On the wake and flapping dynamics of different aspect ratio flags
Listen
Radio episode about this paper
Transcript
Introduction to the show: ident: Physics. The day in general physics: instruments, methods and results across the field.
Kai: We're looking at the paper: "On the wake and flapping dynamics of different aspect ratio flags".
Mira: Here's the gist of the paper. The paper presents systematic time and space-resolved measurements of flag deformation and drag for various aspect ratios and mass ratios to provide a better understanding of the interaction between flag deformation, wake parameters, and mean force Flag Dynamics Parameters The study defines several dimensionless parameters relevant to the flapping dynamics, including the reduced velocity U∗ = U∞ L/√εD, the mass ratio M∗ = ρfL/ρse, Hl, and Re = U∞ L/ν The reduced velocity compares the characteristic period of free vibrations of a beam in vacuum to the convective time of the surrounding flow The mass ratio compares the magnitude of the fluid mass displaced during a flapping cycle to the mass of the flag itself The aspect ratio H/L compares the height to the length of a flag, and flags in this limit behave like ribbons The Reynolds number indicates the relative importance of inertial versus viscous effects in the flow, and its influence is expected to be negligible for Re > 1000 Post-Critical Flapping Regime The research focuses on the post-critical flapping regime, which corresponds to flow velocities beyond the critical velocity In this regime, the dimensionless tip amplitude A/L suddenly increases from almost 0 to 0.27 when increasing the reduced flow velocity beyond the critical onset velocity U∗ onset = 16.4 The dimensionless tip frequency is approximately constant f L/U∞ = 0.53 ± 0.01 when varying the reduced velocity U∗ The experimental extracted offset velocities for all tested flags lie between 12.78 and 17.17 for different mass ratios and aspect ratios Spatial Characteristics of Deformation Waves The spatial characteristics of the flapping deformation waves are investigated by examining the envelope of the motion in Cartesian coordinates (x, y) and its evolution along the curvilinear coordinate s Local amplitude increases monotonically along the curvilinear coordinate for all tested aspect ratios The two necks are highlighted as regions of locally smaller lateral extent, with their positions determined by the spatial evolution of the local amplitude along the centreline The dimensionless wavelength is approximately constant for the full dataset when normalised by the length of the flag λ/L = 1.87 ± 0.08 Link between Mean Drag Coefficient and Flapping Dynamics The mean drag coefficient C¯x undergoes a transition from 0 to a plateau at post-critical velocities The mean drag coefficient of different flags can vary by two orders of magnitude, ranging from C¯x = 0 to 0.55 with no clear relationship with the reduced velocity U∗ An empirical model based on the amplitude-based Strouhal number suggests that the mean drag coefficient can be rewritten as C¯x = (π/2) × St2A / M∗ The paper provides a better connection between the deformation, flow, and force characteristics of flapping flags of different aspect ratio in the post-critical regime The typical length scale to predict the reduction in released circulation during half a stroke should include the height to account for three-dimensional effects By revisiting the model proposed by Thoma (1939), it is shown that the characteristic velocity scale is the tip velocity The relationship between tip frequency and wave speed can be rewritten as c/U∞ = λ/L × f L/U∞ This paper provides a better connection between the deformation, flow, and force characteristics of flapping flags of different aspect ratio in the post-critical regime.
Kai: References Alben, Silas 2022 Dynamics of flags over wide ranges of mass and bending stiffness.
Mira: Physical Review Fluids 7 (1), 013903, publisher: American Physical Society Argentina, Med´ eric & Mahadevan, L.
Kai: ´ 2005 Fluid-flow-induced flutter of a flag.
Title and authors: Kai: We started with the title "On the wake and flapping dynamics of different aspect ratio flags," which immediately tells you the focus is on how shape changes dictate the flow behavior when a flag flaps in a fluid.
Mira: The authors are Gaetan Raynaud and Karen Mulleners, who are linking time resolved measurements to understanding flag deformation and drag across different shapes.
Lev: From an engineering perspective, I'm curious if their approach is purely experimental, or if they also have strong theoretical models guiding the interpretation of these measurements.
Kai: They perform systematic time and space resolved measurements on various aspect ratios and mass ratios, which suggests a very comprehensive experimental setup was involved.
Mira: The implication is that they are establishing a baseline for how shape variations influence the wake structure in this flapping problem.
Lev: Establishing that baseline is important because if we can't predict the behavior of a new flag shape based on these measurements, then we can't design it effectively.
The paper's summary: Kai: So to summarize what the paper actually found, they are mapping out how different aspect ratios and mass ratios lead to specific outcomes in deformation waves and drag coefficients.
Mira: They’re showing that for instance, the dimensionless tip amplitude increases sharply when you cross that critical velocity of sixteen point four.
Lev: That sharp transition is where the non-linear behavior kicks in, which is usually the hardest part to model accurately in fluid dynamics.
Kai: They also found that while one parameter stays relatively stable, another one changes predictably with the reduced velocity U star.
Mira: Specifically, the dimensionless tip frequency remains about point five three plus or minus zero point zero one as they vary U star.
Lev: That stability in frequency suggests a robust flapping mechanism even when you are pushing the flow velocity into that high-velocity regime.
The paper's improvements: Kai: The paper suggests a few ways to improve its understanding, starting with the spatial characteristics of the deformation waves.
Mira: They propose using a robust method to quantify and characterize those spatiotemporal properties of the flag deformation waves by examining how they move in space and time.
Lev: That sounds like they are trying to create a better way to track wave propagation that accounts for turbulence, which is usually where simulations struggle the most.
Kai: They also suggest looking at the two characteristic length scales, the ratio of flag area over its perimeter L star and the square root of area times L over H, as these scale circulation shed during a cycle.
Mira: These two specific ratios are proposed as key parameters because they scale how much circulation is shed during a cycle for different aspect ratios.
Lev: If those two geometric scales are truly universal, then we can use them to predict the circulation for any shape without needing to run a separate simulation for every single geometry.
Conclusion: Kai: So wrapping up the paper on "On the wake and flapping dynamics of different aspect ratio flags," they show that this work connects deformation, flow, and force characteristics in the post-critical regime.
Mira: The main implication is that we have a better way to connect these physical phenomena using these derived scaling laws for circulation and drag based on geometry.
Lev: It moves us from just measuring raw data to having predictive tools that rely on physical relationships rather than just brute force fitting of the data points.
Kai: They show how the dimensionless wave speed scales with the square root of mass ratio times the square root of dynamic pressure.
Mira: And they also emphasize that for predicting circulation reduction during a half stroke, you need to include height because you need those three dimensional effects accounted for in those calculations.
Lev: So, to summarize, this paper gives us concrete scaling relationships to use for predicting flow and force characteristics based on flag geometry.
Kai: It’s about using the full picture of the flag's deformation and wake to get a clearer view of what's happening physically.
Mira: This is a valuable piece of work because it sets up a solid foundation for future studies on complex flapping systems.
Gaetan Raynaud, Karen Mulleners
Institute of Mechanical Engineering, Ecole Polytechnique Fédérale de Lausanne
physics.flu-dyn
Submitted: 2026-02-05
Updated: 2026-11-13
License: http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
Importance score: 90/100
The gist: The paper presents systematic time and space-resolved measurements of flag deformation and drag for various aspect ratios and mass ratios to provide a better understanding of the interaction between…
Key concepts
- Reduced Velocity (U*)
- This dimensionless parameter compares the characteristic period of free vibrations of a beam in a vacuum to the actual time it takes for the surrounding fluid flow to move. It helps define when the flag enters a specific post-critical flapping regime where dynamics change significantly.
- Mass Ratio (M*)
- The mass ratio compares how much fluid mass is displaced during one flapping cycle relative to the flag's actual mass. This ratio is crucial because it dictates how the fluid interaction and resulting drag are affected by the flag's inertia.
- Post-Critical Flapping Regime
- This regime occurs when flow velocities exceed a critical threshold. In this state, key dynamic parameters like tip amplitude suddenly increase, and the dimensionless tip frequency becomes relatively constant despite changes in reduced velocity.
- Mean Drag Coefficient (C̄x)
- The mean drag coefficient is measured across various flags and shows a wide range of values (from 0 to 0.55). The study found an empirical model linking this coefficient to the tip velocity, suggesting that the flag's drag is strongly influenced by its flapping motion.
Terminology
Summary
The paper presents systematic time and space-resolved measurements of flag deformation and drag for various aspect ratios and mass ratios to provide a better understanding of the interaction between flag deformation, wake parameters, and mean force
Flag Dynamics Parameters
The study defines several dimensionless parameters relevant to the flapping dynamics, including the reduced velocity U∗ = U∞ L/√εD, the mass ratio M∗ = ρfL/ρse, Hl, and Re = U∞ L/ν The reduced velocity compares the characteristic period of free vibrations of a beam in vacuum to the convective time of the surrounding flow The mass ratio compares the magnitude of the fluid mass displaced during a flapping cycle to the mass of the flag itself The aspect ratio H/L compares the height to the length of a flag, and flags in this limit behave like ribbons The Reynolds number indicates the relative importance of inertial versus viscous effects in the flow, and its influence is expected to be negligible for Re > 1000
Post-Critical Flapping Regime
The research focuses on the post-critical flapping regime, which corresponds to flow velocities beyond the critical velocity In this regime, the dimensionless tip amplitude A/L suddenly increases from almost 0 to 0.27 when increasing the reduced flow velocity beyond the critical onset velocity U∗ onset = 16. p. 5 The dimensionless tip amplitude
𝐴/𝐿 suddenly increases from almost 0 to 0. 27 when we increase the reduced flow velocity
beyond the critical onset velocity 𝑈
∗
onset = 16. 01 when further increasing 𝑈
∗ > 18. In this post-critical region,
the dimensionless tip frequency is also approximately constant 𝑓 𝐿/U∞ = 0. We extract and briefly discuss the critical
velocities of our flags in the next paragraph before shifting our focus to the post-critical
flapping dynamics. We systematically extracted the critical reduced offset velocity for all tested flags as the
lowest flow velocity with a significant flapping amplitude 𝐴/𝐿 > 0.Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Spatial Characteristics of Deformation Waves
The spatial characteristics of the flapping deformation waves are investigated by examining the envelope of the motion in Cartesian coordinates (x, y) and its evolution along the curvilinear coordinate s Local amplitude increases monotonically along the curvilinear coordinate for all tested aspect ratios The two necks are highlighted as regions of locally smaller lateral extent, with their positions determined by the spatial evolution of the local amplitude along the centreline The dimensionless wavelength is approximately constant for the full dataset when normalised by the length of the flag λ/L = 1.87 ± 0.08
Link between Mean Drag Coefficient and Flapping Dynamics
The mean drag coefficient C¯x undergoes a transition from 0 to a plateau at post-critical velocities The mean drag coefficient of different flags can vary by two orders of magnitude, ranging from C¯x = 0 to 0.55 with no clear relationship with the reduced velocity U∗ An empirical model based on the amplitude-based Strouhal number suggests that the mean drag coefficient can be rewritten as C¯x = (π/2) × St2A / M∗
Conclusion
The paper provides a better connection between the deformation, flow, and force characteristics of flapping flags of different aspect ratio in the post-critical regime The typical length scale to predict the reduction in released circulation during half a stroke should include the height to account for three-dimensional effects By revisiting the model proposed by Thoma (1939), it is shown that the characteristic velocity scale is the tip velocity The relationship between tip frequency and wave speed can be rewritten as c/U∞ = λ/L × f L/U∞ This paper provides a better connection between the deformation, flow, and force characteristics of flapping flags of different aspect ratio in the post-critical regime.
References
Alben, Silas 2022 Dynamics of flags over wide ranges of mass and bending stiffness. Physical Review Fluids 7 (1), 013903, publisher: American Physical Society
Argentina, Med´ eric & Mahadevan, L. ´ 2005 Fluid-flow-induced flutter of a flag. p. 0 Flutter designates a dynamic fluid-structure instability where small deformations of
an object in a fluid flow grow in amplitude to a limit cycle oscillation with constant frequency
(Paidoussis 2014). The onset of flutter occurs when the flow speed exceeds a critical flow
velocity such that the restoring effects of bending stiffness and flow-induced tension can no
longer balance the inertial response of the flag, and the flag extracts energy from the flow
(Connell & Yue 2007; Shelley & Zhang 2011).Where the paper says it
Auregan, Y. & Depollier, C. p. 2 More details on the origin of the flapping time
scales are desirable for further investigation of various applications involving membrane
flutter, including, for instance, the diagnostics of respiratory wheezes (Gavriely et al. 1989),
orinasal snoring and sleep apnoea syndromes (Huang 1995; Auregan & Depollier ´ 1995)
where the frequency of pressure waves is perceived as an audible sound. More details on the origin of the flapping time
scales are desirable for further investigation of various applications involving membrane
flutter, including, for instance, the diagnostics of respiratory wheezes (Gavriely et al. 1989),
orinasal snoring and sleep apnoea syndromes (Huang 1995; Auregan & Depollier ´ 1995)
where the frequency of pressure waves is perceived as an audible sound.Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Bird, Hugh J. A. & Ramesh, Kiran 2021 Unsteady lifting-line theory and the influence of wake vorticity on aerodynamic loads. p. 0 1
On the wake and flapping dynamics of different
aspect ratio flags
Gaetan Raynaud and Karen Mulleners ´ †
Unsteady Flow Diagnostics Laboratory, Institute of Mechanical Engineering, Ecole Polytechnique ´
Fed´ erale de Lausanne (EPFL), Lausanne, 1015, Switzerland ´
The flapping of flags is a classical problem involving fast and large amplitude deformations
of a thin flexible plate and unsteady flow phenomena. We perform systematic time and spaceresolved measurements of the deformation and drag acting on flapping flags for various aspect
ratios and mass ratios.Where the paper says it
Bird, Hugh J. A., Ramesh, Kiran, Otomo, Sh¯ uji & Maria Viola, Ignazio¯ 2022 Usefulness of Inviscid Linear Unsteady Lifting-Line Theory for Viscous Large-Amplitude Problems. p. 1 Two-dimensional conditions are approximated by large aspect ratio flags 𝐻/𝐿 ≫ 1
and have been a classical simplification in the study of flag stability (Alben 2022; Connell &
Yue 2007; Michelin et al. The Reynolds number indicates the relative importance of
inertial versus viscous effects in the flow, and the influence of the Reynolds number on the
flapping dynamics of flags is expected to be negligible for 𝑅𝑒 > 1000 (Yu et al.Where the paper says it
Bornemann, Karoline-Marie & Obrist, Dominik 2025 Leaflet fluttering changes laminar–turbulent transition mechanisms past bioprosthetic aortic valves. Physics of Fluids 37 (5), publisher: AIP Publishing
Caverly, Dylan & Nedic, Jovan ´ 2025 Invariant scaling of impulsively started polygonal disks. Journal of Fluid Mechanics 1010, R1, publisher: Cambridge University Press
Chun-Yu, Bao, Chao, Tang, Xie-Zhen, Yin & Xi-Yun, Lu 2010 Flutter of finite-span flexible plates in uniform flow. Chinese Physics Letters 27 (6), 064601
Connell, Benjamin S. H. & Yue, Dick K. p. 0 Flutter designates a dynamic fluid-structure instability where small deformations of
an object in a fluid flow grow in amplitude to a limit cycle oscillation with constant frequency
(Paidoussis 2014). The onset of flutter occurs when the flow speed exceeds a critical flow
velocity such that the restoring effects of bending stiffness and flow-induced tension can no
longer balance the inertial response of the flag, and the flag extracts energy from the flow
(Connell & Yue 2007; Shelley & Zhang 2011). The onset of flutter occurs when the flow speed exceeds a critical flow
velocity such that the restoring effects of bending stiffness and flow-induced tension can no
longer balance the inertial response of the flag, and the flag extracts energy from the flow
(Connell & Yue 2007; Shelley & Zhang 2011). The stability and the dynamics of flapping flags are governed by the interplay between
inertia, bending rigidity, and fluid dynamic forces.Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Dimitriadis, Grigorios 2024 Unsteady aerodynamics: potential and vortex methods, Aerospace series, vol. 1. Hoboken, NJ: John Wiley & Sons, Inc
Doare, Olivier & Michelin, S´ ebastien ´ 2011 Piezoelectric coupling in energy-harvesting fluttering flexible plates: linear stability analysis and conversion efficiency. Journal of Fluids and Structures 27 (8), 1357–1375
Eloy, Christophe, Kofman, Nicolas & Schouveiler, Lionel 2012 The origin of hysteresis in the flag instability. Journal of Fluid Mechanics 691, 583–593
Eloy, Christophe, Lagrange, Romain, Souilliez, Claire & Schouveiler, Lionel 2008 Aeroelastic instability of cantilevered flexible plates in uniform flow. Journal of Fluid Mechanics 611, 97–106
Eloy, C., Souilliez, C. & Schouveiler, L. 2007 Flutter of a rectangular plate. p. 2 In particular, we
focus on the effect of aspect ratio on the post-critical flapping regime of rectangular flags. We first review the flag instability and describe the spatial characteristics of the double-neck
flutter regime.Where the paper says it
Fernando, John N & Rival, David E 2016a On vortex evolution in the wake of axisymmetric and non-axisymmetric low-aspect-ratio accelerating plates. Physics of Fluids 28 (1)
Fernando, John N. & Rival, David E. 2016b Reynolds-number scaling of vortex pinch-off on low-aspectratio propulsors. p. 2 Three-dimensional flow structures are characterised by an
alternating release of horse-shoe shaped vortex tubes from the trailing edge, and the wake
structures weaken with decreasing aspect ratio (Huang & Sung 2010; Kumar et al. The
time-varying wake produced during flutter serves practical applications such as micro-scale
mixers on lab-on-chip devices (Rips & Mittal 2019), or low-Reynolds number heat dissipation
systems (Shoele & Mittal 2014).Where the paper says it
Gavriely, N., Shee, T. R., Cugell, D. W. & Grotberg, J. B. 1989 Flutter in flow-limited collapsible tubes: a mechanism for generation of wheezes. p. 2 More details on the origin of the flapping time
scales are desirable for further investigation of various applications involving membrane
flutter, including, for instance, the diagnostics of respiratory wheezes (Gavriely et al. 1989),
orinasal snoring and sleep apnoea syndromes (Huang 1995; Auregan & Depollier ´ 1995)
where the frequency of pressure waves is perceived as an audible sound.Where the paper says it
Green, Melissa A., Rowley, Clarence W. & Smits, Alexander J. 2011 The unsteady three-dimensional wake produced by a trapezoidal pitching panel. p. 2 Three-dimensional flow structures are characterised by an
alternating release of horse-shoe shaped vortex tubes from the trailing edge, and the wake
structures weaken with decreasing aspect ratio (Huang & Sung 2010; Kumar et al. The
time-varying wake produced during flutter serves practical applications such as micro-scale
mixers on lab-on-chip devices (Rips & Mittal 2019), or low-Reynolds number heat dissipation
systems (Shoele & Mittal 2014).Where the paper says it
Guermond, Jean-Luc & Sellier, Antoine 1991 A unified unsteady lifting-line theory. Journal of Fluid Mechanics 229, 427–451
Higuchi, H, Anderson, RW & Zhang, J 1996 Three-dimensional wake formations behind a family of regular polygonal plates. AIAA journal 34 (6), 1138–1145
Hiroaki, Keiichi & Watanabe, Masahiro 2024 Flutter generated on a sheet in 3d flow: influence of aspect ratio of sheets on post-critical and hysteretic behavior. Nonlinear Dynamics 112 (18), 15757–15770
Huang, L. 1995 Flutter of Cantilevered Plates in Axial Flow. p. 2 More details on the origin of the flapping time
scales are desirable for further investigation of various applications involving membrane
flutter, including, for instance, the diagnostics of respiratory wheezes (Gavriely et al. 1989),
orinasal snoring and sleep apnoea syndromes (Huang 1995; Auregan & Depollier ´ 1995)
where the frequency of pressure waves is perceived as an audible sound.Where the paper says it
Appendix Details
Appendix A describes the computation of the phase-averaged coefficients of the cantilevered modes from the projection of the dimensionless transverse deformation y(s, t)/L onto the beam mode shapes Appendix B describes how to compute a pressure estimate and derive a relationship between pressure and wave speed Appendix C details how circulation data were obtained from manual integration of positive and negative circulation shed during a stroke Appendix D defines the projected-area mean drag coefficient as C¯x,A = F¯x / √(rhofU∞2A H)
Figure Interpretations
Figure 1 shows the experimental setup, a sketch of the flag with its centreline highlighted with s = 0 at the root and s = L at the tip, and an exemplary visualisation of time-resolved measurements of the deformation of the centreline Figure 2 illustrates dimensionless tip amplitude and frequency as a function of reduced velocity for an example flag Figure 3 shows superposition of time-resolved centreline deformations for a flag with M∗ = 2.27 and H/L = 0.91 Figure 4 shows space-time diagrams of the lateral displacement y/L for two flags at M∗ = 2. p. 9 10
Figure 4: (a, b) Space-time diagrams of the lateral displacement 𝑦/𝐿 for 10 convective
times for two flags (a) 𝐻/𝐿 = 0. 28 and (b) 𝐻/𝐿 = 0.Where the paper says it
Final Summary
The dimensionless wave speed varies as the square root of the mass ratio times the square root of the dynamic pressure and the dynamic pressure is weakened by lower aspect ratio flags as predicted in analytical models The typical length scale to predict the reduction in released circulation during half a stroke should include the height to account for three-dimensional effects The ratio of the area over the perimeter L∗, and the square root of area √HL include both the information of the height and the length and are suitable scale parameters for the circulation of different aspect ratio flags The mean drag coefficient is proportional to M∗ v2tip/U2∞, which can be rewritten as C¯x = (π/2) × St2A / M∗ The typical planar area, or the projected area are not sufficient to explain the spread of measured mean drag coefficient C¯x ranging from 0 to 0.
Green — the paper says it, and the page is printed. Red — no passage carries it, so treat that sentence as unverified. The same check runs on your own text: check a summary against its source, $5.
Improvements for AI systems
-
Improved AI system can predict mean drag coefficient without fitting parameters by using a kinematic-based model that incorporates mass ratio and typical tip speed, as described in Section 1:
This model uses the mass ratio and the typical tip speed, which depends linearly on the wave speed, to predict the mean drag coefficient without any fitting parameter.
-
Improved AI system can accurately quantify propagation rates of travelling waves by employing a robust method to characterize spatiotemporal properties of flag deformation waves, as detailed in Section 3:
We introduce a robust method to quantify and characterise the spatiotemporal properties of the flag deformation waves.
-
Improved AI system can provide physical insights into why different flags have vastly different mean drag coefficients by combining flapping time scales results into an empirical model that quantitatively describes and explains the spread of drag data, as stated in Section 3:
We discuss and test a predictive model for the mean drag coefficient based on the tip velocity.
-
Improved AI system can characterize vortex formation variations with aspect ratio by analyzing phase-averaged dimensionless vorticity snapshots, enabling it to predict how vorticity intensity decreases and coherence changes with decreasing aspect ratio, as shown in Section 3:
With decreasing aspect ratio, the intensity of the vorticity in the wake decreases and the wake vortices are less coherent.
-
Improved AI system can relate wave speed to dynamic pressure by using a derived scaling relationship where
The dimensionless wave speed varies as the square root of the mass ratio times the square root of the dynamic pressure,
as stated in Section 3.5:The dimensionless wave speed varies as the square root of the mass ratio times the square root of the dynamic pressure.
Abstract
The flapping of flags is a classical problem involving fast, large amplitude deformations of a thin flexible plate and unsteady flow phenomena. We perform systematic time- and space-resolved measurements of the deformation and drag acting on flapping flags for various aspect ratios and mass ratios. Flag deformations travel from the root to the tip while growing in amplitude. We present a robust method to determine the travelling wave properties, and reveal that the dimensionless wavelength λ/L is constant for a given flutter mode, and that the wave speed equals the freestream velocity for aspect ratios above unity but decreases with decreasing mass and aspect ratio. We provide a mechanistic explanation of the influence of mass and aspect ratio on the flapping dynamics by introducing a mass-ratio-corrected dimensionless wave speed, which is proportional to the square root of the dynamic pressure difference across the flag. At smaller aspect ratio, the local dynamic pressure exerted by the fluid on the flag is reduced, leading to a decrease in the wave propagation speed and the tip frequency. Based on near wake flow field measurements, we identified two characteristic length scales, the ratio of flag area over its perimeter L* and the square root of area sqrt HL that scale the circulation of vortices shed per cycle. Values of the mean drag coefficient scatter widely, from to, when varying mass and aspect ratio. We can collapse the data when using a kinematics-based model with the mass ratio and the tip speed as inputs.
Related papers
- Emergent Transfer of a Physics Foundation Model from Simulation to Laboratory Turbulence
- Early onset of secondary shear instability in Kelvin-Helmholtz braids at high Reynolds number
- Rotational covariance, continuous spectrum and non-modal growth of three-dimensional planar weak viscous shock layers
- Deep Learning-based Algebraic Reynolds Stress Closures for RANS Simulations of Turbulent Flows
- Neptuna: A Comprehensive Machine Learning Framework for Benchmarking Complex Multiphase Flows
- Size and shape of condensing steam jets and plumes