SHARP(ening the) view of unresolved globular clusters in ultra diffuse galaxies
Listen
Radio episode about this paper
Transcript
Introduction to the show: ident: Astrophysics. The day in astrophysics: observations, models and what the data forces.
Vera: I'm Vera.
Jocelyn: And I'm Jocelyn, here with Subrahmanyan.
Vera: We're looking at the paper: "SHARP(ening the) view of unresolved globular clusters in ultra diffuse galaxies".
Jocelyn: Here's the gist of the paper. Ultra-Diffuse Galaxies (UDGs) challenge current galaxy formation models within the ΛCDM framework, particularly regarding their dark matter content and formation histories In this work, we present the scientific potential of NEXUS@SHARP, a near-infrared multi-slit spectrograph proposed on the upcoming Extremely Large Telescope (ELT) We demonstrate that NEXUS is uniquely positioned to overcome current observational limitations by combining high spatial resolution with efficient multiplexing These capabilities will allow for precise measurements of radial velocities and stellar populations, enabling robust dynamical mass estimates and distinguishing between competing UDG formation scenario Scientific Rationale The efficiency with which galaxies convert their gas reservoirs into stars depends on their halo mass (Moster et al., 2013; Behroozi et al., 2013) In the absence of astrophysical processes, dark matter (DM) halos of all masses would be expected to contain a baryonic component consistent with the cosmological baryon fraction (Planck Collaboration et al., 2020), Ωb∕Ωm ∼ 0.17, meaning that roughly 17% of their total mass should initially be in the form of gas and, eventually, stars In practice, halos retain and convert only a fraction of these baryons into stars due to a variety of internal and external processes that regulate galaxy growth Gas accretion, radiative cooling, star formation, and feedback from supernovae and active galactic nuclei all modulate how much of the baryonic material can condense into galaxies Environmental mechanisms such as ram-pressure stripping and tidal interactions further reduce baryon retention, particularly in low-mass systems Halos with masses comparable to that of the Milky Way are thought to be the most efficient, converting about 20% of their baryons into stars At higher masses, internal and external processes suppress gas cooling, producing lower star-formation efficiencies in massive groups and clusters Conversely, dwarfscale halos retain only about 1–5% of their baryons in stars; this drop is mainly driven by stellar feedback and the halos’ shallow potential wells, which make it easier for gas to escape (Bullock & Boylan-Kolchin, 2017) Tracing Formation Scenarios The origin of UDGs remains an open question, with two main formation scenarios One proposed scenario is that UDGs are "failed" massive galaxies, L∗ systems quenched early (z ∼ 2), which preserved dwarf-like stellar masses within relatively massive halos These galaxies would thus appear red, old, metal-poor, DM dominated, and host unusually rich globular cluster (GC) population (van Dokkum et al., 2015, 2016) Alternatively, UDGs may be "puffed-up" dwarfs, genuinely low-mass galaxies that have expanded due to feedback or environmental processes (Amorisco & Loeb, 2016; Di Cintio et al., 2017; Carleton et al., 2019; Benavides et al., 2023; Zheng et al., 2025) Relative to the previous scenario, such objects are expected to be bluer, exhibit extended star formation histories, and have DM content and GC population, resembling those of typical dwarfs There are also other ways to form UDGs such as external mechanisms including galaxy interactions, mergers, and environmental stripping (e.g., Ivleva et al., 2024) These scenarios yield blue, dusty, star-forming UDGs with low metallicities, little or no DM, and significant UV emission Possible origins include collisional debris from galaxy mergers (Lelli et al., 2015), like tidal dwarf galaxies, or gas clumps stripped by ram pressure from infalling systems (Yozin & Bekki, 2015; Poggianti et al., 2019; Junais et al., 2022; Ivleva et al., 2024) GC Population Diagnostics Studying the GC population of UDGs, especially estimating the number of GCs in such systems, serves as a valuable diagnostic tool to investigate the formation pathways of the UDGs (see Sect.
Vera: 1) GCs are ancient (t ≳ 8 Gyr), compact stellar systems with typical half-light radii of re ∼ 2.5 pc, formed during the early phases of galaxy assembly when intense star formation favored the creation of massive clusters (Larsen & Richtler, 2000; Brodie & Strader, 2006; Forbes et al., 2018a) The total number of GCs in a galaxy correlates with its halo mass (Blakeslee et al., 1997; Harris et al., 2017; Burkert & Forbes, 2020), and is thus providing an indirect tracer of its DM content The velocity dispersion derived from the motions of GCs enables direct estimates of DM content, as higher dispersions generally point to more massive halos (Toloba et al., 2023; Buzzo et al., 2025b; Haacke et al., 2025) SHARP Capabilities and Requirements SHARP is a near-infrared (0.95 − 2.45 μm) spectrograph (Saracco et al., 2025; Mahmoodzadeh et al., 2025) specifically designed to leverage the capabilities of MCAO2-assisted observations at the ESO’s Extremely Large Telescope (ELT), through the MORFEO adaptive optics system (Ciliegi et al., 2021) NEXUS achieves spectral resolutions of R∼6000, ∼2000, or ∼300, making it flexible for both kinematic and stellar population studies NEXUS results to be ideally suited for GC studies in UDGs because it combines high spatial resolution, thanks to AO correction with efficient multiplexing Its multislit capability allows simultaneous observation of multiple GCs within the typically compact fields of UDGs, substantially improving observational efficiency By enabling the systematic spectroscopic survey of GCs in low-surface-brightness systems, NEXUS@SHARP will act as a definitive tool for constraining the formation channels of the most elusive galaxy populations in the local universe This combination of accurate NGC measurements and dynamical mass determinations allows for a self-consistent evaluation of the scaling relation within the same dataset Agreement between the halo masses inferred from GC counts and from dynamical modeling would reinforce the validity of the scaling relation in UDGs Any systematic discrepancies would immediately point to a breakdown of this relation, offering new physical insight into GC formation efficiency, halo assembly, and baryon–DM coupling in low-density galaxy environments By enabling the systematic spectroscopic survey of GCs in low-surface-brightness systems, NEXUS@SHARP will act as a definitive tool for constraining the formation channels of the most elusive galaxy populations in the local universe Acknowledgments The SHARP team acknowledges support by Bando Ricerca Fondamentale INAF 2022, Techno-Grant "SHARP" - 1.05.12.02.01 and Bando Ricerca Fondamentale INAF 2024, Large-Grant "SHARP" - 1.05.24.01.01 Part of this work was supported through the INAF “Astrofisica Fondamentale” GO-grant 2024 n.
Jocelyn: 12 (PI: M.
Vera: Cantiello) The authors thank Gannon et al.
Title and authors: Vera: So we're diving into the title and who wrote this paper, "SHARP(ening the) view of unresolved globular clusters in ultra diffuse galaxies." It sounds like a technical project, but the goal is pretty direct: improving our view of these tricky galaxies.
Jocelyn: The authors are a team from different parts of astronomy—lots of people working on surveys and spectroscopy, which makes sense given what they’re trying to measure. They’ve put together an argument for how specific observational capabilities can unlock this kind of detailed study.
Subrahmanyan: From a theoretical side, this is interesting because it ties directly into the bottom-up assembly picture where small dark matter halos collapse first, and we need these observations to see which pathway those low-mass systems took.
Vera: The paper points out that understanding how galaxies form depends on processes like gas accretion and feedback, and when you look at ultra diffuse galaxies, those physical processes are really hard to constrain because the physics in simulations is so uncertain.
Jocelyn: And that uncertainty is what makes the globular clusters such a good diagnostic tool here. They’re ancient systems, about eight gigayears old or more, which means they formed during a very specific early phase of galaxy assembly.
Subrahmanyan: Because those early phases are where the fundamental differences between forming a massive galaxy and a dwarf galaxy really start to show up in the resulting stellar populations.
The paper's summary: Vera: So, what’s the actual summary of this paper? Simply put, they are arguing that to figure out if an ultra diffuse galaxy is a "failed" massive galaxy or a "puffed-up" dwarf, you need to look at two things: the stellar population and the dark matter content.
Jocelyn: They stress that globular clusters act like fossils in this context. They don't just give you a single number; they trace the entire history of the halo mass and how it moved dynamically over time.
Subrahmanyan: Specifically, they focus on how you can use the properties of these GCs—like their numbers and their velocity dispersions—as a direct diagnostic tool to distinguish between those competing formation scenarios.
Vera: And this paper is proposing that by comparing the halo masses inferred from counting these clusters with the mass estimates we get from dynamical modeling, we can test if our understanding of how dark matter couples with baryons holds up in these low-density environments.
Jocelyn: The paper highlights that GCs are compact systems, with a half light radius around two point five parsecs, and their total number relates directly to the halo mass.
Subrahmanyan: And if those scaling relations hold true when you look at UDGs, it gives us confidence in our model of how baryons settle within these dark matter halos over cosmic time.
The paper's improvements: Vera: Now let’s talk about what the authors suggest to improve things. They are pushing for a coherent analysis that looks at both the stellar populations and the dark matter content simultaneously, which is something they feel is missing in previous studies.
Jocelyn: So, one key improvement they suggest is using a combined analysis framework, like what was done in the Lewis survey in Hydra I, but applying that specifically to UDGs. They want to look at the GCs and field stars together.
Subrahmanyan: And from a theoretical viewpoint, this means we are asking for observations that can provide constraints on both the gravitational potential—which comes from the dark matter—and the star formation history derived from those stellar populations.
Vera: And what they really want is to test a specific prediction: if it’s a failed massive galaxy scenario, then the field stars and the GCs should have similar ages and metallicities.
Jocelyn: Whereas if it’s that "puffed-up" dwarf origin, they suggest those globular clusters are expected to be systematically more metal-poor than the rest of the host galaxy's stellar population.
Conclusion: Vera: So, wrapping this up, the paper on "SHARP(ening the) view of unresolved globular clusters in ultra diffuse galaxies" suggests that by measuring these specific properties—the ages and metallicities of GCs versus field stars—we can start to constrain which formation channel is at play.
Jocelyn: It’s a powerful diagnostic because it links the ancient history recorded in those clusters to the current structure of the galaxy, which helps us test our models about how dark matter and baryons interact in these low-density environments.
Subrahmanyan: If we see agreement between the halo masses we count from GCs and what our dynamical modeling predicts, that really reinforces the scaling relation for these systems. Any major discrepancies would signal a breakdown in how we think about baryon-dark matter coupling or GC formation efficiency at play here.
Vera: So, to sum up this work on ultra diffuse galaxies and globular clusters, it’s a call for more detailed observational data that allows us to move beyond just looking at the galaxy shape and start probing its internal assembly history.
Jocelyn: It sets up a clear path forward by showing exactly what kind of information we need to collect from instruments like NEXUS at the ELT to make those comparisons possible.
Subrahmanyan: We’re excited to see if these observations can provide the constraints needed to refine our simulations of galaxy formation and structure across all mass scales.
Marco Mirabile, Michele Cantiello, Benedetta Di Francescoa, Ivan Di Antonioa, Gianluca Di Ricoa, Chiara Buttitta déi Francesco, Marco Gullieuszik f, Johanna Hartke g h i, Enrichetta Iodiced and Maurizio Paolillod e
INAF Osservatorio Astronomico d’Abruzzo · European Southern Observatory · Gran Sasso Science Institute · INAF – Astronomical Observatory of Capodimonte · University of Naples “Federico IIéi Francesco, C.U. Monte Sant肨ngelo, Via Cinthia
astro-ph.IM, astro-ph.GA
Submitted: 2026-11-04
Updated: 2026-11-04
Comments: 9 pages, 3 figures, 1 table. Paper published on New Astronomy
Journal ref: New Astronomy, Volue 129, Article 102620, year 2026
DOI: 10.1016/j.newast.2026.102620 10.1016/j.newast.2026.102620
License: http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
Importance score: 83/100
The gist: Ultra-Diffuse Galaxies (UDGs) challenge current galaxy formation models within the ΛCDM framework, particularly regarding their dark matter content and formation histories In this work…
Key concepts
- Ultra-Diffuse Galaxies (UDGs)
- These are galaxies that are very faint and have a large size relative to their luminosity. They challenge standard galaxy formation models because their dark matter content seems inconsistent with typical galaxy growth patterns, making them important objects to study.
- Formation Scenarios
- The paper explores two main ways UDGs might have formed: either they are 'failed' massive galaxies that stopped forming stars early, or they are 'puffed-up' low-mass dwarfs. These different origins suggest vastly different physical processes shaped their structure and stellar populations.
- Globular Cluster (GC) Population Diagnostics
- GCs are ancient, compact star systems found in galaxies. Their total number correlates with the galaxy's halo mass, providing an indirect way to measure dark matter content. Analyzing their ages and metallicities helps trace the history of the galaxy's assembly.
- Dynamical Mass Estimates
- Using the motions of GCs, specifically their velocity dispersion, researchers can calculate estimates of the total dark matter content in a galaxy's halo. This is a key tool for testing how galaxies grow and to compare theoretical models with actual observations.
Summary
Ultra-Diffuse Galaxies (UDGs) challenge current galaxy formation models within the ΛCDM framework, particularly regarding their dark matter content and formation histories In this work, we present the scientific potential of NEXUS@SHARP, a near-infrared multi-slit spectrograph proposed on the upcoming Extremely Large Telescope (ELT) We demonstrate that NEXUS is uniquely positioned to overcome current observational limitations by combining high spatial resolution with efficient multiplexing These capabilities will allow for precise measurements of radial velocities and stellar populations, enabling robust dynamical mass estimates and distinguishing between competing UDG formation scenario
Scientific Rationale
The efficiency with which galaxies convert their gas reservoirs into stars depends on their halo mass (Moster et al., 2013; Behroozi et al. p. 0 Scientific Rationale
The efficiency with which galaxies convert their gas
reservoirs into stars depends on their halo mass (Moster
et al. , 2013; Behroozi et al. , 2013; Behroozi et al. In the absence of astrophysical processes, dark matter (DM) halos of all masses
would be expected to contain a baryonic component consistent with the cosmological baryon fraction (Planck Collaboration et al. In the absence of astrophysical processes, dark matter (DM) halos of all masses
would be expected to contain a baryonic component consistent with the cosmological baryon fraction (Planck Collaboration et al. , 2020), Ω𝑏∕Ω𝑚 ∼ 0.Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Tracing Formation Scenarios
The origin of UDGs remains an open question, with two main formation scenarios One proposed scenario is that UDGs are Alternatively, UDGs may be "puffed-up" dwarfs, genuinely
low-mass galaxies that have expanded due to feedback or environmental processes (Amorisco & Loeb, 2016; Di Cintio
et al. , 2017; Carleton et al. , 2017; Carleton et al. , 2019; Benavides et al. , 2019; Benavides et al. , 2023;
Zheng et al. , 2023;
Zheng et al. Relative to the previous scenario, such
objects are expected to be bluer, exhibit extended star formation histories, and have DM content and GC population,
resembling those of typical dwarfs. There are also other ways to form UDGs such as external mechanisms including galaxy interactions, mergers, and
environmental stripping (e. , Ivleva et al. , 2022; Ivleva et al. p. 1 , 2019; Junais et al. , 2022; Ivleva et al. , 2024) Possible
origins include collisional debris from galaxy mergers (Lelli
et al. , 2015), like tidal dwarf galaxies, or gas clumps stripped
by ram pressure from infalling systems (Yozin & Bekki,
2015; Poggianti et al. , 2015), like tidal dwarf galaxies, or gas clumps stripped
by ram pressure from infalling systems (Yozin & Bekki,
2015; Poggianti et al. , 2019; Junais et al.failed
massive galaxies, L∗ systems quenched early (z ∼ 2), which preserved dwarf-like stellar masses within relatively massive halos These galaxies would thus appear red, old, metal-poor, DM dominated, and host unusually rich globular cluster (GC) population (van Dokkum et al., 2015, 2016) Alternatively, UDGs may be puffed-up
dwarfs, genuinely low-mass galaxies that have expanded due to feedback or environmental processes (Amorisco & Loeb, 2016; Di Cintio et al., 2017; Carleton et al. p. 1Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
GC Population Diagnostics
Studying the GC population of UDGs, especially estimating the number of GCs in such systems, serves as a valuable diagnostic tool to investigate the formation pathways of the UDGs (see Sect. 1) GCs are ancient (t ≳ 8 Gyr), compact stellar systems with typical half-light radii of re ∼ 2. p. 2 , 2025a)
1. Globular cluster properties
GCs are ancient (𝑡 ≳ 8 Gyr), compact stellar systems
with typical half-light radii of 𝑟𝑒 ∼ 2. Globular cluster properties
GCs are ancient (𝑡 ≳ 8 Gyr), compact stellar systems
with typical half-light radii of 𝑟𝑒 ∼ 2. 5 pc, formed during the early phases of galaxy assembly when intense star
formation favored the creation of massive clusters (Larsen
& Richtler, 2000; Brodie & Strader, 2006; Forbes et al. ,
2020; Saifollahi et al. The total number of GCs
in a galaxy correlates with its halo mass (Blakeslee et al. The total number of GCs
in a galaxy correlates with its halo mass (Blakeslee et al. ,
1997; Harris et al. Spectroscopic studies of GCs provide valuable constraints on the evolutionary pathways of UDGs by measuring
kinematic signatures that can indicate the influence of tidal
interactions and environmental effects (Toloba et al. The velocity dispersion derived from the motions of GCs enables direct estimates of DM content, as higher dispersions
generally point to more massive halos (Toloba et al. The velocity dispersion derived from the motions of GCs enables direct estimates of DM content, as higher dispersions
generally point to more massive halos (Toloba et al. , 2023;
Buzzo et al. , 2023;
Buzzo et al. , 2025b; Haacke et al.Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
SHARP Capabilities and Requirements
SHARP is a near-infrared (0.95 − 2.45 μm) spectrograph (Saracco et al. p. 4 Perspectives with SHARP
SHARP is a near-infrared (0. 45 𝜇𝑚) spectrograph (Saracco et al. 45 𝜇𝑚) spectrograph (Saracco et al. , 2025; Mahmoodzadeh et al. , 2025; Mahmoodzadeh et al. , 2025)
specifically designed to leverage the capabilities of MCAO2
-
assisted observations at the ESO’s Extremely Large Telescope (ELT), through the MORFEO adaptive optics system (Ciliegi et al.Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Conclusion
By enabling the systematic spectroscopic survey of GCs in low-surface-brightness systems, NEXUS@SHARP will act as a definitive tool for constraining the formation channels of the most elusive galaxy populations in the local universe This combination of accurate NGC measurements and dynamical mass determinations allows for a self-consistent evaluation of the scaling relation within the same dataset Agreement between the halo masses inferred from GC counts and from dynamical modeling would reinforce the validity of the scaling relation in UDGs Any systematic discrepancies would immediately point to a breakdown of this relation, offering new physical insight into GC formation efficiency, halo assembly, and baryon–DM coupling in low-density galaxy environments By enabling the systematic spectroscopic survey of GCs in low-surface-brightness systems, NEXUS@SHARP will act as a definitive tool for constraining the formation channels of the most elusive galaxy populations in the local universe
Acknowledgments
The SHARP team acknowledges support by Bando Ricerca Fondamentale INAF 2022, Techno-Grant 01 and Bando Ricerca Fondamentale INAF
2024, Large-Grant "SHARP" - 1. Part of this
work was supported through the INAF “Astrofisica Fondamentale” GO-grant 2024 n. MM
acknowledges support form the ESO Studentship Program. The authors thank Gannon et al.SHARP
- 1.05.12.02.01 and Bando Ricerca Fondamentale INAF 2024, Large-Grant SHARP
- 1.05.24.01.01 Part of this work was supported through the INAF “Astrofisica Fondamentale” GO-grant 2024 n. p. 7Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Green — the paper says it, and the page is printed. Red — no passage carries it, so treat that sentence as unverified. The same check runs on your own text: check a summary against its source, $5.
Improvements for AI systems
-
Improved system can perform robust dynamical mass estimates by obtaining
radial velocities
from globular clusters using NEXUS@SHARP observations, which are crucial fordistinguishing between competing UDG formation scenario.
-
Improved system can test the empirical scaling relation between GC number and halo mass by comparing halo masses inferred from GC counts with those derived from dynamical modeling, allowing for a
self-consistent evaluation of the scaling relation within the same dataset.
-
Improved system can discriminate between UDG formation channels by comparing
GC ages and metallicities with those of the host galaxy stellar population,
specifically identifying that in the failed-galaxy scenarioGCs and field stars should show similar ages and metallicities, whereas in a puffed-up/diffuse dwarf origin GCs are expected to be systematically more metal-poor than the host stellar population.
Abstract
Ultra-Diffuse Galaxies (UDGs) challenge current galaxy formation models within the ΛCDM framework, particularly regarding their dark matter content and formation histories. Globular Clusters (GCs) serve as excellent tracers for probing the halos of these faint systems; however, current spectroscopic facilities struggle to reach the depth required to fully characterize GC populations beyond the local neighborhood. In this work, we present the scientific potential of NEXUS@SHARP, a near-infrared multi-slit spectrograph proposed on the upcoming Extremely Large Telescope (ELT). We demonstrate that NEXUS is uniquely positioned to overcome current observational limitations by combining high spatial resolution with efficient multiplexing. We show that NEXUS can efficiently help to characterize the GC population in UDGs across diverse environments out to 60 to 70 Mpc - with a few hours of ELT time. These capabilities will allow for precise measurements of radial velocities and stellar populations, enabling robust dynamical mass estimates and distinguishing between competing UDG formation scenario.
Sources
- VEGAS-SSS: An intra-group component in the globular cluster system of NGC 5018 group of galaxies using VST data
- Euclid: Early Release Observations -- Dwarf galaxies in the Perseus galaxy cluster
- Looking into the faintEst WIth MUSE (LEWIS): Exploring the nature of ultra-diffuse galaxies in the Hydra-I cluster. VI. A star-forming UDG in Hydra I: a rare UDG or a transition phase?
- Euclid: Early Release Observations -- Globular clusters in the Fornax galaxy cluster, from dwarf galaxies to the intracluster field
- SHARP: Beyond JWST -- Revealing the galaxy birth and growth with the resolution of the ELT
- Ultra-diffuse galaxies in the EAGLE simulation
- NGC5846-UDG1: A galaxy formed mostly by star formation in massive, extremely dense clumps of gas
Related papers
- On-sky demonstration of a vector Zernike wavefront sensor in a cascaded adaptive optics system
- Euclid Data Release 1 (DR1): Calibration strategy and observations
- The General Antiparticle Spectrometer (GAPS) Antarctic Balloon Payload
- Detection and excision of radio-frequency interference in radio arrays
- Unified matched-filter and excess-power pipeline for gravitational-wave detector characterization
- Ushering in sub-arcsecond angular resolution observatories in the far-infrared: The case for a double-Fourier interferometer