A New Precise Measurement of the e+e-to pi+ pi-(gamma) Cross Section with the Initial-State Radiation Method at BaBar
Listen
Radio episode about this paper
Transcript
Introduction to the show: ident: High Energy Physics: Experiment. The day in high-energy experiment: detectors, searches and limits.
Kai: We're looking at the paper: "A New Precise Measurement of the e+e-to pi+ pi-(gamma) Cross Section with the Initial-State Radiation Method at BaBar".
Mira: Here's the gist of the paper. We report precise results for the e+e- to pi+ pi-(gamma) cross section in the energy range between threshold and 1.4 GeV, which is relevant for the hadronic vacuum polarization contribution to the muon g-2 prediction.
Kai: This measurement utilizes the full 460 fb-1 of on- and off- upsilon(4S) data.
Mira: The cross section is derived from a ratio of pi+ pi- to mu+ mu- initial-state radiation (ISR) events, a method where many systematic uncertainties cancel.
Kai: The ISR method deduces the cross section for a process at the reduced energy sqrt s' = m X, where X can be any final state, such as mu+ mu- or pi+ pi-, from a measurement of the radiative process e+e- to X gamma, where the photon is emitted by one of the initial e+ or e- particles.
Title and authors: Kai: So the title itself tells you a lot, it’s about a new precise measurement of that specific cross section using an initial-state radiation method at BaBar. It suggests they’ve found a way to get much cleaner data than before.
Mira: Exactly. And the authors are listed as J P Lees and his team, which is the group that actually built and analyzed this data from the BaBar experiment at SLAC. They’re basically telling us they’ve improved how we calculate this process because of their method.
Lev: From an error-correction standpoint, what I'm looking for is how much precision they actually achieved in their final result when you translate that cross section measurement into something usable for our real hardware experiments.
Kai: Well, the core idea here is using a ratio of pion to muon initial-state radiation events. This technique cancels out a lot of systematic uncertainties, which is huge for the final number we get.
Mira: Right, and what's interesting is that this method allows them to determine the cross section at a reduced energy, or s prime equals m X, where X can be any final state like muon pair or pion pair.
The paper's summary: Kai: The summary basically boils down to how they use this initial-state radiation method to deduce the cross section for a process at a reduced energy, s prime equals m X, from measuring the radiative process e plus e minus to X gamma.
Mira: That’s because the relationship is defined by an equation that links the number of events at that reduced energy to an effective ISR luminosity and the cross section at that energy, which is what they call Equation one.
Lev: I'm thinking about the practical side here; if you do this ratio method, it means many things cancel out automatically, like the dependence on BABAR luminosity and even vacuum polarization corrections.
Kai: It also means their determination of the ISR luminosity comes from muon data independently, which isn't dependent on a theoretical calculation for how many additional ISR photons there might be.
Mira: And they also state that the ISR photon efficiency cancels out, so it’s a very robust way to handle those kinds of uncertainties in this specific measurement.
The paper's improvements: Kai: One big improvement they point out is fitting the angular distributions in each mass bin to separate contributions from different final states like pions, muons, kaons, and electrons. They use the angle theta star X as the angle for each X component in the center-of-mass frame with respect to that ISR photon direction.
Mira: That separation method requires good sensitivity at large values of cosine theta star pi, which means they need to detect particles with low momenta in order to get those signals right.
Lev: From my side, that implies a real hardware challenge; you need excellent tracking and low momentum resolution to distinguish those different components when you’re trying to reconstruct the final state.
Kai: And they restrict their analysis specifically to the pion pair mass interval between zero point three and one point four giga electron volts. That's their specific focus for this part of the study.
Mira: So, it's a targeted approach, focusing on that specific energy window where the hadronic vacuum polarization contribution becomes important for muon g-two.
Conclusion: Kai: So to wrap up, the paper shows how they used this new method to combine results and get a final contribution to the anomalous magnetic moment of the muon from that pion plus pion gamma cross section.
Mira: The leading order hadronic contribution they calculated using their new two thousand twenty six and combined two thousand nine and two thousand twenty six BaBar measurements in the energy range of zero point three to one point four giga electron volts is five hundred twenty-five point nine plus or minus three point five statistical and plus or minus three point eight systematic units in units of negative ten to the tenth.
Lev: That result is derived by first getting the unblinded energy spectrum of the pion plus pion process using that initial state radiation method, which gives them a cross section consistent with QED predictions for the muon pair process, which they fit at zero point nine nine two zero plus or minus zero point three statistical and plus or minus forty three times BABAR luminosity units.
Kai: And then they use that to determine the pion plus pion gamma cross section, leading to a final combined result of five hundred seventeen point eight with uncertainties of two point four statistical and plus or minus three point three systematic units in negative ten to the tenth across that common energy range.
Mira: They also note that the total systematic uncertainty amounts to zero point seven two percent for the full energy range, and they break it down further into zero point seven two percent, two point four percent, zero point five six percent, and three point two percent in specific sub-regions of the energy spectrum.
Lev: For me, it’s important that they explicitly state those limitations because you can’t just take a number without knowing where it stops working. This measurement is highly dependent on getting those specific efficiency determinations right.
J. P. Lees, V. Poireau, V. Tisserand, E. Grauges, A. Palano, G. Eigen, D. N. Brown, Yu. G., К Kolomensky, ూ Fritsch, H., * R., Ч Cheaib, C., T. S. Mattison, J. A., ౝ McKenna, R. Y. So, V. E. Blinov, A. R., П Druzhinin, E. A., К Kravchenko, S. I., Ч Serednyakov, Yu. I., Ш Skovpen, E. P. Solodov, K. Yu., A. J. Lankford, B., П Dey, J. W., O. Long, A. M., К Eisner, W. S., Ш Panduro Vazquez, D. S., C. H., B. Echenard, K. T., D. G., И Hitlin, Y. Li, D. X., ౝ Middleton, T. S., ు Miyashita, P. Ongmongkolkul, J. Oyang, F. C., M. Rohrken, B. T., Н Sokoloff, J. G., Ш Bernard, M. Verderi, D., К Garzia, E. Luppi, V. Santoro, A. Calcaterra, R., π de Sangro, G. Finocchiaro, S., Ч Martellotti, P. Patteri, I. M., П Peruzzi, M. Piccolo, M. Rotondo, A., ρ Passaggio, C., ς Patrignani, B. J., И Lacker, B. Bhuyan, Н Mallik, * C., J. Cochran, S. Prell, A. V., З Gritsan, N., M. Davier, F., ρ Le Diberder, A. M., Ш Lutz, G. Wormser, Ч Zhang, D. J., Н Lange, D. M., J. P. Coleman, D. E., К Payne, C., A. J., ρ Bevan, M Bona, F Di Lodovico, G Cowan, * Sw., Ш Banerjee, D. N. Brown, C. L., W Gradl, З Griessinger, A Hafner, K. R., Ч Barlow, * G D Lafferty, R. Cenci, A Jawahery, D A Roberts, * R Cowan, S. H. Robertson, R M Seddon, N Neri, * F Palombo
BABAR Collaboration
hep-ex
Submitted: 2026-11-03
Updated: 2026-11-03
Comments: 56 pages, 73 figures, and 6 tables
License: http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
Importance score: 91/100
The gist: We report precise results for the e+e- to pi+ pi-(gamma) cross section in the energy range between threshold and 1.4 GeV…
Key concepts
- Initial-State Radiation (ISR) Method
- This technique uses the ratio of $\pi^+\pi^-$ to $\mu^+\mu^-$ events to determine the cross section at a reduced energy ($\sqrt{s'}$). This cancels many systematic uncertainties, making it a powerful way to extract the desired cross section from radiative processes.
- Angular Distribution Fitting
- The method fits the angular distributions of final state particles in different mass bins. By analyzing these distributions using an angle $\theta^*_X$, researchers can statistically separate contributions from different particle types like pions, muons, and kaons.
- Unfolding Method
- To recover the true underlying distribution of the process as a function of reduced energy ($\sqrt{s'}$), an iterative unfolding method is used. This involves using response matrices derived from simulations to correct for detector effects and obtain accurate physical distributions.
- $g-2$ Contribution
- The measured cross section feeds into the calculation of the hadronic vacuum polarization contribution to the muon's anomalous magnetic moment ($g-2$). This measurement provides a precise leading-order hadronic contribution in the 0.3–1.4 GeV energy range.
Terminology
Summary
We report precise results for the e+e- to pi+ pi-(gamma) cross section in the energy range between threshold and 1. p. 0 Latham, and S. Wu
(The BABAR Collaboration)
We report precise results for the 𝑒
+
𝑒
− → 𝜋
+𝜋
−
(𝛾) cross section in the energy range between threshold and
1. Wu
(The BABAR Collaboration)
We report precise results for the 𝑒
+
𝑒
− → 𝜋
+𝜋
−
(𝛾) cross section in the energy range between threshold and
1. 4 GeV, relevant for the hadronic vacuum polarization contribution to the muon 𝑔 − 2 prediction. 4 GeV, relevant for the hadronic vacuum polarization contribution to the muon 𝑔 − 2 prediction. Using the
full 460 fb−1 of on- and off-𝛶(4𝑆) data, the cross section is derived from the ratio of 𝜋
+𝜋
−
to 𝜇
+𝜇
−
initial-state
radiation (ISR) events, in which many systematic uncertainties cancel. 4 GeV, relevant for the hadronic vacuum polarization contribution to the muon 𝑔 − 2 prediction. Using the
full 460 fb−1 of on- and off-𝛶(4𝑆) data, the cross section is derived from the ratio of 𝜋
+𝜋
−
to 𝜇
+𝜇
−
initial-state
radiation (ISR) events, in which many systematic uncertainties cancel.Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
The ISR method deduces the cross section for a process at the reduced energy sqrt s' = m X, where X can be any final state, such as mu+ mu- or pi+ pi-, from a measurement of the radiative process e+e- to X gamma, where the photon is emitted by one of the initial e+ or e- particles. The cross section is related to the sqrt s' spectrum of e+e- to X gamma events through Equation (1):
dN n X gamma over d sqrt s' = dL eff ISR over d sqrt s' E n X gamma(sqrt s') sigma 0 X(sqrt s'),
where the details of the procedure are provided later. Several advantages stem from taking the pi+ pi- to mu+ mu- ratio as a function of sqrt s': "the result is independent of the BABAR luminosity L ee; • the determination of the ISR luminosity comes from muon data, independently of the number of additional ISR photons, thus not depending on a theoretical calculation; • the ISR photon efficiency cancels out; • vacuum polarization also cancels out."
The new method involves fitting angular distributions in each mass bin to obtain contributions from different components X = pi/mu/K/e of the generic process e+e- to X+X-gamma, using the angle theta* X as the X-angle in the X+X- CM frame with respect to the ISR photon direction. The requirements for this method include good sensitivity at large theta* pi values, which necessitates detection of particles at low momenta, and restricting the analysis to the m pi pi mass interval between 0. p. 5 (2) that separation of the pion and
muon processes through their angular distribution requires a good sensitivity at large | cos 𝜃
∗
𝜋
| values, corresponding to momentum-asymmetric topologies. Thus,
it is necessary to be able to detect particles at low momenta. Wu
(The BABAR Collaboration)
We report precise results for the 𝑒
+
𝑒
− → 𝜋
+𝜋
−
(𝛾) cross section in the energy range between threshold and
1. 4 GeV, relevant for the hadronic vacuum polarization contribution to the muon 𝑔 − 2 prediction.Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
The analysis proceeds through several steps: event selection, kinematic fitting, background estimation (including multihadrons from the qq process and multihadronic ISR processes), trigger efficiency determination, tracking efficiency measurement (using tag&probe method for muons and a combination of methods 1 and 2 for pions), momentum calibration using control samples like J/psi to mu+ mu- and K S to pi+ pi-, mass spectra determination via unfolding the mass spectra to recover the true underlying distribution as a function of sqrt s', and finally, combination of BABAR results. The final contribution to the anomalous magnetic moment of the muon derived from this pi+ pi-(gamma) cross section is given in Section XVII. p. 3 The measurement of the 𝜋
+𝜋
−
(𝛾) cross section and its
combination with the 2009 BABAR measurement are described in Sections XV and XVI, respectively. Finally
the contribution to the anomalous magnetic moment
of the muon derived from the present 𝜋
+𝜋
−
(𝛾) cross
section is given in Section XVII.Where the paper says it
The leading-order hadronic contribution to the muon magnetic anomaly calculated using the new 2026 and combined 2009 and 2026 BABAR measurements in the energy range of 0. p. 0 The new measurement is also compared with other two-pion results. The leading-order hadronic contribution to the muon magnetic anomaly calculated using the new 2026 and
combined 2009 and 2026 BABAR measurements in the energy range of 0. The leading-order hadronic contribution to the muon magnetic anomaly calculated using the new 2026 and
combined 2009 and 2026 BABAR measurements in the energy range of 0. 4 GeV are 525. Between the two
possibilities associated with each beam, the one
with a better 𝜒
2
SA value is retained. In both cases, the constrained fit procedure uses the
energy and direction of the measured ISR photon (plus
those of the LA photon in the LA fit), and the measured momenta and angles of the two tracks with their
covariance matrix in order to satisfy the four energymomentum conservation equations. Between the two
possibilities associated with each beam, the one
with a better 𝜒
2
SA value is retained. In both cases, the constrained fit procedure uses the
energy and direction of the measured ISR photon (plus
those of the LA photon in the LA fit), and the measured momenta and angles of the two tracks with their
covariance matrix in order to satisfy the four energymomentum conservation equations. 5stat ± 3. 8syst
and 517. Between the two
possibilities associated with each beam, the one
with a better 𝜒
2
SA value is retained. In both cases, the constrained fit procedure uses the
energy and direction of the measured ISR photon (plus
those of the LA photon in the LA fit), and the measured momenta and angles of the two tracks with their
covariance matrix in order to satisfy the four energymomentum conservation equations. Between the two
possibilities associated with each beam, the one
with a better 𝜒
2
SA value is retained. In both cases, the constrained fit procedure uses the
energy and direction of the measured ISR photon (plus
those of the LA photon in the LA fit), and the measured momenta and angles of the two tracks with their
covariance matrix in order to satisfy the four energymomentum conservation equations. The measurement of the 𝜋
+𝜋
−
(𝛾) cross section and its
combination with the 2009 BABAR measurement are described in Sections XV and XVI, respectively. Finally
the contribution to the anomalous magnetic moment
of the muon derived from the present 𝜋
+𝜋
−
(𝛾) cross
section is given in Section XVII. We have considered and
measured the contributions from all diagrams with up
to three photons. Cross-section measurement through the 𝜋𝜋/𝜇𝜇 ratio
The cross section for the process 𝑒
+
𝑒
− → 𝑋 is related
to the √
𝑠
′ spectrum of 𝑒
+
𝑒
− → 𝑋𝛾 events through
𝑑𝑁𝑋𝛾
𝑑
√
𝑠
′
=
𝑑𝐿eff
ISR
𝑑
√
𝑠
′
𝜀𝑋𝛾 (
√
𝑠
′
) 𝜎
0
𝑋
(
√
𝑠
′
) , (1)
where 𝑑𝐿eff
ISR/𝑑
√
𝑠
′
is the effective luminosity, 𝜀𝑋𝛾 is
the full acceptance for the event sample, determined by
simulation with corrections obtained from data, and 𝜎
0
𝑋
is the bare cross section (excluding vacuum polarization) for the process 𝑒
+
𝑒
− → 𝑋 (including additional
FSR photons). Between the two
possibilities associated with each beam, the one
with a better 𝜒
2
SA value is retained. In both cases, the constrained fit procedure uses the
energy and direction of the measured ISR photon (plus
those of the LA photon in the LA fit), and the measured momenta and angles of the two tracks with their
covariance matrix in order to satisfy the four energymomentum conservation equations. 4 GeV, relevant for the hadronic vacuum polarization contribution to the muon 𝑔 − 2 prediction. Using the
full 460 fb−1 of on- and off-𝛶(4𝑆) data, the cross section is derived from the ratio of 𝜋
+𝜋
−
to 𝜇
+𝜇
−
initial-state
radiation (ISR) events, in which many systematic uncertainties cancel. The new measurement is also compared with other two-pion results. The leading-order hadronic contribution to the muon magnetic anomaly calculated using the new 2026 and
combined 2009 and 2026 BABAR measurements in the energy range of 0. A minimal ISR
photon energy of 4 GeV in the CM frame is required
at production level, which restricts the generated mass
range to the region relevant for this study. Simulated
samples corresponding to about 10 times the number of
data events are generated for the signal channels. Systematic uncertainty propagation 38
4. Total uncertainty 39
XIV. Event selection
Two-body ISR events are selected by requiring an
ISR photon candidate with 𝐸
∗
𝛾 > 4 GeV and laboratory
polar angle 𝜃 in the range 0. 4 rad, and exactly two
‘good’ tracks of opposite charge, each with transverse
2 For the 2009 BABAR measurement, while Phokhara was still under
development, the full samples of signal events were generated with
AfkQed. Wu
(The BABAR Collaboration)
We report precise results for the 𝑒
+
𝑒
− → 𝜋
+𝜋
−
(𝛾) cross section in the energy range between threshold and
1. 4 GeV, relevant for the hadronic vacuum polarization contribution to the muon 𝑔 − 2 prediction. Calibration of the photon energy and
energy-dependent parameters of the Novosibirsk function is performed beforehand through a dedicated study,
using PID-selected data and MC, subjected to a 3C fit
to 𝑒
+
𝑒
− → 𝜇𝜇𝛾ISR that ignores the 𝛾ISR energy. Each event is characterized by two 𝜒
2 values, 𝜒
2
LA
and 𝜒
2
SA from the LA and SA fits, respectively, which
are reported on a 2d plot.Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Green — the paper says it, and the page is printed. Red — no passage carries it, so treat that sentence as unverified. The same check runs on your own text: check a summary against its source, $5.
Improvements for AI systems
-
Improved AI can perform precise measurement of cross sections by using an initial-state radiation method derived from a ratio of two processes, such as pion to muon initial-state radiation (ISR) events, which cancels many systematic uncertainties.
-
Improved AI can statistically separate pion and muon contributions by fitting the angular distributions in the center-of-mass frame for different final states (pion, muon, kaon), using the relation that
the result is independent of the BABAR luminosity Lee.
-
Improved AI can account for radiative effects more accurately by measuring additional radiation through kinematic fits and utilizing a blind approach where
Blinding is achieved by hiding two important individual data/MC corrections, namely for trigger and tracking efficiencies, by applying offsets known to only one person for each of these corrections.
-
Improved AI can determine the selection efficiency in data using a ratio derived from MC simulations, such as
epsilon pi pi gamma,data q2 = epsilon mu mu gamma,data q2 + epsilon pi pi gamma,MC q2 - epsilon mu mu gamma,MC q2,
which provides a first approximation of the data-to-MC correction to the selection efficiency in pions. -
Improved AI can correct for pion specific inefficiencies by using data/MC corrections derived from muon channels and explicitly studying
Pion-induced fake photons
andEffect of pion secondary interactions
through discriminant variables like Ecal, Zernike20, and docamax xy. -
Improved AI can determine track efficiency by using a tag&probe method that extends to two steps, including Method 1 (standard tag&probe) for safe regions and Method 2 for complementary conditions where
standard tracks are considered as final good track candidates.
-
Improved AI can correct for momentum miscalibration by deriving a data/MC bias in the ratio of reconstructed mass to PDG value, such as
the total estimate of the delta p/p data-MC correction amounts to delta p/p = -(6.4±1.2) x 10-4,
which is applied to track momenta in the MC templates. -
Improved AI can handle mass spectrum determination by employing a three-step strategy involving different | cos theta star pi | ranges and using a combined Neyman-Pearson chi-square test statistic proposed in Ref. [32] to fit the angular distributions and extract fractions of each X component.
-
Improved AI can obtain true underlying distributions by applying an iterative unfolding method, which involves constructing response matrices from simulation and using
an iterative unfolding method, as described in Refs. [38, 39], is implemented.
Abstract
We report precise results for the e+e-to π+π-(γ) cross section in the energy range between threshold and 1.4 GeV, relevant for the hadronic vacuum polarization contribution to the muon g-2 prediction. Using the full 460 fb-1 of on- and off- Υ(4S) data, the cross section is derived from the ratio of π+π- to μ+μ- initial-state radiation (ISR) events, in which many systematic uncertainties cancel. The pion/muon separation does not rely on particle identification as in the 2009 BaBar analysis, but rather makes use of the well-known, different angular distributions in the two-particle center-of-mass system. The compatibility and correlation between the 2026 and 2009 measurements are discussed. The new measurement is also compared with other two-pion results. The leading-order hadronic contribution to the muon magnetic anomaly calculated using the new 2026 and combined 2009 and 2026 BaBar measurements in the energy range of 0.3 - 1.4 GeV are 525.9 plus or minus 3.5 stat plus or minus3.8 syst and 517.8 plus or minus 2.4 stat plus or minus3.3 syst in units of 10-10, respectively.
Sources
- The anomalous magnetic moment of the muon in the Standard Model: an update
- Measurement of additional radiation in the initial-state-radiation processes $e^+e^-\to \mu^+\mu^-\gamma$ and $e^+e^-\to \pi^+\pi^-\gamma$ at BABAR
- Tensions in $e^+e^-\to\pi^+\pi^-(\gamma)$ measurements: the new landscape of data-driven hadronic vacuum polarization predictions for the muon $g-2$
- Precise measurement of the e+ e- to pi+ pi- (gamma) cross section with the Initial State Radiation method at BABAR
- Precise Measurement of the e+ e- --> pi+ pi- (gamma) Cross Section with the Initial-State Radiation Method at BABAR
- Measurement of the $e^+e^-\to\pi^+\pi^-$ cross section from threshold to 1.2 GeV with the CMD-3 detector
- Isospin breaking corrections in $2\pi$ production in tau decays and $e^+e^-$ annihilation: consequences for the muon $g-2$ and CVC tests
- Hybrid calculation of hadronic vacuum polarization in muon g-2 to 0.48\%
- Review of hadronic vacuum polarization calculations via $e^+e^-$ measurements
- New precise measurement of the $e^+e^- \rightarrow \pi^+\pi^-(\gamma)$ cross section with BABAR
- Study of e+e- --> p anti-p via initial-state radiation at BABAR
- Time-Integrated Luminosity Recorded by the BABAR Detector at the PEP-II e+e- Collider
- The BABAR Detector
- The BABAR Detector: Upgrades, Operation and Performance
- The radiative return at phi- and B-factories: FSR at next-to-leading order
- The radiative return at phi- and B-factories: FSR for muon pair production at next-to-leading order
- Four Pion Final States with Tagged Photons at Electron Positron Colliders
- Measuring sigma(e^+e^- \to hadrons) using tagged photon
- BHAGEN95: a Monte Carlo program for Bhabha scattering at LEP1/SLC and LEP2 energies
- The Precision Monte Carlo Event Generator KK For Two-Fermion Final States In e+e- Collisions
Related papers
- DrSai: an agentic AI system toward autonomous physics analysis workflows at BESIII
- CANTON- mu Proposal: A Next-Generation Muon g-2 Measurement at Sub-0.1 ppm Precision
- Search for dark photon dark matter near 1,meV using a superconducting mixer
- ANUBIS detector and its sensitivity to neutral long-lived particles
- How to scale your HEP ML models: A recipe for robust architecture comparisons at scale
- Search for the 16 O(ppp) to 13 C pi+ pi+ e+ Decay Mode in Super-Kamiokande Using Machine Learning Techniques