Role of Spatial Coherence in Single-Shot Lensless Image Reconstruction
Listen
Radio episode about this paper
Transcript
Introduction to the show: ident: Physics. The day in general physics: instruments, methods and results across the field.
Kai: We're looking at the paper: "Role of Spatial Coherence in Single-Shot Lensless Image Reconstruction".
Mira: Here's the gist of the paper. Lensless imaging performance is strongly dependent on the forward model used during image reconstruction because common assumptions about fully coherent propagation lead to errors when illumination exhibits partial spatial coherence.
Kai: This paper examines the role of spatial coherence in single-shot lensless image reconstruction using a generalized van Cittert-Zernike Schell propagation model to show that incorporating partial coherence into the forward model preserves object structure and improves image quality.
Mira: The Problem with Coherent Assumptions A common source of reconstruction error is the assumption of fully coherent propagation, even when the illumination exhibits partial spatial coherence in practice.
Kai: Many practical lensless imaging systems operate with extended sources for which the object plane illumination is only partially spatially coherent.
Title and authors: Mira: We’ve established the importance of coherence, and now let's look at what this paper actually says in its summary section about the findings. It boils down to how they used their new model against the old one.
Kai: They are essentially saying that when you compare reconstructions from a conventional coherent propagator to ones using their partially coherent forward model, the coherence-aware approach generally outperforms it, particularly for certain object types.
Mira: The paper highlights that this is not just a general improvement across the board; it's specifically tied to the structural class of the object being reconstructed.
Lev: So, they’re saying there isn't one universal fix; you need to tailor your model based on what kind of object you are looking at—like HFHD versus LFLD.
Kai: Exactly. They show that for dense high-frequency features, incorporating partial coherence preserves the dominant object structure and improves the overall image quality when using the Mpc model.
Mira: That points to a more nuanced relationship than just saying "coherence helps." It suggests that the benefit scales with how much fine detail is present in your target.
Lev: From an engineering standpoint, that means your reconstruction pipeline might need conditional logic to switch between models based on the expected object class, which adds a bit of overhead to the processing time.
Kai: That overhead is what we have to weigh against the gain in accuracy; they quantify this trade-off using metrics like structural similarity SSIM and mean squared error MSE.
Mira: The paper shows that their choice of weights—using wSSIM equal to zero point three and wMSE equal to zero point seven—dictates how much you prioritize preserving structure versus just minimizing the raw pixel difference in the reconstruction process <ref:2607.15765#pg3>.
Lev: So, it’s a deliberate trade-off: you're accepting slightly higher error in terms of MSE for a better structural similarity metric when that object has fine features.
Kai: Right. They are showing that even with these regularization terms, the coherence-aware model still provides a tangible benefit by correctly handling those specific high-frequency components.
Mira: It confirms their hypothesis that ignoring partial coherence leads to errors being incorrectly attributed to the object structure instead of being artifacts of the illumination model itself.
The paper's summary: Lev: Now let's talk about the specific improvements they suggest in their methodology, moving beyond just stating what they found in segment three, and looking at how you actually implement this change into a solver.
Kai: They suggest implementing an inverse problem solver that minimizes an objective function that balances structural similarity SSIM and mean squared error MSE using both operators.
Mira: This objective function should include a term like Jnu t which specifically balances structural similarity against the mean squared error, using both the partially coherent operator Mpc and the fully coherent operator Mcoh.
Lev: So, they’re suggesting a unified solver that doesn't just pick one model but actively balances between them during the minimization process. That sounds like it could be a powerful way to handle uncertainty in your forward model.
Kai: They state that this method ensures that the reconstruction isn't solely dependent on the numerical formulation but also on the physical accuracy of the forward model, as stated in equation seven.
Mira: That’s crucial because it links the mathematical minimization process directly back to what we know about physical propagation. It makes the result less arbitrary.
Lev: From a hardware perspective, that means you have to solve for parameters that describe both the image and the coherence function simultaneously, which increases your degrees of freedom significantly.
Kai: That’s true, but they emphasize that this is what makes it physically meaningful; it moves us closer to designing systems where spatial coherence is treated as an explicit design parameter.
Mira: And this idea naturally leads to the next step they propose: developing object-adaptive lensless system design criteria using information-theoretic approaches.
Lev: That’s the long-term goal, right? Moving from a fixed model to a dynamic one that knows how to adjust its coherence assumptions based on what you are trying to image.
Kai: Exactly. It shifts the focus from just making one algorithm work well on one class to creating systems optimized for different object classes.
The paper's improvements: Mira: So, let’s bring it all together as we wrap up the discussion on this paper, "Role of Spatial Coherence in Single-Shot Lensless Image Reconstruction." The main implication is that spatial coherence is a consequential component of the inverse problem you have to solve.
Kai: To summarize, they showed that incorporating partial spatial coherence into the forward model improves reconstruction quality by yielding better agreement with measured detector intensities.
Lev: And they pinpointed that this effect is maximized for high-frequency high-density objects because those features demand a lot from the system in terms of accurate spatial frequency transfer.
Mira: So, when designing these systems, you need to treat spatial coherence as an explicit design and modelling parameter rather than just an incidental property of the illumination.
Kai: That’s the final message we want to get across: if you don't account for it, especially for dense features, your reconstruction will be less accurate and less faithful to reality.
Lev: We need to keep pushing on developing those object-adaptive criteria so that future lensless systems are optimized specifically for the objects they are meant to image.
Mira: That’s where the research goes next: using information-theoretic approaches to guide system design based on what we learn about coherence effects.
Kai: It's a lot of work, but it shows that understanding this physical detail is what separates a good reconstruction from one that is truly accurate.
Conclusion: Kai: So to wrap up, this paper on "Role of Spatial Coherence in Single-Shot Lensless Image Reconstruction" shows that ignoring partial spatial coherence leads to errors being mistaken for real object structure when you reconstruct an image.
Mira: Exactly. They used a generalized van Cittert-Zernike Schell model and showed that when you include the actual coherence function, the reconstructed image quality actually improves, especially for those dense high-frequency features.
Lev: From my side, it confirms that this isn't just an abstract mathematical fix; it’s about how your actual measurement system behaves under real-world illumination conditions.
Kai: And they did this by comparing their model against a conventional coherent propagator and the results showed significant quantitative gains in metrics like Pearson correlation coefficient and high-frequency retention error.
Mira: That improvement is most noticeable when you look at the structural classes, particularly high frequency high density objects where those many closely spaced boundaries really stress the reconstruction process.
Lev: I’d say for real hardware, that means your error correction overhead lands differently depending on whether you model it coherently or partially; it's not a simple constant factor increase.
Kai: So, if you're building a system today, this paper tells you that the forward model needs to reflect the illumination reality because treating coherence as an assumption is what causes most of your errors.
Mira: It really reinforces that spatial coherence has to be treated as an explicit design parameter in these lensless imaging systems moving forward, not just something you hope is there.
Lev: I agree. It pushes us toward those object-adaptive criteria you mentioned earlier, so we can optimize the source coherence based on what we are actually trying to image.
Kai: That’s where the next piece of research comes in—figuring out how to use information theory to guide that design process for different object types.
Mira: Yeah, it sets up a really clear path for future work: linking the physical properties of the source illumination directly into the system's optimization goals.
Lev: It’s about moving from just building a solver that runs on one coherent assumption to building something that understands and adapts to partial coherence.
Kai: That’s what we looked at with this paper on "Role of Spatial Coherence in Single-Shot Lensless Image Reconstruction." For those who want to know more about how we actually cooled the qubits for those fidelity numbers, that's another show next week.
School of Electrical and Electronic Engineering, Nanyang Technological University · Institute for Digital Molecular Analytics and Science
physics.optics
Submitted: 2026-07-17
Updated: 2026-07-17
Comments: Main text and supplement with 4 and 3 figures respectively
Journal ref: Opt. Lett (2026)
DOI: 10.1364/OL.611778
License: http://arxiv.org/licenses/nonexclusive-distrib/1.0/
Importance score: 92/100
The gist: Lensless imaging performance is strongly dependent on the forward model used during image reconstruction because common assumptions about fully coherent propagation lead to errors when illumination…
Key concepts
- Fully Coherent Propagation
- This is the common, simplified assumption in imaging where light waves are assumed to be perfectly synchronized across the entire object plane. The paper shows this assumption fails when real-world illumination has partial coherence, leading to incorrect image reconstructions.
- Partial Spatial Coherence
- This describes a real-world scenario where light sources used for imaging do not have perfect synchronization or spatial correlation across the object being imaged. Incorporating this partial coherence into the mathematical model leads to more accurate results.
- Generalized van Cittert-Zernike Schell Model
- This is a specific mathematical framework used to model how light propagates through an optical system, allowing researchers to introduce the effect of partial spatial coherence into the forward model. It helps bridge the gap between idealized and real-world imaging conditions.
- Object Classes (HFHD, HFLD, LFHD, LFLD)
- These are different categories of objects tested in the simulation based on their structural properties, such as how dense or low-frequency their features are. The paper analyzes how the coherence model affects reconstruction performance for each specific type of object.
Terminology
Summary
Lensless imaging performance is strongly dependent on the forward model used during image reconstruction because common assumptions about fully coherent propagation lead to errors when illumination exhibits partial spatial coherence. p. 0 This paper examines the role of spatial coherence in single-shot lensless image reconstruction using a generalized van Cittert-Zernike Schell propagation model to show that incorporating partial coherence into the forward model preserves object structure and improves image quality. p. 0
The Problem with Coherent Assumptions
A common source of reconstruction error is the assumption of fully coherent propagation, even when the illumination exhibits partial spatial coherence in practice. Many practical lensless imaging systems operate with extended sources for which the object plane illumination is only partially spatially coherent. p. 0 This partial coherence influences resolution, contrast transfer, and reconstruction performance across various imaging modalities. p. 0 Since single-shot reconstruction relies entirely on the assumed forward model, these coherence-dependent changes in the diffraction pattern are incorrectly attributed to the object. p. 0
Modeling Spatial Coherence
The paper introduces a coherence-aware forward model based on the generalized van Cittert-Zernike Schell propagation to examine coherence-induced model mismatch. The normalized coherence function is given by a function of the separation between two points in the object plane, denoted as µF (ξo). p. 1 The detector-plane intensity under partial spatial coherence is expressed as Ipc(rd; zod) = F∆ro→rd→∆ro[Icoh(rd; zod)] µF (ξo). p. 1 The fully coherent point-source limit reduces this to the coherent intensity given by Icoh(rd; zod) = Pzod t(ro) exp[ik2zsoro2] (rd). p. 1
Impact on Object Classes
The analysis simulated ensembles of amplitude-only objects spanning four structural classes: high-frequency high-density (HFHD), high-frequency low-density (HFLD), low-frequency high-density (LFHD), and low-frequency low-density (LFLD). Reconstructions obtained with a coherence-aware inverse model are compared with those from a conventional coherent propagator. p. 0 For dense high-frequency features, incorporating partial coherence can preserve object structure and improve image quality. p. 0
Quantitative Reconstruction Advantage
Quantitative comparison using metrics like Pearson correlation coefficient (PCC), high-frequency retention error (HFRE), low-frequency retention error (LFRE), and edge F1 score (EF1) reveals class-dependent advantages. HFHD objects exhibit the largest and most consistent positive improvement from use of Mpc. p. 2 The coherence-aware model preserves the dominant object structure across considered source radii. p. 2
Experimental Validation
Experimental verification using a lensless measurement of a USAF resolution target under partially coherent illumination confirmed the forward-model analysis. The partially coherent model yielded PCC = 0. p. 39871 and FC = 0. p. 39906, compared with PCC = 0. p. 39212 and FC = 0. p. 39396 for the coherent model. p. 3 The results establish spatial coherence as a defining component of the inverse problem in lensless imaging. p. 0
Phase Object Analysis
For phase objects, coherence-aware inversion improves boundary localisation most consistently across all classes. The spectral advantages are strongest for high-frequency phase objects, whereas low-frequency phase objects show weaker or negative spectral-error enhancement despite improvements in boundary recovery. p. 3 p. 3 This supports the conclusion that spatial coherence must be treated as an explicit design and modelling parameter in lensless imaging. p. 4
Conclusion
In conclusion, our results establish spatial coherence as a consequential component of the lensless imaging inverse problem. Incorporating partial spatial coherence into the forward model improves reconstruction quality and yields closer agreement with measured detector intensities. p. 4 The improvement is greatest when the target contains fine, densely distributed features, because such objects place a greater demand on accurate spatialfrequency transfer and boundary localisation. p. 4 Future work could use such criteria to optimise the source coherence for specified objects and imaging tasks. p. 4
Acknowledgments
Ministry of Education, Singapore (RG137/24, EDUN C-33-18-279-V12); Agency for Science, Technology and Research, Singapore (H25-MRG3483).
References
[1] W. Bishara, T. p. 4-W. Su, A. F. Coskun, and A. p. 4 Ozcan, Optics Express 18, 11181 (2010) <ref:2607. p. 415765#pg4>
[2] A. Greenbaum, W. p. 4 Luo, T.-W. Su, et al., Science Translational Medicine 6, 267ra175 (2014) <ref:2607. p. 415765#pg5>
[3] G. M. Balasubramaniam, X. p. 4-L. Chu, R. V. Nair, and M. p. 4 R. Foreman, arXiv preprint arXiv:2604. p. 422270 (2026)
[4] S. O. Isikman, W. p. 4 Bishara, and A. p. 4 Ozcan, Applied Optics 50, H253 (2011)
[5] Y. Chen, X. Wu, L. Lu, et al., Optics Letters 47, 6061 (2022)
[6] M. R. Foreman and P. p. 0 T¨or¨ok, Journal of the Optical Society of America A 26, 2470 (2009)
[7] Y. Bian, W. Wang, A. Hussain, et al. p. 4, Optics Communications 434, 136 (2019)
[8] Y. Cai and F. Wang, Optics Letters 32, 205 (2007)
[9] M. Montoya, M. p. 4 p. 4 J. Lopera Acosta, Y. p. 4 p. 4 Nie, and D. p. 4 p. 4 Blinder, Optics Express 33, 46313 (2025)
[10] K. Pearson, Proceedings of the Royal Society of London 58, 240 (1895)
[11] J. Canny, IEEE Transactions on Pattern Analysis and Machine Intelligence PAMI-8, 679 (1986)
[12] D. R. Martin, C. C. Fowlkes, and J. p. 4 p. 4 Malik, IEEE Transactions on Pattern Analysis and Machine Intelligence 26, 530 (2004)
[13] L. A. Kabuli, H. Pinkard, E. p. 4 p. 4 Markley, et al. p. 4 p. 4, Optica 13, 227 (2026)
Supplemental Material Summary
This supplemental document describes the object generation process and extends the analysis of spatial coherence in lensless image reconstruction to phase objects. It details the synthetic object library generation, which included 25 objects for each structural class (HFHD, HFLD, LFHD, LFLD). p. 6 Phase recovery was performed using two detector-plane intensities to reduce ambiguities pronounced with phase-only inversion. p. 9 The results show that coherence-aware inversion improves phase boundary localisation most consistently across all classes. p. 3
Object Generation Process
The synthetic object library was generated from glyph-based binary patterns using MATLAB. Each object was created on a 2000 × 2000 pixel grid and assigned to one of four structural classes. p. 6 High-frequency objects were generated using smaller, sharper glyphs, whereas low-frequency objects were generated using larger glyphs with Gaussian smoothing. p. 6 Occupancy masks and class-dependent Gaussian smoothing were used to control effective spatial-frequency content. p. 7
Phase Object Reconstruction
The phase object is modelled as a unit-modulus transmittance, t(ro) = exp[iϕ(ro)], 0 ≤ ϕ(ro) ≤ 2π. Phase recovery was performed using two detector-plane intensities, generated at zod = 2 mm and zod = 4 mm. p. 9 The comparison shows that coherence mismatch also affects phase recovery, although the observed improvement differs from that in the amplitude case because phase reconstruction uses two detector planes. p. 9
Quantitative Phase Metrics
Quantitative phase analysis used PCC, HFRE, LFRE, and EF1 metrics. Coherence-aware inversion produces the most consistent improvement in boundary recovery across all phase-object classes. p. 3 The spectral advantages are strongest for high-frequency phase objects, whereas low-frequency phase objects show weaker or negative spectral-error enhancement despite improvements in boundary recovery.
Final Conclusion on Coherence
The results support the conclusion of the main article that spatial coherence must be treated as an explicit component of the lensless inverse model. This finding indicates that coherence should be treated as an explicit design and modelling parameter in lensless imaging rather than as an incidental property of the illumination. p. 4 Recent information-theoretic approaches to object-dependent lensless system design provide a natural framework for extending this analysis. p. 4
[1] Y. LeCun, C. Cortes, and C. J. Burges, “MNIST handwritten digit database,” ATT Labs [Online] 2, 5 (2010)
[9] M. Montoya, M. J. Lopera Acosta, Y. Nie, and D. Blinder, Optics Express 33, 46313 (2025)
[11] J. Canny, IEEE Transactions on Pattern Analysis and Machine Intelligence PAMI-8, 679 (1986)
[12] D. R. Martin, C. C. Fowlkes, and J. Malik, IEEE Transactions on Pattern Analysis and Machine Intelligence 26, 530 (2004)
[13] L. A. Kabuli, H. Pinkard, E. Markley, et al.
Green — the paper says it, and the page is printed. Red — no passage carries it, so treat that sentence as unverified. The same check runs on your own text: check a summary against its source, $5.
Improvements for AI systems
-
Update lensless image reconstruction algorithms to incorporate a coherence-aware forward model based on generalised van Cittert-Zernike Schell propagation instead of assuming fully coherent propagation. This allows the system to preserve object structure and improve image quality, especially for dense high-spatial-frequency features, by explicitly accounting for partial spatial coherence in illumination.
-
Implement an inverse problem solver that minimizes an objective function including a term like Jnu(t) which balances structural similarity (SSIM) and mean squared error (MSE) using both the partially coherent operator Mpc and the fully coherent operator Mcoh. This ensures that reconstructions are not solely dependent on the numerical formulation but also on the physical accuracy of the forward model, as stated in equation 7.
-
Develop object-adaptive lensless system design criteria by using information-theoretic approaches to optimize source coherence for specified objects and imaging tasks. This enables the creation of systems where
spatial coherence is treated as an explicit design and modelling parameter
rather than an incidental property of the illumination, leading to optimized performance for different object classes. -
Enhance phase object reconstruction capabilities by utilizing a two-plane detector configuration during measurement, which provides
additional propagation diversity, reducing ambiguities that are more pronounced with phase-only inversion.
This leads to more consistent improvement in boundary localization across all phase-object classes when coherence is considered. -
For high frequency high density (HFHD) objects, design the system to prioritize boundary localization improvements as these objects
generate many closely spaced boundaries and a broad spatial-frequency spectrum,
making them highly sensitive to partial coherence. The improved system will yield apositive DeltaEF1
across all source radii for phase objects in this class.
Sources
Related papers
- Raman optical activity and helicity-dependent phonon splitting in chiral CoSi
- Stability and optical quality of "windmill"-formed 8CB liquid crystal films for replenishable plasma mirrors
- Experimental Scaling of Diffraction Efficiency in Laser-Induced Plasma Gratings
- Photonic Exceptional Topological Bound States in the Continuum
- SHAPE: a sparse Hamiltonian approach for prescribing eigenstates in metamaterials
- All-photonic millimeter-wave and terahertz signal core at room and cryogenic temperatures