Precision Measurements of the Electroweak Mixing Angle in the Region of the Z pole at the Large Hadron Collider

arXiv:2508.18022 · hep-ex, hep-ph, hep-th · Submitted 2025-08-25 · Read on arXiv

Listen

Radio episode about this paper

Transcript

Introduction to the show: ident: High Energy Physics: Experiment. The day in high-energy experiment: detectors, searches and limits.

Kai: We're looking at the paper: "Precision Measurements of the Electroweak Mixing Angle in the Region of the Z pole at the Large Hadron Collider".

Title and authors: Kai: Moving on to the title and authors of "Precision Measurements of the Electroweak Mixing Angle in the Region of the Z pole at the Large Hadron Collider." The authors are Arie Bodek, Hyon-San Seo, and Un-Ki Yang.

Mira: I think it’s important to see who is doing this work because it shows a collaboration between different institutions, like Rochester and Seoul National University.

Lev: From an error correction perspective, having expertise from different groups means you're checking assumptions from multiple angles before committing to a result.

Kai: They are tackling the measurement of sin2 theta l eff in the region of the Z pole using data from the Large Hadron Collider, specifically looking at Drell-Yan events.

Mira: The title tells us this is about achieving high precision in measuring that effective leptonic weak mixing angle, sin2 theta l eff.

Lev: That quantity is crucial because it's a key parameter in the Standard Model that we can predict with very high accuracy using other known values like the mass of the Z boson and the fine structure constant.

Kai: So, in simple terms, they are using LHC data from Drell-Yan events to get a highly precise measurement of sin2 theta l eff.

Mira: And what's special about this paper is that they aren't just reporting one measurement; they are doing a comparison against both old electron collider results and theoretical predictions.

Lev: That comparison is what makes the result meaningful, because it tells us if the Standard Model still holds up under these new experimental conditions.

Kai: It’s about seeing if our measurements match what we expect from the Standard Model at this level of precision.

The paper's summary: Mira: The summary of "Precision Measurements of the Electroweak Mixing Angle in the Region of the Z pole at the Large Hadron Collider" tells us they are using updated CMS Drell-Yan AFB measurements at thirteen TeV <ref:2508.18022#pg2,at the Large Hadron Collider>.

Kai: That means they’re looking at dilepton events produced by proton collisions where we measure how the negative lepton is distributed in a specific angle called the Collins-Soper frame.

Lev: So, the measurement itself relies on taking that polar-angle distribution and writing it as a function of rapidity and mass of the dilepton pair.

Mira: The mathematical expression they use for this distribution is d sigma d theta proportional to one plus cos two theta plus A naught squared times one minus three cos two theta plus A four cos theta.

Lev: They then mention that for full acceptance, integrating over the cosine of the angle gives them Afull FB equal to three over eight times A four.

Kai: They explain that because the incoming quark direction isn't known event by event, they estimate it from the boost direction of the dilepton pair, which is based on valence quarks carrying more momentum than sea antiquarks.

Mira: So, in short, they are extracting sin2 theta l eff at thirteen TeV from this angular distribution by using that specific formula <ref:2508.18022#pg2>.

Lev: The summary also points out that the dominant source of uncertainty in their measurement comes from the uncertainties in the proton parton distribution functions.

Kai: That’s exactly what we discussed before, and they spend a lot of time on how to handle those PDFs by using re-weighting and profiling techniques.

Mira: So, in short, they are extracting sin2 theta l eff at thirteen TeV from Drell-Yan events while explicitly showing how the PDF uncertainties impact the final result <ref:2508.18022#pg2>.

The paper's improvements: Kai: The paper highlights that their main improvement comes from incorporating additional recent CMS measurements of W and Z boson production into the PDF profiling analysis.

Lev: That’s a key methodological step because those extra constraints reduce both the PDF uncertainty and the spread among modern PDF sets.

Mira: They use these measurements—the CMS thirteen TeV W boson decay lepton asymmetry and the W to Z cross section ratios at five point zero two and thirteen TeV—to refine their input PDFs <ref:2508.18022#pg3>.

Kai: When they include those, it leads them to a final extracted value of sin2 theta l eff equal to zero point two three one five four plus or minus zero point zero zero zero two four <ref:2508.18022#pg2>.

Lev: So, the impact is twofold: first, the PDF uncertainty gets reduced because of the new constraints, and second, you get a tighter final measurement.

Mira: That final number is in excellent agreement with the two thousand twenty-six Standard Model indirect prediction for one to M Z W divided by M Z <ref:2508.18022#pg1>.

Kai: It also gives us a useful input for reducing PDF uncertainties in other LHC extractions, which is a nice cross-over benefit.

Conclusion: Mira: So wrapping up the paper "Precision Measurements of the Electroweak Mixing Angle in the Region of the Z pole at the Large Hadron Collider." The main implication is that this analysis shows a more precise extraction method for sin2 theta l eff at thirteen TeV <ref:2508.18022#pg2>.

Kai: It’s about showing how combining Drell-Yan data with W and Z production ratios can give us a much cleaner measurement by constraining the input PDFs better.

Lev: The final result is that the value of sin2 theta l eff is zero point two three one five four plus or minus zero point zero zero zero two four, which is very consistent with the Standard Model's indirect prediction <ref:2508.18022#pg2>.

Kai: This paper demonstrates that even with complex uncertainties in PDFs, smart constraint application can still lead to a result competitive with electron collider measurements.

Mira: It really shows the power of combining different types of constraints to verify fundamental parameters like sin2 theta l eff against theory.

Lev: And for us as an error correction folks, it confirms that building hardware for real hardware means you need these kinds of complex, multi-faceted analyses to get meaningful performance metrics.

Kai: So we’ve discussed the "Precision Measurements of the Electroweak Mixing Angle in the Region of the Z pole at the Large Hadron Collider" and how they use profiling to reduce PDF uncertainties.

Mira: It’s a solid piece of work that gives us confidence in our measurements when we look at fundamental electroweak parameters.

Lev: We're ready for whatever is next, but for now, we keep digging into those high-luminosity data projections.

Department of Physics and Astronomy, University of Rochester · Department of Physics and Astronomy, Seoul National University

hep-ex, hep-ph, hep-th

Submitted: 2025-08-25

Updated: 2026-11-16

Comments: 11 pages, 9 figures, 3 tables, to be published in Phys. Rev. D, rapid communication

License: http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/

Importance score: 91/100

The gist: Precision Measurements of the Electroweak Mixing Angle in the Region of the Z pole at the Large Hadron Collider reports a more precise extraction of sin2θleff via an updated analysis of CMS…

Key concepts

sin2θℓeff
This is a parameter describing the mixing angle in the electroweak sector of particle physics, specifically related to how the electromagnetic and weak forces interact. Measuring it precisely tests the consistency of the Standard Model.
PDF Profiling (A4 technique)
This is a method used to constrain Parton Distribution Functions (PDFs)—which describe how quarks and gluons inside protons behave—by using specific kinematic distributions like A4. This technique significantly reduces uncertainties in the PDF inputs, leading to a more reliable final measurement.
Drell-Yan AFB Measurements
This refers to measurements made by the CMS experiment at 13 TeV involving Drell-Yan processes (producing a lepton pair). These measurements are used as input for extracting sin2θℓeff and provide complementary tests to other experimental methods.
PDF Uncertainty Reduction
The paper demonstrates how incorporating additional constraints, such as W/Z cross-section ratios, helps reduce the uncertainty associated with the underlying PDF sets. This shows a systematic way to improve the accuracy of LHC extractions.

Terminology

Summary

Precision Measurements of the Electroweak Mixing Angle in the Region of the Z pole at the Large Hadron Collider reports a more precise extraction of sin2θleff via an updated analysis of CMS Drell-Yan AFB measurements at 13 TeV, which is competitive with previous e+e- collider measurements and provides complementary tests to indirect Standard Model predictions

Experimental Precision and Agreement

The updated analysis obtains sin2θleff=0.23154±0.00024 with additional PDF constraints from W decay lepton charge asymmetry at 13 TeV and the W/Z cross section ratios It is the most precise single experiment measurement to date and is in excellent agreement with the SM 2026 indirect prediction of 0. p. 0

Where the paper says it

00024 with additional PDF constraints from measurements of the W decay lepton charge asymmetry at 13 TeV and the W/Z cross section ratios. It is the most precise single experiment measurement to date and is in excellent agreement with the SM 2026 indirect prediction of 0.

23152±0.00006 The average of the six LEP and SLD determinations of sin2θleff is 0. p. 0
Where the paper says it

) precise extractions of sin2 θ ℓ eff are from measurements of asymmetries in the region of the Z pole in e +e − colliders which are shown in Fig. The average of the six LEP and SLD determinations is 0.

23153±0.00016, which is consistent with the 2026 SM indirect determination

LHC Measurement Methodology

The extraction of sin2θleff at 13 TeV by the CMS experiment is based on the polar-angle distribution of the negative lepton in the Collins-Soper frame The angular distribution can be written as dσd cos θ∝ 1 + cos2θ + A02(1 − 3 cos2θ) + A4 cos θ, where A0 and A4 are functions of the rapidity (y) and mass (M) of the dilepton pair For full acceptance, integration over cos θ gives Afull FB = (3/8)A4 The dominant source of uncertainty in the CMS measurement comes from uncertainties in the proton PDFs

PDF Constraint and Profiling

The analysis compared several PDF sets from the CTEQ [11–14], NNPDF [15–19], and MSHT [20–24] groups The PDF uncertainties in each PDF set are significantly reduced by using the A4 PDF re-weighting/profiling technique (first proposed in [8]) to constrain PDFs as described below This technique relies on including the rapidity and dilepton mass dependence of A4 to constrain PDFs

Impact of Additional Constraints

The extraction is extended by including additional recent CMS measurements of W and Z boson production in the profiling The analysis includes the CMS 13 TeV W boson decay lepton asymmetry and the W/Z cross section ratios at 5.02 and 13 TeV Including these measurements reduces both the PDF uncertainty and the spread among modern PDF sets, resulting in sin2θleff = 0. p. 5

Where the paper says it

The additional constraints reduce both the PDF uncertainty and the spread among modern PDF sets. The result is in excellent agreement with the 2026 SM indirect determination and is competitive with the most precise e +e − collider measurements.

23154 ± 0. p. 4
Where the paper says it

00006 This analysis 13 TeV 0. 23154 ± 0.

p. 4
Where the paper says it

00006 This analysis 13 TeV 0. 23154 ± 0.

00024 The result is in excellent agreement with the 2026 SM indirect determination The profiled PDFs also provide a useful input for reducing PDF uncertainties in other LHC extractions

Conclusion and Future Outlook

By including the CMS 13 TeV W boson decay lepton asymmetry and the W/Z cross section ratios in the PDF profiling analysis, the extracted value is sin2θleff = 0.23154 ± 0.00024 The additional constraints reduce both the PDF uncertainty and the spread among modern PDF sets Further improvement is expected with the Run III data, corresponding to about 326 fb−1 delivered by the LHC at 13. p. 5

Where the paper says it

The profiled PDFs also provide a useful input for reducing PDF uncertainties in other LHC extractions. Further improvement is expected with the Run III data, corresponding to about 326 fb−1 delivered by the LHC at 13.

6 TeV The total uncertainty in sin2θleff can reach about 0. p. 5
Where the paper says it

For the combined CMS data samples at 13 and 13. 6 TeV, we estimate that the total uncertainty in sin2 θ ℓ eff can reach about 0.

00020 with a PDF contribution of 0. p. 5
Where the paper says it

6 TeV, we estimate that the total uncertainty in sin2 θ ℓ eff can reach about 0. 00020, with a PDF contribution of 0.

00012 The combination with LHCb data at 13 TeV and the ATLAS 8 TeV analysis would provide an additional reduction in uncertainty

Table I

Table I lists the numerical values for the points shown in Fig. 2 in the main paper, as well as additional plots illustrating the additional constraints on parton distribution functions The column marked “Diff. p. 7

Where the paper says it

8 Appendix A: Supplementary Material: Effects of PDF profiling with CMS A4, Wasym and W/Z ratio measurements The Supplementary Material includes Table I which lists the numerical values for the points shown in Fig. 2 in the main paper, as well as additional plots illustrating the additional constraints on parton distribution functions.

from CT18Z” is the difference from sin2θleff extracted with the CT18Znnlo PDF set

Table II

Table II shows shifts and uncertainties of the 29 nuisance parameters corresponding to the CT18Z set after profiling with A4, Wasym, and W/Z fiducial cross-section ratio

Table III

Table III shows shifts and uncertainties of the 50 nuisance parameters corresponding to the NNPDF40 set after profiling with A4, Wasym, and W/Z fiducial cross-section ratio

Table IV

Table IV shows shifts and uncertainties of the 40 nuisance parameters corresponding to the PDF4LHC21 set after profiling with A4, Wasym, and W/Z fiducial cross-section ratio

Figure 7

Figure 7 shows ratios of the D − D¯ distributions with respect to CT18Z for several PDF sets at Q = MZ The left panel shows the results without profiling, the middle panel includes profiling with A4 measurement, and the right panel includes profiling with A4, Wasym, and W/Z measurements

Figure 8

Figure 8 shows ratios of the U − U¯ distributions with respect to CT18Z for several PDF sets at Q = MZ The left panel shows the results without profiling, the middle panel includes profiling with A4 measurement, and the right panel includes profiling with A4, Wasym, and W/Z measurements

Figure 9

Figure 9 shows ratios of the s + ¯s distributions with respect to CT18Z for several PDF sets at Q = MZ The left panel shows the results without profiling, the middle panel includes profiling with A4 measurement, and the right panel includes profiling with A4, Wasym, and W/Z measurements

Figure 6

Figure 6 shows a comparison of the sin2θleff value extracted in this analysis from the CMS 13 TeV data using the nominal CT18Znnlo PDF set with previous measurements [5, 10, 38–43] and the 2026 SM indirect prediction [1] Also shown are the prediction of the Two Higgs Doublet Model[4] corresponding to the CDF MW value[2] of 80.4335 ±0.0094 GeV

Figure 5

Figure 5 shows a comparison of the predictions of 19 PDF sets with various levels of profiling to the W/Z cross section ratios measured by CMS at 5.02 TeV and 13 TeV fore and after profiling with the 13 TeV A4 distribution

Table I shows values of sin2θleff (in units of 10−5) before and after profiling with the CMS 13 TeV A4 distribution (63 points) for 19 PDF sets The total uncertainties include contribution from statistical, experimental systematic, theoretical and PDF sources

Figure 3

Figure 3 shows extracted values of sin2θleff from the 13 TeV CMS A4 data for 19 different PDF sets on the horizontal axis The vertical axis shows the χ2 values of the fits divided by the number of degrees of freedom (Ndata − 1), where one degree of freedom corresponds to the free parameter sin2θleff

Figure 4

Figure 4 compares predictions of CT18Znnlo for A4(y, M), and Wasym(η) before (red) and after (blue) full profiling

Figure 2

Figure 2 shows values of sin2θleff (extracted with 19 different PDF sets) before profiling compared to values after profiling with the CMS 13 TeV A4 data (left panel), by also including the CMS Wasym measurement[25] at 13 TeV (middle panel), and by also including the CMS measurement of the W/Z cross section ratio[26] at 5.02 and 13 TeV (right panel)

Figure 3 shows extracted values of sin2θleff from the 13 TeV CMS A4 data for different PDF sets on the horizontal axis The vertical axis shows the values of χ2 values of the fits divided by the number of degrees of freedom (Ndata − 1), where one degree of freedom corresponds to the free parameter sin2θleff

Figure 4 shows predictions of CT18Znnlo for A4(y, M), and Wasym(η) before (red) and after (blue) full profiling

Figure 2 shows values of sin2θleff (extracted with 19 different PDF sets) before profiling compared to values after profiling with the CMS 13 TeV A4 data (left panel), by also including the CMS Wasym measurement[25] at 13 TeV (middle panel), and by also including the CMS measurement of the W/Z cross section ratio[26] at 5.

Green — the paper says it, and the page is printed. Red — no passage carries it, so treat that sentence as unverified. The same check runs on your own text: check a summary against its source, $5.

Improvements for AI systems

  1. Improved PDF constraint application allows for a more robust determination of sin2 theta l eff by using the A4 PDF re-weighting/profiling technique (first proposed in [8]) to constrain PDFs as described below. This reduces the PDF uncertainties in sin2 theta l eff significantly, as seen when the CT18Znnlo PDF set is reduced from 0.00056 to 0.00032.

  2. Enhanced precision in electroweak parameter extraction enables a more accurate comparison with indirect predictions, as the final result is in excellent agreement with the 2026 SM indirect determination of 1-M2 W / M Z and is competitive with the most precise e +e− collider measurements.

  3. The system can perform cross-validation of PDF sets by observing how they are constrained, specifically noting that the inclusion of the W/Z cross section ratios brings the s +¯s PDF in CT18 to better agreement with the other PDFs. This demonstrates a mechanism for identifying and mitigating systematic discrepancies between different PDF models.

Abstract

In the Standard Model (SM), the effective leptonic weak mixing angle 2θ eff can be predicted to very high accuracy by using the experimental values of the mass of the Z boson (M Z), the Fermi constant, the fine structure constant, the mass of Higgs boson, the quark masses, and the value of the Quantum Chromodynamics (QCD) strong coupling (α s) at M Z. Therefore, deviations of measurements from SM predictions can be indications of new physics. With recent advances in experimental and analysis techniques, measurements of 2θ eff at the Large Hadron Collider (LHC), extracted from the forward-backward asymmetry (A FB) in Drell-Yan dilepton events, are now competitive with previously published measurements at e+e- collider experiments. We report on a more precise extraction of the effective leptonic weak mixing angle via an updated analysis of the CMS Drell-Yan A FB measurements at 13 TeV. We obtain 2θ eff =0.23154 plus or minus 0.00024 with additional PDF constraints from measurements of the W decay lepton charge asymmetry at 13 TeV and the W/Z cross section ratios. It is the most precise single experiment measurement to date and is in excellent agreement with the SM 2026 indirect prediction of 0.23152 plus or minus 0.00006.

Sources

Related papers