Dynamics of fluid-fluid displacements in a model rough fracture beyond the quasistatic limit: A spectral approach

summary

The gist

In fluid-fluid displacements in porous and fractured materials, viscous friction in microscale interfacial (Haines) jumps is intimately linked to macroscale energy dissipation and the associated…

In short

The paper develops a spectral computational approach to study fluid-fluid displacements in imperfect Hele-Shaw cells with rough fractures beyond steady flow. It successfully models interface evolution and energy dissipation, showing that total energy loss during Haines jumps is independent of viscosity. The method identifies distinct temporal stages in system behavior, providing a quantitative tool for understanding complex fluid dynamics at the microscale.

Key concepts

Imperfect Hele-Shaw cell
This is a simple model system used to study fluid flow where the gap between two plates is not perfectly uniform. It allows researchers to investigate how flow and interface movement occur in systems that are more realistic than ideal models, such as those found in porous media.
Spectral Approach
This method uses Fourier expansion to decompose the complex shape of the fluid interface into a set of simpler mathematical components (Fourier modes). By tracking how these modes evolve over time using derived equations, it achieves high accuracy and computational speed by avoiding fine spatial and temporal discretization required by traditional methods.
Haines Jumps
These are sudden, discontinuous jumps in the fluid interface shape that occur during fluid displacement. The paper analyzes the viscous friction associated with these jumps to link microscale interfacial events to macroscale energy dissipation and pressure hysteresis.

Terminology used across episodes

This episode discusses

The paper

Dynamics of fluid-fluid displacements in a model rough fracture beyond the quasistatic limit: A spectral approach · Read on arXiv

Mykyta V. Chubynsky, Jordi Ort´ın, Marco Dentz, Ran Holtzman

Institute of Environmental Assessment and Water Research (IDAEA), Spanish National Research Council (CSIC) · Departament de Física de la Materia Condensada, Universitat de Barcelona · University of Barcelona Institute of Complex Systems (UBICS)

In fluid-fluid displacements in porous and fractured materials, viscous friction in microscale interfacial (Haines) jumps is intimately linked to macroscale energy dissipation and the associated pressure-saturation (retention) hysteresis. The mode of control (flow rate vs. pressure) and the driving rate (from quasistatic to finite) can substantially affect hysteresis. Despite the significance of hysteresis and dissipation in various technological and natural processes, a quantitative understanding of the link between the micro- and macro-scales, and of the impact of the inherent heterogeneity of porous media, remains elusive. An ``imperfect'' Hele-Shaw cell of variable aperture is a simple model system which allows to study all these in details. However, simulating fluid-fluid interface evolution in heterogeneous media, even in such a simple system, is computationally prohibitive, as multiple length and time scales need to be resolved simultaneously. We develop here a spectral computational approach for interface evolution and energy dissipation and validate it via comparison to computational fluid dynamics simulations and experiments. Computational efficiency is demonstrated by following interface evolution in a cell with a single ``defect'', as well as with random roughness; in both, disparate length scales lead to nontrivial dynamics over many orders of magnitude in time. We also show theoretically that, in the quasi-static limit, while viscous forces during Haines jumps fully account for the energy dissipated between consecutive metastable equilibria, viscosity does not change the total dissipated amount, merely the relaxation time. Our approach provides a stepping stone towards upscaling of fluid-fluid flows in porous media.

Transcript

Introduction to the show: ident: Physics. The day in general physics: instruments, methods and results across the field.

Kai: We're looking at the paper: "Dynamics of fluid-fluid displacements in a model rough fracture beyond the quasistatic limit".

Mira: Here's the gist of the paper. In fluid-fluid displacements in porous and fractured materials, viscous friction in microscale interfacial (Haines) jumps is intimately linked to macroscale energy dissipation and the associated pressure-saturation (retention) hysteresis <ref:2607.23759#pg2> The mode of control (flow rate vs.

Kai: pressure) and the driving rate can substantially affect hysteresis <ref:2607.23759#pg2> Despite the significance of hysteresis and dissipation in various technological and natural processes, a quantitative understanding of the link between the micro- and macro-scales, and of the impact of the inherent heterogeneity of porous media, remains elusive <ref:2607.23759#pg2>.

Mira: Model System Development An “imperfect” Hele-Shaw cell of variable aperture is a simple model system which allows to study all these in details <ref:2607.23759#pg2> The authors develop a spectral computational approach for interface evolution and energy dissipation and validate it via comparison to computational fluid dynamics simulations and experiments <ref:2607.23759#pg2>.

Kai: Computational efficiency is demonstrated by following interface evolution in a cell with a single “defect”, as well as with random roughness <ref:2607.23759#pg2> The approach provides a stepping stone towards upscaling of fluid-fluid flows in porous media <ref:2607.23759#pg2>.

Title and authors: Kai: Let's talk about who wrote this, Kai and Mira are leading the discussion here. The paper is "Dynamics of fluid-fluid displacements in a model rough fracture beyond the quasistatic limit: A spectral approach".

Mira: They are focusing on how fluid flow changes when you go past the slow, steady limit into faster movement regimes. It’s about those complex energy dissipation patterns in rough fractures that we can't easily track with current methods.

Lev: From an engineering standpoint, I wonder what kind of system they used to build this model. Is it something we can actually replicate with our current high-fidelity simulations?

Kai: The paper uses an "imperfect" Hele-Shaw cell of variable aperture as a simple model system to study all these effects in detail. They developed a spectral computational approach for tracking the interface evolution and energy dissipation.

Mira: That spectral approach is key here because it lets them validate their findings by comparing them to computational fluid dynamics simulations and also real experiments.

Lev: And what makes this specific method interesting for real hardware, I mean, the efficiency? Can it handle complex geometries without needing impossibly small time steps?

Kai: They show computational efficiency by following the interface evolution in a cell with just a single defect and also with random roughness. This approach is presented as a stepping stone toward upscaling fluid-fluid flows in porous media.

Mira: So, the core idea here is using this spectral method to get high accuracy without needing the brute force computation that CFD sometimes demands for these complex interfaces.

The paper's summary: Kai: So, what’s the main point of the paper? It tackles the problem of nonlocality, which is how much flow response depends on where you are in the system, and this was really out of reach for existing methods.

Mira: They use a spectral approach formulated based on hydrodynamic equations for bulk flow in that Hele-Shaw cell and kinematic and dynamic boundary conditions for the interface dynamics.

Lev: So, they track the dynamics of Fourier modes into which the interface shape is decomposed, which sounds like a powerful way to capture spatial information efficiently.

Kai: That’s right. The algorithm involves discretizing the solution in space and time, calculating Fourier components, advancing them using equations derived from equilibrium profiles, and then performing an inverse discrete Fourier transform to get the interface shape at all mesh points.

Mira: What’s really striking is their analysis of energy dissipation. They show theoretically that while viscous forces during those microscopic Haines jumps account for all the energy dissipated between consecutive metastable equilibria, viscosity itself doesn't change the total amount of dissipated energy, only how fast it relaxes.

Lev: That means if you drive it quasistatically—meaning at zero flow rate—the total dissipation amount doesn't depend on the actual fluid viscosity; it just equals the work of all forces other than viscous friction.

Kai: The derivation shows that for quasistatic pressure driving, energy dissipation is of viscous origin. This is a big piece of information about where that energy actually comes from in these systems.

The paper's improvements: Mira: Now let's talk about the improvements they suggest for this spectral approach itself. They use it to provide a quantitative tool to resolve fundamental questions, specifically about the individual contribution of viscous friction during continuous flow and of those Haines jumps.

Kai: That’s because this method gives us a way to look at the system that was previously elusive, especially regarding how the inherent heterogeneity of porous media impacts fluid flow.

Lev: I’m interested in how they handle scaling up. The paper suggests this approach opens up possibilities for upscaling flow behavior from the pore scale all the way to the meso scale, which is huge for modeling real geological systems or even complex materials.

Mira: They also show different temporal stages in system behavior when looking at both dissipation rate and interface evolution, identifying them as Stage I through Stage V. These stages show distinct power law and exponential decay behaviors for that dissipation rate.

Kai: And they pinpoint the sequence of these stages based on the defect size; for narrow defects, it’s I through III through IV through V. That gives us a specific fingerprint based on geometry.

Lev: So, if we're looking at real hardware, knowing those distinct power laws and cutoffs helps us set expectations for what kind of dynamics we might actually observe when we run the simulation or experiment.

Conclusion: Kai: So to wrap up this paper on "Dynamics of fluid-fluid displacements in a model rough fracture beyond the quasistatic limit: A spectral approach," they successfully tackle the nonlocality of the flow response to interface deformation, which was previously very hard.

Mira: This provides a quantitative tool for understanding fundamental questions, like what exactly is contributing to energy dissipation during continuous flow versus those intermittent Haines jumps.

Lev: The ability to handle large disordered systems opens up interesting possibilities for upscaling how fluid flows from the pore scale toward the meso scale, which is a major step forward for modeling complex materials.

Kai: We get a tool that gives us insights into both the viscous friction in continuous flow and those jumps, depending on how you drive the system.

Mira: It’s a quantitative method that lets us see different temporal stages in the system behavior through power laws and exponential decays, which depend on things like capillary length or defect width.

Lev: And for real hardware, knowing these dissipation rates are universal in certain stages and only vary with the defect size in stage V gives us concrete rules to follow when we design our error correction or simulation parameters.

Kai: We've seen how the spectral approach matches CFD predictions for both interface evolution and dissipation rate at a small fraction of computational resources.

Mira: It’s a method that allows us to predict interface shapes by solving closed-form expressions for Fourier modes, bypassing the need for extremely small integration time steps required by traditional numerical methods like CFD.

Lev: That efficiency gain is what makes this approach viable for running on more realistic hardware when we move toward large systems.

Kai: So the "Dynamics of fluid-fluid displacements in a model rough fracture beyond the quasistatic limit: A spectral approach" gives us a quantitative way to understand how energy is dissipated and how that dissipation scales with system size and driving rate.

More episodes

← Home