Dielectric tuning and coupling of whispering gallery modes using an anisotropic prism

arXiv:1607.05098 · physics.optics · Submitted 2016-07-18 · Read on arXiv

Listen

Radio episode about this paper

Transcript

Introduction to the show: ident: Physics. The day in general physics: instruments, methods and results across the field.

Kai: We're looking at the paper: "Dielectric tuning and coupling of whispering gallery modes using an anisotropic prism".

Mira: Here's the gist of the paper. Optical whispering gallery mode (WGM) resonators are a powerful and versatile tool used in many branches of science Fine tuning of the central frequency and line width of individual resonances is however desirable in a number of applications including frequency conversion, optical communications and efficient light-matter coupling This work presents a detailed theoretical analysis of dielectric tuning of WGMs supported in axisymmetric resonators The authors study the resonance shift and mode broadening of high Q WGMs when a planar dielectric substrate is brought close to the resonator They find competing red and blue resonance shifts (∼ 30 MHz), deriving from generation of a near field material polarisation and back action from the radiation continuum respectively Furthermore, polarisation selective coupling with extinction ratios of > 104 can be achieved when the resonator and substrate are of the same composition and their optic axes are chosen correctly.

Kai: Theoretical Framework for Mode Analysis The authors generalize analytic WGM profiles to account for the open nature of WGM resonators and detail properties in an isolated uniaxial axisymmetric resonator They use a scalar Helmholtz equation to describe the electric field distribution within the resonator interior.

Mira: The total energy stored within the resonator volume, Uresv, is found by integrating over a toroidal volume defined by the local curvature of the resonator as shown in Figure 1.

Kai: The mode profile outside the resonator exhibits an evanescent decay Eνm(r) ≈ Aν exp − θ2 / 2Θ2m Hpθm e − κ(ρ−P) e imφσˆν res.

Title and authors: Mira: Now, let's look at how the authors frame this work in their title and introduction for "Dielectric tuning and coupling of whispering gallery modes using an anisotropic prism." It sets up the whole framework for what they are investigating here.

Kai: The title clearly states the two main things: dielectric tuning and coupling of whispering gallery modes, both involving an anisotropic prism. It tells you immediately that the geometry of that prism is important for controlling these optical resonances.

Lev: From my side, it suggests they're focusing on a specific type of structure—a uniaxial axisymmetric resonator—and how adding a substrate perturbs those modes in open cavities.

Mira: They introduce the idea of using this analysis to get quantitative predictions for resonance shifts and mode broadening when that dielectric substrate is near the resonator. It moves beyond just observing shifts to providing a theoretical prediction tool.

Kai: So, it’s not just describing what happens; it's giving us a way to calculate how much the frequency changes and how wide the line gets when you introduce this material interaction.

Lev: And they use specific mathematical tools like the Bethe-Schwinger equation and an angular spectrum field representation to model this interaction within that setup, right?

Mira: That’s right, they are using these formalisms to describe the electric field distribution inside the resonator and how it changes when you introduce the substrate.

Kai: It helps bridge that gap between the physical setup—the prism and the substrate—and what happens at a fundamental level with these whispering gallery modes.

The paper's summary: Kai: So, to summarize what they actually did in "Dielectric tuning and coupling of whispering gallery modes using an anisotropic prism," they take a detailed theoretical look at how a planar dielectric substrate affects whispering gallery modes supported in axisymmetric resonators.

Mira: They generalize the analytic profiles for these whispering gallery modes to account for the open nature of the resonators, which means you can't just treat them as isolated systems.

Lev: They use a scalar Helmholtz equation to describe the electric field distribution inside that resonator, and they calculate the total energy stored in that volume by integrating over a toroidal volume defined by the local curvature of the resonator rim.

Kai: The key finding they present is about resonance shifts and mode broadening when a planar dielectric substrate is brought close to these WGMs. They find competing red and blue resonance shifts, which are around thirty megahertz in magnitude.

Mira: Those competing shifts arise from two distinct physical mechanisms: the generation of a near field material polarization, and back action coming from the radiation continuum. That’s what makes it interesting for understanding the physics involved.

Lev: And they also show that when you consider how modes interact with this perturbation, you get surface dressed scattering amplitudes by relating incident and scattered mode coefficients through a matrix equation.

Kai: They specifically found that a whispering gallery mode of order p couples most strongly to the lowest order whispering gallery mode of the same symmetry upon reflection, which is an interesting rule for coupling.

The paper's improvements: Mira: When we look at how these results can be improved, the paper points out that for TE modes, you get maximum red shifts when the refractive index of the perturbing substrate is about equal to that of the resonator material itself.

Kai: That makes sense physically; matching indices often leads to stronger coupling effects in these types of interactions. But then for larger substrate indices, things get more complex.

Lev: Because for larger substrate indices, the radiative contribution starts to dominate, and this leads not only to anomalous blue shifts but also significant mode broadening. The orientation of the optic axis then becomes a central thing in governing the relative losses between these two channels.

Mira: They also found a specific condition for achieving high extinction ratios when using materials that are identical for both the resonator and substrate. You need to choose your optic axis of the resonator and substrate to be parallel to the resonator’s symmetry axis, which is what they call an x-cut, while being perpendicular to the substrate interface, which is an x-cut.

Kai: So it gives us a concrete geometric prescription for designing structures that could achieve high polarization selectivity. That's useful information for experimental design.

Lev: And they provide analytic formulae for the geometrical properties of out coupled beams under general conditions, which helps with simulating the far-field emission patterns accurately.

Conclusion: Mira: To wrap up the paper "Dielectric tuning and coupling of whispering gallery modes using an anisotropic prism," the authors confirm that competing red and blue shifts dictate the total change in resonance frequency.

Kai: They also stress that the relative dominance of each shift depends on both the mode polarization and how much it differs between the refractive index of your substrate and your resonator material.

Lev: And they conclude by saying they've shown how double refraction can split a whispering gallery mode into ordinary and extraordinary waves when propagating in an anisotropic substrate, and they give you formulae for their geometrical properties under general conditions.

Mira: The main implication is that this work provides a quantitative formalism capable of predicting resonance shifts and mode broadening based on bringing a planar dielectric substrate from infinity into the evanescent field of a whispering gallery mode.

Kai: It’s about giving researchers an analytic way to predict how to tune these modes for applications in frequency conversion or optical communications, right?

Lev: And they also confirm that they rigorously proved that coupling between modes of different azimuthal order and parity is forbidden, which simplifies the interactions a bit.

Mira: Overall, it lays out the framework for designing structures for high polarization selectivity by choosing your material compositions and optic axes correctly.

Kai: It’s a solid piece of theory connecting geometry, material properties, and optical resonance behavior for these resonators.

Lev: And they have also provided that predictive model for out coupled beam characteristics based on the equations they derived in the paper.

Matthew R. Foreman, Florian Sedlmeir, Harald G. L. Schwefel, Gerd Leuchs

Max Planck Institute for the Science of Light · Department of Physics, University of Otago · Institut f¨ur Optik, Information und Photonik, Universit¨at Erlangen-N¨urnberg

physics.optics

Submitted: 2016-07-18

Updated: 2016-07-18

Journal ref: J. Opt. Soc. Am. B 33, 2177-2195 (2016)

DOI: 10.1364/JOSAB.33.002177

License: http://arxiv.org/licenses/nonexclusive-distrib/1.0/

Importance score: 86/100

The gist: Optical whispering gallery mode (WGM) resonators are a powerful and versatile tool used in many branches of science Fine tuning of the central frequency and line width of individual resonances is…

Key concepts

Whispering Gallery Mode (WGM)
These are light waves that circulate around the perimeter of a curved structure, like a tiny optical ring. They are used in many applications because they can confine light very tightly and have sharp resonances that can be easily tuned.
Resonance Shift and Broadening
When a substrate is placed near the resonator, it changes the way light interacts with the mode. This causes the central frequency of the resonance to move (shift) and makes its spectral line wider (broadening), which is crucial for applications like frequency conversion.
Polarization Selective Coupling
This refers to designing a system where only light with a specific polarization (like horizontal or vertical) couples strongly into or out of the resonator. The authors show how matching the material properties and orientation can achieve very high extinction ratios, meaning one polarization is strongly transmitted while another is almost completely blocked.
Red and Blue Resonance Shifts
These are competing frequency changes observed when a dielectric substrate interacts with a WGM. One shift (red) comes from the material's polarization effects, while the other (blue) comes from the light being scattered back into the radiation continuum.

Terminology

Summary

Optical whispering gallery mode (WGM) resonators are a powerful and versatile tool used in many branches of science Fine tuning of the central frequency and line width of individual resonances is however desirable in a number of applications including frequency conversion, optical communications and efficient light-matter coupling This work presents a detailed theoretical analysis of dielectric tuning of WGMs supported in axisymmetric resonators The authors study the resonance shift and mode broadening of high Q WGMs when a planar dielectric substrate is brought close to the resonator They find competing red and blue resonance shifts (∼ 30 MHz), deriving from generation of a near field material polarisation and back action from the radiation continuum respectively Furthermore, polarisation selective coupling with extinction ratios of > 104 can be achieved when the resonator and substrate are of the same composition and their optic axes are chosen correctly. p. 0

Theoretical Framework for Mode Analysis

The authors generalize analytic WGM profiles to account for the open nature of WGM resonators and detail properties in an isolated uniaxial axisymmetric resonator They use a scalar Helmholtz equation to describe the electric field distribution within the resonator interior. The total energy stored within the resonator volume, Uresv, is found by integrating over a toroidal volume defined by the local curvature of the resonator as shown in Figure 1. p. 1 The mode profile outside the resonator exhibits an evanescent decay Eνm(r) ≈ Aν exp − θ2 / 2Θ2m Hpθm e − κ(ρ−P) e imφσˆν res. p. 1

Mode Coupling and Scattering Amplitudes

Interaction of a WGM with a dielectric perturbation gives rise to a redistribution of the mode profile. They derive surface dressed scattering amplitudes by relating incident and scattered mode coefficients through the matrix equation b = Na. p. 2 The coupling constant Ku,v is evaluated using an integral I(1)u,v. p. 4 They find that a WGM of order p couples most strongly to the lowest order WGM of the same symmetry upon reflection. p. 5

Resonance Shifts and Line Width Broadening

The total change in the complex resonance frequency induced by the presence of a substrate can then be found by noting dωv = ωv(h + δh) − ωv(h) = − h/ωN(1)v + iN(2)v i N(0)v. The key result of this article is the shift in the (real) resonance frequency and the change in the line width follow as ∆ωv = Re[∆ωv] and ∆γv = −2Im[∆ωv] respectively. p. 9

Anisotropic Substrate Effects

The analysis shows that for TE modes, maximum red shifts occur when the refractive index of the perturbing substrate is approximately equal to that of the resonator. For larger substrate indices, the radiative contribution begins to dominate, leading not only to anomalous blue shifts, but also to significant mode broadening. p. 9 The orientation of the optic axis plays a central role in governing the relative losses between these channels. p. 0

Selective Coupling and Geometric Properties

When the resonator and substrate are fabricated from the same (birefringent) material this dependence renders polarisation selective coupling with a high extinction ratio possible. Optimal selective coupling is found when the optic axis of the resonator and substrate are chosen to lie parallel to the resonator’s symmetry axis (z-cut) and perpendicular to the substrate interface (x-cut) respectively. p. 1 The authors provide analytic formulae for the geometrical properties of out coupled beams under general conditions. p. 0

Numerical Results and Discussion

Competing red and blue shifts were found to dictate the total change in resonance frequency. The relative dominance of each effect was found to be influenced by the both the mode polarisation and the refractive index of the perturbing substrate relative to that of the resonator. p. 1 Maximum extinction ratios are achieved when cˆ lies in the x-y plane (αc = π/2), specifically along the xˆ axis (βc = 0). p. 0 p. 0

Appendix Details

The appendix derives the generalised Fresnel reflection and transmission coefficients of a plane wave in an isotropic medium incident upon a planar uniaxial interface whose surface normal is directed along xˆ. The authors also present the Breit-Wigner line shape with material absorption, showing how absorption modifies the resonance line shape. p. 5 The anisotropic Bethe-Schwinger equation is presented to account for far-field radiative contributions in open cavities. p. 6

Conclusion Summary

In this article we have theoretically studied the properties of WGMs in a z-cut uniaxial axisymmetric resonator placed in close proximity to a planar dielectric substrate, such as a prism. They have furthermore presented an analytic formalism capable of quantitatively predicting the resonance shifts and mode broadening that result from bringing a planar dielectric substrate from infinity into the evanescent field of a WGM. p. 9 The analysis is based on a generalisation of the Bethe-Schwinger perturbation equation which accounts for far-field radiative contributions and is hence suitable for application to open cavities. p. 0

Key Findings

The authors rigorously proved that coupling between modes of differing azimuthal order and parity was forbidden. They also found that net mode broadening of TM WGMs perturbed by a LiNbO3 substrate is nevertheless governed by the radiative loss (N(2)v) term as per physical intuition. p. 9 Maximum extinction ratios are achieved when cˆ lies in the x-y plane (αc = π/2), specifically along the xˆ axis (βc = 0).

Final Remarks

The authors have discussed double refraction of a WGM into ordinary and extraordinary waves propagating in a nearby anisotropic substrate and moreover provided analytic formulae for their geometrical properties under general conditions. The paper concludes by discussing the implications for polarization selective coupling with high extinction ratios. p. 0

Green — the paper says it, and the page is printed. Red — no passage carries it, so treat that sentence as unverified. The same check runs on your own text: check a summary against its source, $5.

Improvements for AI systems

  1. Integration of dielectric tuning models into AI design for tunable optical filters allows AI systems to predict resonance shifts and line width changes based on substrate material properties, as described by Eq 67. This enables AI to rapidly optimize resonator geometries or substrate choices for specific frequency targets.

  2. Development of an anomaly detection system capable of distinguishing between red and blue resonance shifts by analyzing the relative contributions of the N(1)v term (material polarization) and N(2)v term (radiative back action). This allows AI to identify whether a measured shift is due to material work or far-field coupling.

  3. Creation of a selective coupling optimization module for optical devices that utilizes the predicted extinction ratios derived from Eq 67 when the resonator and substrate are of the same composition and their optic axes are chosen correctly. This can guide AI in designing structures for high polarization selectivity.

  4. Implementation of a predictive model for out-coupled beam characteristics, including output angles and angular widths given by Eqs 68, 71, and 72. This allows AI to simulate the far-field emission patterns of WGM resonators accurately for mode identification purposes.

  5. Training a machine learning model on the coupling coefficients Ku,v derived in Eq 35 to predict the strongest coupling between WGM orders based on their polar and radial indices. This aids in designing coupled resonator systems with desired mode interaction strengths.

Sources

Related papers