conclusion and Outlook
The work concludes that the linewidth narrowing of such a Fano cavity at short lengths is accompanied by a concomitant reduction in the optomechanical coupling, making variations comparable to those of a broadband mirror cavity. The strong optomechanical interactions observed suggest that Fano cavities with suspended resonant mirrors are promising for quantum optomechanics with membrane-at-the-end cavities. p. 0 Since the increase in reflectivity at specific wavelengths of nanopatterned thin films exploits the interference between the incident light and guided modes in the structured film, it is also possible to design—and take advantage
of—potentially narrow optical internal (Fano) resonances of the resonant mirror and thereby realize Fano cavities
with strongly wavelength-dependent reflectors [24–27]. Such narrow-linewidth, ultracompact microcavities may open
new possibilities for cavity optomechanics [25, 28–30] and, recently, strong and unconventional optomechanical interactions have been experimentally observed with a photonic crystal semiconductor membrane suspended over a Bragg
reflector [31].Where the paper says it
Funding and Acknowledgments
Novo Nordisk Fonden provided funding for this research. The authors are grateful to Claudiu Genes for enlightening discussions regarding the Fano cavity optomechanics model and Ali A. p. 0 In this work we investigate cavity optomechanics for resonators consisting of a plane-plane arrangement of a broadband reflectivity mirror and a suspended, resonant mirror. We first investigate dispersive Fano cavity optomechanics
in this canonical system on the basis of the analytical coupled-mode model of Ref. Since the increase in reflectivity at specific wavelengths of nanopatterned thin films exploits the interference between the incident light and guided modes in the structured film, it is also possible to design—and take advantage
of—potentially narrow optical internal (Fano) resonances of the resonant mirror and thereby realize Fano cavities
with strongly wavelength-dependent reflectors [24–27]. Such narrow-linewidth, ultracompact microcavities may open
new possibilities for cavity optomechanics [25, 28–30] and, recently, strong and unconventional optomechanical interactions have been experimentally observed with a photonic crystal semiconductor membrane suspended over a Bragg
reflector [31]. ∗ dantan@phys. dk
arXiv:2608. dk
arXiv:2608. 02488v1 [physics. 02488v1 [physics. optics] 3 Aug 2026 Cavity optomechanics with a suspended resonant mirror
Trishala Mitra1
, Gurpreet Singh1
, Søren Peder Madsen2 and Aur´elien Dantan1∗
1Department of Physics and Astronomy, Aarhus University, DK-8000 Aarhus C, Denmark
2Department of Mechanical and Production Engineering,
Aarhus University, DK-8000 Aarhus C, Denmark
(Dated: August 4, 2026)
We investigate optomechanical effects in cavities consisting of a plane-plane arrangement of a
broadband reflectivity mirror and an ultrathin, suspended resonant mirror possessing a high-Q
internal optical resonance. We first investigate dispersive optomechanics in such cavities on the basis
of a generic analytical model as well as finite element method simulations of realistic structures. 02488v1 [physics. optics] 3 Aug 2026 Cavity optomechanics with a suspended resonant mirror
Trishala Mitra1
, Gurpreet Singh1
, Søren Peder Madsen2 and Aur´elien Dantan1∗
1Department of Physics and Astronomy, Aarhus University, DK-8000 Aarhus C, Denmark
2Department of Mechanical and Production Engineering,
Aarhus University, DK-8000 Aarhus C, Denmark
(Dated: August 4, 2026)
We investigate optomechanical effects in cavities consisting of a plane-plane arrangement of a
broadband reflectivity mirror and an ultrathin, suspended resonant mirror possessing a high-Q
internal optical resonance. We first investigate dispersive optomechanics in such cavities on the basis
of a generic analytical model as well as finite element method simulations of realistic structures.Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
References
[1] Markus Aspelmeyer, Tobias J. Kippenberg, and Florian Marquardt, ”Cavity optomechanics,” Rev. p. 0 Cavity optomechanics with a suspended resonant mirror
Trishala Mitra1
, Gurpreet Singh1
, Søren Peder Madsen2 and Aur´elien Dantan1∗
1Department of Physics and Astronomy, Aarhus University, DK-8000 Aarhus C, Denmark
2Department of Mechanical and Production Engineering,
Aarhus University, DK-8000 Aarhus C, Denmark
(Dated: August 4, 2026)
We investigate optomechanical effects in cavities consisting of a plane-plane arrangement of a
broadband reflectivity mirror and an ultrathin, suspended resonant mirror possessing a high-Q
internal optical resonance. We first investigate dispersive optomechanics in such cavities on the basis
of a generic analytical model as well as finite element method simulations of realistic structures.Where the paper says it
[2] J. D. Thompson, B. M. Zwickl, A. M. Jayich, F., Marquardt, S., Girvin, and J., ”Strong dispersive coupling of a high finesse cavity to a micromechanical membrane,” Nature 452, 72 (2008). p. 0 The use of low-reflectivity membranes in high-finesse
optical resonators in the membrane-in-the-middle geometry [2, 3] has led to the observation of the radiation pressure
shot-noise [4], the generation of ponderomotive squeezing [5], the observation of optomechanically induced transparency [6], topological energy transfer [7], motional ground state cooling [8], the control of quantum motion by
measurement [9], and optomechanical heat transport and long-range interactions between resonators [10, 11], among
others. Recently, there has also been substantial progress in increasing the otherwise relatively low reflectivity of thin
micromechanical membranes by patterning them with one- and two-dimensional photonic crystal structures [12–18],
ultimately allowing them to be applied as end-mirrors in optomechanical cavities [19–23].Where the paper says it
[3] D. J. Wilson, C. A. Regal, S. A., Papp, and H., ”Cavity optomechanics with stoichiometric SiN films,” Phys. p. 0 Since the increase in reflectivity at specific wavelengths of nanopatterned thin films exploits the interference between the incident light and guided modes in the structured film, it is also possible to design—and take advantage
of—potentially narrow optical internal (Fano) resonances of the resonant mirror and thereby realize Fano cavities
with strongly wavelength-dependent reflectors [24–27]. Such narrow-linewidth, ultracompact microcavities may open
new possibilities for cavity optomechanics [25, 28–30] and, recently, strong and unconventional optomechanical interactions have been experimentally observed with a photonic crystal semiconductor membrane suspended over a Bragg
reflector [31].Where the paper says it
[4] T. P. Purdy, R. W., Peterson, and C., ”Observation of radiation pressure shot noise on a macroscopic object,” Science 339, 801-804 (2013). p. 0 INTRODUCTION
The coupling via radiation pressure of the motion of flexible ultrathin membranes in optical resonators has enabled
fundamental advances in the field of cavity optomechanics [1]. The use of low-reflectivity membranes in high-finesse
optical resonators in the membrane-in-the-middle geometry [2, 3] has led to the observation of the radiation pressure
shot-noise [4], the generation of ponderomotive squeezing [5], the observation of optomechanically induced transparency [6], topological energy transfer [7], motional ground state cooling [8], the control of quantum motion by
measurement [9], and optomechanical heat transport and long-range interactions between resonators [10, 11], among
others.Where the paper says it
[5] T. P. Purdy, P.-L., Yu, R. W., Peterson, N. S., Kampel, and C., ”Strong optomechanical squeezing of light,” Phys. p. 0 We surmize that the observed strong
optomechanical interactions are due to photothermal effects and put forward a phenomenological model that plausibly
supports these observations. ∗ dantan@phys.Where the paper says it
[6] M- Karuza, C., Biancofiore, M., Bawaj, C., Molinelli, M., Galassi, R., Natali, P., Tombesi, G. Di Giuseppe, and D. Vitali,”Optomechanically induced transparency in a membrane-in-the-middle setup at room temperature,” Phys. p. 0 INTRODUCTION
The coupling via radiation pressure of the motion of flexible ultrathin membranes in optical resonators has enabled
fundamental advances in the field of cavity optomechanics [1]. The use of low-reflectivity membranes in high-finesse
optical resonators in the membrane-in-the-middle geometry [2, 3] has led to the observation of the radiation pressure
shot-noise [4], the generation of ponderomotive squeezing [5], the observation of optomechanically induced transparency [6], topological energy transfer [7], motional ground state cooling [8], the control of quantum motion by
measurement [9], and optomechanical heat transport and long-range interactions between resonators [10, 11], among
others.Where the paper says it
[7] H. Xu, D., Mason, L., Jiang, and J., ”Topological energy transfer in an optomechanical system with exceptional points,” Nature 537, 80-83 (2016). p. 0 INTRODUCTION
The coupling via radiation pressure of the motion of flexible ultrathin membranes in optical resonators has enabled
fundamental advances in the field of cavity optomechanics [1]. The use of low-reflectivity membranes in high-finesse
optical resonators in the membrane-in-the-middle geometry [2, 3] has led to the observation of the radiation pressure
shot-noise [4], the generation of ponderomotive squeezing [5], the observation of optomechanically induced transparency [6], topological energy transfer [7], motional ground state cooling [8], the control of quantum motion by
measurement [9], and optomechanical heat transport and long-range interactions between resonators [10, 11], among
others.Where the paper says it
[8] S. A. Saarinen, N., Krajl, E., Langman, Y., Tsaturyan, and A. Schliesser,”Laser cooling a membrane-in-the-middle system close to the quantum ground state from room temperature,” Optica 10, 364-372 (2023). p. 0 INTRODUCTION
The coupling via radiation pressure of the motion of flexible ultrathin membranes in optical resonators has enabled
fundamental advances in the field of cavity optomechanics [1]. The use of low-reflectivity membranes in high-finesse
optical resonators in the membrane-in-the-middle geometry [2, 3] has led to the observation of the radiation pressure
shot-noise [4], the generation of ponderomotive squeezing [5], the observation of optomechanically induced transparency [6], topological energy transfer [7], motional ground state cooling [8], the control of quantum motion by
measurement [9], and optomechanical heat transport and long-range interactions between resonators [10, 11], among
others.Where the paper says it
[9] M. Rossi, D., Mason, J., Chen, Y., Tsaturyan, and A. Schliesser,”Measurement-based quantum control of mechanical motion,” Nature 563, 53-58 (2018). p. 0 INTRODUCTION
The coupling via radiation pressure of the motion of flexible ultrathin membranes in optical resonators has enabled
fundamental advances in the field of cavity optomechanics [1]. The use of low-reflectivity membranes in high-finesse
optical resonators in the membrane-in-the-middle geometry [2, 3] has led to the observation of the radiation pressure
shot-noise [4], the generation of ponderomotive squeezing [5], the observation of optomechanically induced transparency [6], topological energy transfer [7], motional ground state cooling [8], the control of quantum motion by
measurement [9], and optomechanical heat transport and long-range interactions between resonators [10, 11], among
others.Where the paper says it
[10] C. Yang, X., Wei, J., Sheng, and H. Wu,”Phonon heat transport in cavity-mediated nanomechanical resonators,” Nat. p. 0 INTRODUCTION
The coupling via radiation pressure of the motion of flexible ultrathin membranes in optical resonators has enabled
fundamental advances in the field of cavity optomechanics [1]. The use of low-reflectivity membranes in high-finesse
optical resonators in the membrane-in-the-middle geometry [2, 3] has led to the observation of the radiation pressure
shot-noise [4], the generation of ponderomotive squeezing [5], the observation of optomechanically induced transparency [6], topological energy transfer [7], motional ground state cooling [8], the control of quantum motion by
measurement [9], and optomechanical heat transport and long-range interactions between resonators [10, 11], among
others.Where the paper says it
[11] X. Yao, M., H. J., de Jong, J., Lie, and S. Gr¨oblacher,”Long-Range Optomechanical Interactions in SiN Membrane Arrays,” Phys. p. 0 INTRODUCTION
The coupling via radiation pressure of the motion of flexible ultrathin membranes in optical resonators has enabled
fundamental advances in the field of cavity optomechanics [1]. The use of low-reflectivity membranes in high-finesse
optical resonators in the membrane-in-the-middle geometry [2, 3] has led to the observation of the radiation pressure
shot-noise [4], the generation of ponderomotive squeezing [5], the observation of optomechanically induced transparency [6], topological energy transfer [7], motional ground state cooling [8], the control of quantum motion by
measurement [9], and optomechanical heat transport and long-range interactions between resonators [10, 11], among
others.Where the paper says it
[12] U. Kemiktarak, M., Metcalfe, M., Durand, and J. Lawall,”Mechanically compliant grating reflectors for optomechanics,” Appl. p. 0 Since the increase in reflectivity at specific wavelengths of nanopatterned thin films exploits the interference between the incident light and guided modes in the structured film, it is also possible to design—and take advantage
of—potentially narrow optical internal (Fano) resonances of the resonant mirror and thereby realize Fano cavities
with strongly wavelength-dependent reflectors [24–27]. Such narrow-linewidth, ultracompact microcavities may open
new possibilities for cavity optomechanics [25, 28–30] and, recently, strong and unconventional optomechanical interactions have been experimentally observed with a photonic crystal semiconductor membrane suspended over a Bragg
reflector [31]. 3γ
κL = 0. 10
-150
-100
-50
0
50
100
150
Δ/γ
δω
m
(a.Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
[13] C. H., Bui, J., Zheng, S., Hoch, L. Y., Lee, J. G. E., Harris, and C. W.- Wong,”High-reflectivity, high-Q micromechanical membranes via guided resonances for enhanced optomechanical coupling,” Appl. p. 0 Recently, there has also been substantial progress in increasing the otherwise relatively low reflectivity of thin
micromechanical membranes by patterning them with one- and two-dimensional photonic crystal structures [12–18],
ultimately allowing them to be applied as end-mirrors in optomechanical cavities [19–23]. Since the increase in reflectivity at specific wavelengths of nanopatterned thin films exploits the interference between the incident light and guided modes in the structured film, it is also possible to design—and take advantage
of—potentially narrow optical internal (Fano) resonances of the resonant mirror and thereby realize Fano cavities
with strongly wavelength-dependent reflectors [24–27]. 3γ
κL = 0. 10
-150
-100
-50
0
50
100
150
Δ/γ
δω
m
(a.Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
[14] U. Kemiktarak, M., Durand, M., Metcalfe, and J. Lawall,”Cavity optomechanics with sub-wavelength grating mirrors,” New J. p. 0 Since the increase in reflectivity at specific wavelengths of nanopatterned thin films exploits the interference between the incident light and guided modes in the structured film, it is also possible to design—and take advantage
of—potentially narrow optical internal (Fano) resonances of the resonant mirror and thereby realize Fano cavities
with strongly wavelength-dependent reflectors [24–27]. Such narrow-linewidth, ultracompact microcavities may open
new possibilities for cavity optomechanics [25, 28–30] and, recently, strong and unconventional optomechanical interactions have been experimentally observed with a photonic crystal semiconductor membrane suspended over a Bragg
reflector [31].Where the paper says it
[15] R. A., Moura, and S., ”Mechanical Resonators for Quantum Optomechanics Experiments at Room Temperature,” Phys. p. 0 INTRODUCTION
The coupling via radiation pressure of the motion of flexible ultrathin membranes in optical resonators has enabled
fundamental advances in the field of cavity optomechanics [1]. The use of low-reflectivity membranes in high-finesse
optical resonators in the membrane-in-the-middle geometry [2, 3] has led to the observation of the radiation pressure
shot-noise [4], the generation of ponderomotive squeezing [5], the observation of optomechanically induced transparency [6], topological energy transfer [7], motional ground state cooling [8], the control of quantum motion by
measurement [9], and optomechanical heat transport and long-range interactions between resonators [10, 11], among
others.Where the paper says it
[16] C. Reinhardt, T., M¨uller, A., Bourassa, and J. C., ”Ultralow-Noise SiN Trampoline Resonators for Sensing and Optomechanics,” Phys. p. 0 INTRODUCTION
The coupling via radiation pressure of the motion of flexible ultrathin membranes in optical resonators has enabled
fundamental advances in the field of cavity optomechanics [1]. The use of low-reflectivity membranes in high-finesse
optical resonators in the membrane-in-the-middle geometry [2, 3] has led to the observation of the radiation pressure
shot-noise [4], the generation of ponderomotive squeezing [5], the observation of optomechanically induced transparency [6], topological energy transfer [7], motional ground state cooling [8], the control of quantum motion by
measurement [9], and optomechanical heat transport and long-range interactions between resonators [10, 11], among
others.Where the paper says it
[17] X. Chen, C., Chardin, K., Makles, C., Ca¨er, S., Chua, R., Braive, I., Robert-Philip, T. Briant, P.-F. Cohadon, A. Heidmann, T. Jacqmin, and S. Deleglise,”High-finesse Fabry-Perot cavities with bidimensional Si3N4 photonic-crystal slabs,” Light Sci. p. 0 The use of low-reflectivity membranes in high-finesse
optical resonators in the membrane-in-the-middle geometry [2, 3] has led to the observation of the radiation pressure
shot-noise [4], the generation of ponderomotive squeezing [5], the observation of optomechanically induced transparency [6], topological energy transfer [7], motional ground state cooling [8], the control of quantum motion by
measurement [9], and optomechanical heat transport and long-range interactions between resonators [10, 11], among
others. Recently, there has also been substantial progress in increasing the otherwise relatively low reflectivity of thin
micromechanical membranes by patterning them with one- and two-dimensional photonic crystal structures [12–18],
ultimately allowing them to be applied as end-mirrors in optomechanical cavities [19–23].Where the paper says it
[18] B. Nair, A., Naesby, B. R., Jeppesen, and A. Dantan,”Suspended silicon nitride thin films with enhanced and electrically tunable reflectivity,” Phys. p. 0 Since the increase in reflectivity at specific wavelengths of nanopatterned thin films exploits the interference between the incident light and guided modes in the structured film, it is also possible to design—and take advantage
of—potentially narrow optical internal (Fano) resonances of the resonant mirror and thereby realize Fano cavities
with strongly wavelength-dependent reflectors [24–27]. Such narrow-linewidth, ultracompact microcavities may open
new possibilities for cavity optomechanics [25, 28–30] and, recently, strong and unconventional optomechanical interactions have been experimentally observed with a photonic crystal semiconductor membrane suspended over a Bragg
reflector [31].Where the paper says it
[19] Y. Sang, J., Xu, K., Liu, W., Chen, Y., Xiao, Z., Zhu, N., Liu, and J. Zhang,”Spatial Nonreciprocal Transmission and Optical Bistability Based on Millimiter-scale Suspended Metasurface,” Adv. p. 9 7(b), together
with the theoretical predictions based on the experimentally determined grating transmission model parameters and
cavity lengths. Figure 7(b) also shows the cavity linewidths determined from optical spring measurements which
will be discussed in Sec.Where the paper says it
[20] J. Xu, K., Liu, Y., Sang, Z., Tan, C., Guo, and Z. Zhu,”Millimiter-scale ultrathin suspended metasurface integrated highfinesse optomechanical cavity,” Opt. p. 0 Cavity optomechanics with a suspended resonant mirror
Trishala Mitra1
, Gurpreet Singh1
, Søren Peder Madsen2 and Aur´elien Dantan1∗
1Department of Physics and Astronomy, Aarhus University, DK-8000 Aarhus C, Denmark
2Department of Mechanical and Production Engineering,
Aarhus University, DK-8000 Aarhus C, Denmark
(Dated: August 4, 2026)
We investigate optomechanical effects in cavities consisting of a plane-plane arrangement of a
broadband reflectivity mirror and an ultrathin, suspended resonant mirror possessing a high-Q
internal optical resonance. We first investigate dispersive optomechanics in such cavities on the basis
of a generic analytical model as well as finite element method simulations of realistic structures.Where the paper says it
[21] F. Zhou, Y., Bao, J., Gorman, and J., ”Cavity Optomechanical Bistability with an Ultrahigh Reflectivity Photonic Crystal Membrane,” Laser Photonics Rev. p. 0 Since the increase in reflectivity at specific wavelengths of nanopatterned thin films exploits the interference between the incident light and guided modes in the structured film, it is also possible to design—and take advantage
of—potentially narrow optical internal (Fano) resonances of the resonant mirror and thereby realize Fano cavities
with strongly wavelength-dependent reflectors [24–27]. Such narrow-linewidth, ultracompact microcavities may open
new possibilities for cavity optomechanics [25, 28–30] and, recently, strong and unconventional optomechanical interactions have been experimentally observed with a photonic crystal semiconductor membrane suspended over a Bragg
reflector [31].Where the paper says it
[22] G. Enzian, Z., Wang, A., Simonsen, J., Mathiassen, T. Vibel, Y., Tsaturyan, A., Tagantsev, A., Schliesser, and E. S. Polzik,”Phononically shielded photonic-crystal mirror membranes for cavity quantum optomechanics,” Optics Express 31, 13040-13052 (2023). p. 0 The use of low-reflectivity membranes in high-finesse
optical resonators in the membrane-in-the-middle geometry [2, 3] has led to the observation of the radiation pressure
shot-noise [4], the generation of ponderomotive squeezing [5], the observation of optomechanically induced transparency [6], topological energy transfer [7], motional ground state cooling [8], the control of quantum motion by
measurement [9], and optomechanical heat transport and long-range interactions between resonators [10, 11], among
others. Recently, there has also been substantial progress in increasing the otherwise relatively low reflectivity of thin
micromechanical membranes by patterning them with one- and two-dimensional photonic crystal structures [12–18],
ultimately allowing them to be applied as end-mirrors in optomechanical cavities [19–23].Where the paper says it
[23] M. Khokhar, L., Norder, P., Sberna, R. A., Norte,”High-Stress Si3N4 Reflective Membranes Monolithically Integrated with Cavity Bragg Mirrors,” arxiv:2306. p. 0 The use of low-reflectivity membranes in high-finesse
optical resonators in the membrane-in-the-middle geometry [2, 3] has led to the observation of the radiation pressure
shot-noise [4], the generation of ponderomotive squeezing [5], the observation of optomechanically induced transparency [6], topological energy transfer [7], motional ground state cooling [8], the control of quantum motion by
measurement [9], and optomechanical heat transport and long-range interactions between resonators [10, 11], among
others. Recently, there has also been substantial progress in increasing the otherwise relatively low reflectivity of thin
micromechanical membranes by patterning them with one- and two-dimensional photonic crystal structures [12–18],
ultimately allowing them to be applied as end-mirrors in optomechanical cavities [19–23]. Cavity optomechanics with a suspended resonant mirror
Trishala Mitra1
, Gurpreet Singh1
, Søren Peder Madsen2 and Aur´elien Dantan1∗
1Department of Physics and Astronomy, Aarhus University, DK-8000 Aarhus C, Denmark
2Department of Mechanical and Production Engineering,
Aarhus University, DK-8000 Aarhus C, Denmark
(Dated: August 4, 2026)
We investigate optomechanical effects in cavities consisting of a plane-plane arrangement of a
broadband reflectivity mirror and an ultrathin, suspended resonant mirror possessing a high-Q
internal optical resonance. We first investigate dispersive optomechanics in such cavities on the basis
of a generic analytical model as well as finite element method simulations of realistic structures.Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
[24] A. Naesby and A. Dantan, ”Microcavities with suspended subwavelength structured mirrors,” Opt. p. 0 Since the increase in reflectivity at specific wavelengths of nanopatterned thin films exploits the interference between the incident light and guided modes in the structured film, it is also possible to design—and take advantage
of—potentially narrow optical internal (Fano) resonances of the resonant mirror and thereby realize Fano cavities
with strongly wavelength-dependent reflectors [24–27]. Such narrow-linewidth, ultracompact microcavities may open
new possibilities for cavity optomechanics [25, 28–30] and, recently, strong and unconventional optomechanical interactions have been experimentally observed with a photonic crystal semiconductor membrane suspended over a Bragg
reflector [31].Where the paper says it
[25] A. Cernotik, A. Dantan, and C. p. 0 We surmize that the observed strong
optomechanical interactions are due to photothermal effects and put forward a phenomenological model that plausibly
supports these observations. ∗ dantan@phys. Since the increase in reflectivity at specific wavelengths of nanopatterned thin films exploits the interference between the incident light and guided modes in the structured film, it is also possible to design—and take advantage
of—potentially narrow optical internal (Fano) resonances of the resonant mirror and thereby realize Fano cavities
with strongly wavelength-dependent reflectors [24–27]. Such narrow-linewidth, ultracompact microcavities may open
new possibilities for cavity optomechanics [25, 28–30] and, recently, strong and unconventional optomechanical interactions have been experimentally observed with a photonic crystal semiconductor membrane suspended over a Bragg
reflector [31].Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
[26] T. Mitra, G., Singh, A., Madsen, S., and A. Dantan,”Narrow-linewidth Fano microcavities with resonant subwavelength grating mirror,” Opt. p. 0 Since the increase in reflectivity at specific wavelengths of nanopatterned thin films exploits the interference between the incident light and guided modes in the structured film, it is also possible to design—and take advantage
of—potentially narrow optical internal (Fano) resonances of the resonant mirror and thereby realize Fano cavities
with strongly wavelength-dependent reflectors [24–27]. Such narrow-linewidth, ultracompact microcavities may open
new possibilities for cavity optomechanics [25, 28–30] and, recently, strong and unconventional optomechanical interactions have been experimentally observed with a photonic crystal semiconductor membrane suspended over a Bragg
reflector [31].Where the paper says it
[27] M. Kirkegaard, T., Mitra, G., Singh, and A. Dantan,”Optical microcavity with a pair of suspended resonant mirrors,” Opt. p. 0 Recently, there has also been substantial progress in increasing the otherwise relatively low reflectivity of thin
micromechanical membranes by patterning them with one- and two-dimensional photonic crystal structures [12–18],
ultimately allowing them to be applied as end-mirrors in optomechanical cavities [19–23]. Since the increase in reflectivity at specific wavelengths of nanopatterned thin films exploits the interference between the incident light and guided modes in the structured film, it is also possible to design—and take advantage
of—potentially narrow optical internal (Fano) resonances of the resonant mirror and thereby realize Fano cavities
with strongly wavelength-dependent reflectors [24–27].Where the paper says it
[31] S. K., Manjeshwar, A., Ciers, J., Monsel, H., Pfeifer, C., Peralle, S. M., Wang, P. Tassin, and W. Wieczorek,”Integrated microcavity optomechanics with a suspended photonic crystal mirror above a distributed Bragg reflector,” Opt. p. 0 Since the increase in reflectivity at specific wavelengths of nanopatterned thin films exploits the interference between the incident light and guided modes in the structured film, it is also possible to design—and take advantage
of—potentially narrow optical internal (Fano) resonances of the resonant mirror and thereby realize Fano cavities
with strongly wavelength-dependent reflectors [24–27]. Such narrow-linewidth, ultracompact microcavities may open
new possibilities for cavity optomechanics [25, 28–30] and, recently, strong and unconventional optomechanical interactions have been experimentally observed with a photonic crystal semiconductor membrane suspended over a Bragg
reflector [31].Where the paper says it
[39] C. H. Metzger and K., “Cavity cooling of a microlever,” Nature 432, 1002–1005 (2004). p. 0 INTRODUCTION
The coupling via radiation pressure of the motion of flexible ultrathin membranes in optical resonators has enabled
fundamental advances in the field of cavity optomechanics [1]. The use of low-reflectivity membranes in high-finesse
optical resonators in the membrane-in-the-middle geometry [2, 3] has led to the observation of the radiation pressure
shot-noise [4], the generation of ponderomotive squeezing [5], the observation of optomechanically induced transparency [6], topological energy transfer [7], motional ground state cooling [8], the control of quantum motion by
measurement [9], and optomechanical heat transport and long-range interactions between resonators [10, 11], among
others.Where the paper says it
[47] L th 0 = 2(1 − rd)λ 2 o / (8πγλ), where γλ is the linewidth (HWHM) in wavelength units of the Fano mirror and rd its off-resonant reflectivity level (in amplitude), which can be obtained from a fit to the simulated Fano mirror transmission spectrum. p. 7 The values of the extracted effective lengths are reported in Table I and compared to the
predictions of the analytical model of Ref. [26]
L
th
0 =
2(1 − rd)λ
2
0
8πγλ
, (47)
where γλ is the linewidth (HWHM) in wavelength units of the Fano mirror and rd its off-resonant reflectivity level
(in amplitude), which can be obtained from a fit to the simulated Fano mirror transmission spectrum.Where the paper says it
[48] L th 0 = λ 2 o / (4π dϕ/dλ), where ϕ is the phase of the reflectivity coefficient. p. 7 [26]
L
th
0 =
2(1 − rd)λ
2
0
8πγλ
, (47)
where γλ is the linewidth (HWHM) in wavelength units of the Fano mirror and rd its off-resonant reflectivity level
(in amplitude), which can be obtained from a fit to the simulated Fano mirror transmission spectrum. For the broadband cavity the dispersion of the mirrors can be taken into account to evaluate the effective cavity
length correction due to the penetration of the field into the mirrors and generally can be written [36]
L
th
0 =
λ
2
0
4π
dϕ
dλ, (48)
where ϕ is the phase of the reflectivity coefficient.Where the paper says it
[51] δfm(Pin) = (αη) squared / 2π Pin c 3TR(L + L0) cubed / (∆ squared + κ'2F)2, where α = Gexp/G is a free parameter relating the measured optomechanical coupling Gexp to the theoretically expected dispersive linear optomechanical coupling G = ηκL.
[55] δωm = 2κRc¯in 2G 2ξϵ˜a 2Im[˜ϵa], which is similar to Eq. p. 2 (11)
where ω
′
m = ωm + δωm and γ
′
m = γm + δγm are the effective mechanical frequency and damping. In the weak
optomechanical coupling/good mechanical oscillator regimes relevant for this work, one has
δωm =
1
2G
2
|a¯|
2
Im [ϵa(ωm) − ϵ
∗
a
(−ωm)] , (12)
δγm = G
2
|a¯|
2Re [ϵa(ωm) − ϵ
∗
a
(−ωm)] (13)
3. Following the notations of Ref. [25] and under the same assumptions of dispersive linear
optomechanical coupling as previously, the equations of motion for the optical and mechanical modes now read
a˙ = − (κL + κR + i∆a)a − Gd + iGaq +
√
2κLbin +
√
2κRcin, (16)
˙d = − (γ + i∆d)d − Ga +
p
2γbin, (17)
p˙ = − γmp − ωmq + Ga†
a + Fm, (18)
q˙ = ωmp, (19)
with
G =
√
κLγ + i
√
κ0γ, (20)
∆a = ∆d + 2√
κ0κL, (21)
where κL = c/L is (twice) the cavity free spectral range (FSR), κR = TRκL/4 and κ0 = T0κL/4 are the decay rates
through the broadband mirror and the Fano mirror at resonance, respectively, and γ is the halfwidth of the Fano
mirror resonance.Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Green — the paper says it, and the page is printed. Red — no passage carries it, so treat that sentence as unverified. The same check runs on your own text: check a summary against its source, $5.
Improvements for AI systems
-
Photothermal modeling integration can be incorporated into system simulations to predict strong optomechanical interactions beyond standard dispersive linear coupling. This allows improved AI systems to accurately model experimental results by accounting for extra losses from imperfect interference between incident and guided modes in gratings, as suggested by the phenomenological model proposed in section VI.
-
Enhanced analytical models can be developed that explicitly incorporate the photothermal force term Fph into the equations of motion for cavity optomechanics. This capability would allow AI systems to predict optical spring frequency shifts more accurately when extra losses significantly limit peak reflectivity, as described by equation (56).
-
Simulation pipelines can be upgraded to handle finite-size grating effects using Finite Element Method simulations, including considerations for beam collimation and finite-grating size losses. This allows AI systems to validate the coupled-mode model against realistic experimental structures, as performed in section III C of the paper.
-
Experimental data analysis tools can be improved to fit the experimentally observed optical spring shift equation (50) more robustly across different cavity lengths and power regimes. This would help AI systems extract physically meaningful parameters like α, which are noted to be
considerably much larger than unity,
indicating a stronger optomechanical interaction than expected from standard models. -
The system can be trained to distinguish between the effects of translation versus deformation of the Fano mirror in displacement sensitivity measurements, as shown in figure 5(c). This capability is crucial for interpreting experimental results accurately, given that
the optical spring shift depends on the overlap between the optical mode and the mechanical mode considered.
Abstract
We investigate optomechanical effects in cavities consisting of a plane-plane arrangement of a broadband reflectivity mirror and an ultrathin, suspended resonant mirror possessing a high-Q internal optical resonance. We first investigate dispersive optomechanics in such cavities on the basis of a generic analytical model as well as finite element method simulations of realistic structures. We then report on experimental optical spring measurements using a suspended silicon nitride membrane patterned with a subwavelength grating. While the observed optical spring variations qualitatively match those expected from the dispersive cavity optomechanics model, their magnitude is more than two orders of magnitude larger than predicted. We surmize that this strong optomechanical interaction is due to photothermal effects and put forward a phenomenological model that plausibly supports the observations.
Sources
- A short proof of Allard's and Brakke's regularity theorems
- Nonlinear quantum optomechanics in a Fano-mirror microcavity system
Related papers
- Raman optical activity and helicity-dependent phonon splitting in chiral CoSi
- Stability and optical quality of "windmill"-formed 8CB liquid crystal films for replenishable plasma mirrors
- Experimental Scaling of Diffraction Efficiency in Laser-Induced Plasma Gratings
- Photonic Exceptional Topological Bound States in the Continuum
- SHAPE: a sparse Hamiltonian approach for prescribing eigenstates in metamaterials
- All-photonic millimeter-wave and terahertz signal core at room and cryogenic temperatures