Probing for anisotropies at different angular scales in the arrival directions of the cosmic rays detected at the Pierre Auger Observatory

summary

The gist

Studies of the arrival-direction distribution of ultra-high-energy cosmic rays are crucial for revealing their origin This work investigates the distribution of arrival directions over different…

In short

This work uses a novel method based on a von Mises–Fisher distribution to search for cosmic ray arrival direction overdensities across all angular scales. Results show significant large-scale excesses above 8 EeV, and an excess in the Centaurus region at intermediate scales for energies above 40 EeV.

Key concepts

Large-scale anisotropies
These refer to broad patterns in cosmic ray arrival directions, like a dipole modulation observed above 8 EeV. This suggests that the majority of these ultra-high-energy cosmic rays originate from outside our galaxy, pointing towards an extragalactic source.
Small-to-intermediate scale anisotropies
These are hints of anisotropies at smaller angular scales that have been reported above a few tens of EeV by experiments like Pierre Auger and Telescope Array. The study investigates whether these hints are real excesses or statistical fluctuations.
von Mises–Fisher distribution
This is a mathematical model used to describe the probability distribution of cosmic ray arrival directions relative to an isotropic expectation. It allows researchers to statistically test for overdensities or clustering in the data.
Test Statistics (TS)
The TS is a statistical measure derived from comparing the likelihood of observed event distributions under different models. By minimizing this statistic, researchers can identify the most probable parameters ($\kappa$) describing any detected excess.

Terminology used across episodes

This episode discusses

The paper

Probing for anisotropies at different angular scales in the arrival directions of the cosmic rays detected at the Pierre Auger Observatory · Read on arXiv

A. Abdul Halim, P. Abreu, M. Aglietta, M. Ahmed, I. Allekotte, K. Almeida Cheminant, R. Aloisio, J Alvarez-Muñz, ¡ Ambrosone, § Ammerman Yebra, ⌺ Anchordoqui, B Andrada, L Andrade Dourado, L Apollonio, C Aramo, J.C. Arteaga Velazquázque, P Assis, G Avila, E Avocone, Á Bakalova, Ι Balibrea, A Baluta, F Barbato, A Bartz Mocellin, O Batalla Cruz, J.P Behler, C Berat, М M.E. Bertaina, M Bianciotto, Ι L. Biermann, И V. Binet, K Bismark, T Bister, J Biteau, J Blazek, J Blɛmer, M Bohćova, D Boncioli, К C Bonifazi, P Boril, N. Borodai, J Brack, P G. Brichetto Orquera, S Buitink, A Bwembya, T.R Caba Pineda, K S Caballero-Mora, S Cabana-Freire, Á Caccianiga, J Cara߁a-Valente, R Caruso, A Castellina, F Catalani, G Cataldi, L Cazon, M Cerda, Ш Čermϡková, Ж A. Cermenati, K Cerny, J.A Chinellato, J Chudoba, L Chytka, R W Clay, A C Cobos Cerutti, R Colalillo, R Conceíc҈iоon, G Consolati, M Conte, F Convenga, D Correia dos Santos, P J Costa, C.E Covault, M Cristinziani, C S Cruz Sanchez, S Dasso, К Daumiller, B R Dawson, R M de Almeida, Л E.-T. de Boone, B de Errico, J. de Jesϡs, S J de Jong, J R T de Mello Neto, I De Mitri, D de Oliveira Franco, F. de Palma, И V. de Souza, E De Vito, A Del Popolo, Ι O Deligny, N Denner, K Denner Syrokvas, arXiv:2611.14233v2 [astro-ph.HE] 11 Nov 2026, orgs]: [

Adelaide University · International Center of Advanced Studies and Instituto de Ciencias F࿚sicas · Observatorio Pierre Auger Observatory

Transcript

Introduction to the show: ident: Astrophysics Radio. Generated commentary on the latest astrophysics papers.

Vera: We're looking at the paper: "Probing for anisotropies at different angular scales in the arrival directions of the cosmic rays detected at the Pierre Auger Observatory".

Paper summary: Vera: So we’re looking at the paper titled "Probing for anisotropies at different angular scales in the arrival directions of the cosmic rays detected at the Pierre Auger Observatory". Basically it’s about seeing how cosmic rays come from different places by looking at where they land on Earth.

Jocelyn: Right, so what is this paper actually claiming? What’s the main point they are trying to make about those arrival directions?

Vera: They introduce a new method using a von MisesFisher distribution to search for overdensities across all angular scales. It’s designed to look for excesses beyond just the big, large-scale dips we already saw.

Subrahmanyan: That sounds like they are trying to separate the effects of different physical processes that might be shaping the arrival directions, which is key for figuring out where these particles actually originate.

Vera: Exactly. The paper claims that using this technique lets them probe anisotropies at different angular scales, moving beyond just looking at one scale at a time. They’re testing how the distribution changes depending on the size of the area they are looking at on the sky.

Jocelyn: So if we think about what this means for us, what’s the big picture here? Why does this scaling matter?

Subrahmanyan: It matters because if you can distinguish between large-scale structures and smaller scale features, you get clues about whether the sources are local or distant. If we only see one kind of pattern, it tells us less about the overall cosmic ray landscape.

Vera: They found that for standard energy bins above eight EeV, the most significant overdensities correspond to those large-scale excesses across all energy bins.

Jocelyn: What are the specific numbers they give for those large-scale findings? Are we talking about a specific direction or just a general region?

Vera: They report dipole amplitudes for the eight to sixteen EeV, sixteen to thirty EeV, and above thirty two EeV energy intervals. The lowest piso they find is in the eight to sixteen EeV interval.

Subrahmanyan: When you look at those results from this paper on Probing for anisotropies at different angular scales in the arrival directions of the cosmic rays detected at the Pierre Auger Observatory, they focus on how these large-scale features grow with energy, which is a key piece of evidence for their origin.

Jocelyn: And what about those higher energy intervals? I remember seeing some interesting stuff there.

Vera: They used a sliding window in energy and found that the most significant excesses are still on the large angular scale for all bins starting with six to thirteen EeV up to above forty EeV.

Subrahmanyan: That suggests a consistent pattern across a wide energy range, which supports the idea that whatever is causing these anisotropies isn't just a fleeting phenomenon at one specific energy.

Jocelyn: But what happens when we look at the very highest energies, above forty EeV? That’s where things get really interesting in this paper.

Vera: For above forty EeV, the value of kappa is about sixteen, and that describes an excess on an intermediate angular scale with a sigma of fourteen point four degrees located in the Centaurus region.

Subrahmanyan: A specific location like Centaurus A is important because it points toward potential extragalactic sources at these extreme energies, which fits with what we expect from cosmic rays traveling long distances.

Jocelyn: I see something interesting mentioned about two spatially separated excesses there in the highest-energy intervals, one on large scales and another on intermediate scales outside the ninety-five percent confidence level band.

Vera: That’s a significant detail. They found that simulations don't show that these two excesses at different angular scales above thirty two EeV can be explained by one excess just being a statistical fluctuation of the other.

Subrahmanyan: That lack of explanation for the coexistence suggests we need to keep looking for both types of features, large and intermediate scale, when we analyze these high-energy data sets.

Jocelyn: So, what’s the main conclusion they draw from this whole study on Probing for anisotropies at different angular scales in the arrival directions of the cosmic rays detected at the Pierre Auger Observatory?

Vera: The main conclusion is that while large-scale excesses dominate above eight EeV, using a sliding window in energy showed that large angular scale excesses are still significant for energies from six to thirteen EeV up to above forty EeV.

Subrahmanyan: And they pinpoint an intermediate scale excess at the Centaurus region for above forty EeV, which is something we need to consider when modeling structure formation and particle acceleration in distant galaxies.

Jocelyn: It seems like this work really pushes us to keep searching for these features across different scales in the arrival directions of cosmic rays.

Conclusion: Vera: It’s a pretty complex analysis, but basically, they're using a new way to model those excesses that lets them search for structure across all angular scales.

Jocelyn: Yeah, it uses this von Mises Fisher distribution to check for overdensities against what we expect from an isotropic universe.

Subrahmanyan: It’s interesting how they tackle the idea of separating large-scale dips from smaller, intermediate-scale features in the data.

Vera: They found that for standard energy bins above eight EeV, those large-scale excesses are pretty robust across all energies.

Jocelyn: And then they shift gears at higher energies, and it’s where things get really specific about what’s happening in the Centaurus region.

Subrahmanyan: That Centaurus excess at above forty EeV with a kappa value of sixteen is something that pushes us toward thinking about extragalactic sources again.

Vera: They even found evidence of two separate excesses there, one on large scales and one on intermediate scales, which they say can't just be statistical noise.

Jocelyn: That suggests we need to keep hunting for those different types of signals when we analyze these extreme energy events.

Subrahmanyan: It’s a good thing because if we can untangle those two things, it could really help us understand the particle acceleration mechanisms at these very high energies.

More episodes

← Home