Dielectric perturbations: anomalous resonance frequency shifts in optical resonators

arXiv:2012.12446 · physics.optics · Submitted 2020-12-23 · Read on arXiv

Listen

Radio episode about this paper

Transcript

Introduction to the show: ident: Physics. The day in general physics: instruments, methods and results across the field.

Kai: We're looking at the paper: "Dielectric perturbations: anomalous resonance frequency shifts in optical resonators".

Mira: Here's the gist of the paper. Small perturbations in the dielectric environment around a high quality whispering gallery mode resonator usually lead to a frequency shift of the resonator modes directly proportional to the polarizability of the perturbation Here, we report experimental observations of strong frequency shifts that can be opposite and even exceed the contribution of the perturbations’ polarizability The mode frequencies of a lithium niobate whispering gallery mode resonator are shifted using substrates of refractive indices ranging from 1.50 to 4.22 Both blue- and red-shifts are observed, as well as an increase in mode linewidth, when substrates are moved into the evanescent field of the whispering gallery mode Experimental Setup The experiment utilizes a disk-shaped z-cut Lithium Niobate WGM resonator with a major radius R = 2 mm and a minor radius r = 0.23 mm A fibre-coupled tunable diode laser with a central wavelength of 1550 nm serves as the excitation source for the WGMs The setup involves moving seven substrates of varying refractive indices (nsub) into close proximity to the WGM resonator with nanometer accuracy Lorentzian fits are applied to the acquired spectra to extract linewidths and frequency positions of the mode Observed Frequency Shifts and Broadening The introduction of a substrate penetrating a significant portion of the evanescent field results in an observed shift in resonance frequency and mode broadening For the TE mode, both red-shift and blue-shift are observed when substrates are brought into close proximity Specifically, dielectric substrates with a refractive index significantly larger than that of the resonator excite an anomalous blue-shift The TM polarized mode only exhibits a red-shift An anomalous blue-shift as high as 14 MHz is observed via the Ge substrate in TE polarization Conversely, a red-shift as low as-5 MHz is recorded when a LiNbO3 substrate is used in the TM polarized mode Theoretical Explanation and Discrepancies The resonance shifts can be explained by an altered Goos-H¨anchen shift at the resonator rim, which causes the effective perimeter of the resonator to shift in or out This alteration is modeled by introducing a small (constant) effective distance deff away from the resonator The resonance shift and broadening are given by equations (1) and (2) where resonance shift = -cδΘ / 2 cos θi2πnR, and resonance broadening = 2 cα / 2 cos θi2πnR Remarkable agreement is found between the theory and the experimental results when using effective distances deff,TE = 438.4 nm for TE polarization In conclusion, frequency shifts and mode broadening due to the introduction of dielectric materials into the evanescent field have been observed Both blue- and red-shifts were observed, and the type of shift depends on the polarization of the excited mode Substrates of higher refractive index like Ge, Si, ZnSe excite a blue-shift in TE polarization These results have implications for effective mode tuning without applying any external strain The observed effects are consistent with the theory described by Foreman et al.

1: Reference ID 2012.12446 1 3 4 5 6 Page 1 --- Dielectric perturbations: anomalous resonance frequency shifts in optical resonators Farhan Azeem, Luke S.

Mira: Trainor, Patrick A.

Kai: Devane, Daniel S.

Paper summary: Kai: This is about how dielectric perturbations can cause anomalous resonance frequency shifts when you look at a lithium niobate whispering gallery mode resonator. The paper reports seeing both blue-shifts and red-shifts as substrates of varying refractive indices are moved into the evanescent field of the resonator.

Mira: The main thesis here is that these observed shifts can even exceed the contribution you'd expect from just the polarizability of those surrounding materials, which is a big deal for understanding how these resonators behave.

Lev: So, they aren't just measuring a small correction; they are finding effects that are stronger than the expected baseline interaction.

Kai: Right. They also noted that when these substrates get closer to the resonator, there's a noticeable increase in mode linewidth as well, which is another effect to consider.

Mira: It matters because it shows that you can get these complex results where both directions of shift happen depending on the material and the polarization of the mode.

Lev: That complexity is what makes it hard to model cleanly on real hardware; you have to account for all these coupling losses as you mentioned earlier.

Kai: The paper sets up a disk-shaped z-cut lithium niobate wgm resonator, with a major radius of two millimeters and a minor radius of zero point two three millimeters. They use seven different substrates with refractive indices between one point five zero and four point two two to test this effect <ref:2012.12446#pg1>.

Mira: That range of refractive indices is quite broad, which suggests the effect isn't tied to just one specific material property but is related to the change in the dielectric environment itself.

Lev: From an engineering standpoint, having that wide range means you can map out where these shifts are happening across a whole spectrum of materials.

Kai: The core observation they highlight is that for the transverse electric or TE mode, you see both a red shift and an anomalous blue shift when the substrate refractive index is significantly higher than the resonator's own.

Conclusion: Kai: So, wrapping up this paper on "Dielectric perturbations: anomalous resonance frequency shifts in optical resonators," the main thing is that you can tune your resonator by changing the material right next to it, and sometimes that tuning goes both up and down depending on whether you're looking at a TE or TM mode.

Mira: The implication for us as theorists is that we need to move beyond just looking at static polarizability corrections and start thinking about how the geometry of light confinement—like the Goos-Hänchen shift—can fundamentally change the resonance position.

Lev: For hardware development, this means if you want to tune a chip using ambient materials, you have to budget for that increased linewidth and coupling efficiency reduction they mentioned; it's not a perfect tuning mechanism.

Kai: So, in simple terms, the paper shows that introducing a dielectric material near your resonator can cause both frequency shifts and mode broadening, depending on which polarization you excite and what kind of substrate you use.

Mira: It suggests that for future work, we need to focus more on modeling those coupling losses as a primary driver when considering external perturbations in these systems.

Lev: I agree. If we're going to build real devices that rely on this tuning, we have to account for how much power is leaking out due to the substrate interaction.

Kai: That's the practical side of it, so it’s not just an elegant physics result; it sets a limit on what you can achieve in terms of quality factor and tuning accuracy with external materials.

Farhan Azeem, Luke S. Trainor, Patrick A. Devane, Daniel S. Norman, Alfredo Rueda, Nicholas J. Lambert, Madhuri Kumari, Matthew R. Foreman and Harald G L Schwefel

Dodd-Walls Centre for Photonic and Quantum Technologies in New Zealand · Department of Physics at University of Otago in New Zealand · Blackett Laboratory at Imperial College London, United Kingdom

physics.optics

Submitted: 2020-12-23

Updated: 2020-12-23

Comments: 7 pages, 4 figures

Journal ref: Opt. Lett. 46, 2477-2480 (2021)

DOI: 10.1364/OL.420791

License: http://arxiv.org/licenses/nonexclusive-distrib/1.0/

Importance score: 82/100

The gist: Small perturbations in the dielectric environment around a high quality whispering gallery mode resonator usually lead to a frequency shift of the resonator modes directly proportional to the…

Key concepts

Whispering Gallery Mode (WGM)
A WGM is a mode of light that circulates around the perimeter of a high-quality resonator, like a disk. It relies on total internal reflection to stay trapped inside the material, making it sensitive to changes in the surrounding environment.
Evanescent Field
This is an electromagnetic field that extends from the resonator into the surrounding space. When a substrate is brought close to this field, it interacts with these fields, causing measurable changes like frequency shifts and mode broadening.
Goos-Hänchen Shift
This phenomenon relates to how light reflects off a boundary. In this context, it models the shift in the resonance frequency caused by introducing a dielectric interface near the resonator rim, which alters the effective perimeter of the cavity.

Terminology

Summary

Small perturbations in the dielectric environment around a high quality whispering gallery mode resonator usually lead to a frequency shift of the resonator modes directly proportional to the polarizability of the perturbation The mode frequencies of a lithium niobate whispering gallery mode resonator are shifted using substrates of refractive indices ranging from 1. p. 050 to 4.22 Both blue- and red-shifts are observed, as well as an increase in mode linewidth, when substrates are moved into the evanescent field of the whispering gallery mode

Experimental Observations

The experiment investigates strong frequency shifts that can be opposite and even exceed the contribution of the perturbations’ polarizability The mode frequencies of a lithium niobate whispering gallery mode resonator are shifted using substrates of refractive indices ranging from 1.50 to 4.22 Both blue- and red-shifts are observed, as well as an increase in mode linewidth, when substrates are moved into the evanescent field of the whispering gallery mode The red-shift shown in the figure occurs due to the presence of LiNbO3 substrate and the blue-shift due to Ge substrate within the evanescent field of the resonator

Mode Polarization Dependence

The TM polarized mode only exhibits the red-shift However, the TE polarized mode shows both the red-shift and blue-shift Dielectric substrates with a refractive index significantly larger than that of the resonator excite an anomalous blue-shift A blue-shift as high as 14 MHz is observed in TE polarization, whereas a red-shift as low as −5 MHz is observed in TM polarization

Theoretical Modeling and Discrepancies

The results are in qualitative agreement with the theory described by Foreman et al. [1] However, the model predicts both frequency shifts and mode broadening to be approximately a factor of four larger than those observed This discrepancy is ascribed to experimental deviations from the ideal situation, specifically that relevant surfaces of the substrates used to tune the resonances are unlikely to be completely parallel to the symmetry axis of the resonator

Physical Mechanism Explanation

The shape of expected resonance shifts can be explained by an altered Goos-H¨anchen shift at the resonator rim, which causes the effective perimeter of the resonator to shift in or out This phenomenon is related to how light undergoes total internal reflection (TIR), where a dielectric close to the resonator alters its phase of reflection coefficient The resonance shift and broadening are given by equations relating them to the effective distance between the resonator and the dielectric as fitting parameters The mode broadening is caused by tunneling of photons into the dielectric

Conclusion

In conclusion, frequency shifts and mode broadening due to the introduction of dielectric materials into the evanescent field have been observed, with both blue- and red-shifts being present The type of shift in frequency depends on the polarization of the excited mode Substrates of higher refractive index such as Ge, Si, ZnSe excite a blue-shift in the TE polarization An anomalous blue-shift as high as 14 MHz is observed via the Ge substrate The red-shift is recorded at a low of −5 MHz when a LiNbO3 substrate is used to tune the mode These results have implications for effective mode tuning without applying any external strain which can aid in achieving the optimum phase matching conditions for non-linear processes in WGM resonators

REFERENCE

Green — the paper says it, and the page is printed. Red — no passage carries it, so treat that sentence as unverified. The same check runs on your own text: check a summary against its source, $5.

Improvements for AI systems

  1. Improved AI for material characterization can perform effective mode tuning without external strain by analyzing polarization-dependent frequency shifts. This allows AI systems to determine optimal phase matching conditions for non-linear processes in whispering gallery mode resonators based on substrate choice alone.

  2. Enhanced simulation capabilities allow AI to predict the magnitude and sign of frequency shifts and linewidth broadening by modeling the Goos-Hänchen shift effects as a function of effective distance between the resonator and the dielectric material. This enables faster design cycles for optical systems where precise tuning is required.

  3. AI can be used to diagnose experimental discrepancies between theoretical models and physical observations, specifically by quantifying deviations caused by non-ideal surface geometries like small air gaps at the equator of the WGM. This helps researchers refine their measurement protocols to achieve more accurate results in refractive index sensing applications.

Sources

Related papers