Implementation of two-dimensional selective acoustic tweezers merely using four straight interdigitated transducers:a numerical proof of concept of radiation field synthesis by pulsed acoustic waves
Listen
Radio episode about this paper
Transcript
Introduction to the show: ident: Physics. The day in general physics: instruments, methods and results across the field.
Kai: We're looking at the paper: "Implementation of two-dimensional selective acoustic tweezers merely using four straight interdigitated transducers".
Paper summary: Kai: So, looking at the paper "Implementation of two-dimensional selective acoustic tweezers merely using four straight interdigitated transducers:a numerical proof of concept of radiation field synthesis by pulsed acoustic waves", the authors are essentially showing that you can achieve this specific selective manipulation without needing overly complex hardware setups.
Mira: They focus on the idea that they can use time division multiplexing to combine simple acoustic fields into a combined potential field, which results in a single well surrounded by a smooth landscape, which is what allows for selectivity >
Lev: From my side, I see this as a numerical proof of concept demonstrating that the physical mechanism works under these conditions and that the force balance they assume—where the acoustic radiation force balances Stokes drag and Coulomb dry friction—is what needs to hold for particle mobility >
Kai: It’s interesting because they've used these sequences of pulses to create a combined potential field, leveraging the nonlinearity of the acoustic radiation force to make things more complex than just adding up linear pressure fields >
Mira: And the implication is that this technique could potentially allow for two-dimensional manipulation, something previous methods couldn't do with their current setup of one or two transducers >
Lev: The limitation they explicitly state is that this proof is currently a numerical one, and the authors mention that their current work only utilizes four straight interdigitated transducers in this proof of concept >
Kai: So for someone listening who isn't in the lab, what this means is that we are moving toward a system where we might not need super complex hardware to get fine control over single particles in acoustic fluidics >
Conclusion: Kai: So, we're wrapping up this look at how pulsed acoustic waves can selectively move single particles in two dimensions using just four straight interdigitated transducers and a numerical model from Shuhan Chen and Jia Zhou and Antoine Riaud.
Mira: It’s about taking something that was stuck in one dimension, like the Fourier tweezers, and using these sequences of acoustic pulses to build up a combined potential field that actually has a single trap point in two dimensions.
Lev: From an engineering standpoint, it’s interesting because they're not suggesting some magical new hardware; they are showing this works by combining existing pulse fields—plus shapes and cross shapes—and then the force balance just has to hold for the particle to stay mobile.
Kai: And what that means for me in terms of experimental work is that we might not need a whole new transducer array if we can just sequence pulses correctly to create those more intricate potential landscapes.
Mira: Exactly, it pushes past just simple linear combinations of pressure fields; they are using the nonlinearity of the acoustic radiation force itself as a tool to build something more complex than you could get with just adding up individual inputs.
Lev: But I have to ask, how much overhead does this multiplexing introduce? When you're trying to run this on actual hardware with real noise and thermal fluctuations, keeping that combined potential stable over the time division period of twenty microseconds sounds like a significant challenge for error correction.
Kai: Yeah, the timescale is tight; we’re looking at oscillations under zero point one microsecond, and then building up momentum over eighty microseconds before the particle actually starts moving toward that final trap.
Mira: The result they show is that this combined potential creates a single well surrounded by a smooth landscape, which finally lets you select one particle out of a whole batch.
Lev: So, if we look at the real hardware side, does this complexity mean the required precision on those interdigitated transducers has to be much higher than what's currently achievable in micro-acoustofluidics?
Kai: Right, that's the question; it suggests that if we want two-dimensional control without laser guidance, we really need to push the fabrication of these straight interdigitated transducers to a new level.
Mira: And this could open up a whole new way for manipulating particle arrays, like those HANDS platforms they mentioned earlier, because instead of just moving things in one direction, you could potentially select and move individual particles independently across a plane.
Lev: That's the big implication; if we can do that selective movement without relying on external fields or complex holographic setups, it makes the entire particle manipulation system much more robust for real-world use.
Shuhan Chen, Jia Zhou, Antoine Riaud
School of Microelectronics, Fudan University
physics.flu-dyn, physics.app-ph
Submitted: 2024-06-27
Updated: 2024-06-27
DOI: 10.1103/PhysRevApplied.23.014002
License: http://arxiv.org/licenses/nonexclusive-distrib/1.0/
Importance score: 85/100
The gist: Selective acoustic tweezers can focus the acoustic radiation force on a single particle to manipulate it without affecting its neighbors <ref:2406.19523#pg2> This numerical study shows that pulsed…
Key concepts
- Acoustic Radiation Force (ARF)
- This force is generated by acoustic waves acting on particles without physical contact. It can create trapping forces 100,000 times stronger than optical tweezers. The paper uses the ARF to pull and move microscopic particles in fluid.
- Time-Division Multiplexing (TDM)
- TDM is a technique where multiple acoustic radiation potential fields are combined sequentially over time. By cycling through different field shapes, the system creates a complex, single potential well surrounded by a smooth landscape, allowing selective trapping of only one target particle.
- Pulsed Acoustic Waves
- Instead of continuous waves, this method uses short bursts or pulses of acoustic energy. These pulses are generated using miniaturized interdigitated transducers (IDTs). This approach offers a promising alternative to traditional helical wave fields for creating complex acoustic potentials.
Terminology
Summary
Selective acoustic tweezers can focus the acoustic radiation force on a single particle to manipulate it without affecting its neighbors <ref:2406. p. 019523#pg2> This numerical study shows that pulsed acoustic waves can be used for the selective manipulation of particles using only two pairs of orthogonal transducers <ref:2406. p. 019523#pg2> While these tweezers are well-known for their ability to manipulate arrays of particles, the authors demonstrate that selectivity can be achieved by using sequences of acoustic pulses to iteratively construct a combined acoustic potential focused only on the target particle <ref:2406. p. 019523#pg2>.
Theoretical Foundation of Acoustic Radiation Force
Acoustic tweezers utilize the acoustic radiation force (ARF) to manipulate particles and cells without physical contact <ref:2406.19523#pg2> At equal power density, these tweezers provide a trapping force 100,000 times larger than optical tweezers <ref:2406. p. 019523#pg2>. Traditional selective manipulation methods rely on acoustic vortices which have the advantage of having a vanishing pressure on their propagation axes while having a maximum intensity around this axis <ref:2406. p. 019523#pg2>. The particle dynamics in time-multiplexed acoustic tweezers cover three different timescales: fast nearly periodic oscillations over an acoustic period (< 0. p. 01 µs), gradual build-up of momentum during repeated irradiation by a set of acoustic sub-fields (≈ 80 µs), and slow motion of the particle itself towards the acoustic trap created by the combination of sub-fields (≈ 1 s) <ref:2406. p. 1 p. 119523#pg2>.
Synthesis via Time-Division Multiplexing
The paper introduces time-division multiplexing (TDM) to synthesize a combined acoustic potential field having a single potential well surrounded by a smooth potential landscape which eventually allows selective manipulation <ref:2406.19523#pg2>. This is achieved by combining multiple acoustic radiation potential fields, some being plus-shaped + and others being cross-shaped × (Fig. p. 0 1.g) <ref:2406. p. 0 p. 019523#pg2>. The combined potential is calculated as Ucomb = 1/n Xn j=1 Z T /n 0 Uj dt = 1/n Xn j=1⟨Uj⟩ <ref:2406. p. 219523#pg2>. This approach leverages the nonlinearity of the Acoustic Radiation Force (ARF) as an intermediary step, enabling the creation of more intricate elementary fields than what could be achieved through mere linear combinations of pressure fields <ref:2406. p. 619523#pg2>.
Numerical Modeling and Simulation Setup
The transient ARF is computed using a numerical approach proposed by Chen et al.[17] with the commercial finite-element-method software COMSOL Multiphysics version 5. p. 24 <ref:2406. p. 019523#pg2>. The simulation domain is a square of sidelength Wd = 1 mm and centered on the origin of the coordinates <ref:2406. p. 219523#pg2>. Parameters include a velocity of sound cSAW = 4000 m/s, particle radius Rp = 5 µm, and fluid viscosity set to µ = 1 mPa · s <ref:2406. p. 219523#pg2>. The simulation duration tsim = 0. p. 325 µs is chosen to allow the pulse to travel across the channel, and the duration between sub-fields T /n is set to 20 µs <ref:2406. p. 3 p. 319523#pg2>.
Particle Trajectory and Selectivity Demonstration
The particle trajectory is computed by assuming that the ARF is balanced by the Stokes drag force and the Coulomb dry friction force (between the particle and the microchannel surface) <ref:2406. p. 219523#pg2>. The selective manipulation is demonstrated by simulating a batch of 10 particles dispersed in a microchannel, aiming to move one central particle to describe a square <ref:2406. p. 619523#pg2>. The minimal step for potential trap movement is set by range of radii where the ARF exceeds the surface friction force (22 pN) <ref:2406. p. 519523#pg2>. The simulation shows that when the field is updated, the ARF at this location must again exceed the friction threshold to maintain particle mobility <ref:2406. p. 519523#pg2>.
Conclusion and Future Directions
The simulations suggest that multiplexing could be used to achieve two-dimensional manipulation of particles, addressing the limitation faced by the Fourier tweezers of Xu et al.[15] or sub time-of-flight tweezers of Collins et al. p. 6 p. 6[14] <ref:2406. p. 0 p. 019523#pg2>. This kind of system could also benefit particle arrays, such as the HANDS platform [4], that have been so far limited to affine transformation of the particles coordinates <ref:2406. p. 619523#pg2>. The next significant step towards achieving twodimensional selective manipulation with straightforward acoustic tweezers would be an experimental demonstration of this type of device <ref:2406. p. 6 p. 619523#pg2>. Continued advancements in the field of pulsed manipulation could spur the development of wide bandwidth transducers, specifically designed for micro-acoustofluidics <ref:2406. p. 619523#pg2>.
REFERENCES
Implementation of two-dimensional selective acoustic tweezers merely using four straight interdigitated transducers:a numerical proof of concept of radiation field synthesis by pulsed acoustic waves Shuhan Chen, Jia Zhou,∗ and Antoine Riaud† School of Microelectronics, Fudan University, Shanghai 200433, China (Dated: July 1, 2024>
Selective acoustic tweezers can focus the acoustic radiation force on a single particle to manipulate it without affecting its neighbors. This has long required highly complex hardware <ref:2406. p. 019523#pg2> In this numerical study, we show that pulsed acoustic waves can be used for the selective manipulation of particles using only two pairs of orthogonal transducers <ref:2406. p. 019523#pg2>. While these tweezers are well-known for their ability to manipulate arrays of particles, we show that selectivity can be achieved by using sequences of acoustic pulses to iteratively construct a combined acoustic potential focused only on the target particle <ref:2406. p. 019523#pg2>.
I. INTRODUCTION Acoustic tweezers manipulate particles and cells without contact using the acoustic radiation force (ARF) <ref:2406. p. 019523#pg2> At equal power density, they provide a trapping force 100,000 times larger than optical tweezers[1] <ref:2406. p. 019523#pg2>. This confers them a high biocompatibility which makes them promising for a range of biological applications[2] <ref:2406. p. 019523#pg2>. In some of these applications, large amounts of cells need to be manipulated or clumped together, which is usually achieved using two pairs of orthogonal transducers to create a tunable standing acoustic field[3, 4] <ref:2406. p. 019523#pg2>. In other applications, it is important to capture only one particle among many other identical ones <ref:2406. p. 019523#pg2>. Such selective manipulation requires to finely craft the acoustic radiation force field to act only on a single particle, which is one of the longstanding challenges of acoustofluidics <ref:2406. p. 019523#pg2>. Traditional selective manipulation methods rely on acoustic vortices (a class of acoustic fields featuring a helical wavefront) that have the advantage of having a vanishing pressure on their propagation axes while having a maximum intensity around this axis[5, 6] <ref:2406. p. 019523#pg2>. These fields can be synthesized using transducer arrays or holographic structures such as spiraling transducers <ref:2406. p. 019523#pg2>. Transducer arrays are difficult and costly to miniaturize, while holograms must be mechanically translated to move the trap <ref:2406. p. 019523#pg2>. Pulsed acoustic waves are a promising alternative to helical wave fields <ref:2406. p. 019523#pg2>. Generation of pulses using miniaturized interdigitated transducers were developed when interdigitated transducers (IDTs) were used for pulse compression in radar technologies using chirp IDTs [7] or slanted finger IDTs combined with dispersive grating reflectors for compression ratios exceeding 20 ([8]) <ref:2406. p. 019523#pg2>. Beyond acoustofluidics, these technologies might have found a new life in quantum processing [9] <ref:2406. p. 019523#pg2>. Both technologies have been used in acoustofluidics [10], with chirp IDTs∗ jia. p. 0zhou@fudan. p. 0edu.cn † antoine. p. 0riaud@gmail. p. 0com; current affiliation: ABB Corporate Research Center, Baden-D¨attwil, Switzerland used to control inter-particle distance in acoustic manipulation [3], and slanted-finger IDTs for particle sorting [11] and fine-positioning of acoustic fields relative to an acoustofluidic device [12] or droplet [13] <ref:2406. p. 019523#pg2>. In one-dimension, Collins et al. p. 0[14] have used a single pair of IDTs to trap particles at a predefined location of a microchannel <ref:2406. p. 019523#pg2>. Using such chirp IDTs to increase the transducer bandwidth, Xu et al. p. 0[15] has devised a frequency-multiplexing method able to achieve λ/4 resolution for pulsed manipulation <ref:2406. p. 019523#pg2>. The same year, Wang et al. p. 0 [16] has provided a rigorous theoretical foundation for the manipulation of small particles using pulsed acoustic waves, which can be numerically implemented on finite element software [17] <ref:2406. p. 019523#pg2>. Despite this rapid progress, pulsed acoustic tweezers have been limited to one-dimensional manipulation (excluding expensive laser-guided acoustic tweezers [18]) <ref:2406. p. 019523#pg2>. This is because acoustic fields along each dimension create a one-dimensional acoustic trap, which results in a cross-pattern (see for instance Fig. p. 0 4 of Xu et al.[15]) instead of a single point trap <ref:2406. p. 019523#pg2>. Therefore, any particle along the cross will be captured and selectivity is lost <ref:2406. p. 019523#pg2>. In this paper, we show that using sequences of pulses allows combining multiple acoustic radiation potential fields, some being plus-shaped + and others being crossshaped × (Fig. p. 0 1.g) <ref:2406.19523#pg2>. This time-division multiplexing (TDM) enables the synthesis of a combined acoustic potential field having a single potential well surrounded by a smooth potential landscape (Fig. p. 0 1.h) which eventually allows selective manipulation <ref:2406. p. 019523#pg2>.
II. THEORY The particle dynamics in time-multiplexed acoustic tweezers cover three different timescales: fast nearly periodic oscillations over an acoustic period (< 0. p. 01 µs), gradual build-up of momentum during repeated irradiation by a set of acoustic sub-fields (≈ 80 µs), and slow motion of the particle itself towards the acoustic trap created by the combination of sub-fields (≈ 1 s) <ref:2406.19523#pg2>. In the following, we consider particles of density ρp and compressibility κp and radius Rp immersed in an inviscid fluid of density ρ0, velocity of sound c0, compressibility κ0 = 1/(ρ0c 2 0) <ref:2406. p. 119523#pg2>. The resulting ARF reads Frad = −4πR cubed p 3∇⟨U⟩, (1) with U a mathematical artifact that can be interpreted as the instantaneous Gor’kov potential <ref:2406. p. 119523#pg2>. Computing U requires knowing the incident acoustic pressure field ˜pin and incident vibration velocity field v˜in <ref:2406. p. 119523#pg2>. The relation ˆvz = ˆp/(ρ0c 0 cos ΘR) is now independent of the direction, and allows using the wellknown acoustic impedance to deduce the z-component of the velocity from the pressure field in the transient direct-space domain <ref:2406. p. 119523#pg2>. As illustrated in Fig. p. 2 1(g), selective manipulation is achieved by cycling through a set of n sub-fields to generate a combined potential Ucomb = ⟨U⟩ = (1/T) R T 0 U dt, where T is the multiplexing period <ref:2406. p. 219523#pg2>. The particle trajectory is computed by assuming that the ARF is balanced by the Stokes drag force and the Coulomb dry friction force (between the particle and the microchannel surface) <ref:2406.19523#pg2>.
III. METHOD In our simulations, the ARF of each sub-field is first computed using a two-dimensional acoustic model, then the combined force field is computed and exported to a Python script to compute the particle motion <ref:2406. p. 219523#pg2>. The ARF is exported as the orthogonal x-component Fx = −(4πR cubed p/3)∂xUcomb and y-component Fy = −(4πR cubed p/3)∂yUcomb unless otherwise specified <ref:2406. p. 219523#pg2>. The total simulation duration tsim = 0. p. 325 µs is chosen to allow the pulse to travel across the channel, and the duration between sub-fields T /n is set to 20 µs <ref:2406.19523#pg2>.
IV. RESULTS A Acoustic radiation potential of sub-fields We first examine the behavior of acoustic pressure and acoustic radiation potential fields for the first sub-field (s = s1) and setting (xp, yp) = (0, 0) In Fig. p. 3 2(a), we observe the evolution of the acoustic field over time, where pairs of perpendicular pulsed plane waves (blue and red ripples) propagate inward from the domain boundaries <ref:2406. p. 319523#pg2>. The instantaneous Gor’kov potential U1,inst (Fig. p. 3 2(b)) reflects the non-zero acoustic pressure topology <ref:2406. p. 319523#pg2>. The resulting potential build-up is shown in Fig. p. 3 2(c) <ref:2406. p. 019523#pg2>. The superposition of well-chosen sub-field acoustic radiation potentials can create a singular region of zero potential energy surrounded by a circular barrier, trapping particles exclusively at that focal point <ref:2406. p. 319523#pg2>. Fig. 4(a) shows the potential distribution of the combined field composed of sub-fields, revealing a clover-leaf pattern with a prominent circular potential well at the center <ref:2406. p. 419523#pg2>. The ARF profile is translated from xp = −λd/6 to +λd/6 <ref:2406. p. 519523#pg2>. The friction force (F = 22 pN) requires the successive force fields to intersect above this force threshold in order to maintain particle mobility <ref:2406. p. 619523#pg2>.
V. DISCUSSION These simulations suggest that can multiplexing could be used to achieve two-dimensional manipulation of particles, addressing the limitation faced by the Fourier tweezers of Xu et al. p. 6[15] or sub time-of-flight tweezers of Collins et al.[14] <ref:2406.19523#pg2>. Furthermore, the simulations suggests that this kind of system could also benefit particle array, such as the HANDS platform [4], that have been so far limited to affine transformation of the particles coordinates (rotation of the array, scaling, skewing, and translation) and depending on the stretching it also allows merging of particles <ref:2406. p. 619523#pg2>. The authors note that using pulses could allow this type of array tweezers to selectively move one particle independently of all the others <ref:2406. p. 619523#pg2>.
VI. CONCLUSION Currently, selective manipulation of particles necessitates intricate transducers or transducer arrays <ref:2406. p. 619523#pg2> Acoustic manipulation with pulsed waves promises simpler transducers for selective manipulation, but was only demonstrated in one dimension <ref:2406. p. 619523#pg2>. Our simulations suggest that selective manipulation with pulsed waves could be expanded to two-dimensions by using combination of pulses <ref:2406. p. 619523#pg2>. Our method leverages the nonlinearity of the Acoustic Radiation Force (ARF) as an intermediary step, enabling the creation of more intricate elementary fields than what could be achieved through mere linear combinations of pressure fields <ref:2406. p. 619523#pg2>. The next significant step towards achieving twodimensional selective manipulation with straightforward acoustic tweezers would be an experimental demonstration of this type of device <ref:2406.19523#pg2>. This approach could potentially be expanded to incorporate all four transducers, moving beyond the 2+2 combinations utilized in our current work <ref:2406. p. 619523#pg2>.
Green — the paper says it, and the page is printed. Red — no passage carries it, so treat that sentence as unverified. The same check runs on your own text: check a summary against its source, $5.
Improvements for AI systems
-
Adaptive field synthesis for particle manipulation: The system can use sequences of pulses to
combine multiple acoustic radiation potential fields, some being plus-shaped + and others being crossshaped ×
to create acombined acoustic potential field having a single potential well surrounded by a smooth potential landscape.
-
Selective trapping based on interference: The AI system can exploit the relationship between constructive and destructive interference in sub-fields, using them to
compensate for the destructive interference
by ensuringthe positive potential along the diagonal is equal to the background field.
-
Dynamic trap movement control: By adjusting the phase of alpha in Equation 8, the system can control particle location, allowing for a
smooth particle motion
and enabling manipulation by setting a minimal step size of approximately lambda d over six. -
Enhanced array manipulation: The method suggests that multiplexing could be used to expand array tweezers to benefit systems like the HANDS platform, allowing for the selective movement of one particle independently of all others.
Sources
Related papers
- Data-driven impeller model for efficient large eddy simulations of metastable von K'arm'an flows
- Numerical study of nitrogen oxides chemistry during plasma assisted combustion in a sequential combustor
- Emergent Transfer of a Physics Foundation Model from Simulation to Laboratory Turbulence
- Early onset of secondary shear instability in Kelvin-Helmholtz braids at high Reynolds number
- Rotational covariance, continuous spectrum and non-modal growth of three-dimensional planar weak viscous shock layers
- Deep Learning-based Algebraic Reynolds Stress Closures for RANS Simulations of Turbulent Flows