What solves the Hubble tension in phenomenological dark energy models at background level?
Listen
Radio episode about this paper
Transcript
Introduction to the show: ident: Astrophysics Radio. Generated commentary on the latest astrophysics papers.
Vera: We're looking at the paper: "What solves the Hubble tension in phenomenological dark energy models at background level?".
Paper summary: Vera: We're moving into how they set up these models. The paper "What solves the Hubble tension in phenomenological dark energy models at background level?" introduces PEDE and GOHDE as minimal extensions of our standard lambda CDM framework >
Jocelyn: These are just minimal additions, so they aren't introducing a whole new zoo of extra parameters, which is something people really like about them compared to more complex theories >
Subrahmanyan: They are exploring these models specifically to assess how correlations between the Hubble parameter H0 and matter density omega m, as well as the choice of datasets influence their conclusions regarding solving the Hubble tension at the background level >
Vera: So, they start by setting up PEDE and GOHDE, then they explore various ways to re-parameterize these models, which is something often done in this kind of work >
Jocelyn: Then they analyze how different datasets perform with these models in addressing the Hubble tension, and it highlights how important that correlation between free parameters and the assumed fiducial cosmology is when extracting certain data points >
Subrahmanyan: It’s about figuring out which specific features of these minimal extensions are actually what can help them address the Hubble tension >
Vera: Their findings show that these extensions don't favor a significantly large value of H0 in the full picture, even when you explore them within an interacting dark sector framework >
Jocelyn: And they examine the specific features of these minimal extensions to see what they actually do >
Subrahmanyan: The model employs a specific parameter nu, where nu is less than zero, and it's defined as being between zero and one, with a base depending on whether that base is zero, negative, or greater than one >
Vera: And the paper points out that the PEDE model represents a specific case where that base is exactly ten >
Jocelyn: That highlights how much the free parameter nu, which acts kind of like the dark energy equation of state in the w CDM model, plays a pivotal role in resolving this tension >
Subrahmanyan: Specifically, a positive nu has the potential to alleviate this tension, whereas a negative nu may actually make it worse >
Vera: So investigating that PEDE model or its generalized version becomes this pursuit to constrain the value of nu >
Jocelyn: And they initially adopt a non-negative Dirac and uniform prior for nu, but then they broaden the scope to include negative values too >
Conclusion: Vera: Now we get into how much the performance of these models actually depends on the data. The paper shows that it’s heavily dependent on the specific datasets used for background level studies >
Jocelyn: They show that the impact of those datasets on both PEDE and GOHDE appears remarkably similar, if not identical in how they affect their analysis >
Subrahmanyan: The structure of the manuscript lays out the analysis first, then they explore various re-parameterizations of these models, and then analyze how different datasets perform with these models in addressing the Hubble tension >
Vera: The critical role played by that correlation between free parameters and the assumed fiducial cosmology is really what shapes the extracted data points at the background level >
Jocelyn: It’s about how those correlations shape those derived conclusions, especially when you look at different datasets >
Subrahmanyan: The analysis shows that while cosmic chronometer data favors a best-fit Hubble parameter close to the Planck one hundred eighty CMB estimate >
Vera: But then if you look at BAO galaxy clustering data, it displays a pronounced tension with the SH0ES measurement >
Jocelyn: And including those BAO galaxy clustering data points at a redshift of around two point three results in a Hubble parameter that remains in significant tension with SH0ES measurements >
Subrahmanyan: That inclusion actually favors a higher H0 value >
Cochin University of Science and Technology
astro-ph.CO, gr-qc
Submitted: 2025-05-30
Updated: 2025-06-11
Comments: 20 pages. Comments and feedback are greatly appreciated. Currently under journal review. In this version - fixed typos in equations
Journal ref: Journal of High Energy Astrophysics Date: July 2026 Article: 100622 Volume: Volume 53
DOI: 10.1016/j.jheap.2026.100622
License: http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
Importance score: 65/100
The gist: What solves the Hubble tension in phenomenological dark energy models at background level? The paper investigates how correlations between cosmological parameters and data influence conclusions…
Key concepts
- Hubble Tension
- This refers to the discrepancy between measurements of the universe's expansion rate ($H_0$) obtained from different cosmological observations. The tension exists because different methods yield significantly different values for how fast our universe is expanding.
- Phenomenological Dark Energy Models (PEDE/GOHDE)
- These are minimal extensions to the standard $\Lambda$CDM model that introduce dark energy through phenomenological terms. They are tested to see if they can predict a higher background Hubble parameter, which is necessary to potentially resolve the observed tension.
- Null Energy Condition (NEC) Violation
- The NEC is a condition in general relativity stating that matter density plus pressure must be non-negative ($\rho + p \ge 0$). Violating this condition means dark energy behaves like phantom energy, leading to an increasing Hubble parameter over time, which is key for solving the tension.
- BAO Ly$eta$ Data
- This specific type of cosmological data provides crucial constraints on the expansion history of the universe. Including this data point at a redshift around 2.3 significantly influences the derived Hubble parameter in these models, often favoring a higher $H_0$ value.
Terminology
Summary
What solves the Hubble tension in phenomenological dark energy models at background level? p. 0 24743v2 [astro-ph. CO] 11 Jun 2025
What solves the Hubble tension in phenomenological dark energy models at background level? These models achieve this without introducing additional parameters, akin to the
simplicity of the concordance ΛCDM model. In this work, we investigate two such models – Phenomenologically
Emergent Dark Energy (PEDE) and Granda-Oliveros Holographic Dark Energy (GOHDE) – to assess how
correlations between 𝐻0 and Ω𝑚, as well as the choice of datasets, influence conclusions regarding their
potential to address the Hubble tension at the background level.Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Model Frameworks and Theoretical Basis
The study introduces two phenomenological models, PEDE and GOHDE, as minimal extensions of the standard ΛCDM framework <ref:2505.24743#pg2>. These models are explored to assess how they can predict a higher value for the Hubble parameter at the background level <ref:2505. p. 0 Here, we
will not attempt to resolve this issue; instead, we will focus
on identifying the specific features that explicitly enable these
models to address the Hubble tension. If a model can resolve the Hubble tension at the background
level—solely by considering the expansion history—it must
predict a higher value of the Hubble parameter using datasets
that provide the Hubble flow 𝐻(𝑧) at various redshifts (𝑧). However, the reliance on phantom behaviour to address the Hubble tension represents arguably the
most significant (and perhaps the sole) challenge in employing
dark energy as a solution at the background level. Here, we
will not attempt to resolve this issue; instead, we will focus
on identifying the specific features that explicitly enable these
models to address the Hubble tension.Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Data Dependence and Parameter Correlation
The performance of these models is shown to be heavily dependent on the specific datasets employed <ref:2505.24743#pg2>. The analysis demonstrates that the inclusion of BAO Lyalpha data points at a redshift of ∼ 2. p. 4 BAO Ly𝛼 data points for the Hubble parameter near
redshift 𝑧 ∼ 2. The survey labelled “Ly𝛼-QSO+
” refers to the
combined analysis of Ly𝛼-QSO and Ly𝛼-Ly𝛼 correlation data. 3 results in a Hubble
parameter that remains in significant tension with SH0ES measurements. In contrast, including these data
points favours a higher 𝐻0, as they suggest a relatively lower matter density within the framework of the assumed
fiducial cosmology. To this
end, we employ various datasets that are commonly used to
study the expansion history of the Universe at the background
level. Interestingly, despite their different theoretical origins,
the impact of the data on the analysis for both models appears
remarkably similar, if not identical. Subsequently, we explore various re-parameterizations
of these models, as proposed by [10]. Next, we analyse the
influence of different datasets on the models’ performance in
addressing the Hubble tension, highlighting the critical role
played by the correlation between free parameters and the assumed fiducial cosmology in the extraction of certain data
points, shaping the derived conclusions at the background
level.Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Resolution Mechanism via Interaction
The authors demonstrate that addressing the Hubble tension necessitates a varying γΛ characterized by a singular sign-switch behaviour, which is equivalent to the onset of violation of the null energy condition in the future <ref:2505.24743#pg2>. This phantom behavior, or equivalently, the onset of violation of the null energy condition in the future, is crucial for minimal models to solve the Hubble tension <ref:2505. p. 0 Finally, reinterpreting these models in terms of interacting dark sectors with 𝑄 = 3𝐻𝛾Λ𝜌˜𝑚 reveals
that addressing the Hubble tension necessitates a varying 𝛾Λ characterised by a singular sign-switch behaviour. This phantom behaviour, or equivalently, the onset of violation of the null energy condition in the future, is
crucial for minimal models to solve the Hubble tension. The corresponding continuity
equations with interaction are then expressed as,
𝜌˜¤𝑚 + 3𝐻𝜌˜𝑚 = 𝑄, ˜ and 𝜌˜¤Λ = −𝑄. ˜ (16)
To establish the equivalence between these models and the
continuity equations above, it is necessary to recognise a relationship between the energy densities and the interaction term
𝑄˜.Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Conclusion on Model Efficacy
The conclusion is that models like PEDE and GOHDE inherently possess the capability to resolve the Hubble tension when including the BAO Lyalpha data <ref:2505.24743#pg2>. The primary reason these models alleviate the Hubble tension when including the BAO Lyalpha data is related to correlations among free parameters of the model <ref:2505. p. 7 We will examine the specific features of these models
in more detail later. The primary reason these models alleviate
the Hubble tension when including the BAO Ly𝛼 data is the Finally, reinterpreting these models in terms of interacting dark sectors with 𝑄 = 3𝐻𝛾Λ𝜌˜𝑚 reveals
that addressing the Hubble tension necessitates a varying 𝛾Λ characterised by a singular sign-switch behaviour. This phantom behaviour, or equivalently, the onset of violation of the null energy condition in the future, is
crucial for minimal models to solve the Hubble tension. This raises the pertinent question: What resolves the Hubble tension in phenomenological
dark energy models at the background level? To address this
in a broader context, we examine both the PEDE model and
a comparable framework, the Granda-Oliveros Holographic
Dark Energy (GOHDE) model [9], which can address the
Hubble tension without introducing an additional free parameter, as required by PEDE.Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Data Constraints and Model Sensitivity
The analysis shows that while cosmic chronometer data favors a best-fit H0 close to the Planck 18 CMB estimate, BAO galaxy clustering data displays a pronounced tension with the SH0ES value <ref:2505.24743#pg2>. The inclusion of Pantheon+ supernova data, combined with the CMB shift parameter, tightens constraints on matter density and makes it evident how these models can perform well <ref:2505. p. 0 We demonstrate that the inclusion of stringent constraints, such as the CMB shift-parameter along
with Pantheon+
, on the effective pressure less matter density significantly impacts the estimation of the Hubble
parameter. Finally, reinterpreting these models in terms of interacting dark sectors with 𝑄 = 3𝐻𝛾Λ𝜌˜𝑚 reveals
that addressing the Hubble tension necessitates a varying 𝛾Λ characterised by a singular sign-switch behaviour. Next, we analyse the
influence of different datasets on the models’ performance in
addressing the Hubble tension, highlighting the critical role
played by the correlation between free parameters and the assumed fiducial cosmology in the extraction of certain data
points, shaping the derived conclusions at the background
level. We then examine the specific features of these minimal extensions.Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Parameter Tuning and Future Implications
The behavior of GOHDE closely mirrors that of PEDE, and both models do not naturally resolve the Hubble tension when their free parameters are left entirely free <ref:2505.24743#pg2>. The choice of prior for parameters like ν or β significantly influences the results, with specific fixed values being critical to achieving a higher H0 prediction <ref:2505.24743#pg2>. The violation of the null energy condition is deferred to the future in these models, suggesting that a future increase in the Hubble parameter is predicted after a certain period <ref:2505. p. 0 Finally, reinterpreting these models in terms of interacting dark sectors with 𝑄 = 3𝐻𝛾Λ𝜌˜𝑚 reveals
that addressing the Hubble tension necessitates a varying 𝛾Λ characterised by a singular sign-switch behaviour. This phantom behaviour, or equivalently, the onset of violation of the null energy condition in the future, is
crucial for minimal models to solve the Hubble tension.Where the paper says it
Final Synthesis on Resolution
The fundamental aspect for resolving the Hubble tension is not simply the presence of phantom dark energy, but “when” the NEC is violated <ref:2505.24743#pg2>. This particular phantom behavior is the key feature needed for models like PEDE and GOHDE to raise H0 and potentially resolve the Hubble tension <ref:2505. p. 7 Notably, with ΛCDM, the estimates align perfectly with the
analysis protocols of these references, while PEDE and GOHDE emerge as two models capable of resolving the Hubble
tension. Therefore, we conclude that models like PEDE and GOHDE inherently possess the capability to resolve the Hubble
tension. Our findings reveal that these extensions do
not favour a significantly large value of 𝐻0 in the full picture. By exploring the models within the interacting dark sector
framework, we demonstrate that a future violation of the null
energy condition is sufficient to resolve the Hubble tension. Our findings reveal that these extensions do
not favour a significantly large value of 𝐻0 in the full picture. By exploring the models within the interacting dark sector
framework, we demonstrate that a future violation of the null
energy condition is sufficient to resolve the Hubble tension. Our findings reveal that these extensions do
not favour a significantly large value of 𝐻0 in the full picture. By exploring the models within the interacting dark sector
framework, we demonstrate that a future violation of the null
energy condition is sufficient to resolve the Hubble tension.Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Data Influence on Matter Density
The effective matter density Ω˜ m plays a key role in constraining the Hubble parameter, and this distinction is particularly important when interpreting data points such as the CMB shift parameter <ref:2505.24743#pg2>. The CMB shift parameter significantly underestimates the matter density, leading to an overestimation of the Hubble parameter <ref:2505. p. 0 Additionally, recent DESI DR1 and DR2 data exhibit mild tension with BAO-𝐻(𝑧) estimates
from SDSS. We demonstrate that the inclusion of stringent constraints, such as the CMB shift-parameter along
with Pantheon+
, on the effective pressure less matter density significantly impacts the estimation of the Hubble
parameter. In such
cases, we calculate 𝜒
2 using the formula 𝜒
2 = Δ𝑇Σ
−1Δ or
equivalently 𝜒
2 =
1
2
Í𝑁
𝑘
[𝑑𝑘−𝜇𝑘 ( 𝜃 )]
2
𝜎2
𝑘
. Among various models
applied to a fixed data set (or a specific combination of data
sets), the model yielding the lowest −2 ln L (𝑑|𝜃) value is
considered the best.Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Model Comparison and Preference
When comparing PEDE and GOHDE, PEDE is statistically favored over GOHDE when using Pantheon+ data combined with other data sets <ref:2505.24743#pg2>. The model with the lowest AIC value is generally considered optimal for model selection <ref:2505. p. 7 For instance, AIC and DIC often show striking numerical similarity,
if not equivalence, under such conditions [60]. The model with
the lowest IC value is generally considered optimal. Instead, we observe that the preference between
models is usually marginal, with one model only slightly outperforming the other. Significant differences in preference are
noted only when extensive datasets, such as Pantheon+
, are
employed. The resolution of
the Hubble tension at the background level is closely tied to the
correlation between 𝐻0 and Ω𝑚. Despite these complexities,
both PEDE and GOHDE have demonstrated their ability to
alleviate the tension at the background level, as shown in FIG.Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Interaction Sign Reversal
The divergence in interaction strength and a reversal in the energy flow direction between components signify a violation of the second law of horizon thermodynamics <ref:2505.24743#pg2>. This onset of violation manifests as a sign flip and divergence in the interaction strength, offering a novel interpretation not previously reported in the literature <ref:2505. p. 1 By exploring the models within the interacting dark sector
framework, we demonstrate that a future violation of the null
energy condition is sufficient to resolve the Hubble tension. This conclusion remains consistent across various extensions
and manifests as a pole in the evolving interaction strength. Finally, reinterpreting these models in terms of interacting dark sectors with 𝑄 = 3𝐻𝛾Λ𝜌˜𝑚 reveals
that addressing the Hubble tension necessitates a varying 𝛾Λ characterised by a singular sign-switch behaviour. This phantom behaviour, or equivalently, the onset of violation of the null energy condition in the future, is
crucial for minimal models to solve the Hubble tension.Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Final Requirement for Resolution
The fundamental aspect for resolving the Hubble tension is not simply the presence of phantom dark energy, but “when” the NEC is violated <ref:2505.24743#pg2>. A past violation leads to an overestimation of H0, while a future violation sets H0 to a value more consistent with observational constraints <ref:2505. p. 1 By exploring the models within the interacting dark sector
framework, we demonstrate that a future violation of the null
energy condition is sufficient to resolve the Hubble tension. This conclusion remains consistent across various extensions
and manifests as a pole in the evolving interaction strength.Where the paper says it
Summary of Key Findings
The paper finds that models like PEDE and GOHDE inherently possess the capability to resolve the Hubble tension <ref:2505.24743#pg2>. The resolution is closely tied to the correlation between H0 and Ωm <ref:2505. p. 7 This
dynamic shifted upon the inclusion of just four additional data
points from BAO Ly𝛼, reversing the trends. The resolution of
the Hubble tension at the background level is closely tied to the
correlation between 𝐻0 and Ω𝑚. This
dynamic shifted upon the inclusion of just four additional data
points from BAO Ly𝛼, reversing the trends. The resolution of
the Hubble tension at the background level is closely tied to the
correlation between 𝐻0 and Ω𝑚. Across all cases, the trends generated by the data
remain consistent; however, PEDE and GOHDE demonstrate
greater effectiveness in addressing the Hubble tension. Notably, the SDSS-derived estimates are more effective in resolving the tension, while the inclusion of Ly𝛼 auto-correlation
data shows a similar and enhanced capacity to mitigate the
Hubble tension.Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Final Summary Statement
In summary, the violation of the second law of horizon thermodynamics is equivalent to violating the null energy condition, which requires ρ + p ≥ 0 <ref:2505.24743#pg2>. The NEC implies that the derivative of the Hubble parameter should be negative, i. p. 3 The physical significance of 𝑄˜ lies in its sign: a positive value indicates energy
transfer from dark energy to dark matter, while a negative value
implies the reverse. This characteristic is key to understanding and identifying a distinctive signature associated with the
mechanisms that elevate the Hubble tension in dark energy
models. BAO Ly𝛼 data points for the Hubble parameter near redshift
𝑧 ∼ 2. These estimates primarily assume a drag radius 𝑟𝑑 based on
the CMB data available at the time. The CMB shift parameter is a dimensionless quantity, representing a ratio. It is defined as,
𝑅 =
𝑙
′𝑇𝑇
1
𝑙
𝑇𝑇
1
(27)
Here, 𝑙
𝑇𝑇
1
denotes the position of the first acoustic peak in the
CMB temperature perturbation spectrum, while the primed
quantity corresponds to the same position calculated under the
assumption Ω𝑚 = 1.Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
Green — the paper says it, and the page is printed. Red — no passage carries it, so treat that sentence as unverified. The same check runs on your own text: check a summary against its source, $5.
Improvements for AI systems
-
Improved AI system can perform model selection by directly using Log-Likelihood values rather than just chi squared values to select models, as stated in
In this analysis, we report-2 ln L (dtheta) instead of chi squared itself.
-
Improved AI system can quantify tension between model parameters and reference values using the formula Tension = Ae - Ar / sqrt(sigmae squared + sigmaR 2), which allows for a standardized measure of discrepancy.
-
Improved AI system can identify the critical role of specific data points by showing how
the inclusion of these data points results in a notable shift in the H0 estimates for all models,
as seen when adding BAO Lyalpha data. -
Improved AI system can analyze parameter correlations by recognizing that
the correlation between free parameters and data interact[s] to shape these conclusions
and thatmodel-independent analysis using H(z) data constrains only the combination ΩmH20.
-
Improved AI system can determine the necessary condition for resolving the Hubble tension as
a future violation of the second law of horizon thermodynamics is inevitable if these phenomenological models are chosen to address the Hubble tension at the background level,
which corresponds tothe onset of a change in the rate of horizon entropy evolution.
Abstract
Few phenomenological models tend to favour higher values of the Hubble parameter, often at the expense of invoking phantom transitions. These models achieve this without introducing additional parameters, akin to the simplicity of the concordance Λ CDM model. In this work, we investigate two such models -- Phenomenologically Emergent Dark Energy (PEDE) and Granda-Oliveros Holographic Dark Energy (GOHDE) -- to assess how correlations between H 0 and Ω m, as well as the choice of datasets, influence conclusions regarding their potential to address the Hubble tension at the background level. We find that minimally extended versions of these models favour notably low values for the Hubble parameter, with the perceived preference for higher values driven by the associated prior. Excluding BAO Ly α - H(z) data points at a redshift of about 2.3 results in a Hubble parameter that remains in significant tension with SH0ES measurements. In contrast, including these data points favours a higher H 0, as they suggest a relatively lower matter density within the framework of the assumed fiducial cosmology. Additionally, recent DESI DR1 and DR2 data exhibit mild tension with BAO- H(z) estimates from SDSS. We demonstrate that the inclusion of stringent constraints, such as the CMB shift-parameter along with Pantheon+, on the effective pressure less matter density significantly impacts the estimation of the Hubble parameter. Finally, reinterpreting these models in terms of interacting dark sectors with Q = 3Hγ Λ ρ m reveals that addressing the Hubble tension necessitates a varying γ Λ characterised by a singular sign-switch behaviour. This phantom behaviour, or equivalently, the onset of violation of the null energy condition in the future, is crucial for minimal models to solve the Hubble tension.
Sources
- The CosmoVerse White Paper: Addressing observational tensions in cosmology with systematics and fundamental physics
- Status Report on the Chicago-Carnegie Hubble Program (CCHP): Measurement of the Hubble Constant Using the Hubble and James Webb Space Telescopes
- DESI DR2 Results II: Measurements of Baryon Acoustic Oscillations and Cosmological Constraints
- Challenging $\Lambda$CDM: 5$\sigma$ Evidence for a Dynamical Dark Energy Late-Time Transition
- DESI DR2 Results I: Baryon Acoustic Oscillations from the Lyman Alpha Forest
- Observational evidence for parametrized emergent dark energy models
- Entropy Bounds and Holographic Dark Energy: Conflicts and Consensus
- Interacting Dark Sectors in light of DESI DR2
- New constraints on interacting dark energy from DESI DR2 BAO observations
- Dynamical dark energy with AdS-dS transitions vs. Baryon Acoustic Oscillations at $z =$ 2.3-2.4
- Union Through UNITY: Cosmology with 2,000 SNe Using a Unified Bayesian Framework
- How predictions of cosmological models depend on Hubble parameter data sets
Related papers
- 21cmEMUv3: a hybrid diffusion-LSTM emulator of 21cmFAST summary observables
- Connecting field-level and n-point function measurements of galaxy bias
- The Impact of Cosmic Variance and Satellites on JWST Clustering Measurements at Redshift around 6
- Universality of Primordial Anisotropies in Gravitational Wave Background
- KiDS-1000 cosmic shear reanalysis using MetaCalibration
- 2Flow2SN: Dusty Supernova Cosmology with Photometric Redshifts and Contamination using Neural Simulation-Based Inference