Dual-polarized, mid-infrared nonreciprocal absorption

arXiv:2609.00607 · physics.optics · Submitted 2026-09-01 · Read on arXiv

Listen

Radio episode about this paper

Transcript

Introduction to the show: ident: Physics. The day in general physics: instruments, methods and results across the field.

Kai: We're looking at the paper: "Dual-polarized, mid-infrared nonreciprocal absorption".

Mira: Here's the gist of the paper. Dual-polarized, mid-infrared nonreciprocal absorption is demonstrated using a nanophotonic dual-polarized nonreciprocal absorber consisting of an a-Si photonic crystal slab on top of a doped InAs substrate operating in the midinfrared spectral range (11–20 μm) This design is a step toward the complete control of light as heat, which could improve photonic energy conversion, thermal management, and mid-infrared optical isolation and circulation.

Kai: Fundamental Principles of Nonreciprocity Kirchhoff’s law states that spectral directional emissivity and absorptivity are equal (1) However, this equality breaks down in systems that do not obey Lorentz reciprocity.

Mira: Nonreciprocity can be achieved by applying a magnetic field, which introduces antisymmetric components in the dielectric tensor to break time reversal symmetry.

Kai: The relationship between directional emissivity and absorptivity is given by Equation (1).

Paper summary: Kai: What the paper is claiming is that they demonstrated dual-polarized nonreciprocal absorption using this specific nanophotonic design operating in the eleven to twenty micrometers range.

Mira: The core claim is that this system allows for nonreciprocal absorption for both s and p polarized light, which goes beyond what’s been demonstrated before, where only p-polarized light was shown in the Voigt configuration.

Lev: So they’re showing that you can get this nonreciprocity in both channels at once, which is a big step toward controlling heat flow.

Kai: They use a finite element method simulation, employing a gyrotropic Drude Lorentz model for the InAs dielectric tensor to calculate the spolarized spectral directional absorptance.

Mira: The simulation domain used periodic boundary conditions in x and y with periodic ports for s and p polarized light to map out how this structure behaves.

Lev: And they used time-domain modeling with harmonic inversion because frequency domain methods just don't work well for these dispersive media, which is a key technical challenge there >

Kai: Experimentally, they measured room temperature absorptance using magnetic field integrated absorptance spectroscopy to see if the nonreciprocity actually happened.

Mira: They confirmed that both s and p polarized light showed nonreciprocal absorption near the energy of zero transition wavelength at thirteen point two micrometers, which is what you’d expect.

Lev: The results show that their polarization averaged nonreciprocity was stronger than if they only had one polarization working, suggesting better system utilization >

Conclusion: Kai: Looking at the paper Dual-polarized, mid-infrared nonreciprocal absorption by Simo Pajovic and others, it boils down to them proving that this new nanophotonic absorber works for both s and p polarized light in the eleven to twenty micrometers range.

Mira: The implication is that this design moves us toward a complete control of light as heat, which could seriously improve things like photonic energy conversion and thermal management systems.

Lev: It’s a step toward better optical isolation and circulation in those mid-infrared bands >

Kai: So the title itself, Dual-polarized, mid-infrared nonreciprocal absorption, highlights that this is about controlling how light interacts with heat in multiple directions at once.

Mira: The authors are essentially showing how to use a magnetic field to break reciprocity so that emission and absorption can be decoupled for both polarization channels >

Lev: But they also mention a limitation, which is that the simplicity of the design limits tunability, and they point out there's a trade-off between the energy range where nonreciprocity is strongest and loss.

Kai: So while it’s a step forward in showing dual-polarization response, overcoming those fabrication defects and material losses will be crucial for making this practical >

Simo Pajovic, Yiting Zhao, Yae-Chan Lim, Ruzan Sokhoyan, Harry A. Atwater

Department of Applied Physics and Materials Science, California Institute of Technology · Resnick Sustainability Institute, California Institute of Technology · Department of Physics, Imperial College London

physics.optics

Submitted: 2026-09-01

Updated: 2026-11-09

Comments: 36 pages, 4 figures in main text + 12 pages, 12 figures in Supplementary Information; added new experimental results and discussion, revised figures and text, and added Supplementary Information

Code: https://github.com/NanoComp/harminv

License: http://arxiv.org/licenses/nonexclusive-distrib/1.0/

Importance score: 89/100

The gist: Dual-polarized, mid-infrared nonreciprocal absorption is demonstrated using a nanophotonic dual-polarized nonreciprocal absorber consisting of an a-Si photonic crystal slab on top of a doped InAs…

Key concepts

Nonreciprocity
This is the property where the response of a system depends on the direction of propagation, meaning if you reverse the direction of light travel, it doesn't necessarily produce the same result. In this paper, it is achieved by applying a magnetic field to break time reversal symmetry in materials.
Photonic Crystal (PhC) Slab
This is a nanostructure made of an alternating layer of materials (like air and silicon) that acts as a selective filter for light. It supports specific modes that can interact with both s-polarized and p-polarized light, allowing for precise control over how the light is absorbed.
Kirchhoff's Law Violation
Kirchhoff's law suggests that spectral absorption equals spectral emissivity. This paper demonstrates a violation of this law in nonreciprocal systems, showing that absorption can become direction-dependent even when considering thermal radiation, which is key for advanced thermal management.

Terminology

Summary

Dual-polarized, mid-infrared nonreciprocal absorption is demonstrated using a nanophotonic dual-polarized nonreciprocal absorber consisting of an a-Si photonic crystal slab on top of a doped InAs substrate operating in the midinfrared spectral range (11–20 μm) This design is a step toward the complete control of light as heat, which could improve photonic energy conversion, thermal management, and mid-infrared optical isolation and circulation. p. 1

Fundamental Principles of Nonreciprocity

Kirchhoff’s law states that spectral directional emissivity and absorptivity are equal (1) However, this equality breaks down in systems that do not obey Lorentz reciprocity. Nonreciprocity can be achieved by applying a magnetic field, which introduces antisymmetric components in the dielectric tensor to break time reversal symmetry. p. 2 The relationship between directional emissivity and absorptivity is given by Equation (1). p. 0 For s-polarized light in the Voigt configuration, its electric field is parallel to the applied magnetic field, meaning it does not interact with the magnetic field due to the Lorentz force. p. 3 In contrast, p-polarized light's electric field is perpendicular to the magnetic field and exhibits cyclotron motion when translational symmetry is broken by periodic voids.

Design and Simulation Methodology

The design utilizes an a-Si photonic crystal (PhC) slab on top of an InAs wafer, where the PhC slab supports eigenmodes that couple to both s- and p-polarized light. Finite-element method (FEM) simulations were used to calculate the spolarized spectral directional absorptance, employing a gyrotropic Drude-Lorentz model for the InAs dielectric tensor. p. 6 The simulation domain included periodic boundary conditions in x and y with periodic ports for s- and p-polarized light. p. 5 Time-domain modeling using harmonic inversion was employed to calculate the photonic band structure of the full, PhC-slab-on-InAs structure because frequency-domain methods fail for dispersive media. p. 7

Experimental Results and Observations

The experimental demonstration involved measuring room-temperature absorptance using magnetic field-integrated absorptance spectroscopy. Both s- and p-polarized light showed nonreciprocal absorption in the vicinity of the ENZ wavelength at 13. p. 72 μm, as expected. p. 0 The polarization-averaged nonreciprocity was stronger than if only one polarization were nonreciprocal, indicating better utilization of the system compared to single-polarized designs. p. 8 The results showed good agreement between theory and experiments for both polarizations across wavelengths, angles of incidence, and planes of incidence. p. 4

Limitations and Future Directions

The simplicity of the design limits tunability, and the quality factors (Q-factors) of resonances play a crucial role in performance. A fundamental trade-off exists between the ENZ spectral range, where nonreciprocal response is strongest, and loss, which includes scattering due to fabrication defects as well as intrinsic material loss. p. 4 Longer ENZ wavelengths benefit from higher-Q resonances but the power carried by thermal emission at realistic temperatures is relatively low. p. 2 Operating off the Voigt configuration presents drawbacks, such as light polarization becoming elliptical and a generally weaker nonreciprocal optical response. p. 8 Simple photonic crystal-based design motifs can be adapted to nonreciprocal systems by using an applied magnetic field to make the photonic band structure asymmetric with respect to the wavevector. p. 0

Fabrication Details

The fabrication process involved depositing a layer of a-Si via PECVD, followed by spin-coating negative electron beam resist, patterning using electron beam lithography, and depositing Al2O3 via PVD for the hardmask. The holes in the hardmask were created by lifting off developed resist after etching through the a-Si using an inductively coupled plasma reactive-ion etcher with an anisotropic dry etching process. p. 9 The dimensions of the structure were determined using ellipsometry, scanning electron microscopy, and optical profilometry. p. 9 The magnetic field was generated by a Halbach array controlled by adjusting the gap width between pole pieces. p. 3

Experimental Setup

The measurement utilized an infrared ellipsometer in its reflectance mode to measure polarization-dependent, spectral directional absorptance. The magnetic field was generated by a Halbach array and controlled by adjusting the gap width between pole pieces. p. 3 p. 3 A custom, 4-axis stage was built to control the sample's position and alignment with the magnetic field array. The measurement involved scanning from 35° to 60° in 1° increments with 40 scans per spectrum for comparison with theory. p. 3 p. 3 The Onsager-Casimir reciprocal relations were invoked to relate the measured reflectance data to the nonreciprocal absorption contrast. p. 9

Author Contributions

S.P. and H.A.A. originally conceived the project. S.P., Y.-C.L., R.-S., and Yae-Chan Lim carried out FDTD and FEM simulations with input from Ruzan Sokhoyan. p. 0 S.P. and Y.Z. built the magnetic-field-integrated absorptance spectroscopy setup and performed experiments. p. 4 Y.Z., Ruzan Sokhoyan, and Harry A. p. 0 Atwater measured and simulated the magnetic field distribution generated by the Halbach array. p. 9 S.P. and Y.-C.L. developed the fabrication process. S.P., Yae-Chan Lim, Ruzan Sokhoyan, Harry A. p. 0 Atwater performed imaging and characterization of the sample. p. 2 All authors contributed to the writing and preparation of this manuscript. p. 4

References

1 G Kirchhoff, Ueber das Verhältniss zwischen dem Emissionsvermögen und dem Absorptionsvermögen der Körper für Wärme und Licht. Annalen der Physik und Chemie 185, 275–301 (1860)

2 J R Howell, M P Mengüç, K Daun, R Siegel, Thermal Radiation Heat Transfer (CRC Press, Boca Raton, FL, 2020)

3 C Luo, A Narayanaswamy, G Chen, J D Joannopoulos Direct calculation of thermal emission for three-dimensionally periodic photonic crystal slabs. Physical Review Letters 93, 213905 (2004)

4 D L C Chan, M Soljačić, J D Joannopoulos Direct calculation of thermal emission for three-dimensionally periodic photonic crystal slabs. Physical Review E 74, 1–9 (2006)

5 H A Lorentz, The theorem of Poynting concerning the energy in the electromagnetic field and two general propositions concerning the propagation of light. Amsterdammer Akademie der Wetenschappen 4, 176 (1896)

6 L D Landau, E M Lifshitz, “The reciprocity principle” in Electrodynamics of Continuous Media (Pergamon Press Ltd., Elmsford, NY, 1984), pp. 308–309

7 K J Shayegan, S Biswas, B Zhao, S Fan, H A Atwater Direct observation of the violation of Kirchhoff’s law of thermal radiation. Nature Photonics 17, 891–896 (2023)

8 M A Green, Time-Asymmetric Photovoltaics. Nano Letters 12, 5985–5988 (2012)

9 Y Park, B Zhao, S Fan, Reaching the Ultimate Efficiency of Solar Energy Harvesting with a Nonreciprocal Multijunction Solar Cell. Nano Letters 22, 448–452 (2022)

10 L Remer, E Mohler, W Grill, B Lüthi, Nonreciprocity in the optical reflection of magnetoplasmas. Physical Review B 30, 3277–3282 (1984)

11 W C Snyder, Z Wan, X Li, Thermodynamic constraints on reflectance reciprocity and Kirchhoff’s law. Applied Optics 37, 3464 (1998)

12 L Zhu, S Fan, Near-complete violation of detailed balance in thermal radiation. Physical Review B 90, 220301 (2014)

13 Y Tsurimaki, X Qian, S Pajovic, F Han, M Li, G Chen Large nonreciprocal absorption and emission of radiation in type-I Weyl semimetals with time reversal symmetry breaking. Physical Review B 101, 165426 (2020)

14 K J Shayegan, B Zhao, Y Kim, S Fan, H A Atwater Nonreciprocal infrared absorption via resonant magneto-optical coupling to InAs. Science Advances 8, eabm4308 (2022)

15 M Liu, S Xia, W Wan, J Qin, H Li, C Zhao, L Bi C-W Qiu Broadband mid-infrared non-reciprocal absorption using magnetized gradient epsilon-near-zero thin films. Nature Materials 22, 1196–1202 (2023)

16 K J Shayegan, J S Hwang, B Zhao, A P Raman, H A Atwater Broadband nonreciprocal thermal emissivity and absorptivity. Light: Science & Applications 13, 176 (2024)

17 S Pajovic, Y Tsurimaki, X Qian, G Chen S V Boriskina Nonreciprocal reflection of mid-infrared light by highly doped InAs at low magnetic fields. Optics Express 33, 8661–8674 (2025)

18 B Nabavi, S Jafari Ghalekohneh, K J Shayegan E J Tervo H Atwater B Zhao HighTemperature Strong Nonreciprocal Thermal Radiation from Semiconductors. ACS Photonics 12, 2767–2774 (2025)

19 Z Zhang, A Kalantari Dehaghi, P Ghosh, L Zhu Observation of Strong Nonreciprocal Thermal Emission. Physical Review Letters 135, 16901 (2025)

20 H T Miyazaki, K Ikeda, T Kasaya, K Yamamoto Y Inoue K Fujimura T Kanakugi M Okada K Hatade S Kitagawa Thermal emission of two-color polarized infrared waves from integrated plasmon cavities. Applied Physics Letters 92, 141114 (2008)

21 R Starko-Bowes, J Dai, W Newman, S Molesky L Qi A Satija Y Tsui M Gupta R Fedosejevs S Pramanik Y Xuan Z Jacob Dual-band quasi-coherent radiative thermal source. Journal of Quantitative Spectroscopy and Radiative Transfer 216, 99–104 (2018)

22 X Wang, T Sentz, S Bharadwaj S K Ray Y Wang D Jiao L Qi Z Jacob Observation of nonvanishing optical helicity in thermal radiation from symmetry-broken metasurfaces. Sci. Adv. 9, eade4203 (2023)

23 A Nguyen, J P Hugonin, A L Coutrot E Garcia-Caurel B Vest J J Greffet Large circular dichroism in the emission from an incandescent metasurface. Optica 10, 232 (2023)

24 T Guo, C Jiang, X Zhang G Xu M R Zarei J Wang Z Guo Nanophotonics Engineering Polarization Manipulation in Thermal Radiations: A Review. Advanced Optical Materials 14, e03724 (2026)

25 J Fang, M Wang, T Liu, J Yue X Sun Y Wu D Zhang Dual-polarization strong nonreciprocal thermal radiation with silicon-based nanopore arrays. International Journal of Thermal Sciences 195, 108602 (2024)

26 H Zou, B Wang, J Wu, Polarization-independent nonreciprocal thermal radiation by cylindrical grating structure. International Journal of Heat and Mass Transfer 231, 125819 (2024)

Experimental Setup and Measurement

The magnetic field was generated by a Halbach array purchased from the research group of Dr Arne Laucht at the University of New South Wales. A custom, 4-axis stage was built to control the sample's position and alignment with the magnetic field array. The ellipsometer facilitated the measurement of absorptance automatically as a function of frequency, polar angle of incidence (via a motorized 2 theta stage), and both input and output polarization. p. 2 Measurements were taken from 35° to 60° in 1° increments with 40 scans per spectrum for comparison with theory. p. 2 The Onsager-Casimir reciprocal relations were used to relate the measured reflectance data to the nonreciprocal absorption contrast. p. 9

Conclusion and Outlook

The work observed a dual-polarized, nonreciprocal optical response in the 11–14 μm spectral range, close to the peak wavelength of room-temperature thermal radiation. Both s- and p-polarized light showed nonreciprocal absorptance in reasonably good agreement with theoretical predictions. p. 3 The design is relatively simple, based on a canonical, well-studied photonic structure, but tunability is somewhat limited. p. 6 Loss is arguably the most important factor affecting performance in this system High-Q-factor resonances are crucial for achieving a near-total breakdown of Kirchhoff’s law of thermal radiation. p. 2 Photonic crystals offer selectivity over spectrum, direction, polarization, and LDOS to bridge the gap between fundamental limitations and opportunities in nonreciprocal thermal photonics. p. 3 The challenge of loss must be overcome for simple photonic crystal-based designs to be further adapted to nonreciprocal systems. p. 0

Methods

The a-Si PhC slab was fabricated on top of an n-type, Sn-doped, (100)-oriented InAs wafer The dimensions of the wafer were 10 mm × 10 mm × 0.5 mm. A-Si was deposited using PECVD with 5% SiH4 in N2 at 200 °C. p. 9 The patterning was prepared using KLayout and BEAMER software, and the patterns were written using a Raith EBPG 5000+ electron beam pattern generator. p. 9 The structure was etched through the a-Si using an inductively coupled plasma reactive-ion etcher with an anisotropic dry etching process. p. 9 Ellipsometry was used to measure the optical properties of the InAs wafer at zero applied magnetic field. p. 9 The dielectric function of a-Si was modeled as a Lorentz oscillator, and the dielectric function of InAs was fitted using the Drude model. p. 6 COMSOL Multiphysics was used for polarization-dependent, spectral directional absorptance calculations via FEM simulations. p. 6 MPB was used to calculate the photonic band structure of the isolated, PhC slab in air. p. 7 Harmonic inversion was used to calculate the photonic band structure of the full, PhC-slab-on-InAs structure. p. 7 The magnetic field was generated by a Halbach array and controlled by adjusting the gap width between pole pieces. A custom, 4-axis stage was built to control the sample's position and alignment with the magnetic field array. The measurement involved scanning from 35° to 60° in 1° increments with 40 scans per spectrum for comparison with theory.

Acknowledgements

The authors thank Jared Sisler and Martin Thomaschewski for helpful discussions on fabrication, as well as Sachin Vaidya and Jinseok Kong for advice on simulations. p. 6 The authors also thank Guy DeRose, Nathan Lee, Kelly McKenzie, Yonghwi Kim, Ivy Chen, and Fabian Williams for training on the deposition, lithography, and characterization tools critical to this work. S.P. gratefully acknowledges the support of the Resnick Sustainability Institute at Caltech via the Pioneer Postdoctoral Fellowship. p. 0 Y.Z. was supported by a Summer Undergraduate Research Fellowship (SURF) via Caltech. p. 0 The authors thank Jared Sisler and Martin Thomaschewski for helpful discussions on fabrication, as well as Sachin Vaidya and Jinseok Kong for advice on simulations. The authors also thank Guy DeRose, Nathan Lee, Kelly McKenzie, Yonghwi Kim, Ivy Chen, and Fabian Williams for training on the deposition, lithography, and characterization tools critical to this work. S.

Green — the paper says it, and the page is printed. Red — no passage carries it, so treat that sentence as unverified. The same check runs on your own text: check a summary against its source, $5.

Improvements for AI systems

  1. Dual-polarized nonreciprocal absorption capability: The improved system can experimentally demonstrate dual-polarized, nonreciprocal absorption in long wavelength mid-infrared (11–20 μm) using an a-Si photonic crystal slab on top of an InAs wafer. This allows the system to decouple emission and absorption along the same channels for better energy conversion.

  2. Enhanced thermal management: The system can enable better thermal management via directionally asymmetric thermal emission, as suggested by the paper's goal to improve this aspect of applications like thermal camouflage.

  3. Mid-infrared optical isolation and circulation: The dual-polarized nonreciprocal response facilitates improved mid-infrared optical isolation and circulation, which is a key application area for such systems.

  4. Polarization control in thermal channels: The system can achieve better utilization of nonreciprocal thermal emission by showing that the polarization-averaged peak and valley values are greater than half the corresponding value for either polarization alone.

  5. Spectral selectivity: By using photonic crystals, the system can be tailored to enable spectral selectivity for both thermal emission and absorption in the mid-infrared range.

Sources

Related papers