Bayesian Inference of the Landau Parameter G'0 from Joint Gamow-Teller Measurements

arXiv:2506.05564 · nucl-th, astro-ph.HE · Submitted 2025-06-05 · Read on arXiv

Listen

Radio episode about this paper

Transcript

Introduction to the show: ident: Nuclear Theory. The day in nuclear theory: structure, reactions and the models behind them.

Kai: We're looking at the paper: "Bayesian Inference of the Landau Parameter G'0 from Joint Gamow-Teller Measurements".

Mira: Here's the gist of the paper. Bayesian inference of the Landau parameter G′0 from joint Gamow-Teller measurements reports that G′0 is 0.48 ± 0.034 using a self-consistent Skyrme Random Phase Approximation (RPA) model and joint constraints from experimental GTR measurements on 208Pb, 132Sn, and 90Zr.

Kai: Characterization of the Landau Parameter G′0 The Landau-Migdal parameter G′0 characterizes the main part of the spin-isospin dependent nucleon-nucleon interaction.

Mira: Consequently, it is closely related to the Gamow-Teller resonance (GTR), beta and doublebeta decay rates of finite nuclei, and the response of hot and dense nucleonic matter.

Kai: The spin-isospin part of the nuclear force is believed to be repulsive at densities relevant to nuclei and nuclear matter in the inner crust/outer core region of compact stars.

Title and authors: Kai: Let's start with the title and the authors of this paper, "Bayesian Inference of the Landau Parameter G prime zero from Joint Gamow-Teller Measurements". It tells us immediately that they are using a Bayesian approach to figure out G prime zero from joint measurements.

Mira: And it points out that they are doing this in a self consistent Skyrme Random Phase Approximation model, which is the theoretical machinery they're using to bridge the gap between nuclear structure and these parameters.

Lev: I’m curious how they set up this Skyrme framework, because for real hardware, you can't just plug in any interaction; everything has to be built on a very specific foundation.

Kai: The paper details that they first build the Random Phase Approximation model using a Hartree Fock scheme with Skyrme interactions before doing the inference part. They define the QRPA matrix equation on a particle hole basis, which is standard for describing giant resonances in finite nuclei <ref:2506.05564#pg2>.

Mira: They then define those matrix elements A and B based on the residual p-h interaction, which is where G prime zero shows up as the dominant part of these matrix elements <ref:2506.05564#pg3>. This is how they connect their parameter to the physics of the nuclear force.

Lev: So, from an engineering standpoint, building this QRPA framework on a Skyrme interaction means you have to ensure the input parameters for that interaction are well constrained before you even start calculating excitations.

The paper's summary: Kai: Now for the summary of what they actually did in "Bayesian Inference of the Landau Parameter G prime zero from Joint Gamow-Teller Measurements". They used joint constraints from GTR measurements on two hundred eight lead, one hundred thirty-two tin, and ninety zirconium to constrain Skyrme models <ref:2506.05564#pg3>.

Mira: The core method is Bayesian inference, where they use these experimental data points—the GTR measurements—as evidence to narrow down the possible values for the Skyrme parameters within their model space.

Lev: So, it’s not just fitting a curve; it’s using a statistical framework to find the most probable underlying interaction that matches all these different nuclei simultaneously <ref:2506.05564#pg2>.

Kai: They also mentioned incorporating other observables like charge radii and spin orbit splittings into the constraints, which helps tighten up the model significantly. This gives them a much richer set of data than just looking at one measurement.

Mira: What I find particularly important is their analysis of intrinsic scattering parameters, which they use to quantify those systematic uncertainties that you always have when you're relying on a theoretical framework <ref:2506.05564#pg3>.

The paper's improvements: Kai: Moving onto the improvements suggested by this work. They argue that using this joint Bayesian approach allows for a more robust extraction of G prime zero, giving them a quantified uncertainty of zero point forty-eight plus or minus zero point thirty-four.

Mira: That’s better than previous phenomenological extractions because they provide a statistical quantification, not just a single number with an arbitrary error bar attached <ref:2506.05564#pg1>. It moves the field from fitting to inference.

Lev: From my side, what this means is that if you were to build real hardware based on these Skyrme interactions, you’d need to be really careful about how much weight you give those different data sets during the Bayesian sampling process.

Kai: They also suggest a way to systematically analyze the correlations between GTR features and the underlying G prime zero using posterior distributions derived from that inference <ref:2506.05564#pg3>. This helps them see how much uncertainty in one measurement feeds into the uncertainty of G prime zero.

Conclusion: Mira: So, to wrap up with this paper, the authors conclude that they’ve extracted a G prime zero value of zero point forty-eight plus or minus zero point thirty-four using joint constraints from Gamow-Teller measurements across three nuclei.

Kai: They note that this value is close to existing Skyrme model predictions but smaller than some previous results derived from pion exchange models, which suggests the Skyrme framework is doing a decent job here <ref:2506.05564#pg1>.

Lev: For us on the hardware side, this G prime zero value is what we need to constrain charged current neutrino-nucleon interactions in things like core collapse supernovae and binary neutron star mergers, which are high density environments <ref:2506.05564#pg1>.

Mira: Exactly. And they also found that the effective nucleon mass sampled from this GTAll Bayesian inference has a mean of zero point sixty-seven which is smaller than what some traditional empirical methods assumed for m star/m <ref:2506.05564#pg3>.

Kai: So, in short, this paper gives us a way to get a quantified G prime zero from joint measurements using Bayesian inference within a Skyrme model framework. It’s a solid piece of work for constraining the nuclear force <ref:2506.05564#pg1>.

Zidu Lin, Gianluca Colo, Andrew W. Steiner, Amber Stinson

Department of Physics and Astronomy, University of Tennessee Knoxville · Department of Physics and Astronomy, University of New Hampshire · Dipartimento di Fisica, Universita degli Studi di Milano · INFN Sezione di Milano · Physics Division, Oak Ridge National Laboratory

nucl-th, astro-ph.HE

Submitted: 2025-06-05

Updated: 2026-11-03

Comments: The scope of this manuscript is refined to focus on the Bayesian study of $G'_0$ (accepted by PRL). The study of neutrino opacity and the correlation emerging from the Bayesian posterior of Skyrme models is presented in a separate work titled "Information content of the Gamow Teller Resonance: Bayesian inference with self-consistent Skyrme models" (accepted by PRC)

License: http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-sa/4.0/

Importance score: 97/100

The gist: Bayesian inference of the Landau parameter G′0 from joint Gamow-Teller measurements reports that G′0 is 0.48 ± 0.034 using a self-consistent Skyrme Random Phase Approximation (RPA) model and…

Key concepts

Landau Parameter G'0
This parameter describes the main spin-isospin dependent part of the nucleon-nucleon interaction within the nucleus. It is crucial for understanding phenomena like Gamow-Teller resonances and how nuclear matter behaves under extreme conditions, such as in compact stars.
Skyrme Random Phase Approximation (RPA)
This is a theoretical framework used to model nuclear structure. The RPA builds upon a Hartree-Fock scheme using Skyrme interactions to calculate the Gamow-Teller strength functions. It allows researchers to self-consistently determine G'0 by linking the microscopic nucleon interactions with observable nuclear properties.
Bayesian Inference
This statistical method is used to constrain the parameters of Skyrme models based on experimental data. By combining prior knowledge about Skyrme parameters with observational constraints from GTR measurements and other nuclear observables, it yields a statistically rigorous estimate for G'0.

Terminology

Summary

Bayesian inference of the Landau parameter G′0 from joint Gamow-Teller measurements reports that G′0 is 0. p. 0

Where the paper says it

Bayesian Inference of the Landau Parameter G′ 0 from Joint Gamow-Teller Measurements Zidu Lin,1, 2 Gianluca Colo,` 3, 4 Andrew W. Steiner,1, 5 and Amber Stinson1 1Department of Physics and Astronomy, University of Tennessee Knoxville, Knoxville, TN 37996-1200, USA.

48 ± 0.034 using a self-consistent Skyrme Random Phase Approximation (RPA) model and joint constraints from experimental GTR measurements on 208Pb, 132Sn, and 90Zr. p. 0
Where the paper says it

Consequently, the G ′ 0 is closely related to the Gamow-Teller resonance (GTR), the beta and doublebeta decay rates of finite nuclei, the response of hot and dense nucleonic matter that modifies the neutrinonucleon absorption rates in core-collapse supernovae (CCSNe) and binary neutron star (BNS) mergers, and finally the critical density for pion condensation in neutron stars. In this letter, for the first time, we report the G ′ 0 with quantified uncertainty in the framework of Bayesian inference, using a self-consistent standard Skyrme Random Phase Approximation (RPA) model and joint constraints from experimental GTR measurements on 208Pb, 132Sn, 90Zr.

Characterization of the Landau Parameter G′0

The Landau-Migdal parameter G′0 characterizes the main part of the spin-isospin dependent nucleon-nucleon interaction. Consequently, it is closely related to the Gamow-Teller resonance (GTR), beta and doublebeta decay rates of finite nuclei, and the response of hot and dense nucleonic matter. p. 0

Where the paper says it

The Landau-Migdal parameter G ′ 0 characterizes the main part of the spin-isospin dependent nucleon-nucleon interaction. Consequently, the G ′ 0 is closely related to the Gamow-Teller resonance (GTR), the beta and doublebeta decay rates of finite nuclei, the response of hot and dense nucleonic matter that modifies the neutrinonucleon absorption rates in core-collapse supernovae (CCSNe) and binary neutron star (BNS) mergers, and finally the critical density for pion condensation in neutron stars.

The spin-isospin part of the nuclear force is believed to be repulsive at densities relevant to nuclei and nuclear matter in the inner crust/outer core region of compact stars. p. 0
Where the paper says it

For example, neutrino interactions with dense matter in core-collapse supernovae and neutron star mergers [5–7], beta-decay and neutrinoless double beta-decay rates in finite nuclei [2, 8– 10], and pion condensation in dense matter are all related to the spin-isospin part of the nuclear force [11, 12]. The spin-isospin-dependent nuclear force is characterized by the density-dependent Landau parameter G′ 0 (ρ) [13], and is believed to be repulsive at densities relevant to nuclei and nuclear matter in the inner crust/outer core region of compact stars.

Historically, G′0(ρ0) was extracted by fitting it to the peak location of the experimental GTR spectrum EGT. p. 0
Where the paper says it

Consequently, G′ 0 (ρ) should be positive but its quantitative determination remains challenging if phenomenological models are used, together with either uncontrolled approximations or simplistic uncertainty quantification. Historically, G′ 0 (ρ0) was extracted by fitting it to the peak location of the experimental GTR spectrum EGT.

Methodological Framework

The work employs a self-consistent Random Phase Approximation (RPA) model based on a Hartree-Fock (HF) scheme using Skyrme interactions. The RPA matrix equation is built on a particle-hole (p-h) basis, where the matrix elements A and B are defined using the residual p-h interaction. p. 1

Where the paper says it

Given the energies ϵ and wave functions of the HF singleparticle states, one can build the QRPA matrix equation A B −B∗ −A∗ Xν Y ν = Eν Xν Y µ , (1) on a particle-hole (p-h) basis. The matrix elements A and B are defined as Ami,nj = (ϵm − ϵi)δmnδij + ⟨mj|Vres|in⟩, (2) Bmi,nj = ⟨mn|Vres|ij⟩, (3) where occupied (unoccupied) states are denoted as i, j (m, n).

The density-dependent LandauMigdal parameter G′0(ρ) is the dominant part in these RPA matrix elements. p. 1
Where the paper says it

After solving the RPA matrix equation, the Gamow-Teller strength function is obtained from the eigenstates |ν⟩, as S(E) = X n |⟨ν||OˆGT||0⟩|2 δ(E − Eν), (4) where Oˆ± GT = PA i=1 σ i ±τ i ±. The density-dependent LandauMigdal parameter G′ 0 (ρ), is the dominant part in the RPA matrix elements A and B, as discussed in the references we have provided.

Bayesian inference is used to constrain Skyrme models given observational data. p. 1
Where the paper says it

Bayesian inference is a widely used method in nuclear and astrophysics to constrain theoretical models given observational data [37–39]. For the first time, the experimental measurements of GTR are used in a state-of-the-art Bayesian inference to constrain Skyrme models.

Constraints and Priors

The joint constraints include GTR measurements on 208Pb, 132Sn, and 90Zr, alongside charge radii, binding energy (from 208Pb, 132Sn, 90Zr and 48Ca), neutron skin thickness in specific nuclei, and spin-orbit splitting values. The Bayesian prior for Skyrme parameters is chosen similarly as in Ref. p. 7

Where the paper says it

The six parameters represent systematic uncertainty of m0% in finite nuclei, the systematic uncertainty of EGT, the systematic uncertainty of ground state properties of 208Pb and 132Sn, the systematic uncertainty of ground state properties of 90Zr and 48Ca, the systematic uncertainty of the spin-orbit splittings of 208Pb and 132Sn, and the systematic uncertainty of spin-orbit splittings of 90Zr and 48Ca. Bayesian prior The prior distribution of Skyrme parameters is chosen similarly as in Ref.

[14]. Intrinsic scattering (IS) parameters are included as additional degrees of freedom to quantify systematic model uncertainties. p. 7
Where the paper says it

The “intrinsic scattering (IS) parameters" are applied in the Bayesian inference of this work as additional degrees of freedom. Here, the IS parameters of Oˆ k are defined as the logarithm of the ratio of the systematic uncertainty to the mean of experimental measurement: IS = log10 σk,sys Ok,mean , (X.

Key Findings and Comparisons

The extracted G′0 value is 0.48 ± 0.034, which is close to the prediction of a few existing Skyrme models but smaller than values reported in previous works based on pion exchange models. p. 3

Where the paper says it

From the posterior distribution, the value of G′ 0 with quantified uncertainty is 0. This value is close to the prediction of a few set of existing Skyrme models and is smaller than the G′ 0 values reported in previous works based on pion exchange models.

The consistency between different Skyrme models in predicting GTR features is guaranteed by applying the same Skyrme model. p. 2
Where the paper says it

24 ( 132Sn) from Ref. While in this letter, the consistency is guaranteed by applying the same Skyrme model to predict the GRT features of different nuclei.

Furthermore, most standard Skyrme EDFs suggest that a G′0 close to those extracted from phenomenological models is not necessary to reproduce experimental GTR spectrum features. p. 3
Where the paper says it

This value is close to the prediction of a few set of existing Skyrme models and is smaller than the G′ 0 values reported in previous works based on pion exchange models. We find that for most standard Skyrme EDFs, it is not necessary to have a G′ 0 close to the ones extracted from phenomenological models [14, 34–36] to reproduce the experimental GTR spectrum features.

The effective nucleon mass sampled from the GTAll Bayesian inference has a mean of 0. p. 3
Where the paper says it

The effective nucleon mass is certainly different in the two cases. This warns against the use of hybrid Hartree Fock + RPA models (which use Skyrme parameterization to calculate the mean field and empirically fitted values of G′ 0 to calculate the RPA residual force [45]).

67, suggesting it may be smaller than former assumptions used in traditional empirical methods. p. 3
Where the paper says it

5 may result in an overestimate of m0%. We should consider that in previous works a few critical assumptions were made as we have explained, and empirical single-particle states are generally input, whereas ours is a self-consistent model.

Implications for Future Work

The extracted G′0 with quantified uncertainties has been used for constraining charged current neutrino-nucleon interactions in the dense nucleonic matter of CCSNe and BNS mergers. Future improvements may involve increasing the accuracy of singleparticle states in Skyrme models and investigating Bayesian inference with extended Skyrme models. p. 3

Where the paper says it

The extracted G′ 0 with quantified uncertainties has been used by us for constraining the calculations of charged current neutrino-nucleon interactions in the dense nucleonic matter of CCSNe and BNS mergers [17]. Future improvements along the line of this work may involve: increasing the accuracy of the description of singleparticle states in Skyrme models, investigating the Bayesian inference of G′ 0 with extended Skyrme models [47, 48], and inventing fast and accurate emulators of the GTR spectral features given a set of Skyrme parameters [49].

This extracted value may be different based on different many-body methods. p. 3
Where the paper says it

, second RPA, or particlevibration coupling (PVC) models). In fact, we emphasize that the present value of G′ 0 is extracted within the framework of Skyrme EDFs and RPA models, and this extracted value may be different based on different many-body methods.

The model dependency of the G′0 extraction is left for future studies. p. 3
Where the paper says it

In fact, we emphasize that the present value of G′ 0 is extracted within the framework of Skyrme EDFs and RPA models, and this extracted value may be different based on different many-body methods. The model dependency of the G′ 0 extraction is left for future stud4

Green — the paper says it, and the page is printed. Red — no passage carries it, so treat that sentence as unverified. The same check runs on your own text: check a summary against its source, $5.

Improvements for AI systems

  1. Bayesian inference of Landau parameter G prime zero from joint Gamow-Teller measurements allows for a self-consistent extraction of G prime zero (0.48 +/- 0.034) using Skyrme models, providing a quantified uncertainty that surpasses previous phenomenological extractions which lacked such robust quantification.

  2. The improved system can perform self consistent inference by calculating Gamow-Teller strength functions from self consistent Skyrme Random Phase Approximation RPA models, enabling the simultaneous constraint of G prime zero with experimental measurements and other nuclear observables like charge radii and spin orbit splittings.

  3. The system can systematically analyze correlations between predictions of GTR features and the underlying Landau parameter G prime zero using posterior distributions derived from Bayesian inference, allowing for a direct comparison between Skyrme model predictions and empirical models.

  4. The AI system can identify tensions between successful Skyrme models and experimental data by analyzing intrinsic scattering parameters, which quantify the unknown systematic uncertainties in the theoretical framework.

  5. The improved system can predict the effective nucleon mass m star/m in symmetric nuclear matter at a density of 0.16 fm-3, with a mean value of 0.67 derived from GTAll calculations, offering a more physically grounded input for subsequent calculations compared to previous assumptions of m star/m between 0.8 and 1.0.

Abstract

G'0 is the leading-order Landau-Migdal parameter that characterizes the spin-isospin dependent nucleon-nucleon interaction. Consequently, the G'0 is closely related to the Gamow-Teller resonance (GTR), the beta and double-beta decay rates of finite nuclei, the response of hot and dense nucleonic matter that modifies the neutrino-nucleon absorption rates in core-collapse supernovae (CCSNe) and binary neutron star (BNS) mergers, and finally the critical density for pion condensation in neutron stars. In this letter, for the first time, we report the G'0 with quantified uncertainty in the framework of Bayesian inference, using a self-consistent standard Skyrme Random Phase Approximation (RPA) model and joint constraints from experimental GTR measurements on 208 Pb, 132 Sn, 90 Zr. Our extracted G 0' at saturation density is 0.48 plus or minus0.034, which is close to the prediction of a few existing Skyrme models that consider spin-isospin observables but smaller than the traditional ones extracted from pion-exchange models. The reasons for this deviation, like the value of the nucleon effective mass m* over m and the density dependence of G'0, are investigated. The density-dependent G 0' values extracted in this work may guide the construction of new energy density functionals that aims to self-consistently describe the dense matter properties in the spin-isospin channel.

Sources

Related papers