Nanoparticle-assisted STED nanoscopy with gold nanospheres

arXiv:1611.00045 · physics.optics, physics.bio-ph · Submitted 2016-10-31 · Read on arXiv

Listen

Radio episode about this paper

Transcript

Introduction to the show: ident: Physics. The day in general physics: instruments, methods and results across the field.

Kai: We're looking at the paper: "Nanoparticle-assisted STED nanoscopy with gold nanospheres".

Mira: Here's the gist of the paper. We demonstrate stimulated emission depletion (STED) microscopy with 20 nm gold nanospheres coated by fluorescent silica Compared with previous demonstrations of STED with a hybrid plasmonic fluorescent label, the current implementation offers a substantially smaller label and a better resolution improvement of up to 2.5-fold beyond the diffraction limit of confocal microscopy This is achieved at approximately 2 times lower intensity than conventional STED based on dyes alone, and in an aqueous environment, demonstrating the relevance to bio-imaging Finally, we also show, for the first time in this context, a 3-fold reduction in the rate of photobleaching compared to standard dye-based STED, thus, enabling brighter images.

Kai: Pruning redundant reasoning tokens The paper presents a novel method called nanoparticle-assisted STED nanoscopy using 20 nm gold nanospheres coated with fluorescent silica.

Mira: This approach significantly improves upon earlier demonstrations by achieving a resolution improvement of up to 2.5-fold beyond the diffraction limit of confocal microscopy.

Kai: The authors also report a substantial reduction in the rate of photobleaching, which allows for brighter images compared to standard dye-based STED.

Paper summary: Kai: To recap, this paper shows that by using twenty nm gold nanospheres coated with fluorescent silica, they achieve a resolution improvement up to two point five times beyond the diffraction limit of confocal microscopy <ref:1611.00045#pg1,beyond the diffraction limit of confocal microscopy>.

Mira: The authors are comparing this method to previous demonstrations of STED using hybrid plasmonic fluorescent labels and they claim their implementation uses a substantially smaller label and achieves this better resolution.

Lev: The core idea is that the gold core design leads to lower average near-field enhancement levels because of how the field decays as you move away from that shell, which is different from thinner metal shells.

Kai: They found this was achieved by detuning the STED wavelength, choosing five ninety five nanometers for their Atto four hundred eighty-eight dye, which resulted in an average near-field enhancement of about one point one eight.

Mira: They also measured a fluorescence decay time of one point nine nanoseconds within the nanoparticles under excitation at four hundred eighty eight nanometers, which matched their theoretical calculations for lifetime shortening to be at one point nine five nanoseconds.

Lev: That lifetime measurement confirms the physics behind how fast the dye decays inside the particles, which is necessary input for any real hardware simulation.

Kai: When they look at saturation powers, they found that for the nanoparticles, those required intensities are around four point six to five point eight megawatts per square centimeter compared to eight point one to ten megawatts per square centimeter for their control sample.

Mira: That means their estimated saturation intensities are about thirty percent better than the theoretical prediction based on a reduction of one over one point one eight.

Lev: The main caveat they mention is that the major obstacle to achieving even better performance right now is nanoparticle miniaturization and decreasing the metal volume.

Kai: They expect particles two to three times smaller than those used in current studies should still give comparable imaging performance. They also suggest optimal matching of the STED wavelength to the local plasmon resonance band could reduce required input intensity further.

Mira: Finally, they argue that replacing the thick dye-doped silica shell with fluorophores linked at a specific distance from the metal surface could lead to up to three times higher field enhancement, which is another potential path for improvement.

Conclusion: Kai: So this paper on "Nanoparticle-assisted STED nanoscopy with gold nanospheres" demonstrated that this hybrid label approach gives a resolution improvement of about two point five times beyond the diffraction limit and a three times reduction in photobleaching rate.

Mira: The authors are pointing out that the most important advance is performing imaging in water instead of index matching oil, opening up possibilities for studying biological samples like fixed cells.

Lev: In simple terms, they used tiny gold spheres to boost the signal so it works better and brighter in a real-world setting.

Kai: The whole point is that this setup allows for better resolution at lower input intensity than standard dye-based STED while also reducing bleaching.

Mira: It’s about taking the existing NP-STED concepts and making them more practical for actual bio-imaging applications by using a material that works in water.

Nicolai T. Urban, Matthew R. Foreman, Stefan W. Hell, Yonatan Sivan

Max Planck Institute for Biophysical Chemistry · Blackett Laboratory Department of Physics Imperial College London Unit of Electro-optics Engineering Faculty of Engineering Sciences Ben-Gurion University of the Negev

physics.optics, physics.bio-ph

Submitted: 2016-10-31

Updated: 2016-10-31

Journal ref: ACS Photon. 5, 2574-2583 (2018)

DOI: 10.1021/acsphotonics.7b00833

License: http://arxiv.org/licenses/nonexclusive-distrib/1.0/

Importance score: 94/100

The gist: We demonstrate stimulated emission depletion (STED) microscopy with 20 nm gold nanospheres coated by fluorescent silica Compared with previous demonstrations of STED with a hybrid plasmonic…

Key concepts

STED Microscopy
Stimulated Emission Depletion (STED) is a super-resolution microscopy technique that achieves resolution beyond the diffraction limit of conventional microscopes. It works by using a depletion laser beam to selectively turn off fluorescence in the periphery of a focal spot, effectively shrinking the point of excitation and allowing for finer spatial detail.
Hybrid Plasmonic-Fluorescent Labels
These labels consist of 20 nm gold spheres coated with a silica shell doped with an STED dye. The gold core provides near-field enhancement, which concentrates the light around it. This combination allows for high resolution while maintaining the necessary fluorescence properties for imaging.
Near-Field Enhancement
This refers to the localized increase in electromagnetic field intensity that occurs when light interacts with nanoscale structures like gold spheres. In this case, the gold core enhances the local optical field, which is crucial for achieving STED performance and improving resolution beyond what is possible with standard dyes alone.

Terminology

Summary

We demonstrate stimulated emission depletion (STED) microscopy with 20 nm gold nanospheres coated by fluorescent silica Compared with previous demonstrations of STED with a hybrid plasmonic fluorescent label, the current implementation offers a substantially smaller label and a better resolution improvement of up to 2. p. 05-fold beyond the diffraction limit of confocal microscopy This is achieved at approximately 2 times lower intensity than conventional STED based on dyes alone, and in an aqueous environment, demonstrating the relevance to bio-imaging Finally, we also show, for the first time in this context, a 3-fold reduction in the rate of photobleaching compared to standard dye-based STED, thus, enabling brighter images. p. 0

Pruning redundant reasoning tokens

The paper presents a novel method called nanoparticle-assisted STED nanoscopy using 20 nm gold nanospheres coated with fluorescent silica. This approach significantly improves upon earlier demonstrations by achieving a resolution improvement of up to 2. p. 05-fold beyond the diffraction limit of confocal microscopy. p. 0 The authors also report a substantial reduction in the rate of photobleaching, which allows for brighter images compared to standard dye-based STED. p. 0

Principles of NP-STED

The hybrid plasmonic-fluorescent labels consist of 20 nm diameter gold spheres coated with a 20 nm glass shell doped with a standard green STED dye (Atto 488). The particles are substantially smaller than the gold shells used before, and they are substantially easier to fabricate as compared to the thinner gold nanoshells required for optimal NP-STED performance. p. 2 The STED intensity reduction due to average near-field enhancement levels associated with this gold-core design is substantially lower than those predicted for thin metal shells because the dye around a metal sphere experiences a field that decays as a function of the distance from the metal shell. p. 2 At the local plasmon resonance, λLPR ≈ 553 nm, the spatially averaged near-field enhancement is about ∼ 1. p. 334. The authors chose a STED wavelength of λSTED = 595 nm, which is standard for Atto 488 and similar green dyes, but is slightly detuned from the plasmon resonance, resulting in an average near-field enhancement of ∼ 1. p. 318.

Results

The fluorescence decay of the Atto 488 dye within the nanoparticle samples was considerably shorter (τ = 0.9 ns) than when contained in fixated cells (τ = 2. p. 58 ns) or when freely suspended in water (τ = 4. p. 52 ns) under 488 nm excitation. p. 5 The measured fluorescence decay within the NPs closely matched theoretical calculations of the lifetime shortening (τ = 0. p. 595 ns). When illuminated only with the STED beam, at low STED power (< 10 mW) only a dim fluorescence signal could be detected originating from the NPs, which hinted at a two-photon process. p. 5 As the STED power was increased beyond 10 mW, the dim fluorescence was quickly overwhelmed by a growing, fast luminescence signal with a lifetime virtually indistinguishable from the instrument response function. p. 5 This fast luminescence emanating from the metal NPs was clearly doughnut-shaped and could be observed over a wide range of wavelengths. p. 5

How the gains come from

The resolution increase over confocal imaging due to STED should follow an inverse square-root law, dSTED P(inc) STED ∼ dconf/q 1+P(inc) STED/P∗sat. The saturation powers required for the NPs is reduced by ∼ 1/1. p. 975 compared to the control. p. 7 The estimated saturation intensities Isat of the samples are about 8. p. 91 − 10.0 MW/cm2 for the control sample and 4. p. 96−5.8 MW/cm2 for the NPs. p. 9 This experimental result is approximately 30% better than the theoretical prediction of a reduction in required STED intensity of 1/1. p. 918.

Discussion

The study demonstrates sub-diffraction resolution of ∼ 100 nm with hybrid metal dielectric NP-STED labels, exceeding substantially the results presented in the initial study where only a modest super-resolution level was demonstrated. The authors confirm, for the first time in the context of STED, a prediction regarding the reduction of bleaching ensuing from the use of hybrid metal-fluorescent labels—up to a 3-fold bleaching rate reduction was observed. p. 4 The most important advance demonstrated is that imaging of hybrid labels was performed in water rather than in index matching oil, highlighting the possibility of applying NP-STED to the study of biological samples, specifically, to fixed cells. p. 2

Future Directions

The major obstacle to achieving even better performance is NP miniaturization and decreasing the metal volume. The authors expect that particles which are 2–3 times smaller than those used in the current studies are realistic and should still yield comparable imaging performance. p. 1 Further intensity reduction can be achieved by optimally matching the STED wavelength to the LPR band of the Au sphere. p. 2 The authors note that applying a similar procedure for the Au nanospheres used here, namely, replacing the thick dye-doped silica shell with fluorophores linked at a specific distance from the metal surface can lead to up to 3-fold higher field enhancement. The third avenue involves enhancing existing bio-related applications of metal NPs with a significant level of super-resolution imaging, creating a versatile bio-tool. p. 1

Methods

Sample preparation involved diluting the hybrid nanoparticles in pure water, sonication to ensure no agglomeration occurred, and applying them to coverslips coated with a thin PolyL Lysine layer. The control samples consisted of MeOH-fixated Vero cells, immunohistochemically stained with a primary anti-vimentin antibody and a secondary Atto-488 sheep/anti-mouse antibody and mounted in Mowiol. p. 5 The STED nanoscope used a 488 nm pulsed diode laser with pulse lengths of ≈ 110 ps and typical laser powers between 1–10 µW in the back focal aperture. p. 5

Measurement details

All STED images were recorded using time-gated detection, separating the first 450 ps after onset of the excitation pulse from the rest of the signal to distinguish fluorescence from any occurring metal luminescence. The lifetime of the dye under various circumstances was determined by fitting fluorescence decay using a routine implemented in Matlab. p. 6 The effective bleaching rate of a given emitter can be determined as in,27, however, the resultant bleaching curves will be formed of the superposition of multiple exponential curves. p. 4 p. 4

Theoretical calculations and modelling

Standard Mie theory was used to determine the electric field distribution for the core-shell geometry NPs. The near field enhancement ΓI was determined by taking the ratio of the resulting intensity distribution as compared to that of a plane wave in a homogeneous Mowiol environment. p. 3 Position dependant radiative Purcell factors, Fr = Pr/P0 for dipole emitters oriented both radially and tangentially with respect to the core were calculated using a method based on accepted theory. p. 3 The effective bleaching rate of a given emitter can be determined as in,27, however, the resultant bleaching curves will be formed of the superposition of multiple exponential curves.

Green — the paper says it, and the page is printed. Red — no passage carries it, so treat that sentence as unverified. The same check runs on your own text: check a summary against its source, $5.

Improvements for AI systems

  1. Reduced label volume enables better spatial resolution for imaging systems, as the 20-fold reduction of the label volume — from approximately 160 nm gold shells to particles which are approximately 60 nm diameter allows for achieving resolutions better than those attainable by other approaches, including Structured Illumination Microscopy.

  2. Lower required excitation intensity improves system efficiency and reduces potential damage to biological samples, as the study demonstrates that the NP-STED label requires approximately 2 times lower input intensity than needed for the standard dye.

  3. Reduced bleaching rate enhances image brightness and longevity, as the authors show a 3-fold reduction in the rate of photobleaching compared to standard dye-based STED and that this effect is enabled by the presence of the metal NPs.

  4. The capability for imaging in aqueous environments allows NP-STED to be applied directly to biological samples, as the imaging of the hybrid labels was performed in water (rather than in index matching oil, as was done so far).

  5. The ability to use hybrid labels as multi-functional tools enables advanced bio-imaging techniques, such as performing bleachingfree imaging at enhanced resolution at the excitation wavelength and quantitative phase contrast microscopy via the photothermal effect.

  6. The system can be adapted for novel bio-diagnostics by combining NP-STED with existing metal NP applications, such as using them for selective treatment of cancer cells via hyperthermia, membrane perforation and gene therapy treatments.

Sources

Related papers