On the zeros of odd weight Eisenstein series

arXiv:2312.12163 · math.NT · Submitted 2023-12-19 · Read on arXiv

Listen

Radio episode about this paper

Transcript

Introduction to the show: ident: Mathematics. The day in mathematics: new theorems, new proofs, and what they open.

Ada: We're looking at the paper: "On the zeros of odd weight Eisenstein series".

Emmy: Here's the gist of the paper. On the zeros of odd weight Eisenstein series counts the number of zeros of holomorphic odd weight Eisenstein series in all SL2(Z)-translates of the standard fundamental domain The main idea is to determine the distribution of zeros for these non-(quasi)modular odd weight Eisenstein series by extending ideas from Rankin and Swinnerton-Dyer Definition and Context of Odd Weight Eisenstein Series The paper introduces the odd weight Eisenstein series as holomorphic quantum modular forms, a weaker notion defined by Zagier The definition via the q-expansion is given as Ek(τ):= 1 + ck X n≥1 σk−1(n) q n (k ≥ 2, q = e 2πiτ) This definition is non-trivial for odd k, contrasting with even weight series Counting Zeros in the Standard Fundamental Domain The weighted number of zeros Nλ(Ek) for odd k ≥ 3 and all λ ∈ P1(Q) is bounded by Nλ(Ek) − k/12 ≤ 3/4 For the standard fundamental domain (λ = ∞), this result is proven by writing Ek(τ) = 1 + 1 τ k + 1 (τ + 1)k + 1 (τ − 1)k + Rk(τ) Distribution of Zeros for Specific Parameters The distribution of zeros is summarized in Table 1, which provides the value of Nλ(Ek) depending on k (mod 12) and λ Theorem 1.4 states that for Gk (related to Ek), the weighted number of zeros in F equals N∞(Gk) = k/6 if k ≡ 3, 5, 11 mod 12 and k/6 if k ≡ 1, 7, 9 mod 12 Generalization to SL2(Z)-Translates The results are extended to all Γ-translates of the standard fundamental domain by explicitly computing VOAS(Ekγ) for S ∈ L, C, R as a function of λ = γ−1(∞) Proposition 3.5 provides the result N0(Ek) = (⌊ k/12⌋ if k ≡ 1, 7, 9 mod 12 or ⌈ k/12⌉ if k ≡ 3, 5, or 11 mod 12) Bounds on Zero Locations For odd k ≥ 3 and all λ ∈ P1(Q) except for special cases, the zeros z of Ek in F satisfy 1 < z < 4/k Furthermore, for even k, Gk has exactly the same number of zeros in γF as Ek unless λ(γ) ∈ Σ = −∞, ±1, ∞ The zeros of Gk (k odd) are located on the vertical boundaries ± 1/2 + it: t ≥ 1/2√3 or at i∞ Special Cases and Boundary Conditions The paper analyzes specific cases for λ, including the case λ > 0 (Proposition 3.3), where Nλ(Ek) = Round k/12 = Nλ(Gk) The case λ = 0 yields N0(Ek) based on k mod 12 The case 0 1 Table 2 summarizes the (special) values of Nλ(Gk) for boundary cases References

Dim19: Vesselin Dimitrov, A proof of the Schinzel–Zassenhaus conjecture on polynomials.

Ada: ArXiv e-prints: 1912.12545, 27 pp., 2019

EBS10: Abdelkrim El Basraoui and Abdellah Sebbar, Zeros of the Eisenstein series E2.

Emmy: Proc.

Ada: Amer.

Title and authors: Ada: Now, let's talk about what the paper actually claims regarding the distribution of these zeros. The paper summarizes how they found these counts for all odd k and all values of lambda in P one Q.

Emmy: They present a summary table that shows exactly how the weighted number of zeros, which they call N lambda E k, depends on the value of k modulo twelve and also on the magnitude of lambda.

Kolya: This is pretty concrete information because it gives us specific numbers for different cases, like when k is congruent to three, five, or eleven modulo twelve.

Ada: It's interesting because they provide these piecewise constant values for N lambda E k which helps pinpoint the exact distribution of zeros in the standard fundamental domain F.

Emmy: They also state a theorem that for odd k greater than or equal to three, all zeros z of Ek in F have their magnitude strictly between one and four divided by k.

Kolya: That bound, one less than four over k, is a strong statement because it tells us how the zeros behave as k gets larger.

The paper's summary: Ada: Moving on to the main results, the paper extends these findings from just the standard fundamental domain F to all of SL2(Z) translates of it.

Emmy: They explicitly compute what they call VOAS E k by a gamma translate, which is essentially calculating the number of zeros in that translated domain as a function of lambda, where lambda is related to the translation parameter gamma.

Kolya: The paper then states Proposition three point five, which gives us the exact formula for N zero E k when you consider all those translations by saying N zero E k equals the ceiling of k over twelve if k is congruent to three, five, or eleven modulo twelve.

Ada: That's a really useful result because it moves beyond just one specific domain and gives us a general rule for counting zeros under any SL2(Z) translation.

Emmy: The structure behind this computation suggests that the distribution of zeros for G k, which is related to Ek, follows the same pattern as Ek itself when lambda is not in a special set.

Kolya: So, if you pick a translation parameter lambda that isn't one of those specific values they list, you can predict the zero count for G k just by looking at k modulo twelve.

The paper's improvements: Ada: The paper also points out some ways they’ve improved previous work or suggested future directions for this line of research.

Emmy: One significant improvement is that the authors show how their method works for G k, which is proportional to Ek up to a multiplicative constant, and they relate its zero distribution directly back to Ek.

Kolya: The paper suggests that because the even zeta values are given by Bk two k times minus two pi i k times (k minus one) factorial, the formula for odd zeta values is different and expected to be algebraically independent of each other and pi.

Ada: That's a big implication because it means we can't just use the known relations for even weights to predict what happens with odd weights.

Emmy: They also look at special cases where lambda is greater than zero, where they show that N lambda E k equals the round of k over twelve, which matches the count for G k in that case.

Kolya: And they also have these bounds on the location of zeros, stating that for odd k greater than or equal to three and all lambda except for some special cases, the zeros z satisfy one less than four over k.

Conclusion: Ada: So to wrap up, the paper "On the zeros of odd weight Eisenstein series" gives us a very systematic way to count the zeros of these functions across all SL2(Z) translates.

Emmy: We've seen that they use their intrinsic definition and then extend those counting rules to cover all possible translations by explicitly computing VOAS E k for every relevant lambda.

Kolya: What this really means for us is that we can predict the distribution of these zeros quite accurately, especially when k is odd and you are looking at the counts in a translated domain F.

Ada: It gives us a clear picture of where those zeros live, showing them to be constrained within one less than four over k as k gets bigger.

Emmy: And they’ve given us the precise counting formulas for even k on vertical boundaries, which is useful for understanding the structure of these functions geometrically.

Kolya: For me, it's about taking a complex problem involving modular forms and turning it into a series of manageable counting problems based on k modulo twelve.

Ada: It’s a lot to digest, but this work gives us the tools to study these odd weight Eisenstein series much more thoroughly.

Jan-Willem van Ittersum, Berend Ringeling

Max-Planck-Institut für Mathematik · University of Cologne · Radboud University

math.NT

Submitted: 2023-12-19

Updated: 2023-12-19

Comments: 22 pages, 2 figures, 2 tables

Journal ref: Mathematika 71 (2025), no. 1

DOI: 10.1112/mtk.70004

License: http://arxiv.org/licenses/nonexclusive-distrib/1.0/

Importance score: 90/100

The gist: On the zeros of odd weight Eisenstein series counts the number of zeros of holomorphic odd weight Eisenstein series in all SL2(Z)-translates of the standard fundamental domain The main idea is to…

Key concepts

Odd Weight Eisenstein Series
These are holomorphic quantum modular forms defined by a specific q-expansion. They are non-trivial when the weight k is odd, unlike even weight series. They serve as the central objects of study for their zero distribution properties.
Weighted Number of Zeros Nλ(Ek)
This measures the number of zeros of an Eisenstein series Ek within a specific region defined by a parameter lambda. The paper provides exact formulas and bounds for this count, showing how it depends on the weight k modulo 12 and the value of lambda.
SL2(Z)-Translates
This refers to shifting the standard fundamental domain using elements from the modular group SL2(Z). The study extends zero counting results to all these translated regions, providing a comprehensive view of where zeros appear across different parts of the modular space.

Terminology

Summary

On the zeros of odd weight Eisenstein series counts the number of zeros of holomorphic odd weight Eisenstein series in all SL2(Z)-translates of the standard fundamental domain

The main idea is to determine the distribution of zeros for these non-(quasi)modular odd weight Eisenstein series by extending ideas from Rankin and Swinnerton-Dyer

Definition and Context of Odd Weight Eisenstein Series

The paper introduces the odd weight Eisenstein series as holomorphic quantum modular forms, a weaker notion defined by Zagier The definition via the q-expansion is given as Ek(τ):= 1 + ck X n≥1 σk−1(n) q n (k ≥ 2, q = e 2πiτ) This definition is non-trivial for odd k, contrasting with even weight series

Counting Zeros in the Standard Fundamental Domain

The weighted number of zeros Nλ(Ek) for odd k ≥ 3 and all λ ∈ P1(Q) is bounded by Nλ(Ek) − k/12 ≤ 3/4 For the standard fundamental domain (λ = ∞), this result is proven by writing Ek(τ) = 1 + 1 τ k + 1 (τ + 1)k + 1 (τ − 1)k + Rk(τ)

Distribution of Zeros for Specific Parameters

The distribution of zeros is summarized in Table 1, which provides the value of Nλ(Ek) depending on k (mod 12) and λ Theorem 1.4 states that for Gk (related to Ek), the weighted number of zeros in F equals N∞(Gk) = k/6 if k ≡ 3, 5, 11 mod 12 and k/6 if k ≡ 1, 7, 9 mod 12

Generalization to SL2(Z)-Translates

The results are extended to all Γ-translates of the standard fundamental domain by explicitly computing VOAS(Ekγ) for S ∈ L, C, R as a function of λ = γ−1(∞) Proposition 3.5 provides the result N0(Ek) = (⌊ k/12⌋ if k ≡ 1, 7, 9 mod 12 or ⌈ k/12⌉ if k ≡ 3, 5, or 11 mod 12)

Bounds on Zero Locations

For odd k ≥ 3 and all λ ∈ P1(Q) except for special cases, the zeros z of Ek in F satisfy 1 < z < 4/k Furthermore, for even k, Gk has exactly the same number of zeros in γF as Ek unless λ(γ) ∈ Σ = −∞, ±1, ∞ The zeros of Gk (k odd) are located on the vertical boundaries ± 1/2 + it: t ≥ 1/2√3 or at i∞

Special Cases and Boundary Conditions

The paper analyzes specific cases for λ, including the case λ > 0 (Proposition 3.3), where Nλ(Ek) = Round k/12 = Nλ(Gk) The case λ = 0 yields N0(Ek) based on k mod 12 The case 0 1 Table 2 summarizes the (special) values of Nλ(Gk) for boundary cases

References

[Dim19] Vesselin Dimitrov, A proof of the Schinzel–Zassenhaus conjecture on polynomials. ArXiv e-prints: 1912. p. 012545, 27 pp., 2019

[EBS10] Abdelkrim El Basraoui and Abdellah Sebbar, Zeros of the Eisenstein series E2. Proc. Amer. Math. Soc. 138(7): 2289–2299, 2010

[GKZ06] Herbert Gangl, Masanobu Kaneko, and Don Zagier, Double zeta values and modular forms. In Automorphic forms and zeta functions: 71–106. p. 2 World Sci. Publ., Hackensack, NJ, 2006

[Gek01] Ernst-Ulrich Gekeler, Some observations on the arithmetic of Eisenstein series for the modular group SL(2, Z). Arch. Math. 77: 5–21, 2001

[GO22] Sanoli Gun and Joseph Oesterl´e, Critical points of Eisenstein series. Mathematika 68(1): 259–298, 2022

[IJT14] Ozlem Imamoglu, Jonas Jermann, and Arp´ad T´oth, ´ Estimates on the zeros of E2. Abh. Math. Semin. Univ. Hambg. 84(1): 123–138, 2014

[IR22] Jan-Willem van Ittersum and Berend Ringeling, Critical points of modular forms. ArXiv e-prints: 2204. p. 000432, 29 pp., 2022

[Noz08] H. Nozaki, A separation property of the zeros of Eisenstein series for SL(2, Z). p. 4 Bull. Lond. Math. Soc. 40(1): 26–36, 2008

[Ran82] Robert A. Rankin, The zeros of certain Poincar´e series. p. 1 Compositio Math. p. 0 46(3), 255–272, 1982

[RVY17] Sarah Reitzes, Polina Vulakh and Matthew P. Young, Zeros of certain combinations of Eisenstein series. p. 1 Mathematika 63 (2): 666–695, 2017

[Whe23] Campbell Wheeler, Modular q–difference equations and quantum invariants of hyperbolic three–manifolds.

Green — the paper says it, and the page is printed. Red — no passage carries it, so treat that sentence as unverified. The same check runs on your own text: check a summary against its source, $5.

Improvements for AI systems

  1. Improved zero counting for odd weight Eisenstein series: The system can now compute Nlambda(Ek) exactly for all odd k >= 3 and all lambda in P1(Q) by using the piecewise constant values given in Table 1, which is a significant advancement over previous approximations.

  2. Enhanced localization of zeros: The AI can determine the exact location of zeros z of Ek in F for odd k >= 3 to satisfy Theorem 1.2, specifically showing that all zeros satisfy 1 < |z| < C1/k as k tends to infinity.

  3. Precise zero distribution prediction: The system can predict the distribution of zeros for Gk (where Gk is proportional to Ek up to a multiplicative constant) in any SL2(Z) translate γF, as Theorem 1.3 states Nlambda(Gk) = Nlambda(Ek) for lambda not in the special set.

  4. Detailed analysis of zero location based on weight: The system can identify that for odd k >= 3, all zeros of Ek lie arbitrarily close to the unit circle as k tends to infinity, providing a strong asymptotic understanding of their distribution.

  5. Zero counting for Gk on vertical boundaries: The AI can calculate the weighted number of zeros Ninf(Gk) exactly based on k mod 12 by using Theorem 1.4, which states Ninf(Gk) = k over 6 if k is congruent to 3, 5, or 11 mod 12, and k over (6-3) if k is congruent to 1, 7, or 9 mod 12.

  6. Zero location on vertical boundaries for Gk: The system can predict that all zeros of Gk (for odd k >= 3) are located on the vertical boundaries at ±1/2 + it where t >= sqrt(3)/2, which provides a specific geometric constraint for zero searching.

Sources

Related papers