What solves the Hubble tension in phenomenological dark energy models at background level?

summary

The gist

What solves the Hubble tension in phenomenological dark energy models at background level? The paper investigates how correlations between cosmological parameters and data influence conclusions…

In short

The study investigates Phenomenologically Emergent Dark Energy (PEDE) and Granda-Oliveros Holographic Dark Energy (GOHDE) models to address the Hubble tension. The findings show that these models can resolve the tension when specific data, like BAO Ly$eta$ data, is included. Resolution requires a varying $\gamma\Lambda$ with a sign-switch, which corresponds to violating the null energy condition in the future.

Key concepts

Hubble Tension
This refers to the discrepancy between measurements of the universe's expansion rate ($H_0$) obtained from different cosmological observations. The tension exists because different methods yield significantly different values for how fast our universe is expanding.
Phenomenological Dark Energy Models (PEDE/GOHDE)
These are minimal extensions to the standard $\Lambda$CDM model that introduce dark energy through phenomenological terms. They are tested to see if they can predict a higher background Hubble parameter, which is necessary to potentially resolve the observed tension.
Null Energy Condition (NEC) Violation
The NEC is a condition in general relativity stating that matter density plus pressure must be non-negative ($\rho + p \ge 0$). Violating this condition means dark energy behaves like phantom energy, leading to an increasing Hubble parameter over time, which is key for solving the tension.
BAO Ly$eta$ Data
This specific type of cosmological data provides crucial constraints on the expansion history of the universe. Including this data point at a redshift around 2.3 significantly influences the derived Hubble parameter in these models, often favoring a higher $H_0$ value.

Terminology used across episodes

This episode discusses

The paper

What solves the Hubble tension in phenomenological dark energy models at background level? · Read on arXiv

Cochin University of Science and Technology

Few phenomenological models tend to favour higher values of the Hubble parameter, often at the expense of invoking phantom transitions. These models achieve this without introducing additional parameters, akin to the simplicity of the concordance Λ CDM model. In this work, we investigate two such models -- Phenomenologically Emergent Dark Energy (PEDE) and Granda-Oliveros Holographic Dark Energy (GOHDE) -- to assess how correlations between H 0 and Ω m, as well as the choice of datasets, influence conclusions regarding their potential to address the Hubble tension at the background level. We find that minimally extended versions of these models favour notably low values for the Hubble parameter, with the perceived preference for higher values driven by the associated prior. Excluding BAO Ly α - H(z) data points at a redshift of about 2.3 results in a Hubble parameter that remains in significant tension with SH0ES measurements. In contrast, including these data points favours a higher H 0, as they suggest a relatively lower matter density within the framework of the assumed fiducial cosmology. Additionally, recent DESI DR1 and DR2 data exhibit mild tension with BAO- H(z) estimates from SDSS. We demonstrate that the inclusion of stringent constraints, such as the CMB shift-parameter along with Pantheon+, on the effective pressure less matter density significantly impacts the estimation of the Hubble parameter. Finally, reinterpreting these models in terms of interacting dark sectors with Q = 3Hγ Λ ρ m reveals that addressing the Hubble tension necessitates a varying γ Λ characterised by a singular sign-switch behaviour. This phantom behaviour, or equivalently, the onset of violation of the null energy condition in the future, is crucial for minimal models to solve the Hubble tension.

DOI: 10.1016/j.jheap.2026.100622

Transcript

Introduction to the show: ident: Astrophysics Radio. Generated commentary on the latest astrophysics papers.

Vera: We're looking at the paper: "What solves the Hubble tension in phenomenological dark energy models at background level?".

Paper summary: Vera: We're moving into how they set up these models. The paper "What solves the Hubble tension in phenomenological dark energy models at background level?" introduces PEDE and GOHDE as minimal extensions of our standard lambda CDM framework >

Jocelyn: These are just minimal additions, so they aren't introducing a whole new zoo of extra parameters, which is something people really like about them compared to more complex theories >

Subrahmanyan: They are exploring these models specifically to assess how correlations between the Hubble parameter H0 and matter density omega m, as well as the choice of datasets influence their conclusions regarding solving the Hubble tension at the background level >

Vera: So, they start by setting up PEDE and GOHDE, then they explore various ways to re-parameterize these models, which is something often done in this kind of work >

Jocelyn: Then they analyze how different datasets perform with these models in addressing the Hubble tension, and it highlights how important that correlation between free parameters and the assumed fiducial cosmology is when extracting certain data points >

Subrahmanyan: It’s about figuring out which specific features of these minimal extensions are actually what can help them address the Hubble tension >

Vera: Their findings show that these extensions don't favor a significantly large value of H0 in the full picture, even when you explore them within an interacting dark sector framework >

Jocelyn: And they examine the specific features of these minimal extensions to see what they actually do >

Subrahmanyan: The model employs a specific parameter nu, where nu is less than zero, and it's defined as being between zero and one, with a base depending on whether that base is zero, negative, or greater than one >

Vera: And the paper points out that the PEDE model represents a specific case where that base is exactly ten >

Jocelyn: That highlights how much the free parameter nu, which acts kind of like the dark energy equation of state in the w CDM model, plays a pivotal role in resolving this tension >

Subrahmanyan: Specifically, a positive nu has the potential to alleviate this tension, whereas a negative nu may actually make it worse >

Vera: So investigating that PEDE model or its generalized version becomes this pursuit to constrain the value of nu >

Jocelyn: And they initially adopt a non-negative Dirac and uniform prior for nu, but then they broaden the scope to include negative values too >

Conclusion: Vera: Now we get into how much the performance of these models actually depends on the data. The paper shows that it’s heavily dependent on the specific datasets used for background level studies >

Jocelyn: They show that the impact of those datasets on both PEDE and GOHDE appears remarkably similar, if not identical in how they affect their analysis >

Subrahmanyan: The structure of the manuscript lays out the analysis first, then they explore various re-parameterizations of these models, and then analyze how different datasets perform with these models in addressing the Hubble tension >

Vera: The critical role played by that correlation between free parameters and the assumed fiducial cosmology is really what shapes the extracted data points at the background level >

Jocelyn: It’s about how those correlations shape those derived conclusions, especially when you look at different datasets >

Subrahmanyan: The analysis shows that while cosmic chronometer data favors a best-fit Hubble parameter close to the Planck one hundred eighty CMB estimate >

Vera: But then if you look at BAO galaxy clustering data, it displays a pronounced tension with the SH0ES measurement >

Jocelyn: And including those BAO galaxy clustering data points at a redshift of around two point three results in a Hubble parameter that remains in significant tension with SH0ES measurements >

Subrahmanyan: That inclusion actually favors a higher H0 value >

More episodes

← Home