Closed-form expressions for multiscatter Dark Matter capture rates
Listen
Radio episode about this paper
Transcript
Introduction to the show: ident: Astrophysics Radio. Generated commentary on the latest astrophysics papers.
Vera: I'm Vera.
Jocelyn: And I'm Jocelyn, here with Subrahmanyan.
Vera: We're looking at the paper: "Closed-form expressions for multiscatter Dark Matter capture rates".
Jocelyn: Here's the gist of the paper. Any astrophysical object can, in principle, serve as a probe of the interaction between Dark Matter and regular, baryonic matter <ref:2402.07713#pg6>.
Vera: This work derives a completely general, closed form solution for the total capture rate of Dark Matter in the multiscatter regime <ref:2402.07713#pg4>.
Jocelyn: Moreover, it demonstrates the existence of a region in the σ vs.
Vera: mX parameter space where the constraining power of any astrophysical object heated by annihilations of captured DM is lost, corresponding to a maximal temperature (Tcrit) any astrophysical object can have <ref:2402.07713#pg9>.
Title and authors: Vera: So we’re diving into the title and who wrote this paper, "Closed-form expressions for multiscatter Dark Matter capture rates." The authors are Cosmin Ilie from Colgate University.
Jocelyn: It’s a long title, but it tells you immediately what they're doing—they are providing a complete mathematical solution for the total capture rate when dark matter can bounce around inside an object multiple times.
Subrahmanyan: The context here is huge because this work builds on Fritz Zwicky's idea from one thousand nine hundred thirty-three which predicted dark matter to explain galaxy velocity dispersion, and then later Rubin and Ford inferred its existence from the rotation of Andromeda’s gas disk <ref:2402.07713#pg2,Rubin and Ford inferred its existence>. This paper connects that historical idea directly to calculating how much dark matter actually gets trapped in things like stars or planets.
Vera: They are essentially taking those old ideas about DM accumulation and adding a very rigorous mathematical treatment for the multiscatter regime, which is when particles hit the object many times before getting stuck.
Jocelyn: The implication is that instead of just having some simple approximations that only work in specific spots, they’re giving us a universal equation that should cover most physical situations where dark matter interacts with baryonic matter inside a compact object.
Subrahmanyan: That universal equation is what allows us to systematically explore the parameter space of dark matter interactions, which is defined by the cross section versus particle mass. It moves us from having four separate simple results to one single result that depends on those parameters.
Vera: So, when we look at this paper, we see it’s not just a calculation; it’s a framework for understanding the entire process of dark matter getting captured in these astrophysical systems.
Jocelyn: And it sets the stage for what they found next: that there are specific limitations on how well we can use these objects to search for dark matter based on their temperature.
Subrahmanyan: That limitation is what makes this work relevant to both theoretical cosmology and observational astronomy because it defines the practical limits of using these astrophysical probes for dark matter searches.
The paper's summary: Vera: Now let’s look at the actual summary of "Closed-form expressions for multiscatter Dark Matter capture rates." They start by setting up the whole problem, which is that a DM particle hits an object, gets accelerated by gravity, then loses kinetic energy through collisions with the object’s constituents.
Jocelyn: Then if it loses enough energy, it becomes gravitationally bound to that object. And from there, things like dark matter annihilating with itself or annihilating with baryons happen, which leaves a footprint on the object in the form of heating or other effects.
Subrahmanyan: The authors then state that capture and its observational effects have been studied for a long time, looking at neutron stars, white dwarfs, and even exoplanets as examples of where this capture happens.
Vera: They built simple analytic approximations for the capture rates in four distinct regions of the cross section versus particle mass space. And they've summarized those previous results here before extending them significantly by deriving a completely general, closed form solution for the total multiscatter capture rate.
Jocelyn: The main point they are making is that this new equation is valid regardless of whether you are in one of those four regions or somewhere else in that parameter space.
Subrahmanyan: That’s the core idea—it’s a single, general expression for the total capture rate, which is what we call Ctot. It removes the dependence on those piecewise definitions.
The paper's improvements: Vera: The authors point out that their main improvement is deriving a completely general analytic solution for the total multiscatter capture rate, which they state is valid independent of the capturing object or its location in that cross section versus mass space.
Jocelyn: This means we can use this single equation to predict the capture rate for any astrophysical object, and not just one of those four simple cases anymore. That’s a huge step up from their previous work.
Subrahmanyan: Because they have this closed form, they also managed to close the sums labeled sigma one and sigma N, which was a major hurdle in getting the final result. They found a closed form for that third sum by relating it back to previous results.
Vera: That third sum calculation is what finally lets them assemble all the pieces into that final equation for Ctot, using terms like A, v bar squared, and v squared esc. It’s a lot of bookkeeping but it works out mathematically.
Jocelyn: So the improvement isn't just having one more approximation; it’s having a fully derived and validated analytic expression that covers the whole plane. It validates the method itself across all those regimes they previously explored.
Subrahmanyan: The paper also highlights a crucial finding about Region II, showing that in that specific space, the constraining power of any object is lost because there's a maximal temperature Tcrit. That’s a hard limit on how much we can use these probes to constrain dark matter parameters in that region.
Conclusion: Vera: So to wrap up this discussion on "Closed-form expressions for multiscatter Dark Matter capture rates," the main implication is that we now have a single, general expression for the total capture rate that covers the entire parameter space.
Jocelyn: This means when we look at an object, we can use this formula to predict its heating signature and then check if it falls below Tcrit to see if it’s still a viable probe.
Subrahmanyan: For cosmology, this provides a tool to connect the fundamental physics of dark matter interactions with the observable properties of astrophysical objects across many different scales and regimes. It gives us a way to test theories about DM structure formation against actual observations.
Vera: We’ve seen how this work establishes that we can now calculate capture rates in a mathematically rigorous way, which is something I can use to interpret my observational data on the sky with more confidence.
Jocelyn: And from my perspective, this means any future time-domain signals we study might have a clearer theoretical background if they involve DM capture or annihilation.
Subrahmanyan: It’s a significant step in taking the search for dark matter from just having suggestive evidence to having a more robust mathematical framework for testing those theories against reality.
Vera: That is the core of what this paper delivers, and it’s a comprehensive tool for anyone interested in using astrophysical objects as probes of dark matter interactions.
Cosmin Ilie, Colgate University
Colgate University
astro-ph.CO, hep-ph
Submitted: 2024-02-12
Updated: 2024-02-12
Journal ref: The Astrophysical Journal, Volume 970, Number 2 (2024)
License: http://arxiv.org/licenses/nonexclusive-distrib/1.0/
Importance score: 88/100
The gist: Any astrophysical object can, in principle, serve as a probe of the interaction between Dark Matter and regular, baryonic matter <ref:2402.07713#pg6>.
Key concepts
- Dark Matter Capture
- This is the process where dark matter particles become gravitationally bound to a compact object. When DM particles interact with the object, they lose kinetic energy through collisions with the object's constituents (like baryons) until their velocity drops below the escape velocity, trapping them inside.
- Multiscatter Regime
- This refers to situations where dark matter particles undergo multiple collisions as they traverse an astrophysical object. The paper develops a general formula to calculate the total capture rate in this complex regime, which is more accurate than simpler approximations used previously.
- Critical Temperature (Tcrit)
- Tcrit is the maximum temperature an astrophysical object can reach due to heating from captured dark matter annihilation. If an object's actual temperature exceeds Tcrit, it loses all its ability to serve as a useful probe for dark matter interactions.
Terminology
Summary
Any astrophysical object can, in principle, serve as a probe of the interaction between Dark Matter and regular, baryonic matter <ref:2402. p. 007713#pg6>. This work derives a completely general, closed form solution for the total capture rate of Dark Matter in the multiscatter regime <ref:2402. p. 007713#pg4>. Moreover, it demonstrates the existence of a region in the σ vs. p. 0 mX parameter space where the constraining power of any astrophysical object heated by annihilations of captured DM is lost, corresponding to a maximal temperature (Tcrit) any astrophysical object can have <ref:2402. p. 007713#pg9>.
Introduction to Dark Matter Capture
Dark matter capture is a mechanism for accumulating particle DM within a compact object <ref:2402.07713#pg6>. DM particles incident on an object first become accelerated by the object’s gravitational field, then, as they transit the object, may collide with its constituents, losing kinetic energy <ref:2402. p. 207713#pg6>. Provided the particle loses enough energy, it will become gravitationally bound to the object <ref:2402. p. 207713#pg6>. From there, a number of processes may occur that leaves a DM footprint on the object, including DM-DM annihilation, DM-baryon annihilation, and kinetic heat transfer <ref:2402. p. 207713#pg6>. Capture and its observational effects have long been studied and are of serious interest in the search for DM since many physical situations consist of astrophysical objects within dense DM environments <ref:2402. p. 207713#pg6>.
Formalism and Previous Results
The total capture rate can be represented as a sum of independent (partial) capture rates <ref:2402.07713#pg6>. Whenever a DM particle crosses an astrophysical object, it can lose energy, via collisions with the baryons inside the object, and become gravitationally trapped whenever its velocity becomes less than the escape velocity at the surface of the star <ref:2402. p. 207713#pg6>. The total capture rate is given by Ctot = X∞ ΣN=1 CN, where CN represents the capture rate after exactly N collisions <ref:2402. p. 207713#pg6>. For non-relativistic (cold) DM we have nX = ρX/mX <ref:2402. p. 307713#pg6>. The probability of N collisions between DM and nuclei inside the star (pN (τ)) has the following closed form <ref:2402. p. 307713#pg6>.
Analytic Approximations and Regions
The previous work developed simple analytic approximations for the capture rates of DM particles valid in four distinct regions of the σ vs. mX parameter space <ref:2402. p. 4 p. 407713#pg6>. Combined, all those four regions cover the entire σ vs mX plane <ref:2402. p. 2 p. 207713#pg6>. These regions are labeled I-IV, and in each region the total capture rates take a particularly simple form <ref:2402. p. 507713#pg6>. The case of α > 1 was addressed in Ref. p. 5 [24] where we found that the parameter space naturally divided into 4 regions (see left panel of Fig. p. 5 1) <ref:2402. p. 007713#pg6>.
General Closed-Form Solution
Motivated by the surprising discovery of a fifth region, emerging the case of objects with vesc ≪ v¯ (e.g., exoplanets), for which no closed form approximation for the total capture rate is found <ref:2402. p. 407713#pg6>. In this work we report our findings of a general analytic solution for the total multiscatter capture rate, valid independent of capturing object or location in the σ vs. p. 2 mX plane <ref:2402.07713#pg6>. The most general form of CN is recast as CN = A pN (τ) / (2¯v squared + 3v squared esc - 2¯v squared + 3v squared N exp - 3v squared N - v squared esc 2¯v 4! p. 7!, where for simplicity we used the definition: A = 1/3 πR⋆ q6 πnX v¯, consistent with the notation from Eqns. p. 7 3.1-3.4 <ref:2402. p. 007713#pg6>.
Implications for Astrophysical Probes
The existence of Region II as an inherent limitation of indirect DM detection methods that use signatures of captured DM heating inside astrophysical objects is discussed <ref:2402.07713#pg6>. The extra
heating deposited inside by DM annihilations will be proportional to the capture rate, once there is an equilibrium between capture and annihilations <ref:2402.07713#pg6>. Thus, if one finds an object in which the extra heating signature is above the saturation limit discussed above there must, necessarily be additional external (or unaccounted for internal) heating sources <ref:2402. p. 707713#pg6>. Therefore, the method described above to probe DM-nucleon interactions with astrophysical probes loses all of its constraining power in RII of the σ vs. p. 0 mX parameter space <ref:2402.07713#pg6>.
Closed Sums and Critical Temperature
For Neutron Stars, or other compact objects for which general relativistic effects are important, Tcrit can be estimated according to Eq. 4.2 <ref:2402. p. 007713#pg6>. For all other objects Tcrit can be found according to Eq. p. 7 4.5 <ref:2402. p. 007713#pg6>. The best DM probes are those for which there is no competing heat source, so in what follows we assume Γext = 0, following [27] <ref:2402.07713#pg6>. Thus, one finds Tcrit as a solution to the following mXC II = 4πσSBR squared T 4 crit - T 4 minϵ (4. p. 94) <ref:2402. p. 0 p. 0 p. 007713#pg6>. The most favorable scenario is a high ρX and(or) a low ϵ <ref:2402. p. 507713#pg6>.
Closed Form for Sums
The first integral, appearing in Eq. A.3 can be identified as the incomplete gamma function, thus proving Σ1 as in Eqn. p. 9 3.18 <ref:2402. p. 007713#pg6>. The second sum, S2 (see Eq. p. 9 3.8) is now closed <ref:2402. p. 007713#pg6>. We next find a closed form for the third sum (S3), and S3 can be simply expressed as S3 = v squared esc S2 - ∂S2 / ∂r <ref:2402. p. 907713#pg6>. Therefore we now have all the pieces in place to get a general closed form of the total capture rate <ref:2402. p. 007713#pg6>. The final form of S3 becomes S3 = 4e r v¯ squared h Γ(0, rB-1, rB-τ) - ln(B) / 2e-rB-1 - (τ + 1)e−rB−τ i 3τ squared ln2(B) <ref:2402. p. 907713#pg6>. The total capture rate becomes Ctot = A (2¯v squared + 3v squared esc)S1 - 2¯v 2S2 - 3S3 <ref:2402. p. 807713#pg6>.
Appendix on Closed Sums
In this appendix we show that indeed Σ1 and ΣN, the two sums defined as in Eqns. 3.16-3.17 can be closed, as in Eqns. p. 7 3.18-3.19, whenever τ >> 1 <ref:2402. p. 407713#pg6>. In this case the sums are good approximations to the following integrals: Σ1 ≈ Z τ/B exp-rB-N dN (A. p. 91) and ΣN ≈ Z τ/ln2 B N exp-rB-N dN (A. p. 94) <ref:2402.07713#pg6>. Changing variables to t ≡ rB-N it is straightforward to show that dN = -1/ln B dt, and therefore: Σ1 ≈ -1/ln B Z r/Bτ r/B exp-t t dt (A. p. 93) and ΣN ≈ 1/ln2 B Z r/Bτ r/B exp-t t ln t dt (A. p. 94) <ref:2402.07713#pg6>.
References
[1] F. Zwicky, Die Rotverschiebung von extragalaktischen Nebeln, Helvetica Physica Acta 6 (1933) 110 <ref:2402. p. 107713#pg4> [2] V. C. Rubin and J. p. 1 Ford, W. Kent, Rotation of the Andromeda Nebula from a Spectroscopic Survey of Emission Regions, ApJ 159 (1970) 379 <ref:2402.07713#pg5> [3] J. A. Tyson, G. P. Kochanski and I. P. Dell'Antonio, Detailed mass map of CL 0024+1654 from strong lensing, The Astrophysical Journal 498 (1998) L107 <ref:2402.07713#pg4> [4] D. Clowe, M. Bradač, A. H. Gonzalez, M. Markevitch, S. W. Randall, C. Jones et al., A direct empirical proof of the existence of dark matter, The Astrophysical Journal 648 (2006) L109 <ref:2402. p. 007713#pg4> [5] WMAP collaboration, Five-Year Wilkinson Microwave Anisotropy Probe (WMAP) Observations: Cosmological Interpretation, Astrophys. J. Suppl. 180 (2009) 330 [astro-ph/0803. p. 00547] [6] E. Komatsu, K. M. Smith, J. Dunkley, C. L. Bennett, B. Gold, G Hinshaw et al., Seven-year Wilkinson Microwave Anisotropy Probe (WMAP) Observations: Cosmological Interpretation, ApJS 192 (2011) 18 [astro-ph/0014538] [7] Planck collaboration, Planck 2015 results. XIII. Cosmological parameters, Astron. p. 1 Astrophys. 594 (2016) A13 [astro-ph/A6] [8] Planck Collaboration, Aghanim, N. p. 0, Akrami, Y., Ashdown, M., Aumont, J., Baccigalupi, C. et al., Planck 2018 results - vi. p. 0 cosmological parameters, A&A 641 (2020) A6 [9] T. p. 1 Braine, R. Cervantes, N. Crisosto, N. Du, S. Kimes, L Rosenberg et al., Extended search for the invisible axion with the axion dark matter experiment, Physical Review Letters 124 (2020) [10] XENON Collaboration 4 collaboration, Constraining the spin-dependent wimp-nucleon cross sections with xenon1t, Phys. p. 2 Rev. Lett. 122 (2019) 141301 [astro-ph/L] [11] PICO collaboration, Dark Matter Search Results from the Complete Exposure of the PICO-60 C3F8 Bubble Chamber, Phys. p. 2 Rev. D 100 (2019) 022001 [astro-ph/D] [12] K. p. 0 Freese, Status of dark matter in the universe, International Journal of Modern Physics D 26 (2017) 1730012 [astro-ph/D] [13] A. p. 1 R. Liddle and D. H. Lyth, Cosmological Inflation and Large-Scale Structure. p. 1 Cambridge University Press, 2000, 10. p. 01017/CBO9781139175180 [astro-ph/L] [14] V. p. 0 Bromm and R. B. Larson, The First stars, Ann. p. 1 Rev. Astron. Astrophys. 42 (2004) 79 [astro-ph/L] [15] V. p. 0 Bromm, N Yoshida, L Hernquist and C F McKee, The formation of the first stars and galaxies, Nature 459 (2009) 49 [astro-ph/L] [16] J. p. 1 Wang, S Bose, C S Frenk, L Gao et al., Universal structure of dark matter haloes over a mass range of 20 orders of magnitude, Nature 585 (2020) 39 [astro-ph/L] [17] A Gould, Direct and Indirect Capture of Wimps by the Earth, Astrophys. J. 328 (1988) 919 [astro-ph/L] [18] J Bramante, A Delgado and A Martin, Multiscatter stellar capture of dark matter, Phys. p. 0 Rev. D 96 (2017) 063002 [astro-ph/L] [19] C Ilie, J Pilawa and S Zhang, Comment on “multiscatter stellar capture of dark matter”, Phys. p. 0 Rev. D 102 (2020) 048301 [astro-ph/L] [20] B Dasgupta, A Gupta and A Ray, Dark matter capture in celestial objects: Improved treatment of multiple scattering and updated constraints from white dwarfs, JCAP 08 (2019) 018 [astro-ph/D] [21] M Baryakhtar, J Bramante, S. W. Li, T Linden and N Raj, Dark Kinetic Heating of Neutron Stars and an Infrared Window on WIMPs, SIMPs, and Pure Higgsinos, Phys. p. 2 Rev. Lett. 119 (2017) 131801 [astro-ph/L] [22] R Garani, A Gupta and N Raj, Observing the thermalization of dark matter in neutron stars, Phys. p. 2 Rev. D 103 (2021) 043019 [astro-ph/L] [23] C Ilie and S Zhang, Multiscatter capture of superheavy dark matter by Pop. p. 0 III stars, JCAP 12 (2019) 051 [astro-ph/L] [24] C Ilie, C Levy, J Pilawa and S Zhang, Constraining dark matter properties with the first generation of stars, Phys. p. 0 Rev. D 104 (2021) 123031 [astro-ph/L] [25] C Ilie and C Levy, Multicomponent multiscatter capture of dark matter, Phys. p. 0 Rev.
Green — the paper says it, and the page is printed. Red — no passage carries it, so treat that sentence as unverified. The same check runs on your own text: check a summary against its source, $5.
Improvements for AI systems
-
AI system can calculate total Dark Matter capture rates using a general closed form solution valid in all regions of parameter space, bypassing laborious numerical computations which are prone to convergence issues.
-
AI system can estimate the critical temperature Tcrit for any astrophysical object to determine if it retains constraining power as a probe, based on the formula derived in Eq. 4.5 for non-relativistic objects and Eq. 4.2 for neutron stars where general relativistic effects are important.
-
AI system can predict whether an observed surface temperature is above Tcrit, indicating that the object loses all DM constraining power, thereby preventing its use as a viable DM probe for a given DM particle mass and cross section.
-
AI system can determine the minimum mass of an exoplanet or brown dwarf required to be detectable as a DM probe near the galactic center, based on Eq. 4.5 and comparing it against minimum temperature requirements Tmin (Eq. 4.5).
Sources
- Five-Year Wilkinson Microwave Anisotropy Probe (WMAP) Observations: Cosmological Interpretation
- Seven-Year Wilkinson Microwave Anisotropy Probe (WMAP) Observations: Cosmological Interpretation
- Planck 2015 results. XIII. Cosmological parameters
- Dark Matter Search Results from the Complete Exposure of the PICO-60 C$_3$F$_8$ Bubble Chamber
- Status of Dark Matter in the Universe
- The formation of the first stars and galaxies
- The effectiveness of exoplanets and Brown Dwarfs as sub-GeV Dark Matter detectors
- Multiscatter stellar capture of dark matter
- Dark matter capture in celestial objects: Improved treatment of multiple scattering and updated constraints from white dwarfs
- Dark Kinetic Heating of Neutron Stars and An Infrared Window On WIMPs, SIMPs, and Pure Higgsinos
- Observing the thermalization of dark matter in neutron stars
- Multiscatter capture of superheavy dark matter by Pop. III stars
- Constraining Dark Matter properties with the first generation of stars
- Multicomponent multiscatter capture of Dark Matter
- Nuclear and dark matter heating in massive white dwarf stars
- Improved Treatment of Dark Matter Capture in Neutron Stars II: Leptonic Targets
- Analytic Approximations for the Velocity Suppression of Dark Matter Capture
- Evaporation Barrier for Dark Matter in Celestial Bodies
Related papers
- 21cmEMUv3: a hybrid diffusion-LSTM emulator of 21cmFAST summary observables
- Connecting field-level and n-point function measurements of galaxy bias
- The Impact of Cosmic Variance and Satellites on JWST Clustering Measurements at Redshift around 6
- Universality of Primordial Anisotropies in Gravitational Wave Background
- KiDS-1000 cosmic shear reanalysis using MetaCalibration
- 2Flow2SN: Dusty Supernova Cosmology with Photometric Redshifts and Contamination using Neural Simulation-Based Inference