Finite Vertical Windows: Seeing Only Part of the Picture in Rotating Turbulence

arXiv:2604.11457 · physics.flu-dyn · Submitted 2026-04-13 · Read on arXiv

Listen

Radio episode about this paper

Transcript

Introduction to the show: ident: Physics. The day in general physics: instruments, methods and results across the field.

Kai: We're looking at the paper: "Finite Vertical Windows".

Mira: Here's the gist of the paper. We report high-resolution measurements of three-dimensional (3D) turbulence in a rapidly rotating fluid by decomposing the velocity field into a vertically averaged component and a three-dimensional residual, showing that each dominates distinct frequency ranges The separation is not intrinsic to the flow but strongly depends on the finite vertical span of the measurements This finding calls into question the usage of the concept of pure 2D manifold in theoretical description and highlights the need for frameworks that account for resolution-dependent parts of the flow.

Kai: Flow Decomposition Mechanism The decomposition used involves defining a vertically averaged component as v2D(x, y, t) and a residual field as v3D(x, y, z, t).

Mira: For a finite measurement height ∆h, this vertical averaging acts as a low-pass filter in kz, retaining modes with kz ≲ 2π/∆h.

Kai: This decomposition is commonly interpreted as separating the kz = 0 mode from the kz ≠ 0 modes of the flow.

Paper summary: Kai: So, to recap the paper "Finite Vertical Windows: Seeing Only Part of the Picture in Rotating Turbulence", it focuses on using high-resolution three-dimensional particle image velocimetry measurements to decompose the velocity field into a vertically averaged component and a residual part. The core claim is that these two components dominate distinct frequency ranges in the rotating flow.

Mira: They show that this separation isn't an intrinsic feature of the fluid dynamics alone, but it changes based on how much vertical space you are actually measuring. They found that as the vertical measurement range increases, this crossover point between the two regimes shifts predictably.

Lev: The paper mentions that they investigate how a finite vertical resolution impacts the decomposition between the quasi-two-dimensional and wave parts of the flow, which is important because real hardware has limits on what it can resolve.

Kai: Specifically, they looked at how this affects energy partitioning. They found that as you increase the measurement scale, more energy gets assigned to that three-dimensional component, even when you think you're only measuring a part of the system.

Mira: And they give us some specific scaling laws for these components. For example, the low-frequency regime follows an energy scaling close to E2D omega minus five over three, and at higher frequencies, the three-dimensional component dominates and its energy scales like omega minus one over two near two times the rotation frequency.

Lev: Those are some pretty specific spectral signatures they found. If you were trying to run a simulation or an experiment that relies on a fixed separation between those two regimes, those scaling laws tell you exactly how sensitive that model is to your chosen vertical window size.

Kai: And they also looked at the residual field specifically, Ethree dee omega, and showed it follows an energy scaling like omega minus one over two in the high-frequency range. This matches predictions from weak wave turbulence theory for inertial waves.

Mira: It's important to note that they are addressing the subtleties introduced by the finite vertical measurement range when trying to resolve the vanishing kz limit, which is where you get into those three-dimensional inertial wave interactions.

Lev: So, it’s not just about finding two components; it’s about understanding how resolving them depends on your setup. That's a key consideration for building error correction schemes or any numerical model of these systems.

Conclusion: Kai: So, looking at the title "Finite Vertical Windows: Seeing Only Part of the Picture in Rotating Turbulence", it really captures the essence of their finding. They are showing us that what we see is only a part of the total story, and that what dominates depends entirely on how much you are seeing vertically.

Mira: They're calling into question the idea of a pure two-dimensional manifold when describing rotating turbulence theoretically because they show that this picture breaks down based on measurement resolution.

Lev: From an engineering standpoint, this means we can't just assume a clean separation between these two types of motion; we have to account for the coupling between wavelike and vortex-like motions.

Kai: It highlights that in any realistic setup, whether it’s a lab experiment or a computer simulation, you have to deal with these resolution-dependent parts of the flow. They emphasize that these effects are unavoidable in geophysical and astrophysical flows too.

Mira: Ultimately, this suggests that we need new theoretical frameworks for rotating turbulence that explicitly handle the near singular behavior when the wave number kz goes to zero and how those modes get resolved differently depending on your vertical slice.

Lev: So, it’s not a single answer; it’s a set of conditions where you can use one model over another. We need models that can handle this resolution dependency so we don't misinterpret the physics just because our measurement setup isn't perfect.

Omri Shaltiel, Eran Sharon

physics.flu-dyn

Submitted: 2026-04-13

Updated: 2026-04-13

DOI: 10.1098/rsta.2025.0144

License: http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/

Importance score: 83/100

The gist: We report high-resolution measurements of three-dimensional (3D) turbulence in a rapidly rotating fluid by decomposing the velocity field into a vertically averaged component and a three-dimensional…

Key concepts

Flow Decomposition
The velocity field is split into two parts: a vertically averaged component (v2D) and a three-dimensional residual (v3D). The averaging acts like a low-pass filter, keeping only slow vertical motions. This separation is not inherent to the flow itself but depends on how high the measurement window is.
Quasi-2D Component
This component dominates at low frequencies and follows an energy scaling close to E2D(ω) ∼ ω −5/3. It represents large-scale, persistent vortices that last over many rotation periods. Its energy fraction changes as the measurement height increases.
Three-Dimensional Component
The residual field (v3D) dominates at high frequencies and exhibits a sharp cutoff near ω = 2Ω, matching inertial wave dispersion relations. This component is associated with smaller-scale, vertically modulated fluctuations that show anisotropic vertical correlations.

Terminology

Summary

We report high-resolution measurements of three-dimensional (3D) turbulence in a rapidly rotating fluid by decomposing the velocity field into a vertically averaged component and a three-dimensional residual, showing that each dominates distinct frequency ranges The separation is not intrinsic to the flow but strongly depends on the finite vertical span of the measurements This finding calls into question the usage of the concept of pure 2D manifold in theoretical description and highlights the need for frameworks that account for resolution-dependent parts of the flow. p. 0

Where the paper says it

Finite Vertical Windows: Seeing Only Part of the Picture in Rotating Turbulence Omri Shaltiel, Eran Sharon April 14, 2026 Abstract We report high-resolution measurements of three-dimensional (3D) turbulence in a rapidly rotating fluid. By decomposing the velocity field into a vertically averaged component and a three-dimensional residual, we show that each dominates distinct frequency ranges: the quasi2D component at low frequencies and the 3D component at higher ones.

Flow Decomposition Mechanism

The decomposition used involves defining a vertically averaged component as v2D(x, y, t) and a residual field as v3D(x, y, z, t). For a finite measurement height ∆h, this vertical averaging acts as a low-pass filter in kz, retaining modes with kz ≲ 2π/∆h. p. 4

Where the paper says it

(4) For a finite measurement height ∆h, the vertical averaging in Eq. 3 does not isolate a strictly kz = 0 mode, but acts as a low-pass filter in kz, retaining modes with |kz| ≲ 2π/∆h.

This decomposition is commonly interpreted as separating the kz = 0 mode from the kz ≠ 0 modes of the flow. p. 4
Where the paper says it

3 does not isolate a strictly kz = 0 mode, but acts as a low-pass filter in kz, retaining modes with |kz| ≲ 2π/∆h. This decomposition is commonly interpreted as separating the kz = 0 mode from the kz ̸= 0 modes of the flow [8, 9, 16, 28].

Spectral Characteristics of Components

The temporal energy spectrum E(ω) is dominated by the quasi-2D component at low frequencies, following an energy scaling close to E2D(ω) ∼ ω −5/3. At higher frequencies, the three-dimensional component v3D becomes dominant and exhibits a sharp cutoff near ω = 2omega, consistent with the upper frequency bound imposed by the inertial-wave dispersion relation. p. 6

Where the paper says it

At higher frequencies, the three-dimensional component v3D becomes dominant. Its spectrum exhibits a sharp cutoff near ω = 2Ω, consistent with the upper frequency bound imposed by the inertial-wave dispersion relation.

The residual field E3D(ω) follows E3D(ω) ∝ ω −1/2, which is consistent with predictions from Weak Wave Turbulence theory for inertial waves. p. 7
Where the paper says it

Panel (b) presents the temporal energy spectrum of v3D, the residual field E3D(ω). The highfrequency range follows E3D(ω) ∝ ω −1/2 , consistent with the prediction of Weak Wave Turbulence theory for inertial waves (See SI [33] and [5, 9]).

Influence of Vertical Resolution

The crossover frequency ω⋆ at which E2D(ω⋆) = E3D(ω⋆) decreases as ∆h increases. This dependence is approximately described by a power-law trend: ω⋆(∆h) ∼ ∆h −0. p. 7

Where the paper says it

Figure 5 shows that the crossover frequencyω ⋆ decreases as ∆h increases. Over the accessible range of vertical scan sizes, the dependence of ω ⋆ on ∆h is approximately described by a power8

67. Increasing the measurement scale more energy is included in the ”3D” component. p. 2
Where the paper says it

Modes with very small but nonzero kz are inevitably included in the quasi-2D component. As a result, when increasing the measurement scale more energy is included in the ”3D” component.

Energy Partition Shift

As ∆h increases, the fraction of energy attributed to the quasi-2D component decreases while the energy associated with the 3D component increases. Extrapolating this trend to the full system height suggests that measurements spanning the full height of the tank would reveal a quasi-2D component that is not dominant, but instead comparable in energy to the three-dimensional wave component. p. 9

Where the paper says it

Naturally, as the vertical measurement range increases the ratio between the total energy in the 3D and the 2D components increases. Although not accessible in our present experimental setup, we cannot exclude the possibility that measurements spanning the full height of the tank would reveal a quasi-2D 10

This demonstrates that the apparent partition of energy depends explicitly on vertical resolution. p. 9
Where the paper says it

As in the previous subsection, this extrapolation is intended as an illustrative, order-of-magnitude estimate. These measurements demonstrate that the apparent partition of energy between quasi-2D and three-dimensional motions depends explicitly on the vertical resolution of the measurement.

Conclusion and Implications

These results call for a reassessment of theoretical descriptions that treat rotating turbulence as a superposition of decoupled two-dimensional and wave fields. Any realistic framework must account explicitly for the near-singular behavior as kz → 0 and for the resolution-dependent classification of modes. p. 0

Where the paper says it

As the vertical scan range increases, the apparent crossover between 2D and 3D-dominated regimes shifts systematically, revealing that the commonly assumed partition is strongly shaped by measurement limits. These findings call into question the usage of the concept of pure 2D manifold, in the theoretical description of rotating turbulence and highlight the need for frameworks that account for resolution-dependent parts of the flow and the coupling between wavelike and vortex-like motions.

Such effects are unavoidable in numerical simulations and laboratory experiments, as well as in geophysical and astrophysical flows. p. 0
Where the paper says it

These findings call into question the usage of the concept of pure 2D manifold, in the theoretical description of rotating turbulence and highlight the need for frameworks that account for resolution-dependent parts of the flow and the coupling between wavelike and vortex-like motions. 1 Introduction Understanding rotating turbulence is a fundamental and enduring challenge in fluid dynamics, with profound implications for a variety of geophysical and astrophysical phenomena.

The reported temporal scaling E(ω) ∝ ω −4/3 reported in [32] does not correspond to a distinct dynamical regime, but instead emerges from the superposition of slow quasi-2D motions and faster wave-dominated fluctuations. p. 6
Where the paper says it

At low frequencies, the spectrum is dominated by the quasi-2D component, which follows an energy scaling close to E2D(ω) ∼ ω −5/3 . This regime reflects the slow evolution of large-scale vortical structures.

References

[1] Alexandros Alexakis and Luca Biferale. Cascades and transitions in turbulent flows. p. 1

Where the paper says it

Two key dimensionless parameters describe rotating turbulence: the Reynolds number, Re = UL/ν, which quantifies inertial relative to viscous effects, and the Rossby number, Ro = U/(2ΩL), which measures inertial relative to Coriolis forces. Rotating turbulent flows typically exhibit large Re and small Ro, implying strong rotation and a broad inertial range.

Physics Reports, 767:1–101, 2018

[2] Luca Biferale, Fabio Bonaccorso, Irene M Mazzitelli, Michel AT van Hinsberg, Alessandra S Lanotte, Stefano Musacchio, Prasad Perlekar, and Federico Toschi. Coherent structures and extreme events in rotating multiphase turbulent flows. p. 1

Where the paper says it

Rotating turbulent flows typically exhibit large Re and small Ro, implying strong rotation and a broad inertial range. One hallmark of rotating turbulence at large scales is the formation of coherent vortices aligned along the axis of rotation.

Physical Review X, 6(4):041036, 2016

[3] Fabien S Godeferd and Fred´ eric Moisy. Structure and dynamics of rotating turbulence: a ´review of recent experimental and numerical results. p. 2

Where the paper says it

While the weakly nonlinear inertial wave field provides a natural framework for describing small-scale dynamics, it is well established that the quasi-2D component dominates the total energy of rotating turbulence. In many theoretical and experimental works [1, 15–26] considerable attention has therefore been devoted to understanding how energy is transferred from the wave field into the 2D component.

Applied Mechanics Reviews, 67(3), 2015

[4] Peter Alan Davidson. Turbulence in rotating, stratified and electrically conducting fluids. p. 0

Where the paper says it

Finite Vertical Windows: Seeing Only Part of the Picture in Rotating Turbulence Omri Shaltiel, Eran Sharon April 14, 2026 Abstract We report high-resolution measurements of three-dimensional (3D) turbulence in a rapidly rotating fluid. By decomposing the velocity field into a vertically averaged component and a three-dimensional residual, we show that each dominates distinct frequency ranges: the quasi2D component at low frequencies and the 3D component at higher ones.

Cambridge University Press, 2013

[5] Sebastien Galtier. Weak inertial-wave turbulence theory. p. 1

Where the paper says it

We demonstrated through detailed experimental measurements that these seemingly 2D vortices are, in fact, composed of inertial wave modes characterized by near-zero frequency and low vertical wavenumber kz. At smaller scales, the dynamics transition to a regime governed by weak inertial wave interactions described effectively by Weak Wave Turbulence (WWT) theory [6, 9].

´ Physical Review E, 68(1):015301, 2003

[6] Eduardo Monsalve, Maxime Brunet, Basile Gallet, and Pierre-Philippe Cortet. Quantitative experimental observation of weak inertial-wave turbulence. p. 7

Where the paper says it

The highfrequency range follows E3D(ω) ∝ ω −1/2 , consistent with the prediction of Weak Wave Turbulence theory for inertial waves (See SI [33] and [5, 9]). This observation highlights the distinct temporal signature of the wave-dominated component compared with the slowly evolving quasi-2D flow.

Physical Review Letters, 125(25):254502, 2020

[7] Maxime Brunet, Basile Gallet, and Pierre-Philippe Cortet. Shortcut to geostrophy in wavedriven rotating turbulence: the quartetic instability. p. 0

Where the paper says it

Finite Vertical Windows: Seeing Only Part of the Picture in Rotating Turbulence Omri Shaltiel, Eran Sharon April 14, 2026 Abstract We report high-resolution measurements of three-dimensional (3D) turbulence in a rapidly rotating fluid. By decomposing the velocity field into a vertically averaged component and a three-dimensional residual, we show that each dominates distinct frequency ranges: the quasi2D component at low frequencies and the 3D component at higher ones.

Physical Review Letters, 124(12):124501, 2020

[8] Antoine Campagne, Basile Gallet, Fred´ eric Moisy, and Pierre-Philippe Cortet. Disentangling ´inertial waves from eddy turbulence in a forced rotating-turbulence experiment. p. 2

Where the paper says it

In many theoretical and experimental works [1, 15–26] considerable attention has therefore been devoted to understanding how energy is transferred from the wave field into the 2D component. This coupling between three-dimensional inertial waves and 2D modes remains one of the central open questions in the theory of rotating turbulence.

Physical Review E, 91(4):043016, 2015

[9] Omri Shaltiel, Omri Gat, and Eran Sharon. Confirming wave turbulence predictions in rotating turbulence, 2025

[10] Harvey Philip Greenspan et al. The theory of rotating fluids. p. 2

Where the paper says it

In many theoretical and experimental works [1, 15–26] considerable attention has therefore been devoted to understanding how energy is transferred from the wave field into the 2D component. This coupling between three-dimensional inertial waves and 2D modes remains one of the central open questions in the theory of rotating turbulence.

CUP Archive, 1968

[11] Ehud Yarom, Yuval Vardi, and Eran Sharon. Experimental quantification of inverse energy cascade in deep rotating turbulence. p. 1

Where the paper says it

One hallmark of rotating turbulence at large scales is the formation of coherent vortices aligned along the axis of rotation. These structures result from an inverse energy cascade, an inherently antidiffusive process wherein energy accumulates at progressively larger scales rather than dissipating to smaller scales.

Physics of Fluids, 25(8):085105, 2013

[12] Omri Shaltiel, Alon Salhov, Omri Gat, and Eran Sharon. Direct measurement of energy transfer in strongly driven rotating turbulence. p. 9

Where the paper says it

These measurements demonstrate that the apparent partition of energy between quasi-2D and three-dimensional motions depends explicitly on the vertical resolution of the measurement. 4 Conclusions This study challenges the conventional view that rotating turbulence consists of independent 2D and inertial wave-driven three-dimensional flows.

Physical Review Letters, 132(22):224001

[13] Pablo Daniel Mininni and Annick Pouquet. Rotating helical turbulence. p. 0

Where the paper says it

Finite Vertical Windows: Seeing Only Part of the Picture in Rotating Turbulence Omri Shaltiel, Eran Sharon April 14, 2026 Abstract We report high-resolution measurements of three-dimensional (3D) turbulence in a rapidly rotating fluid. By decomposing the velocity field into a vertically averaged component and a three-dimensional residual, we show that each dominates distinct frequency ranges: the quasi2D component at low frequencies and the 3D component at higher ones.

i. global evolution and spectral behavior. p. 6
Where the paper says it

At low frequencies, the spectrum is dominated by the quasi-2D component, which follows an energy scaling close to E2D(ω) ∼ ω −5/3 . This regime reflects the slow evolution of large-scale vortical structures.

Physics of Fluids, 22(3), 2010

[14] Enrico Deusebio, Guido Boffetta, Erik Lindborg, and Stefano Musacchio. Dimensional transition in rotating turbulence. p. 1

Where the paper says it

We demonstrated through detailed experimental measurements that these seemingly 2D vortices are, in fact, composed of inertial wave modes characterized by near-zero frequency and low vertical wavenumber kz. At smaller scales, the dynamics transition to a regime governed by weak inertial wave interactions described effectively by Weak Wave Turbulence (WWT) theory [6, 9].

Physical Review E, 90(2):023005, 2014

[15] Leslie M Smith and Fabian Waleffe. Transfer of energy to two-dimensional large scales in forced, rotating three-dimensional turbulence. p. 1

Where the paper says it

At smaller scales, the dynamics are governed by three-dimensional inertial wave interactions [4–9]. Understanding the relations between these two ”components” of the flow is a central task in the theoretical modeling of rotating turbulence.

Physics of fluids, 11(6):1608–1622, 1999

[16] Michele Buzzicotti, Patricio Clark Di Leoni, and Luca Biferale. On the inverse energy transfer in rotating turbulence. p. 0

Where the paper says it

1 Introduction Understanding rotating turbulence is a fundamental and enduring challenge in fluid dynamics, with profound implications for a variety of geophysical and astrophysical phenomena. The influence of rotation fundamentally alters turbulent flow, breaking the isotropy inherent to classical turbulence and introducing strong anisotropy into the energy transfer across scales.

The European Physical Journal E, 41(11):1–8, 2018

[17] Antoine Campagne, Basile Gallet, Fred´ eric Moisy, and Pierre-Philippe Cortet. Direct and ´inverse energy cascades in a forced rotating turbulence experiment. p. 1

Where the paper says it

One hallmark of rotating turbulence at large scales is the formation of coherent vortices aligned along the axis of rotation. These structures result from an inverse energy cascade, an inherently antidiffusive process wherein energy accumulates at progressively larger scales rather than dissipating to smaller scales.

Physics of Fluids, 26(12):125112, 2014

[18] Amrik Sen, Pablo D Mininni, Duane Rosenberg, and Annick Pouquet. Anisotropy and nonuniversality in scaling laws of the large-scale energy spectrum in rotating turbulence. p. 6

Where the paper says it

At low frequencies, the spectrum is dominated by the quasi-2D component, which follows an energy scaling close to E2D(ω) ∼ ω −5/3 . This regime reflects the slow evolution of large-scale vortical structures.

Physical Review E, 86(3):036319, 2012

[19] Charles N Baroud, Brendan B Plapp, Harry L Swinney, and Zhen-Su She. Scaling in three-dimensional and quasi-two-dimensional rotating turbulent flows. p. 9

Where the paper says it

These measurements demonstrate that the apparent partition of energy between quasi-2D and three-dimensional motions depends explicitly on the vertical resolution of the measurement. 4 Conclusions This study challenges the conventional view that rotating turbulence consists of independent 2D and inertial wave-driven three-dimensional flows.

Physics of Fluids, 15(8):2091–2104, 2003

[20] Cyril Lamriben, Pierre-Philippe Cortet, and Fred´ eric Moisy. Direct measurements of ´anisotropic energy transfers in a rotating turbulence experiment. p. 9

Where the paper says it

These measurements demonstrate that the apparent partition of energy between quasi-2D and three-dimensional motions depends explicitly on the vertical resolution of the measurement. 4 Conclusions This study challenges the conventional view that rotating turbulence consists of independent 2D and inertial wave-driven three-dimensional flows.

Physical review letters, 107(2):024503, 2011

[21] Patricio Clark di Leoni and Pablo D Mininni. Quantifying resonant and near-resonant interactions in rotating turbulence. p. 1

Where the paper says it

We demonstrated through detailed experimental measurements that these seemingly 2D vortices are, in fact, composed of inertial wave modes characterized by near-zero frequency and low vertical wavenumber kz. At smaller scales, the dynamics transition to a regime governed by weak inertial wave interactions described effectively by Weak Wave Turbulence (WWT) theory [6, 9].

Journal of Fluid Mechanics, 809:821–842, 2016

[22] Thomas Le Reun, Basile Gallet, Benjamin Favier, and Michael Le Bars. Near-resonant instability of geostrophic modes: beyond greenspan’s theorem. p. 1

Where the paper says it

In earlier work [12], we showed that despite this apparent . We demonstrated through detailed experimental measurements that these seemingly 2D vortices are, in fact, composed of inertial wave modes characterized by near-zero frequency and low vertical wavenumber kz.

Journal of Fluid Mechanics, 900, 2020

[23] Claude Cambon, Nagi N Mansour, and Fabien S Godeferd. Energy transfer in rotating turbulence. p. 0

Where the paper says it

1 Introduction Understanding rotating turbulence is a fundamental and enduring challenge in fluid dynamics, with profound implications for a variety of geophysical and astrophysical phenomena. The influence of rotation fundamentally alters turbulent flow, breaking the isotropy inherent to classical turbulence and introducing strong anisotropy into the energy transfer across scales.

Journal of Fluid Mechanics, 337:303–332, 1997

[24] Fabien Bellet, FS Godeferd, JF Scott, and Claude Cambon. Wave turbulence in rapidly rotating flows. p. 9

Where the paper says it

These measurements demonstrate that the apparent partition of energy between quasi-2D and three-dimensional motions depends explicitly on the vertical resolution of the measurement. 4 Conclusions This study challenges the conventional view that rotating turbulence consists of independent 2D and inertial wave-driven three-dimensional flows.

Journal of Fluid Mechanics, 562:83–121, 2006

[25] Basile Gallet. Exact two-dimensionalization of rapidly rotating large-reynolds-number flows. p. 1

Where the paper says it

Two key dimensionless parameters describe rotating turbulence: the Reynolds number, Re = UL/ν, which quantifies inertial relative to viscous effects, and the Rossby number, Ro = U/(2ΩL), which measures inertial relative to Coriolis forces. Rotating turbulent flows typically exhibit large Re and small Ro, implying strong rotation and a broad inertial range.

Journal of Fluid Mechanics, 783:412–447, 2015

[26] Sergei V Nazarenko and Alexander A Schekochihin. Critical balance in magnetohydrodynamic, rotating and stratified turbulence: towards a universal scaling conjecture. p. 6

Where the paper says it

This regime reflects the slow evolution of large-scale vortical structures. A similar scaling was observed experimentally in rotating turbulence when coherent vortices were directly generated in a rotating tank [8].

Journal of Fluid Mechanics, 677:134–153, 2011

[27] Hadar Ben-Gida, Roi Gurka, and Alex Liberzon. Openpiv-matlab—an open-source software for particle image velocimetry; test case: Birds’ aerodynamics. p. 2

Where the paper says it

In the present study, we directly address the subtleties introduced by the finite vertical measurement range and its implications for resolving the vanishing-kz limit. Employing high-resolution 3D2C Particle Image Velocimetry (PIV) measurements of steady-state rotating turbulence, we investigate how finite vertical resolution impacts the decomposition between the quasi-2D and wave parts of the flow.

SoftwareX, 12:100585, 2020

[28] Alexandros Alexakis. Quasi-two-dimensional turbulence. p. 1

Where the paper says it

At smaller scales, the dynamics are governed by three-dimensional inertial wave interactions [4–9]. Understanding the relations between these two ”components” of the flow is a central task in the theoretical modeling of rotating turbulence.

Reviews of Modern Plasma Physics, 7(1):31, 2023

[29] Julian F Scott. Wave turbulence in a rotating channel. p. 1

Where the paper says it

At smaller scales, the dynamics are governed by three-dimensional inertial wave interactions [4–9]. Understanding the relations between these two ”components” of the flow is a central task in the theoretical modeling of rotating turbulence.

Journal of fluid mechanics, 741:316–349, 2014

[30] Geoffrey Ingram Taylor. The spectrum of turbulence. p. 1

Where the paper says it

At smaller scales, the dynamics transition to a regime governed by weak inertial wave interactions described effectively by Weak Wave Turbulence (WWT) theory [6, 9]. WWT predicts a strongly anisotropic forward cascade with an energy spectrum computed by Galtier [5]: E(kr, kz) ∝ √ ϵΩk −5/2 r k −1/2 z , (2) 2

Proceedings of the Royal Society of London. Series A-Mathematical and Physical Sciences, 164(919):476–490, 1938

[31] Hans L Pecseli and Jan K Trulsen. On the applicability of taylor’s hypothesis, including small ´sampling velocities. p. 6

Where the paper says it

These scaling regimes resemble the inverse-energy-cascade and forward-enstrophy-cascade scalings in 2D turbulence. Such a correspondence between temporal and spatial scalings could arise if a Taylor-type frozen-field hypothesis holds, linking frequency and wavenumber through ω ∼ U k [30, 31].

Journal of Fluid Mechanics, 932:A22, 2022

[32] Ehud Yarom and Eran Sharon. Experimental observation of steady inertial wave turbulence in deep rotating flows. p. 9

Where the paper says it

These measurements demonstrate that the apparent partition of energy between quasi-2D and three-dimensional motions depends explicitly on the vertical resolution of the measurement. 4 Conclusions This study challenges the conventional view that rotating turbulence consists of independent 2D and inertial wave-driven three-dimensional flows.

Nature Physics, 10(7):510–514, 2014

[33] Supplemental information. See Supplemental Information at URL will be inserted by publisher

--- Page 3 ---

Figure 2: Visualization of the flow decomposition into quasi-2D and 3D components. (a–c) Instantaneous kinetic energy density E and (d–f) vertical vorticity ωz in a rotating turbulent flow, shown for: the full velocity field (left), its vertical average v2D (center), and the residual field v3D (right) Data correspond to Re ≈ 3000 and Ro ≈ 0. p. 5

Where the paper says it

(a–c) Instantaneous kinetic energy density E and (d–f) vertical vorticity ωz in a rotating turbulent flow, shown for: the full velocity field (left), its vertical average v2D (center), and the residual field v3D (right). Data correspond to Re ≈ 3000 and Ro ≈ 0.

02

vortical component from a three-dimensional inertial-wave field when both evolve separately. Here we show experimentally that rotating turbulence exhibits behavior consistent with this separation, while also revealing its dependence on the finite measurement volume A representative snapshot of this decomposition is shown in Fig. p. 5

Where the paper says it

Here we show experimentally that rotating turbulence exhibits behavior consistent with this separation, while also revealing its dependence on the finite measurement volume. A representative snapshot of this decomposition is shown in Fig.

2. The full flow field (left panels) displays anisotropic turbulence characterized by vertically coherent columns and broadband horizontal fluctuations. p. 5
Where the paper says it

A representative snapshot of this decomposition is shown in Fig. The full flow field (left panels) displays anisotropic turbulence characterized by vertically coherent columns and broadband horizontal fluctuations.

The quasi-2D component retains disordered, large-scale vortices that persist over many rotation periods, while the 3D component highlights smaller-scale, vertically modulated fluctuations with anisotropic vertical correlations. p. 5
Where the paper says it

The full field exhibits broadband anisotropic turbulence with vertically coherent columns. The quasi-2D component retains disordered, large-scale vortices that persist over many rotation periods, while the 3D component highlights smaller-scale, vertically modulated fluctuations with anisotropic vertical correlations.

--- Page 6 ---

Figure 2: Visualization of the flow decomposition into quasi-2D and 3D components. (a–c) Instantaneous kinetic energy density E and (d–f) vertical vorticity ωz in a rotating turbulent flow, shown for: the full velocity field (left), its vertical average v2D (center), and the residual field v3D (right) The quasi-2D component retains disordered, large-scale vortices that persist over many rotation periods, while the 3D component highlights smaller-scale, vertically modulated fluctuations with anisotropic vertical correlations

--- Page 9 ---

Figure 3: Left: Temporal energy spectra of the full velocity field (dashed blue), quasi-2D component v2D (yellow), and 3D component v3D (red). The quasi-2D contribution dominates at low frequencies, while the 3D component dominates at high frequencies and exhibits a sharp cutoff near ω = 2omega, consistent with inertial-wave dispersion relation

--- Page 10 ---

Panel (b) presents the temporal energy spectrum of v3D, the residual field E3D(ω). The highfrequency range follows E3D(ω) ∝ ω −1/2, consistent with the prediction of Weak Wave Turbulence theory for inertial waves

--- Page 10 ---

The temporal energy spectra of the total velocity field and its quasi-2D and 3D components are shown in Fig. 3. At low frequencies, the spectrum is dominated by the quasi-2D component, which follows an energy scaling close to E2D(ω) ∼ ω −5/3. p. 6

Where the paper says it

The temporal energy spectra of the total velocity field and its quasi-2D and 3D components are shown in Fig. At low frequencies, the spectrum is dominated by the quasi-2D component, which follows an energy scaling close to E2D(ω) ∼ ω −5/3 .

--- Page 8 ---

Panel (a) shows the quasi-2D spectra E2D(ω), which display two power-law regimes: E2D ∝ ω −5/3 at low frequencies and E2D ∝ ω −3 at higher frequencies

--- Page 8 ---

Panel (b) presents the temporal energy spectrum of v3D, the residual field E3D(ω). The highfrequency range follows E3D(ω) ∝ ω −1/2, consistent with the prediction of Weak Wave Turbulence theory for inertial waves

--- Page 9 ---

At higher frequencies, the three-dimensional component v3D becomes dominant

--- Page 9 ---

The highfrequency range follows E3D(ω) ∝ ω −1/2, consistent with the prediction of Weak Wave Turbulence theory for inertial waves

--- Page 9 ---

Panel (b) presents the temporal energy spectrum of v3D, the residual field E3D(ω). The highfrequency range follows E3D(ω) ∝ ω −1/2, consistent with the prediction of Weak Wave Turbulence theory for inertial waves

--- Page 9 ---

Panel (b) presents the temporal energy spectrum of v3D, the residual field E3D(ω).

Green — the paper says it, and the page is printed. Red — no passage carries it, so treat that sentence as unverified. The same check runs on your own text: check a summary against its source, $5.

Improvements for AI systems

  1. Adaptive decomposition based on vertical resolution: The AI system can dynamically adjust its classification of flow modes by incorporating a parameter representing measurement scale, allowing it to classify modes as quasi-2D or 3D based on the finite vertical span used in the simulation or observation window.

  2. Resolution-dependent spectral analysis: The system can perform temporal and spatial energy spectrum analysis that explicitly accounts for the vertical measurement range, specifically by calculating a crossover frequency omega star at which E2D equals E3D as a function of this range.

  3. Predictive modeling of energy partitioning: The AI system can predict the fraction of total energy residing in 2D versus 3D components based on the assumed vertical measurement height, enabling it to estimate how increasing resolution impacts the ratio between these two flow components.

Abstract

We report high-resolution measurements of three-dimensional (3D) turbulence in a rapidly rotating fluid. By decomposing the velocity field into a vertically averaged component and a three-dimensional residual, we show that each dominates distinct frequency ranges: the quasi-2D component at low frequencies and the 3D component at higher ones. This separation is not intrinsic to the flow but strongly depends on the finite vertical span of the measurements. As the vertical scan range increases, the apparent crossover between 2D and 3D-dominated regimes shifts systematically, revealing that the commonly assumed partition is strongly shaped by measurement limits. These findings call into question the usage of the concept of pure 2D manifold, in the theoretical description of rotating turbulence and highlight the need for frameworks that account for resolution-dependent parts of the flow and the coupling between wave-like and vortex-like motions.

Related papers