The effectiveness of exoplanets and Brown Dwarfs as sub-GeV Dark Matter detectors

arXiv:2312.13979 · astro-ph.CO, hep-ph · Submitted 2023-12-21 · Read on arXiv

Listen

Radio episode about this paper

Transcript

Introduction to the show: ident: Astrophysics Radio. Generated commentary on the latest astrophysics papers.

Vera: We're looking at the paper: "The effectiveness of exoplanets and Brown Dwarfs as sub-GeV Dark Matter detectors".

Jocelyn: Here's the gist of the paper. The effectiveness of exoplanets and Brown Dwarfs as sub-GeV Dark Matter detectors is severely hindered by Dark Matter evaporation, which necessitates a re-evaluation of their potential as probes in the sub-GeV regime.

Vera: Limitation Imposed by Evaporation Dark Matter evaporation severely hinders the effectiveness of exoplanets and Brown Dwarfs as sub-GeV DM probes.

Jocelyn: The authors find that for Jupiter-like exoplanets and Brown Dwarfs placed at the Galactic Center, the evaporation mass is around ∼ 1 GeV, suggesting they are quite poor DM probes in the sub-GeV regime.

Vera: Furthermore, they point out a DM parameter dependent critical temperature (Tcrit), above which astrophysical objects lose any sensitivity as Dark Matter probes.

Paper summary: Vera: So wrapping up this discussion on "The effectiveness of exoplanets and Brown Dwarfs as sub-GeV Dark Matter detectors," the core message is that Dark Matter evaporation significantly limits their utility as direct probes in the sub-GeV regime zero.

Jocelyn: The authors show that for Jupiter-like objects at the Galactic Center, this evaporation mass is around one GeV, which makes them quite poor probes for this energy range <ref:2312.13979#pg1>.

Subrahmanyan: It also sets a DM parameter dependent critical temperature Tcrit above which astrophysical objects lose sensitivity as Dark Matter probes <ref:2312.13979#pg1>.

Vera: The paper also provided analytic closed form approximations for the capture rates of these objects, valid in four distinct regions of the sigma-mX parameter space <ref:2312.13979#pg1>.

Jocelyn: And they explicitly show how the one GeV evaporation mass approximation is an underestimate, finding it to be around one GeV for Jupiters and Brown Dwarfs at the Galactic Center <ref:2312.13979#pg2>.

Subrahmanyan: The implications are that we need a much more detailed model incorporating capture, evaporation, and annihilation processes to get reliable sensitivity estimates zero. This requires us to look beyond simple approximations when constraining Dark Matter with exoplanets or Brown Dwarfs.

Vera: It really pushes the field toward needing better modeling of internal heating and density profiles within these objects <ref:2312.13979#pg3>.

Jocelyn: So, for a listener just tuning in, the main thing is that these objects aren't as straightforward DM detectors as we might hope because of the evaporation effects they model zero.

Subrahmanyan: And it points us toward needing observations that can constrain those Tcrit values directly to see if we are in or out of sensitivity <ref:2312.13979#pg1>.

Conclusion: Vera: So we've seen how Dark Matter evaporation really throws a wrench in using exoplanets and Brown Dwarfs to hunt for sub-GeV particles, right?

Jocelyn: Exactly. This paper is titled "The effectiveness of exoplanets and Brown Dwarfs as sub-GeV Dark Matter detectors," and the authors are looking at how good these things actually are.

Subrahmanyan: They're really digging into the physics here, connecting it to structure formation. The main point is that evaporation mass around one GeV for Jupiter-like objects at the Galactic Center means they aren't great probes for this sub-GeV energy range.

Vera: That’s right. They find a critical temperature where these objects stop being useful DM detectors, which is about seven hundred Kelvin for a three times Jupiter mass object at the Galactic Center.

Jocelyn: And they show that using just one GeV as an evaporation mass estimate is actually too low, finding it's closer to one GeV for those specific objects.

Subrahmanyan: That suggests we need a much more detailed model involving capture and annihilation rates to get any real sensitivity constraints on Dark Matter with these kinds of targets.

Vera: It really points toward needing better modeling of how things actually behave inside these objects, like the density profiles, because that's where the next big challenge is.

C. Ilie, C. Levyb, J. Diksa

Department of Physics and Astronomy, Colgate University · Physics Department, Harvard University

astro-ph.CO, hep-ph

Submitted: 2023-12-21

Updated: 2023-12-21

Journal ref: Journal of Cosmology and Astroparticle Physics, Volume 2024, April 2024

DOI: 10.1088/1475-7516/2024/04/082

License: http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/

Importance score: 86/100

The gist: The effectiveness of exoplanets and Brown Dwarfs as sub-GeV Dark Matter detectors is severely hindered by Dark Matter evaporation…

Key concepts

Dark Matter Evaporation
This process describes how Dark Matter particles can escape an astrophysical object due to interactions with surrounding matter. The paper shows that for Jupiter-like objects at the Galactic Center, this evaporation mass is about 1 GeV, which significantly limits their usefulness as detectors for sub-GeV Dark Matter.
$T_{crit}$ (Critical Temperature)
This is a temperature threshold above which astrophysical objects lose any sensitivity as Dark Matter probes. For Jupiters at the Galactic Center, this critical temperature ranges from 700 K to 950 K, meaning objects must be hot enough to overcome this barrier for detection.
Annihilation Rate ($\Gamma_A(N_X)$)
This models how frequently Dark Matter particles annihilate within the object. The 'Co-SIMP' sub-GeV model is used, assuming annihilation occurs via the process DM+DM+SM $\rightarrow$ DM+SM. This rate is a key factor in determining the overall detection effectiveness.
Density Profiles (LTE Limit)
This refers to how Dark Matter particles are distributed within an object under Local Thermal Equilibrium (LTE). When the Dark Matter mass falls below a certain point, the profile exhibits a 'floating' behavior, meaning densities increase toward the object's edge.

Terminology

Summary

The effectiveness of exoplanets and Brown Dwarfs as sub-GeV Dark Matter detectors is severely hindered by Dark Matter evaporation, which necessitates a re-evaluation of their potential as probes in the sub-GeV regime. p. 0

Where the paper says it

edu Abstract. In this work we demonstrate that Dark Matter (DM) evaporation severely hinders the effectiveness of exoplanets and Brown Dwarfs as sub-GeV DM probes.

Limitation Imposed by Evaporation

Dark Matter evaporation severely hinders the effectiveness of exoplanets and Brown Dwarfs as sub-GeV DM probes. The authors find that for Jupiter-like exoplanets and Brown Dwarfs placed at the Galactic Center, the evaporation mass is around ∼ 1 GeV, suggesting they are quite poor DM probes in the sub-GeV regime. p. 2

Where the paper says it

We find instead, that for the objects considered (Jupiters and Brown Dwarfs placed at the Galactic Center) the evaporation mass for is around ∼ 1 GeV (see Figs. As such, exoplanets and Brown Dwarfs are quite poor DM probes in the sub-GeV regime.

Furthermore, they point out a DM parameter dependent critical temperature (Tcrit), above which astrophysical objects lose any sensitivity as Dark Matter probes. p. 0
Where the paper says it

the entire flux crossing an object. As a consequence of this region, which for many objects falls within the parameter space not excluded by direct detection experiments, we point out the existence of a DM parameter dependent critical temperature (Tcrit), above which astrophysical objects lose any sensitivity as Dark Matter probes.

For instance, Jupiters at the Galactic Center have a Tcrit ranging from 700 K (for a 3MJ Jupiter) to 950 K (for 14MJ). p. 0
Where the paper says it

As a consequence of this region, which for many objects falls within the parameter space not excluded by direct detection experiments, we point out the existence of a DM parameter dependent critical temperature (Tcrit), above which astrophysical objects lose any sensitivity as Dark Matter probes. For instance, Jupiters at the Galactic Center have a Tcrit ranging from 700 K (for a 3MJ Jupiter) to 950 K (for 14MJ ).

Modeling Dark Matter Processes

The effectiveness of any given astrophysical object as a Dark Matter probe is controlled by the interplay between capture, evaporation, and annihilation processes. The differential equation governing the total number of DM particles NX in the object at time t is dNX/dt = C - ΓA(NX) - ENX. p. 3

Where the paper says it

The interplay between those will controll the effectiveness of any given astrophysical object as a Dark Matter probe. If we label C as the rate at which DM particles accumulate in the object through down-scattering, ΓA the rate at which they annihilate within the object, and E the per-particle rate at which they leave the object through up-scattering, then the differential equation governing the total number of DM particles NX in the object at time t is: dNX dt = C − ΓA(NX) − ENX.

The annihilation rate, ΓA(NX), is modeled using the “Co-SIMP” sub-GeV model where annihilation is given by DM+DM+SM→DM+SM. p. 3
Where the paper says it

1) The annihilation rate, ΓA(NX), is a model-dependent quantity. In this work, we primarly consider the “Co-SIMP” [41] sub-GeV model, where annihilation is given by: DM+DM+SM→ DM+SM.

Sensitivity Estimates and Critical Temperature

The authors produce sensitivity limits that account directly for evaporation and explicitly show how the evaporation mass approximation (∼ 10−2 GeV) used in [30] is an underestimate, finding it to be around ∼ 1 GeV for Jupiters and Brown Dwarfs at the Galactic Center. The constraint of Tcrit > Tmin restricts us to exoplanets with mass M ≳ 3MJ for Jupiters at the galactic center. p. 0

Where the paper says it

As a consequence of this region, which for many objects falls within the parameter space not excluded by direct detection experiments, we point out the existence of a DM parameter dependent critical temperature (Tcrit), above which astrophysical objects lose any sensitivity as Dark Matter probes. For instance, Jupiters at the Galactic Center have a Tcrit ranging from 700 K (for a 3MJ Jupiter) to 950 K (for 14MJ ).

Density Profiles and Limiting Regimes

The DM distribution profile in the Local Thermal Equilibrium (LTE) limit exhibits a floating profile when the DM mass falls below a point where p ≡ EeTc + 3/2 − α0 becomes negative, leading to higher densities toward the edge of the object. The true DM profile is approximated by combining the LTE and isothermal profiles via Eq. p. 9

Where the paper says it

Typically, one finds themselves in a regime of either very high or very low interaction and in these cases, computing the evaporation rate is relatively simple, since finding the profile is straightforward. However, when straddling the border between isothermal and LTE, some – 9 –

2.24, which shows that for a 1MJ Jupiter at mX = 0. p. 0
Where the paper says it

As a consequence of this region, which for many objects falls within the parameter space not excluded by direct detection experiments, we point out the existence of a DM parameter dependent critical temperature (Tcrit), above which astrophysical objects lose any sensitivity as Dark Matter probes. For instance, Jupiters at the Galactic Center have a Tcrit ranging from 700 K (for a 3MJ Jupiter) to 950 K (for 14MJ ).

034 GeV, the red line converges on the green and blue lines respectively. p. 7
Where the paper says it

When α ≤ 1, we see the erasure of Region III as seen in the central and right panels. In the right panel, when α < 1, we see an interesting phenomenon occur: the boundary between Region I (blue dashed line) and Region II (red dashed line) become disassociated.

Green — the paper says it, and the page is printed. Red — no passage carries it, so treat that sentence as unverified. The same check runs on your own text: check a summary against its source, $5.

Improvements for AI systems

  1. Improved DM probe sensitivity calculation: The improved system can now calculate a Dark Matter parameter dependent critical temperature Tc, which is essential for determining if an astrophysical object loses any sensitivity as Dark Matter probes above a certain temperature. This allows for setting practical lower bounds on the mass of a Jupiter such that it can be considered a useful DM probe, based on the condition Tcrit > Tmin.

  2. Evaporation rate modeling: The system can now explicitly compute the evaporation rate for Jupiters and Brown Dwarfs using polytropic models and account for the exponential tail in calculations, leading to more accurate estimates of sensitivity limits compared to previous approximations like those in [30].

  3. Capture rate region identification: The improved AI can accurately map the dark matter capture rates across four distinct regions in the sigma - mX parameter space, identifying where capture saturates at its geometric limit and where approximations break down, as shown by Fig 1.

  4. Density profile approximation: For high-mass DM models, the system can analytically compute the DM distribution integrals for both local thermal equilibrium and isothermal limits using Taylor expansions of the Lane-Emden function, providing useful closed form solutions to avoid difficult numerical integration for cored profiles.

  5. Temperature constraint application: The system can apply the derived critical temperature Tcrit to observed temperatures (Tobs) from missions like JWST to determine if the object is constrained by DM heating, or if external heat sources must be considered, allowing for a more complete interpretation of observational data.

Abstract

In this work we demonstrate that Dark Matter (DM) evaporation severely hinders the effectiveness of exoplanets and Brown Dwarfs as sub-GeV DM probes. Moreover, we find useful analytic closed form approximations for DM capture rates for arbitrary astrophysical objects, valid in four disticnt regions in the σ-m X parameter space. As expected, in one of those regions the Dark Matter capture saturates to its geometric limit, i.e. the entire flux crossing an object. As a consequence of this region, which for many objects falls within the parameter space not excluded by direct detection experiments, we point out the existence of a DM parameter dependent critical temperature (T crit), above which astrophysical objects lose any sensitivity as Dark Matter probes. For instance, Jupiters at the Galactic Center have a T crit ranging from 700 K (for a 3 M J Jupiter) to 950 K (for 14 M J). This limitation is rarely (if ever) considered in the previous literature of indirect Dark Matter detection based on observable signatures of captured Dark Matter inside celestial bodies.

Sources

Related papers