Linear relations among radicals

arXiv:2511.02498 · math.NT · Submitted 2025-11-04 · Read on arXiv

Listen

Radio episode about this paper

Transcript

Introduction to the show: ident: Mathematics. The day in mathematics: new theorems, new proofs, and what they open.

Ada: We're looking at the paper: "Linear relations among radicals".

Emmy: Here's the gist of the paper. Let K be a field, fix an algebraic closure K, and let G be a subgroup of K×.

Ada: We are able to give a closed formula for the ratio between the degree

K(G): K: and the index GK×: K×, provided that the latter is finite Our formula explains all the K-linear relations among radicals, which (beyond the ones stemming from the multiplicative group GK×/K×) are generated by relations among roots of unity and single radicals Main Theorem Summary The main result of this paper is that a closed formula exists for the ratio between the degree

K(G): K: and the index GK×: K×, which explains all the K-linear relations among radicals in GK× Entanglement and Relations Among Radicals The paper investigates entanglement (of radicals), a phenomenon that occurs when all K-linear relations among the radicals in G do not stem from multiplicative relations The smallest positive integer n such that Gn ⊆ K× is denoted by n, and z is the product of the odd prime divisors p of n such that ζp ∈/ K× and ζp ∈ GK×.

Ada: If n is odd, the ratio

K(G): K: GK×: K× equals

K(ζz): K: µn(GK×) ∩ K(ζz)×: µn(K×).

Paper summary: Ada: To follow up on that, the paper starts by defining what they mean by radicals over a field K, which are elements alpha in K times for which there's an integer n coprime to the characteristic of K such that alpha to the power of n is in K times.

Emmy: They fix a group G of these radicals where the index GK times K times: K times is finite, and they look at the degree of this extension over K, which they call G over K.

Kolya: Then they investigate how that degree compares to that index, trying to find a closed formula for their ratio under specific conditions. It seems like they are trying to pin down the relationship between algebraic structure and group structure here.

Ada: The core claim is that if all the K-linear relations among the radicals in G come from multiplicative relations, then they can give you a precise way to calculate that degree versus that index.

Emmy: They also look at a phenomenon where certain powers of zeta p times p over n of order larger than p, which are inside GK times K times, can actually be contained in the field generated by zeta p.

Kolya: That leads to these new K-linear relations among roots of unity, and they equate those expressions to find a relation among the roots of unity themselves. It’s a structural link between the multiplicative group and the radical structure here.

Ada: They also look at elements in µ n prime times GK times K times intersecting with powers of zeta z, which are powers of zeta n prime and also K-linear combinations of powers of zeta z. Equating those gives another relation among the roots of unity.

Conclusion: Emmy: Thinking about the title "Linear relations among radicals," it really focuses on those non-multiplicative ways that these radical elements can be related over K. The authors are essentially saying there's a complete accounting for how radicals interact linearly, not just multiplicatively.

Ada: And the implication is that if you want to understand the full structure of an extension involving radicals, you don't just look at the multiplicative group part; you have to factor in these linear relations among roots of unity and single radicals.

Kolya: So for someone looking at this from a probabilistic side, it suggests that these linear relations govern the behavior of certain extensions, and understanding their structure helps bound how complex those extensions can get.

Emmy: They also look at growth bounds in radical extensions later on, which shows that there's a way to bound the degree of these extensions by looking at specific subgroups related to n.

Ada: The paper sets up this framework by showing that all the relations they are interested in are explained by these roots of unity and single radicals, which is a very strong structural statement about how these elements combine over K.

ANTONELLA PERUCCA

math.NT

Submitted: 2025-11-04

Updated: 2026-11-09

Comments: v2: Theorem 3 and its applications in the paper have been corrected

License: http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/

Importance score: 76/100

The gist: Let K be a field, fix an algebraic closure K, and let G be a subgroup of K×.

Key concepts

Entanglement (of radicals)
This refers to K-linear relationships among the various radical elements within a group G. The paper investigates when these relations do not arise solely from the standard multiplicative structure of GK×/K×, focusing on how roots of unity and single radicals generate these extra dependencies.
n
This is the smallest positive integer such that Gn is contained within K×. It plays a crucial role in determining the structure of the ratio formula. If n is odd, a specific formula applies; if n is even, a more complex formula involving 2fn' and other terms must be used.
Kneser’s Theorem
This theorem relates the index |GK×: K×| to the degree [K(G): K] under certain conditions concerning roots of unity in K×. It establishes a baseline relationship, but the paper shows that if specific conditions (like z > 1) are not met, this equality cannot hold.
Kummer Theory
This theory connects the Galois group Gal(K(G)/K), the multiplicative group GK×/K×, and the radical extension GnK×n/K×n when a root of unity ζn is in K. It leads to an isomorphism where all three groups are identical, simplifying the degree calculation.

Terminology

Summary

Let K be a field, fix an algebraic closure K, and let G be a subgroup of K×. p. 0

Where the paper says it

LINEAR RELATIONS AMONG RADICALS ANTONELLA PERUCCA In memory of Marc Rybowicz ABSTRACT. Let K be a field, fix an algebraic closure K, and let G be a subgroup of K × .

We are able to give a closed formula for the ratio between the degree [K(G): K] and the index GK×: K×, provided that the latter is finite Our formula explains all the K-linear relations among radicals, which (beyond the ones stemming from the multiplicative group GK×/K×) are generated by relations among roots of unity and single radicals

Main Theorem Summary

The main result of this paper is that a closed formula exists for the ratio between the degree [K(G): K] and the index GK×: K×, which explains all the K-linear relations among radicals in GK×

Entanglement and Relations Among Radicals

The paper investigates entanglement (of radicals), a phenomenon that occurs when all K-linear relations among the radicals in G do not stem from multiplicative relations

** The smallest positive integer n such that Gn ⊆ K× is denoted by n, and z is the product of the odd prime divisors p of n such that ζp ∈/ K× and ζp ∈ GK×. 1. **

** If n is odd, the ratio [K(G): K] GK×: K× equals [K(ζz): K] µn(GK×) ∩ K(ζz)×: µn(K×). p. 0

Where the paper says it

If n is odd, we have [K(G) : K] |GK× : K×| = [K(ζz) : K] |µn(GK×) ∩ K(ζz)× : µn(K×)| . If n is even, writing n = 2fn ′ where f is a positive integer and n ′ is an odd integer, the ratio [K(G):K] |GK×:K×| equals [K(ζz) : K] · 2 −∆ |µn′(GK×) ∩ K(ζz)× : µn′(K×)| · |µ2 f+1 (GK×)(GK× ∩ √ K×) ∩ K(ζz)× : K×| where ∆ is the non-negative integer from Definition 17.

1. **

** If n is even, writing n = 2fn', the ratio equals [K(ζz): K] · 2 −∆ µn′(GK×) ∩ K(ζz)×: µn′(K×) · µ2 f+1 (GK×)(GK× ∩ √K×) ∩ K(ζz)×: K×. 1. **

** This result allows to completely understand the K-linear relations among the radicals in GK×. p. 0

Where the paper says it

If n is even, writing n = 2fn ′ where f is a positive integer and n ′ is an odd integer, the ratio [K(G):K] |GK×:K×| equals [K(ζz) : K] · 2 −∆ |µn′(GK×) ∩ K(ζz)× : µn′(K×)| · |µ2 f+1 (GK×)(GK× ∩ √ K×) ∩ K(ζz)× : K×| where ∆ is the non-negative integer from Definition 17. This result allows to completely understand the K-linear relations among the radicals in GK×: for p an odd prime such that ζp ∈ GK× and ζp ∈/ K×, calling dp = [K(ζp) : K], we have ζ dp p , .

3. **

Kneser's Theorem and Kummer Theory

The paper explores Kneser’s theorem and Kummer theory in relation to radical extensions

** The sequence (1) implies GK×: K× = G nK×n: K×n · µn(GK×): µn(K×). 3. **

** Theorem 4 (Kneser’s Theorem) states that [K(G): K] = GK×: K× if certain conditions hold regarding the presence of roots of unity in K×. p. 2

Where the paper says it

We rely on the famous result by Martin Kneser from [6]: Theorem 4 (Kneser’s Theorem). We have [K(G) : K] = |GK× : K×| if the following two conditions hold: for every odd prime p we have ζp ∈ K× or ζp ∈/ GK×; we have ζ4 ∈ K× or 1 ± ζ4 ∈/ GK×.

3. **

** Proposition 5 shows that the two conditions in Kneser’s theorem are necessary, implying that if z > 1, [K(G): K] GK×: K× cannot be equal. p. 2

Where the paper says it

Our main result implies the following: Proposition 5. The two conditions in Kneser’s theorem are necessary.

3. **

** Theorem 7 (Kummer theory) states that if ζn ∈ K, the groups Gal(K(G)/K), GK×/K× and GnK×n/K×n are isomorphic, leading to [K(G): K] = GK×: K× = G nK×n: K ×n. p. 3

Where the paper says it

4 ANTONELLA PERUCCA Theorem 7 (Kummer theory). If ζn ∈ K, the groups Gal(K(G)/K) and GK×/K× and GnK×n/K×n are isomorphic.

4. **

Case Analysis for Even Exponents

The paper analyzes the case where n is a power of 2, setting n = 2f, and introduces related concepts like ξ2t

** Lemma 10 (Schinzel) concerns the kernel of a map related to K×/K×n induced by the inclusion. 7. **

** Theorem 13 defines a subgroup H based on conditions involving w, f, and whether −ξn2w+1 ∈/ GnK×n, such that [K(G): K] GK×: K× = [K(H): K] HK×: K×. p. 5

Where the paper says it

Let δ be as in Theorem 12 and set H =    µ2n(GK×) if w > f µn(GK×) if w = f and −ξ n 2w+1 ∈/ GnK×n ⟨1 + ζ2w , ζn⟩ if w = f and −ξ n 2w+1 ∈ GnK×n µn(GK×) if w < f and δ = 1 < 1 + ζ2w > µn(GK×) if w < f and δ = 1/2 . Then H is a subgroup of GK× and we have [K(G) : K] |GK× : K×| = [K(H) : K] |HK× : K×| .

6. **

** Lemma 14 provides formulas for [K(H):K] HK×:K× based on the value of m and the condition of w, f, and δ. p. 0

Where the paper says it

Our formula explains all the K-linear relations among radicals, which (beyond the ones stemming from the multiplicative group GK×/K×) are generated by relations among roots of unity and single radicals. Our work builds on results by Rybowicz, which in turn are based on work by Kneser and Schinzel.

7. **

General Case and Growth Bounds

The general case involves factoring n into prime powers pvp for primes p dividing n, leading to a decomposition of the degree

** Remark 15 states that GK×: K× = Yp GpK×: K× where p varies among the prime divisors of n. 8. **

** Theorem 16 (Schinzel’s theorem on abelian radical extensions) provides a formula for [K(G): K] GK×: K× involving Yp terms. p. 1

Where the paper says it

Our results build on two theorems by Rybowicz (Theorems 8 and 12) which express the degree [K(G) : K] also in the cases in which the famous theorem by Kneser (Theorem 4) cannot be applied. Other results that we make use of is a lemma by Schinzel about radicals to extend the base field to K(ζ4) (Lemma 10) and Schinzel’s Theorem on abelian radical extensions (Theorem 16).

9. **

** Theorem 18 establishes a bound on the growth of radical extensions, stating that there exists an N0 such that [K(RN): K] RNK×: K× = [K(Rgcd(N,N0)): K] Rgcd(N,N0)K×: K×. p. 9

Where the paper says it

So suppose that N is even. Since RN ∩ √ K× = R2 v2(N) ∩ √ K× and because of the bound on |RNK× : K×| we may define N0 (such that v2(N0) is large enough) so that RNK× ∩ √ K× = Rgcd(N,N0)K× ∩ √ K×.

10. **

** Theorem 19 reformulates the result for a finitely generated subgroup Γ of K× as [K(RN): K] RNK×: K× = [K(Rgcd(N,N0)): K] Rgcd(N,N0)K×: K× · YpN,p∤N0,ζp∈/K× p − 1. p. 9

Where the paper says it

Let K be a number field, fix a finitely generated subgroup Γ of K× and for every positive integer N let RN = N√ Γ. Then there exists a positive integer N0 such that [K(RN ) : K] |RNK× : K×| = [K(Rgcd(N,N0) ) : K] |Rgcd(N,N0)K× : K×| · Y p|N,p∤N0,ζp∈/K× p − 1 p .

10. **

Conclusion on Entanglement Sources

The paper concludes that all entanglement stems from K-linear relations among roots of unity

** The K-linear relation 1 + ζp + ζ2p + · · · + ζp−1 p = 0 has to be counted only if ζp ∈/ K×, and it is only relevant if ζp ∈ GK×. 5. **

** The minimal polynomial of ζp gives a K-linear relation among 1, ζp,. p. 4

Where the paper says it

LINEAR RELATIONS AMONG RADICALS 5 has to be counted only if ζp ∈/ K×, and it is only relevant if ζp ∈ GK×. If dp := [K(ζp) : K], the minimal polynomial of ζp gives a K-linear relation among 1, ζp, .

.., ζdp p, and all the powers ζ i p for i ≥ dp are K-linear combinations of the roots of unity 1, ζp,. p. 4
Where the paper says it

If dp := [K(ζp) : K], the minimal polynomial of ζp gives a K-linear relation among 1, ζp, . , ζdp p , and all the powers ζ i p for i ⩾ dp are K-linear combinations of the roots of unity 1, ζp, .

.., ζdp−1 p. p. 4
Where the paper says it

If dp := [K(ζp) : K], the minimal polynomial of ζp gives a K-linear relation among 1, ζp, . , ζdp p , and all the powers ζ i p for i ⩾ dp are K-linear combinations of the roots of unity 1, ζp, .

5. **

** These K-linear relations generate all others for K(G) (beyond those stemming from the group GK×/K×) because by the above result they already explain the degree of K(G)/K. p. 4

Where the paper says it

We also have (ζpm) p j+max(m−m0,0) ∈ 1K + ζpK + · · · + ζ dp−1 p K for j ⩾ 0 because any element in K(ζp) is of this form. These K-linear relations generate all others for K(G) (beyond those stemming from the group GK×/K×) because by the above result they already explain the degree of K(G)/K.

5.

Green — the paper says it, and the page is printed. Red — no passage carries it, so treat that sentence as unverified. The same check runs on your own text: check a summary against its source, $5.

Improvements for AI systems

  1. Improved AI can compute a closed formula for the ratio between degree [K(G): K] and index GKx: Kx when GKx: Kx is finite, explaining all K-linear relations among radicals beyond those stemming from multiplicative group GKx/Kx.

  2. Improved AI can determine if all K-linear relations among the radicals in G stem from multiplicative relations by comparing the degree and index, identifying the phenomenon called entanglement (of radicals).

  3. Improved AI can compute a specific ratio based on whether n is odd or even, providing a formula for the ratio [K(G): K] / GKx: Kx involving terms like [K(ζz): K] and subgroups of roots of unity.

  4. Improved AI can deduce that the degree [K(G): K] divides 1/z · [K(ζz): K] · GKx: Kx, providing a general property for radical extensions based on the main result.

  5. Improved AI can determine if certain powers of ζp of order larger than p (and contained in GKx) may be contained in K(ζp) x, leading to further K-linear relations among the roots of unity.

  6. Improved AI can identify K-linear relations among roots of unity by equating expressions for elements in µn'GKx ∩ K(ζz) x and powers of ζn', or between single elements of G whose square is in Kx and powers of ζ2f+1z.

  7. Improved AI can use the main result to deduce that [K(G): K] divides 1/z · [K(ζz): K] · GKx: Kx.

Abstract

Let K be a field, fix an algebraic closure, and let G be a subgroup of times. We are able to give a closed formula for the ratio between the degree [K(G):K] and the index GK times:K times, provided that the latter is finite. Our formula explains all the K-linear relations among radicals, which (beyond the ones stemming from the multiplicative group GK times/K times) are generated by relations among roots of unity and single radicals. Our work builds on results by Rybowicz, which in turn are based on work by Kneser and Schinzel.

Sources

Related papers