A transmission hologram for slitless spectrophotometry on a convergent telescope beam. Optimisation and characterization

arXiv:2509.25547 · astro-ph.IM · Submitted 2025-09-29 · Read on arXiv

Listen

Radio episode about this paper

Transcript

Introduction to the show: ident: Astrophysics. The day in astrophysics: observations, models and what the data forces.

Vera: We're looking at the paper: "A transmission hologram for slitless spectrophotometry on a convergent telescope beam. Optimisation and characterization".

Jocelyn: Here's the gist of the paper. A transmission hologram for slitless spectrophotometry on a convergent telescope beam details the optimization and characterization of a holographic optical element that has been successfully installed on the Rubin-LSST observatory's auxiliary telescope to measure atmospheric transparency as a function of wavelength.

Vera: Context and Aims This article details the optimization and the characterization of the hologram described in a companion paper published in 2021, which showed the superiority of a holographic optical element over a periodic grating as a disperser installed in the path of a converging beam on an on-axis detector for slitless spectroscopy.

Jocelyn: The goal was to produce a hologram with the best diffraction performance across the entire spectrum covered by the filters of the Rubin-LSST observatory’s main telescope.

Vera: Optimization Process The optimization strategy was driven by optical test-bench measurements, which enabled a progressive refinement of the fabrication parameters (e.g.

Title and authors: Vera: So we're looking at this paper, "A transmission hologram for slitless spectrophotometry on a convergent telescope beam. Optimisation and characterization," which details how they fine-tuned this holographic element installed on the Rubin-LSST observatory to measure atmospheric transparency across different wavelengths.

Jocelyn: Exactly, it’s about taking that optical element and making it as effective as possible for slitless spectroscopy, which means we can study the atmosphere without needing a slit.

Subrahmanyan: I'm curious about how they compared this holographic approach to what they were using before, like a periodic grating.

Vera: Well, the paper says this new holographic element showed superiority over a standard periodic grating as a disperser in the path of that converging beam on an on-axis detector for slitless spectroscopy.

Jocelyn: So, it’s not just about having one good part, but showing that this thin hologram has better diffraction performance across the whole spectrum covered by the main telescope's filters.

Subrahmanyan: That makes sense when you think about gathering atmospheric data; you want the best possible signal through that element to constrain things like how light is actually getting affected by the air.

Vera: They drove this optimization using test bench measurements, which led them through three successive generations of prototypes to refine things like the exposure time and grain size of the emulsion.

Jocelyn: And they were focused on maximizing that first-order diffraction light over as wide a wavelength range as possible, specifically looking at a recording laser wavelength of six hundred thirty-nine nanometers.

Subrahmanyan: It sounds like they were systematically testing different fabrication parameters to see what really gave them the best results for this dispersion element.

Vera: Right, and they found that optimizing those parameters pushed them toward a maximum first-order diffraction transmission of thirty-two percent with the thin hologram, which is very close to the theoretical maximum possible.

Jocelyn: Thirty-two percent is a solid number, and they also confirmed through bench measurements that the separating power of this hologram is better than one nanometer at five hundred seventy-seven nanometers.

Subrahmanyan: That level of separation precision at those wavelengths is important for high-resolution spectroscopy, and on-sky tests with varying detector characteristics showed reliable operation across a range defined by delta w, delta l, and delta DCCD.

Vera: It sounds like the optimization process was really systematic, moving from one prototype to the next based on measured transmission curves to push toward that theoretical limit.

Jocelyn: What I find interesting is how they modeled this mathematically using a complex two dimensional transmission function, H of w, l and lambda.

Subrahmanyan: Modeling the recording and image restitution using that function shows them have a formal way to predict the performance of this element as it works across the spectrum.

Vera: They derived that local complex two dimensional transmission function from the local optical path supplement map, which they then modeled using a sigmoid parametrization based on how that optical path difference changes with illumination.

Jocelyn: So they’re not just measuring; they’re building a model of how the light interacts with the emulsion based on those physical optics.

Subrahmanyan: And by relating the relative intensity of a plane wave diffracted at order p by a grating to the square of that one dimensional Fourier coefficient, tp lambda squared, they connect it back to traditional diffraction theory.

Vera: The result is that this final hologram has demonstrated a wavelength resolution superior to what you'd get from a periodic grating and achieved high diffracted light throughput, up to thirty-two percent.

Jocelyn: This element is now enabling the high performance slitless spectrophotometry needed to study atmospheric transmission, and it’s already being used as part of the Rubin-LSST survey.

Subrahmanyan: The implication here is that this technique could be generalized to transform any imaging telescope into a high performance, low cost slitless spectrograph without needing extra mechanical modifications.

Vera: That would really open up a lot of possibilities for how we use existing imaging telescopes for atmospheric characterization.

Jocelyn: It’s also interesting that they looked at predicting the spectral resolution, R lambda sigma zero lambda, using an expression that depends on atmospheric turbulence quantified by sigma zero equals seeing over two point three five arcsec minus one.

Subrahmanyan: That links the performance of different diffraction orders to how much atmospheric seeing is present at a given wavelength.

Vera: And they also mentioned a way to verify the geometry of production retrospectively by analyzing dispersion properties as a function of beam impact location, which checks for manufacturing repeatability across different holograms.

Jocelyn: So it sounds like this whole process—from the initial design to the final characterization—is very rigorous and covers both optical performance and manufacturing quality.

Subrahmanyan: It’s a good demonstration of how precision optics, when coupled with systematic optimization, can yield an instrument that performs better than simpler alternatives for a specific task.

Vera: To wrap up on the transmission hologram for slitless spectrophotometry on a convergent telescope beam. Optimisation and characterization, this paper shows how careful optimization of the fabrication parameters leads to a high performance element that exceeds grating performance in terms of resolution and throughput.

Jocelyn: It really shows how we can use light interference patterns recorded on an emulsion to achieve slitless spectroscopy for atmospheric studies.

Subrahmanyan: The real impact is that this method could become a standard tool for transforming various imaging telescopes into flexible, high performance spectrographs in the future.

The paper's summary: Vera: So, this paper is about taking that holographic element they built and really dialing in how good it gets for measuring atmospheric transparency across different wavelengths, without needing a physical slit in the light path.

Jocelyn: Right, so they took a complex setup—a transmission hologram on a converging beam—and spent a lot of time optimizing the fabrication details to get the best possible signal when you look at how light passes through it.

Subrahmanyan: I see it as them trying to squeeze every bit of usable spectral information out of that optical element, which is crucial if we want to understand what’s happening in the atmosphere.

Vera: Exactly. They show that this holographic element is actually better than using a standard periodic grating for dispersion when you're doing slitless spectroscopy on an on-axis detector.

Jocelyn: It means they managed to create something with superior diffraction performance across the entire spectrum of what the main telescope filters can see.

Subrahmanyan: If it performs better than a simpler periodic grating, that’s a solid result because it suggests they’ve found a way to handle the light interaction more efficiently.

Vera: They optimized their fabrication process through three generations of prototypes, tweaking things like the exposure time and the grain size of the emulsion to maximize that first-order diffraction light.

Jocelyn: And when they got there, they achieved a maximum first-order diffraction transmission of thirty two percent with this thin hologram, which is close to what theory predicts is possible.

Subrahmanyan: Thirty two percent throughput is significant because it tells us how much useful light we can get through the system for atmospheric studies.

Vera: They also confirmed that the separating power of this hologram actually beats one nanometer at five hundred seventy-seven nanometers, which is a key measurement for resolving spectral features.

Jocelyn: So, they’re not just looking at how much light gets through; they’re measuring how precisely they can separate different wavelengths using this setup.

Subrahmanyan: That precision is what matters when you’re trying to measure atmospheric parameters because the turbulence really affects those fine details in the spectrum.

Vera: On-sky tests, using a DCCD detector, showed that this element works reliably over a range defined by five minus five millimeters for width and ten to ten millimeters for length.

Jocelyn: It’s good to know it holds up in real conditions, not just on a bench test setup.

Subrahmanyan: And the conclusion is that this final hologram gives them wavelength resolution better than a periodic grating, while still maintaining high light throughput, up to that thirty two percent level.

Vera: The big implication is that this technique can be used for high performance slitless spectrophotometry to study atmospheric transmission, and it’s already being used in the Rubin-LSST survey.

Jocelyn: It’s a practical tool now, but they also suggested this method could be generalized to turn any imaging telescope into a high performance, low cost slitless spectrograph.

Subrahmanyan: That generalization would be huge if it means we can use existing telescopes for atmospheric characterization without needing extra mechanical modifications.

Vera: The work also included a way to predict the spectral resolution using an expression that depends on atmospheric turbulence quantified by sigma zero equals seeing over two point three five arcsec minus one.

Jocelyn: So they’re linking the performance of different diffraction orders directly to how much atmospheric seeing is present at a specific wavelength.

Subrahmanyan: That connection between turbulence and spectral resolution is important for modeling structure formation and how those details get smeared out by the air.

Vera: They also mentioned using a fitted geometric model from a previous paper to check the production geometry, which ensures that manufacturing stays consistent across different holograms.

Jocelyn: It sounds like they’ve covered both the performance of the optical element and making sure it’s actually being built correctly every time.

Subrahmanyan: It’s a good demonstration of how careful optimization can yield an instrument that performs better than simpler alternatives for measuring atmospheric effects.

The paper's improvements: Tom: So, we're looking at what they suggest to do next with this hologram system—basically, how they want to improve on what they just achieved in terms of design and operation.

Vera: They propose an automated optimization system that can use a mathematical model of the transmission function to guide decisions between different prototype series faster than manual testing.

Jocelyn: That’s smart because it cuts down on those three generations of prototypes they had to build just to find the best settings for things like the exposure time and grain size.

Subrahmanyan: If you can automate the search for the best fabrication parameters, that really speeds up how quickly we can iterate toward a better optical element.

Vera: They also suggest a way to use that transmission model in real time to estimate atmospheric transparency, which is based on the optical path shift they modeled earlier.

Jocelyn: So, instead of waiting for the final measurement record to process everything, you could deduce what light is actually passing through between the atmosphere and your detector right away.

Subrahmanyan: That real-time estimation would be powerful because it lets you look at atmospheric effects as they happen, which is key for cosmology stuff.

Vera: Another suggestion involves designing a high throughput slitless spectrograph that can use this thin hologram inserted into any converging beam path without needing extra mechanical modifications.

Jocelyn: That’s the generalization part—taking this concept and making it useful for *any* imaging telescope, not just the Rubin-LSST auxiliary telescope.

Subrahmanyan: If you can transform any imager into a high performance, low cost spectrograph that way, that opens up a lot of possibilities for using existing infrastructure.

Vera: They also think there’s a way to use the spectral resolution formula they developed to predict how different diffraction orders will perform based on atmospheric turbulence, quantified by sigma zero equals seeing over two point three five arcsec minus one.

Jocelyn: So they're trying to build a predictive tool for performance across different wavelengths based on the actual seeing conditions you’re getting.

Subrahmanyan: That link between turbulence and resolution is important because it helps us understand how much atmospheric distortion affects our measurements of large-scale structure.

Vera: Finally, they suggest an automated geometric characteristic verification system that uses a fitted geometric model to check the production geometry of the hologram retrospectively by analyzing dispersion properties based on where the beam hits.

Jocelyn: So it's not just about how good the final result looks, but making sure the manufacturing process is repeatable across different holographic elements.

Subrahmanyan: That verification step is important for building trust in a new type of instrument, ensuring that what you measure isn't just an artifact of how it was physically made.

Vera: It sounds like they’re moving from proving it works to building a whole system that can optimize itself and predict its own performance.

Jocelyn: And the next step after building the element is figuring out how to actually use this data efficiently for atmospheric science.

Conclusion: Tom: So, to wrap up, this paper on "A transmission hologram for slitless spectrophotometry on a convergent telescope beam" shows how they successfully optimized a holographic element to achieve better spectral resolution and light throughput than standard gratings for atmospheric studies.

Vera: Basically, they proved that this specific optical element is reliable enough to be installed directly into the Rubin-LSST survey setup for measuring atmospheric transparency as wavelength changes.

Jocelyn: It shows that we can get high quality data on how the atmosphere affects light without having to physically cut a slit in our telescope's beam path.

Subrahmanyan: From a cosmology point of view, this is useful because it provides a way to constrain the effects of atmospheric turbulence on the light we use for observations across various wavelengths.

Vera: They’ve shown that even with the limitations they found, like having to deal with varying detector characteristics defined by delta w, delta l and delta DCCD, it still works reliably over a specific range.

Jocelyn: And the potential to generalize this technique is huge for future instruments; they think you can use this method to turn any imaging telescope into a high performance, low cost slitless spectrograph.

Subrahmanyan: If that generalization holds up across different telescope designs, it could fundamentally change how we approach ground-based atmospheric characterization studies.

Vera: The work on optimizing the fabrication parameters and modeling the complex transmission function gives us a solid blueprint for designing these elements in the future.

Jocelyn: It’s a great piece of engineering that connects optical design directly to real sky observations, which is what we love to see.

Subrahmanyan: This paper moves us closer to having better tools for modeling how things look when light travels through turbulent media, which is always a big deal in structure formation studies.

S. Dagoret-Campagne, M. Moniez, J. Neveu, A. Blot, P. Antilogus, C. Juramy, L. Le Guillou, É Repain2E Sepulveda2C Michel3F Colas4

Laboratoire de Physique des deux infinis Iréne Joliot-Curie, University Paris-Saclay, CNRS/IN2P3 · Laboratoire de Physique Nuclére et de Hautes Énergies · IP2I - Plateforme LMA, Observatoire de Paris

astro-ph.IM

Submitted: 2025-09-29

Updated: 2026-10-03

Comments: V2: paper shortened with some reorganization, but scientific results unchanged with respect to V1. 13 pages, 18 figures, accepted by A&A

Journal ref: A&A 715, A89 (2026)

DOI: 10.1051/0004-6361/202557458

License: http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-sa/4.0/

Importance score: 83/100

The gist: A transmission hologram for slitless spectrophotometry on a convergent telescope beam details the optimization and characterization of a holographic optical element that has been successfully…

Key concepts

Transmission Hologram
A specialized optical element created by recording a pattern onto a thin film (emulsion) to manipulate light waves. This specific hologram was designed to act as a disperser in slitless spectroscopy, allowing the measurement of atmospheric transparency across different wavelengths.
Slitless Spectrophotometry
A technique used to measure the spectral properties of light without physically splitting the beam into separate slits. The transmission hologram is crucial here because it uses diffraction to spread the light spectrum, enabling high-resolution measurements directly from a single beam.
Diffraction Performance
This refers to how effectively the hologram spreads incoming light into different orders (like p=1). Optimization focused on maximizing this performance across a wide wavelength range. Achieving 32% first-order transmission indicates excellent light throughput and spectral dispersion capabilities.
Atmospheric Transparency Modeling
The paper uses mathematical models to relate the optical path shift ($\Delta(Erec, \lambda)$) caused by atmospheric turbulence to the measured diffraction patterns. This allows scientists to deduce how much light is lost or shifted as it travels from the top of the atmosphere into the detector.

Summary

A transmission hologram for slitless spectrophotometry on a convergent telescope beam details the optimization and characterization of a holographic optical element that has been successfully installed on the Rubin-LSST observatory's auxiliary telescope to measure atmospheric transparency as a function of wavelength.

Context and Aims

This article details the optimization and the characterization of the hologram described in a companion paper published in 2021, which showed the superiority of a holographic optical element over a periodic grating as a disperser installed in the path of a converging beam on an on-axis detector for slitless spectroscopy. The goal was to produce a hologram with the best diffraction performance across the entire spectrum covered by the filters of the Rubin-LSST observatory’s main telescope. p. 0

Where the paper says it

We describe in detail the steps and results of optimizing the final optical holographic element installed on the spectrograph, with an emphasis on the equipment and modeling tools used. The goal was to produce a hologram with the best diffraction performance across the entire spectrum covered by the filters of the Rubin-LSST observatory’s main telescope.

Optimization Process

The optimization strategy was driven by optical test-bench measurements, which enabled a progressive refinement of the fabrication parameters (e.g. exposure time, grain size, and chemical bath composition) over three successive generations of prototypes. p. 2

Where the paper says it

Detail of the assembled production optical bench showing the microscope objectives, the 30µm filtering holes, the prism-mirror and the illuminated plate. grain size, and chemical bath composition) over three successive generations of prototypes.

The process involved several series of prototypes to maximize first-order diffraction light over the widest wavelength range. p. 4
Where the paper says it

sion type and thickness, and the laser beam intensity ratio were adjusted to achieve the transmissions shown in Fig. We optimized all these parameters to maximize first-order diffraction light over the widest wavelength range, using the series of prototypes briefly described below.

Key parameters optimized included the recording laser wavelength λR = 639 nm, exposure time of 150 ms, and a beam intensity ratio of about 1/3. p. 4
Where the paper says it

We optimized all these parameters to maximize first-order diffraction light over the widest wavelength range, using the series of prototypes briefly described below. A preliminary series of tests enabled us to determine the recording laser wavelength λR = 639 nm, and to select the silver halide emulsions (Bjelkhagen 1995).

Modeling and Theoretical Basis

A formal mathematical modeling of the recording and image restitution is proposed using the complex 2D transmission function H(w, l, λ). The local complex 2D transmission function of the emulsion is derived from the local optical path supplement map ∆(Erec(w, l), λ). p. 6

Where the paper says it

The curves labeled λ = 400 nm and 1000 nm show the effect of the emulsion exposed to Erec energy on the transmission of light at these wavelengths (see Sect. (Bottom) the resulting phase supplement motif along the dispersion axis of the recorded periodic pattern ∆(Erec, f) as a function of f the fractional position in the periodic motif.

This dependence is modeled by a sigmoid parametrization ∆(Erec, λ) = ∆max(λ) / (1 + exp [−γ(Erec − E0)/E0)]. p. 5
Where the paper says it

Combined with the characteristic exposure–density response of silver-halide emulsions, this motivates a sigmoid parametrization (Bjelkhagen (1995) and Neipp et al. (1999)) ∆(Erec, λ) = ∆max(λ) 1 + exp [−γ(Erec − E0)/E0)] , (3) where E0 ∼ 600 µJ/cm2 is the sensitivity of the Ultimate 04 emulsion (Gentet et al.

The relative intensity of a plane wave diffracted at order p by a grating is given by the square of the (1D) fourier coefficient tp(λ)2. p. 5
Where the paper says it

(1990) and Cruz-Arreola & Mata-Mendez (2011), the relative intensity of a plane wave of wavelength λ diffracted at order p by a grating periodic in direction w (see Fig. 1), described by the (1D) periodic transfer (or transmittance) function t(w, λ), is given by the square of the (1D) fourier coefficient tp(λ) |tp(λ)| 2= 1 a Z a 0 t(w, λ) exp [−i2πpw/a]dw 2 , (1) where w is the coordinate along the axis perpendicular to the grating lines and a is the period of the grating.

Performance and Validation

The optimization resulted in achieving a maximum first-order diffraction transmission of 32% with the thin hologram, which is very close to the theoretical maximum possible. Bench measurements confirmed good focus and that the separating power of the hologram is better than 1 nm at λ = 577 nm. p. 7

Where the paper says it

Resolution of the AuxTel spectrograph The measured main characteristics of the final hologram from a geometric point of view are as described in paper 1. Measurements performed on the test bench confirmed the good focus and that the separating power of the hologram is better than 1 nm at λ = 577 nm (Fig.

On-sky tests with varying DCCD confirm reliable operation over at least (∆w, ∆l, ∆DCCD) = ([−5, 5], [−10, 10], [120, 200]) mm. p. 6
Where the paper says it

Transmission remains constant to within 1% for ±(1, 1) mm and within 10% for ±(4, 4) mm across all wavelengths. Additional on-sky tests with varying DCCD confirm reliable operation over at least (∆w, ∆l, ∆DCCD) = ([−5, 5], [−10, 10], [120, 200]) mm around A ′ .

Conclusion and Application

The final hologram has demonstrated a wavelength resolution superior to that of a periodic grating and a high diffracted light throughput (up to 32%, close to the theoretical maximum possible). This element enables the high performance slitless spectrophotometry needed to study atmospheric transmission and is now in use as part of the Rubin-LSST survey. p. 0

Where the paper says it

This article details the optimization and the characterization of the hologram described in a companion paper published in 2021, which showed the superiority of a holographic optical element over a periodic grating as a disperser installed in the path of a converging beam on an on-axis detector (unbent spectrograph) for slitless spectroscopy. This hologram now equips the auxiliary telescope (AuxTel) at the Rubin-LSST observatory, a refurbished telescope designed to serve as both an imager and a spectrophotometer for measuring the transparency of the atmosphere as a function of wavelength.

The technique could be generalized to transform any imaging telescope into a high-performance, low-cost slitless spectrograph. p. 0
Where the paper says it

Consequently, this spectrograph cannot be angled—which produces optical path length variations with wavelength—and its disperser must be inserted into a converging (rather than parallel) beam. The hologram-based technique we propose has thus led us to a solution that can be generalized to any imager that the user might wish to easily convert into a spectrophotometer.

Green — the paper says it, and the page is printed. Red — no passage carries it, so treat that sentence as unverified. The same check runs on your own text: check a summary against its source, $5.

Improvements for AI systems

  1. Automated hologram optimization system This system can use a model like equation 3 to guide decisions between subsequent prototype series by comparing measured transmission curves, thereby accelerating the iterative refinement process described in Section 4.

  2. Real-time atmospheric transmission estimation The system can utilize the relationship described in Section 5.2.1 to model the optical path shift Delta (Delta(Erec, lambda)), allowing it to deduce in real time the effective pass-band crossed by light between the top of the atmosphere and detector output, as mentioned in Section 1.

  3. High-throughput slitless spectrograph design This system can generalize the technique to any imager by using a thin hologram inserted into a converging beam path, transforming it into a high-performance, low-cost slitless spectrograph without additional mechanical modifications.

  4. Accurate spectral resolution prediction This system can use the expression for spectral resolution R(lambda, sigma0(lambda)) to estimate the performance of different diffraction orders based on atmospheric turbulence quantified by sigma0 = seeing/2.35 arcsec-1, allowing for reliable performance prediction across wavelengths.

  5. Automated geometric characteristic verification This system can use the fitted geometric model from Paper 1 to verify the geometry of production retrospectively by analyzing dispersion properties as a function of beam impact location, ensuring manufacturing repeatability across different holograms.

Abstract

This article details the optimization and the characterization of the hologram described in a companion paper published in 2021, which showed the superiority of a holographic optical element over a periodic grating as a disperser installed in the path of a converging beam on an on-axis detector (unbent spectrograph) for slitless spectroscopy. This hologram now equips the auxiliary telescope (AuxTel) at the Rubin-LSST observatory, a refurbished telescope designed to serve as both an imager and a spectrophotometer for measuring the transparency of the atmosphere as a function of wavelength. We describe in detail the steps and results of optimizing the final optical holographic element installed on the spectrograph, with an emphasis on the equipment and modeling tools used. The goal was to produce a hologram with the best diffraction performance across the entire spectrum covered by the filters of the Rubin-LSST observatory's main telescope. We utilized our technical resources - an optical bench and telescopes for sky measurements - as well as specialized modeling tools, which enabled us to determine the optimal production parameters for the AuxTel hologram after four prototyping phases. We also conducted on-sky checks and measurements using various telescopes. Thanks to this optimization, we have succeeded in achieving a maximum first-order diffraction transmission of 32% with our thin hologram, a value very close to the theoretical maximum possible. This hologram has been in place on AuxTel's spectrograph since February 2021 and has been performing satisfactorily ever since, in conjunction with analysis software adapted to slitless spectroscopy.

Related papers