A New Precise Measurement of the e+e-to pi+ pi-(gamma) Cross Section with the Initial-State Radiation Method at BaBar

summary

The gist

We report precise results for the e+e- to pi+ pi-(gamma) cross section in the energy range between threshold and 1.4 GeV…

In short

This study precisely measured the cross section for $e^+e^- o \pi^+\pi^-(\gamma)$ between 0.3 and 1.4 GeV using BaBar data. By employing an initial-state radiation method based on the ratio of $\pi^+\pi^-$ to $\mu^+\mu^-$ events, the authors achieved a result consistent with QED predictions, yielding a final contribution of $517.8(2.4)(3.3) \times 10^{-10}$ to the muon $g-2$ anomaly.

Key concepts

Initial-State Radiation (ISR) Method
This technique uses the ratio of $\pi^+\pi^-$ to $\mu^+\mu^-$ events to determine the cross section at a reduced energy ($\sqrt{s'}$). This cancels many systematic uncertainties, making it a powerful way to extract the desired cross section from radiative processes.
Angular Distribution Fitting
The method fits the angular distributions of final state particles in different mass bins. By analyzing these distributions using an angle $\theta^*_X$, researchers can statistically separate contributions from different particle types like pions, muons, and kaons.
Unfolding Method
To recover the true underlying distribution of the process as a function of reduced energy ($\sqrt{s'}$), an iterative unfolding method is used. This involves using response matrices derived from simulations to correct for detector effects and obtain accurate physical distributions.
$g-2$ Contribution
The measured cross section feeds into the calculation of the hadronic vacuum polarization contribution to the muon's anomalous magnetic moment ($g-2$). This measurement provides a precise leading-order hadronic contribution in the 0.3–1.4 GeV energy range.

Terminology used across episodes

This episode discusses

The paper

A New Precise Measurement of the e+e-to pi+ pi-(gamma) Cross Section with the Initial-State Radiation Method at BaBar · Read on arXiv

J. P. Lees, V. Poireau, V. Tisserand, E. Grauges, A. Palano, G. Eigen, D. N. Brown, Yu. G., К Kolomensky, ూ Fritsch, H., * R., Ч Cheaib, C., T. S. Mattison, J. A., ౝ McKenna, R. Y. So, V. E. Blinov, A. R., П Druzhinin, E. A., К Kravchenko, S. I., Ч Serednyakov, Yu. I., Ш Skovpen, E. P. Solodov, K. Yu., A. J. Lankford, B., П Dey, J. W., O. Long, A. M., К Eisner, W. S., Ш Panduro Vazquez, D. S., C. H., B. Echenard, K. T., D. G., И Hitlin, Y. Li, D. X., ౝ Middleton, T. S., ు Miyashita, P. Ongmongkolkul, J. Oyang, F. C., M. Rohrken, B. T., Н Sokoloff, J. G., Ш Bernard, M. Verderi, D., К Garzia, E. Luppi, V. Santoro, A. Calcaterra, R., π de Sangro, G. Finocchiaro, S., Ч Martellotti, P. Patteri, I. M., П Peruzzi, M. Piccolo, M. Rotondo, A., ρ Passaggio, C., ς Patrignani, B. J., И Lacker, B. Bhuyan, Н Mallik, * C., J. Cochran, S. Prell, A. V., З Gritsan, N., M. Davier, F., ρ Le Diberder, A. M., Ш Lutz, G. Wormser, Ч Zhang, D. J., Н Lange, D. M., J. P. Coleman, D. E., К Payne, C., A. J., ρ Bevan, M Bona, F Di Lodovico, G Cowan, * Sw., Ш Banerjee, D. N. Brown, C. L., W Gradl, З Griessinger, A Hafner, K. R., Ч Barlow, * G D Lafferty, R. Cenci, A Jawahery, D A Roberts, * R Cowan, S. H. Robertson, R M Seddon, N Neri, * F Palombo

BABAR Collaboration

We report precise results for the e+e-to π+π-(γ) cross section in the energy range between threshold and 1.4 GeV, relevant for the hadronic vacuum polarization contribution to the muon g-2 prediction. Using the full 460 fb-1 of on- and off- Υ(4S) data, the cross section is derived from the ratio of π+π- to μ+μ- initial-state radiation (ISR) events, in which many systematic uncertainties cancel. The pion/muon separation does not rely on particle identification as in the 2009 BaBar analysis, but rather makes use of the well-known, different angular distributions in the two-particle center-of-mass system. The compatibility and correlation between the 2026 and 2009 measurements are discussed. The new measurement is also compared with other two-pion results. The leading-order hadronic contribution to the muon magnetic anomaly calculated using the new 2026 and combined 2009 and 2026 BaBar measurements in the energy range of 0.3 - 1.4 GeV are 525.9 plus or minus 3.5 stat plus or minus3.8 syst and 517.8 plus or minus 2.4 stat plus or minus3.3 syst in units of 10-10, respectively.

Transcript

Introduction to the show: ident: High Energy Physics: Experiment. The day in high-energy experiment: detectors, searches and limits.

Kai: We're looking at the paper: "A New Precise Measurement of the e+e-to pi+ pi-(gamma) Cross Section with the Initial-State Radiation Method at BaBar".

Mira: Here's the gist of the paper. We report precise results for the e+e- to pi+ pi-(gamma) cross section in the energy range between threshold and 1.4 GeV, which is relevant for the hadronic vacuum polarization contribution to the muon g-2 prediction.

Kai: This measurement utilizes the full 460 fb-1 of on- and off- upsilon(4S) data.

Mira: The cross section is derived from a ratio of pi+ pi- to mu+ mu- initial-state radiation (ISR) events, a method where many systematic uncertainties cancel.

Kai: The ISR method deduces the cross section for a process at the reduced energy sqrt s' = m X, where X can be any final state, such as mu+ mu- or pi+ pi-, from a measurement of the radiative process e+e- to X gamma, where the photon is emitted by one of the initial e+ or e- particles.

Title and authors: Kai: So the title itself tells you a lot, it’s about a new precise measurement of that specific cross section using an initial-state radiation method at BaBar. It suggests they’ve found a way to get much cleaner data than before.

Mira: Exactly. And the authors are listed as J P Lees and his team, which is the group that actually built and analyzed this data from the BaBar experiment at SLAC. They’re basically telling us they’ve improved how we calculate this process because of their method.

Lev: From an error-correction standpoint, what I'm looking for is how much precision they actually achieved in their final result when you translate that cross section measurement into something usable for our real hardware experiments.

Kai: Well, the core idea here is using a ratio of pion to muon initial-state radiation events. This technique cancels out a lot of systematic uncertainties, which is huge for the final number we get.

Mira: Right, and what's interesting is that this method allows them to determine the cross section at a reduced energy, or s prime equals m X, where X can be any final state like muon pair or pion pair.

The paper's summary: Kai: The summary basically boils down to how they use this initial-state radiation method to deduce the cross section for a process at a reduced energy, s prime equals m X, from measuring the radiative process e plus e minus to X gamma.

Mira: That’s because the relationship is defined by an equation that links the number of events at that reduced energy to an effective ISR luminosity and the cross section at that energy, which is what they call Equation one.

Lev: I'm thinking about the practical side here; if you do this ratio method, it means many things cancel out automatically, like the dependence on BABAR luminosity and even vacuum polarization corrections.

Kai: It also means their determination of the ISR luminosity comes from muon data independently, which isn't dependent on a theoretical calculation for how many additional ISR photons there might be.

Mira: And they also state that the ISR photon efficiency cancels out, so it’s a very robust way to handle those kinds of uncertainties in this specific measurement.

The paper's improvements: Kai: One big improvement they point out is fitting the angular distributions in each mass bin to separate contributions from different final states like pions, muons, kaons, and electrons. They use the angle theta star X as the angle for each X component in the center-of-mass frame with respect to that ISR photon direction.

Mira: That separation method requires good sensitivity at large values of cosine theta star pi, which means they need to detect particles with low momenta in order to get those signals right.

Lev: From my side, that implies a real hardware challenge; you need excellent tracking and low momentum resolution to distinguish those different components when you’re trying to reconstruct the final state.

Kai: And they restrict their analysis specifically to the pion pair mass interval between zero point three and one point four giga electron volts. That's their specific focus for this part of the study.

Mira: So, it's a targeted approach, focusing on that specific energy window where the hadronic vacuum polarization contribution becomes important for muon g-two.

Conclusion: Kai: So to wrap up, the paper shows how they used this new method to combine results and get a final contribution to the anomalous magnetic moment of the muon from that pion plus pion gamma cross section.

Mira: The leading order hadronic contribution they calculated using their new two thousand twenty six and combined two thousand nine and two thousand twenty six BaBar measurements in the energy range of zero point three to one point four giga electron volts is five hundred twenty-five point nine plus or minus three point five statistical and plus or minus three point eight systematic units in units of negative ten to the tenth.

Lev: That result is derived by first getting the unblinded energy spectrum of the pion plus pion process using that initial state radiation method, which gives them a cross section consistent with QED predictions for the muon pair process, which they fit at zero point nine nine two zero plus or minus zero point three statistical and plus or minus forty three times BABAR luminosity units.

Kai: And then they use that to determine the pion plus pion gamma cross section, leading to a final combined result of five hundred seventeen point eight with uncertainties of two point four statistical and plus or minus three point three systematic units in negative ten to the tenth across that common energy range.

Mira: They also note that the total systematic uncertainty amounts to zero point seven two percent for the full energy range, and they break it down further into zero point seven two percent, two point four percent, zero point five six percent, and three point two percent in specific sub-regions of the energy spectrum.

Lev: For me, it’s important that they explicitly state those limitations because you can’t just take a number without knowing where it stops working. This measurement is highly dependent on getting those specific efficiency determinations right.

More episodes

← Home