Towards Genuine Coexistence: Per-Satellite Emission and Radiation Limits to Protect Radio Astronomy and Geodetic VLBI at 1-14 GHz from Satellite Constellations

arXiv:2608.11659 · astro-ph.IM · Submitted 2026-08-12 · Read on arXiv

Listen

Radio episode about this paper

Transcript

Introduction to the show: ident: Astrophysics. The day in astrophysics: observations, models and what the data forces.

Vera: We're looking at the paper: "Towards Genuine Coexistence".

Jocelyn: Here's the gist of the paper. The study provides a quantitative assessment of how operational Non-Geostationary Satellite Orbit (NGSO) constellations impact both single-dish radio astronomy and geodetic Very Long Baseline Interferometry (VLBI) across the 1–26 GHz frequency range.

Vera: The research establishes three primary conclusions: 1.

Jocelyn: Impact on Single-Dish Radio Astronomy: The threat to single-dish radio astronomy is already realized with the current satellite fleet, as measured emission and radiation levels exceed the nominal ITU-R RA.769 continuum criterion across the entire sky at every tested frequency.

Vera: This interference stems from three main sources: the intended 2620 MHz downlink, Direct-to-Device (DTD) harmonics, and bright platform Unintended Electromagnetic Radiation (UEMR) detections.

Paper summary: Jocelyn: So, what this paper is actually claiming is that we need per-satellite emission limits to manage the interference from satellite constellations affecting both radio astronomy and geodetic VLBI. They set these limits based on the analysis they did of emissions across one to fourteen gigahertz.

Vera: The core of their argument seems to be that while single-dish radio astronomy already sees issues with current fleets, geodetic VLBI is affected differently because it uses a less strict criterion and the interference doesn't always decorrelate well across long baselines.

Subrahmanyan: So, they are essentially trying to find the boundary where coexistence becomes physically possible by setting a ceiling for each individual satellite's noise contribution.

Jocelyn: They derive these limits by inverting an equivalent power flux density model against the RA769 thresholds to get maximum tolerable levels for spurious emissions and for unintended electromagnetic radiation, expressed as a field-strength limit in decibels microvolts per meter at ten meters for standard-setting bodies.

Vera: And they specifically looked at Sun-synchronous orbit orbital data centers as a case where the unintended electromagnetic radiation is expected to be the dominant problem.

Subrahmanyan: That’s an interesting angle because if you have those data centers in sun-synchronous orbit, it introduces a distinct type of UEMR that needs special attention in this calculation.

Conclusion: Vera: So, looking at the final conclusions of this paper about per-satellite emission limits, it really boils down to a challenge in spacecraft engineering—reducing unwanted and unintended emissions before the satellites even launch.

Jocelyn: They found that for geodetic VLBI to coexist with three hundred thousand satellites, every radiating satellite has to meet a ceiling of approximately sixty five to seventy one decibels microvolts per meter.

Subrahmanyan: That is a very specific number because it’s derived from the aggregate loss of sensitivity caused by the simultaneous emission from many emitters, not just some big single source saturating the equipment.

Vera: And on top of that, they found that restoring high-sensitivity single-dish radio astronomy requires meeting more stringent continuum ceilings detailed in Table eleven <ref:2608.11659#pg1>.

Jocelyn: So, the implication is that if we want to keep both services running, we have two different targets: one set of limits for VLBI and a stricter set for radio astronomy.

Subrahmanyan: The paper suggests that the challenge isn't just about spectrum allocation; it’s fundamentally about engineering spacecraft to meet these derived per-satellite limits.

Vera: That’s the main point, so if we want this coexistence, every satellite needs to be engineered to stay under those specific power and radiation constraints across that wide frequency range.

CSIRO Space & Astronomy Institute of the Commonwealth of Australia School of Natural Sciences University of Tasmania ASTRON The Netherlands Institute for Radio Astronomy BKG Federal Agency for Cartography and Geodesy MPIfR Max-Planck-Institut fur Radioastronomie SKAO Square Kilometre Array Observatory Department of Physics and Astronomy Chalmers University of Technology Cahill Center for Astronomy and Astrophysics Max-Planck-Institut fur Radioastronomie Radioobservatorium Effelsberg Centre for Radio Astronomy Techniques and Technologies Rhodes University

astro-ph.IM

Submitted: 2026-08-12

Updated: 2026-11-06

Comments: 43 pages, 27 figures

License: http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/

Importance score: 77/100

The gist: The study provides a quantitative assessment of how operational Non-Geostationary Satellite Orbit (NGSO) constellations impact both single-dish radio astronomy and geodetic Very Long Baseline…

Key concepts

Geodetic VLBI
This technique uses extremely long baselines between ground stations to measure the precise positions of satellites. It is crucial for establishing the fundamental link between celestial and terrestrial reference frames, making it highly sensitive to interference from space-based sources.
Spurious Emissions
These are unwanted radio signals generated by satellite systems that are not intended for transmission. They often appear as harmonics or unintended radiation, which can interfere with sensitive radio astronomy observations and geodetic measurements.
UEMR (Unintended Electromagnetic Radiation)
This refers to electromagnetic radiation emitted by satellites that is not part of the intended signal but is still detectable. This includes spurious emissions and harmonics, which must be controlled because they can degrade the performance of radio astronomy receivers and VLBI systems.

Terminology

Summary

The study provides a quantitative assessment of how operational Non-Geostationary Satellite Orbit (NGSO) constellations impact both single-dish radio astronomy and geodetic Very Long Baseline Interferometry (VLBI) across the 1–26 GHz frequency range. p. 0

Where the paper says it

The unprecedented proliferation of non-geostationary satellite orbit (NGSO) constellations threatens this mode of operation. Geodetic very long baseline interferometry (VLBI) is a vulnerable application of RAS: it provides the fundamental link between the celestial and terrestrial reference frames, and is the only technique that uniquely determines UT1−UTC.

The research establishes three primary conclusions:

  1. Impact on Single-Dish Radio Astronomy: The threat to single-dish radio astronomy is already realized with the current satellite fleet, as measured emission and radiation levels exceed the nominal ITU-R RA.769 continuum criterion across the entire sky at every tested frequency. p. 9

    Where the paper says it

    769 criterion across 1–14 GHz; the geodetic VLBI special case (the looser 1%-of-noise criterion and the VGOS broadband bands) is treated separately in Section 6. The result is uniform at the bright detections: the intended downlink, its local-oscillator fundamental, the harmonics, and the 2700 and 8640 MHz unintended radiation cause 100% data loss at every facility, already at the present fleet, so the singledish radio astronomy threshold is exceeded for all emissions and radiations we found, reminding the reader that these findings refer to the impact on astronomical observations throughout the entire spectrum, but not to cases of interference in the regulatory sense as in most cases the detections are outside of RAS allocated bands.

    This interference stems from three main sources: the intended 2620 MHz downlink, Direct-to-Device (DTD) harmonics, and bright platform Unintended Electromagnetic Radiation (UEMR) detections. p. 2
    Where the paper says it

    145), comprising harmonic emissions, parasitic emissions, intermodulation products and frequency conversion products. The main SNIFFLES-I detections falling into this category are the harmonics up to the fourth order of the Starlink DTD downlink, placing emission at 5240, 7860 and 10480 MHz, all within the 3–14 GHz VGOS span (and near the legacy bands); • Unintended electromagnetic radiation (UEMR)b , consisting of broadband noise from onboard electronics and power converters (predominantly at frequencies below 350 MHz (Di Vruno et al.

  2. Impact on Geodetic VLBI: Geodetic VLBI is comparatively less affected due to its less stringent 1%-of-noise criterion and the decorrelation of interference across long baselines, which mitigates the impact of narrowband unintended radiation. However, it remains vulnerable to broadband downlink harmonics; specifically, the second harmonic at 5240 MHz already breaches the VLBI criterion today, and its degradation worsens as projected growth approaches 300,000 satellites. p. 0

    Where the paper says it

    For geodetic VLBI, the dominant threat is spurious emission from the 2620 MHz Direct-todevice (DTD) downlink, whose second harmonic at 5240 MHz already causes at least 59% data loss today. At a forecast 300 000 satellites that loss reaches 100%.

    The third harmonic at 7860 MHz is expected to degrade from a 7. p. 7
    Where the paper says it

    This is physical for the non-directional UEMR as we demonstrate: ATCA tracking of the second, third and fourth DTD harmonics (19, 8 and 5 satellite passes respectively) finds their range-corrected level flat to within ∼2 dB over the accessible elevation range, as expected for emission or radiation emanating through an array not designed for its frequency, so we take the isotropic assumption to hold for the harmonics too. From all features investigated in this study, only the intended 2620 MHz downlink is subject to beamforming on the transmitter side, noting that no beam was ever pointing to the radio telescope owing to the established exclusion area.

    3% loss (at a conservative 200-second reference) to approximately 68% loss by the time the fleet reaches this size. p. 0
    Where the paper says it

    For geodetic VLBI, the dominant threat is spurious emission from the 2620 MHz Direct-todevice (DTD) downlink, whose second harmonic at 5240 MHz already causes at least 59% data loss today. At a forecast 300 000 satellites that loss reaches 100%.

  3. Binding Constraint: The most critical constraint for VGOS-class antennas is statistical sensitivity loss, which manifests as an aggregate loss of sensitivity caused by the simultaneous emission from numerous emitters, rather than front-end saturation. This necessitates a per-satellite emission/radiation ceiling derived in the units used by standards bodies (Table 10). p. 3

    Where the paper says it

    predict the resulting data loss for radio astronomy in general (Section 5), and treat broadband geodetic VLBI as a special case (Section 6); 5. recast the result as per-satellite spurious-emission and radiation limits in the units standards bodies use, and assess current compliance (Section 7); 6.

    This limit ensures coexistence with geodetic VLBI at 300,000 satellites, requiring every satellite to adhere to a ceiling of approximately 65–71 dB(mu V/m). p. 8
    Where the paper says it

    This criterion dependence enables a potential mitigation: operator-side boresight avoidance, in which the operator suppresses its downlink while a satellite crosses a telescope’s near-boresight cone. This can relieve the VLBI criterion (at 300 000 satellites every breaching realisation at 7860 MHz un-breaches if the contributions within 5◦ are removed) but offers no relief against the single-dish continuum criterion.

    Simultaneously, restoring high-sensitivity single-dish radio astronomy requires meeting the more stringent continuum ceilings detailed in Table 11. p. 3
    Where the paper says it

    This necessitates a system design fundamentally different from spectral-line or continuum radio astronomy: • Geodetic VLBI does not depend on any protected spectral line. Observing frequencies are chosen for compatibility across the global network, for technical feasibility of the receiving and recording systems, and for delay precision, which favours the widest possible frequency span (ITU-R 2022); • sensitivity to interference is therefore set by group-delay corruption and receiver saturation; • every station in the network must observe the same frequency bands simultaneously, so interference at one station affects every baseline to it.

The paper concludes that the challenge is fundamentally one of spacecraft engineering—reducing unwanted and unintended emissions before launch—rather than solely spectrum allocation. The derived per-satellite limits serve as a benchmark for assessing coexistence. p. 9

Where the paper says it

10 RAS & Satellite coexistence: Emission and radiation limits group delay. 769 thresholds are the spectral PFD at which that in-channel power becomes detrimental, derived assuming the interference fills the channel.

For geodetic VLBI to coexist with 300,000 satellites, every radiating satellite must meet the 65–70 dB(mu V/m) ceiling of Table 10. p. 3
Where the paper says it

extrapolate the SNIFFLES-I per-satellite intended-emission, spurious-emission and UEMR measurements from the current fleet to a conservative ∼300 000-satellite future, using both an analytic aggregate-power argument and a Monte-Carlo equivalent power flux density (EPFD) simulation, for the Australian RAS facilities of Table 1 (Section 4); 4. predict the resulting data loss for radio astronomy in general (Section 5), and treat broadband geodetic VLBI as a special case (Section 6); 5.

Restoring single-dish radio astronomy sensitivity requires meeting the 40 dB more stringent continuum ceilings of Table 11. p. 7
Where the paper says it

769 criteria, each interpolated to the emission or radiation frequency as in Section 3. 3: the single-dish radio astronomy (continuum) limits of Table 1 and the VLBI limits of Table 3 (ITU-R 2003).

Green — the paper says it, and the page is printed. Red — no passage carries it, so treat that sentence as unverified. The same check runs on your own text: check a summary against its source, $5.

Improvements for AI systems

  1. Per-satellite emission/radiation limits can be calculated using Equation 7: EIRPlim = Slim - K - 10 log10(N/N0), which provides a limit fixed by the RA.769 threshold and aggregate geometry alone, independent of the measured level Emeas.

  2. The AI system can predict the resulting data loss for radio astronomy in general and geodetic VLBI by using both an analytic aggregate-power scaling and a Monte-Carlo EPFD simulation to capture spatial and temporal statistics of interference.

  3. The AI system can quantify how a single entry of Table 6 is built by calculating the fraction of samples that exceed Slim, which becomes the entry in Table 6, resolving the paradox where sky maps sit near thresholds yet data loss is not 100%.

  4. The system can determine if a detection carries a finite sub-2% data loss at large constellation sizes by comparing Exceed = 10 log10(300 000/Nbreach) to the per-satellite limit, which shows that the two are consistent and not contradictory.

  5. The AI system can assess compliance against both the VLBI criterion (1% of receiver noise power) and the single-dish continuum criterion by using a composite threshold defined in Table 9 for each VGOS sub-band.

  6. The system can predict which band an administration licenses for DTD largely determines the potential to impact VGOS measurements by mapping authorized space-to-Earth bands against the four VGOS sub-bands and legacy X-band.

Abstract

Geodetic very long baseline interferometry (VLBI) is a vulnerable application of the radio astronomy service (RAS): it provides the fundamental link between the celestial and terrestrial reference frames, and is the only technique that uniquely determines UT1-UTC. The next-generation geodetic VLBI Global Observing System (VGOS) achieves millimetre accuracy by synthesising group delay across 3-14 GHz using 32x32 MHz channels, most of which lie outside RAS primary allocations. The SNIFFLES-I survey (Indermuehle et al 2026) measured intended emissions, unwanted emissions (spurious emissions, notably harmonics), and unintended electromagnetic radiation (UEMR) of NGSO systems from 1-26 GHz. On this basis we model the equivalent power flux density (EPFD) of current and future constellations and compare against protection criteria of ITU-R RA.769. The analysis extends to frequencies without radio astronomy allocations where SNIFFLES-I made detections. For geodetic VLBI, we run a Monte-Carlo EPFD model at the AuScope VGOS stations and scale the aggregate from the present catalogued fleet (12000 satellites) to the hundreds of thousands on file with a validated method. Inverting the EPFD analysis against the interpolated RA.769 thresholds yields maximum tolerable per-satellite levels for spurious emissions and for UEMR, expressed as a field-strength limit in dB(uV/m) at 10 m for standard-setting bodies. We treat proposed orbital-data-centres in Sun-synchronous orbit as a distinctively UEMR-dominated case. We find that already today the single-dish protection criteria are exceeded in two primary RAS bands. For geodetic VLBI, the dominant threat is spurious emission from the 2620 MHz Direct-to-device (DTD) downlink, whose second harmonic at 5240 MHz already causes at least 59% data loss today. (Abstract modified for arxiv limits)

Sources

Related papers