Early onset of secondary shear instability in Kelvin-Helmholtz braids at high Reynolds number

arXiv:2604.16173 · physics.flu-dyn · Submitted 2026-04-17 · Read on arXiv

Listen

Radio episode about this paper

Transcript

Introduction to the show: ident: Physics. The day in general physics: instruments, methods and results across the field.

Kai: I'm Kai.

Mira: And I'm Mira, here with Lev.

Kai: We're looking at the paper: "Early onset of secondary shear instability in Kelvin-Helmholtz braids at high Reynolds number".

Mira: Here's the gist of the paper. Early onset of secondary shear instability in Kelvin–Helmholtz braids at high Reynolds number; this study develops an inviscid, time-dependent model for the braid and the onset of SSI by modifying classical analysis and adding a new stability criterion, showing that SSI can develop significantly earlier than primary billow saturation at sufficiently high initial Richardson number Ri.

Kai: Modeling the Braid Evolution The authors introduce an inviscid model for the time evolution and stability of the braid in section 2.

Mira: The authors suggest that the timescale over which the threshold (2.13) is reached scales approximately as 1/sqrt(gamma1).

Kai: Numerical Validation and Results Direct numerical simulations (DNS) were run using Oceananigans.jl with geophysically relevant Ri =

0.05, 0.10, 0.15, 0.20: and Re =

104, 105, 106, 107: = 105.

Title and authors: Mira: Now that we know they developed a model for this, let's look at what the paper actually summarizes about it, because it’s not just a list of results, it’s building on the background of Kelvin-Helmholtz instability.

Kai: They begin by defining the braid regions connecting primary Kelvin-Helmholtz billows and then they focus specifically on secondary shear instability SSI, which produces trains of vortices that are advected along the braid and towards the cores >"

Mira: They frame turbulent transition as a competition between these instabilities, showing how their evolution changes significantly as the primary billow grows and saturates in amplitude >"

Lev: So they are looking at this competition between different instability growth rates, which is a common theme in turbulence research. But what specifically do they show about that competition?

Kai: They show how the growth rates of these instabilities evolve significantly as the primary billow grows and saturates in amplitude, meaning the competition isn't static; it changes over time >"

Mira: They argue that in the ocean, Kelvin-Helmholtz instability is considered a primary pathway between submesoscales and stratified turbulence, with coherent structures observed from deep ocean to the thermocline and continental shelves >"

Lev: That connects their work to what we see in large-scale geophysical flows. But they focus on SSI specifically where things get messy. What’s the specific mechanism driving this secondary shear instability?

Kai: They found that strain induced by the billows stabilizes the braids, but it also compresses their tilted isopycnals, which enhances baroclinic shear that enables rapid perturbation growth >"

Mira: That's a key physical mechanism. So they are linking the primary billow’s effect—stabilization—to something that actually promotes instability: increased baroclinic shear >"

Lev: And this is what drives the secondary instability, right? It’s not just random noise; it’s driven by the flow structure itself >"

Kai: Exactly. They develop an inviscid model for braid evolution following Corcos and Sherman from one thousand nine hundred seventy-six defining braid-aligned coordinates x prime and z prime >" <ref:2604.16173#pg1>

Mira: They define these coordinates by saying the along-braid variation of the angle is insignificant, but they neglect the time-dependent rotation of this coordinate system in their governing equations >"

Lev: So they are simplifying things by neglecting that rotation. That’s a choice that might be important later on when we think about real simulations. What does that simplification mean for accuracy?

Kai: They neglect the time-dependent rotation of the coordinate system, and they assume gradients in z prime are greater than those in x prime, which means they neglect terms involving the partial derivative with respect to x prime over time >"

Mira: So their governing equations then become a specific form that captures the key physics of braid evolution under these assumptions >"

Lev: And that leads directly into equation two point five and two point six, where they define the equations for the braid velocity and vorticity based on those assumptions >"

Kai: Yes, equation two point five gives you the evolution of braid velocity, which is governed by advection terms and diffusion terms based on Re and Pr >"

Mira: And then equation two point six gives you the evolution of vorticity, which includes those Ri terms that depend on the tilt angle and the strain rate >"

Lev: So they are showing how these two equations together describe the whole system under their assumptions, which is a pretty clean way to present their model >"

Kai: It’s a clean presentation because it isolates the key physical drivers—the advection, diffusion, and those specific Ri terms that dictate when SSI starts >"

The paper's summary: Lev: Okay, so we’ve seen the model structure. Now let's move on to what they suggest are the actual improvements they made over previous work or how their approach is better than just sticking with classical analysis.

Kai: The main improvement is that they modify the classical analysis of Corcos and Sherman from one thousand nine hundred seventy-six by modifying it in braid-aligned coordinates and adding an additional stability criterion based on the ratio of strain rate to shear >" <ref:2604.16173#pg1,in braid-aligned coordinates and adding an additional stability criterion based on>

Mira: That new criterion, based on the ratio of strain rate to shear, is what allows them to develop this new inviscid, time-dependent model for the braid and SSI onset >"

Lev: So that means they’ve moved beyond just looking at static conditions. They are now diagnosing instability based on a dynamic balance of forces rather than just checking if some fixed number is exceeded >"

Kai: Exactly. They show that this criterion can be achieved significantly earlier than the saturation of the primary billow at sufficiently high initial Richardson number Ri, as increased stratification slows billow growth while accelerating baroclinic shear p"

Mira: So they are emphasizing that the competition between these growth rates is what determines when instability happens, and they link it directly to how stratification affects those rates >"

Lev: If you think about running this on real hardware or a supercomputer, how does that dynamic criterion compare to what we'd typically use for stability criteria? Is it computationally expensive?

Kai: The paper shows that this dynamic criterion provides a more rigorous threshold than previous methods, allowing AI to diagnose instability based on this ratio of strain rate to vorticity, called gamma omega z prime equals gamma1 t plus gamma0 over S t >"

Mira: That ratio is the one they formalized as the ratio of strain rate to vorticity, which acts as a threshold for diagnosing instability based on this dynamic balance instead of static conditions >"

Lev: And that sounds like it could be useful for running real hardware because it gives us a more precise way to diagnose the instability based on what’s happening in the flow right now >"

Kai: They also suggested that a higher Pr will reduce the interface thickness at which diffusion hinders strain-induced thinning, thus promoting closer agreement with the inviscid model and favoring SSI >"

Mira: So they are suggesting that viscous effects aren't always negligible, and when Pr is high, diffusion doesn't stop the strain-induced thinning as much, which makes it closer to the pure inviscid behavior >"

Lev: And what about computational constraints? They mentioned something about grid spacing for simulations. Did they establish a concrete rule for resolution?

Kai: In their simulations, they established a criterion for minimum grid spacing: d prime greater than ten delta z at the time of SSI onset >"

Mira: That’s important because it tells us what resolution you need to run your simulation to capture the onset of SSI accurately, moving beyond just standard criteria like Kolmogorov or Batchelor scale criteria >"

Lev: So they are giving a practical rule for setting up simulations based on the physics of the instability itself. That's something we can use.

The paper's improvements: Kai: Alright, let’s bring it all together for this paper, "Early onset of secondary shear instability in Kelvin-Helmholtz braids at high Reynolds number." We’ve seen how they developed an inviscid model and their results from the simulations with Re up to one hundred seven.

Mira: They conclude that early SSI requires a Richardson number Ri greater than or equal to zero point one zero in the inviscid limit for sufficient separation between the two instability times >"

Lev: So, if we look at what this means for our real-world applications, it suggests that we can predict when secondary shear instability will occur relative to primary billow saturation by incorporating a time-dependent model for braid evolution >"

Kai: They also show that at geophysically relevant Reynolds numbers greater than or equal to one hundred six the braid dynamics are effectively inviscid, so their results for SSI onset across the space of Richardson number Ri and Reynolds number Re should be independent of Pr greater than one >"

Mira: They suggest that a higher Pr will reduce the interface thickness where diffusion hinders strain-induced thinning, thus promoting closer agreement with the inviscid model and favoring SSI >"

Lev: And they give us a practical rule for setting up simulations: d prime greater than ten delta z at the time of SSI onset >"

Kai: So, to wrap up this paper on "Early onset of secondary shear instability in Kelvin-Helmholtz braids at high Reynolds number," the main point is that we can predict when secondary shear instability will occur relative to primary billow saturation by incorporating a time-dependent model for braid evolution >"

Mira: It also confirms that at geophysically relevant Reynolds numbers greater than or equal to one hundred six braid dynamics are effectively inviscid, so their results for SSI onset across the space of Richardson number Ri and Reynolds number Re should be independent of Pr greater than one >"

Kai: That’s the main thing. It’s about understanding how stratification and shear work together to create these instabilities earlier than we thought.

Conclusion: Kai: So, this paper is about "Early onset of secondary shear instability in Kelvin–Helmholtz braids at high Reynolds number." Basically, they developed an inviscid, time-dependent model for how these braids evolve and when that secondary shear instability starts >

Mira: It shows that you can get this instability much earlier than you thought if the initial stratification is high enough because the primary billow grows slower while the shear production speeds up >

Lev: And they found a specific dynamic criterion using the ratio of strain rate to vorticity to diagnose when that instability hits, which is different from just looking at static conditions >

Kai: They ran direct numerical simulations with Reynolds numbers up to one hundred seven and Richardson numbers in the range of zero point zero five to zero point two >

Mira: The key finding is that for this early onset of secondary shear instability, you need a Richardson number greater than or equal to zero point one in the inviscid limit >

Lev: That means if you’re running real hardware, that condition sets a minimum baroclinic shear production threshold for the braid dynamics to stay stable against this type of instability >

Kai: They also found that at Reynolds numbers of about one hundred and seven, the braid dynamics are essentially inviscid, so their results for Richardson number and Reynolds number should be mostly independent of Prandtl number greater than one >

Mira: But they did mention that a higher Prandtl number actually helps the model agree more closely with the inviscid math because it reduces how much diffusion hinders that strain-induced thinning >

Lev: And computationally, they gave us a rule for setting up simulations: you need your grid spacing to be greater than ten times the delta z at the moment of instability onset >

Kai: So to recap, this paper on "Early onset of secondary shear instability in Kelvin–Helmholtz braids at high Reynolds number" shows that timing matters in these flows and gives us a better way to set up simulations for those tricky transitions >

Mira: It really highlights how stratification and shear work together to create these instabilities much sooner than standard analysis predicts >

Lev: And it’s good to see a concrete criterion for grid spacing, because that tells us what resolution you actually need if you want to capture that onset accurately on a real system >

Kai: We’ll keep an eye on how this helps us understand the turbulent transition in these large-scale flows >

University of Cambridge

physics.flu-dyn

Submitted: 2026-04-17

Updated: 2026-04-17

DOI: 10.1017/jfm.2026.12012

License: http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/

Importance score: 98/100

The gist: Early onset of secondary shear instability in Kelvin–Helmholtz braids at high Reynolds number; this study develops an inviscid…

Key concepts

Secondary Shear Instability (SSI)
This is an instability that occurs within the Kelvin-Helmholtz braids, where secondary shear develops. The study focuses on how this instability can begin to develop much sooner than when the main wave structures (primary billows) fully form, especially under certain conditions.
Richardson Number (Ri)
Ri is a parameter representing the ratio of stable stratification to shear forces in the fluid. The paper shows that SSI onset is strongly dependent on Ri; higher initial values of Ri favor the earlier development of this secondary instability.
Inviscid Model
The authors created a mathematical model for braid evolution assuming no viscosity (inviscid). They showed that for geophysically relevant Reynolds numbers, this inviscid model accurately predicts braid dynamics and SSI onset, suggesting that diffusion effects are less important in these specific high-Re regimes.
Primary Billow Saturation Time (t2D)
This refers to the time when the main, large wave structures (primary billows) reach their saturated state. The research demonstrates that at sufficiently high initial Richardson numbers, SSI can develop before this primary saturation time.

Terminology

Summary

Early onset of secondary shear instability in Kelvin–Helmholtz braids at high Reynolds number; this study develops an inviscid, time-dependent model for the braid and the onset of SSI by modifying classical analysis and adding a new stability criterion, showing that SSI can develop significantly earlier than primary billow saturation at sufficiently high initial Richardson number Ri. p. 0

Where the paper says it

73, 241-264, 1976) in braid-aligned coordinates and adding an additional stability criterion based on the ratio of strain rate to shear, we develop an inviscid, time-dependent model for the braid and the onset of SSI. We show that the criterion for instability can be achieved significantly earlier than the saturation of the primary billow at sufficiently high initial Richardson number Ri, as increased stratification slows billow growth while accelerating baroclinic shear production in the braid.

Modeling the Braid Evolution

The authors introduce an inviscid model for the time evolution and stability of the braid in section 2. The authors suggest that the timescale over which the threshold (2. p. 3

Where the paper says it

11) together with the observation that 𝜙0 and 𝛾0 are small yields 𝑆(𝑡) ∼ exp(𝛾1𝑡 2 /2) for large 𝑡. This implies that the timescale over which the threshold (2.

13) is reached scales approximately as 1/sqrt(gamma1). p. 3
Where the paper says it

Importantly, however, these studies assumed that SSI develops at a time when braid thickness 𝛿 has reached an equilibrium in which straining is balanced by viscous diffusion, as was verified at the time using simulations at Re < 104 . This viscous equilibrium occurs approximately at time 𝑡2𝐷, defined as the time at which the amplitude of the primary billow saturates and the braid strain becomes approximately constant.

Numerical Validation and Results

Direct numerical simulations (DNS) were run using Oceananigans.jl with geophysically relevant Ri = [0. p. 0

Where the paper says it

At high Re, we find that SSI indeed develops early in the braid, as predicted by the inviscid model, while the primary billow is still growing and before viscosity slows braid thinning. These results provide a mechanistic explanation for field observations of braid-dominated mixing and suggest that, at geophysically relevant Ri and Re, SSI can control the three-dimensional turbulent transition and ensuing diapycnal mixing by preceding and pre-empting both vortex pairing instabilities and secondary convective instabilities in the billow core.

05, 0.10, 0.15, 0.20] and Re = [104, 105, 106, 107] = 105. p. 4
Where the paper says it

We present a set of 16 simulations with geophysically-relevant Ri = [0. 20] and Re = [104 , 105 , 106 , 107 ].

Conclusions on Stability and Relevance

The paper concludes that early SSI requires Ri >= 0.10 in the inviscid limit, for which sufficient separation develops between t∗ and the primary billow saturation time t2D as Ri increases = 0. p. 8

Where the paper says it

In the inviscid limit, early SSI requires Ri ≳ 0. 10, for which sufficient separation develops between 𝑡 ∗ and the primary billow saturation time 𝑡2𝐷 as Ri increases, providing sufficient time for SSI to grow to finite amplitude.

10 at Re = 106 and 107, where the braid dynamics remain essentially inviscid and well predicted by their model. p. 8
Where the paper says it

2, simulations confirm early SSI onset for Ri ≳ 0. 10 at Re = 106 and 107 , where the braid dynamics remain essentially inviscid and well predicted by our model.

The results show that at geophysically relevant Re >= 106, braid dynamics are effectively inviscid, so their results for SSI onset across (Ri, Re) space should be independent of Pr > 1 can influence braid evolution and SSI onset. p. 9
Where the paper says it

10 inviscid, so our results for SSI onset across (Ri, Re) space should be independent of Pr. At lower Re = 𝑂(104 − 105 ), however, Pr ≫ 1 can influence braid evolution and SSI onset, particularly near marginal (Ri, Re) values.

The authors suggest that a higher Pr will reduce the interface thickness at which diffusion hinders strain-induced thinning, thus promoting closer agreement with the inviscid model and favouring SSI. p. 9
Where the paper says it

At lower Re = 𝑂(104 − 105 ), however, Pr ≫ 1 can influence braid evolution and SSI onset, particularly near marginal (Ri, Re) values. A higher Pr will reduce the interface thickness at which diffusion hinders strain-induced thinning, thus promoting closer agreement with the inviscid model and favouring SSI.

The paper also notes that rapid mixing in the braid may strongly affect billow dynamics, and field observations at Re = O(105 - 107) indeed show intense braid mixing and weak mixing in billow cores. p. 8
Where the paper says it

An avenue for future work is to investigate the turbulence generated by the early onset of SSI, and its impact on the subsequent evolution of KH billows in three-dimensional DNS. As first noted by CS76, rapid mixing in the braid may strongly affect billow dynamics, and field observations at Re = 𝑂(105 − 107 ) indeed show intense braid mixing and weak mixing in billow cores, suggesting that braid turbulence may arrest primary billow growth.

The simple framework introduced here to estimate the interface thickness d provides a criterion for the minimum grid spacing required to capture SSI onset. p. 8
Where the paper says it

Poorly resolved interfaces can trigger spurious instabilities that vanish with increasing resolution (Lewin & Caulfield 2021; Lecoanet et al. The simple framework introduced here to estimate the interface thickness 𝛿 provides a criterion for the minimum grid spacing required to capture SSI onset.

REFERENCE

arXiv:2604.16173v1 [physics. p. 0

Where the paper says it

uk arXiv:2604. 16173v1 [physics.

Green — the paper says it, and the page is printed. Red — no passage carries it, so treat that sentence as unverified. The same check runs on your own text: check a summary against its source, $5.

Improvements for AI systems

  1. Improved prediction of turbulent transition timing by incorporating a time-dependent model for braid evolution that explicitly accounts for the time-evolving steepening of the braid. This allows AI systems to predict when secondary shear instability (SSI) will occur relative to primary billow saturation, which is crucial for understanding the control SSI has over three-dimensional turbulent transition.

  2. Enhanced parameter sensitivity analysis across Richardson and Reynolds numbers by quantifying how the onset of SSI is influenced by these parameters, specifically showing that at sufficiently high initial Richardson number Ri, as increased stratification slows billow growth while accelerating baroclinic shear production in the braid. This enables AI to map out parameter spaces where SSI is likely to dominate.

  3. Development of a predictive criterion for SSI using the ratio of strain rate to shear, formalized as the ratio of strain to vorticity (shear): Gamma Omega z prime = gamma1t + gamma0 / S(t). This provides a more rigorous threshold than previous methods, allowing AI to diagnose instability based on this dynamic balance rather than static conditions.

  4. Integration of numerical constraints into computational fluid dynamics by establishing a criterion for minimum grid spacing: "In our simulations, d prime > 10 delta z at the time of SSI onset." This helps AI systems select appropriate resolution levels for simulations aiming to capture the onset of SSI accurately, moving beyond standard Kolmogorov or Batchelor scale criteria.

  5. Improved modeling of high Prandtl number effects by incorporating a mechanism where a higher Pr will reduce the interface thickness at which diffusion hinders strain-induced thinning, thus promoting closer agreement with the inviscid model and favouring SSI. This allows AI to better predict behavior in geophysical flows where Pr is large, suggesting that viscous effects are not always negligible.

Abstract

We study the onset of two-dimensional secondary shear instability (SSI) in the braid regions connecting primary Kelvin-Helmholtz billows in stratified shear flows. While strain induced by the billows stabilises the braids, it also compresses their tilted isopycnals, enhancing baroclinic shear that enables rapid perturbation growth. By modifying the classical analysis of Corcos & Sherman (J. Fluid Mech. 73, 241-264, 1976) in braid-aligned coordinates and adding an additional stability criterion based on the ratio of strain rate to shear, we develop an inviscid, time-dependent model for the braid and the onset of SSI. We show that the criterion for instability can be achieved significantly earlier than the saturation of the primary billow at sufficiently high initial Richardson number Ri, as increased stratification slows billow growth while accelerating baroclinic shear production in the braid. Two-dimensional direct numerical simulations up to Reynolds numbers Re=10 7 quantify the role of viscosity. At high Re, we find that SSI indeed develops early in the braid, as predicted by the inviscid model, while the primary billow is still growing and before viscosity slows braid thinning. These results provide a mechanistic explanation for field observations of braid-dominated mixing and suggest that, at geophysically relevant Ri and Re, SSI can control the three-dimensional turbulent transition and ensuing diapycnal mixing by preceding and pre-empting both vortex pairing instabilities and secondary convective instabilities in the billow core.

Sources

Related papers