Nahm Sums Dual to Zagier's Rank Three Examples and Related Identities

arXiv:2607.23257 · math.NT, math.CO · Submitted 2026-07-25 · Read on arXiv

Listen

Radio episode about this paper

Transcript

Introduction to the show: ident: Mathematics. The day in mathematics: new theorems, new proofs, and what they open.

Ada: I'm Ada.

Emmy: And I'm Emmy, here with Kolya.

Ada: We're looking at the paper: "Nahm Sums Dual to Zagier's Rank Three Examples and Related Identities".

Paper summary: Ada: So looking at the title, Nahm Sums Dual to Zagier's Rank Three Examples and Related Identities, it really highlights that this paper is about connecting the known examples to their dual counterparts. The authors are settling all those remaining cases for rank three modularity by showing these duals are modular too >

Emmy: It’s interesting because they achieve this by proving new Rogers-Ramanujan type identities that give these sums a specific form as finite sums of infinite products, which is a very concrete way to establish the structure >

Kolya: And the implication is that they're not just confirming existing knowledge about modularity, but they’re discovering two brand new families of rank three Nahm sums along the way, which opens up new avenues for research on these functions >

Ada: So in simple terms, this paper takes a set of twelve known examples and confirms that their duals are modular by finding specific product formulas that describe those sums. It establishes modularity for every defined dual in Zagier’s rank three list >

Emmy: It essentially builds on the work of Zagier and Wang to close the book on these rank three cases, giving us a comprehensive set of modular Nahm sums >

Kolya: What this means for someone just listening is that we now have a more complete set of modular structures for these rank three objects, which helps in understanding the underlying mathematical physics they're connected to >

Conclusion: Ada: So we’ve seen how these authors are wrapping up the book on Zagier's rank three examples by looking at their duals in this new paper, "Nahm Sums Dual to Zagier's Rank Three Examples and Related Identities."

Emmy: It seems like the main takeaway is that they finally settled all those remaining cases for modularity, confirming that these dual Nahm sums are also modular.

Kolya: What I find interesting is how they achieve this by proving new Rogers–Ramanujan type identities that express these Nahm sums as finite sums of infinite products. That’s a pretty concrete way to establish the structure you need.

Ada: Exactly, it’s not just theoretical confirmation; they provide explicit formulas for the Nahm sums, and they discover two entirely new families of rank three Nahm sums through those proofs.

Emmy: The implication is that they didn't just confirm what was already there; they expanded the known set of these structures significantly by finding brand new ones.

Kolya: From a probabilistic standpoint, it means we have more concrete tools for analyzing these dual objects, which should help us understand the tails of their distributions better.

Ada: It definitely gives us a much richer picture of this area, moving beyond just checking existing cases to actively discovering new mathematical families.

Emmy: So what does this mean for the broader field? It suggests that modularity isn't just confined to these specific examples but is a more pervasive property across these Nahm sum constructions.

Kolya: It points toward a deeper underlying symmetry in the mathematics that we might be missing when we only look at the most famous cases.

CHANGSONG SHI, LIUQUAN WANG

math.NT, math.CO

Submitted: 2026-07-25

Updated: 2026-11-18

Comments: 80 pages

License: http://arxiv.org/licenses/nonexclusive-distrib/1.0/

Importance score: 83/100

The gist: In 2007, Zagier identified twelve families of candidates for rank-three modular Nahm sums, establishing modularity for three cases, with the remaining ones subsequently confirmed by Wang.

Key concepts

Nahm Sums
These are specific mathematical functions denoted by $M(h)(q)$ that arise in the study of modular forms. The paper focuses on their properties, particularly whether they are 'modular,' meaning they satisfy certain transformation rules under modular group actions.
Modularity
Modularity is a property of these Nahm sums indicating that they behave predictably when subjected to transformations related to the modular group. Establishing modularity for these sums confirms their deep connection to the theory of modular forms.
Rogers–Ramanujan Type Identities
These are new mathematical formulas used in the paper to express certain Nahm sums as finite sums of infinite products. Discovering these identities helps settle remaining cases and reveals new families of rank-three Nahm sums.

Terminology

Summary

In 2007, Zagier identified twelve families of candidates for rank-three modular Nahm sums, establishing modularity for three cases, with the remaining ones subsequently confirmed by Wang. p. 0 Zagier's duality observation suggests that the Nahm sums associated with the duals of these examples might also be modular, a conjecture confirmed by this work. The authors settle all remaining cases by proving new Rogers–Ramanujan type identities that express these relevant Nahm sums as finite sums of infinite products, and they discover two new families of rank-three Nahm sums. p. 0 Applications include proving some Nahm sum identities conjectured by Cao–Wang, Li, and the present authors. p. 0

The paper investigates the modularity of the duals to Zagier's rank-three examples (Examples 1–3 and 7–12). The modularity of the duals for Examples 1–3 is known, while all remaining duals (Examples 7–12) are confirmed to be modular by establishing specific identities. p. 0 The authors present proofs for Theorems 1. p. 04 and 1.5, which yield new modular Nahm sums, as well as proofs for some conjectural Nahm sum identities on rank four tadpole Nahm sums (Theorems 1. p. 36–1.7). Specific results include several complex identities derived from the analysis of 3-dissections of these Nahm sums, and the establishment of new Bailey pairs relative to 1 and q, which are utilized to evaluate the dual Nahm sums. p. 0

The core contribution is establishing modularity for all defined duals in Zagier’s rank-three list and discovering new families of rank-three Nahm sums through the proof of Theorems 1. p. 04 and 1.5, which are expressed as infinite products. p. 0 The explicit formulas for the Nahm sums M(h)(q) are derived by substituting the components A(h)(q), B(h)(q), C(h)(q), and D(h)(q) into a general formula derived from the analysis of the structure. p. 8 Furthermore, Theorem 1. p. 67 is proven by splitting the function N(u, v, w; q) based on the parity of k, simplifying it using Lemma 5. p. 51 to express components in terms of infinite products and summations over t. p. 0 By substituting specific values for u and (v, w) and replacing q with q squared, the resulting expression is shown to be:

N(h)(q 2) = q ch J 4a(q) A(h)(q) + 3C 1(1)(q) + b(q)3B(h)(q) + D(h)(q).

This process confirms the validity of identity (1. p. 537) using a Maple approach and proves Li’s conjecture by showing that conjectural identities (1. p. 740) and (1.41) hold based on the relation M 2(q) = L 1(q 2) + qL 2(q 2), utilizing a 2-dissection formula for J 3J 1. p. 7

Green — the paper says it, and the page is printed. Red — no passage carries it, so treat that sentence as unverified. The same check runs on your own text: check a summary against its source, $5.

Improvements for AI systems

  1. Enhanced ability to classify Nahm sums by residue of exponent modulo 4: The AI can now utilize Table 7 to categorize series like A(1)(q) B(1)(q) C(1)(q) D(1)(q) based on whether their exponent residue is 0, 1, or 2.

  2. Improved verification of modularity proofs: The system can perform complex algebraic manipulations using the Bailey pair machinery to verify the modularity of Nahm sums by substituting specific Bailey pairs into transformation formulas like (2.67).

  3. Derivation of new rank-three Nahm sums: The AI can derive explicit product representations for dual Nahm sums, such as Theorem 1.5, by systematically applying the results from Lemma 4.5 and the Bailey pair substitutions into the general form F(u, v, w).

  4. Automated verification of conjectured identities: The system can check whether conjectural identities (1.10) through (1.14) hold by comparing their resulting infinite products with known evaluations derived from the duals of Examples 8 and 9.

  5. Mapping Nahm sums to modular forms: The AI can use Theorem 3.8 to express any rank-three Nahm sum M(h)(q) as a linear combination of four specific functions R(h)i, which aids in finding simpler formulas for low-rank cases like M(2)(q).

  6. Systematic handling of complex summation identities: The AI can apply the transformation formulas derived from Heine's formula (2.30) and related identities to evaluate Nahm sums dual to Examples 7, 8, and 10 by reducing them to known single sums with product evaluations.

Sources

Related papers