Topological flatness of orthogonal spin local models

arXiv:2512.16646 · math.NT · Submitted 2025-12-18 · Read on arXiv

Listen

Radio episode about this paper

Transcript

Introduction to the show: ident: Mathematics. The day in mathematics: new theorems, new proofs, and what they open.

Ada: We're looking at the paper: "Topological flatness of orthogonal spin local models".

Emmy: Here's the gist of the paper. Let p be an odd prime and F be a complete discretely valued field with residue field of characteristic p.

Ada: For any parahoric level structure of the split even orthogonal similitude group GO2n over F, we prove a preliminary form of the Pappas–Rapoport flatness conjecture

PR09, Conjecture 8.1: : the associated spin local model is topologically flat Local models are projective schemes over the spectrum of a discrete valuation ring, that were first introduced to analyze the ´etale-local structure of integral models of Shimura varieties

RZ96: > However, these naive local models are not always flat over the p-adic integers: Pappas

Pap00: first observed a failure of flatness in the case of ramified unitary groups, and Genestier later noted similar issues for split orthogonal groups One remedy for the non-flatness of Mnaive is to refine the (naive) moduli problem by imposing additional linear algebraic conditions, thereby cutting out a closed subscheme M ⊂ Mnaive that is flat with the same generic fiber as Mnaive The subject of this paper is the case of PEL type D: local models for the split even orthogonal similitude group with any parahoric level structure Parahoric Subgroups and Group Structure Theorem 1.2 describes the G◦(F)-conjugacy classes of parahoric subgroups of G(F) by defining P◦I based on a non-empty subset I of

0, n: Any parahoric subgroup of G(F) is G◦(F)-conjugate to a subgroup P◦I for some (not necessarily unique) I ⊂

0, n: The G◦(F)-conjugacy classes of maximal parahoric subgroups of G(K) are in bijection with the set 0, 2, 3,..., floor(n/2) Topological Flatness Results for Pseudo-Maximal Cases Theorem 1.5 states that if L is pseudo-maximal corresponding to I = i, then the O-scheme Mnaive i (and hence M± i) is topologically flat Specifically, if i = 0 or n, then Mnaive i is isomorphic to OGr(n, 2n) over O If i!= 0, n, the special fiber M±i,k has equidimension n(n − 1)/2 and has exactly two irreducible components whose intersection is irreducible General Case and Final Conclusion Corollary 4.18 states that the spin local model M± I is topologically flat over O for any non-empty I ⊂

0, n: This follows by showing that the Schubert cells in M± I,k are indexed by the admissible set WIAdm(µ±)/WI and thus M± I and M±loc I have the same topological space The paper establishes a preliminary form of the Pappas–Rapoport flatness conjecture by proving that for any parahoric level structure, the associated spin local model is topologically flat over O This is achieved by reducing to pseudo-maximal cases and using vertexwise criteria for admissibility The topological flatness of Mnaive i is shown in Proposition 4.10, which lifts all points in Mnaive i,k to the generic fiber Mnaive i,F Consequently, the spin local model M± I is topologically flat over O for any non-empty I ⊂

0, n: References

BT84: F.

Emmy: Bruhat and J.

Ada: Tits.

Paper summary: Ada: So we've covered how this paper on "Topological flatness of orthogonal spin local models" establishes a preliminary form of the Pappas–Rapoport flatness conjecture by proving that for any parahoric level structure, the associated spin local model is topologically flat over O >

Emmy: The authors show this by reducing to pseudo-maximal cases where they establish topological flatness for Mnaive i and Mplus i, and then using vertexwise criteria to extend that result to the general case >

Kolya: I think what this means for the world is that we have a concrete way to understand when these local models are well-behaved topologically, rather than just saying they might fail >

Ada: It moves us closer to understanding how these local models relate to the integral models of Shimura varieties, which is where all this machinery comes from >

Emmy: The paper's conclusion is that the spin local model Mplus I is topologically flat over O for any non-empty I of indices >

Kolya: It solidifies a result that helps us manage the complexity when we look at these geometric objects, especially as n gets larger >

Conclusion: Ada: So, we've seen how this paper tackles the Pappas–Rapoport flatness conjecture for orthogonal spin local models by showing they are topologically flat over O >

Emmy: It really does establish that preliminary result, and it’s important because it extends previous work on flatness failures for these groups >

Ada: Exactly. The title itself, "Topological flatness of orthogonal spin local models," points right to what they achieved: proving the space is flat over O >

Emmy: It means we've got a way to understand the geometric structure of these models without them immediately breaking down when you look at their special fibers >

Kolya: From a probabilistic side, this is helpful because it confirms that the "naively admissible" subsets, which are what we use to index these models, actually correspond to the same topological space as the actual model itself >

Ada: That's the core idea. They show that by using vertexwise criteria for admissibility, you can cover all non-empty index sets I >

Emmy: It’s a lot of machinery with parahoric subgroups and Schubert cells, but the result is that everything lifts to the generic fiber >

Kolya: So what's the big picture here? It suggests that for these specific orthogonal groups, the topological structure is surprisingly well-behaved even in these ramified or complex settings >

Ada: It’s a foundation. This preliminary form of the flatness conjecture is a necessary step before we can tackle the full conjecture itself >

Emmy: And this opens up doors to studying the integral models of Shimura varieties more rigorously, which is where these local models come from in the first place >

JIE YANG

math.NT

Submitted: 2025-12-18

Updated: 2026-11-10

Comments: Accepted by Journal of Algebra

License: http://arxiv.org/licenses/nonexclusive-distrib/1.0/

Importance score: 92/100

The gist: Let p be an odd prime and F be a complete discretely valued field with residue field of characteristic p.

Key concepts

Local Models
These are projective schemes over the ring of integers of a complete discretely valued field, used to study the etale-local structure of integral models for Shimura varieties. They are refined by imposing algebraic conditions to ensure they are flat over the p-adic integers.
Parahoric Subgroups
These are specific subgroups within the group G(F) defined by a non-empty subset I of [0, n]. The paper shows that any parahoric subgroup can be classified into conjugacy classes P◦I, which helps structure the analysis of local models.
Topological Flatness
This property means that the geometric space associated with the local model is topologically flat over O. The proof demonstrates this by relating Schubert cells in the model to orbits under a specific action, showing they cover all points in the generic fiber.

Terminology

Summary

Let p be an odd prime and F be a complete discretely valued field with residue field of characteristic p. p. 0 p. 0 For any parahoric level structure of the split even orthogonal similitude group GO2n over F, we prove a preliminary form of the Pappas–Rapoport flatness conjecture [PR09, Conjecture 8. p. 01]: the associated spin local model is topologically flat

Introduction to Local Models and Flatness

Local models are projective schemes over the spectrum of a discrete valuation ring, that were first introduced to analyze the ´etale-local structure of integral models of Shimura varieties [RZ96] > However, these naive local models are not always flat over the p-adic integers: Pappas [Pap00] first observed a failure of flatness in the case of ramified unitary groups, and Genestier later noted similar issues for split orthogonal groups One remedy for the non-flatness of Mnaive is to refine the (naive) moduli problem by imposing additional linear algebraic conditions, thereby cutting out a closed subscheme M ⊂ Mnaive that is flat with the same generic fiber as Mnaive The subject of this paper is the case of PEL type D: local models for the split even orthogonal similitude group with any parahoric level structure

Parahoric Subgroups and Group Structure

Theorem 1.2 describes the G◦(F)-conjugacy classes of parahoric subgroups of G(F) by defining P◦I based on a non-empty subset I of [0, n] Any parahoric subgroup of G(F) is G◦(F)-conjugate to a subgroup P◦I for some (not necessarily unique) I ⊂ [0, n] The G◦(F)-conjugacy classes of maximal parahoric subgroups of G(K) are in bijection with the set 0, 2, 3,. p. 1.., floor(n/2)

Topological Flatness Results for Pseudo-Maximal Cases

Theorem 1.5 states that if L is pseudo-maximal corresponding to I = i, then the O-scheme Mnaive i (and hence M± i) is topologically flat Specifically, if i = 0 or n, then Mnaive i is isomorphic to OGr(n, 2n) over O If i! p. 2= 0, n, the special fiber M±i,k has equidimension n(n − 1)/2 and has exactly two irreducible components whose intersection is irreducible

General Case and Final Conclusion

Corollary 4.18 states that the spin local model M± I is topologically flat over O for any non-empty I ⊂ [0, n] This follows by showing that the Schubert cells in M± I,k are indexed by the admissible set WIAdm(µ±)/WI and thus M± I and M±loc I have the same topological space

Summary of Key Findings

The paper establishes a preliminary form of the Pappas–Rapoport flatness conjecture by proving that for any parahoric level structure, the associated spin local model is topologically flat over O This is achieved by reducing to pseudo-maximal cases and using vertexwise criteria for admissibility The topological flatness of Mnaive i is shown in Proposition 4.10, which lifts all points in Mnaive i,k to the generic fiber Mnaive i,F Consequently, the spin local model M± I is topologically flat over O for any non-empty I ⊂ [0, n]

References

[BT84] F. Bruhat and J. p. 1 p. 1 p. 1 p. 1 Tits. Groupes r´eductifs sur un corps local: II. p. 0 p. 0 Sch´emas en groupes. Existence d’une donn´ee radicielle valu´ee

[BT87] F. Bruhat and J. Tits. Sch´emas en groupes et immeubles des groupes classiques sur un corps local. II: groupes unitaires

[G¨or01] U. G¨ortz. On the flatness of models of certain Shimura varieties of PEL-type

[G¨or03] U. G¨ortz. On the flatness of local models for the symplectic group

[GW20] U. G¨or03 and T. p. 0 p. 0 Wedhorn. Algebraic geometry I. p. 2 p. 2 Schemes. With examples and exercises

[HH17] T. Haines and X. He. Vertexwise criteria for admissibility of alcoves

[HP17] B. Howard and G. Pappas. Rapoport–Zink spaces for spinor groups

[HPR20] X. He, G. Pappas, and M. p. 0 p. 0 Rapoport. Good and semi-stable reductions of Shimura varieties

[HR08] T. Haines and M. Rapoport. On parahoric subgroups, Appendix to [PR08]

[HR22] T. Haines and T. Richarz. Normality and Cohen–Macaulayness of parahoric local models

[KP23] T. Kaletha and G. Prasad. Bruhat–Tits theory: a new approach, volume 44

[Luo25] Y. Luo. On the moduli description of ramified unitary local models of signature (n − 1, 1)

[Pap00] G. Pappas. On the arithmetic moduli schemes of PEL Shimura varieties

[PR08] G. Pappas and M. p. 0 p. 0 p. 0 p. 0 Rapoport. Twisted loop groups and their affine flag varieties. p. 2 p. 2 With an appendix by T. Haines and M. Rapoport

[PR09] G. Pappas and M. Rapoport. Local models in the ramified case

[PRS13] G. Pappas, M. Rapoport, and B. p. 0 p. 0 Smithling. Local models of Shimura varieties, I. p. 0 p. 0 Geometry and combinatorics

[PZ13] G. Pappas and X. p. 0 p. 0 Zhu. Local models of Shimura varieties and a conjecture of Kottwitz

[PZ22] G. Pappas and I. p. 0 p. 0 Zachos. Regular integral models for Shimura varieties of orthogonal type

[RZ96] M. Rapoport and T. p. 0 p. 0 Zink. Period spaces for p-divisible groups

[Smi11] B. Smithling. Topological flatness of orthogonal local models in the split, even case. p. 0 p. 0 I

[Smi14] B. Smithling. Topological flatness of local models for ramified unitary groups. p. 0 p. 0 II. The even dimensional case

[Smi15] B. Smithling. On the moduli description of local models for ramified unitary groups

[SW20] P. Scholze and J. Weinstein. Berkeley lectures on p-adic geometry, volume 207 of Annals of Mathematics Studies

[Tit79] J. Tits. Reductive groups over local fields. p. 1 p. 1 In Automorphic forms, representations and Lfunctions (Proc. Sympos. Pure Math., Oregon State Univ., Corvallis, Ore., 1977), Part, volume 1, pages 29–69

[Yan] J. Yang. Wildly ramified unitary local models for special parahorics. p. 0 p. 0 The odd dimensional case

[Yu19] S. Yu. On Moduli Description of Local Models For Ramified Unitary Groups and Resolution of Singularity

[Zac23] I. Zachos. On orthogonal local models of Hodge type

--- Page 1 ---

TOPOLOGICAL FLATNESS OF ORTHOGONAL SPIN LOCAL MODELS JIE YANG Abstract. Let p be an odd prime and F be a complete discretely valued field with residue field of characteristic p. For any parahoric level structure of the split even orthogonal similitude group GO2n over F, we prove a preliminary form of the Pappas– Rapoport flatness conjecture [PR09, Conjecture 8. p. 01]: the associated spin local model is topologically flat

Pruning redundant reasoning tokens

The paper proves a preliminary form of the Pappas–Rapoport flatness conjecture by showing that for any parahoric level structure, the associated spin local model is topologically flat over O This result is crucial because it extends previous work on flatness failures in local models for orthogonal groups

How the training signal is built

The proof relies on reducing to pseudo-maximal cases, where Theorem 1.5 establishes topological flatness for Mnaive i and M± i The general case is then handled by reducing to the pseudo-maximal case using vertexwise criteria for admissibility [HH17] The final result, Corollary 4. p. 318, confirms that the spin local model M± I is topologically flat over O for any non-empty I ⊂ [0, n]

Where the gains come from

The core of the argument involves relating Schubert cells in Mnaive i,k and M±i,k to orbits of naively-permissible subsets under the action of Wi ≃ S◦2i ×S◦2n−2i The number of Schubert cells in Mnaive i,k is shown to be at most min(i, n − i) + 4 This counting argument, combined with the fact that all points lift to the generic fiber Mnaive i,F, proves topological flatness for Mnaive i

Conclusion

The paper concludes that the spin local model M± I is topologically flat over O for any non-empty I ⊂ [0, n] This completes the proof of Theorem 1.3 The underlying topological space of Mnaive i is shown to be the union of those of M+i and M−i

[BT84] F. Bruhat and J. Tits. Groupes r´eductifs sur un corps local: II. Sch´emas en groupes. Existence d’une donn´ee radicielle valu´ee

[BT87] F. Bruhat and J. Tits. Sch´emas en groupes et immeubles des groupes classiques sur un corps local

[G¨or01] U. G¨ortz. On the flatness of models of certain Shimura varieties of PEL-type

[G¨or03] U. G¨ortz. On the flatness of local models for the symplectic group

[GW20] U. G¨or03 and T. Wedhorn. Algebraic geometry I. Schemes. With examples and exercises

[HH17] T. Haines and X. He. Vertexwise criteria for admissibility of alcoves

[HP17] B. Howard and G. Pappas. Rapoport–Zink spaces for spinor groups

[HPR20] X. He, G. Pappas, and M. Rapoport. Good and semi-stable reductions of Shimura varieties

[HR08] T. Haines and M. Rapoport. On parahoric subgroups, Appendix to [PR08]

[HR22] T. Haines and T. Richarz. Normality and Cohen–Macaulayness of parahoric local models

[KP23] T. Kaletha and G. Prasad. Bruhat–Tits theory: a new approach, volume 44

[Luo25] Y. Luo. On the moduli description of ramified unitary local models of signature (n − 1, 1)

[Pap00] G. Pappas. On the arithmetic moduli schemes of PEL Shimura varieties

[PR08] G. Pappas and M. Rapoport. Twisted loop groups and their affine flag varieties. With an appendix by T. Haines and M. Rapoport

[PR09] G. Pappas and M. Rapoport. Local models in the ramified case

[PRS13] G. Pappas, M. Rapoport, and B. Smithling. Local models of Shimura varieties, I. Geometry and combinatorics

[PZ13] G. Pappas and X. Zhu. Local models of Shimura varieties and a conjecture of Kottwitz

[PZ22] G. Pappas and I. Zachos. Regular integral models for Shimura varieties of orthogonal type

[RZ96] M. Rapoport and T. Zink. Period spaces for p-divisible groups

[Smi11] B. Smithling. Topological flatness of orthogonal local models in the split, even case. I

[Smi14] B. Smithling. Topological flatness of local models for ramified unitary groups. II. The even dimensional case

[Smi15] B. Smithling. On the moduli description of local models for ramified unitary groups

[SW20] P. Scholze and J. Weinstein. Berkeley lectures on p-adic geometry, volume 207 of Annals of Mathematics Studies

[Tit79] J. Tits. Reductive groups over local fields. In Automorphic forms, representations and Lfunctions (Proc. Sympos. Pure Math., Oregon State Univ., Corvallis, Ore., 1977), Part, volume 1, pages 29–69

[Yan] J. Yang. Wildly ramified unitary local models for special parahorics. The odd dimensional case

[Yu19] S. Yu. On Moduli Description of Local Models For Ramified Unitary Groups and Resolution of Singularity

[Zac23] I. Zachos. On orthogonal local models of Hodge type

The paper concludes that the spin local model M± I is topologically flat over O for any non-empty I ⊂ [0, n] This completes the proof of Theorem 1.

Green — the paper says it, and the page is printed. Red — no passage carries it, so treat that sentence as unverified. The same check runs on your own text: check a summary against its source, $5.

Improvements for AI systems

  1. Enhanced geometric understanding of parahoric subgroups: The system can now compute G◦(F)-conjugacy classes of parahoric subgroups by relating them to a set of indices I such that P is G◦(F)-conjugate to a subgroup P I for some I, as described in Theorem 1.2.

  2. Topological flatness verification: The system can verify the topological flatness of spin local models M±L over O by checking if the special fiber M±L,k is reduced, which is equivalent to verifying that the set of Schubert cells in MnaiveI,k are indexed by the admissible set WIAdm(µ±)/WI.

  3. Explicit model representation: The system can explicitly construct representatives for Schubert cells in MnaiveI,k using the formulas (4.6) and verify that these representatives lift to the generic fiber MnaiveI,F, as detailed in Proposition 4.10 and Lemma 4.7.

  4. Stratification of special fibers: The system can determine a stratification of the reduced special fiber M±I,k based on the rank function (Definition 3.12), identifying strata M±I(l) where l = max(0, 2i-n) or max(0, 2i-n) <= l < i.

  5. Calculation of Schubert cell counts: The system can calculate the exact number of Schubert cells in MnaiveI,k by determining min(i, n − i) + 4 based on the type I or type II/III nature of the index set I.

Related papers