Drop Spray Electrification

arXiv:2608.05828 · physics.flu-dyn, physics.app-ph · Submitted 2026-08-06 · Read on arXiv

Listen

Radio episode about this paper

Transcript

Introduction to the show: ident: Physics. The day in general physics: instruments, methods and results across the field.

Kai: We're looking at the paper: "Drop Spray Electrification".

Title and authors: Kai: So the paper "Drop Spray Electrification" looks at how water drops hitting superhydrophobic meshes generate charged secondary droplets as liquid penetrates and fragments through the mesh pores. That's what they set out to show.

Mira: It’s important because it clarifies the role of controlled fragmentation on these surfaces, which was unclear in earlier studies of waterfall and spray electrification.

Lev: It seems like a lot of variables are being controlled here; how do they manage the different pathways of spray formation when you're looking at something that happens so fast?

Kai: They varied the distance between the mesh and the syringe needle from two centimeters up to fifty centimeters to control the drop velocity.

Mira: That range suggests they’re trying to map out how different impact energies translate into different fragmentation behaviors, which is a good way to explore this.

Lev: But what about those measurements themselves; did they just measure charge, or did they capture the dynamics of how that charge develops during the impact?

Kai: They used a microbalance to determine the total mass of all secondary droplets for five consecutive drop impacts at each height, and then analyzed the drop dynamics using ImageJ software.

The paper's summary: Mira: The core finding is that no measurable charge is detected below the penetration threshold, but once you hit a certain Weber number, things get interesting.

Kai: They found that at low Weber numbers, recoil jet formation gives a high charge per unit spray mass.

Lev: So they have a regime where the charging efficiency is really high right at the beginning of the fragmentation process?

Mira: Exactly; this happens because of charge accumulation during droplet retraction when it’s still attached to the mesh. They call this low Weber numbers, less than twenty, and no charge is detected then.

Kai: Then they move to intermediate Weber numbers, between thirty and fifty, where both recoil jets and impact-jet mechanisms contribute to charging.

Lev: That means you get a mix of charges coming from the retraction phase and the immediate impact phase simultaneously in that range?

Mira: Precisely; they show that when you increase Weber number up to about seventy-five, pancake bouncing suppresses the recoil jet formation, so charging becomes dominated by impact induced penetration.

Kai: And at those higher Weber numbers, where it's over seventy-five, the total charge approaches a saturated value because the charging is dominated by that impact induced penetration pathway.

The paper's improvements: Lev: I want to know about their suggestions for improvement; what are they telling us how to get a better result from this setup?

Mira: They suggest that smaller mesh pores enhance the charge-to-mass ratio, which is a big finding, and they also point out that conductive meshes provide stable charging under repeated impacts.

Kai: Smaller pores increase the effective liquid solid interaction area within the mesh, which they think further enhances charge separation. That makes sense physically.

Lev: So if I'm designing a device for this, I should focus on minimizing the pore opening and trying to use a material that allows for rapid charge relaxation between impacts?

Mira: Yes, that’s right; reducing the pore opening leads to an almost order of magnitude increase in the measured charge per unit spray mass.

Kai: And for stability, they recommend using conductive bases like metal because it provides a rapid pathway for charge dissipation so the surface potential recovers between impacts.

Conclusion: Mira: To wrap up, this study on "Drop Spray Electrification" shows that water drops hitting superhydrophobic meshes can produce charged sprays through liquid solid contact separation both inside and around the mesh pores.

Kai: They identified four distinct regimes of spray charging separated by three characteristic transition Weber numbers.

Lev: So we have a low Weber regime where recoil jets give high charge per unit spray mass, an intermediate one where both jets contribute, and then a high Weber regime dominated by impact induced penetration leading to saturation.

Mira: And the geometry matters; smaller pores boost the charge-to-mass ratio, and conductive meshes offer stability for repeated impacts.

Kai: The authors also show that salt concentration can be modulated to enhance energy output at about one millimolar salt, up to one molar.

Lev: So it’s a lot of design parameters here: Weber number, pore size, mesh conductivity, and even the electrolyte concentration if you want to tune the output.

Mira: That's what we have on "Drop Spray Electrification." It really shows how controlling fragmentation lets us engineer these charges.

Kai: It gives us clear guidelines for designing passive systems for droplet impact based charge separation and potential rain energy harvesting.

Lev: For me, it points toward needing better control over the dynamics of those liquid-solid interfaces because the results are so sensitive to the Weber number transitions.

Mira: Definitely, it opens up a new avenue for using water impact energy in a controlled way, moving beyond just simple sliding or falling drops.

Graduate School of Engineering, Tohoku University · Max Planck Institute for Polymer Research

physics.flu-dyn, physics.app-ph

Submitted: 2026-08-06

Updated: 2026-08-06

Importance score: 91/100

The gist: Charge separation during the breakup of water drop has been recognized since the early studies of waterfall and spray electrification…

Key concepts

Weber Number (We)
This number compares the forces of inertia (how fast the drop is moving) against surface tension (the liquid's tendency to stay together). It helps predict how a water drop will behave when it hits a surface, determining whether it forms a recoil jet or an impact jet during spray formation.
Recoil Jet Formation
This occurs at low Weber numbers where the water drop remains attached to the mesh after spreading. As the drop retracts, it causes a cavity collapse that drives liquid through the mesh, ejecting liquid that has already acquired a charge from droplet retraction, leading to high charge per mass.
Impact-Induced Penetration
This regime occurs at high Weber numbers where spray is produced before the primary drop's contact line recedes. In this phase, the spray is dominated by liquid jets passing through the mesh pores immediately upon impact. Charge generation here results from liquid separating from the solid interface locally within those pores.

Terminology

Summary

Charge separation during the breakup of water drop has been recognized since the early studies of waterfall and spray electrification, yet the role of controlled drop fragmentation at structured liquid-repellent surfaces remains unclear Here we show that water drops impacting superhydrophobic meshes generate charged secondary droplets as liquid penetrates and fragments through the mesh pores By combining Faraday-cup charge measurements with highspeed imaging, we identify how the charge depends on the Weber number and on the pathway of spray formation

Experimental Setup and Materials

The experimental setup consisted of a drop dispensing needle, a superhydrophobic mesh, a Faraday cup, an electrometer and a high-speed camera All experiments were conducted at 23 ± 2 oC temperature and 30-50% RH First, drops of 25 μl deionized water (18.2 MΩ.cm) were generated using a peristaltic pump (Minipuls 3, Gilson) The drop, formed from a grounded syringe needle, was allowed to fall onto a grounded superhydrophobic mesh directly below it Secondary droplets that passed through the mesh due to the impact were collected in a Faraday cup positioned directly beneath the mesh An electrometer (6514 System Electrometer, Keithley) was connected to the Faraday cup to measure the charge A high-speed camera (FASTCAM Mini AX, Photron, 10,000 fps, shutter speed 1/frame, resolution 768 × 528 pixels) was positioned directly beside the mesh to capture the dynamics of drop impact and atomization The distance (i. p. 4e., height) between the mesh and the syringe needle was varied from 2 to 50 cm to control velocity At each height three measurements were recorded The total mass of all secondary droplets was determined by a microbalance (EX225D, OHAUS) for 5 consecutive drop impacts at a particular height Drop dynamics was analyzed using ImageJ software

Charge Dependence on Weber Number

We measured the charge of the ejected spray as a function of the Weber number The Weber number quantifies the ratio between inertial and surface tension forces and is defined as We = ρU2D₴/γ As shown in Fig. 2(a), no measurable charge was detected at low We (< 20) With increasing We, the charge carried by the spray increased, reached a maximum value at We 100 Beyond this We, the charge remained nearly constant and showed a saturation behavior, even when the We was increased up to 500 The observed increase in spray charge with increasing We may suggest that the enhanced charge (Q) originates simply from the increased amount of liquid ejected through the mesh However, this interpretation is misleading Although the mass of the generated spray increased with increasing We and saturated above We 100 (Inset, Fig. p. 6 2b), the charge normalized by the spray mass (Q/m) exhibited a different trend It increased to 6 pC/mg at We = 30 and then decreased with increasing We It eventually reached a nearly constant value of 0. p. 65 pC/mg (Fig. p. 4 2b) This behavior indicates that the charge accumulation in spray is not governed solely by the amount of liquid participating in the spray formation process The spray mass increased at a faster rate than the total charge carried by the spray Therefore, the increase in charge with We is not proportional to the amount of liquid ejected through the mesh Instead, a progressively smaller fraction of the generated spray contributes to charge accumulation At lower We (< 20), no charge was detected because of no spray formation

Spray Generation Regimes

From the high-speed videos three distinct spray-generation regimes could be distinguished (Supplementary video S1, S2 and S3) At low We (25), spray was generated exclusively through recoil-jet formation (Fig. 4a, Supplementary video S1) At intermediate We (30 < We < 50), both recoil-jet and impact-jet mechanisms contributed to spray generation (Fig. p. 9 4b, Supplementary video S2) At high We (> 50), spray was produced solely by impact-induced penetration (Fig. p. 9 4c, Supplementary video S3) At low We (= 25), the drop remained attached to the mesh after reaching its maximum spreading diameter and underwent a complete retraction cycle Charge generation is expected to occur primarily during the separation of liquid and solid interfaces During retraction, cavity collapse drives liquid penetration through the mesh, producing a recoil jet Consequently, when the recoil jet penetrates through the mesh, it ejects liquid that is already charged (Fig. p. 9 4d) This provides a mechanism for the relatively high charge per unit spray mass observed at low We As the We increases (30), impact-induced penetration begins immediately upon drop impact Liquid jets pass through the mesh pores during the impact phase (impact jet) Charge is generated as the liquid separates from the solid interface Because the impacting drop is initially electrically neutral, the impact-jet contribution is limited to the charge generated locally within the pores (Fig. p. 9 4d) In addition, in this regime, recoil-driven penetration still occurs after maximum spreading Therefore, both mechanisms operate simultaneously: the impact jet contributes locally generated charge, while the recoil jet additionally ejects liquid that has already acquired charge during droplet retraction At high We (>75), the spray is produced before the contact line of the primary drop has receded In this phase the primary drop is not charged When pancake bouncing occurs, the rebound mode changes fundamentally The droplet lifts off immediately after maximum spreading, before a recoil jet can develop (Fig. p. 9 4c showing We 150) Once contact with the mesh is lost, recoil-driven charging is minimized or suppressed Consequently, spray generation is dominated solely by impact-induced penetration, and the additional contribution from the charged recoil jet disappears

Design Principles for Optimization

For practical energy-harvesting of mesh-induced spray charging, the mesh geometry must be optimized to maximize charge separation per unit spray mass The present results indicate that the recoil jet mode produces a substantially larger Q/m ratio than the impact jet mode Therefore, extending the We range over which recoil-driven ejection occurs is desirable Previous studies have shown that reducing the pore opening (w) promotes and prolongs recoil jet ejection In addition, a smaller pore opening increases the effective liquid–solid interaction area within the mesh, which can further enhance charge separation Consistent with this expectation, decreasing the pore opening leads to an almost order-of-magnitude increase in the measured charge per unit spray mass (Fig. 6a) The enhancement is most pronounced for meshes that combine small pore openings with small wire diameters, since this geometry supports recoil-dominated spray formation while maintaining larger contact area

Operational Considerations and Robustness

Because the charge generated by a single drop impact is small, practical energy harvesting requires operation at high drop-impact frequencies Under such conditions, the charge dissipation of the mesh between successive impacts becomes important If the surface retains residual charge for a long time, the next drop encounters a partially charged interface, which reduces the effective charge separation during liquid–solid interaction Therefore, meshes with slow charge-dissipation dynamics are not ideal for continuous operation Using a conductive base mesh, such as metal, provides a rapid pathway for charge relaxation, allowing the surface potential to recover between impacts (Fig. 6b) As a result, each incoming drop interacts with an effectively refreshed surface, promoting repeatable and maximized charge separation In contrast, insulating meshes such as polypropylene retain charge over longer timescales This residual surface charge progressively screens further charge transfer, causing the charge generated per drop to decrease with repeated impacts and eventually saturate at a lower steady value after only a few droplets Although superhydrophobic surfaces are desirable because they enable rapid drop removal, they are often mechanically fragile Repeated drop impacts can damage the surface microstructure (Fig. p. 1 6d) leading to deterioration of its superhydrophobic properties and changes in wettability, which may lead to change in spray charge

Modulation of Output

The effect of salt concentration (NaCl) on the charge separation on steel mesh at We 150 is shown in Fig. 6(c) The charge output initially increased with increasing salt concentration, reaching a maximum value of 0. p. 678 pC/mg at 1 mM followed by a gradual decrease with further increase in concentration up to 1 M Thus, the salt concentration can be modulated to enhance energy output A similar enhancement in charge output was also observed for droplet sliding on hydrophobic surfaces

Conclusion

This study shows that the impact of water drops on superhydrophobic meshes can produce charged sprays through liquid–solid contact separation inside and around the mesh pores We identify four distinct regimes of spray charging, separated by three characteristic transition Weber numbers In the first regime (We < 20), no liquid penetrates the mesh, and consequently no measurable charge is generated In the second regime (20 < We < 30), recoil jets dominate spray formation, producing a relatively high charge per unit spray mass due to charge accumulation during droplet retraction In the third regime (30 < We < 75), the combined action of recoil and impact jets enhances the total charge output In the fourth regime (We > 75), pancake bouncing suppresses recoil-jet formation, and charging becomes dominated by impact-induced penetration Mesh geometry plays a key role: smaller pores increase the charge-to-mass ratio Conductive meshes allow rapid charge dissipation and stable performance under repeated droplet impacts These findings clarify the mechanisms of mesh-induced spray charging and provide guidelines for designing passive systems for droplet-impact-based charge separation and potential rainenergy harvesting

Acknowledgments

The authors gratefully acknowledge Jürgen Thiel for help in making superhydrophobic mesh and Chitransh Upreti for assistance with the SEM imaging The authors also thank Prof. Prosenjit Sen and Bheema Shankar Reddy for providing the mesh samples used in this study Setup figure was partly generated using Google Gemini, followed by authors edit to ensure technical accuracy

Author Declarations

The authors have no conflicts to disclose Conflict of Interest The authors have no conflicts to disclose Author Contributions H.J.B., M.T. and R.L. conceived the project R.K carried out experiments R. p. 6 p. 6L designed experiments R. p. 4 p. 4K and R.L analysed the data R.L and H.J.B supervised the project R.L wrote the manuscript R.L, R.K., M.T and H.J.B discussed results, reviewed and revised the manuscript

Data Availability

The data that support the findings of this study are available from the corresponding authors upon reasonable request The data that support the findings of this study are available from the corresponding authors upon reasonable request

References

1 Sun, Y. J., Huang, X. & Soh, S. Using the gravitational energy of water to generate power by separation of charge at interfaces

3 Lin, Z. H., Cheng, G., Lee, S., Pradel, K. C. & Wang, Z. L. Harvesting water drop energy by a sequential contact-electrification and electrostatic-induction process

11 Darvish, F., Isaacs, M., Shumaly, S., Delance, L. & Butt, H.-J. Water drops sliding over arrays of Janus micropillars with hydrophilic tops: A new mechanism of drop charging

19 Ryu, S., Sen, P., Nam, Y. & Lee, C. Water penetration through a superhydrophobic mesh during a drop impact

31 Ratschow, A. D., Butt, H.-J., Hardt, S. & Weber, S. p. 1 p. 1 A. L. Liquid slide electrification: advances and open questions

33 Werner, L. J. et al. Freezing–thawing-induced hydrogen peroxide formation in PFA containers

Supplementary Information

Supplementary Video S1: High speed video of 25 μl droplet impacting on steel mesh at We 25

Supplementary Video S2: High speed video of 25 μl droplet impacting on steel mesh at We 30

Supplementary Video S3: High speed video of 25 μl droplet impacting on steel mesh at We 150

Conflict of Interest The authors have no conflicts to disclose Author Contributions H.J.B., M.T. and R.L conceived the project R.K carried out experiments R.L designed experiments R.K and R.L analysed the data R.L and H.J.B supervised the project R.L wrote the manuscript R.L, R.K., M.T and H.J.B discussed results, reviewed and revised the manuscript

1 Sun, Y. J., Huang, X. & Soh, S. Using the gravitational energy of water to generate power by separation of charge at interfaces

3 Lin, Z. H., Cheng, G., Lee, S., Pradel, K. C. & Wang, Z. L. Harvesting water drop energy by a sequential contact-electrification and electrostatic-induction process

11 Darvish, F., Isaacs, M., Shumaly, S., Delance, L. & Butt, H.-J. Water drops sliding over arrays of Janus micropillars with hydrophilic tops: A new mechanism of drop charging

19 Ryu, S., Sen, P., Nam, Y. & Lee, C. Water penetration through a superhydrophobic mesh during a drop impact

31 Ratschow, A. D., Butt, H.-J., Hardt, S. & Weber, S. A. L. Liquid slide electrification: advances and open questions

33 Werner, L. J. et al.

Green — the paper says it, and the page is printed. Red — no passage carries it, so treat that sentence as unverified. The same check runs on your own text: check a summary against its source, $5.

Improvements for AI systems

  1. Improved AI system can accurately predict spray charge behavior across different Weber numbers by incorporating physical regimes identified in the study, such as recoil jet formation at low We and impact-induced penetration at high We.

  2. Improved AI system can design optimized mesh geometries for energy harvesting by using the finding that a smaller pore opening increases the charge-to-mass ratio and that meshes with small pore openings and small wire diameters are most effective.

  3. Improved AI system can predict stable performance under repeated impacts by incorporating the recommendation to use conductive meshes, such as metal, provides a rapid pathway for charge relaxation, which allows the surface potential to recover between impacts.

  4. Improved AI system can modulate energy output by using salt concentration as a tunable parameter, leveraging the observation that the salt concentration can be modulated to enhance energy output by reaching a maximum value at 1 mM NaCl.

Related papers