A calculation method to estimate thermal conductivity of high entropy ceramic for thermal barrier coatings

summary

The gist

High entropy ceramics are highly promising as next generation thermal barrier coatings due to their unique disorder structure…

In short

This study developed a method using supercell phonon unfolding (SPU) to predict thermal conductivity in high entropy rocksalt oxides, which are promising for thermal barrier coatings. The method calculates phonon dispersion spectra from supercells and uses the resulting linewidths to build a prediction model based on the Boltzmann equation. Results show good agreement with experimental measurements, validating the approach.

Key concepts

High Entropy Ceramics
These ceramics have a unique disordered structure due to multiple dopants. This disorder is key because it creates ultra-low thermal conductivity and provides excellent stability at high temperatures, making them ideal for thermal barrier coatings.
Supercell Phonon Unfolding (SPU)
SPU is a calculation technique that maps the phonon dispersion spectra from a large supercell structure back to the primitive cell of the material. This allows researchers to precisely analyze how disorder affects vibrational properties, providing accurate data for thermal conductivity prediction.
Boltzmann Equation with Relaxation Time Approximation
This equation is used to calculate thermal conductivity by relating it to phonon lifetime. The paper uses the SPU linewidths as an indicator of phonon lifetime, allowing them to construct a specific model ($\Lambda$) to estimate the material's thermal conductivity.

Terminology used across episodes

This episode discusses

The paper

A calculation method to estimate thermal conductivity of high entropy ceramic for thermal barrier coatings · Read on arXiv

Yuxuan Wanga, Guoqiang Lana, Jun Songa

Department of Mining and Materials Engineering, McGill University

High entropy ceramics are highly promising as next generation thermal barrier coatings due to their unique disorder structure, which imparts ultra-low thermal conductivity and good high temperature stability. Unlike traditional ceramic materials, the thermal resistance in high entropy ceramics predominantly arises from phonon-disorder scattering rather than phonon-phonon interactions. In this study, we propose a calculation method based on the supercell phonon unfolding (SPU) technique to predict the thermal conductivity of high entropy ceramics, specially focusing on rocksalt oxides structures. Our prediction method relies on using the reciprocal value of SPU phonon spectra linewidth as an indicator of phonon lifetime. The obtained results demonstrate a strong agreement between the predicted thermal conductivities and the experimental measurements, validating the feasibility of our calculation method. Furthermore, we extensively investigate and discuss the atomic relaxation and lattice distortion effects in 5-dopants and 6-dopants rocksalt structures during the process.

DOI: 10.1016/j.jmst.2025.08.021

Transcript

Introduction to the show: ident: Condensed Matter. The day in condensed matter: materials, phases and the measurements under them.

Kai: I'm Kai.

Mira: And I'm Mira, here with Lev.

Kai: We're looking at the paper: "A calculation method to estimate thermal conductivity of high entropy ceramic for thermal barrier coatings".

Mira: Here's the gist of the paper. High entropy ceramics are highly promising as next generation thermal barrier coatings due to their unique disorder structure, which imparts ultra-low thermal conductivity and good high temperature stability In this study, we propose a calculation method based on the supercell phonon unfolding (SPU) technique to predict the thermal conductivity of high entropy ceramics, specially focusing on rocksalt oxides The obtained results demonstrate a strong agreement between the predicted thermal conductivities and the experimental measurements, validating the feasibility of our calculation method The methodology involves constructing supercell structures for high entropy rocksalt oxides and utilizing the supercell phonon unfolding (SPU) method to calculate the phonon dispersion spectra Supercell structures optimization and relative atomic force constants were calculated by DFT (density functional theory), performed using Vienna ab initio simulation package (VASP) The supercell construction was realized by SQS (special quasi-random supercells) method through Python package ICET For 5-dopant oxide (MgxNixCuxCoxZnx)O, primitive cell was used to extend to its 5×5×5 supercell (250 atoms) while conventional cell was used to extend to its 3×3×3 supercell (216 atoms) for other 6-dopant oxides (MgxNixCuxCoxZnxXx)O, primitive cell was used Phonon properties were evaluated using PHONOPY package on 20 × 20 × 20 q grid for all the high entropy oxide samples Analysis of Structure and Distortion The study analyzed the atomic relaxation and lattice distortion effects in 5-dopants and 6-dopants rocksalt structures during the process The space group symbol of rocksalt oxide structure is Fm3m, in which oxygen atom occupies the 4b position while metal atom takes the 4a position It’s evident that the displacements distribution of J14 differs from other compositions The magnitude of displacement for oxygen atoms is nearly twice as large as that for the other metal elements Thermal Conductivity Prediction Model A thermal conductivity prediction indicator Λ is built based on the Boltzmann equation with relaxation time approximation, where phonon linewidth is inversely proportional to phonon lifetime The indicator Λ can be written as: lambda = A N V0 ∑ Cvlambda·vlambda2 x lwlambda / λ The linewidth curves presented in Fig.

Kai: 6 represent the averaged results of these five repetitions, thereby eliminating calculation randomness Disorder Mechanism Insights The research indicates that the disorder-phonon scattering mechanism in high entropy system arises from both force and mass disorder The only notable difference lies in the sixth dopant element, which implies that the mass differences among the compositions are not prominent The broadening of stress force distribution should be responsible for the linewidths change of acoustic transverse branch in Fig 6, from flat curve of J14 to gradually increasing curve of other 6-dopant oxides around the gamma point The unfolded phonon spectra calculations assume that the atoms remain at their ideal positions while considering disordered force constants of relaxed lattice structure We must admit that there are still certain unknown factors that require further investigation to fully understand the mechanism of thermal conduction in high entropy ceramics The phonon-disorder scattering mechanism and the quantification of mass and force disorder are areas that warrant continued study Page 1 --- A calculation method to estimate thermal conductivity of high entropy ceramic for thermal barrier coatings Yuxuan Wanga, Guoqiang Lana, Jun Songa, a Department of Mining and Materials Engineering, McGill, University, Montreal, Quebec, H3A 0C5, Canada⁎ Corresponding author.

Mira: E-mail address: jun.song2@mcgill.ca (J.

Kai: Song).

Title and authors: Kai: So we're diving into the specifics now about this paper, "A calculation method to estimate thermal conductivity of high entropy ceramic for thermal barrier coatings." We just covered the basic premise that these materials are good for TBCs because they have low thermal conductivity and high stability.

Mira: This section really lays out exactly what the paper does by summarizing its approach, which is using supercell phonon unfolding to get those predictions. It shows how they set up their supercells and then use a specific calculation indicator, lambda, based on the Boltzmann equation with relaxation time approximation to predict thermal conductivity.

Lev: I'm curious about how they handle the complexity of high entropy materials when setting up these structures; that’s where my experience with real hardware comes in—how much overhead is involved in getting those initial supercells right?

Kai: They describe optimizing these supercell structures using density functional theory and then using special quasi-random supercells through a Python package called ICET for the construction. They also used different cell sizes based on whether they were looking at five or six dopant oxides.

Mira: And they didn't just stop there, they analyzed the atomic relaxation and lattice distortion effects in both five-dopants and six-dopants rocksalt structures, specifically looking at how the displacement distribution of J14 differs from other compositions.

Lev: That lattice distortion analysis is critical because it tells us about the internal forces involved; if those displacements are large, it means there's a big force component at play during scattering.

The paper's summary: Kai: To summarize what they actually found in the main body of this work, the core finding is that the disorder-phonon scattering mechanism in these high entropy systems comes from both force and mass disorder.

Mira: They point out that for six dopants, the only notable difference among compositions is the sixth dopant element itself, suggesting that mass differences between those specific compositions aren't super prominent.

Lev: So they’re saying we should focus more on the force disorder because the mass differences are less significant across those samples. That narrows down where we need to concentrate our theoretical effort if we want to model this accurately.

Kai: And they specifically mention that the broadening of stress force distribution is what should be responsible for the linewidth changes you see in the acoustic transverse branch of Fig six shifting from a flat curve for J14 to a gradually increasing curve for other six-dopant oxides around the gamma point.

Mira: That’s a key link they draw between the force disorder and the phonon linewidth behavior, which directly feeds into their prediction model.

The paper's improvements: Lev: Now let's talk about what they suggest as improvements to this calculation method because that’s where we see if it’s practical for real-world use.

Kai: They introduce a thermal conductivity prediction indicator, lambda, which is built based on the Boltzmann equation with relaxation time approximation, where the phonon linewidth is inversely proportional to the phonon lifetime.

Mira: That indicator lambda can be written as A N V0 times Cv times nu squared times lw over lambda where lw is the phonon linewidth. This model allows them to predict thermal conductivity by extracting this linewidth information from the unfolded phonon spectra.

Lev: It seems they are essentially creating a way to use the spectral width directly as a proxy for how long those phonons live, which is helpful when you can't easily measure lifetimes experimentally in these complex systems.

Kai: They also mention that this indicator lambda is calculated by taking the averaged results of five repetitions, which helps eliminate calculation randomness from the process.

Conclusion: Mira: So wrapping up this paper on "A calculation method to estimate thermal conductivity of high entropy ceramic for thermal barrier coatings," it confirms that their SPU method provides a strong agreement between their predicted thermal conductivities and the experimental measurements they have.

Lev: But we have to keep an eye on the limitations they mention; they state that the unfolded phonon spectra calculations assume that the atoms remain at their ideal positions while considering only disordered force constants of relaxed lattice structure.

Kai: That means there are still certain unknown factors out there, and they flag that as something requiring further investigation to fully understand how thermal conduction happens in high entropy ceramics.

Mira: And they specifically call out the phonon-disorder scattering mechanism and the quantification of mass and force disorder as areas that definitely warrant continued study.

Lev: For me, from a hardware standpoint, it means we need to figure out how much mass disorder versus force disorder actually impacts the measured thermal conductivity in real samples before we can trust this model fully.

Kai: So, in short, they've validated their prediction approach for these rocksalt oxides using SPU and have given us a clear path forward for better modeling of thermal barrier coatings.

More episodes

← Home