A calculation method to estimate thermal conductivity of high entropy ceramic for thermal barrier coatings
Listen
Radio episode about this paper
Transcript
Introduction to the show: ident: Condensed Matter. The day in condensed matter: materials, phases and the measurements under them.
Kai: I'm Kai.
Mira: And I'm Mira, here with Lev.
Kai: We're looking at the paper: "A calculation method to estimate thermal conductivity of high entropy ceramic for thermal barrier coatings".
Mira: Here's the gist of the paper. High entropy ceramics are highly promising as next generation thermal barrier coatings due to their unique disorder structure, which imparts ultra-low thermal conductivity and good high temperature stability In this study, we propose a calculation method based on the supercell phonon unfolding (SPU) technique to predict the thermal conductivity of high entropy ceramics, specially focusing on rocksalt oxides The obtained results demonstrate a strong agreement between the predicted thermal conductivities and the experimental measurements, validating the feasibility of our calculation method The methodology involves constructing supercell structures for high entropy rocksalt oxides and utilizing the supercell phonon unfolding (SPU) method to calculate the phonon dispersion spectra Supercell structures optimization and relative atomic force constants were calculated by DFT (density functional theory), performed using Vienna ab initio simulation package (VASP) The supercell construction was realized by SQS (special quasi-random supercells) method through Python package ICET For 5-dopant oxide (MgxNixCuxCoxZnx)O, primitive cell was used to extend to its 5×5×5 supercell (250 atoms) while conventional cell was used to extend to its 3×3×3 supercell (216 atoms) for other 6-dopant oxides (MgxNixCuxCoxZnxXx)O, primitive cell was used Phonon properties were evaluated using PHONOPY package on 20 × 20 × 20 q grid for all the high entropy oxide samples Analysis of Structure and Distortion The study analyzed the atomic relaxation and lattice distortion effects in 5-dopants and 6-dopants rocksalt structures during the process The space group symbol of rocksalt oxide structure is Fm3m, in which oxygen atom occupies the 4b position while metal atom takes the 4a position It’s evident that the displacements distribution of J14 differs from other compositions The magnitude of displacement for oxygen atoms is nearly twice as large as that for the other metal elements Thermal Conductivity Prediction Model A thermal conductivity prediction indicator Λ is built based on the Boltzmann equation with relaxation time approximation, where phonon linewidth is inversely proportional to phonon lifetime The indicator Λ can be written as: lambda = A N V0 ∑ Cvlambda·vlambda2 x lwlambda / λ The linewidth curves presented in Fig.
Kai: 6 represent the averaged results of these five repetitions, thereby eliminating calculation randomness Disorder Mechanism Insights The research indicates that the disorder-phonon scattering mechanism in high entropy system arises from both force and mass disorder The only notable difference lies in the sixth dopant element, which implies that the mass differences among the compositions are not prominent The broadening of stress force distribution should be responsible for the linewidths change of acoustic transverse branch in Fig 6, from flat curve of J14 to gradually increasing curve of other 6-dopant oxides around the gamma point The unfolded phonon spectra calculations assume that the atoms remain at their ideal positions while considering disordered force constants of relaxed lattice structure We must admit that there are still certain unknown factors that require further investigation to fully understand the mechanism of thermal conduction in high entropy ceramics The phonon-disorder scattering mechanism and the quantification of mass and force disorder are areas that warrant continued study Page 1 --- A calculation method to estimate thermal conductivity of high entropy ceramic for thermal barrier coatings Yuxuan Wanga, Guoqiang Lana, Jun Songa, a Department of Mining and Materials Engineering, McGill, University, Montreal, Quebec, H3A 0C5, Canada⁎ Corresponding author.
Mira: E-mail address: jun.song2@mcgill.ca (J.
Kai: Song).
Title and authors: Kai: So we're diving into the specifics now about this paper, "A calculation method to estimate thermal conductivity of high entropy ceramic for thermal barrier coatings." We just covered the basic premise that these materials are good for TBCs because they have low thermal conductivity and high stability.
Mira: This section really lays out exactly what the paper does by summarizing its approach, which is using supercell phonon unfolding to get those predictions. It shows how they set up their supercells and then use a specific calculation indicator, lambda, based on the Boltzmann equation with relaxation time approximation to predict thermal conductivity.
Lev: I'm curious about how they handle the complexity of high entropy materials when setting up these structures; that’s where my experience with real hardware comes in—how much overhead is involved in getting those initial supercells right?
Kai: They describe optimizing these supercell structures using density functional theory and then using special quasi-random supercells through a Python package called ICET for the construction. They also used different cell sizes based on whether they were looking at five or six dopant oxides.
Mira: And they didn't just stop there, they analyzed the atomic relaxation and lattice distortion effects in both five-dopants and six-dopants rocksalt structures, specifically looking at how the displacement distribution of J14 differs from other compositions.
Lev: That lattice distortion analysis is critical because it tells us about the internal forces involved; if those displacements are large, it means there's a big force component at play during scattering.
The paper's summary: Kai: To summarize what they actually found in the main body of this work, the core finding is that the disorder-phonon scattering mechanism in these high entropy systems comes from both force and mass disorder.
Mira: They point out that for six dopants, the only notable difference among compositions is the sixth dopant element itself, suggesting that mass differences between those specific compositions aren't super prominent.
Lev: So they’re saying we should focus more on the force disorder because the mass differences are less significant across those samples. That narrows down where we need to concentrate our theoretical effort if we want to model this accurately.
Kai: And they specifically mention that the broadening of stress force distribution is what should be responsible for the linewidth changes you see in the acoustic transverse branch of Fig six shifting from a flat curve for J14 to a gradually increasing curve for other six-dopant oxides around the gamma point.
Mira: That’s a key link they draw between the force disorder and the phonon linewidth behavior, which directly feeds into their prediction model.
The paper's improvements: Lev: Now let's talk about what they suggest as improvements to this calculation method because that’s where we see if it’s practical for real-world use.
Kai: They introduce a thermal conductivity prediction indicator, lambda, which is built based on the Boltzmann equation with relaxation time approximation, where the phonon linewidth is inversely proportional to the phonon lifetime.
Mira: That indicator lambda can be written as A N V0 times Cv times nu squared times lw over lambda where lw is the phonon linewidth. This model allows them to predict thermal conductivity by extracting this linewidth information from the unfolded phonon spectra.
Lev: It seems they are essentially creating a way to use the spectral width directly as a proxy for how long those phonons live, which is helpful when you can't easily measure lifetimes experimentally in these complex systems.
Kai: They also mention that this indicator lambda is calculated by taking the averaged results of five repetitions, which helps eliminate calculation randomness from the process.
Conclusion: Mira: So wrapping up this paper on "A calculation method to estimate thermal conductivity of high entropy ceramic for thermal barrier coatings," it confirms that their SPU method provides a strong agreement between their predicted thermal conductivities and the experimental measurements they have.
Lev: But we have to keep an eye on the limitations they mention; they state that the unfolded phonon spectra calculations assume that the atoms remain at their ideal positions while considering only disordered force constants of relaxed lattice structure.
Kai: That means there are still certain unknown factors out there, and they flag that as something requiring further investigation to fully understand how thermal conduction happens in high entropy ceramics.
Mira: And they specifically call out the phonon-disorder scattering mechanism and the quantification of mass and force disorder as areas that definitely warrant continued study.
Lev: For me, from a hardware standpoint, it means we need to figure out how much mass disorder versus force disorder actually impacts the measured thermal conductivity in real samples before we can trust this model fully.
Kai: So, in short, they've validated their prediction approach for these rocksalt oxides using SPU and have given us a clear path forward for better modeling of thermal barrier coatings.
Yuxuan Wanga, Guoqiang Lana, Jun Songa
Department of Mining and Materials Engineering, McGill University
cond-mat.mtrl-sci
Submitted: 2023-11-14
Updated: 2023-11-14
Comments: 19 page, 8 figures
Journal ref: Wang Y, Lan G, Song J. Quantitative thermal conductivity prediction based on supercell phonon-unfolding for high-entropy ceramic oxides[J]. Journal of Materials Science & Technology, 2025
DOI: 10.1016/j.jmst.2025.08.021
License: http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-nd/4.0/
Importance score: 80/100
The gist: High entropy ceramics are highly promising as next generation thermal barrier coatings due to their unique disorder structure…
Key concepts
- High Entropy Ceramics
- These ceramics have a unique disordered structure due to multiple dopants. This disorder is key because it creates ultra-low thermal conductivity and provides excellent stability at high temperatures, making them ideal for thermal barrier coatings.
- Supercell Phonon Unfolding (SPU)
- SPU is a calculation technique that maps the phonon dispersion spectra from a large supercell structure back to the primitive cell of the material. This allows researchers to precisely analyze how disorder affects vibrational properties, providing accurate data for thermal conductivity prediction.
- Boltzmann Equation with Relaxation Time Approximation
- This equation is used to calculate thermal conductivity by relating it to phonon lifetime. The paper uses the SPU linewidths as an indicator of phonon lifetime, allowing them to construct a specific model ($\Lambda$) to estimate the material's thermal conductivity.
Terminology
Summary
High entropy ceramics are highly promising as next generation thermal barrier coatings due to their unique disorder structure, which imparts ultra-low thermal conductivity and good high temperature stability In this study, we propose a calculation method based on the supercell phonon unfolding (SPU) technique to predict the thermal conductivity of high entropy ceramics, specially focusing on rocksalt oxides The obtained results demonstrate a strong agreement between the predicted thermal conductivities and the experimental measurements, validating the feasibility of our calculation method
Methodology for Calculation
The methodology involves constructing supercell structures for high entropy rocksalt oxides and utilizing the supercell phonon unfolding (SPU) method to calculate the phonon dispersion spectra
** Supercell structures optimization and relative atomic force constants were calculated by DFT (density functional theory), performed using Vienna ab initio simulation package (VASP) **
** The supercell construction was realized by SQS (special quasi-random supercells) method through Python package ICET **
** For 5-dopant oxide (MgxNixCuxCoxZnx)O, primitive cell was used to extend to its 5×5×5 supercell (250 atoms) while conventional cell was used to extend to its 3×3×3 supercell (216 atoms) for other 6-dopant oxides (MgxNixCuxCoxZnxXx)O, primitive cell was used **
** Phonon properties were evaluated using PHONOPY package on 20 × 20 × 20 q grid for all the high entropy oxide samples **
Analysis of Structure and Distortion
The study analyzed the atomic relaxation and lattice distortion effects in 5-dopants and 6-dopants rocksalt structures during the process
** The space group symbol of rocksalt oxide structure is Fm3m, in which oxygen atom occupies the 4b position while metal atom takes the 4a position **
** It’s evident that the displacements distribution of J14 differs from other compositions **
** The magnitude of displacement for oxygen atoms is nearly twice as large as that for the other metal elements **
Thermal Conductivity Prediction Model
A thermal conductivity prediction indicator Λ is built based on the Boltzmann equation with relaxation time approximation, where phonon linewidth is inversely proportional to phonon lifetime
** The indicator Λ can be written as: lambda = A N V0 ∑ Cvlambda·vlambda2 x lwlambda / λ **
** The linewidth curves presented in Fig. 6 represent the averaged results of these five repetitions, thereby eliminating calculation randomness **
Disorder Mechanism Insights
The research indicates that the disorder-phonon scattering mechanism in high entropy system arises from both force and mass disorder
** The only notable difference lies in the sixth dopant element, which implies that the mass differences among the compositions are not prominent **
** The broadening of stress force distribution should be responsible for the linewidths change of acoustic transverse branch in Fig 6, from flat curve of J14 to gradually increasing curve of other 6-dopant oxides around the gamma point **
Conclusion and Limitations
The unfolded phonon spectra calculations assume that the atoms remain at their ideal positions while considering disordered force constants of relaxed lattice structure
** We must admit that there are still certain unknown factors that require further investigation to fully understand the mechanism of thermal conduction in high entropy ceramics **
** The phonon-disorder scattering mechanism and the quantification of mass and force disorder are areas that warrant continued study **
--- Page 1 ---
A calculation method to estimate thermal conductivity of high entropy ceramic for thermal barrier coatings Yuxuan Wanga, Guoqiang Lana, Jun Songa, a Department of Mining and Materials Engineering, McGill, University, Montreal, Quebec, H3A 0C5, Canada⁎ Corresponding author. E-mail address: jun. p. 0 A calculation method to estimate thermal
conductivity of high entropy ceramic for
thermal barrier coatings
Yuxuan Wanga
, Guoqiang Lana
, Jun Songa,*
a Department of Mining and Materials Engineering, McGill, University, Montreal, Quebec, H3A 0C5, Canada
⁎ Corresponding author. E-mail address: jun. E-mail address: jun. song2@mcgill.Where the paper says it
Where the paper says it
--- Page 2 ---
Thermal barrier coating materials have been extensively used in fields of aerospace and power industry[1-6] Thermal barrier coating (TBCs) generally refers to the outermost ceramic isolation layer, and two significant performance index of which are low thermal conductivity and high temperature phase stability[3, 7, 8] Low thermal conductivity ensures a significant temperature drop from the coating surface to the metal component, while high temperature thermal stability guarantees the integrity of the coating in a high temperature environment Currently most-used commercial TBC materials is 7 8 wt% Y2O3 stabilized zirconia (7-8YSZ) However, when temperature keeps higher than 1200 °C, the t’-tetragonal phase will transform to another tetragonal phase (t) and/or a cubic phase (c) and then to monoclinic (m) phase [9, 10] This phase transition compromises the integrity of the coating To address this issue and develop the next generation TBC materials, extensive researches have been conducted on complex oxides such as pyrochlore oxides [11-18] and silicate oxides[19-22] And recently, a new class of complex oxides - high entropy oxides have garnered considerable attention
--- Page 3 ---
The development of high-performance computer cluster makes computational materials screening possible, greatly simplifying the tedious experimental process However, the conventional calculational model employed for predicting thermal conductivity encounters limitation when applied to high entropy materials On one hand, strictly, high entropy oxides lack crystallographic symmetry, which means no primitive cell can be identified for subsequent analysis On the other hand, for general ceramic materials, thermal conductivity mainly come from phonon-phonon interaction, which can be evaluated by solving the Boltzmann Transport Equation (BTE)[34] But for high entropy oxide, phonons interaction will be complicatedly influenced by mass disorder and force disorder To address the crystallographic problem, although does not follow strict symmetry, long-term order can still be detected experimentally in high entropy materials It means if ignore the force and mass differences and lattice distortion on dopants position, minimal periodic unit can be defined Therefore, some mean-field theories, like Virtual Crystal Approximation (VCA) [35] and (coherent potential approximation) CPA[36, 37] are proposed to deal with the mass and force disorder However, these approaches neglect the local differences of atomic interaction
--- Page 4 ---
More recently, supercell phonon unfolding (SPU)[38, 39] method has emerged as a promising alternative This method considers the interaction from every individual atomic pairs and reflect it on phonon dispersion spectra, which makes it more precise for describing the disordered system It maps the phonon dispersion of supercell to that of primitive cell, at the same time keeping all the information, and thus make it easier to compare the result with that of similar primitive structure Moreover, several studies have shown that the phonon dispersion spectra offer an accurate portrayal of vibrational physics, with the linewidth of the spectra inversely proportional to the phonon lifetime[37] This finding afford an opportunity to construct thermal conductivity model specially tailored for high entropy ceramic materials This study aims to construct the supercell structure for high entropy rocksalt oxides and utilized the supercell phonon unfolding (SPU) method to calculate the phonon dispersion spectra And based on these calculation, a prediction model for thermal conductivity is developed Additionally, the atomic relaxation and lattice distortion of these six high entropy rocksalt oxides are thoroughly investigated and analyzed in this study
--- Page 5 ---
Supercell structures optimization and relative atomic force constants were calculated by DFT (density functional theory), performed using Vienna ab initio simulation package (VASP) For pseudopotential treatment, Perdew-Burke- Ernzerhof (PBE) GGA approach based on plane-wave base sets was adopted The supercell construction was realized by SQS (special quasi-random supercells) method through Python package ICET Only the positions of metal atoms were randomly replaced by different equiatomic dopants while keeping unchanged of oxygen positions For 5-dopant oxide (MgxNixCuxCoxZnx)O (J14, x = 1/5), primitive cell was used to extend to its 5×5×5 supercell (250 atoms) while conventional cell was used to extend to its 3×3×3 supercell (216 atoms) for other 6-dopant oxides (MgxNixCuxCoxZnxXx)O (J30, J31, J34, J35, J36 for X = Sc, Sb, Sn, Cr, Ge and x = 1/6) to ensure the number of every element to be integers For every composition, 5 random structures were created for repeated trials And for structure optimization cell shape and atomic positions were firstly fixed and the lattice constants with lowest energy were calculated And then lattice constants were fixed to relax the atom positions Gamma-centered k-mesh of 1 × 1 × 1 for Brillouin-zone integrations and cutoff energy of 520 eV for the plane-wave-basis were used in DFT calculation with convergence criteria for energy on each ion set as 5 × 10-8 eV The realspace force constants were calculated with finite displacement method using 1 × 1 × 1 supercell And phonon properties were evaluated using PHONOPY package on 20 × 20 × 20 q grid for all the high entropy oxide samples
--- Page 6 ---
Supercell phonon-unfolding method stems from a kind of band-unfolding treatment dealing with electron and phonons in random alloying system By unfolding the band of large random alloy supercell onto that of small primitive-cell periodic basis, an effective band spectra can be obtained In this paper, we used the unfolding program upho written by Ikeda etc By unfolding the spectral function is defined as: A(k k, ω) = ∑ [P̂kk̃(K,J)] l2 J δ[ω − ω(K,J)], where kk is wave vector of primitive cell while K is from supercell, J is band index and δ means delta function In this expression, P̂kk represents projection operator at k point in the primitive Brillouin zone, and ṽ(K,J) denotes the eigenvectors of dynamical matrix of the supercell for wave vector K Delta function δ were smeared by the Lorentzian functions with half width at half maximum (HWHM) of 0.05THz for spectra plotting And the linewidths of phonon band were defined as the full width at half maximum (FWHM) of unfolded spectra through Lorentzian function fitting Referring Boltzmann equation with a relaxation time approximation to describe thermal conductivity[44], we built a thermal conductivity prediction indicator Λ of high entropy ceramics Consider that phonon linewidth is inversely proportional to phonon lifetime, indicator Λ can be written as: lambda = A N V0 ∑ Cvlambda·vlambda2 x lwlambda / λ where A is adjustment parameter, V0 is volume of primitive cell, N is number of wave vector, Cv is heat capacity, v is phonon velocity, and lw is phonon linewidth
--- Page 7 ---
According to Boltzmann equation with relaxation time approximation, thermal conductivity can be expressed as: κ = 1/N V0 ∑ Cvlambda · vlambda2 λ · τλ (1) where N is the number of wave vectors, V0 is the volume of primitive cell, Cv is heat capacity, v is the speed of sound (phonon group velocity), τ is phonon lifetime and λ is grid wave vector point To determine thermal conductivity Considering phonon lifetime in high entropy system can be regarded as inversely proportional to unfolded phonon spectra linewidth, our predicted thermal conductivity can be written as: lambda = A N V0 ∑ Cvlambda · vlambda2 x lwlambda / λ where lw is phonon spectra linewidth, A is adjustment factor to be fitted
--- Page 8 ---
Fig. 6 is the phonon spectra linewidths of high entropy rocksalt oxides, which were extracted by applying Lorentzian function fitter To ensure accuracy and account for randomness, five random supercells were constructed for each composition, followed by unfolding calculations The graph clearly shows that the linewidth of J14 has the lowest profile while J31 has the highest profile which means J14 has the longest phonon lifetime and J31 has the shortest A notable difference in linewidth trends can be observed between the optical and acoustic branches along the X direction By and large, the linewidths of optical branches display a negative relationship with the phonon dispersion curve whereas the linewidths of acoustic branches show a positive relationship with the phonon dispersion Considering the significant contribution of acoustic branches to thermal conductivity due to their larger phonon velocities and lifetimes, our primary focus should be on the linewidths of the acoustic branches
--- Page 9 ---
The prediction results along the reciprocal direction from Γ to X (corresponding to the [001] direction in real space) are presented in Fig. 7, alongside the experimental results for comparison After adjusting the scale of the y-coordinate, we observe a close match between our predicted values and the experimental results This alignment suggests the validity of our assumptions and the feasibility of our prediction approach However, for the J30 composition, a slight discrepancy can be observed between the experimental and predicted values This difference can be attributed to the formation of vacancies in the experimental samples The addition of the Sc element may result in a higher vacancy concentration compared to the other elements This vacancies disrupt the crystal's continuity, distort the lattice, and substantially reduce the thermal conductivity
--- Page 10 ---
Indeed, it is evident that the disorder-phonon scattering in our high entropy system arises from both force and mass disorder However, considering the compositional selection in our study, the only notable difference lies in the sixth dopant element, which implies that the mass differences among the compositions are not prominent Consequently, we can focus our investigation on the force disorder within the high entropy system Fig. 6 depicts the distribution of force constant Фxy for the first-nearest-neighbor (1NN) metal-oxygen pair Compared to Фxx distribution which is distributedly disorganized, the distribution of Фxy exhibits a more regular pattern that can be analyzed The FWHM of J14 is 0. p. 7 To deeply investigate the lattice distortion, we analyzed the 1st nearest neighbor (1NN) metaloxygen coordinating distance in [MO6] polyhedrons. 3 is the histogram of 1NN M-O distance
distribution.Where the paper says it
--- Page 11 ---
Figure 5 Unfolded phonon spectra of rocksalt high entropy oxides along X direction The blue dash lines represent the results of virtual crystal approximation (VCA) method Basically, the configuration of phonon unfolding spectra aligns well with the curves of VCA results For the upper longitudinal optical branches, the spectra center is slightly higher than that of VCA curve, which means that the VCA underestimates the optical curves But for acoustic branches, the results are opposite Both the longitudinal and transvers phonon spectra of all samples are slightly lower than that of VCA results Compared to VCA, unfolded phonon dispersion is a spectrum and it has different distribution at different wave vector And for phonon spectra of 5-dopant oxide J14, the spectra distribution is more compact and the intensity is concentrated in the red part However, for other 6-dopant samples, the phonon spectra are more widely distributed It’s rare to see the red part in optical phonon branches and only the front and middle part of acoustic branches show concentrated red area The value of spectra intensity come from the projection operator and have been normalized, which means that at any wavevector position, the integral of the spectra equals to the number of phonon branches And this spectra intensity can be regarded as the probability of phonon dispersion appearance And most importantly, its reported that these calculated phonon spectra can express the phonon scatteri…
Green — the paper says it, and the page is printed. Red — no passage carries it, so treat that sentence as unverified. The same check runs on your own text: check a summary against its source, $5.
Improvements for AI systems
-
Improved prediction of thermal conductivity for high entropy ceramics using a calculation method based on supercell phonon unfolding (SPU) to predict thermal conductivity of high entropy ceramics, specially focusing on rocksalt oxides structures. This improved system can accurately predict thermal conductivities by using the reciprocal value of SPU phonon spectra linewidth as an indicator of phonon lifetime.
-
Enhanced investigation into atomic relaxation and lattice distortion effects in 5-dopants and 6-dopants rocksalt structures during the process. The improved system can specifically analyze how the
substantial change of copper atom displacement distribution may be responsible for the abruptly reduction of thermal conductivity after the addition of the sixth dopant.
-
Development of a prediction model for thermal conductivity using Boltzmann equation with relaxation time approximation, expressed as Lambda = A / (N V0 sum Cv lambda · v squared x lw lambda), where lw is phonon spectra linewidth. This system can predict thermal conductivities by extracting the linewidth information from phonon spectra and constructing this specific prediction model.
Abstract
High entropy ceramics are highly promising as next generation thermal barrier coatings due to their unique disorder structure, which imparts ultra-low thermal conductivity and good high temperature stability. Unlike traditional ceramic materials, the thermal resistance in high entropy ceramics predominantly arises from phonon-disorder scattering rather than phonon-phonon interactions. In this study, we propose a calculation method based on the supercell phonon unfolding (SPU) technique to predict the thermal conductivity of high entropy ceramics, specially focusing on rocksalt oxides structures. Our prediction method relies on using the reciprocal value of SPU phonon spectra linewidth as an indicator of phonon lifetime. The obtained results demonstrate a strong agreement between the predicted thermal conductivities and the experimental measurements, validating the feasibility of our calculation method. Furthermore, we extensively investigate and discuss the atomic relaxation and lattice distortion effects in 5-dopants and 6-dopants rocksalt structures during the process.
Related papers
- Structural contribution to light-induced gap suppression in Ta 2 NiSe 5
- Anatomy of fast current-induced skyrmion motion in synthetic antiferromagnets
- Magnetic control of an exciton-polariton condensate in a van der Waals magnet
- High-pressure elastic properties of GeO2 polymorphs up to 120 GPa
- Decoupling Strain-Rate Sensitivity and Deformation Length Scale Effects in Neutron-Irradiated Tungsten: A Coupled Nano-Indentation, HR-EBSD and Crystal Plasticity Study
- Magnetism modulation in Co3Sn2S2 by current-assisted domain wall motion