The NewMag crystal-field code for f-element systems: Implementation for extended active spaces, second-order correlated energies, and generalisation to fn configurations

summary

The gist

The NewMag crystal-field code for f-element systems enables the extraction of Stevens crystal-field parameters after relativistic and multiconfigurational calculations…

In short

NewMag is a code that extracts Stevens crystal-field parameters for f-element systems from advanced quantum chemistry calculations like SA-CASSCF and SOCI. It allows users to use extended active spaces and second-order energies, providing tools to understand the magnetic and optical properties of these materials.

Key concepts

Stevens Crystal Field Parameters
These are specific parameters that describe how the electric field of surrounding ions splits the energy levels of electrons in an f-element atom. NewMag extracts them using advanced calculations to accurately model magnetic properties.
Extended Active Spaces
This refers to using a larger set of electronic orbitals in quantum chemistry calculations than standard methods require. This allows for a more complete description of the electron correlation and better modeling of complex f-element systems.
Spin-Orbit Coupling (SOC)
SOC is an interaction between an electron's spin and its orbital motion around the nucleus. NewMag extracts this constant at the SOCI level, which is crucial for understanding magnetic properties in many f-element complexes.

Terminology used across episodes

This episode discusses

The paper

The NewMag crystal-field code for f-element systems: Implementation for extended active spaces, second-order correlated energies, and generalisation to fn configurations · Read on arXiv

University of Rennes CNRS ISCR Institute des Sciences Chimiques de Rennes · Faculty of Chemistry Alexandru Ioan Cuza University of Ias,i Institute for Computational Science and Research in Romania

We report a massive update of the NewMag program, which enables to extract Stevens crystal-field parameters (CFPs) after relativistic and multiconfigurational calculations are performed. The code can now post-treat ORCA and OpenMolcas outputs that contain state-average complete active space self-consistend field (SA-CASSCF) calculations with minimal or extended active spaces, second-order NEVPT2 or CASPT2 calculations, and spin-orbit configuration interaction (SOCI) calculations. Stevens parameters are extracted following the original Stevens convention with the so-called "extended" parameters. Rotation invariant indicators are also computed, after applying a correction of the parameter values to ensure normalization, following Rudowicz. At the SOCI level, the spin-orbit coupling (SOC) constant is also extracted within a spherical approximation of the SOC operator. For all the reference calculation levels, the model spectrum is reconstructed, allowing a direct assessment of its quality. The reported implementation is successfully applicable to f-element systems with a non-void, non-half-filled/empty or non-full f shell, that is for f n configurations with n != 0, != 7 and != 14. Similarities and differences with the SINGLE ANISO and AILFT codes are discussed. With selected examples, we showcase the interest of determining CFPs in f-element systems to understand their magnetic and optical properties in general, and more specifically the added value of NewMag. Finally, application of this approach to d-element systems is discussed, to reveal when it readily and successfully applies and when it may fail in reproducing satisfactorily the ab initio energies.

Transcript

Introduction to the show: ident: Physics. The day in general physics: instruments, methods and results across the field.

Kai: We're looking at the paper: "The NewMag crystal-field code for f-element systems".

Mira: Here's the gist of the paper. The NewMag crystal-field code for f-element systems enables the extraction of Stevens crystal-field parameters after relativistic and multiconfigurational calculations, which is important because it provides a tool to understand the magnetic and optical properties of f-element systems.

Kai: Code Capabilities The code can post-treat ORCA and OpenMolcas outputs that contain state-average complete active space self-consistend field (SA-CASSCF) calculations with minimal or extended active spaces, second-order NEVPT2 or CASPT2 calculations, and spin-orbit configuration interaction (SOCI) calculations.

Mira: Stevens parameters are extracted following the original Stevens convention with the so-called “extended” parameters.

Kai: Rotation invariant indicators are also computed, after applying a correction of the parameter values to ensure normalization, following Rudowicz.

Title and authors: Kai: We started by looking at this paper titled "The NewMag crystal-field code for f-element systems: Implementation for extended active spaces, second-order correlated energies, and generalisation to fn configurations". The title itself tells us immediately that they’re expanding the NewMag program.

Mira: It signals an update on the existing code that focuses on extending its capabilities to handle more complex theoretical inputs from programs like ORCA and OpenMolcas.

Lev: So, what does this extension actually mean in terms of computation? Are we talking about a massive jump in required memory or just a change in how the calculation is structured?

Kai: It’s not necessarily a massive jump, but they are post-treating outputs that already have state average complete active space self consistent field calculations with minimal or extended active spaces.

Mira: Minimal or extended active spaces means they can take results from calculations that might be less demanding than the full calculation, which is smart for accessibility.

Lev: If you’re running this on a real quantum computer, having a way to ingest these already calculated intermediates saves you from doing the most expensive part of the job from scratch.

Kai: The paper emphasizes that they are including second order correlated energies like NEVPT2 or CASPT2 in their post-treatment capabilities, which is important for getting more accurate results.

Mira: Including those second order methods means they are aiming for higher precision than just using the single point estimates from the first level of calculation.

Lev: Higher precision usually means more time spent on correlation effects, and we have to be careful about how that scales with the size of these active spaces.

Kai: The paper also mentions spin-orbit configuration interaction SOC calculations as part of what this code can post-treat, which is a key ingredient for magnetic studies.

Mira: That SOC calculation is where things get interesting, because spin-orbit coupling is often the dominant factor in determining the magnetic anisotropy in these systems.

Lev: And from an engineering perspective, if you need to model SOC effects accurately on hardware, you really need to be careful about how those terms are scaled up when you move from simpler approximations to the full interaction.

Kai: So, they’re essentially creating a pipeline that takes existing high-level calculations and refines them for magnetic property extraction.

Mira: It sounds like they are trying to make the analysis part of this process more rigorous, rather than just relying on empirical fitting models which I see in some older literature.

Lev: That’s where the value is; if you can post-treat those outputs, you’re not just getting a number; you’re validating the entire theoretical structure used to get that number.

Kai: The paper sets up this new framework for extracting Stevens crystal field parameters after relativistic and multiconfigurational calculations are performed Gwenhaël Duplaix-Rata,one Dumitru-Claudiu Sergentu,two three Boris Le Guennic,one and Rémi Maurice*one one)Univ Rennes, CNRS, ISCR (Institut des Sciences Chimiques de Rennes) – UMR six thousand two hundred twenty-six F-thirty-five thousand Rennes France <ref:2609.37541#pg1,Gwenhaël Duplaix-Rata,1 Dumitru-Claudiu Sergentu,2, 3 Boris Le Guennic>.

Mira: And the authors are clearly building on previous work by NewMag but adding significant new features to make it more powerful for modern computational chemistry.

Lev: It’s interesting that they're focusing on f n configurations where n is not zero, not seven or fourteen, which suggests they are targeting a wider range of systems than just the most common ones.

The paper's summary: Kai: Now moving into the summary of this paper, it’s about how NewMag works and what it actually achieves with all these new features. They want to show that this code is a viable tool for extracting crystal field parameters from these complex ab initio calculations.

Mira: The summary explains that they can extract Stevens parameters following the original convention with the so called extended parameters, plus rotation invariant indicators after applying a correction by Rudowicz to ensure normalization.

Lev: Normalization corrections always sound like necessary evils, but you have to ask what those corrections actually are and how much they change the final derived values.

Kai: They also detail how they compute rotation invariant indicators after applying a correction of the parameter values to ensure normalization following Rudowicz, which is an important step for comparison.

Mira: And at the SOCI level, they extract the spin-orbit coupling constant within a spherical approximation of that SOC operator, which is another key magnetic property.

Lev: Extracting that SOC constant through a specific approximation means you have to be aware of the assumptions made about the SOC operator structure; it’s not always exact.

Kai: They describe their methodology for building the effective Hamiltonian at the SR level in the basis of ML components of the ground two S plus one L term of the reference free ion, and this involves five specific steps to process ab initio wave functions.

Mira: Those five steps are where they handle everything from root selection to transforming wave functions into complex spherical harmonics and many electron orbital bases.

Lev: That sounds like a lot of transformation matrices; from an engineering standpoint, you have to ensure those transformations are numerically stable so you don't introduce huge numerical errors during the process.

Kai: For parameter extraction at the SR level, they follow the irreducible tensor operator procedure of Chibotaru and Ungur for the crystal field B q k parameters.

Mira: And at that same SOCI level, they apply the ITO procedure to extract lambda of SOCI.

Lev: So you have two different procedures—ITO for one level and a coupled basis approach for the other—which means we’re comparing results between two slightly different theoretical frameworks.

Kai: They also mention that their resulting SOC constants at the SOCI level are similar to those obtained by AILFT since NewMag uses the spherical approximation.

Mira: That similarity is a good sign, suggesting that their approach is consistent with other established methods when looking at the spin-orbit coupling effects.

Lev: Consistency across different extraction methods usually means you’re in a safer spot computationally, but we still need to check if that consistency holds true for all f n configurations they are testing.

Kai: They show that this methodology is always successful with lanthanide complexes, and they further discuss its applicability to transition metal and actinide complexes.

Mira: So the paper is demonstrating a broad applicability by showing success across those different element series, which is a significant claim if true for the transition metals too.

Lev: Showing success across f n configurations where n isn't zero, not seven or fourteen means they’re covering a lot of ground in terms of system diversity.

The paper's improvements: Kai: The paper really lays out several improvements they are making to NewMag, and these are all about expanding what the code can handle.

Mira: First big thing is the extension to f n configurations where n is not zero, not seven or fourteen, including f two through f six and f eight through f thirteen configurations with extended active spaces.

Lev: That’s covering a lot of ground in terms of element series diversity, which is exactly what we need when we are trying to model a wide variety of real-world systems.

Kai: They also improved the methodology for how they build the effective Hamiltonian at the SR level by letting users choose between retaining pseudo-L roots or providing an output from an independent self consistent field calculation.

Mira: That choice gives users flexibility in deciding how much computational effort they want to invest based on their specific needs, which is very practical.

Lev: Flexibility is good, but it means the user has to be careful about what’s actually inside those pseudo-L roots if they’re not running the full CASSCF calculation.

Kai: They also introduced a workflow that processes ORCA or OpenMolcas outputs by first localizing active space orbitals, then feeding them to subsequent CASCI calculations to identify SR wave functions through "localized" and "purified" active orbitals.

Mira: That localization step sounds like it’s an extra filtering mechanism to ensure you are working with the most relevant parts of the wavefunction before proceeding.

Lev: Filtering out irrelevant components can reduce noise, but we need to make sure that this filtering doesn't accidentally remove a crucial piece of physics.

Kai: They also have these improvements for parameter extraction, such as re-scaling extracted CFPs based on normalized versions, like B prime q k parameters defined using rank two four and six operators to ensure consistency with Rudowicz normalization.

Mira: That’s an attempt to enforce a more standardized way of presenting the results, which helps when comparing results from different theoretical sources.

Lev: Standardizing the output format is helpful for benchmarking, but we have to be sure that the re-scaling doesn't introduce systematic errors that aren't accounted for in the original theory.

Kai: They also improved how they handle J mixing due to second order CF couplings by constructing the CF Hamiltonian in the ML S basis prior to transforming it to the J basis, which naturally introduces J mixing and allows its quantification at both SR and SOCI levels.

Mira: So they’re not just extracting parameters; they are actively looking for those subtle effects like J mixing that happen due to second order coupling, which is where the physics gets really interesting.

Lev: Quantifying that J mixing is crucial because it tells you how much the simple model Hamiltonian deviates from reality, and we need to see if this quantification is meaningful for experimental comparison.

Conclusion: Kai: So to wrap up this paper on "The NewMag crystal-field code for f-element systems: Implementation for extended active spaces, second-order correlated energies, and generalisation to fn configurations". They’ve shown a lot of capabilities in terms of post-treatment.

Mira: They proved that the code can successfully extract Stevens parameters following the original convention with the so called extended parameters and rotation invariant indicators after applying a correction by Rudowicz for normalization.

Lev: So, we have to keep an eye on those normalization corrections because they are a necessary part of getting those final, comparable numbers.

Kai: And at the SOCI level, they successfully extract the spin-orbit coupling constant within a spherical approximation of that SOC operator as well.

Mira: This gives us another way to see how spin-orbit effects are influencing the magnetic behavior directly from their calculations.

Lev: It’s interesting that they managed to keep that SOC constant consistent with AILFT, which means the spherical approximation is a relatively good assumption for those specific cases.

Kai: They demonstrate broad applicability across lanthanides and discuss its applicability to transition metal and actinide complexes, even with the noted limitations in those latter cases.

Mira: It’s a solid tool for detailed analysis of magnetic properties in these f-element systems when you have the right input calculations ready to go.

Lev: If you’re looking for a tool to help map out the landscape of crystal field parameters, this code is definitely worth checking out for your next project.

Kai: We've seen how they extend NewMag to handle more f configurations and incorporate second order correlated energies into the extraction process.

Lev: That’s fair; for hardware implementation, you need to know exactly where those coupling errors land so you can design better error mitigation strategies.

Kai: Overall, this paper on "The NewMag crystal-field code for f-element systems: Implementation for extended active spaces, second-order correlated energies, and generalisation to fn configurations" provides a detailed method for extracting Stevens parameters from complex ab initio calculations Gwenhaël Duplaix-Rata,one Dumitru-Claudiu Sergentu,two Dumitru Le Guennic,one and Rémi Maurice*one one)Univ Rennes, CNRS, ISCR (Institut des Sciences Chimiques de Rennes) – UMR six thousand two hundred twenty-six F-thirty-five thousand Rennes France <ref:2609.37541#pg1,Le Guennic,1 and Rémi Maurice*1 1)Univ Rennes, CNRS, ISCR>.

Mira: It’s a helpful tool for pushing the analysis of magnetic properties in f-element systems further than before.

Lev: We need to keep an eye on those normalization corrections because they are a necessary part of getting those final, comparable numbers.

More episodes

← Home