Quantitative Junction Transport Modeling of RHIC Charge and Baryon Stopping
Listen
Radio episode about this paper
Transcript
Introduction to the show: ident: Nuclear Theory. The day in nuclear theory: structure, reactions and the models behind them.
Kai: I'm Kai.
Mira: And I'm Mira, here with Lev.
Kai: We're looking at the paper: "Quantitative Junction Transport Modeling of RHIC Charge and Baryon Stopping".
Mira: Here's the gist of the paper. Charge and baryon stopping in Ru+Ru and Zr+Zr isobar collisions are modeled by HIJING with junction.
Kai: The tuned generator reproduces STAR’s netbaryon yield, charge difference, and scaled baryon-to-charge ratio at midrapidity.
Mira: Junctions set the ratio’s magnitude while neutron skins drive its centrality trend.
Kai: This tuned generator reproduces RHIC data and predicts O+O behavior, setting a quantitative benchmark for baryon transport.
Paper summary: Kai: So we're looking at this paper, "Quantitative Junction Transport Modeling of RHIC Charge and Baryon Stopping." This work uses HIJING with a junction to model charge and baryon stopping in ruthenium plus ruthenium and zirconium plus zirconium collisions. The authors claim that tuning the generator reproduces STAR’s netbaryon yield, charge difference, and scaled baryon-to-charge ratio at midrapidity.
Mira: That means they're proposing a model where this junction plays a specific role in how baryons stop in these heavy ion collisions. What’s interesting is how they use the junction to set the magnitude of that ratio while the neutron skins of these nuclei drive its centrality trend.
Lev: From an engineering standpoint, what we need to watch is how much overhead this modeling adds when we try to run it on real hardware. The paper focuses on tuning parameters like sigma J equals twenty-eight millibarns and lambda J equals zero point five five to match the measured rapidity slope of the net-proton distribution in Au plus Au collisions.
Kai: So, what they're doing is looking at an alternative picture for baryon number transport, where you have a Y shaped configuration of gluons called a baryon junction that traces the baryon number. This object is made of soft gluons and carries a small fraction of the nucleon momentum, allowing it to stop near midrapidity in high-energy collisions while the valence quarks keep moving toward the beam rapidity.
Mira: And they are using this junction concept to build into their HIJING version two point zero. They enable baryon junction exchange with a cross section of twenty-eight millibarns, which reproduces the netbaryon yield in the isobars. A baryon is formed from that junction and three sea quarks, and its rapidity samples from exp(lambda J y) between the outermost string ends, carrying baryon number without transporting charge.
Lev: I see them also increase the effective string tension above a value of one gigaparsec per fermi in nucleus plus nucleus collisions, using kappa equals two times that value for these collisions and one point five times that value for proton plus proton collisions. They mention that this enhanced string tension is another physics addition in this version two point zero.
Paper summary: Kai: So, the results they get by adjusting parameters like the quark diquark splitting probability Pu to zero point five eight match the charge difference observable while midrapidity hadron yields are insensitive to it. This suggests a specific relationship between these variables in their model.
Mira: And when they switch off the junction mechanism, the charge difference observable remains essentially unchanged, comparing one point zero to one point four times ten to the minus three versus one point one to one point three times ten to the minus three with it on. That’s a bit surprising because it shows that this junction exchange contributes about half of the midrapidity netbaryon number but doesn't affect the charge difference observable at all.
Lev: I gotta ask, if it only affects the baryon number and not charge, what does that tell us about how we actually measure these quantities in an experiment? It sounds like a specific signature.
Kai: The paper also compares their model to Au plus Au and proton plus proton baryon sectors at the level of experimental uncertainties. Specifically for O plus O collisions at the same average number of participants as peripheral isobar collisions, they predict a specific ordering for the net-baryon number per participant, charge difference, and scaled ratio across the Ru minus Zr, O minus Ru and O minus Zr pairs.
Mira: That ordering they predict is that in charge difference we get O minus Ru less than ruthenium minus zirconium less than oxygen minus zirconium. And in the scaled ratio we get ruthenium minus zirconium less than oxygen minus zirconium less oxygen minus ruthenium.
Lev: That prediction about the scaling of those ratios is where I need to be careful. It depends heavily on the nuclear structure details they are inputting for these isobars, specifically those neutron skins which they suggest drive that centrality dependence.
Kai: They link that centrality trend in the scaled ratio directly to the neutron skins of the isobars, and they say that removing this deformation doesn't change either charge difference or the scaled ratio beyond statistical uncertainties. The oxygen minus zirconium pair is highlighted as being the best determined because it has a large lever.
Paper summary: Mira: So, what this means for us is that we have two separate things setting those two different parts of the ratio: the junction sets its magnitude, and then nuclear geometry provides its centrality dependence.
Lev: And I need to point out a limitation here. The paper mentions that at LHC energies, large asymmetric pair production in HIJING can obscure these junction effects, causing apparent tension with data. They also say that this tuned generator is constrained to string fragmentation at LHC multiplicities rather than baryon transport itself, which suggests the junction version of HIJING might not be directly applicable for those high energy regimes.
Kai: So, if we look at the full scope of "Quantitative Junction Transport Modeling of RHIC Charge and Baryon Stopping," it boils down to this: the junction component sets the magnitude of that ratio, with turning it off giving a range from zero point four to zero point nine like models without junctions.
Mira: And because the neutron skins are what drive the centrality dependence, those skins are crucial for understanding how baryon transport scales across different collision centralities. This model predicts a specific ordering for O plus O collisions at peripheral isobar collisions' average number of participants, which STAR data can test.
Lev: It’s interesting that they also found that between two hundred and nine hundred gigaparsecs per fermi, the junction component falls by a factor of zero point three seven, which is consistent with what we actually measure in other experiments.
Kai: So to wrap up the paper's main contribution, it reproduces STAR isobar measurements at two hundred gigaparsecs per fermi in all centrality classes. The junction sets its magnitude, and the neutron skins set its centrality dependence.
Mira: And for O plus O collisions at peripheral isobar collisions' average number of participants, the model predicts the ordering of pairs which STAR data can test. That seems like a solid quantitative benchmark for how baryon transport works in these systems.
Conclusion: Kai: So we've looked at how this paper, "Quantitative Junction Transport Modeling of RHIC Charge and Baryon Stopping," uses these isobars to explain how charge and baryons stop in collisions at two hundred gigaparsecs per fermi.
Mira: It’s basically about using a new idea called the baryon junction to model this transport, which they show matches the data from STAR experiments pretty well across different centrality classes.
Lev: From an engineering standpoint, what's cool is that they tuned their HIJING generator with parameters like sigma J equals twenty-eight millibarns and lambda J equals zero point five five to get those yields right.
Kai: And the authors are suggesting that this junction sets the magnitude of the charge difference ratio, while the neutron skins of these nuclei control how that ratio changes as you move from central to peripheral collisions.
Mira: So what they're really saying is that you have two separate things setting up that final number, one part from the junction mechanism and another part from how much stuff is in the nucleus.
Lev: The authors also point out a scaling issue, showing that this junction contribution drops by about thirty-seven percent when you go from two hundred gigaparsecs per fermi to nine hundred gigaparsecs per fermi.
Kai: It’s interesting because they say that at nine hundred gigaparsecs per fermi, the junction component by itself accounts for the whole net proton yield, suggesting that extra protons in those high-energy events come from pair asymmetry instead.
Mira: That implies a certain kind of behavior for baryon transport at very high energies that we need to keep an eye on as we look at future data.
Lev: It's a lot of assumptions packed into this model, and it really pushes the limits on what these phenomenological models can actually predict before we get real hardware running them.
Ashish Pandav, *Zhangbu Xu, †Bedangadas Mohanty
Center for Nuclear Research, Department of Physics, Kent State University · School of Physical Sciences, National Institute of Science Education and Research, HBNI
nucl-th, hep-ph
Submitted: 2026-11-12
Updated: 2026-11-12
License: http://arxiv.org/licenses/nonexclusive-distrib/1.0/
Importance score: 83/100
The gist: Charge and baryon stopping in Ru+Ru and Zr+Zr isobar collisions are modeled by HIJING with junction.
Key concepts
- Baryon Junction
- This is a Y-shaped configuration of soft gluon fields connecting the three valence quarks of a baryon. It traces the baryon number and carries only a small fraction of the nucleon's momentum, allowing it to stop near midrapidity in high-energy collisions.
- Junction Exchange Cross Section (σJ)
- The model incorporates an exchange mechanism where a baryon is formed from the junction and three sea quarks. This cross section is tuned to 28 mb and reproduces the observed net-baryon yield in isobar collisions, showing its role in baryon transport.
- Neutron Skins
- The nuclear structure, specifically the neutron skins of Ru and Zr isobars, dictates the centrality dependence of observables. These skins affect how many protons participate in peripheral collisions versus central ones, influencing the charge difference and scaled ratio.
Terminology
Summary
Charge and baryon stopping in Ru+Ru and Zr+Zr isobar collisions are modeled by HIJING with junction. p. 0 The tuned generator reproduces STAR’s netbaryon yield, charge difference, and scaled baryon-to-charge ratio at midrapidity. p. 0 Junctions set the ratio’s magnitude while neutron skins drive its centrality trend. p. 0 This tuned generator reproduces RHIC data and predicts O+O behavior, setting a quantitative benchmark for baryon transport. p. 0
Baryon Number Transport Mechanisms
The paper discusses the alternative picture of baryon number where the three valence quarks of a baryon are connected by a Y-shaped configuration of gluon fields, known as the baryon junction, which traces the baryon number. This gluonic object is made of soft gluons and carries a small fraction of the nucleon momentum, allowing it to be stopped near midrapidity in a high-energy collision while valence quarks continue toward beam rapidity. p. 0 Regge theory predicts a net-baryon rapidity density that falls as exp(−αB δy) with the rapidity shift δy from the beam, with αB between 0. p. 042 and 1. Diquark transport in string models, where baryon number stays with the valence quarks, gives a much steeper fall. p. 0
Modeling Junction Effects
The HIJING/BB version 2.0 incorporates two additional mechanisms to study junction effects. p. 0 First, baryon junction exchange is enabled, with a cross section σJ = 28 mb which reproduces the net-baryon yield in the isobars. p. 0 A baryon is formed from the junction and three sea quarks, and its rapidity is sampled from exp(λJ y) between the outermost string ends, carrying baryon number without transporting charge. p. 1 Second, strong color fields increase the effective string tension above the Lund value κ0 = 1 GeV/fm. p. 1
Parameter Tuning and Results
Three parameters were adjusted in this work: σJ = 28 mb, λJ = 0.55, and Pu = 0.58. The default SU(6) value is Pu = 2/3, but using Pu = 0. p. 158 matches the chargedifference (∆Q) observable while midrapidity hadron yields are insensitive to its variation. p. 1 When the junction mechanism is switched off, ∆Q remains essentially unchanged, (1. p. 20–1.4)×10−3 versus (1. p. 21–1.3) × 10−3 with it on. The junction supplies about half of the midrapidity netbaryon number, demonstrating that junction exchange contributes to baryon transport but does not enter the charge-difference observable. p. 2
System Comparison and Predictions
The model reproduces Au+Au and p+p baryon sector at the level of experimental uncertainties. In O+O collisions at the same ⟨Npart⟩ as peripheral isobar collisions, the net-baryon number per participant, charge difference, and scaled ratio are obtained for the Ru−Zr, O−Ru and O−Zr pairs. p. 4 The model thus predicts the ordering of these pairs: in the charge difference, O−Ru < Ru−Zr < O−Zr and in the scaled ratio, Ru−Zr < O−Zr < O−Ru. p. 4
Nuclear Structure Influence
The centrality dependence of the scaled ratio is produced by the neutron skins of the isobars, as suggested by TRENTO comparisons. The neutron skins of Zr lower the fraction of participating protons in peripheral collisions, far more in Zr+Zr than in Ru+Ru, which raises ∆Q there. p. 3 Removing the deformation changes neither ∆Q nor the scaled ratio beyond statistical uncertainties. p. 6 The O−Zr pair is the best determined of the three pairs because it has the largest lever. p. 4
Conclusion and Future Scope
In summary, HIJING/BB with the baryon junction reproduces STAR isobar measurement of ⟨B⟩/∆Q × ∆Z/A at √sNN = 200 GeV in all centrality classes. The junction sets the magnitude of the ratio, with the junction off giving 0. p. 44 to 0.9 like models without junctions. p. 4 p. 4 The neutron skins of the isobars set its centrality dependence. p. 4 p. 4 For O+O collisions at peripheral isobar collisions' ⟨Npart⟩, the model predicts the ordering of pairs, which STAR O+O data can test. The junction contribution falls by a factor of 0. p. 3 p. 337 between 200 and 900 GeV, consistent with measured reduction. p. 3 The junction component alone at 900 GeV accounts for the observed net-proton yield, implying the excess arises from pair asymmetry. p. 3 The model constrains HIJING string fragmentation at LHC multiplicities rather than baryon transport. p. 3 The paper foresees future developments addressing this issue before the junction version of HIJING can be used at LHC energies. p. 3
Figure 3 Analysis
Figure 3 shows ⟨B⟩/∆Q × ∆Z/A at y < 0.5 in Ru+Ru and Zr+Zr collisions at √sNN = 200 GeV versus centrality. p. 3 p. 3 With the junction off, the ratio is ∼0. p. 0 p. 044 to 0.87 (Fig. 3), in the range of other models without junctions. p. 3 p. 3 The two pieces of the ratio have different origins, with magnitude from the junction and centrality dependence from nuclear geometry. p. 3
Figure 4 Analysis
Figure 4 shows ∆Q/⟨Npart⟩ and ⟨B⟩/∆Q×∆(Z/A) for the three pairs Ru−Zr, O−Ru and O−Zr. The Ru−Zr pair gives ∆Q/⟨Npart⟩ = (1. p. 430±0.10)×10−3 and a scaled ratio ⟨B⟩/∆Q×∆Z/A = 0. p. 099±0.08. The O−Zr pair has twice the lever but only 1. p. 435 times the charge difference, (1. p. 475±0.10)×10−3, and a ratio of 1. p. 051±0.09.
Figure S2 Analysis
Figure S2 repeats Figs. 1 and 3 of the main text with the neutron skin removed (deformation kept) and with the deformation removed (skin kept). p. 6 The net-baryon number per participant is unchanged in both cases. p. 6 Without the skin, the participant proton fraction of Zr is at its bulk value in all classes. p. 6 The charge difference then falls in peripheral collisions, from 1. p. 63 to 1.0 × 10−3 in 60–80%, where the neutron-rich surface of Zr no longer depletes the participating protons, and rises in central collisions, from 1. p. 62 to 1.5×10−3 in 0–10%, where the diffuse neutron tail of the halo-type skin no longer leaves the participants slightly proton-rich. p. 6 The ratio is then ∼1. p. 04 to 1.6, flat within uncertainties. p. 6
Figure S1 Analysis
Figure S1 shows the ratio of per-event midrapidity yields with Pu = 0.58 to those with Pu = 2/3, junction on, in Ru+Ru and Zr+Zr collisions for each centrality class. p. 6 All yields, π±, K±, p, ¯p, n and the charged multiplicity change by less than 0. p. 63%, and the net-baryon number and ⟨Npart⟩ in each class by less than 0. p. 63% and 0.05%. The ∆Q of Fig. p. 2 1(a) of the main text changes by a factor two. p. 6
Figure 2 Analysis
Figure 2 shows proton, antiproton and net-proton rapidity densities in 0–5% Au+Au collisions with STAR midrapidity yields. The model gives dN/dy = 40. p. 25 for protons and 30. p. 13 for antiprotons at y < 0. p. 25, against 34. p. 27 ± 4.4 and 26.7 ± 3.4. The model follows the measured decrease from 0. p. 275±0.04 at y = 0 to 0.22±0.03 at y = 3.1. In p+p collisions at the same energy, the model gives an inclusive net-proton density of 0. p. 2032 per unit rapidity per non-single-diffractive event against the STAR value of 0. p. 2025 ± 0.004. The model with the junction reproduces Au+Au and p+p baryon sector at the level of experimental uncertainties. p. 2
Table II Analysis
Table II gives the three components of the midrapidity net-proton yield at y < 0.5, in p+p collisions at √s = 200 and 900 GeV. p. 3 The junction contribution falls by a factor of 0.37 between 200 and 900 GeV, consistent with the measured reduction, 0. p. 336 ± 4.14. At 900 GeV, the junction component alone (0. p. 30043) accounts for the observed net-proton yield, implying that the excess arises from pair asymmetry. p. 3 The junction baryons were identified by their origin in the event record and set aside. p. 3
Figure 3 shows ⟨B⟩/∆Q × ∆Z/A at y < 0.5 in Ru+Ru and Zr+Zr collisions at √sNN = 200 GeV versus centrality. With the junction off, the ratio is ∼0.44 to 0.87 (Fig. 3), in the range of other models without junctions. The magnitude comes from the junction, and its centrality dependence comes from nuclear geometry. p. 3
Figure 4 shows ∆Q/⟨Npart⟩ and ⟨B⟩/∆Q×∆(Z/A) for the three pairs Ru−Zr, O−Ru and O−Zr. The model predicts the ordering of pairs in charge difference and scaled ratio. p. 4 The O−Zr pair is the best determined because it has the largest lever. p. 4
Figure 4 Ordering
The model thus predicts the ordering of pairs: in the charge difference, O−Ru < Ru−Zr < O−Zr and in the scaled ratio, Ru−Zr < O−Zr < O−Ru. The STAR O+O data can test these predictions for peripheral isobar collisions at √sNN = 200 GeV. p. 4 The paper concludes that the junction sets the magnitude of the ratio, with junction off giving 0. p. 44 to 0.9 like models without junctions. The neutron skins of the isobars set its centrality dependence.
Green — the paper says it, and the page is printed. Red — no passage carries it, so treat that sentence as unverified. The same check runs on your own text: check a summary against its source, $5.
Improvements for AI systems
-
Improvement of event generator accuracy in describing baryon transport by implementing junction exchange and enhanced string tension in HIJING/BB v2.0, which allows for a direct comparison with STAR results in both Au+Au and p+p collisions at 200 GeV.
-
Improved ability to reproduce the scaled ratio of net-baryon number to charge difference, denoted as Rb/Q = ⟨B⟩ / (∆Q × ∆Z/A), by tuning the quark-diquark splitting probability Pu to match STAR data in isobar collisions, specifically using Pu = 0.58.
-
Enhanced prediction of centrality dependence in the scaled ratio by incorporating realistic nuclear geometry, such as the neutron skin of Zr, which is shown to drive the magnitude of this ratio across different centrality classes.
-
Refined modeling of baryon number transport by showing that
the junction supplies about half of the midrapidity netbaryon number,
demonstrating that baryon stopping in diquark strings alone is insufficient at this energy. -
Improved prediction for proton and antiproton ratios in p+p collisions, where the model follows the measured decrease from 0.75 to 0.22 as rapidity increases, and it can reproduce BRAHMS results for antiproton/proton ratios in specific centrality classes like 0-20%.
-
Better discrimination between charge transport and baryon number transport by demonstrating that
the junction exchange and enhanced string tension are the only physics additions in v2.0,
which is essential for isolating the junction contribution to the observables.
Sources
- Search for baryon junctions in photonuclear processes and isobar collisions at RHIC
- Correlations of Baryon and Charge Stopping in Heavy Ion Collisions
- Understanding baryon stopping at the BNL Relativistic Heavy Ion Collider top energies
- Baryon Transport in Color Flux Tubes
- Search for baryon junctions in e+A collisions at the Electron Ion Collider
- Baryon stopping and charge deposition in heavy-ion collisions due to gluon saturation
- Disentangling baryon stopping and neutron skin effects in heavy-ion collisions
- Tracking the baryon number with nuclear collisions
- Beam energy dependence of net-hyperon yield and its implication on baryon transport mechanism
- Microscopic Models for Ultrarelativistic Heavy Ion Collisions
- Relativistic Hadron-Hadron Collisions in the Ultra-Relativistic Quantum Molecular Dynamics Model (UrQMD)
- A Multi-Phase Transport Model for Relativistic Heavy Ion Collisions
- Baryon and electric charge stoppings in nuclear collisions and the role of strangeness
- Alternative ansatz to wounded nucleon and binary collision scaling in high-energy nuclear collisions
- Probing the neutron skin with ultrarelativistic isobaric collisions
- Measuring neutron skin by grazing isobaric collisions
- Baryon Number Transport via Gluonic Junctions
- Anti-Hyperon Enhancement through Baryon Junction Loops
- Baryon Junction Loops in HIJING/B\=Bv2.0 and the Baryon/Meson Anomaly at RHIC
Related papers
- Constrained Hamiltonian Formulation of Kinetic Theory for Relativistic Spin- 1/2 Particles
- Active-subspace learning reveals dominant parameter directions in nuclear observables
- Long- and short-range longitudinal flow decorrelations in the quark-gluon plasma
- Recurrent Fourier Neural Operator for Event-by-Event Relativistic Hydrodynamics
- Bayesian Inference of the Landau Parameter G'0 from Joint Gamow-Teller Measurements
- UrQMD-Agent: An LLM-Assisted Framework for Microscopic Tracing of Proton Azimuthal Correlations