Connecting field-level and n-point function measurements of galaxy bias

arXiv:2611.14456 · astro-ph.CO · Submitted 2026-11-10 · Read on arXiv

Listen

Radio episode about this paper

Transcript

Introduction to the show: ident: Astrophysics Radio. Generated commentary on the latest astrophysics papers.

Vera: We're looking at the paper: "Connecting field-level and n-point function measurements of galaxy bias".

Paper summary: Vera: So to recap, this paper "Connecting field-level and n-point function measurements of galaxy bias" is about using the renormalization group to bridge two different ways of measuring galaxy bias parameters. It claims that you can relate finite cutoff measurements from simulations to the standard n-point function results when you take the cutoff scale to zero.

Jocelyn: The core idea is setting up this RG framework so that these two measurement types can talk to each other consistently, which is important because they often use different renormalization conditions for their analysis.

Subrahmanyan: What matters here is that they generate mock galaxy fields using a Lagrangian perturbation theory forward model and a galaxy bias expansion, and then measure the bias parameters across a range of cutoffs.

Vera: And Jocelyn mentioned that these RG predictions match the running they measured, which aligns with tree-level n-point function measurements of first order b delta and second order b delta squared, b G two.

Jocelyn: They also check this by looking at bias on halo catalogs derived from N body simulations and show the RG prediction holds up well within expected systematic errors.

Subrahmanyan: This is important because it connects the theoretical framework to actual simulation results for halos, which are a key input for many cosmological studies.

Vera: They also discuss how they handle things like the incomplete forward model by decomposing the tracer density field into deterministic and missing parts, which contributes to their estimated bias parameters.

Jocelyn: And they test how well this forward model works by running convergence tests, examining how different choices of matter forward models affect the running of the bias parameters.

Subrahmanyan: The paper also looks at a relation between the Lagrangian perturbation theory and SPT kernels by decomposing displacement into longitudinal and transverse components, revealing expressions for F one, F two, and F three up to n equal to three.

Vera: So it’s not just about the main connection; they also look at how different parts of perturbation theory describe the underlying matter field structure.

Jocelyn: They also address how nonlinear contributions get translated into fitted transfer functions by relating cutoff dependent bias parameter b lambda o to measured transfer functions via a matching coefficient matrix Dai k lambda o.

Conclusion: Vera: The authors of "Connecting field-level and n-point function measurements of galaxy bias" show that the galaxy-bias RG is a natural way to connect those finite cutoff field-level measurements to renormalized bias parameters from n-point functions in the limit lambda goes to zero.

Jocelyn: This framework allows for consistent comparisons between different analysis schemes, which is crucial when you're trying to use these measurements across different survey methods.

Subrahmanyan: For the bigger picture, this means we have a systematic way to predict the running of these parameters, including estimated uncertainties from higher order terms that you might miss otherwise.

Vera: So in simple terms, they’ve built a tool that lets us reliably use field-level measurements to inform those n-pt renormalized bias parameters for galaxy surveys.

Jocelyn: It provides a structure for comparing how we measure the bias across different analysis methods and helps construct consistent priors for those analyses.

Subrahmanyan: The RG calculation is valuable because it gives controlled predictions of the running, including estimated uncertainties from higher order terms in a way that you can track.

Hsiang-Ming Huang, Henrique Rubira, Fabian Schmidtd

University Observatory, Faculty of Physics, Ludwig-Maximilians-Universität · Kavli Institute for Cosmology Cambridge · Centre for Theoretical Cosmology, Department of Applied Mathematics and Theoretical Physics University of Cambridge · Max Planck Institut für Astrophysik

astro-ph.CO

Submitted: 2026-11-10

Updated: 2026-11-10

Comments: 37 pages, 10 figures

License: http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/

Importance score: 100/100

The gist: Precise measurements of galaxy bias parameters are essential for extracting cosmological information from galaxy surveys.

Key concepts

Renormalization Group (RG) Framework
The RG framework is used to relate different bias measurements by treating them as flowing under a change in scale ($\Lambda$). It allows researchers to derive one-loop equations for bias parameters, which can then be expanded to predict how these parameters change (run) with scale.
Field-Level Bias Measurements
These are direct measurements of galaxy bias parameters obtained from analyzing the density field at different spatial cutoffs. The paper uses a Lagrangian perturbation theory forward model to generate mock fields and measure the bias across various scales to test these measurements.
n-Point Function Measurements
These involve measuring correlations in the galaxy distribution using n-point functions, such as $b_{\delta}$ (first-order) and $b_{\delta}^2$ (second-order). The RG framework connects these correlation measurements to the field-level bias measurements, providing a way to relate different types of data.
Finite Cutoff Renormalization
This describes how bias parameters change when calculations are performed with a finite cutoff scale ($\Lambda > 0$). The paper shows how these cutoff-dependent predictions relate to the true renormalized bias parameters obtained in the limit where $\Lambda$ approaches zero.

Terminology

Summary

Precise measurements of galaxy bias parameters are essential for extracting cosmological information from galaxy surveys. p. 0

Where the paper says it

de Abstract. Precise measurements of galaxy bias parameters are essential for extracting cosmological information from galaxy surveys.

The work establishes a connection between field-level bias measurements and finite-cutoff renormalization group predictions, showing how these two approaches relate in the limit where the cutoff scale goes to zero. p. 0
Where the paper says it

Field-level analyses infer bias coefficients at a finite cutoff Λ, typically related to the lattice resolution, while n-point function analyses typically adopt renormalization conditions defined in the low-k limit. In this work, we use the renormalization group (RG) to relate field-level measurements at different cutoffs and connect them to n-point function measurements.

Connecting Field-Level and N-Point Function Measurements

The paper uses the renormalization group (RG) to relate field-level measurements at different cutoffs and connect them to n-point function measurements. They generate mock galaxy fields using a Lagrangian perturbation theory forward model and a galaxy bias expansion, then measure the bias parameters across a range of cutoffs. p. 0

Where the paper says it

In this work, we use the renormalization group (RG) to relate field-level measurements at different cutoffs and connect them to n-point function measurements. We generate mock galaxy fields with a Lagrangian perturbation theory forward model and a galaxy bias expansion, and then measure the bias parameters across a range of cutoffs.

The RG predictions describe the measured running and agree with tree-level n-point function measurements of first-order bδ and second-order bδ 2, bG2. p. 0
Where the paper says it

We generate mock galaxy fields with a Lagrangian perturbation theory forward model and a galaxy bias expansion, and then measure the bias parameters across a range of cutoffs. We show that the RG predictions describe the measured running and, in the limit Λ → 0, agree with the (tree-level) n-point function measurements of first-order bδ and second-order bδ 2 , bG2 .

They also measure the running on halo catalogs based on full N-body simulations and show that the RG prediction describes the measurements well within predicted systematic errors. p. 0
Where the paper says it

We show that the RG predictions describe the measured running and, in the limit Λ → 0, agree with the (tree-level) n-point function measurements of first-order bδ and second-order bδ 2 , bG2 . We also measure the running on halo catalogs based on full N-body simulations and show that the RG prediction describes the measurements well within the predicted systematic errors.

The Renormalization Group Framework

The RG framework is derived from the partition function for the galaxy density field, which is closed under the RG flow in the sense that a shift Λ → Λ+λ is absorbed into the coefficients CmO(Λ). The RG equations for bias parameters are derived by splitting the functional integral and expanding in powers of the shell operator, leading to a one-loop RG equation. p. 8

Where the paper says it

Expanding the full RG solution makes clear the importance of treating the running of the bias parameters in full, since it resums the higher powers of σ 2 generated by higher-loop diagrams, in contrast to only retaining the leading σ 2 piece [3]. Moreover, because the entries of s 1L ab vanish for Ord(Oa) > Ord(Ob) + 2, an operator of order n contributes to one of order n ′ < n only starting at order (∆σ 2 ) l n−n ′ 2 m .

This equation admits an exponential solution that can be expanded in powers of ∆σ2 = σ2∗ − σ2bσ2(Λ). p. 7
Where the paper says it

12) Notice that the RGE of the bias coefficients is described by minus the transpose of the matrix that describes the RGE of the operators, corresponding to the differential (generator) version of the general bias transformation law (App. After changing variables to σ 2 , the ODE admits an exponential solution, which can be expanded in powers of ∆σ 2 = σ 2 ∗ − σ 2 ba σ 2 (Λ) = h e s¯ 1L×∆σ 2 i ac b ∗ c (2.

Methodology and Truncation

The methodology involves using a Lagrangian EFT forward model to generate tracer density fields, which are then used to infer bias coefficients via a Gaussian likelihood. The inference analytically marginalizes over third-order bias parameters assuming a Gaussian prior. p. 1

Where the paper says it

2 Resolution of Eulerian grid 28 C. 3 Prior volume in higher-order bias parameters 30 D Validation of n-pt measurement with halo catalogs 31 E Transfer function approach and the missing cutoff 32 1 Introduction Increasingly precise surveys of large-scale structure (LSS) offer new opportunities to constrain dark matter, dark energy, gravity, and the initial conditions of the Universe.

Truncation of the RG is performed at a fixed order in ∆σ2, and this truncation corresponds to a specific LPT order required to achieve the desired accuracy. p. 9
Where the paper says it

This truncation of the RG, however, is a fundamental feature of perturbative theories, which are only meant to reproduce the underlying theory up to a given order in the expansion parameters, at the precision required by the problem. The RG therefore captures the correct running up to a fixed order in ∆σ 2 .

Validation and Comparison

The results are tested on two types of data: mocks generated by LEFTfield and dark matter halo catalogs. For the mocks, good agreement is found between theoretical RG predictions and both n-point function and field-level measurements. p. 0

Where the paper says it

Connecting field-level and n-point function measurements of galaxy bias Hsiang-Ming Huang,a,d Henrique Rubira,a,b,c Fabian Schmidtd aUniversity Observatory, Faculty of Physics, Ludwig-Maximilians-Universität, Scheinerstr. 1, D-81679 München, Germany bKavli Institute for Cosmology Cambridge, Madingley Road, Cambridge CB3 0HA, UK cCentre for Theoretical Cosmology, Department of Applied Mathematics and Theoretical Physics University of Cambridge, Wilberforce Road, Cambridge, CB3 0WA, UK dMax-Planck-Institut für Astrophysik, Karl-Schwarzschild-Str.

For halo catalogs, the RG curves are fitted to measured bias parameters using a model dba/dσ2 = -bbs[n≤3]ba + Ba. p. 0
Where the paper says it

We show that the RG predictions describe the measured running and, in the limit Λ → 0, agree with the (tree-level) n-point function measurements of first-order bδ and second-order bδ 2 , bG2 . We also measure the running on halo catalogs based on full N-body simulations and show that the RG prediction describes the measurements well within the predicted systematic errors.

Conclusion

The work demonstrates that the galaxy-bias RG is a natural way to connect finite-cutoff field-level measurements to renormalized bias parameters from n-point functions in the limit Λ → 0. This framework allows for consistent comparisons between different analysis schemes and for constructing consistent bias priors for galaxy-survey analyses. p. 0

Where the paper says it

We also measure the running on halo catalogs based on full N-body simulations and show that the RG prediction describes the measurements well within the predicted systematic errors. Our results establish the RG flow as a natural formulation for relating galaxy bias measurements at different cutoffs and connecting the schemes used in field-level and n-point function analyses.

The RG calculation provides a systematic way to predict the running, including estimated uncertainties from higher-order terms.

A Relation between LPT and SPT kernels

The appendix reviews the relation between the LPT and SPT descriptions of the perturbative matter density field by decomposing the displacement into longitudinal and transverse components. The expansion of the exponential eik·s in powers of the displacement and matching to SPT kernels reveals expressions for F1, F2, and F3 up to n = 3. p. 7

Where the paper says it

12) Notice that the RGE of the bias coefficients is described by minus the transpose of the matrix that describes the RGE of the operators, corresponding to the differential (generator) version of the general bias transformation law (App. After changing variables to σ 2 , the ODE admits an exponential solution, which can be expanded in powers of ∆σ 2 = σ 2 ∗ − σ 2 ba σ 2 (Λ) = h e s¯ 1L×∆σ 2 i ac b ∗ c (2.

The Effect of Incomplete Forward Model

The analysis discusses systematic errors arising from the incomplete forward model by decomposing the tracer density field into deterministic and missing parts. The residual term Rk,k′ represents the part of the density field missing from the model, which contributes to the estimated bias parameters. p. 3

Where the paper says it

LEFTfield [18], a Lagrangian EFT forward model that evolves initial conditions using Lagrangian perturbation theory (LPT) and constructs the tracer density field using the galaxy bias expansion. We also examine how bias parameters defined at a finite cutoff relate to those obtained from renormalized n-point function measurements [3] in the limit of zero cutoff.

Convergence Tests of the Forward Model

Convergence tests are performed by examining how different choices of matter forward models affect the running of bias parameters. The choice of Eulerian grid size NGEul affects the measured running, and comparing results across different LPT orders shows how well higher orders capture the required running.

Validation of N-Point Measurement with Halo Catalogs

The n-point function methodology is validated by comparing the resulting measured linear and quadratic bias parameters with known bias relations derived from previous measurements. The behaviors of all three bias parameters match the results of [14] within the expected uncertainties. p. 2

Where the paper says it

Both the lattice cutoff and the renormalized bias framework based on Eq. 2) are expected to match when the lattice cutoff is sent to zero, corresponding to just matching tree-level correlators [4].

Transfer Function Approach and the Missing Cutoff

The transfer function approach relates the cutoff-dependent bias parameter bΛO to measured transfer functions via a matching coefficient matrix Dai(k,Λ). This approach helps study under what conditions the transfer functions yield physical bias parameters. p. 1

Where the paper says it

2 Resolution of Eulerian grid 28 C. 3 Prior volume in higher-order bias parameters 30 D Validation of n-pt measurement with halo catalogs 31 E Transfer function approach and the missing cutoff 32 1 Introduction Increasingly precise surveys of large-scale structure (LSS) offer new opportunities to constrain dark matter, dark energy, gravity, and the initial conditions of the Universe.

The k-dependence of Dai(k,Λ) tells us how nonlinear contributions are translated into fitted transfer functions. p. 2
Where the paper says it

The lattice-cutoff RG framework has since been extended to include stochastic terms [7], primordial non-Gaussianity [8], two-loop contributions [9], and higher-derivative operators [10]. A fundamental alternative approach to measuring bias using n-point correlation functions is to employ the measured and predicted tracer fields, δg and δg,det, respectively, directly [11–17].

In conclusion, the results fully describe the cutoff dependence of the bias running for both controlled mock samples and halo catalogs. The RG connection between finite-cutoff field-level bias parameters and n-point function measurements at Λ → 0 is crucial for reliably using field-level measurements to inform n-pt-renormalized bias parameters. p. 3

Where the paper says it

LEFTfield [18], a Lagrangian EFT forward model that evolves initial conditions using Lagrangian perturbation theory (LPT) and constructs the tracer density field using the galaxy bias expansion. We also examine how bias parameters defined at a finite cutoff relate to those obtained from renormalized n-point function measurements [3] in the limit of zero cutoff.

The work provides a framework for comparing bias measurements across different analysis schemes and constructing consistent bias priors. p. 0
Where the paper says it

In this work, we use the renormalization group (RG) to relate field-level measurements at different cutoffs and connect them to n-point function measurements. We generate mock galaxy fields with a Lagrangian perturbation theory forward model and a galaxy bias expansion, and then measure the bias parameters across a range of cutoffs.

The RG calculation allows for controlled predictions of the running, including estimated uncertainties from higher-order terms. p. 3
Where the paper says it

2, we review the RG framework for galaxy bias and discuss the theoretical uncertainties associated with its truncation. 3, we describe the simulation setup, including the grids and filters, and both the field-level likelihood derived from the partition function and the n-point function measurement of the bias parameters.

Acknowledgments

Hsiang-Ming Huang thanks Ivana Nikolac, Beatriz Tucci and Julia Stadler for useful discussions on LEFTfield. All numerical computations were performed on the HPC cluster FREYA, maintained by the Max Planck Computing & Data Facility.

AI usage statement

ChatGPT (GPT-5.6) was used to optimize the original code written by a human, to improve individual formulations, and to perform grammar checks. The authors have verified all results and take full responsibility for all results presented herein. p. 0

Where the paper says it

We also measure the running on halo catalogs based on full N-body simulations and show that the RG prediction describes the measurements well within the predicted systematic errors. Our results establish the RG flow as a natural formulation for relating galaxy bias measurements at different cutoffs and connecting the schemes used in field-level and n-point function analyses.

--- Page 23 ---

0

−0.5

0.0

0.5

1.0

Table 2

The comparison between the best-fit parameters bΛ=0O≤[2] for the fitting scenario ‘FLI only’ and the n-pt best-fit bias parameters bnptO≤[2]. The quoted uncertainties on FLI inferences correspond to the 1σ errors. p. 0

Where the paper says it

We show that the RG predictions describe the measured running and, in the limit Λ → 0, agree with the (tree-level) n-point function measurements of first-order bδ and second-order bδ 2 , bG2 . We also measure the running on halo catalogs based on full N-body simulations and show that the RG prediction describes the measurements well within the predicted systematic errors.

Figure 6

The running of the linear and quadratic bias parameters for dark matter halos. The left and right panels show the samples with log M = 12. p. 2

Where the paper says it

2) where O denotes the bare operator, and [O] is its renormalized counterpart. Since these conditions are defined via tree-level n-point functions on the right-hand side, we refer to the [O] as n-pt-renormalized operators, and the corresponding bias coefficients as n-pt bias parameters.

5–13.0 at z = 0 and log M = 14.0–14.5 at z = 1. Curves show the RG fits with linear and quadratic bias parameters either fixed to the n-point function measurements (at Λ = 0) or fitted using only the field-level measurements. p. 3
Where the paper says it

We also examine how bias parameters defined at a finite cutoff relate to those obtained from renormalized n-point function measurements [3] in the limit of zero cutoff. We show that the renormalization group equations provide a natural way to relate bias parameters at different reference scales, using them to predict the bias values at other cutoffs.

Figure 9

Left: effect of different choices of prior on the third-order bias parameters on the first- and second-order parameters. Right: RG running of the third-order bias parameters. p. 2

Where the paper says it

Since these conditions are defined via tree-level n-point functions on the right-hand side, we refer to the [O] as n-pt-renormalized operators, and the corresponding bias coefficients as n-pt bias parameters. Assuming that the complete set of bias operators is employed, the counterterms involved in the construction of [O] are the bias operators themselves, both at leading and higher order in derivatives.

Figure 8

The resolution effect from the matter grid size NGEul = NGNy(nΛ) on the magnitude of running. The n = 4 case closely reproduces the n-point function when Λ → 0. p. 2

Where the paper says it

A fundamental alternative approach to measuring bias using n-point correlation functions is to employ the measured and predicted tracer fields, δg and δg,det, respectively, directly [11–17]. In case of simulated tracers, one can employ the initial conditions used in the simulations for the prediction, thus canceling cosmic variance to the largest degree possible.

Figure 7

The running of the bias parameters with different nLPT matter forward models.

Figure 5

Shows the n-point function measurements at Λ = 0 (left panel) and the field-level measurements at Λ = 0.05, 0.06, 0.075, 0.1 h/Mpc (right panel). p. 2

Where the paper says it

2) where O denotes the bare operator, and [O] is its renormalized counterpart. Since these conditions are defined via tree-level n-point functions on the right-hand side, we refer to the [O] as n-pt-renormalized operators, and the corresponding bias coefficients as n-pt bias parameters.

The results for bδ, bδ 2, and bG2 are shown in different colors. p. 0
Where the paper says it

We generate mock galaxy fields with a Lagrangian perturbation theory forward model and a galaxy bias expansion, and then measure the bias parameters across a range of cutoffs. We show that the RG predictions describe the measured running and, in the limit Λ → 0, agree with the (tree-level) n-point function measurements of first-order bδ and second-order bδ 2 , bG2 .

Figure 3

A summary of the choices of grid sizes and their k-mode information at each step of the LEFTfield pipeline employed in this work.

Table 1

Coefficients s1Lab in the Galilean basis. At one-loop level, the entries of s1Lab vanish whenever Ord(Oa) ≥ Ord(Ob) + 2. p. 7

Where the paper says it

The index a is the row and the index b is the column. At one-loop level, the entries of s 1L ab vanish whenever Ord(Oa) ≥ Ord(Ob) + 2.

Green — the paper says it, and the page is printed. Red — no passage carries it, so treat that sentence as unverified. The same check runs on your own text: check a summary against its source, $5.

Improvements for AI systems

  1. Implement a renormalization group (RG) flow solver that can relate field-level measurements at different cutoffs to n-point function measurements in a consistent manner, as described by the RG equations in Section 2.

  2. Develop an EFT forward model capable of generating mock galaxy fields using Lagrangian perturbation theory and a galaxy bias expansion, allowing for the measurement of bias parameters across a range of cutoffs.

  3. Integrate an inference engine that uses the Gaussian EFT likelihood function to extract bias parameters from field-level data, including analytical marginalization over higher-order bias parameters.

  4. Create a module for comparing RG predictions with measurements from mock tracer fields and halo catalogs, allowing for systematic error bar estimation based on the ensemble of realizations.

  5. Implement a method to perform convergence tests by varying the perturbative order of the matter forward model (LPT) and Eulerian grid resolution to determine the optimal setup for predicting bias running.

Abstract

Precise measurements of galaxy bias parameters are essential for extracting cosmological information from galaxy surveys. Field-level analyses infer bias coefficients at a finite cutoff Λ, typically related to the lattice resolution, while n-point function analyses typically adopt renormalization conditions defined in the low- k limit. In this work, we use the renormalization group (RG) to relate field-level measurements at different cutoffs and connect them to n-point function measurements. We generate mock galaxy fields with a Lagrangian perturbation theory forward model and a galaxy bias expansion, and then measure the bias parameters across a range of cutoffs. We show that the RG predictions describe the measured running and, in the limit Λ to 0, agree with the (tree-level) n-point function measurements of first-order b δ and second-order b δ squared, b G 2. We also measure the running on halo catalogs based on full N-body simulations and show that the RG prediction describes the measurements well within the predicted systematic errors. Our results establish the RG flow as a natural formulation for relating galaxy bias measurements at different cutoffs and connecting the schemes used in field-level and n-point function analyses.

Sources

Related papers