M-SHIVA 1.0: A Relativistic Resistive MHD Code for Heavy-Ion Collisions, with Applications to Momentum Anisotropy and Joule Heating in QGP

arXiv:2611.13899 · nucl-th, hep-ph, physics.comp-ph · Submitted 2026-11-10 · Read on arXiv

Listen

Radio episode about this paper

Transcript

Introduction to the show: ident: Nuclear Theory. The day in nuclear theory: structure, reactions and the models behind them.

Kai: We're looking at the paper: "M-SHIVA 1.0: A Relativistic Resistive MHD Code for Heavy-Ion Collisions, with Applications to Momentum Anisotropy and Joule Heating in QGP".

Mira: Here's the gist of the paper. M-SHIVA 1.0 presents a (2 + 1)-dimensional relativistic resistive magnetohydrodynamics code for heavy-ion collisions in Cartesian and boost-invariant Milne coordinates The ratio of Joule heating to expansion cooling lies approximately in the range 10−14–10−11 for Pb+Pb collisions at 2.76 TeV, 10−8–10−5 for Au+Au collisions at 200 GeV and 10−7–10−4 at 62.4 GeV Code Development and Numerical Methodology The code, M-SHIVA 1.0, is a (2 + 1)-dimensional relativistic resistive magnetohydrodynamics code that treats inviscid dynamics and employs an implicit-explicit (IMEX) Runge–Kutta scheme for the stiff conductivity-dependent terms It uses a generalized Lagrange multiplier (GLM) formulation to preserve Maxwell constraints, which is necessary because truncation errors can generate non-zero values of the divergence of the magnetic field and of the Gauss law for the electric field The numerical implementation involves a two-step process where numerical fluxes are computed using a piecewise-linear total-variation-diminishing reconstruction with the minmod limiter These fluxes are then used to evolve the conserved variables in time via a finite-volume scheme Physical System Setup and Initialization The simulations investigate momentum anisotropy and electromagnetic energy transfer in an expanding quark–gluon plasma (QGP) Initial conditions are constructed using optical-Glauber matter profiles for the energy density and spectator-generated electromagnetic fields from Monte Carlo Glauber models for proton positions The evolution is performed in Milne coordinates, which is well suited for describing boost-invariant longitudinal expansion in high-energy heavy-ion collisions The initial electromagnetic fields are sourced exclusively by spectator protons, and the local temperature is obtained from the lattice-QCD EoS Benchmark Testing and Results The code is tested against several important benchmarks, including standard shock-tube, cylindrical-blast-wave and relativistic-rotor problems In Cartesian coordinates, the Brio–Wu shocktube test examines the one-dimensional shockcapturing capability of the HLL scheme and its approach to the ideal-relativistic MHD limit with increasing electrical conductivity In (2 + 1)-dimensional Cartesian coordinates, a strong cylindrical explosion test demonstrates numerical robustness in the presence of strong shocks, anisotropic magnetic stresses, and steep electromagnetic gradients Electromagnetic Energy Transfer Analysis The study separates the electromagnetic work into mechanical Lorentz-force work and irreversible Joule heating The decomposition of the total normalized momentum anisotropy into matter and electromagnetic contributions shows that the direct contribution from the electromagnetic field is the dominant effect, while the matter momentum anisotropy deviates only weakly from its zero-field evolution The irreversible Joule heating density QJ is a positive definite source that opposes the reduction of the matter internal energy caused by expansion For the collision energies considered, Joule heating produces no appreciable modification of the bulk thermal evolution The conductivity dependence of the matter and total momentum anisotropies, εM p and εtot p, is not appreciably affected within the considered range The present heavy-ion calculation primarily establishes the conductivity dependence of the electromagnetic energy transfer within the RRMHD framework The results suggest that Joule heating becomes increasingly important at still lower energies, such as those probed in the RHIC Beam Energy Scan and at FAIR and NICA Acknowledgments V.R.

Kai: acknowledges support from the ANRF Core Research Grant (grant no.

Mira: CRG/2023/001309) We would also like to thank Reghukrishnan Gangadharan for the valuable discussions K.S, and V.R also acknowledges Department of Atomic Energy (DAE), India for financial support The paper is 2611.13899.

Kai: EVERY sentence must end with a reference token.

Paper summary: Mira: So to wrap up this paper, M-SHIVA one point zero provides a framework for understanding momentum anisotropy and electromagnetic energy transfer in an expanding quark gluon plasma QGP one <ref:2611.13899#pg1,momentum anisotropy and electromagnetic energy transfer in an expanding quark gluon plasma>. The authors used the code to study how the fields affect the system when they are in an elliptic fireball setup one <ref:2611.13899#pg1>. It shows that the electromagnetic field's direct contribution to transverse stress tensor dominates over changes to matter anisotropy one <ref:2611.13899#pg1>.

Kai: The title itself, M-SHIVA one point zero: A Relativistic Resistive MHD Code for Heavy-Ion Collisions, with Applications to Momentum Anisotropy and Joule Heating in QGP, frames the whole thing perfectly one <ref:2611.13899#pg1,M-SHIVA 1.0: A Relativistic Resistive MHD Code for Heavy-Ion>. It’s not just solving the equations; it's specifically looking at how resistive heating compares to expansion cooling one <ref:2611.13899#pg1>.

Lev: What this means for us is that even though resistive heating gets bigger as you lower the collision energy, it still doesn't significantly alter the bulk thermal evolution of these systems one <ref:2611.13899#pg1>. This paper establishes the conductivity dependence of electromagnetic energy transfer within this specific resistive magnetohydrodynamics framework one <ref:2611.13899#pg1>.

Kai: It’s a solid piece of work because they connect the theoretical setup to concrete results from established benchmarks like shock tube and cylindrical blast wave problems one <ref:2611.13899#pg1>. It gives us a tool to look at these complex electromagnetic dynamics in an expanding background one <ref:2611.13899#pg1>.

Conclusion: Mira: So we’ve been looking at M-SHIVA one point zero, and now we’re getting to the wrap up on this paper about momentum anisotropy and Joule heating in a quark gluon plasma one.

Kai: The title itself says it's a resistive magnetohydrodynamics code for heavy-ion collisions, which means they built something that handles the fluid motion and the magnetic fields when there's some electrical resistance involved one.

Lev: Right, it’s not just ideal MHD; they’re dealing with finite conductivity terms in their equations, so we need to know how those stiff source terms behave on real hardware, which is where this code comes in one.

Mira: The authors use a (two + one) -dimensional setup in Milne coordinates, which is great because it handles that longitudinal expansion you see in these collisions really well one.

Kai: They tested it against some standard benchmarks like shock tubes and cylindrical blast waves to make sure the code itself is numerically stable before they applied it to the QGP stuff two.

Lev: And they used a generalized Lagrange multiplier formulation to keep those Maxwell constraints satisfied, which is crucial because numerical errors can easily mess up magnetic field divergence one.

Mira: The big result here is about how Joule heating compares to expansion cooling in an expanding quark gluon plasma one. It shows the ratio is very small, around ten to one hundred times smaller than the cooling effect one.

Kai: That means that while resistive heating gets bigger as the collision energy drops, it still doesn't change the overall thermal evolution of these systems significantly two.

Lev: For us on hardware, this suggests that if we were trying to model this on a real system, the overhead from tracking all those conductivity-dependent effects might be manageable at certain scales one.

Mira: So what does this mean for us in the big picture? It tells us that for these specific collision energies, you don't need to worry about resistive heating dominating the thermal dynamics one.

Kai: But it does set up a baseline; it shows exactly how much energy transfer happens through resistivity, which is important context before we look at lower energies two.

Krishanu Sengupta, Victor Roy

National Institute of Science Education and Research · Homi Bhabha National Institute

nucl-th, hep-ph, physics.comp-ph

Submitted: 2026-11-10

Updated: 2026-11-10

Comments: 32 pages, 16 figures, 4 tables

License: http://arxiv.org/licenses/nonexclusive-distrib/1.0/

Importance score: 76/100

The gist: M-SHIVA 1.0 presents a (2 + 1)-dimensional relativistic resistive magnetohydrodynamics code for heavy-ion collisions in Cartesian and boost-invariant Milne coordinates The ratio of Joule heating to…

Key concepts

Relativistic Resistive Magnetohydrodynamics (RRMHD)
This framework describes how charged fluids and magnetic fields interact in relativistic heavy-ion collisions. It solves coupled equations for fluid motion, energy conservation, and Maxwell's equations simultaneously. It is necessary because the conductivity of the plasma affects how these fields evolve over time.
Implicit-Explicit (IMEX) Scheme
This is a numerical method used to solve complex differential equations in the code. It handles stiff terms—like those related to high electrical conductivity—by treating them implicitly (more accurately) while treating the rest of the equations explicitly. This allows for stable and efficient simulation even when conductivity changes rapidly.
Joule Heating
Joule heating is a form of irreversible energy dissipation that occurs when an electric current flows through a resistive medium, like the quark-gluon plasma. In this study, it is separated from mechanical work to see how much it contributes to the total energy evolution during the collision.
Momentum Anisotropy
This refers to the uneven distribution of momentum within a fluid, meaning that particles move differently in different directions. The code investigates how electromagnetic fields influence this anisotropy and how energy moves between the matter and the electromagnetic field.

Terminology

Summary

M-SHIVA 1.0 presents a (2 + 1)-dimensional relativistic resistive magnetohydrodynamics code for heavy-ion collisions in Cartesian and boost-invariant Milne coordinates The ratio of Joule heating to expansion cooling lies approximately in the range 10−14–10−11 for Pb+Pb collisions at 2. p. 076 TeV, 10−8–10−5 for Au+Au collisions at 200 GeV and 10−7–10−4 at 62. p. 04 GeV

Code Development and Numerical Methodology

The code, M-SHIVA 1.0, is a (2 + 1)-dimensional relativistic resistive magnetohydrodynamics code that treats inviscid dynamics and employs an implicit-explicit (IMEX) Runge–Kutta scheme for the stiff conductivity-dependent terms It uses a generalized Lagrange multiplier (GLM) formulation to preserve Maxwell constraints, which is necessary because truncation errors can generate non-zero values of the divergence of the magnetic field and of the Gauss law for the electric field The numerical implementation involves a two-step process where numerical fluxes are computed using a piecewise-linear total-variation-diminishing reconstruction with the minmod limiter These fluxes are then used to evolve the conserved variables in time via a finite-volume scheme

Physical System Setup and Initialization

The simulations investigate momentum anisotropy and electromagnetic energy transfer in an expanding quark–gluon plasma (QGP) Initial conditions are constructed using optical-Glauber matter profiles for the energy density and spectator-generated electromagnetic fields from Monte Carlo Glauber models for proton positions The evolution is performed in Milne coordinates, which is well suited for describing boost-invariant longitudinal expansion in high-energy heavy-ion collisions The initial electromagnetic fields are sourced exclusively by spectator protons, and the local temperature is obtained from the lattice-QCD EoS

Benchmark Testing and Results

The code is tested against several important benchmarks, including standard shock-tube, cylindrical-blast-wave and relativistic-rotor problems In Cartesian coordinates, the Brio–Wu shocktube test examines the one-dimensional shockcapturing capability of the HLL scheme and its approach to the ideal-relativistic MHD limit with increasing electrical conductivity In (2 + 1)-dimensional Cartesian coordinates, a strong cylindrical explosion test demonstrates numerical robustness in the presence of strong shocks, anisotropic magnetic stresses, and steep electromagnetic gradients

Electromagnetic Energy Transfer Analysis

The study separates the electromagnetic work into mechanical Lorentz-force work and irreversible Joule heating The decomposition of the total normalized momentum anisotropy into matter and electromagnetic contributions shows that the direct contribution from the electromagnetic field is the dominant effect, while the matter momentum anisotropy deviates only weakly from its zero-field evolution The irreversible Joule heating density QJ is a positive definite source that opposes the reduction of the matter internal energy caused by expansion

Conclusion on Dissipation and Anisotropy

For the collision energies considered, Joule heating produces no appreciable modification of the bulk thermal evolution The conductivity dependence of the matter and total momentum anisotropies, εM p and εtot p, is not appreciably affected within the considered range The present heavy-ion calculation primarily establishes the conductivity dependence of the electromagnetic energy transfer within the RRMHD framework The results suggest that Joule heating becomes increasingly important at still lower energies, such as those probed in the RHIC Beam Energy Scan and at FAIR and NICA

Acknowledgments

V.R. acknowledges support from the ANRF Core Research Grant (grant no. p. 0 CRG/2023/001309) We would also like to thank Reghukrishnan Gangadharan for the valuable discussions K. p. 1S, and V.R also acknowledges Department of Atomic Energy (DAE), India for financial support The paper is 2611. p. 013899. EVERY sentence must end with a reference token. p. 5

--- Page 5 ---

M-SHIVA 1.0: A Relativistic Resistive MHD Code for Heavy-Ion Collisions, with Applications to Momentum Anisotropy and Joule Heating in QGP Krishanu Sengupta∗ and Victor Roy† School of Physical Sciences, National Institute of Science Education and Research, An OCC of Homi Bhabha National Institute, Jatni - 752050, India (Dated: November 11, 2026 We present M-SHIVA 1. p. 00 (Magneto-resistive Solver for Heavy Ions with finite-Volume Algorithms), a (2 + 1)-dimensional relativistic resistive magnetohydrodynamics code for heavy-ion collisions in Cartesian and boost-invariant Milne coordinates The present implementation treats inviscid dynamics and employs an implicit-explicit (IMEX) Runge–Kutta scheme for the stiff conductivitydependent terms, together with complementary primitive-variable recovery procedures and generalized Lagrange multiplier (GLM) divergence cleaning The code reproduces standard shock-tube, cylindrical-blast-wave and relativistic-rotor benchmarks We use the framework to investigate the momentum anisotropy and electromagnetic energy transfer in an expanding quark–gluon plasma (QGP) In a controlled elliptic-fireball setup, the electromagnetic field modifies the total momentum anisotropy mainly through its direct contribution to the transverse stress tensor, while the matter anisotropy is only weakly affected We further separate the electromagnetic work into mechanical Lorentz-force work and irreversible Joule heating Applications to Au+Au collisions at √sNN = 62. p. 04 and 200 GeV and Pb+Pb collisions at √sNN = 2. p. 076 TeV employ optical-Glauber matter profiles, spectator-generated electromagnetic fields, and a temperature-dependent electrical conductivity motivated by lattice-QCD results Increasing the conductivity enhances the early Ohmic response while accelerating the relaxation of the electric field The ratio of Joule heating to expansion cooling is approximately 10−14–10−11 for Pb+Pb collisions at 2. p. 076 TeV, 10−8 – 10−5 for Au+Au collisions at 200 GeV and 10−7 – 10−4 at 62. p. 04 GeV, with no appreciable conductivity dependence of the matter or total momentum anisotropy These results indicate that, although the relative importance of resistive heating grows by several orders of magnitude with decreasing collision energy, it remains energetically negligible compared with longitudinal expansion cooling for all systems considered

--- Page 7 ---

I. INTRODUCTION In relativistic heavy-ion collisions, the charged protons inside the colliding nuclei generate extremely intense electromagnetic fields during the earliest stages of the collision, with magnetic-field strengths typically estimated to be of order 10 18 G at RHIC energies and 10 19 G, or larger, at LHC energies [1–12] In non-central collisions the event-averaged field acquires a preferred direction perpendicular to the reaction plane, while event-byevent fluctuations of the proton positions produce fields of comparable magnitude even in central collisions [2, 9] The subsequent evolution of these initial strong fields depends not only on the sources (charged protons in the colliding nuclei) but also on the electrical response of the produced quark-gluon plasma (QGP) [13–17] A quantitatively controlled description of this evolution therefore requires a dynamical framework in which the fluid variables and the electromagnetic fields are evolved consistently at finite electrical conductivity Relativistic resistive magnetohydrodynamics (RRMHD) provides such a framework, in which one solves for the energy-momentum tensor of the combined field and matter (fluid) system self-consistently with the help of appropriate constitutive equations The numerical solution of RRMHD is challenging because the conductivity-dependent current in Ohm’s law introduces stiff source terms In the large-conductivity regime, a purely explicit method would require a time step much smaller than the usual Courant time step, scaling with the resistive relaxation time Implicitexplicit (IMEX) time integration avoids this restriction by treating the hyperbolic transport explicitly and the stiff electric-field relaxation implicitly A second numerical issue with RRMHD is the preservation of the Maxwell constraints In a finite-volume discretization, truncation errors can generate non-zero values of the divergence of the magnetic field (∇ · B ≠ 0) and of the Gauss law for the electric field (∇·E−q ≠ 0) We therefore use the standard generalized Lagrange multiplier (GLM) formulation, in which auxiliary fields ϕ and ψ propagate and damp constraint violations The present work develops M-SHIVA 1. p. 00 (Magnetoresistive Solver for Heavy Ions with finite-Volume Algorithms), a finite-volume RRMHD code in 2 + 1 dimenarXiv:2611. p. 013899v1 [nucl-th] 10 Nov 2026

--- Page 8 ---

sions in Cartesian and boost-invariant Milne coordinates, which has been tested and validated against several important benchmarks The conductivitydependent electric-field relaxation in Ampere’s law is treated implicitly through a local cell-wise update, while the hyperbolic transport and non-stiff source terms are evolved explicitly Particular attention is given to primitive-variable recovery: an inversion based on the Lorentz-boosted enthalpy Z = wγ squared is employed during the explicit evolution, while a complementary pressurebased inversion is applied after the implicit electric-field update The numerical implementation is examined using standard Cartesian benchmarks and a relativistic rotor in Milne coordinates, which test shock capturing, the resistive-to-ideal transition, multidimensional magnetic stresses, and transverse fluid–electromagnetic dynamics in an expanding background

--- Page 9 ---

II. RELATIVISTIC RESISTIVE MAGNETOHYDRODYNAMICS The primary equations of resistive relativistic magnetohydrodynamics (RRMHD) consist of the conservation of a current Nµ, conservation of the total energy–momentum tensor Tµν, and Maxwell’s equations for the electromagnetic fields Mathematically these equations are given as Nµ;µ = 0, (10) Tµν;µ = 0, (11) Fµν;µ = Jν, (12) F˜µν;µ = 0, (13) Here Nμ = nuμ is the current associated with a conserved quantity, uμ is the fluid four-velocity, and n is the corresponding density in the local rest frame of the fluid In heavy-ion collisions Nµ is naturally identified with the net-baryon current Several standard RRMHD benchmark problems, taken from the astrophysical literature, are instead formulated in terms of the rest-mass density together with an ideal-gas equation of state; for those tests we interpret n as the rest-mass density, n = m np, where np is the number density of a conserved species of mass m Tµν is the energymomentum tensor; Fµν is the Faraday tensor, and F˜µν its dual, which is defined as F˜µν = 1/2ϵ µναβFαβ with ϵ µναβ = (−g) −1/2 [µναβ] The energy-momentum tensor contains two terms: one corresponding to the matter part TµνM and the other due to the electromagnetic field Tµνf; hence we can write Tµν = TµνM +Tµνf For an ideal fluid, TµνM is defined as Tµnu M:= euμu ν − P ∆μν, (14) where e = Tµnu M uμu ν is the proper energy density (local rest frame) and P = -1/3∆μνTµnu M is the isotropic pressure of the fluid Further, if we ignore magnetization and polarization effects, then Tµνf:= -FµαFνα + 1/4 gµνFγβFβ Using (11) together with (15) and Maxwell’s equations (12), one can show that Tµnu M;µ = FναJα, i. p. 2e. the matter energy-momentum tensor is not separately conserved; the Lorentz four-force FναJα exchanges energy and momentum between the fluid and the electromagnetic field The Faraday tensor and its dual tensor are given as Fµν = Eµuν − Eνuµ + ϵ µναβuαBβ, (17) F˜µν = Bµuν − Bνuµ − ϵ µναβuαEβ Where Eµ = Fµnu uν and Bµ = F˜µnu uν are the electric and magnetic fields measured in the co-moving frame of the fluid, respectively, in the sense that Eµ and Bµ reduce to (0, E') and (0, B') in the local rest frame of the fluid If we decompose the fluid four-velocity as uµ = γ(1, v), where γ is the Lorentz factor, then the laboratory-frame electric field E and magnetic field B are related to Eµ and Bµ in the following way, Eµ = [γv · E, γE + γ(v × B)], (20) Bµ = [γv · B, γB − γ(v × E)].

--- Page 10 ---

The system of equations is closed by specifying an EoS together with Ohm’s law The equation of state relates the thermodynamic pressure, the proper energy density, and the conserved charge density, P:= P(e, n) (22) For an ideal gas, the EoS is given as P = (Γ − 1)(e − n), (23) where Γ is the adiabatic index and, following the standard convention of the astrophysical RRMHD benchmark problems, n is interpreted as the rest-mass density Here e includes both the rest-mass and internal-energy contributions in the local rest frame, so that e − n is the internal energy density In the ultra-relativistic(suitable for heavy ion collisions) limit n ≪ e, Eq. (23) reduces to P ≃ (Γ − 1)e, and therefore to the conformal equation of state P = e/3 for Γ = 4/3 For the heavy-ion simulations, we use either this conformal EoS or a latticeQCD EoS at vanishing baryon chemical potential [41] Ohm’s law is given as Jµ = σEµ + q0uµ, (24) where σ is the electrical conductivity (assumed isotropic), q0 = Jµuµ is the net local charge density of the fluid in the co-moving frame, and q = J 0 is the time component of the four-current in the laboratory frame The ideal-MHD limit corresponds to a very large magnetic Reynolds number, Rm >> 1, where Rm is defined as Rm = σµLU, where L denotes the characteristic length (or time) scale of the fluid (QGP), U is the characteristic flow velocity, and µ is the magnetic permeability of the fluid (QGP) [47] If we take σ → ∞ while keeping the other three quantities finite, we recover the ideal conditions: since the conduction current σEµ must remain finite in this limit, one requires Eµ = 0, which implies v ·E = 0 and E = −(v × B), matching the ideal-MHD conditions (Appendix A) p. 3

Green — the paper says it, and the page is printed. Red — no passage carries it, so treat that sentence as unverified. The same check runs on your own text: check a summary against its source, $5.

Improvements for AI systems

  1. Improved initialization of electromagnetic fields can be achieved by using the superposition of the fields generated by individual protons whose positions are sampled from a Monte Carlo Glauber model to set initial transverse electric and magnetic fields at midrapidity, as described in section VI B.

  2. The AI system can accurately predict the relaxation of the electric field in a finite-volume RRMHD framework by employing an implicit explicit IMEX Runge-Kutta scheme, specifically the SSP2(3,3,2) or SSP3(3,3,2) schemes mentioned in section H.

  3. The AI can perform primitive variable recovery using a Lorentz-boosted enthalpy inversion after the explicit step and a complementary pressure-based inversion after the implicit update to reconstruct physical state variables like density and pressure.

  4. The system can maintain Maxwell constraints in finite volume by introducing generalized Lagrange multiplier fields, which are evolved via telegrapher's equation to damp truncation errors, as detailed in section III A.

  5. The AI can determine the irreversible Joule heating contribution by decomposing the electromagnetic power into mechanical Lorentz-force work and non-negative Joule heating using the relation W dot E dot J equals W dot v fEM plus W dot QJ over gamma, as presented in section VII D.

Sources

Related papers