Crest factor optimization of multi-tone signals generated for low-temperature sensor readout

arXiv:2611.17207 · astro-ph.IM, physics.ins-det · Submitted 2026-11-12 · Read on arXiv

Listen

Radio episode about this paper

Transcript

Introduction to the show: ident: Astrophysics. The day in astrophysics: observations, models and what the data forces.

Vera: We're looking at the paper: "Crest factor optimization of multi-tone signals generated for low-temperature sensor readout".

Jocelyn: Here's the gist of the paper. Microwave kinetic inductance detectors (MKID) are a growing technology of cryogenic detectors and have a great potential in radio-astronomy and cosmic microwave background (CMB) characterization The focus is on the crest factor optimization process for proper excitation and readout of these large arrays of detectors Readout System Requirements Reading an array of MKIDs is done with electronics at room temperature, which is a huge advantage compared to other sensing technologies such as transition edge sensors, which require cryogenic SQUIDs for each pixel The readout electronics have the general task of performing multiple complex microwave transmission (S21) measurements in real time, around 4-10 GHz, to monitor the instantaneous resonance frequency and dissipation of the superconducting micro-resonators working as detectors in the specific range of wavelengths of the experiment One of the most stringent requirements for the electronic readout system is that it should be able to perform the measurements of the parameter S21 at a noise level that is limited only by the noise temperature of the cryogenic amplifier (LNA) that follow the arrangement of MKIDs The noise contribution from the readout electronics must be below this level, meaning the noise/carrier ratio at the output of the HEMT amplifier must be preserved through the electronic chain of the readout system Tone Generation Process To approximate our digital signals to (7) we can start by analyzing a real-valued, constant-amplitude signal The worst choice of phases is theta k = 0, k = 1,..., N, which produces a peak of u∞ = sqrt(2N) (which occurs at n = 0) A phase pattern chosen with some criteria is needed so that cancellations always keep u(n) small The Newman’s phases are defined for N tones as theta (New) k = pi(k − 1)2 / N This method allows obtaining the lowest CF and by means of which crest factors of 4.6 dB are obtained for N on the order of a few hundred, decreasing even for larger N Crest Factor Optimization The Newman’s tone generation method is analyzed because it is the method that allows obtaining the lowest CF and by means of which crest factors of 4.6 dB are obtained for N on the order of a few hundred, decreasing even for larger N Simulations show that in the case of random variation of phases and amplitudes, the peak of the FDM signal is in the order u∞ = 2.6 sqrt(log N), N ≥ 1000 Numerical analysis shows that the crest factor for Newman’s multi-tone signal is always very small, about 4.6 dB for a moderate N (up to a few hundred) and decreases very little for larger N Hardware Savings The algorithms presented ensure less variation in the reading power per pixel throughout the range N The power per pixel is greater, which translates into hardware savings in the readout system Fig.

Vera: 5 shows a comparison between results of the maximum allowable power per tone in arrays of 100 to 10.000 resonators applied to a single DAC output Analyzing the results presented in Fig.

Jocelyn: 5, it can be concluded that for the algorithms used in this paper there is less variation in the readout power per pixel through the entire range N The power per pixel is higher, which can result in a saving of attenuators in the electronic readout chain From the work presented, it is possible to understand the hardware requirements of a system designed for the excitation and readout of large arrays of superconducting resonators (detectors) It was shown how the generation of phases using the Newman algorithm leads to optimal results in terms of the crest factor of the multi-frequency signal Using the algorithms presented ensure less variation in the reading power per pixel throughout the range N The power per pixel is greater, which translates into hardware savings in the readout system The main contribution be seen in the optimal method found to generate the carriers It was shown how the generation of phases using the Newman algorithm leads to optimal results in terms of the crest factor of the multi-frequency signal The algorithms presented ensure less variation in the reading power per pixel throughout the range N.

Vera: APPENDIX The crest factor (CF) is defined as the ratio of the absolute value of the peak in the data divided by the value of the root mean square (rms) of the same data In engineering terms, u∞ is nothing other than the peak of the signal u and u2 is its effective value The crest factor of a non-zero signal is defined as the ratio of its peak value to rms value CF(u) = u∞ / u2 Normally, the crest factor is expressed in decibels, that is, CFdB(u) = 20 log10(CF(u)) An important characteristic is that the crest factor is always at least one This can be seen as follows, u(t) 2 ≤ u2 for all t, therefore 1/T Z T 0 (u(t))2 dt ≤ u2 Taking square roots and dividing gives CF(u) ≥ 1 The paper is titled "Crest factor optimization of multi-tone signals generated for low-temperature sensor readout".

Paper summary: Vera: So, we're looking at this paper, "Crest factor optimization of multi-tone signals generated for low-temperature sensor readout." Essentially, they are tackling a big problem when you want to read out a huge array of these microwave kinetic inductance detectors. The main goal is figuring out how to excite and read them properly so you don't get signal distortion.

Jocelyn: That means they are focusing on optimizing the crest factor for the excitation and readout of these large arrays of detectors, which is really important for getting good data from experiments like those looking at the cosmic microwave background. It’s about making sure you get a clear signal without too much unwanted noise or distortion in your electronic chain.

Subrahmanyan: From a theoretical standpoint, this optimization process directly impacts how efficiently we can use the electronic chain when dealing with thousands of pixels, which is what these large arrays are all about <ref:2611.17207#pg3>. If the crest factor isn't managed well, you lose dynamic range in your readout system.

Vera: Exactly. The paper shows an algorithm to optimize how the phase generation of those carriers is done to get a low crest factor, and they claim that this method favors better usage of the electronic chain for reading out these large arrays <ref:2611.17207#pg1>. They found crest factors around four point six decibels for a few hundred tones, which keeps things manageable even as you scale up the number of tones <ref:2611.17207#pg3>.

Jocelyn: That sounds really practical because it addresses the noise level requirement for the readout electronics, which has to be limited only by the noise temperature of that cryogenic amplifier, or LNA. The whole point is keeping the noise contribution from your electronics below that limit so you preserve your signal quality <ref:2611.17207#pg3>.

Subrahmanyan: If we look at the mathematics they use, they are generating these tones by considering a real-valued, constant-amplitude signal and choosing phases carefully to keep the peaks small across all frequencies <ref:2611.17207#pg1>. They mention that Newman's phases are one specific way to choose those phases for N tones that helps them get the lowest crest factor, even as N gets bigger.

Vera: It seems like they found a method where the crest factor stays very small, about four point six decibels for a moderate number of tones, and it doesn't change much even when you increase the number of tones to a few hundred <ref:2611.17207#pg2>. That suggests this approach is robust for scaling up the system.

Paper summary: Jocelyn: And they also look at what happens when things aren't perfectly optimized, like if you use random variations in phases and amplitudes. In those cases, the peak of the signal can be much larger, scaling with something like two point six times the square root of log N when N is over a thousand <ref:2611.17207#pg1>.

Subrahmanyan: That scaling difference between optimized and unoptimized signals tells us that careful phase control is not just a minor detail; it fundamentally changes the signal characteristics across the entire range of tones you are generating <ref:2611.17207#pg3>. It's about controlling how the signal behaves as you move from one frequency to another.

Vera: And they also point out a hardware benefit here. By using these algorithms, they ensure less variation in the reading power per pixel across the whole range of tones <ref:2611.17207#pg1>. That means the power per pixel is higher, which translates into savings in hardware components like attenuators in that electronic readout chain Vera.

Jocelyn: Higher power per pixel for less variation sounds like a solid engineering win for building these systems, especially when you're dealing with arrays of ten thousand pixels or more <ref:2611.17207#pg2>. It’s about making the system more efficient in terms of what you need to build.

Subrahmanyan: From a cosmological perspective, if we can build these large arrays efficiently, it means we can probe the CMB with better sensitivity over larger areas <ref:2611.17207#pg3>. This efficiency in readout is what allows us to move from small experiments to instruments capable of measuring the structure formation of the universe on a grand scale.

Vera: So, they've shown an optimal way to generate the carriers that keeps the crest factor low and gives you better hardware savings while maintaining a good signal quality for these cryogenic detectors <ref:2611.17207#pg1>. The main contribution here is finding that specific method for generating those carriers efficiently.

Jocelyn: It’s really about making sure the signal stays readable even when you're pushing the limits of how many tones you can use to monitor all those detectors at once <ref:2611.17207#pg3>. It shows how to keep the dynamic range of your electronic chain working well.

Subrahmanyan: The implication for structure formation is that if we can handle the readout requirements for these detectors, we open up new avenues for using CMB data to constrain models of gravity and dark matter <ref:2611.17207#pg3>. It connects the engineering challenge directly to the theoretical payoff in cosmology.

Paper summary: Vera: So, looking at this paper, it really lays out the specific hardware requirements for setting up excitation and readout for these large superconducting resonators <ref:2611.17207#pg1>. It shows exactly how using Newman's algorithm helps you get those optimal results in terms of the crest factor.

Jocelyn: And the authors emphasize that their algorithms ensure less variation in the reading power per pixel throughout the entire range of tones, which is a key finding <ref:2611.17207#pg1>. That stability across N tones is what makes this method work well for arrays.

Subrahmanyan: Overall, it shows how generating phases using the Newman algorithm leads to optimal results in terms of the crest factor of the multi-frequency signal <ref:2611.17207#pg3>. This optimization is crucial for ensuring you can properly excite and read out those large arrays effectively.

Vera: So, to wrap up on this paper, it’s about understanding the hardware needs for systems that excite and read out huge arrays of superconducting resonators <ref:2611.17207#pg1>. The core finding is that using the Newman algorithm gives you optimal results regarding the crest factor of the multi-tone signal.

Jocelyn: And because those algorithms ensure less variation in reading power per pixel across all N, you get hardware savings in your readout system through things like needing fewer attenuators <ref:2611.17207#pg1>. That stability is what matters for real-world implementation.

Subrahmanyan: The main contribution here is that optimal method found to generate the carriers, which directly leads to those better results in terms of crest factor and hardware savings <ref:2611.17207#pg3>. It’s a concrete way to improve the performance of these readout systems.

Vera: That’s what it is: understanding the hardware requirements for exciting and reading out large arrays of superconducting resonators <ref:2611.17207#pg1>. The paper really shows how phase generation using the Newman algorithm leads to optimal results in terms of the crest factor of the multi-tone signal.

Jocelyn: And it also shows how those algorithms ensure less variation in the reading power per pixel throughout that whole range N, which is a huge practical benefit <ref:2611.17207#pg1>.

Subrahmanyan: It really shows how the generation of phases using the Newman algorithm leads to optimal results in terms of the crest factor of the multi-frequency signal <ref:2611.17207#pg3>. That’s a key piece for anyone thinking about scaling up these detectors.

Conclusion: Vera: So, we've been looking at how they optimized phase generation to keep that crest factor low for these microwave detectors. This paper is all about getting that readout right so we can actually get usable data from them.

Jocelyn: Yeah, they focus on the title "Crest factor optimization of multi-tone signals generated for low-temperature sensor readout." It sounds super technical, but it’s really just making sure the signal you get back from those tiny detectors isn't too messy.

Subrahmanyan: The main idea is that if you use the right way to generate those multiple tones, you keep the peak of your data small compared to the average noise level. That’s important because we need that low noise floor for these experiments.

Vera: Exactly, and they show how this method keeps that crest factor around four point six decibels even when you have hundreds of tones. That's a pretty good number for keeping the signal clean in your electronics chain.

Jocelyn: And they show that when you use their method, the power per pixel stays more consistent across all those tones, which means less hardware needed for your readout system. It translates to real savings in things like attenuators.

Subrahmanyan: From a cosmology angle, if we can build these arrays efficiently and keep the signal quality high this way, it opens up new ways to use cosmic microwave background data to study structure formation on a larger scale.

Vera: That’s the big picture. It’s about making the hardware work better so we can push those experiments further out in what we can measure in the sky.

Jocelyn: So, they found an optimal way to generate those carrier tones that gives you low crest factor and saves hardware, which is a solid piece of engineering for these detectors.

Subrahmanyan: The next thing we need to see is how this readout performance affects the actual physical limits of what we can measure in the CMB.

L. H. Arnaldi

Laboratorio Deteccion de Part ículas y Radiacion · Bariloche Atomic Center and Instituto Balseiro, National Commission of Atomic Energy

astro-ph.IM, physics.ins-det

Submitted: 2026-11-12

Updated: 2026-11-12

Comments: Accepted version. \c{opyright} 2023 IEEE. 6 pages, 5 figures

Journal ref: 2023 Argentine Conference on Electronics (CAE)

DOI: 10.1109/CAE56623.2023.10086985

License: http://arxiv.org/licenses/nonexclusive-distrib/1.0/

Importance score: 79/100

The gist: Microwave kinetic inductance detectors (MKID) are a growing technology of cryogenic detectors and have a great potential in radio-astronomy and cosmic microwave background (CMB) characterization The…

Key concepts

Crest Factor (CF)
The CF is a measure comparing the peak value of a signal to its root mean square (rms) value. It is calculated as ||u||∞ divided by ||u||2. A higher CF indicates a more peaked signal, and it is expressed in decibels (dB). The paper aims to minimize this factor for optimal signal quality.
Newman's Phases
These are a specific set of phases defined for generating N tones. They are chosen because they ensure that cancellations occur when the signal is analyzed, which helps keep the peak value small and thus minimizes the crest factor. This method is effective at obtaining low CF values.
MKID Readout Requirements
Reading MKIDs involves performing real-time microwave transmission measurements (S21) around 4-10 GHz to monitor detector resonance. The readout electronics must maintain a high signal quality, ensuring the noise contribution from the electronics remains below the noise floor set by cryogenic amplifiers.

Terminology

Summary

Microwave kinetic inductance detectors (MKID) are a growing technology of cryogenic detectors and have a great potential in radio-astronomy and cosmic microwave background (CMB) characterization The focus is on the crest factor optimization process for proper excitation and readout of these large arrays of detectors

Readout System Requirements

Reading an array of MKIDs is done with electronics at room temperature, which is a huge advantage compared to other sensing technologies such as transition edge sensors, which require cryogenic SQUIDs for each pixel The readout electronics have the general task of performing multiple complex microwave transmission (S21) measurements in real time, around 4-10 GHz, to monitor the instantaneous resonance frequency and dissipation of the superconducting micro-resonators working as detectors in the specific range of wavelengths of the experiment One of the most stringent requirements for the electronic readout system is that it should be able to perform the measurements of the parameter S21 at a noise level that is limited only by the noise temperature of the cryogenic amplifier (LNA) that follow the arrangement of MKIDs The noise contribution from the readout electronics must be below this level, meaning the noise/carrier ratio at the output of the HEMT amplifier must be preserved through the electronic chain of the readout system

Tone Generation Process

To approximate our digital signals to (7) we can start by analyzing a real-valued, constant-amplitude signal The worst choice of phases is theta k = 0, k = 1,..., N, which produces a peak of u∞ = sqrt(2N) (which occurs at n = 0) A phase pattern chosen with some criteria is needed so that cancellations always keep u(n) small The Newman’s phases are defined for N tones as theta (New) k = pi(k − 1)2 / N This method allows obtaining the lowest CF and by means of which crest factors of 4. p. 26 dB are obtained for N on the order of a few hundred, decreasing even for larger N

Crest Factor Optimization

The Newman’s tone generation method is analyzed because it is the method that allows obtaining the lowest CF and by means of which crest factors of 4.6 dB are obtained for N on the order of a few hundred, decreasing even for larger N Simulations show that in the case of random variation of phases and amplitudes, the peak of the FDM signal is in the order u∞ = 2. p. 36 sqrt(log N), N ≥ 1000 Numerical analysis shows that the crest factor for Newman’s multi-tone signal is always very small, about 4. p. 36 dB for a moderate N (up to a few hundred) and decreases very little for larger N

Hardware Savings

The algorithms presented ensure less variation in the reading power per pixel throughout the range N The power per pixel is greater, which translates into hardware savings in the readout system Fig. 5 shows a comparison between results of the maximum allowable power per tone in arrays of 100 to 10. p. 4000 resonators applied to a single DAC output Analyzing the results presented in Fig. p. 4 5, it can be concluded that for the algorithms used in this paper there is less variation in the readout power per pixel through the entire range N The power per pixel is higher, which can result in a saving of attenuators in the electronic readout chain

Conclusion

From the work presented, it is possible to understand the hardware requirements of a system designed for the excitation and readout of large arrays of superconducting resonators (detectors) It was shown how the generation of phases using the Newman algorithm leads to optimal results in terms of the crest factor of the multi-frequency signal Using the algorithms presented ensure less variation in the reading power per pixel throughout the range N The power per pixel is greater, which translates into hardware savings in the readout system The main contribution be seen in the optimal method found to generate the carriers It was shown how the generation of phases using the Newman algorithm leads to optimal results in terms of the crest factor of the multi-frequency signal The algorithms presented ensure less variation in the reading power per pixel throughout the range N.

APPENDIX

The crest factor (CF) is defined as the ratio of the absolute value of the peak in the data divided by the value of the root mean square (rms) of the same data In engineering terms, u∞ is nothing other than the peak of the signal u and u2 is its effective value The crest factor of a non-zero signal is defined as the ratio of its peak value to rms value CF(u) = u∞ / u2 Normally, the crest factor is expressed in decibels, that is, CFdB(u) = 20 log10(CF(u)) An important characteristic is that the crest factor is always at least one This can be seen as follows, u(t) 2 ≤ u2 for all t, therefore 1/T Z T 0 (u(t))2 dt ≤ u2 Taking square roots and dividing gives CF(u) ≥ 1 The paper is titled Crest factor optimization of multi-tone signals generated for low-temperature sensor readout.

Green — the paper says it, and the page is printed. Red — no passage carries it, so treat that sentence as unverified. The same check runs on your own text: check a summary against its source, $5.

Improvements for AI systems

  1. Improved carrier phase generation using Newman’s method can lead to optimal results in terms of crest factor of the multi-frequency signal, achieving crest factors of around 4.6 dB for N on the order of a few hundred and decreasing even for larger N.

  2. The algorithms presented ensure less variation in reading power per pixel throughout the range N, and this higher power per pixel translates into hardware savings in the readout system by reducing the need for attenuators in the electronic readout chain.

Sources

Related papers