Scaling of the minimal energy for turbulence transition in pipe flow

arXiv:2606.23269 · physics.flu-dyn · Submitted 2026-06-22 · Read on arXiv

Listen

Radio episode about this paper

Transcript

Introduction to the show: ident: Physics. The day in general physics: instruments, methods and results across the field.

Kai: I'm Kai.

Mira: And I'm Mira, here with Lev.

Kai: We're looking at the paper: "Scaling of the minimal energy for turbulence transition in pipe flow".

Mira: Here's the gist of the paper. Predicting the transition of turbulence in pipe flow remains a fundamental problem in fluid dynamics.

Kai: The minimum perturbation energy required to cause transition in pipe flow scales as O (Re-3).

Mira: Understanding and predicting the transition between laminar and turbulent states is a central problem in fluid dynamics since the pioneering work of Reynolds.

Kai: The difficulty in predicting transition stems from the linear stability of the system up to at least Re ≥ 107.

Title and authors: Kai: So this paper is called "Scaling of the minimal energy for turbulence transition in pipe flow". Mira, what's the real takeaway from that title?

Mira: It sounds very specific, focusing on how much energy you need to start turbulence in a pipe, and scaling with something. It suggests they are looking at the minimum amount of disturbance required to break laminar flow.

Lev: From an engineering standpoint, I wonder if this minimal energy is something we can actually measure in a real system without needing impossibly small initial perturbations.

Kai: Exactly, because usually these transition studies rely on linear stability theory which tells us that up to Reynolds numbers like one hundred seven the flow is stable <ref:2606.23269#pg2>. This paper seems to be pushing beyond that linear boundary to find where things actually break down experimentally.

Mira: Right, and the authors are using a variational approach to compute nonlinear optimal perturbations for pipe flow when the Reynolds number is less than or equal to five thousand <ref:2606.23269#pg1,a variational approach to compute nonlinear optimal perturbations>. That’s a specific range they’re testing.

Lev: If you're looking at real hardware, that Reynolds number constraint is important because we have to worry about how much computational overhead it adds when trying to model these nonlinear effects.

Kai: It seems the whole point is showing that even in this relatively low Reynolds number regime, we can still find the optimal way to trigger transition using these nonlinear perturbations.

The paper's summary: Mira: So, what’s the actual finding here? Basically, they found that transition happens when the energy of a perturbation crosses a certain threshold and it scales with Reynolds number in a specific way.

Kai: They found that this minimum required energy scales as O of Re to the power negative three. That's quite a specific scaling law they’ve derived for the threshold.

Lev: O of Re to the power negative three is something we need to check against our simulations because it dictates how small an initial seed perturbation needs to be if we want a certain transition probability.

Mira: The authors identify these optimal perturbations as nonlinear optimal perturbations, or NLOPs, which are special disturbances that combine the Orr and lift-up mechanisms with a nonlinear oblique phase.

Kai: They show that these NLOPs are what actually trigger transition efficiently because they outgrow the simpler linear optimal perturbations.

Lev: But I have to ask, how robust is this finding? Does it hold up when we try to run these simulations on actual hardware instead of just on a pseudo-spectral code like nsPipe-GPU?

Mira: Well, they set up a checkpointing procedure using the direct adjoint optimization procedure in the GPU version of their Navier Stokes code. They found that for a pipe length L equal to fifty the energy gain becomes independent of L, which is good for them <ref:2606.23269#pg3>.

Kai: And they verified their spatial resolution by simulating the last optimal perturbation inside the laminar attractor at Reynolds number four thousand with a spatial resolution of one hundred forty-four radial points, one hundred twenty azimuthal modes, and five hundred forty axial modes <ref:2606.23269#pg3,the last optimal perturbation inside the laminar attractor>.

The paper's improvements: Kai: One big improvement they point out is how the optimal perturbations behave as the Reynolds number increases. They say that while the structure stays similar, it starts to localize more, with their radial thickness scaling as delta r proportional to Re to the power negative one over three.

Mira: So, as flow gets faster and more turbulent, these optimal structures don't just get bigger; they get squeezed in space. That localization is key for understanding where the energy goes.

Lev: If the thickness scales that way, it means that for higher Reynolds numbers, you need a much sharper initial seed perturbation to maintain that optimal structure before it triggers transition.

Kai: They also discuss how the energy gain during the Orr phase increases linearly with Re but is independent of your initial energy E0. That part seems quite powerful because it suggests the mechanism itself drives the growth initially.

Mira: And then there’s that lift-up phase, where they say the energy gain scales as proportional to Re to the power two. That nonlinear interaction between oblique waves and lift-up is what really pushes things over the edge.

Lev: So, if we were trying to build a real hardware system for this, we'd need to manage that transition from linear growth driven by Re to this quadratic growth phase driven by E0 and Re squared. That’s a lot of dynamics for any controller.

Conclusion: Kai: So, wrapping up the Scaling of the minimal energy for turbulence transition in pipe flow paper, we see that NLOPs are the key drivers here because they combine those initial linear Orr growth with that subsequent strong nonlinear interaction from oblique waves and lift-up.

Mira: The main conclusion they draw is that to find this minimal seed, you need an initial perturbation energy E crit zero that scales as Etr multiplied by Re to the power negative three, where Etr is approximately zero point one three <ref:2606.23269#pg1>.

Lev: For hardware design, this means if we want to reach a certain transition probability at a high Reynolds number, we need to ensure our seed energy is proportional to Re negative three.

Kai: And they also noted that this minimal seed structure remains similar but localizes as the Reynolds number increases, with that radial thickness decreasing as delta r proportional to Re negative one over three.

Mira: It’s interesting because they pinpoint exactly how the nonlinearities enhance the growth via that lift-up mechanism, which strongly depends on E0 and Re squared.

Lev: I just want to say that while their scaling relationship is helpful for prediction, we still have to figure out how much overhead that actual nonlinear optimization procedure adds when you try to run it on real hardware instead of a simulator.

Kai: Yeah, so we’ve seen what they’ve done with this specific case in the Scaling of the minimal energy for turbulence transition in pipe flow paper. That's where we are for now.

Center of Applied Space Technology and Microgravity at University of Bremen · MAPEX Center for Materials and Processes at University of Bremen

physics.flu-dyn

Submitted: 2026-06-22

Updated: 2026-11-12

License: http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-nd/4.0/

Importance score: 76/100

The gist: Predicting the transition of turbulence in pipe flow remains a fundamental problem in fluid dynamics.

Key concepts

Nonlinear Optimal Perturbations (NLOPs)
These are specific, localized perturbations that grow fastest in time. They achieve this by combining two mechanisms: the Orr mechanism and the lift-up mechanism, linked by a nonlinear oblique phase. These structures are crucial because they efficiently trigger transition from laminar flow.
Orr Mechanism
This is an initial growth phase where the energy gain of a perturbation is independent of its initial size (E0) but increases linearly with the Reynolds number (Re). It sets up the initial instability that allows for further nonlinear development and energy extraction.
Lift-up Mechanism
This mechanism involves strong nonlinear interactions between various oblique modes, leading to the growth of streaks and cross-sectional vortices. This phase is highly dependent on the initial energy (E0) and Reynolds number, significantly amplifying the perturbation's energy before transition occurs.

Terminology

Summary

Predicting the transition of turbulence in pipe flow remains a fundamental problem in fluid dynamics. p. 0

Where the paper says it

Moron´ 1 and M. Avila 12 1Center of Applied Space Technology and Microgravity (ZARM), University of Bremen, Am Fallturm 2, 28359 Bremen, Germany 2MAPEX Center for Materials and Processes, University of Bremen, Am Biologischen Garten 2, 28359 Bremen, Germany Corresponding author: xxxx (Received xx; revised xx; accepted xx) Predicting the transition of turbulence in pipe flow remains a fundamental problem in fluid dynamics.

The minimum perturbation energy required to cause transition in pipe flow scales as O (Re-3). p. 0
Where the paper says it

We find that regardless of the Reynolds number, transition occurs if the energy of the perturbation exceeds a constant threshold. As a result, the minimum perturbation energy required to cause transition in pipe flow scales as O (𝑅𝑒−3 ).

Background and Problem Statement

Understanding and predicting the transition between laminar and turbulent states is a central problem in fluid dynamics since the pioneering work of Reynolds. The difficulty in predicting transition stems from the linear stability of the system up to at least Re ≥ 107. p. 0

Where the paper says it

Predicting the transition to turbulence, however, is extremely difficult. This difficulty stems from the linear stability of the system up to at least 𝑅𝑒 ≳ 107 (Meseguer & Trefethen 2003), whereas transition in †patrick.

This discrepancy between linear stability and experimental observations is due to finite–amplitude perturbations that can experience a significant transient amplification by extracting energy from the laminar flow. p. 1
Where the paper says it

Avila ´ experiments is observed between 1500 ≲ 𝑅𝑒 ≲ 105 (Pfenniger 1961). The discrepancy between linear stability and experimental observations is due to finite– amplitude perturbations that can experience a significant transient amplification by extracting energy from the laminar flow (Schmid & Henningson 2001).

Optimal Perturbation Structures

The optimal perturbation, i.e. the perturbation that experiences the highest energy gain G = E(T)/E0 at a time t = T, consists of a pair of streamwise independent vortices in the linear regime. p. 1

Where the paper says it

In the linear regime, 𝐸0 → 0, the optimal perturbation, i. the perturbation that experiences the highest energy gain 𝐺 = 𝐸(𝑇)/𝐸0 at a time 𝑡 = 𝑇, consists of a pair of streamwise independent vortices (Schmid & Henningson 1994).

Nonlinear optimal perturbations (NLOPs) emerge for sufficiently large E0 and are fully localised in space. p. 1
Where the paper says it

In all systems, NLOPs emerges for sufficiently large 𝐸0. They are fully localised in space and leverage a combination of Orr and lift–up mechanism connected by a nonlinear oblique phase to significantly outgrow LOPs and efficiently trigger transition (Kerswell 2018).

These NLOPs leverage a combination of Orr and lift–up mechanism connected by a nonlinear oblique phase to significantly outgrow LOPs and efficiently trigger transition. p. 1
Where the paper says it

In all systems, NLOPs emerges for sufficiently large 𝐸0. They are fully localised in space and leverage a combination of Orr and lift–up mechanism connected by a nonlinear oblique phase to significantly outgrow LOPs and efficiently trigger transition (Kerswell 2018).

Growth Mechanisms in the Nonlinear Regime

The energy gain during the Orr phase is independent of E0 but increases linearly with Re, scaling as GOrr ≈ C1Re. Afterwards, the evolution is characterized by strong nonlinear interactions of various oblique modes leading to the growth of rolls and streaks. p. 6

Where the paper says it

2) where 𝐶1 ≈ 0. Afterwards, the evolution is characterised by strong nonlinear interactions of various oblique modes leading to the growth of rolls and streaks and a de-localisation of the perturbation.

The energy gain during the oblique and lift–up phase strongly depends on E0, scaling approximately as Glift ≈ C2 (Emax)Re squared. p. 6
Where the paper says it

In contrast to the Orr phase, the energy growth during the oblique and lift-up phase strongly depends on 𝐸0 (figure 3𝑎). To identify the dependence of the energy gain on 𝑅𝑒 during this phase, we compare NLOPs at different 𝑅𝑒 interpolated to reach the same maximum dimensionless amplification, here 𝐸max = 0.

Scaling of the Instability Threshold

The overall energy gain is governed by a sequence of linear Orr phase and quadratic oblique wave and lift-up phase. The transition criterion reads Ecrit0 C1ReC2 (Etr)Re squared > Etr. p. 6

Where the paper says it

The Orr phase dominates the energy gain for 𝑅𝑒 ≲ 1750. Considering that NLOPs need to surpass an approximately constant threshold energy to trigger turbulence, the transition criterion reads 𝐸 crit 0 𝐶1𝑅𝑒𝐶2 (𝐸tr)𝑅𝑒2 > 𝐸tr.

This leads to the instability threshold scaling as Ecrit0 > Etr C1C2 (Etr)Re-3 ≈ (6. p. 1
Where the paper says it

Various studies determined the critical perturbation amplitude required to trigger transition as a function of 𝑅𝑒 for different types of perturbations. Generally, the instability threshold follows a power law scaling, 𝐸 crit 0 ∝ 𝑅𝑒𝛾 , whereas the scaling exponent ranges between 𝛾 = −2.

09 · 105)Re-3. p. 1
Where the paper says it

Moron and M. p. 0

Where the paper says it

Keuchel1† , D. Moron´ 1 and M.

p. 0
Where the paper says it

Keuchel1† , D. Moron´ 1 and M.

p. 0
Where the paper says it

Keuchel1† , D. Moron´ 1 and M.

p. 0
Where the paper says it

Keuchel1† , D. Moron´ 1 and M.

p. 0
Where the paper says it

Keuchel1† , D. Moron´ 1 and M.

p. 0
Where the paper says it

Keuchel1† , D. Moron´ 1 and M.

p. 0
Where the paper says it

Keuchel1† , D. Moron´ 1 and M.

p. 0
Where the paper says it

Keuchel1† , D. Moron´ 1 and M.

Avila ´ experiments is observed between 1500 ≲ 𝑅𝑒 ≲ 105 (Pfenniger 1961).

Reynolds Number Dependence

As Re increases, the minimal seed remains structurally similar but further localises, with its radial thickness decreasing approximately as Δr ∝ Re-1/3. The instability threshold of nonlinear optimal perturbations approximately decreases as Ecrit0 ∝ Re-3 due to the combination of Orr mechanism, lift-up mechanism and strong nonlinearities. p. 7

Where the paper says it

With increasing 𝑅𝑒, NLOPs remain qualitatively identical but further localise in (𝑟, 𝜃, 𝑧) whereas their radial thickness decreases as 𝛿𝑟 ∝ 𝑅𝑒−1/3 . The instability threshold of nonlinear optimal perturbations approximately decreases as 𝐸 crit 0 ∝ 𝑅𝑒−3 due the combination of Orr mechanism, lift-up mechanism and strong nonlinearities.

p. 7
Where the paper says it

With increasing 𝑅𝑒, NLOPs remain qualitatively identical but further localise in (𝑟, 𝜃, 𝑧) whereas their radial thickness decreases as 𝛿𝑟 ∝ 𝑅𝑒−1/3 . The instability threshold of nonlinear optimal perturbations approximately decreases as 𝐸 crit 0 ∝ 𝑅𝑒−3 due the combination of Orr mechanism, lift-up mechanism and strong nonlinearities.

This confirms that NLOPs must reach a minimal energy of about Etr ≈ 0. p. 7
Where the paper says it

5) with the numerical results and find excellent agreement with the critical initial energy for 𝑅𝑒 ≳ 1750 (compare the black triangles and line). Thus, to trigger turbulence transition, NLOPs must reach a minimal energy of about 𝐸tr ≳ 0.

13 independent of Re, whereas the required initial energy reduces as Ecrit0 ∝ Re-3. p. 7
Where the paper says it

Thus, to trigger turbulence transition, NLOPs must reach a minimal energy of about 𝐸tr ≳ 0. 13 independent of 𝑅𝑒, whereas the required initial energy of NLOPs to surpass this threshold reduces as 𝐸 crit 0 ∝ 𝑅𝑒−3 .

Conclusion and Implications

NLOPs initially grow via the Orr mechanism with an energy gain that is independent of E0 but increases linearly with Re. Subsequently, NLOPs rely on bent streaks and nonlinear interaction of oblique waves to sustain cross-sectional vortices and to transfer energy into low wavenumber modes that experience a large long term amplification. p. 7

Where the paper says it

NLOPs initially grow via the Orr mechanism with an energy gain that is independent of 𝐸0 but increases linearly with 𝑅𝑒. Subsequently, NLOPs rely on bent streaks and nonlinear interaction of oblique waves to sustain cross-sectional vortices and to transfer energy into low wavenumber modes that experience a large long term amplification.

Effectively, nonlinearities enhance the growth by the lift-up mechanism and the energy gain strongly increases with E0 and Re. p. 7
Where the paper says it

Subsequently, NLOPs rely on bent streaks and nonlinear interaction of oblique waves to sustain cross-sectional vortices and to transfer energy into low wavenumber modes that experience a large long term amplification. Effectively, nonlinearities enhance the growth by the lift-up mechanism and the energy gain strongly increases with 𝐸0 and 𝑅𝑒.

Once it surpasses a critical value, Emax > Etr, large amplitude streaks generated by the lift-up mechanism become unstable and trigger transition in the form of puffs or slugs. p. 7
Where the paper says it

Effectively, nonlinearities enhance the growth by the lift-up mechanism and the energy gain strongly increases with 𝐸0 and 𝑅𝑒. Once surpasses a critical value, 𝐸max > 𝐸tr, independent of 𝑅𝑒, large amplitude streaks generated by the lift-up mechanism become unstable and trigger transition in the form of puffs or slugs.

The instability threshold of nonlinear optimal perturbations approximately decreases as Ecrit0 ∝ Re-3 due to the combination of Orr mechanism, lift-up mechanism and strong nonlinearities.

Acknowledgement

This work was funded by the Deutsche Forschungsgemeinschaft (DFG) in the framework of the research unit FOR 2688 ’Instabilities, Bifurcations and Migration in Pulsatile Flows’ under grant number 349558021, which is gratefully acknowledged.

References

Avila, K., Moxey, D. p. 8

Where the paper says it

REFERENCES Avila, K. , Moxey, D.

, Lozar, A. p. 8
Where the paper says it

, Moxey, D. , Lozar, A.

De, Avila, M. p. 0
Where the paper says it

Moron´ 1 and M. Avila 12 1Center of Applied Space Technology and Microgravity (ZARM), University of Bremen, Am Fallturm 2, 28359 Bremen, Germany 2MAPEX Center for Materials and Processes, University of Bremen, Am Biologischen Garten 2, 28359 Bremen, Germany Corresponding author: xxxx (Received xx; revised xx; accepted xx) Predicting the transition of turbulence in pipe flow remains a fundamental problem in fluid dynamics.

, Barkley, D. p. 8
Where the paper says it

De, Avila, M. , Barkley, D.

& Hof, B. 2011 The onset of turbulence in pipe flow

Chagelishvili, G., Hau, J., Khujadze, G. p. 8

Where the paper says it

Chagelishvili, G. , Khujadze, G.

& Oberlack, M. p. 8
Where the paper says it

, Khujadze, G. & Oberlack, M.

2016 Mechanical picture of the linear transient growth of vortical perturbations in incompressible smooth shear flows

Chapman, S. J. 2002 Subcritical transition in channel flows

Cherubini, S., Palma, P. p. 8

Where the paper says it

Cherubini, S. , Palma, P.

p. 8
Where the paper says it

Cherubini, S. , Palma, P.

p. 8
Where the paper says it

Cherubini, S. , Palma, P.

De & Robinet, J. p. 8
Where the paper says it

, Palma, P. De & Robinet, J.

-Ch. 2015 Nonlinear optimals in the asymptotic suction boundary layer: Transition thresholds and symmetry breaking

Cherubini, S., Palma, P. De, Robinet, J. p. 8

Where the paper says it

, Palma, P. De & Robinet, J.

p. 8
Where the paper says it

, Palma, P. De & Robinet, J.

-Ch. & Bottaro, A. p. 8
Where the paper says it

De, Robinet, J. & Bottaro, A.

p. 8
Where the paper says it

De, Robinet, J. & Bottaro, A.

2010 Rapid path to transition via nonlinear localized optimal perturbations in a boundary-layer flow

Cherubini, S., Palma, P. De, Robinet, J.-Ch. & Bottaro, A. 2011 The minimal seed of turbulent transition in the boundary layer

Duguet, Y., Brandt, L. p. 8

Where the paper says it

689, 221–253. , Brandt, L.

p. 8
Where the paper says it

689, 221–253. , Brandt, L.

p. 8
Where the paper says it

689, 221–253. , Brandt, L.

& Larsson, B. p. 8
Where the paper says it

, Brandt, L. & Larsson, B.

R. J. 2010 Towards minimal perturbations in transitional plane couette flow

Duguet, Y., Monokrousos, A. p. 1

Where the paper says it

Nonlinear optimal perturbations (NLOPs) have been computed for boundary–layer flow (Cherubini et al. 2010, 2011), plane Couette flow (Monokrousos et al.

, Brandt, L. & Henningson, D. p. 1
Where the paper says it

Avila ´ experiments is observed between 1500 ≲ 𝑅𝑒 ≲ 105 (Pfenniger 1961). The discrepancy between linear stability and experimental observations is due to finite– amplitude perturbations that can experience a significant transient amplification by extracting energy from the laminar flow (Schmid & Henningson 2001).

p. 1
Where the paper says it

Avila ´ experiments is observed between 1500 ≲ 𝑅𝑒 ≲ 105 (Pfenniger 1961). The discrepancy between linear stability and experimental observations is due to finite– amplitude perturbations that can experience a significant transient amplification by extracting energy from the laminar flow (Schmid & Henningson 2001).

p. 1
Where the paper says it

Avila ´ experiments is observed between 1500 ≲ 𝑅𝑒 ≲ 105 (Pfenniger 1961). The discrepancy between linear stability and experimental observations is due to finite– amplitude perturbations that can experience a significant transient amplification by extracting energy from the laminar flow (Schmid & Henningson 2001).

p. 1
Where the paper says it

Avila ´ experiments is observed between 1500 ≲ 𝑅𝑒 ≲ 105 (Pfenniger 1961). The discrepancy between linear stability and experimental observations is due to finite– amplitude perturbations that can experience a significant transient amplification by extracting energy from the laminar flow (Schmid & Henningson 2001).

S. 2013 Minimal transition threshold in plane couette flow

Ellingsen, T. & Palm, E. 1975 Stability of linear flow

Frame, P. & Towne, A. p. 8

Where the paper says it

noise with different correlations in space and time (similar to Frame & Towne (2024)). Comparing flow features of such suboptimal transition routes to NLOPs might reveal statistically dominant mechanisms and could contribute towards control techniques in systems where instantaneous perturbation structures are unknown but whose statistics may be prescribed.

2024 Beyond optimal disturbances: a statistical framework for transient growth

Henningson, D. S. 1996 Comment on ”transition in shear flows. p. 8

Where the paper says it

Henningson, D. 1996 Comment on ”transition in shear flows.

nonlinear normality versus non-normal linearity” [phys. p. 8
Where the paper says it

1996 Comment on ”transition in shear flows. nonlinear normality versus non-normal linearity” [phys.

fluids 7, 3060 (1995)]

Hof, B., Juel, A. & Mullin, T. p. 1

Where the paper says it

0 and depends on the details of the perturbation (Hof et al. 2003; Meseguer 2003; Peixinho & Mullin 2007; Mellibovsky & Meseguer 2009).

p. 1
Where the paper says it

0 and depends on the details of the perturbation (Hof et al. 2003; Meseguer 2003; Peixinho & Mullin 2007; Mellibovsky & Meseguer 2009).

2003 Scaling of the turbulence transition threshold in a pipe

Jimenez, J. ´ 2013 How linear is wall-bounded turbulence? p. 8

Where the paper says it

Jimenez, J. ´ 2013 How linear is wall-bounded turbulence?

Phys. Fluids 25, 110814

Kerswell, R. R. 2018 Nonlinear nonmodal stability theory

Kerswell, R. R., Pringle, C. p. 1

Where the paper says it

2011; Duguet et al. 2010, 2013) steady pipe flow (Pringle & Kerswell 2010; Pringle et al.

C. T. & Willis, A. p. 8
Where the paper says it

, Pringle, C. & Willis, A.

P. 2014 An optimization approach for analysing nonlinear stability with transition to turbulence in fluids as an example

Keuchel, P. & Avila, M. p. 0

Where the paper says it

Moron´ 1 and M. Avila 12 1Center of Applied Space Technology and Microgravity (ZARM), University of Bremen, Am Fallturm 2, 28359 Bremen, Germany 2MAPEX Center for Materials and Processes, University of Bremen, Am Biologischen Garten 2, 28359 Bremen, Germany Corresponding author: xxxx (Received xx; revised xx; accepted xx) Predicting the transition of turbulence in pipe flow remains a fundamental problem in fluid dynamics.

p. 0
Where the paper says it

Moron´ 1 and M. Avila 12 1Center of Applied Space Technology and Microgravity (ZARM), University of Bremen, Am Fallturm 2, 28359 Bremen, Germany 2MAPEX Center for Materials and Processes, University of Bremen, Am Biologischen Garten 2, 28359 Bremen, Germany Corresponding author: xxxx (Received xx; revised xx; accepted xx) Predicting the transition of turbulence in pipe flow remains a fundamental problem in fluid dynamics.

2025 Nonlinear optimal perturbation growth in pulsatile pipe flow

Landahl, M. T 1980 A note on an algebraic instability of inviscid parallel shear flows

Mellibovsky, F. & Meseguer, A. p. 0

Where the paper says it

Predicting the transition to turbulence, however, is extremely difficult. This difficulty stems from the linear stability of the system up to at least 𝑅𝑒 ≳ 107 (Meseguer & Trefethen 2003), whereas transition in †patrick.

2009 Critical threshold in pipe flow transition

Meseguer, A. ´ 2003 Streak breakdown instability in pipe poiseuille flow

Meseguer, A. & Trefethen, L. p. 0

Where the paper says it

Predicting the transition to turbulence, however, is extremely difficult. This difficulty stems from the linear stability of the system up to at least 𝑅𝑒 ≳ 107 (Meseguer & Trefethen 2003), whereas transition in †patrick.

N. ´ 2003 Linearized pipe flow to reynolds number 107

Monokrousos, A., Bottaro, A. p. 8

Where the paper says it

De, Robinet, J. & Bottaro, A.

, Brandt, L., Vita, A. Di & Henningson, D. p. 1
Where the paper says it

Avila ´ experiments is observed between 1500 ≲ 𝑅𝑒 ≲ 105 (Pfenniger 1961). The discrepancy between linear stability and experimental observations is due to finite– amplitude perturbations that can experience a significant transient amplification by extracting energy from the laminar flow (Schmid & Henningson 2001).

S. 2011 Nonequilibrium thermodynamics and the optimal path to turbulence in shear flows

Moron, D., Vela-Mart ´ ´ın, A. p. 9

Where the paper says it

Physical Review Letters 106. , Vela-Mart ´ ´ın, A.

& Avila, M. 2024 Predictability of decay events in transitional wall-bounded flows

Orr, W. M. F. 1907 The stability or instability of the steady motions of a perfect liquid and of viscous liquid

Peixinho, J. & Mullin, T. 2007 Finite-amplituzde thresholds for transition in pipe flow

Pfenniger, W. 1961 Boundary layer suction experiments with laminar flow at high reynolds numbers in the inlet length of a tube by various suction methods

Pringle, C. C. T. & Kerswell, R. p. 1

Where the paper says it

Similar scaling exponents where found in the asymptotic analysis of Chapman (2002) for different transition routes in plane Poiseuille flow. Nonlinear stability analysis enables the computation of the lowest–energy perturbation able to trigger transition, termed the minimal seed, which marks the lowest instability threshold (Kerswell 2018).

p. 1
Where the paper says it

Similar scaling exponents where found in the asymptotic analysis of Chapman (2002) for different transition routes in plane Poiseuille flow. Nonlinear stability analysis enables the computation of the lowest–energy perturbation able to trigger transition, termed the minimal seed, which marks the lowest instability threshold (Kerswell 2018).

p. 1
Where the paper says it

Similar scaling exponents where found in the asymptotic analysis of Chapman (2002) for different transition routes in plane Poiseuille flow. Nonlinear stability analysis enables the computation of the lowest–energy perturbation able to trigger transition, termed the minimal seed, which marks the lowest instability threshold (Kerswell 2018).

R. 2010 Using nonlinear transient growth to construct the minimal seed for shear flow turbulence

Pringle, C. C. T., Willis, A. p. 8

Where the paper says it

, Pringle, C. & Willis, A.

p. 8
Where the paper says it

, Pringle, C. & Willis, A.

P. & Kerswell, R. R. 2012 Minimal seeds for shear flow turbulence: using nonlinear transient growth to touch the edge of chaos

Pringle, C. C. T., Willis, A. P. & Kerswell, R. R. 2015 Fully localised nonlinear energy growth optimals in pipe flow

Reddy, S. C., Schmid, P. p. 1

Where the paper says it

Avila ´ experiments is observed between 1500 ≲ 𝑅𝑒 ≲ 105 (Pfenniger 1961). The discrepancy between linear stability and experimental observations is due to finite– amplitude perturbations that can experience a significant transient amplification by extracting energy from the laminar flow (Schmid & Henningson 2001).

J., Baggett, J. p. 9
Where the paper says it

, Schmid, P. , Baggett, J.

S. & Henningson, D. S. 1998 On stability of streamwise streaks and transition thresholds in plane channel flows

Reynolds, O. 1883 An experimental investigation of the circumstances which determine whether the motion of water shall be direct or sinuous, and of the law of resistance in parallel channels

Schmid, P. & Henningson, D. S. 1994 Optimal energy density growth in hagen-poiseuille flow

Schmid, P. & Henningson, D. S. 2001 Stability and Transition in Shear Flows

Trefethen, L. N., Trefethen, A. p. 0

Where the paper says it

Predicting the transition to turbulence, however, is extremely difficult. This difficulty stems from the linear stability of the system up to at least 𝑅𝑒 ≳ 107 (Meseguer & Trefethen 2003), whereas transition in †patrick.

E., Reddy, S. p. 1
Where the paper says it

In the presence of residual noise transition may be triggered by secondary instabilities of the inflectional streaky profile, provided that the initial perturbation amplitude is sufficiently large (Zikanov 1996). However, Reddy et al.

C. & Driscoll, T. p. 9
Where the paper says it

, Reddy, S. & Driscoll, T.

A. 1993 Hydrodynamic stability without eigenvalues

Zikanov, O. Y. 1996 On the instability of pipe poiseuille flow

--- Page 1 ---

Banner appropriate to article type will appear here in typeset article

Scaling of the minimal energy for turbulence transition in pipe flow

P. Keuchel1†, D. p. 0

Where the paper says it

Banner appropriate to article type will appear here in typeset article Scaling of the minimal energy for turbulence transition in pipe flow P. Keuchel1† , D.

Moron´ 1 and M. p. 0
Where the paper says it

Keuchel1† , D. Moron´ 1 and M.

Avila 12 Center of Applied Space Technology and Microgravity (ZARM), University of Bremen, Am Fallturm 2, 28359 Bremen, Germany MAPEX Center for Materials and Processes, University of Bremen, Am Biologischen Garten 2, 28359 Bremen <ref:2606. p. 0
Where the paper says it

Moron´ 1 and M. Avila 12 1Center of Applied Space Technology and Microgravity (ZARM), University of Bremen, Am Fallturm 2, 28359 Bremen, Germany 2MAPEX Center for Materials and Processes, University of Bremen, Am Biologischen Garten 2, 28359 Bremen, Germany Corresponding author: xxxx (Received xx; revised xx; accepted xx) Predicting the transition of turbulence in pipe flow remains a fundamental problem in fluid dynamics.

23269#pg2>.

Corresponding author: xxxx (received xx; revised xx; accepted xx)

--- Page 2 ---

P. Keuchel, D. p. 0

Where the paper says it

This difficulty stems from the linear stability of the system up to at least 𝑅𝑒 ≳ 107 (Meseguer & Trefethen 2003), whereas transition in †patrick. keuchel@zarm.

p. 0
Where the paper says it

This difficulty stems from the linear stability of the system up to at least 𝑅𝑒 ≳ 107 (Meseguer & Trefethen 2003), whereas transition in †patrick. keuchel@zarm.

p. 0
Where the paper says it

This difficulty stems from the linear stability of the system up to at least 𝑅𝑒 ≳ 107 (Meseguer & Trefethen 2003), whereas transition in †patrick. keuchel@zarm.

p. 0
Where the paper says it

This difficulty stems from the linear stability of the system up to at least 𝑅𝑒 ≳ 107 (Meseguer & Trefethen 2003), whereas transition in †patrick. keuchel@zarm.

p. 0
Where the paper says it

This difficulty stems from the linear stability of the system up to at least 𝑅𝑒 ≳ 107 (Meseguer & Trefethen 2003), whereas transition in †patrick. keuchel@zarm.

p. 0
Where the paper says it

This difficulty stems from the linear stability of the system up to at least 𝑅𝑒 ≳ 107 (Meseguer & Trefethen 2003), whereas transition in †patrick. keuchel@zarm.

p. 0
Where the paper says it

This difficulty stems from the linear stability of the system up to at least 𝑅𝑒 ≳ 107 (Meseguer & Trefethen 2003), whereas transition in †patrick. keuchel@zarm.

p. 0
Where the paper says it

This difficulty stems from the linear stability of the system up to at least 𝑅𝑒 ≳ 107 (Meseguer & Trefethen 2003), whereas transition in †patrick. keuchel@zarm.

Moron and M. Avila ´ <ref:2606. p. 0
Where the paper says it

uni-bremen. de 0 X0-1 arXiv:2606.

p. 0
Where the paper says it

uni-bremen. de 0 X0-1 arXiv:2606.

p. 0
Where the paper says it

uni-bremen. de 0 X0-1 arXiv:2606.

p. 0
Where the paper says it

uni-bremen. de 0 X0-1 arXiv:2606.

p. 0
Where the paper says it

uni-bremen. de 0 X0-1 arXiv:2606.

p. 0
Where the paper says it

uni-bremen. de 0 X0-1 arXiv:2606.

p. 0
Where the paper says it

uni-bremen. de 0 X0-1 arXiv:2606.

p. 0
Where the paper says it

uni-bremen. de 0 X0-1 arXiv:2606.

23269#pg2>

--- Page 3 ---

P. Keuchel, D. Moron and M. Avila ´ <ref:2606.23269#pg2>

--- Page 4 ---

P. Keuchel, D. Moron and M. Avila ´ <ref:2606.23269#pg2>

--- Page 5 ---

P. Keuchel, D. Moron and M. Avila ´ <ref:2606.23269#pg2>

--- Page 6 ---

P. Keuchel, D. Moron and M. Avila ´ <ref:2606.23269#pg2>

--- Page 7 ---

P. Keuchel, D. Moron and M. Avila ´ <ref:2606.23269#pg2>

--- Page 8 ---

P. Keuchel, D. Moron and M. Avila ´ <ref:2606.23269#pg2>

--- Page 9 ---

P. Keuchel, D. Moron and M. Avila ´ <ref:2606.

Green — the paper says it, and the page is printed. Red — no passage carries it, so treat that sentence as unverified. The same check runs on your own text: check a summary against its source, $5.

Improvements for AI systems

  1. The AI system can predict transition in pipe flow by computing optimal perturbations using a variational approach to compute nonlinear optimal perturbations to the laminar flow at Reynolds number Re less than or equal to 5000.

  2. The system can determine that transition occurs if the energy of the perturbation exceeds a constant threshold and that the minimum perturbation energy required to cause transition in pipe flow scales as O (Re-3).

  3. The AI system can compute the minimal seed for turbulent transition by finding NLOPs, which are defined as perturbations that leverage a combination of Orr and lift-up mechanism connected by a nonlinear oblique phase to significantly outgrow LOPs and efficiently trigger transition.

  4. The system can predict the critical initial energy E crit 0 (Re) of the minimal seed using the scaling relationship E crit 0 > Etr C1 C2 (Etr) Re-3, where Etr is approximately 0.13.

  5. The improved AI system can be used to analyze how NLOPs remain structurally similar but localize as Reynolds number increases, with their radial thickness decreasing as delta r proportional to Re-1/3.

Abstract

Predicting the transition to turbulence in pipe flow remains a fundamental problem in fluid dynamics. We use a variational approach to compute nonlinear optimal perturbations to the laminar flow. Optimal perturbations are structurally similar for all Reynolds numbers, 1750 at most Re at most 10 4, considered. As Re increases, they increasingly localise in space with thickness scaling as Re-1/3. They grow via the Orr mechanism, followed by a phase of energy transfer across oblique waves of different axial wavenumber, characterised by a rapid delocalisation. The energy gain in the Orr and oblique-wave phases is independent of the initial perturbation energy, E 0. Subsequently, rolls grow by nonlinear mechanisms and streaks via the lift-up effect. The energy gain of the (inviscid) Orr phase is independent of the Reynolds number, whereas it increases linearly with Re during the initial oblique-wave phase and quadratically in the roll and lift-up phase. We find that, transition occurs if the energy of the optimal perturbation exceeds a maximum energy threshold during its temporal evolution. This energy is given by the edge state energy and found to be independent of Re. As a result, the minimum perturbation energy required to cause transition in pipe flow scales as E 0 crit proportional to Re-3, which is consistent with our computation of minimal seeds. We note that insufficiently long pipes lead to an exponent of smaller magnitude and that much larger numerical resolutions are required to accurately compute the energy gain than to compute the critical threshold.

Related papers