Characterization of the mechanical vibrations of the Schmidt Camera at the Tonantzintla Astronomical Observatory
Listen
Radio episode about this paper
Transcript
Introduction to the show: ident: Astrophysics. The day in astrophysics: observations, models and what the data forces.
Vera: We're looking at the paper: "Characterization of the mechanical vibrations of the Schmidt Camera at the Tonantzintla Astronomical Observatory".
Jocelyn: Here's the gist of the paper. Mechanical vibrations in astronomical telescopes degrade image quality, making their detection and analysis crucial This work presents a low-cost, portable vibration monitoring system using MEMS accelerometers and microcontrollers, tested in the historic Schmidt Camera at Tonantzintla Results reveal dominant frequencies and structural couplings that may impact image quality The system’s design, deployment, and preliminary results demonstrate the viability of inertial sensing for heritage-class telescopes and future instrumentation efforts System Development The development and validation of a low-cost, portable vibration detection system based on MEMS (microelectromechanical systems) accelerometers interfaced with a microcontroller is presented in detail The system architecture including sensor integration, signal acquisition, and data analysis software is described in detail Laboratory tests were performed to evaluate the system’s performance under controlled conditions A compact MEMS-based sensor combining a 3-axis accelerometer and 3-axis gyroscope, the MPU6050, was selected for this study This dual-sensor setup provides redundancy, reducing random noise and enhancing the signal-to-noise ratio The IMUs and microcontroller were enclosed in custom 3D-printed housings, incorporating RJ11 connectors for reliable 4-wire communication and neodymium magnets to ensure rigid attachment to ferrous surfaces Data Acquisition and Analysis The sampling rate was experimentally varied between 30 Hz and 1 kHz and ultimately fixed at 350 Hz for spectral analysis Each data acquisition session was stored in files containing matrices of 16,384 rows by 6 columns The variables AccX, AccY, and AccZ correspond to the linear acceleration components along the orthogonal axes X, Y, and Z These six-degree-of-freedom signals enable precise characterization of both translational and rotational dynamics By calculating the FFT of each column of this matrix, the frequency spectrum of the vibration component on each axis is obtained Vibration Source Identification The MPU6050 sensors were strategically installed at different locations on the telescope, as shown in Figure 4 (1) Two sensors were placed at the base of the telescope, where the greater distance from the support fork and the higher moment of inertia allow for better detection of high-energy vibrations (2) A sensor was positioned inside the telescope, adjacent to the detector, to capture vibrations that most significantly degrade astronomical images (3) Additional sensors were mounted near the declination motor and (4) the right ascension motor to monitor vibrations generated by these components Furthermore, sensors were also placed on the dome traction motors and on the air conditioning compressor located at the base of the CCD camera Observed Vibrational Patterns The analysis of raw astronomical images uncovers systematic elongation in stellar profiles, suggesting mechanical contributions to image degradation This effect becomes more evident when zooming in on individual stars, where it is clear that the point sources lack a circularly symmetric profile The observed elongation along a preferred axis instead suggests the influence of mechanical tracking errors or structural vibrations of the telescope Structural and Mitigation Insights An unexpected mechanical coupling was identified between the telescope base and the dome floor, possibly due to maintenance personnel sealing the gap without awareness of its critical role The drive bearing associated with motor 1 is located very close to the telescope base and is likely the primary source of the vibrations transmitted to the structure Repositioning each motor to the next bearing in the counterclockwise direction would increase the separation between motor 1 and the telescope base The use of IMUs proved to be a key component in the dynamic assessment of the system Based on our findings, we propose targeted actions to mitigate the effects of these vibrations We also recommend the permanent integration of IMU-based monitoring systems to provide real-time feedback to operators regarding vibrational conditions during observations The device developed in this study offers significant advantages compared to commercial solutions This capability makes the system not only a practical tool for the Schmidt Camera but a promising template for similar applications in heritage-class and modern observatories worldwide The work demonstrates the potential of inertial sensing as a practical, cost-effective, and robust approach for vibrational diagnostics in heritage-class telescopes ACKNOWLEDGMENTS We acknowledge the collaboration grant from INAOE awarded to Dr.
Vera: Miguel Antonio Nieto-Suárez, as well as the support provided by the technicians of the Schmidt Camera in Tonantzintla, Agustín Márquez Limón and Guillermo Cerdán Hernández, which was essential for the realization of this study REFERENCES
1: Turner, H.
Jocelyn: W., et al.
Vera: (1950).
Title and authors: Vera: So we're diving into the details of this study, "Characterization of the mechanical vibrations of the Schmidt Camera at the Tonantzintla Astronomical Observatory," and who wrote it.
Jocelyn: It was written by Miguel Antonio Nieto-Suárez, supported by his collaborators from INAOE, and Agustín Márquez Limón and Guillermo Cerdán Hernández from the Schmidt Camera itself.
Subrahmanyan: Having researchers from both the theoretical side of things, like cosmology, and practical instrumentation working together is always interesting because you get that bridge between the abstract theory and what's actually happening on a specific instrument.
Vera: Exactly. They are bringing together the data perspective with the engineering reality of how these old instruments behave over time.
Jocelyn: The title itself sets up a very clear picture: they are characterizing the mechanical vibrations specifically at that Tonantzintla site.
The paper's summary: Vera: Now, looking at the summary of this paper, it’s about how they built this whole monitoring system and what kind of data they ended up collecting.
Jocelyn: They used a compact MEMS-based sensor called the MPU6050, which is a dual-sensor setup with both an accelerometer and a gyroscope to get better signal quality by reducing random noise.
Subrahmanyan: That dual setup suggests they weren't just looking at simple linear movement; they were trying to capture both translational and rotational dynamics, which is key when you're dealing with complex structures like a telescope.
Vera: The system was designed using three dee-printed housings with RJ11 connectors and neodymium magnets so the sensors could be rigidly attached to the metal surfaces of the telescope structure <ref:2611.14732#pg2>.
Jocelyn: They sampled their data at a sampling rate between thirty hertz and one thousand hertz, but they settled on three hundred fifty hertz for their spectral analysis.
Subrahmanyan: That frequency range is pretty useful for identifying mechanical resonances within a large structure like an old telescope dish.
The paper's improvements: Vera: The paper points out a few ways they improved the setup, like using that dual-sensor approach to enhance the signal-to-noise ratio.
Jocelyn: They also made sure the deployment was modular and secure by using those custom housings with magnets and connectors for reliable attachment.
Subrahmanyan: And they mentioned that similar accelerometer-based approaches have been successfully applied to other large radio and optical telescopes, like the Nobeyama forty-five m dish or even the Subaru Telescope <ref:2611.14732#pg2,similar accelerometer-based approaches have been successfully applied to>.
Vera: That comparison is important because it shows that this kind of inertial sensing isn't just a niche idea for this one telescope; it’s a viable method for larger instruments too.
Jocelyn: The authors also set up specific sensor locations, placing two sensors at the base of the telescope and one inside adjacent to the detector to capture different types of vibrations.
Conclusion: Vera: So, looking at what they concluded about these observed patterns, they found systematic elongation in stellar profiles in their raw astronomical images.
Jocelyn: That elongation suggests there are mechanical contributions affecting the image quality, which becomes much clearer when you zoom in on individual stars because those point sources don't have a perfectly circular shape.
Subrahmanyan: That elongation along a preferred axis strongly hints at the influence of mechanical tracking errors or structural vibrations within the telescope itself.
Vera: They also identified an unexpected mechanical coupling between the telescope base and the dome floor, which they suspect might be related to maintenance work not fully accounting for how critical that gap is.
Jocelyn: And they pointed out that a drive bearing on motor one is located very close to the telescope base and is probably the main source of vibrations transmitted throughout the structure.
Subrahmanyan: The suggested fix, repositioning each motor to the next bearing in a counterclockwise direction, aims to increase the separation between that motor and the telescope base.
Vera: So they wrap up by saying that using Inertial Measurement Units proved key for assessing their system dynamically, and they recommend integrating this IMU-based monitoring into real time feedback systems for operators.
Jocelyn: They conclude that this device offers significant advantages over commercial solutions and serves as a template for heritage-class telescopes and future instrumentation efforts worldwide.
Subrahmanyan: From a theoretical view, it’s about proving that inertial sensing can be a practical, cost-effective way to diagnose vibrations in old telescopes, which opens the door for more comprehensive monitoring across many environments.
University of Miami · National Institute of Astrophysics, Optics and Electronics (INAOE)
astro-ph.IM
Submitted: 2026-11-10
Updated: 2026-11-10
Comments: 12 pages, 14 figures, SOMI XXXVIII Instrumentation Congress October 2025
License: http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
Importance score: 83/100
The gist: Mechanical vibrations in astronomical telescopes degrade image quality, making their detection and analysis crucial This work presents a low-cost…
Key concepts
- MEMS Accelerometers
- These are tiny sensors made using microelectromechanical systems that can measure linear acceleration (movement in X, Y, and Z directions). They were used in this study to detect the subtle mechanical vibrations within the telescope structure. Their small size makes them ideal for portable, low-cost monitoring systems.
- Frequency Spectrum Analysis
- This technique involves taking recorded vibration data and using a mathematical tool called the Fast Fourier Transform (FFT) to break down complex signals into their constituent frequencies. This allowed researchers to pinpoint the specific vibrations causing image degradation by identifying which frequencies were dominant in the telescope's movement.
- Structural Coupling
- This refers to an unexpected physical connection or interaction between different parts of a structure, such as how the telescope base is physically linked to the dome floor. Identifying these couplings helps pinpoint hidden mechanical sources of vibration that might not be obvious from simple sensor placement.
- Inertial Sensing
- Inertial sensing is the process of using inertial sensors, like accelerometers and gyroscopes, to measure motion and dynamics. In this context, it means using these sensors to dynamically assess the mechanical health of a telescope by monitoring its vibrations in real-time or during observation.
Terminology
Summary
Mechanical vibrations in astronomical telescopes degrade image quality, making their detection and analysis crucial This work presents a low-cost, portable vibration monitoring system using MEMS accelerometers and microcontrollers, tested in the historic Schmidt Camera at Tonantzintla Results reveal dominant frequencies and structural couplings that may impact image quality The system’s design, deployment, and preliminary results demonstrate the viability of inertial sensing for heritage-class telescopes and future instrumentation efforts
System Development
The development and validation of a low-cost, portable vibration detection system based on MEMS (microelectromechanical systems) accelerometers interfaced with a microcontroller is presented in detail The system architecture including sensor integration, signal acquisition, and data analysis software is described in detail Laboratory tests were performed to evaluate the system’s performance under controlled conditions A compact MEMS-based sensor combining a 3-axis accelerometer and 3-axis gyroscope, the MPU6050, was selected for this study This dual-sensor setup provides redundancy, reducing random noise and enhancing the signal-to-noise ratio The IMUs and microcontroller were enclosed in custom 3D-printed housings, incorporating RJ11 connectors for reliable 4-wire communication and neodymium magnets to ensure rigid attachment to ferrous surfaces
Data Acquisition and Analysis
The sampling rate was experimentally varied between 30 Hz and 1 kHz and ultimately fixed at 350 Hz for spectral analysis Each data acquisition session was stored in files containing matrices of 16,384 rows by 6 columns The variables AccX, AccY, and AccZ correspond to the linear acceleration components along the orthogonal axes X, Y, and Z These six-degree-of-freedom signals enable precise characterization of both translational and rotational dynamics By calculating the FFT of each column of this matrix, the frequency spectrum of the vibration component on each axis is obtained
Vibration Source Identification
The MPU6050 sensors were strategically installed at different locations on the telescope, as shown in Figure 4 (1) Two sensors were placed at the base of the telescope, where the greater distance from the support fork and the higher moment of inertia allow for better detection of high-energy vibrations (2) A sensor was positioned inside the telescope, adjacent to the detector, to capture vibrations that most significantly degrade astronomical images (3) Additional sensors were mounted near the declination motor and (4) the right ascension motor to monitor vibrations generated by these components Furthermore, sensors were also placed on the dome traction motors and on the air conditioning compressor located at the base of the CCD camera
Observed Vibrational Patterns
The analysis of raw astronomical images uncovers systematic elongation in stellar profiles, suggesting mechanical contributions to image degradation This effect becomes more evident when zooming in on individual stars, where it is clear that the point sources lack a circularly symmetric profile The observed elongation along a preferred axis instead suggests the influence of mechanical tracking errors or structural vibrations of the telescope
Structural and Mitigation Insights
An unexpected mechanical coupling was identified between the telescope base and the dome floor, possibly due to maintenance personnel sealing the gap without awareness of its critical role The drive bearing associated with motor 1 is located very close to the telescope base and is likely the primary source of the vibrations transmitted to the structure Repositioning each motor to the next bearing in the counterclockwise direction would increase the separation between motor 1 and the telescope base
Conclusion and Future Work
The use of IMUs proved to be a key component in the dynamic assessment of the system Based on our findings, we propose targeted actions to mitigate the effects of these vibrations We also recommend the permanent integration of IMU-based monitoring systems to provide real-time feedback to operators regarding vibrational conditions during observations The device developed in this study offers significant advantages compared to commercial solutions This capability makes the system not only a practical tool for the Schmidt Camera but a promising template for similar applications in heritage-class and modern observatories worldwide The work demonstrates the potential of inertial sensing as a practical, cost-effective, and robust approach for vibrational diagnostics in heritage-class telescopes
ACKNOWLEDGMENTS
We acknowledge the collaboration grant from INAOE awarded to Dr. Miguel Antonio Nieto-Suárez, as well as the support provided by the technicians of the Schmidt Camera in Tonantzintla, Agustín Márquez Limón and Guillermo Cerdán Hernández, which was essential for the realization of this study
REFERENCES
[1] Turner, H. W., et al. (1950). Herbig–Haro Objects and T-Tauri Stars from Tonantzintla
[2] Haro, G. & Chavira, E. (1950). Observaciones iniciales con la Cámara Schmidt de Tonantzintla
[3] Hashimoto, I., Chiba, M., Okada, N., et al. (2020). Wind- and Operation-Induced Vibration Measurements of the Main Reflector of the Nobeyama 45m dish.
arXiv:2003.05134
[4] Snel, R. C., Mangum, J. G., & Baars, J. W. M. (2007). Study of the Dynamics of Large Reflector Antennas with Accelerometers.
arXiv:0710.4254
[5] Lozi, J., Guyon, O., Jovanovic, N., et al. (2018). Characterizing Vibrations at the Subaru Telescope for SCExAO.
arXiv:1809.08296
[6] Byrnes, P. W. G., Hayward, T. L., & Chinn, B. (2020). Vibration measurements in astronomical observatories toward robust AO designs.
SPIE Proceedings, Vol. 11445
[7] McBride, W. R. & Stratton, M. (2018). Contemporary facilities such as the Daniel K. Inouye Solar Telescope (DKIST) and Extremely Large
Telescopes (ELTs) have adopted multi-layered vibration control techniques, including feedforward
correction using accelerometers, structural stiffening, and modal damping approaches [8,9].Vibration measurements in the Daniel K. Inouye Solar Telescope (DKIST). p. 1
SPIE Proceedings, Vol. 10700Where the paper says it
[8] Adams, D., Fordham, B., Jakob, G. H., et al. (2022). Management of Equipment Vibration for Extremely Large Telescopes.
JATIS, 8(2), 021512
[9] Bronowicki, A. J. (2003). A Layered Vibration Control Strategy for Space Telescopes.
SPIE, Vol. 5056
[10] François, B., Palacios, M., et al. (2021). Vibration Mitigation in Optical Telescopes: A Review.
Sensors, 21(11), 3613 https://doi.org/10.3390/s21113613
[11] Nieto-Suárez, M. A. (2023). Utilización de sensores inerciales en telescopios astronómicos.
Nthe, 43, 36–44 Available at: https://nthe.mx/detallesrev.php?id=69
[12] Nieto-Suárez, M. A. (2023). ScopeVibes: Mechanical Vibration Monitoring in Telescopes.
Available at: https://sites.google.com/view/scopevibes/home
[13] InvenSense Inc. (19 de 08 de 2013). MPU6050-DataSheet. p. 1 When applied to astronomical telescopes, IMUs allow the detection and quantification of vibrational motion
across multiple axes, providing insight into mechanical behavior under operational conditions. For this study, we selected the MPU6050 [13], a compact MEMS-based sensor combining a 3-axis
accelerometer and 3-axis gyroscope. Previous publications have highlighted the potential of these sensors
for observatory applications [10]. Furthermore, the present study builds on earlier work by the authors
focused on the integration of inertial systems in astronomical telescopes [11], as well as resources made
available through the ScopeVibes project, an ongoing initiative dedicated to structural monitoring in
observatories [12]. The
total number of files then depends on the data acquisition time, which can be subsequently processed
individually or averaged with other files, drastically reducing the level of random noise. By calculating the
FFT of each column of this matrix, the frequency spectrum of the vibration component on each axis is
obtained.Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
[14] Arduino UNO R3. (11 de 07 de 2023). A000066-datasheet.pdf Available at: A000066-datasheet. p. 1 Previous publications have highlighted the potential of these sensors
for observatory applications [10]. Furthermore, the present study builds on earlier work by the authors
focused on the integration of inertial systems in astronomical telescopes [11], as well as resources made
available through the ScopeVibes project, an ongoing initiative dedicated to structural monitoring in
observatories [12].Where the paper says it
Green — the paper says it, and the page is printed. Red — no passage carries it, so treat that sentence as unverified. The same check runs on your own text: check a summary against its source, $5.
Improvements for AI systems
-
Make AI systems capable of predictive modeling of image quality deterioration by using early knowledge of vibration amplitudes and frequencies to inform design decisions from the outset, as this enables
predictive modeling of image quality deterioration through numerical simulations.
-
Develop real-time diagnostic capabilities for heritage telescopes by integrating MEMS accelerometers with microcontrollers to provide
real time diagnostics and sensor-based feedback in maintaining image quality,
allowing for immediate identification of mechanical disturbances. -
Improve data filtering strategies for astronomical images by enabling AI systems to identify and filter out degraded frames based on quantified mechanical disturbances, as the paper suggests this is essential
to filter out the most degraded frames prior to image stacking and processing.
-
Enhance structural monitoring for observatories by creating open-source, low-cost vibration detection systems that can be
easily replicated and customized,
facilitating adistributed network of sensors for comprehensive monitoring of telescopes or other sensitive environments.
Abstract
Mechanical vibrations in astronomical telescopes can degrade image quality, making their detection and characterization essential. This work presents the development and validation of a low-cost, portable vibration monitoring system based on MEMS accelerometers interfaced with a microcontroller. The system integrates sensor acquisition and data analysis capabilities and was evaluated through controlled laboratory tests. The system was subsequently deployed at the historic Schmidt Camera of the Tonantzintla Astronomical Observatory in Mexico. After more than 80 years of operation, this study represents the first characterization of its mechanical vibrations. Preliminary measurements reveal dominant frequency components and their corresponding amplitudes, providing insight into the telescope's dynamic behavior and potential structural couplings that may affect image quality. Understanding the vibrational environment of astronomical telescopes is essential for the successful integration of new instrumentation. Identifying vibration frequencies and amplitudes can support the development of mitigation strategies, data filtering techniques, and numerical simulations to predict image quality degradation. The results demonstrate the feasibility of low-cost inertial sensing for monitoring heritage-class telescopes and provide a foundation for future instrumentation and preservation efforts at the Tonantzintla Observatory.
Sources
- Wind- and Operation-Induced Vibration Measurements of the Main Reflector of the Nobeyama 45 m Radio Telescope
- Study of the Dynamics of Large Reflector Antennas with Accelerometers
- Characterizing Vibrations at the Subaru Telescope for the Subaru Coronagraphic Extreme Adaptive Optics instrument
Related papers
- On-sky demonstration of a vector Zernike wavefront sensor in a cascaded adaptive optics system
- Euclid Data Release 1 (DR1): Calibration strategy and observations
- The General Antiparticle Spectrometer (GAPS) Antarctic Balloon Payload
- Detection and excision of radio-frequency interference in radio arrays
- Unified matched-filter and excess-power pipeline for gravitational-wave detector characterization
- Ushering in sub-arcsecond angular resolution observatories in the far-infrared: The case for a double-Fourier interferometer