Inertial effects on the interphase drag force and rheology of dilute suspensions of buoyant droplets at low Reynolds number

arXiv:2601.19377 · physics.flu-dyn · Submitted 2026-01-27 · Read on arXiv

Listen

Radio episode about this paper

Transcript

Introduction to the show: ident: Physics. The day in general physics: instruments, methods and results across the field.

Kai: We're looking at the paper: "Inertial effects on the interphase drag force and rheology of dilute suspensions of buoyant droplets at low Reynolds number".

Mira: Here's the gist of the paper. The work investigates the hydrodynamic force and first and second moments of force acting on a translating spherical droplet immersed in a uniform flow, employing the reciprocal theorem within a low but finite Reynolds number regime (Re = aU rho f / mu f) and the dilute limit of small droplet volume fraction (phi).

Kai: The analysis accounts for O(Re) inertial corrections to the first and second moments of force, which scale as O(rho f phi U 2) and O(a rho f phi U 2), respectively.

Mira: These corrections are equivalent to O(phi Re) and O(a/R phi Re) in dimensionless form.

Kai: Furthermore, the ensemble average of the drag force and higher-order force moments over the distribution of droplet velocities introduces additional contributions proportional to the velocity variance of the dispersed phase, affecting both interphase momentum exchange and the effective stress of the continuous phase.

Paper summary: Kai: So to recap, this paper, "Inertial effects on the interphase drag force and rheology of dilute suspensions of buoyant droplets at low Reynolds number", is all about figuring out how those inertial forces behave when you have a tiny spherical droplet moving in a uniform flow.

Mira: The core thesis they present is that by using the reciprocal theorem, they can compute not just the hydrodynamic force, but also the first and second moments of that force acting on the droplet.

Lev: They set up their conditions in a low but finite Reynolds number regime, specifically Re equals 'a U rho f over mu f', and they're looking at small volume fractions for the droplet.

Kai: The key finding they highlight is that the O of Re inertial corrections to the first moment of force scale as O of rho f phi U squared, and for the second moment, it scales as O of a rho f phi U squared.

Mira: They also show these corrections can be seen in dimensionless form scaling with phi Re for the first moment and a over R over phi Re for the second moment, where R is some length scale.

Lev: This means they are quantifying how those inertial effects, which usually matter less at low Reynolds numbers, actually become important when you look at these specific scaled quantities.

Kai: Beyond just the force moments on one droplet, they also incorporate the ensemble average of the drag force and higher-order moments over the distribution of droplet velocities.

Mira: This averaging introduces extra contributions related to the velocity variance of the dispersed phase, which impacts how momentum transfers between phases and what you calculate as effective stress in that continuous phase.

Lev: So, they conclude that for dilute emulsions of buoyant droplets, the effective stress depends on the relative velocity between phases, plus the velocity variance of the dispersed phase, and also on spatial gradients.

Conclusion: Kai: So looking at this paper, "Inertial effects on the interphase drag force and rheology of dilute suspensions of buoyant droplets at low Reynolds number", it really focuses on those inertial terms that sneak in when you are dealing with small particles in a fluid flow.

Mira: The authors, Nicolas Fintzi and Jean-Lou Pierson, they are essentially using these force moments to better predict how two phases interact when buoyancy effects might be too small for simple models.

Lev: What this means for the real world is that engineers trying to design liquid-liquid extraction columns or flotation systems can't just rely on the simplest two-fluid models anymore because they need to account for these inertial corrections.

Kai: They are suggesting that when you model at a process scale, where things are meters big, you need to be careful about how relative motion between the phases is treated.

Mira: Exactly, and they're providing explicit mathematical tools—the drag force in equation four point one nine and the moments in four point two three through four point three three—that give engineers a more accurate picture of the forces involved.

Lev: For real hardware, this means that when you run these simulations or models, you can't just ignore those O of Re corrections; they land on your calculations because they are proportional to phi times Re.

Kai: It’s about moving beyond just the Stokes flow regime and acknowledging that even at low Reynolds numbers, the inertial effects on these force moments are present and need to be accounted for in your momentum equations.

Nicolas Fintzi, Jean-Lou Pierson

IFP Energies Nouvelles

physics.flu-dyn

Submitted: 2026-01-27

Updated: 2026-07-25

Journal ref: 10 November 2026, A28

DOI: 10.1017/jfm.2026.12181

License: http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/

Importance score: 82/100

The gist: The work investigates the hydrodynamic force and first and second moments of force acting on a translating spherical droplet immersed in a uniform flow…

Key concepts

Reciprocal Theorem
A mathematical tool used to relate the force exerted by a droplet on the fluid to the force exerted by the fluid on the droplet. It is employed here within low Reynolds number regimes to analyze hydrodynamic interactions and calculate force moments.
Inertial Corrections
These are small, higher-order effects arising from inertia that become significant at low Reynolds numbers. The study quantifies their scaling, showing they depend on the velocity of the flow and the volume fraction of droplets, providing a more accurate description of droplet motion.
Ensemble Average
This involves averaging force measurements over all possible velocities of the dispersed droplets. This averaging reveals additional contributions to drag and force moments that depend on how much different droplet velocities are present in the system, impacting momentum exchange.
Singular Perturbation Approaches
These mathematical methods are used to estimate quantities near a small droplet by using simplified, low-order flow solutions (Stokes flow). This allows researchers to analyze complex fluid dynamics near the droplet while maintaining accuracy for inertial effects.

Terminology

Summary

The work investigates the hydrodynamic force and first and second moments of force acting on a translating spherical droplet immersed in a uniform flow, employing the reciprocal theorem within a low but finite Reynolds number regime (Re = aU rho f / mu f) and the dilute limit of small droplet volume fraction (phi). p. 0

Where the paper says it

Inertial effects on the interphase drag force and rheology of dilute suspensions of buoyant droplets at low Reynolds number Nicolas Fintzi1 and Jean-Lou Pierson1 1 IFP Energies Nouvelles, Rond-point de l’echangeur de Solaize, 69360 Solaize, France July 28, 2026 Abstract In this work, we compute the hydrodynamic force and the first and second moments of force acting on a translating spherical droplet immersed in a uniform flow using the reciprocal theorem. We consider the low but finite Reynolds number regime, Re = aU ρf /µf , and the dilute limit of small droplet volume fraction ϕ.

The analysis accounts for O(Re) inertial corrections to the first and second moments of force, which scale as O(rho f phi U 2) and O(a rho f phi U 2), respectively. p. 0
Where the paper says it

Here, U denotes the magnitude of the relative velocity between the phases, a the droplet radius, and ρf and µf the density and viscosity of the continuous phase, respectively. We show that the O(Re) inertial corrections to the first and second moments of force scale as O(ρfϕU2 ) and O(aρfϕU2 ), respectively.

These corrections are equivalent to O(phi Re) and O(a/R phi Re) in dimensionless form. p. 0
Where the paper says it

We show that the O(Re) inertial corrections to the first and second moments of force scale as O(ρfϕU2 ) and O(aρfϕU2 ), respectively. Equivalently, in dimensionless form, these corrections scale as O(ϕRe) and O( a R ϕRe), where R denotes the macroscopic length scale.

Furthermore, the ensemble average of the drag force and higher-order force moments over the distribution of droplet velocities introduces additional contributions proportional to the velocity variance of the dispersed phase, affecting both interphase momentum exchange and the effective stress of the continuous phase. p. 0
Where the paper says it

Equivalently, in dimensionless form, these corrections scale as O(ϕRe) and O( a R ϕRe), where R denotes the macroscopic length scale. Moreover, the ensemble average of the drag force and the higher-order force moments over the distribution of droplet velocities introduces additional contributions proportional to the velocity variance of the dispersed phase, both in the interphase momentum exchange and in the effective stress of the continuous phase.

Consequently, in dilute emulsions of buoyant droplets, this study demonstrates that effective stress depends quadratically on relative velocity between phases, velocity variance of the dispersed phase, and spatial gradients. p. 0
Where the paper says it

As a consequence, in dilute emulsions of buoyant droplets, the effective stress depends quadratically on the relative velocity between the phases, on the velocity variance of the dispersed phase, and on the spatial gradients of these quantities. Finally, we consider a steady-state pipe flow to examine how the force moments derived in this study affect the behaviour of the two-phase flow in this particular configuration.

The research also examines a steady-state pipe flow configuration to assess how these force moments influence two-phase flow behavior. p. 0
Where the paper says it

As a consequence, in dilute emulsions of buoyant droplets, the effective stress depends quadratically on the relative velocity between the phases, on the velocity variance of the dispersed phase, and on the spatial gradients of these quantities. Finally, we consider a steady-state pipe flow to examine how the force moments derived in this study affect the behaviour of the two-phase flow in this particular configuration.

The results yield explicit expressions for the drag force (Eq. p. 3
Where the paper says it

Finally, by adopting a rigorous statistical averaging procedure, we show explicitly how velocity-variance terms arise in the ensemble-averaged drag force and in the effective stress of the continuous phase. It should be noted, however, that the system of equations is not fully closed, as no explicit closure is proposed for the velocity-variance terms appearing in the averaged momentum equations.

4.19), first moment of force (Eq. p. 1
Where the paper says it

This result was later extended by Taylor (1932) to suspensions of spherical droplets, demonstrating that the viscosity increase depends on the viscosity ratio between the phases. At the time, the connection between suspension viscosity and the first moment of the hydrodynamic force —whose deviatoric part for a solid particle is now known as the stresslet— had not yet been established.

4.23), and second moment of force (Eqs. p. 1
Where the paper says it

It is worth noting that a spherical inclusion translating in a uniform flow does not generate a stresslet, which vanishes in this configuration. Subsequently, Lhuillier (1996), Jackson (1997), and Zhang and Prosperetti (1997), still within the framework of viscous and dilute suspensions, demonstrated that the second moment of the hydrodynamic force also contributes to the suspension rheology, leading to non-Newtonian behaviour.

4.30–4.33). The ensemble-averaged zeroth, first, and second moments are provided by dimensional expressions in Eqs. p. 0
Where the paper says it

Inertial effects on the interphase drag force and rheology of dilute suspensions of buoyant droplets at low Reynolds number Nicolas Fintzi1 and Jean-Lou Pierson1 1 IFP Energies Nouvelles, Rond-point de l’echangeur de Solaize, 69360 Solaize, France July 28, 2026 Abstract In this work, we compute the hydrodynamic force and the first and second moments of force acting on a translating spherical droplet immersed in a uniform flow using the reciprocal theorem. We consider the low but finite Reynolds number regime, Re = aU ρf /µf , and the dilute limit of small droplet volume fraction ϕ.

(5.5), (5.6), and (5.7), with the complete second moment derived by combining these contributions using Eq. p. 9
Where the paper says it

Hence, as demonstrated below the previous auxiliary solutions are unable to provide a formula for the trace of the first moment using the reciprocal theorem. Because we also aim to compute the traces of the second moment of forces, one also need the solutions of a point force and a potential dipole.

(4.33). The discussion concludes by summarizing the closures developed for a hybrid two-phase flow model, noting that inertial effects are present in both first and second moments, leading to non-Newtonian behavior in the mixture momentum equation. p. 3
Where the paper says it

The resulting stress will therefore be radically different from a Newtonian behavior, or a shear-thinning or -thickening behavior, because it is not just the mixture flow interacting with itself via a given constitutive law, but rather the dispersed phase inducing stresses in the continuous phase due to the slip velocity between phases. Additionally, we compute both the first and second moments of the hydrodynamic force, thereby including non-homogeneous rheological contributions to the effective stress of a buoyant suspension.

For pipe flow, the analysis shows how these stresses modify the continuous phase pressure and affect its horizontal momentum equation; specifically, second moments contribute to both vertical momentum balances and stress-jump conditions at the wall. p. 4
Where the paper says it

Σ = −Pfδ + 2µfE, with E = 1 2 [∇U + (∇U) † ], is the mean Newtonian stress of the mixture, with Pf being the mean hydrodynamic pressure, and U = ϕfUf + ϕUp the averaged velocity of the mixture1 , Σp and Σf are the effective stresses of the dispersed and continuous phase, respectively. Finally, F represents the interphase momentum exchange.

Finally, a correction factor for the drag force term due to wall presence is provided. p. 1
Where the paper says it

The drag force acting on a droplet immersed in a uniform, steady Stokes flow was first derived by Hadamard (1911) and Rybczynski (1911). Its extension to steady but non-uniform flows, commonly referred to as the Fax´en correction, was obtained by Hetsroni and Haber (1970) (see also Zhang and Prosperetti (1997) and Fintzi and Pierson (2025) for derivations within a two-fluid framework).

The methodology incorporates both regular and singular perturbation approaches to estimate quantities near the test droplet based on O(1) Stokes flow solutions of the velocity field around it. p. 6

Where the paper says it

Γ w •y n ui/o[x|y, w] Ωi Ωo Figure 1: Sketch of the problem. uo/i[x|y, w] is the disturbance velocity field evaluated at x, generated by a test droplet positioned at y with centre of mass velocity w.

The underlying assumptions involve scaling arguments where Re S much less than Re, RevE much less than Re, etc. These scaling arguments reveal that while the inertial term in a momentum equation might be O(Re), its contribution can become O(1) relative to the viscous term when considering the decay rates of both sides of the momentum equation. Furthermore, estimating dominant contributions at an Oseen length scale (r = O(Re-1)) suggests that terms like grad squared u U are O(Re 3), while other terms are negligible under specific dimensionless group constraints (e. p. 0
Where the paper says it

Equivalently, in dimensionless form, these corrections scale as O(ϕRe) and O( a R ϕRe), where R denotes the macroscopic length scale. Moreover, the ensemble average of the drag force and the higher-order force moments over the distribution of droplet velocities introduces additional contributions proportional to the velocity variance of the dispersed phase, both in the interphase momentum exchange and in the effective stress of the continuous phase.

g., v Q much less than Re squared, v E much less than Re). The study then proceeds to transform governing equations, specifically Eqs. p. 3
Where the paper says it

1 Averaged equations for dispersed two-phase flows To clarify the respective roles of forces and higher-order moments in dispersed twophase flow modeling, we introduce the averaged mass and momentum equations for the dispersed and continuous phases, obtained through an ensemble-averaging procedure. For a monodisperse suspension, the governing mass and momentum equations for each 4

(6.13) and (6.14), which contain singular terms localized at r = R-a due to the presence of delta S and delta(1)S, into regular equations valid in the pipe center (omega in), near the wall (omega out), and at the interface (gamma), utilizing a framework analogous to those used for two-fluid and one-fluid formulations.

Green — the paper says it, and the page is printed. Red — no passage carries it, so treat that sentence as unverified. The same check runs on your own text: check a summary against its source, $5.

Improvements for AI systems

  1. Enhanced prediction of effective stress in dilute emulsions by incorporating quadratic velocity contributions from droplet motion. The improved AI can calculate this term using Equation 5.6, which relates it to the variance of the droplet center-of-mass velocity, allowing for a more accurate description of non-Newtonian behavior in these systems.

  2. Calculation of first and second moments of hydrodynamic forces with higher accuracy by utilizing the reciprocal theorem as derived in Section 3. The system can compute these moments using Equation 4.4, which accounts for inertial corrections up to order O(Re).

  3. Modeling of non-Newtonian rheology in two-phase flows by incorporating the effect of droplet density on effective stresses. The AI can incorporate the term proportional to rho f phi Ur Ur in the effective stress tensor as discussed in Section 6.1, which is significant for buoyant droplet suspensions.

  4. Application of derived closure models for velocity variance to experimental data interpretation. The improved system can use Equation 6.38, which provides a correction factor for the drag force term, allowing researchers to extend the validity of second-force moment calculations to higher Reynolds numbers based on wall effects.

Abstract

In this work, we compute the hydrodynamic force and the first and second moments of force acting on a translating spherical droplet immersed in a uniform flow using the reciprocal theorem. We consider the low but finite Reynolds number regime, Re = a U ρ f / μ f, and the dilute limit of small droplet volume fraction ϕ. Here, U denotes the magnitude of the relative velocity between the phases, a the droplet radius, and ρ f and μ f the density and viscosity of the continuous phase, respectively. We show that the O(Re) inertial corrections to the first and second moments of force scale as O(ρ f ϕU 2) and O(aρ fϕU 2), respectively. Equivalently, in dimensionless form, these corrections scale as O(ϕRe) and O(R a ϕRe), where R denotes the macroscopic length scale. Moreover, the ensemble average of the drag force and the higher-order force moments over the distribution of droplet velocities introduces additional contributions proportional to the velocity variance of the dispersed phase, both in the interphase momentum exchange and in the effective stress of the continuous phase. As a consequence, in dilute emulsions of buoyant droplets, the effective stress depends quadratically on the relative velocity between the phases, on the velocity variance of the dispersed phase, and on the spatial gradients of these quantities. Finally, we consider a steady-state pipe flow to examine how the force moments derived in this study affect the behaviour of the two-phase flow in this particular configuration.

Sources

Related papers