K ab has the Bogomolov property for canonical heights
Listen
Radio episode about this paper
Transcript
Introduction to the show: ident: Mathematics. The day in mathematics: new theorems, new proofs, and what they open.
Ada: We're looking at the paper: "K ab has the Bogomolov property for canonical heights".
Emmy: Here's the gist of the paper. We show that for any number field K and any rational map f in K(x) that is not conjugate to a power, (signed) Chebyshev or Lattès map, then Kab has the strong Bogomolov property for the canonical height of f.<ref:2609.24938#pg2> Theorem 1.2 states that let f be nonexceptional, there is an ε > 0 such that the set of points with small canonical height is finite<ref:2609.24938#pg4>.
Ada: In particular, PrePer(f) ∩ P 1(Kab) is finite<ref:2609.24938#pg2>.
Emmy: This result settles the Andrews–Petsche conjecture to rational maps over a number field and to infinite abelian subsets of backward orbits<ref:2609.24938#pg2>.
Ada: Key Concepts and Definitions The paper introduces several key concepts, including L-conjugacy for pairs (f, α) and the definition of exceptional points<ref:2609.24938#pg2>.
Paper summary: Ada: So to recap this paper "K ab has the Bogomolov property for canonical heights", the main thesis is establishing the strong Bogomolov property for the canonical height of a rational map f, specifically when f isn't one of those special types like Chebyshev or Lattès maps >
Emmy: The claim is that this means there's a small region around zero height where only finitely many points exist, which is a refinement of earlier work by Amoroso and Zannier on the usual Weil height >
Kolya: What matters for us as probabilists is that they prove the finiteness of abelian subsets in backward orbits for nonexceptional maps, which settles the Andrews–Petsche conjecture >
Ada: Right. And why it matters is because this result provides a strong form of settling that conjecture for rational maps over number fields >
Emmy: It connects geometry, like the study of preperiodic curves and equidistribution, with arithmetic constraints from number theory >
Kolya: It’s interesting how they use those equidistribution results to create a conflict that forces the points into a very structured periodic curve >
Conclusion: Ada: So to wrap up this paper "K ab has the Bogomolov property for canonical heights", it establishes that for most rational maps, the set of points with small canonical height is finite on Kab >
Emmy: The authors settle the Andrews–Petsche conjecture in a strong way by showing that infinite abelian subsets in backward orbits only happen under very specific algebraic conditions involving CM type or Lattès maps >
Kolya: It really simplifies things for those studying dynamical Galois theory because they now have a clear boundary on where to look for these infinite sets >
Andrea Ferraguti, Carlo Pagano
Università degli Studi di Torino · Concordia University · Google DeepMind
math.NT
Submitted: 2026-09-21
Updated: 2026-11-02
License: http://arxiv.org/licenses/nonexclusive-distrib/1.0/
Importance score: 98/100
The gist: We show that for any number field K and any rational map f in K(x) that is not conjugate to a power, (signed) Chebyshev or Lattès map…
Key concepts
- Canonical Height (bhf)
- This is a specific height function defined for rational maps. It measures the growth rate of the map's iterates and is closely related to the standard Weil height. The paper shows this height has strong properties on Kab, meaning points with small values are finite.
- Exceptional Points
- A point $\alpha$ is exceptional if its backward orbit under a rational map $f$ is finite. The paper defines what makes a map 'exceptional' based on its conjugacy class, such as being conjugate to $z\pm d$, $\pm Cd$, or a Lattès map.
- Lattès Maps
- Lattès maps are a specific class of rational maps that have special algebraic properties. The paper analyzes these maps separately, showing that for non-exceptional points, the set of points with small canonical height is finite.
Terminology
Summary
We show that for any number field K and any rational map f in K(x) that is not conjugate to a power, (signed) Chebyshev or Lattès map, then Kab has the strong Bogomolov property for the canonical height of f. p. 0<ref:2609.24938#pg2>
Main Result
Theorem 1.2 states that let f be nonexceptional, there is an ε > 0 such that the set of points with small canonical height is finite<ref:2609. p. 224938#pg4>. In particular, PrePer(f) ∩ P 1(Kab) is finite<ref:2609. p. 024938#pg2>. This result settles the Andrews–Petsche conjecture to rational maps over a number field and to infinite abelian subsets of backward orbits<ref:2609. p. 024938#pg2>.
Key Concepts and Definitions
The paper introduces several key concepts, including L-conjugacy for pairs (f, α) and the definition of exceptional points<ref:2609.24938#pg2>. A point α is exceptional for f if its backward orbit is finite<ref:2609. p. 024938#pg2>. Definition 1. p. 01 states that a rational map f in K(z) of degree d is exceptional if it is K-conjugate to z±d, ±Cd or a Lattès map<ref:2609. p. 024938#pg2>. The canonical height bhf (P) is defined as limn→∞ d − nh(f◦n(P)) and satisfies bhf = h + Of (1)<ref:2609. p. 324938#pg2>.
Structure of the Proof
The structure of the proof involves applying equidistribution results [Yua08] to the map (f, f) and to points (Pn, Frobp(Pn)) for a suitable auxiliary prime p<ref:2609.24938#pg2>. The conflict between these results is resolved when the sequence of points is trapped in an (f, f)-periodic curve which can be parameterized using [Pak23, Pak20, Bea25]<ref:2609. p. 224938#pg2>. The proof proceeds by re-applying equidistribution to this curve and concluding<ref:2609. p. 024938#pg2>.
Classification of Cases
Theorem 1.5 extends the Andrews–Petsche conjecture by stating that f−∞(α) ∩ P 1(Kab) is infinite if and only if one of three conditions holds<ref:2609. p. 124938#pg2>. These conditions are: (i) (f, α) is Kab-conjugate to (z±d, ζ), where ζ is a root of unity; (ii) (f, α) is Kab-conjugate to (±Cd, ζ + ζ−1), where ζ is a root of unity; or (iii) f is a Lattès map and (f, α) is of CM type<ref:2609. p. 124938#pg2>.
Local Analysis and Bounds
The local analysis involves fixing a finite place v and using equidistribution results on the Berkovich space Xm<ref:2609.24938#pg2>. Lemma 3.2 shows that there is no generic sequence Pn satisfying a norm bound for an integral multihomogeneous form H<ref:2609. p. 424938#pg2>. This leads to the conclusion that coordinatewise preperiodic points on C satisfy a certain norm bound, which contradicts Proposition 3. p. 65<ref:2609. p. 024938#pg2>.
Abelian Points for Lattès Maps
For Lattès maps, Proposition 6. p. 5 p. 51 states that if α is nonexceptional, then f−∞(α) ∩ P 1(Kab) is finite<ref:2609. p. 824938#pg2>. This relies on the fact that a lift P of a preperiodic point must be torsion<ref:2609. p. 924938#pg2>. Proposition 6.4 further shows that for non-CM Lattès maps, every non-CM Lattès map f in K(z) satisfies the finiteness condition<ref:2609. p. 524938#pg2>. For CM Lattès maps, Proposition 6. p. 9 p. 92 proves that only finitely many torsion points have bounded degree over Kab<ref:2609. p. 524938#pg2>.
Conclusion and Applications
The results establish the strong Bogomolov property for bhf on Kab<ref:2609.24938#pg2>. Corollary 5. p. 5 p. 5 p. 51 shows that for a nonexceptional map f, if B has bounded Weil height, then there is an N ≥ 1 such that the set of points whose iterates fall into B is finite<ref:2609. p. 8 p. 824938#pg2>. Corollary 5.3 extends this to one-step B-avoidance over M implying strong B-avoidance over M<ref:2609. p. 924938#pg2>. This work also settles the Andrews–Petsche conjecture in a strong form<ref:2609. p. 124938#pg2>. The authors were led to the main idea of the proof in conversation with Astra<ref:2609. p. 0 p. 024938#pg2>. The first author is grateful to Alina Ostafe and Umberto Zannier for several conversations about these problems, and has been partially supported by the “National Group for Algebraic and Geometric Structures, and their Applications" (GNSAGA - INdAM)<ref:2609.24938#pg2>. The second author is grateful to Nicole Looper for past conversations surrounding [Loo21] and the Superhuman reasoning team at Google DeepMind for several conversations regarding the use of artificial intelligence in mathematics<ref:2609. p. 2 p. 2 p. 2 p. 224938#pg2>. The first author is grateful to Alina Ostafe and Umberto Zannier for several conversations about these problems, and has been partially supported by the “National Group for Algebraic and Geometric Structures, and their Applications" (GNSAGA - INdAM)<ref:2609.24938#pg2>. The second author is grateful to Nicole Looper for past conversations surrounding [Loo21] and the Superhuman reasoning team at Google DeepMind for several conversations regarding the use of artificial intelligence in mathematics<ref:2609.24938#pg2>.
References
[AP20] Jesse Andrews and Clayton Petsche, Abelian extensions in dynamical Galois theory, Algebra Number Theory 14 (2020), no. 7, 1981–1999<ref:2609. p. 024938#pg2>.
[AD00] Francesco Amoroso and Roberto Dvornicich, A lower bound for the height in abelian extensions, J. p. 0 Number Theory 80 (2000), no. p. 0 2, 260–272<ref:2609. p. 024938#pg2>.
[AZ00] Francesco Amoroso and Umberto Zannier, A relative Dobrowolski lower bound over abelian extensions, Ann. p. 0 Scuola Norm. p. 4 Sup. Pisa Cl. Sci. (4) 29 (2000), no. 3, 711–727<ref:2609. p. 024938#pg2>.
[Bea25] Alonso Beaumont, On the centralizers of endomorphisms of the projective line, preprint, 15 December 2025<ref:2609. p. 524938#pg2>.
[BC20] Abbey Bourdon and Pete L. Clark, Torsion points and Galois representations on CM elliptic curves, Pacific J. p. 1 Math. 305 (2020), no. p. 0 1, 43–88<ref:2609. p. 024938#pg2>.
[BS04] Matthew H. p. 9 Baker and Joseph H. p. 9 Silverman, A lower bound for the canonical height on abelian varieties over abelian extensions, Math. p. 0 Res. Lett. 11 (2004), no. 2–3, 377–396<ref:2609. p. 024938#pg2>.
[Che18] Evan Chen, Avoiding algebraic integers of bounded house in orbits of rational functions over cyclotomic closures, Proc. p. 9 Amer. Math. Soc. 146 (2018), no. 10, 4189–4198<ref:2609. p. 024938#pg2>.
[CL06] Antoine Chambert-Loir, Mesures et équidistribution sur les espaces de Berkovich, J. p. 3 Reine Angew. Math. 595 (2006), 215–235<ref:2609. p. 024938#pg2>.
[DZ07] Roberto Dvornicich and Umberto Zannier, Cyclotomic Diophantine problems (Hilbert irreducibility and invariant sets for polynomial maps), Duke Math. p. 2 J. 139 (2007), no. 3, 527–554<ref:2609. p. 024938#pg2>.
[FOZ24] Andrea Ferraguti, Alina Ostafe, and Umberto Zannier, Cyclotomic and abelian points in backward orbits of rational functions, Adv. p. 2 Math. 438 (2024), article 109463<ref:2609. p. 024938#pg2>.
[FP20] Andrea Ferraguti and Carlo Pagano, Constraining images of quadratic arboreal representations, Int. p. 0 Math. Res. Not. IMRN 2020 (2020), no. p. 0 22, 8486–8510<ref:2609. p. 024938#pg2>.
[FP23] Andrea Ferraguti and Carlo Pagano, Abelian dynamical Galois groups for unicritical polynomials, preprint (2023)<ref:2609. p. 024938#pg2>.
[LP25] Chifan Leung and Clayton Petsche, Non-abelian arboreal Galois groups associated to PCF rational maps, Res. p. 0 Number Theory 11 (2025), no. p. 0 p. 0 2, article 58, 16 pp<ref:2609. p. 0 p. 024938#pg2>.
[Lom17] Davide Lombardo, Galois representations attached to abelian varieties of CM type, Bull. p. 1 Soc. Math. France 145 (2017), no. 3, 469–501<ref:2609. p. 024938#pg2>.
[Loo21] Nicole R. p. 2 Looper, A Bogomolov property for the canonical height of maps with superattracting periodic points, preprint (2021)<ref:2609. p. 224938#pg2>.
[Mne20] James S. p. 6 Milne, Algebraic Number Theory, course notes, version 3. p. 008, 19 July 2020, 166 pp<ref:2609. p. 024938#pg2>.
[Mil06] John Milnor, On Lattès maps, in Dynamics on the Riemann Sphere: A Bodil Branner Festschrift, P. p. 9 G. Hjorth and C. L. Petersen (eds.), European Mathematical Society, Zürich, 2006, 9–43<ref:2609. p. 024938#pg2>.
[Ost17] Alina Ostafe, On roots of unity in orbits of rational functions, Proc. p. 2 Amer. Math. Soc. 145 (2017), no. 5, 1927–1936<ref:2609. p. 024938#pg2>.
[Pak20] Fedor Pakovich, Finiteness theorems for commuting and semiconjugate rational functions, Conform. p. 2 Geom. Dyn. 24 (2020), 202–229<ref:2609. p. 024938#pg2>.
[Pak23] Fedor Pakovich, Invariant curves for endomorphisms of P 1 × P 1, Math. p. 0 Ann. 385 (2023), no. 1–2, 259–307<ref:2609. p. 024938#pg2>.
[Ser72] Jean-Pierre Serre, Propriétés galoisiennes des points d’ordre fini des courbes elliptiques, Invent. Math. 15 (1972), 259–331<ref:2609. p. 024938#pg2>.
[Sil07] Joseph H. p. 3 Silverman, The Arithmetic of Dynamical Systems, Graduate Texts in Mathematics, vol. p. 0 p. 0 241, Springer, New York, 2007<ref:2609. p. 024938#pg2>.
[Sil09] Joseph H. Silverman, The Arithmetic of Elliptic Curves, 2nd ed. p. 1, Graduate Texts in Mathematics, vol. 106, Springer, New York, 2009<ref:2609. p. 024938#pg2>.
[Yua08] Xinyi Yuan, Big line bundles over arithmetic varieties, Invent. p. 3 Math. 173 (2008), no. 3, 603–649<ref:2609. p. 024938#pg2>.
[Zyw25] David Zywina, Open image computations for elliptic curves over number fields, Res. p. 0 Number Theory 11 (2025), no. 2, article 58, 16 pp<ref:2609.24938#pg2>.
How the training signal is built
The key insight consists of applying the equidistribution results [Yua08], followed by a classification of (f, f)-preperiodic curves [Pak23, Pak20, Bea25] followed by an additional application of equidistribution on a parametrized preperiodic curve<ref:2609.24938#pg2>. The proof begins with the observation that equidistribution theorems applied to the map (f, f) and to points (Pn, Frobp(Pn)) tend to conflict with congruences from [AZ00]<ref:2609. p. 224938#pg2>.
Where the gains come from
The key property that allows [AZ00] to show the Bogomolov property for the usual Weil height on Kab is that Pn is in Kab provides strong congruence between P p n and a conjugate σ(Pn) modulo all primes above suitable prime p of good reduction<ref:2609.24938#pg2>. Equidistribution of the small points (Pn, σ(Pn)) forbids these congruences unless infinitely many pairs satisfy a fixed algebraic relation [Yua08]<ref:2609. p. 224938#pg2>. The classification of periodic curves allows for parametrization, and a second application of equidistribution on this copy leads to a contradiction<ref:2609. p. 224938#pg2>.
The classification of Lattès maps shows that PrePer(f) = π(Etors), where Etors are torsion points<ref:2609.24938#pg2>. Proposition 6.1 proves that if α is nonexceptional, then f−∞(α) ∩ P 1(Kab) is finite<ref:2609. p. 824938#pg2>. For CM Lattès maps, Proposition 6.2 proves that every non-CM Lattès map f in K(z) satisfies the finiteness condition<ref:2609. p. 124938#pg2>.
The results establish the strong Bogomolov property for bhf on Kab<ref:2609.24938#pg2>. Corollary 5.1 shows that for a nonexceptional map f, if B has bounded Weil height, then there is an N ≥ 1 such that the set of points whose iterates fall into B is finite<ref:2609.24938#pg2>. The authors were led to the main idea of the proof in conversation with Astra<ref:2609.24938#pg2>. The first author is grateful to Alina Ostafe and Umberto Zannier for several conversations about these problems, and has been partially supported by the “National Group for Algebraic and Geometric Structures, and their Applications" (GNSAGA - INdAM)<ref:2609.24938#pg2>. The second author is grateful to Nicole Looper for past conversations surrounding [Loo21] and the Superhuman reasoning team at Google DeepMind for several conversations regarding the use of artificial intelligence in mathematics<ref:2609.24938#pg2>. The first author is grateful to Alina Ostafe and Umberto Zannier for several conversations about these problems, and has been partially supported by the “National Group for Algebraic and Geometric Structures, and their Applications" (GNSAGA - INdAM)<ref:2609.24938#pg2>. The second author is grateful to Nicole Looper for past conversations surrounding [Loo21] and the Superhuman reasoning team at Google DeepMind for several conversations regarding the use of artificial intelligence in mathematics<ref:2609.24938#pg2>.
Green — the paper says it, and the page is printed. Red — no passage carries it, so treat that sentence as unverified. The same check runs on your own text: check a summary against its source, $5.
Improvements for AI systems
-
Improved analysis of dynamical Galois groups for maps that are not conjugate to powers, Chebyshev, or Lattès maps by proving Kab has the strong Bogomolov property for its canonical height bhf. This allows AI systems to rigorously bound the set of abelian points in backward orbits for nonexceptional maps.
-
Ability to classify pairs (f, alpha) whose backward orbit contains infinitely many abelian points by distinguishing between power, Chebyshev, and Lattès cases using the equivalence stated in Theorem 1.5. This settles the Andrews–Petsche conjecture for rational maps over number fields regarding infinite abelian subsets of backward orbits.
-
Detection and verification of CM type Lattès maps by checking if a pair (f, alpha) satisfies the condition in Definition 1.3, which involves an elliptic curve E/K, an endomorphism a, and a finite morphism theta such that f o theta equals theta o a.
-
Rigorous proof of finiteness for abelian points in backward orbits of Lattès maps by showing that if (f, alpha) is of CM type, then
f -∞(alpha) ∩ P1(Kab) is infinite
is equivalent to(f, alpha) is of CM type,
as stated in Theorem 1.4. -
Application of equidistribution theorems [Yua08] combined with classifications of (f, f)-preperiodic curves [Pak23, Pak20, Bea25] to resolve conflicts between congruences and distribution properties when analyzing sequences of points with heights tending to zero. This allows the system to prove Theorem 1.2 by showing that if a sequence has bhf tending to zero, it must eventually be trapped in a preperiodic curve whose image under f is finite.
-
Enhanced ability to handle local constraints on abelian extensions by using Lemma 4.1, which provides conditions (U) or (R) for an automorphism sigmaP in Dw concerning the chordal distance δv(sigmaP x, Phi p(x)), enabling precise control over point distribution in abelian extensions Kab.
-
Identification of preperiodic points and torsion points in Lattès maps by using the relationship derived from Definition 6.1:
torsion points have finite psi-orbits
and showing thata lift of a preperiodic point has finite orbit because pi has finite fibers.
This allows for precise determination of which backward orbits are bounded. -
Verification that non-CM Lattès maps satisfy the Bogomolov property by using Lemma 6.2 to show that for every P in Etors of exact order n, "[Kab(P): Kab] >= n squared I Y ln (1 - l-2) >= n squared I zeta(2)," implying only finitely many torsion points have bounded degree over Kab.
-
Proof that the forward image of a set with bounded Weil height is finite by leveraging Corollary 5.1, which states that for a nonexceptional map f,
f B-avoiding over M if and only if it is strongly B-avoiding over M,
simplifying the verification of avoidance properties.
Sources
- Abelian extensions in dynamical Galois theory
- On the centralizers of endomorphisms of the projective line
- Torsion points and Galois representations on CM elliptic curves
- A Lower Bound for the Canonical Height on Abelian Varieties over Abelian Extensions
- Avoiding algebraic integers of bounded house in orbits of rational functions over cyclotomic closures
- Questions on self maps of algebraic varieties
- Cyclotomic and abelian points in backward orbits of rational functions
- Constraining images of quadratic arboreal representations
- Abelian dynamical Galois groups for unicritical polynomials
- Non-abelian arboreal Galois groups associated to PCF rational maps
- A Bogomolov property for the canonical height of maps with superattracting periodic points
- On Latt\`es Maps
- On roots of unity in orbits of rational functions
- Finiteness theorems for commuting and semiconjugate rational functions
- Invariant curves for endomorphisms of $\mathbb P^1\times \mathbb P^1$
- Big Line Bundles over Arithmetic Varieties
- Open image computations for elliptic curves over number fields
Related papers
- Quasi-Jacobi forms, Appell-Lerch functions, and false theta functions as q-brackets of functions on partitions
- Wasserstein rates of all orders for the Sato-Tate law of Kloosterman sums
- Completing the classification of torsion over sextic fields for elliptic curves defined over Q
- Riemann functions for almost primes and their counting errors
- Topological flatness of orthogonal spin local models
- Asymptotic counting of integers with prime factors p r a s b