Stability and optical quality of "windmill"-formed 8CB liquid crystal films for replenishable plasma mirrors

arXiv:2509.18448 · physics.optics, physics.plasm-ph · Submitted 2025-09-22 · Read on arXiv

Listen

Radio episode about this paper

Transcript

Introduction to the show: ident: Physics. The day in general physics: instruments, methods and results across the field.

Kai: We're looking at the paper: "Stability and optical quality of "windmill"-formed 8CB liquid crystal films for replenishable plasma mirrors".

Mira: Here's the gist of the paper. Liquid crystal (LC) film plasma mirrors (PMs) based on 4-octyl-4’-cyanobiphenyl (8CB) are an enabling technology for reflecting high-fluence laser pulses These freestanding LC films can achieve high optical quality and are well-suited for rep-rated applications, as motorized devices continuously replenish films over an aperture following each destructive laser shot However, a systematic characterization of film quality as a function of seminal operating conditions had not yet been performed for the LC "windmill" version of the device, which aims to match the repetition rate of an existing "spinning disk" (SDI) version and the angular stability of the "linear slider" (LSTI) version We determined the 8CB film quality using low-power wavefront measurements, and studied the film-to-film wavefront stability and formation reliability.

Kai: Film Formation Reliability and Operating Conditions The film-formation reliability of 8CB LC films demonstrated >97% formation success at 2.7 mm/s film-forming speeds, but decreased to 45% at 10.8 mm/s These reliability numbers will inform future designs to reach Hz-level repetition rates and beyond.

Mira: Depending on area-of-interest within the 10 mm diameter film, the added wavefront root-mean-squared (RMS) variation was as small as 12 nm for a 2 mm diameter region, and <50 nm for a 3 mm diameter region.

Kai: Within the optimal 21-22°C operating regime, pointing fluctuations remained at or below 0.5 mrad.

Title and authors: Kai: So we’re looking at this paper today, "Stability and optical quality of "windmill"-formed 8CB liquid crystal films for replenishable plasma mirrors <ref:2509.18448#pg1,Stability and optical quality of "windmill"-formed 8CB liquid crystal films for>." We've seen that these LC films can be used to reflect high-fluence laser pulses and need constant replenishment.

Mira: They are essentially building a system where motorized wipers keep laying down new 8CB film over an opening, and they needed to systematically characterize how the film quality changes based on the operating conditions <ref:2509.18448#pg1>.

Lev: The authors wanted to compare this "windmill" version against other types of systems, like the "spinning disk" or the "linear slider," so they had to look at stability and reliability under various settings.

Kai: It seems like this paper is focused on making sure that when you’re trying to build something that runs repeatedly, you need to understand how sensitive the optical quality is to things like temperature and speed.

Mira: Exactly. They determined the film quality by looking at wavefront measurements and studying both the stability between different films and how reliable they were in forming those films.

Lev: It sets up a baseline for future designs aiming for high repetition rates, which is kind of what we need if you want to push this technology further.

Kai: So, what does this characterization actually show about the performance limits of these windmill films?

The paper's summary: Mira: The paper found that the film formation reliability was pretty good; it showed over ninety-seven percent success at a film forming speed of two point seven millimeters per second.

Kai: But that number drops to forty-five percent when you increase the speed up to ten point eight millimeters per second, which tells us we need to be careful about how fast we move things for high repetition rates.

Lev: That reliability number is critical because if you're aiming for Hz-level repetition rates, those speed constraints really matter for whether the device can actually keep up.

Mira: They also looked at the size of the optical quality errors; depending on where you look on that ten millimeter wide film, they found that the added wavefront root mean squared error was as small as twelve nanometers for a two millimeter region.

Kai: And for a three millimeter region, it was less than fifty nanometers, which suggests localized quality issues depending on the area of interest.

Lev: Plus, they found that within an optimal temperature range of twenty-one to twenty-two degrees Celsius, the pointing fluctuations were kept at or below zero point five milliradian.

Mira: So these results establish that windmill formed 8CB films are promising candidates for moving toward rep rated plasma mirror operation with a maximum effective film formation frequency of about zero point two five hertz <ref:2509.18448#pg1>.

Kai: It sounds like they've laid out some solid benchmarks for what we can expect from this configuration.

The paper's improvements: Lev: One major thing they found is that operating within the twenty-one to twenty-two degrees Celsius temperature window gives them the most robust optical quality, where the wavefront root mean squared error only varies between twelve nanometers and sixteen nanometers across all tested wiping speeds.

Kai: That’s a pretty tight window for temperature control, which is always good news when you’re trying to maintain precise optical alignment.

Mira: They also analyzed the angular stability, looking at the tip tilt Zernike coefficients of the reference subtracted wavefront data to see how much those films wobble between shots.

Lev: And across all tested temperatures and wiping speeds, the total angular fluctuation spanned from approximately two hundred seventy zero to seven four zero micromirradians.

Kai: So they showed that even with the variations in speed and temperature, the pointing fluctuations were kept under half a milliradian at or below zero point five milliradian.

Mira: These results suggest that you can constrain those pointing fluctuations to less than zero point five milliradian by carefully controlling your operating conditions.

Conclusion: Kai: So, to wrap up this paper on "Stability and optical quality of "windmill"-formed 8CB liquid crystal films for replenishable plasma mirrors," the main points are that windmill-formed films can be used for high-power laser applications <ref:2509.18448#pg1,Stability and optical quality of "windmill"-formed 8CB liquid crystal films for>.

Mira: They showed that they achieve the highest film quality when operating in the twenty-one to twenty-two degrees Celsius temperature window, with a wavefront root mean squared error only of twelve to sixteen nanometers over a two millimeter analysis pupil.

Lev: And they also confirmed that film to film angular pointing fluctuations are constrained to less than zero point five milliradian across all conditions they tested.

Kai: Plus, they demonstrated robust film formation and laser energy redirection during high-power tests using the BELLA PW laser, showing a minimum transmission of four point zero plus or minus zero point two percent at the maximum fluence of two hundred forty joules per centimeter squared.

Mira: This work establishes these windmill formed 8CB LC films as a replenishable PM technology for high-power laser applications with an effective film formation frequency of about zero point two five hertz <ref:2509.18448#pg1>.

Lev: It’s a solid demonstration that this configuration can handle the high power pulses needed for your application, and it sets clear targets for the next iteration of hardware development.

Lawrence Berkeley National Laboratory · Department of Nuclear Engineering University of California Berkeley · The Ohio State University

physics.optics, physics.plasm-ph

Submitted: 2025-09-22

Updated: 2026-11-09

Comments: 8 pages, 6 figures, 1 supplementary table

License: http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/

Importance score: 100/100

The gist: Liquid crystal (LC) film plasma mirrors (PMs) based on 4-octyl-4’-cyanobiphenyl (8CB) are an enabling technology for reflecting high-fluence laser pulses These freestanding LC films can achieve…

Key concepts

8CB LC Films
These are liquid crystal films made from the material 4-octyl-4’-cyanobiphenyl (8CB). They are used as plasma mirrors because they can reflect high-fluence laser pulses while maintaining good optical quality. These films are manufactured using a motorized 'windmill' device that continuously replenishes the film over an aperture.
Film Formation Reliability
This measures how successfully the LC film is formed during the manufacturing process. The study found success rates above 97% at slow speeds (2.7 mm/s) but dropped to 45% at faster speeds (10.8 mm/s), indicating limits for achieving very high repetition rates.
Wavefront RMS Error
This quantifies the optical quality of the film by measuring how much the actual surface deviates from a perfect flat surface. The study showed that in the optimal 21-22°C temperature range, this error was very small (12-16 nm) over a 2 mm analysis area.
Angular Stability
This refers to how much the orientation of the LC film changes or fluctuates during operation. The study showed that for windmill films at 21-22°C, these fluctuations were constrained to less than 0.5 mrad, ensuring stable pointing for the plasma mirror.

Terminology

Summary

Liquid crystal (LC) film plasma mirrors (PMs) based on 4-octyl-4’-cyanobiphenyl (8CB) are an enabling technology for reflecting high-fluence laser pulses These freestanding LC films can achieve high optical quality and are well-suited for rep-rated applications, as motorized devices continuously replenish films over an aperture following each destructive laser shot However, a systematic characterization of film quality as a function of seminal operating conditions had not yet been performed for the LC windmill version of the device, which aims to match the repetition rate of an existing spinning disk (SDI) version and the angular stability of the linear slider (LSTI) version We determined the 8CB film quality using low-power wavefront measurements, and studied the film-to-film wavefront stability and formation reliability.

Film Formation Reliability and Operating Conditions

The film-formation reliability of 8CB LC films demonstrated >97% formation success at 2.7 mm/s film-forming speeds, but decreased to 45% at 10. p. 0

Where the paper says it

The film-formation reliability of 8CB LC films demonstrated >97% formation success at 2. 7 mm/s film-forming speeds, but decreased to 45% at 10.

p. 0
Where the paper says it

The film-formation reliability of 8CB LC films demonstrated >97% formation success at 2. 7 mm/s film-forming speeds, but decreased to 45% at 10.

8 mm/s These reliability numbers will inform future designs to reach Hz-level repetition rates and beyond. p. 0
Where the paper says it

7 mm/s film-forming speeds, but decreased to 45% at 10. These reliability numbers will inform future designs to reach Hz-level repetition rates and beyond.

p. 0
Where the paper says it

7 mm/s film-forming speeds, but decreased to 45% at 10. These reliability numbers will inform future designs to reach Hz-level repetition rates and beyond.

Depending on area-of-interest within the 10 mm diameter film, the added wavefront root-mean-squared (RMS) variation was as small as 12 nm for a 2 mm diameter region, and <50 nm for a 3 mm diameter region. p. 0
Where the paper says it

These reliability numbers will inform future designs to reach Hz-level repetition rates and beyond. Depending on area-of-interest within the 10 mm diameter film, the added wavefront root-mean-squared (RMS) variation was as small as 12 nm for a 2 mm diameter region, and <50 nm for a 3 mm diameter region.

Within the optimal 21-22°C operating regime, pointing fluctuations remained at or below 0. p. 0
Where the paper says it

Depending on area-of-interest within the 10 mm diameter film, the added wavefront root-mean-squared (RMS) variation was as small as 12 nm for a 2 mm diameter region, and <50 nm for a 3 mm diameter region. Within the optimal 21-22◦C operating regime, pointing fluctuations remained at or below 0.

p. 0
Where the paper says it

Depending on area-of-interest within the 10 mm diameter film, the added wavefront root-mean-squared (RMS) variation was as small as 12 nm for a 2 mm diameter region, and <50 nm for a 3 mm diameter region. Within the optimal 21-22◦C operating regime, pointing fluctuations remained at or below 0.

5 mrad. With a maximum effective film formation frequency of 0. p. 0
Where the paper says it

Within the optimal 21-22◦C operating regime, pointing fluctuations remained at or below 0. With a maximum effective film formation frequency of ~0.

p. 0
Where the paper says it

Within the optimal 21-22◦C operating regime, pointing fluctuations remained at or below 0. With a maximum effective film formation frequency of ~0.

25 Hz, these results establish windmill-formed 8CB films as promising candidates to pursue next-iteration improvements towards rep-rated plasma-mirror operation. p. 0
Where the paper says it

With a maximum effective film formation frequency of ~0. 25 Hz, these results establish windmill-formed 8CB films as promising candidates to pursue next-iteration improvements towards rep-rated plasma-mirror operation.

p. 0
Where the paper says it

With a maximum effective film formation frequency of ~0. 25 Hz, these results establish windmill-formed 8CB films as promising candidates to pursue next-iteration improvements towards rep-rated plasma-mirror operation.

Optical Quality Characterization

Optical characterization of LC films in vacuum was conducted using a low power diagnostic laser beam as illustrated in the schematic layout in Fig. 1(c) A 532 nm continuouswave (CW) diode laser was used for wavefront measurements with an Imagine Optic HASO LIFT 680 wavefront sensor. p. 2

Where the paper says it

Optical characterization of LC films in vacuum was conducted using a low power diagnostic laser beam as illustrated in the schematic layout in Fig. A 532 nm continuouswave (CW) diode laser was used for wavefront measurements with an Imagine Optic HASO LIFT 680 wavefront sensor.

p. 2
Where the paper says it

Optical characterization of LC films in vacuum was conducted using a low power diagnostic laser beam as illustrated in the schematic layout in Fig. A 532 nm continuouswave (CW) diode laser was used for wavefront measurements with an Imagine Optic HASO LIFT 680 wavefront sensor.

The smallest reliably resolvable spatial period on the LC film was 35 µm. p. 2
Where the paper says it

With this imaging relay, the film-to-sensor magnification was M ≈ 1. 14, and the smallest reliably resolvable spatial period on the LC film was 35 µm.

p. 2
Where the paper says it

With this imaging relay, the film-to-sensor magnification was M ≈ 1. 14, and the smallest reliably resolvable spatial period on the LC film was 35 µm.

Reference wavefronts were recorded by replacing the film with a 1 inch diameter gold mirror with a manufacturerspecified surface flatness of λ/10 peak-to-valley at 633 nm. p. 2
Where the paper says it

For this purpose, reference wavefronts (see Fig. 1(e)) were recorded by replacing the film with a 1 inch diameter gold mirror with a manufacturerspecified surface flatness of λ/10 peak-to-valley at 633 nm.

The optical aberrations attributable to the LC film were isolated by subtracting the reference wavefront from the corresponding film wavefront measurement. p. 2
Where the paper says it

Independent measurements indicated that the mirror flatness over a central 4 mm diameter region was < 5nm (the noise floor of the wavefront sensor). The optical aberrations attributable to the LC film were isolated by subtracting the ref-

Angular Stability and Fluctuation Analysis

The angular stability of films formed with the windmill were derived from the tip/tilt Zernike coefficients of the reference-subtracted wavefront data. p. 3

Where the paper says it

The defocus term was consistently measured at or below the noise floor of the wavefront sensor. The angular stability of films formed with the windmill were derived from the tip/tilt Zernike coefficients of the reference-subtracted wavefront data.

Film-to-film fluctuations of the wavefront RMS, analyzed for a 2 mm pupil size, are displayed in Fig. p. 4
Where the paper says it

Across the full range of temperatures and wiping speeds, the total angular fluctuation (∆θtotal) spanned from approximately 270 to 740 µrad, which is within the range of standard motorized actuators for tip/tilt correction (all individual film angle measurements are listed in the Supplementary Table). Film-to-film fluctuations of the wavefront RMS, analyzed for a 2 mm pupil size, are displayed in Fig.

p. 4
Where the paper says it

Across the full range of temperatures and wiping speeds, the total angular fluctuation (∆θtotal) spanned from approximately 270 to 740 µrad, which is within the range of standard motorized actuators for tip/tilt correction (all individual film angle measurements are listed in the Supplementary Table). Film-to-film fluctuations of the wavefront RMS, analyzed for a 2 mm pupil size, are displayed in Fig.

p. 4
Where the paper says it

Across the full range of temperatures and wiping speeds, the total angular fluctuation (∆θtotal) spanned from approximately 270 to 740 µrad, which is within the range of standard motorized actuators for tip/tilt correction (all individual film angle measurements are listed in the Supplementary Table). Film-to-film fluctuations of the wavefront RMS, analyzed for a 2 mm pupil size, are displayed in Fig.

5(a) for an operating condition of 21–22°C and 5. p. 4
Where the paper says it

Film-to-film fluctuations of the wavefront RMS, analyzed for a 2 mm pupil size, are displayed in Fig. 5(a) for an operating condition of 21–22◦C and 5.

p. 4
Where the paper says it

Film-to-film fluctuations of the wavefront RMS, analyzed for a 2 mm pupil size, are displayed in Fig. 5(a) for an operating condition of 21–22◦C and 5.

p. 4
Where the paper says it

Film-to-film fluctuations of the wavefront RMS, analyzed for a 2 mm pupil size, are displayed in Fig. 5(a) for an operating condition of 21–22◦C and 5.

4 mm/s wiping speed. p. 1
Where the paper says it

These previous results support the exploration of LC film formation devices as replenishable PMs in high-power laser facilities. However, a systematic study characterizing film formation reliability, optical quality, and angular fluctuation from film to film, at increasing wiping speed rates, is currently missing.

p. 1
Where the paper says it

These previous results support the exploration of LC film formation devices as replenishable PMs in high-power laser facilities. However, a systematic study characterizing film formation reliability, optical quality, and angular fluctuation from film to film, at increasing wiping speed rates, is currently missing.

p. 1
Where the paper says it

These previous results support the exploration of LC film formation devices as replenishable PMs in high-power laser facilities. However, a systematic study characterizing film formation reliability, optical quality, and angular fluctuation from film to film, at increasing wiping speed rates, is currently missing.

The horizontal angular fluctuation exceeded the vertical component, a trend that was observed across nearly all tested configurations. p. 4
Where the paper says it

The corresponding film-to-film angular fluctuations for the same operating conditions are shown in Fig. The horizontal angular fluctuation exceeded the vertical component, a trend that was observed across nearly all tested configurations.

High-Power Demonstration

In this work, the BELLA PW laser was used to test windmill-formed 8CB LC films as replenishable PMs capable of redirecting high-power pulses into a beam dump to protect downstream components The transmitted light through the plasma mirror was diagnosed using a ceramic screen located behind a wedge downstream of the interaction. At the maximum fluence, 240 J/cm2, the transmission reached a minimum of (4. p. 5

Where the paper says it

In this scenario, a portion of the pulse is reflected by the transient plasma and redirected away from the transmission diagnostic toward the dump. At the maximum fluence, 240 J/cm2 , the transmission reached a minimum of (4.

p. 5
Where the paper says it

In this scenario, a portion of the pulse is reflected by the transient plasma and redirected away from the transmission diagnostic toward the dump. At the maximum fluence, 240 J/cm2 , the transmission reached a minimum of (4.

0 ± 0.2)%.

Conclusion

This work establishes windmill-formed 8CB LC films as a replenishable PM technology for high-power laser applications, with a maximum effective film formation frequency of 0.25 Hz We observed the highest film quality when operating in a temperature range of 21–22°C, in which the films added a wavefront RMS error of only 12–16 nm over a 2 mm analysis pupil. p. 6

Where the paper says it

CONCLUSION This work establishes windmill-formed 8CB LC films as a replenishable PM technology for high-power laser applications, with a maximum effective film formation frequency of ~0. We observed the highest film quality when operating in a temperature range of 21–22◦C, in which the films added a wavefront RMS error of only 12–16 nm over a 2 mm analysis pupil, 22–50 nm over a 3 mm pupil, and 59–125 nm over a 4 mm pupil.

p. 6
Where the paper says it

CONCLUSION This work establishes windmill-formed 8CB LC films as a replenishable PM technology for high-power laser applications, with a maximum effective film formation frequency of ~0. We observed the highest film quality when operating in a temperature range of 21–22◦C, in which the films added a wavefront RMS error of only 12–16 nm over a 2 mm analysis pupil, 22–50 nm over a 3 mm pupil, and 59–125 nm over a 4 mm pupil.

Furthermore, film-to-film angular pointing fluctuations were constrained to ≤ 0. p. 6
Where the paper says it

We observed the highest film quality when operating in a temperature range of 21–22◦C, in which the films added a wavefront RMS error of only 12–16 nm over a 2 mm analysis pupil, 22–50 nm over a 3 mm pupil, and 59–125 nm over a 4 mm pupil. Furthermore, film-to-film angular pointing fluctuations were constrained to ≤ 0.

p. 6
Where the paper says it

We observed the highest film quality when operating in a temperature range of 21–22◦C, in which the films added a wavefront RMS error of only 12–16 nm over a 2 mm analysis pupil, 22–50 nm over a 3 mm pupil, and 59–125 nm over a 4 mm pupil. Furthermore, film-to-film angular pointing fluctuations were constrained to ≤ 0.

5 mrad. Additionally, we demonstrated robust film formation and laser energy redirection during high-power tests using the BELLA PW laser. p. 6
Where the paper says it

5 mrad, and the device maintained >90% film formation reliability for wiping speeds up to 5. Additionally, we demonstrated robust film formation and laser energy redirection during high-power tests using the BELLA PW laser.

Table I summarizes the wavefront statistics for liquid crystal films across various parameters The data shows that the total angular fluctuation spanned from approximately 270 to 740 µrad across all tested conditions. p. 4

Where the paper says it

Across the full range of temperatures and wiping speeds, the total angular fluctuation (∆θtotal) spanned from approximately 270 to 740 µrad, which is within the range of standard motorized actuators for tip/tilt correction (all individual film angle measurements are listed in the Supplementary Table). Film-to-film fluctuations of the wavefront RMS, analyzed for a 2 mm pupil size, are displayed in Fig.

The results indicate that the optical quality was most robust within the 21–22°C temperature window, where the wavefront RMS only varied between 12 nm and 16 nm across all investigated wiping speeds. p. 4
Where the paper says it

Across all tested conditions, the wavefront RMS of higher order Zernike terms (excluding piston, tip, tilt, and defocus Zernike terms) for the 2 mm diagnostic pupil ranged from 10 to 46 nm, with corresponding peak-to-valley (PV) values between 83 and 282 nm (Fig. We found that the optical quality was most robust within the 21–22◦C temperature window, where the wavefront RMS only varied between 12 nm and 16 nm across all investigated wiping speeds.

The device maintained >90% film formation reliability for wiping speeds up to 5. p. 6
Where the paper says it

Furthermore, film-to-film angular pointing fluctuations were constrained to ≤ 0. 5 mrad, and the device maintained >90% film formation reliability for wiping speeds up to 5.

4 mm/s.

--- Page 1 ---

Stability and optical quality of windmill-formed 8CB liquid crystal films for replenishable plasma mirrors

Pruning redundant reasoning tokens

Liquid crystal (LC) film plasma mirrors (PMs) based on 4-octyl-4’-cyanobiphenyl (8CB) are an enabling technology for reflecting high-fluence laser pulses These freestanding LC films can achieve high optical quality and are well-suited for rep-rated applications, as motorized devices continuously replenish films over an aperture following each destructive laser shot.

How the training signal is built

The film-formation reliability of 8CB LC films demonstrated >97% formation success at 2.7 mm/s film-forming speeds, but decreased to 45% at 10.8 mm/s. These reliability numbers will inform future designs to reach Hz-level repetition rates and beyond.

Where the gains come from

Depending on area-of-interest within the 10 mm diameter film, the added wavefront root-mean-squared (RMS) variation was as small as 12 nm for a 2 mm diameter region, and <50 nm for a 3 mm diameter region. Within the optimal 21-22°C operating regime, pointing fluctuations remained at or below 0.5 mrad. With a maximum effective film formation frequency of 0.25 Hz, these results establish windmill-formed 8CB films as promising candidates to pursue next-iteration improvements towards rep-rated plasma-mirror operation.

Optical characterization of LC films in vacuum was conducted using a low power diagnostic laser beam as illustrated in the schematic layout in Fig. 1(c). A 532 nm continuouswave (CW) diode laser was used for wavefront measurements with an Imagine Optic HASO LIFT 680 wavefront sensor. The smallest reliably resolvable spatial period on the LC film was 35 µm.

The angular stability of films formed with the windmill were derived from the tip/tilt Zernike coefficients of the reference-subtracted wavefront data. Film-to-film fluctuations of the wavefront RMS, analyzed for a 2 mm pupil size, are displayed in Fig. 5(a) for an operating condition of 21–22°C and 5.4 mm/s wiping speed.

In this work, the BELLA PW laser was used to test windmill-formed 8CB LC films as replenishable PMs capable of redirecting high-power pulses into a beam dump to protect downstream components At the maximum fluence, 240 J/cm2, the transmission reached a minimum of (4.0 ± 0.2)%.

This work establishes windmill-formed 8CB LC films as a replenishable PM technology for high-power laser applications, with a maximum effective film formation frequency of 0.25 Hz We observed the highest film quality when operating in a temperature range of 21–22°C, in which the films added a wavefront RMS error of only 12–16 nm over a 2 mm analysis pupil. Furthermore, film-to-film angular pointing fluctuations were constrained to ≤ 0.5 mrad.

--- Page 3 ---

Stability and optical quality of windmill-formed 8CB liquid crystal films for replenishable plasma mirrors

Maintaining the temperature of the LC in the smectic phase (20-30◦C) allows the intrinsic surface tension of the PM to produce an optically smooth film surface with nearly uniform film thickness. If the assembly is operated outside of this smectic phase, it could transition into unusable phases such as: crystalline (40 °C). p. 1

Where the paper says it

Maintaining the temperature of the LC in the smectic phase (20-30◦C 28,32) allows the intrinsic surface tension of the PM to produce an optically smooth film surface with nearly uniform film thickness. 23 If the assembly is operated outside of this smectic phase, it could transition into unusable phases such as: crystalline (<20 ◦C), nematic (approximately 30-40 ◦C), or liquid (>40 ◦C).

The front of the windmill is shown in Fig. 1(a). A stepper motor drove a rotor configured with six arms (expandable to twelve), each holding one end of a 10 mm × 12 mm wiper (length × width, a close-up is shown in Fig. p. 1

Where the paper says it

The front of the windmill is shown in Fig. A stepper motor drove a rotor configured with six arms (expandable to twelve), each holding one end of a 10 mm × 12 mm wiper (length × width, a close-up is shown in Fig.

2) that traversed the stationary 10 mm diameter aperture on a polished aluminum plate. p. 1
Where the paper says it

A stepper motor drove a rotor configured with six arms (expandable to twelve), each holding one end of a 10 mm × 12 mm wiper (length × width, a close-up is shown in Fig. 2) that traversed the stationary 10 mm diameter aperture on a polished aluminum plate.

To ensure a reproducible LC reservoir on the surface after new LC was applied, a conditioning protocol was performed where the motor was run at a slow speed for 10–15 minutes to evenly distribute the material. p. 1
Where the paper says it

This configuration facilitated a consistent wiping mechanism while avoiding damage to the polished surface. To ensure a reproducible LC reservoir on the surface after new LC was applied, a conditioning protocol was performed where the motor was run at a slow speed for 10–15 minutes to evenly distribute the material.

Following this wiping process, the resulting films (Fig. 1(b)) were found to maintain a central flat region of approximately 3–4 mm across the 10 mm aperture, as confirmed through diagnostic testing described in this paper. p. 1

Where the paper says it

Following this wiping process, the resulting films (Fig. 1(b)) were found to maintain a central flat region of approximately 3–4 mm across the 10 mm aperture, as confirmed through diagnostic testing described in this paper.

Optical characterization of LC films in vacuum was conducted using a low power diagnostic laser beam as illustrated in the schematic layout in Fig. 1(c). The beam was incident on the surface at 14◦ to the normal and was slightly larger than the aperture size to allow full-profile film imaging. p. 2

Where the paper says it

1(c) and 1(d), the diagnostic beam was reflected from films on the side of the windmill assembly that is opposite of the side containing the wipers. The beam was incident on the surface at 14◦ to the normal and was slightly larger than the aperture size to allow full-profile film imaging.

Before reaching the wavefront sensor, the reflected beam traversed a 200 mm focal-length lens that imaged the film plane to the wavefront sensor chip. p. 2
Where the paper says it

The beam was incident on the surface at 14◦ to the normal and was slightly larger than the aperture size to allow full-profile film imaging. Before reaching the wavefront sensor, the reflected beam traversed a 200 mm focal-length lens that imaged the film plane to the wavefront sensor chip.

To accurately assess the film’s intrinsic optical quality over a multi-mm central area, the aberrations introduced by the LC film on the reflected diagnostic beam had to be isolated from the beam’s intrinsic wavefront. The angular stability of films formed with the windmill were derived from the tip/tilt Zernike coefficients of the reference-subtracted wavefront data.

The windmill was installed at a location 19 cm downstream of the laser focus, where the laser beam diameter (FWHM) on the films was approximately wx = 1.9 mm (horizontal) and wy = 2. p. 4

Where the paper says it

The corresponding film-to-film angular fluctuations for the same operating conditions are shown in Fig. The horizontal angular fluctuation exceeded the vertical component, a trend that was observed across nearly all tested configurations.

0 mm (vertical), using a standard F/65 off-axis parabolic mirror. p. 5
Where the paper says it

9 mm (horizontal) and wy = 2. 0 mm (vertical), using a standard F/65 off-axis parabolic mirror.

--- Page 4 ---

Stability and optical quality of windmill-formed 8CB liquid crystal films for replenishable plasma mirrors

The impact from the presence of a highpower laser pulse on film-formation reliability was investigated. We suspect that this formation probability trend arises from coupled physical limitations at the moving LC boundary: (i) insufficient relaxation time for smectic ordering to re-establish after rapid drawing, and (ii) stress/defect-mediated interfacial dynamics localized near the aperture edge. p. 4

Where the paper says it

For analysis pupil diameters of (a) 2 mm, (b) 3 mm, and (c) 4 mm, the wavefront root-mean-square (RMS) values (nm) after subtraction of a flat-mirror reference, where in each cell, the displayed value corresponds to the mean ± standard deviation over 120 film-formation attempts in vacuum per grid configuration, excluding piston, tip, tilt, and defocus Zernike terms for this analysis. coupled physical limitations at the moving LC boundary: (i) insufficient relaxation time for smectic ordering to re-establish after rapid drawing, and (ii) stress/defect-mediated interfacial dynamics localized near the aperture edge.

In smectic materials, ordering is governed by reorientation/reorganization kinetics that depend on how effectively stress can be dissipated during interfacial motion. As the film edge is a natural site for elevated stress concentration, it may dominate defect creation and evolution during boundary motion. p. 4

Where the paper says it

In smectic materials, ordering is governed by reorientation/reorganization kinetics that depend on how effectively stress can be dissipated during interfacial motion. 33 As the film edge is a natural site for elevated stress concentration, it may dominate defect creation and evolution during boundary motion.

Liquid crystals can form boundarystabilized configurations by adapting their molecular arrangement to surface features. p. 4
Where the paper says it

34 This molecular instability may also be modulated by the microscopic texture of the aperture edge. Liquid crystals can form boundarystabilized configurations by adapting their molecular arrangement to surface features.

The optical quality of the LC films across different pupil sizes, temperatures, and wiping speeds using said six arm configuration are summarized in Fig. 4. Across all tested conditions, the wavefront RMS of higher order Zernike terms (excluding piston, tip, tilt, and defocus Zernike terms) for the 2 mm diagnostic pupil ranged from 10 to 46 nm. p. 4

Where the paper says it

36 The optical quality of the LC films across different pupil sizes, temperatures, and wiping speeds using said six arm configuration are summarized in Fig. Across all tested conditions, the wavefront RMS of higher order Zernike terms (excluding piston, tip, tilt, and defocus Zernike terms) for the 2 mm diagnostic pupil ranged from 10 to 46 nm, with corresponding peak-to-valley (PV) values between 83 and 282 nm (Fig.

p. 4
Where the paper says it

36 The optical quality of the LC films across different pupil sizes, temperatures, and wiping speeds using said six arm configuration are summarized in Fig. Across all tested conditions, the wavefront RMS of higher order Zernike terms (excluding piston, tip, tilt, and defocus Zernike terms) for the 2 mm diagnostic pupil ranged from 10 to 46 nm, with corresponding peak-to-valley (PV) values between 83 and 282 nm (Fig.

We found that the optical quality was most robust within the 21–22◦C temperature window, where the wavefront RMS only varied between 12 nm and 16 nm across all investigated wiping speeds. p. 4
Where the paper says it

Across all tested conditions, the wavefront RMS of higher order Zernike terms (excluding piston, tip, tilt, and defocus Zernike terms) for the 2 mm diagnostic pupil ranged from 10 to 46 nm, with corresponding peak-to-valley (PV) values between 83 and 282 nm (Fig. We found that the optical quality was most robust within the 21–22◦C temperature window, where the wavefront RMS only varied between 12 nm and 16 nm across all investigated wiping speeds.

Across the full range of temperatures and wiping speeds, the total angular fluctuation (∆θtotal) spanned from approximately 270 to 740 µrad. Film-to-film fluctuations of the wavefront RMS, analyzed for a 2 mm pupil size, are displayed in Fig. 5(a) for an operating condition of 21–22°C and 5.4 mm/s wiping speed.

The transmitted laser energy was measured through the LC film, while the reflected pulse was directed into a beam dump 20 cm away The results of the transmission measurements are displayed in Fig. 6. At the maximum fluence, 240 J/cm2, the transmission reached a minimum of (4.0 ± 0.2)%.

--- Page 7 ---

Stability and optical quality of windmill-formed 8CB liquid crystal films for replenishable plasma mirrors

A possible explanation is that adjacent wipers cut from the same tissue sheet were not perfectly identical: individual wipers could therefore generate films with distinct aberration signatures and corresponding repeatable angle deviations. This suggests that further standardization of wiper production could reduce film-to-film variations of optical quality. p. 4

Where the paper says it

A possible explanation is that adjacent wipers cut from the same tissue sheet were not perfectly identical: individual wipers could therefore generate films with distinct aberration signatures and corresponding repeatable angle deviations. This suggests that further standardization of wiper production could reduce film-to-film variations of optical quality.

In addition, we observed slow drifts when wipers were not exchanged on the order of a week or when operating at higher temperatures/speeds. p. 4
Where the paper says it

This suggests that further standardization of wiper production could reduce film-to-film variations of optical quality. In addition, we observed slow drifts when wipers were not exchanged on the order of a week or when operating at higher temperatures/speeds.

We attributed this behavior to excess LC accumulating unevenly at the trailing edge of the aperture during horizontal wiping. p. 4
Where the paper says it

In addition, we observed slow drifts when wipers were not exchanged on the order of a week or when operating at higher temperatures/speeds. We attributed this behavior to excess LC accumulating unevenly at the trailing edge of the aperture during horizontal wiping.

The optical quality of the LC films across different pupil sizes, temperatures, and wiping speeds using said six arm configuration are summarized in Fig. 4. Across all tested conditions, the wavefront RMS of higher order Zernike terms (excluding piston, tip, tilt, and defocus Zernike terms) for the 2 mm diagnostic pupil ranged from 10 to 46 nm.

The transmitted laser energy was measured through the LC film, while the reflected pulse was directed into a beam dump 20 cm away The results of the transmission measurements are displayed in Fig. 6.

--- Page 9 ---

Stability and optical quality of windmill-formed 8CB liquid crystal films for replenishable plasma mirrors

The data that support the findings of this study are openly available in Zenodo at doi:10.5281/zenodo. p. 6

Where the paper says it

DATA AVAILABILITY The data that support the findings of this study are openly available in Zenodo at doi:10. 5281/zenodo.

20561401, reference number [39]. p. 6
Where the paper says it

5281/zenodo. 20561401 , reference number [39].

Green — the paper says it, and the page is printed. Red — no passage carries it, so treat that sentence as unverified. The same check runs on your own text: check a summary against its source, $5.

Improvements for AI systems

  1. Improved predictive modeling for PM performance by incorporating film-to-film wavefront stability data across varying wiping speeds and temperatures. The improved system can accurately predict wavefront RMS error based on operating conditions, as demonstrated by the characterization of windmill-formed 8CB films showing the optical quality was most robust within the 21–22◦C temperature window.

  2. Enhanced reliability assessment for high repetition rate applications by integrating film formation probability into operational limits. The improved system can determine if a target repetition rate is achievable by calculating the effective film formation frequency using the formula feff(T,v) = f0(v)P(T,v)/100, and identifying speed regimes where reliability drops significantly.

  3. Optimized design parameters for LC PMs based on characterization of angular stability under high-speed operation. The improved system can predict angular fluctuation by correlating horizontal and vertical tip/tilt Zernike coefficients with wiper speed and temperature, allowing designers to select operating conditions that constrain pointing fluctuations to ≤ 0.5 mrad.

  4. Real-time adaptive control for wavefront correction in plasma mirror systems using the measured aberration signatures. The improved system can dynamically adjust correction algorithms based on the observed film-induced aberrations, utilizing the measured higher order Zernike terms to minimize residual optical errors during operation.

  5. Automated quality assurance for film production by analyzing surface texture and material consistency. The improved system can flag batches of LC films that exhibit defects or inconsistent optical quality by correlating formation probability with assembly temperature and wiping speed, addressing issues like stress/defect-mediated interfacial dynamics localized near the aperture edge.

Abstract

Liquid crystal (LC) film plasma mirrors (PMs) based on 4-octyl-4'-cyanobiphenyl (8CB) are an enabling technology for reflecting high-fluence laser pulses. These freestanding LC films can achieve high optical quality and are well-suited for rep-rated applications, as motorized devices continuously replenish films over an aperture following each destructive laser shot. However, a systematic characterization of film quality as a function of seminal operating conditions had not yet been performed for the LC "windmill" version of the device, which aims to match the repetition rate of an existing "spinning disk" (SDI) version and the angular stability of the "linear slider" (LSTI) version. We determined the 8CB film quality using low-power wavefront measurements, and studied the film-to-film wavefront stability and formation reliability. The film-formation reliability of 8CB LC films demonstrated 97% formation success at 2.7 mm/s film-forming speeds, but decreased to 45% at 10.8 mm/s. These reliability numbers will inform future designs to reach Hz-level repetition rates and beyond. Depending on area-of-interest within the 10 mm diameter film, the added wavefront root-mean-squared (RMS) variation was as small as 10 nm for a 2 mm diameter region, and < 50 nm for a 3 mm diameter region. Within the optimal 21-22 C operating regime, pointing fluctuations remained at or below 0.52 mrad. With a maximum effective film formation frequency of 0.25 Hz, these results establish windmill-formed 8CB films as promising candidates to pursue next-iteration improvements towards rep-rated plasma-mirror operation.

Related papers