The joint dynamics of Personal, Expressed and Social beliefs

summary

The gist

Beliefs are central to individual decision-making and societal dynamics, and they are shaped through complex interactions between personal cognition and social environments <ref:2502.14362#pg2> The…

In short

The PES meta-model integrates personal, expressed, and social beliefs to understand belief dynamics. It formalizes processes like ego projection and social influence while allowing comparison with existing models. The model shows how misperception occurs when people conform their expressed beliefs to perceived beliefs of others, revealing a mechanism for collective misperceptions.

Key concepts

Personal Beliefs
These are the private beliefs held by an individual that are known only to them. They form the core of an agent's internal cognitive state and are subject to internal processes like self-reinforcement and dissonance when challenged by external information.
Expressed Beliefs
These are the beliefs an individual shares with others, representing their public stance. The model distinguishes these from personal beliefs to analyze how individuals strategically distort what they say based on what they perceive others believe.
Social Beliefs
These refer to an individual's beliefs about the personal and expressed beliefs of other people. This layer captures the perception of others' minds, which is crucial for understanding phenomena like pluralistic ignorance and how social influence shapes belief change.

Terminology used across episodes

This episode discusses

The paper

The joint dynamics of Personal, Expressed and Social beliefs · Read on arXiv

Filippo Zimmaro, Henrik Olsson

University of Bologna · University of Pisa · Complexity Science Hub Vienna

Understanding belief dynamics is essential for dealing with societal phenomena from misperceptions and conflicts to polarization and stalemates in collective action. However, it is impeded by two main challenges. First, rich and largely qualitative knowledge about socio-cognitive processes involved in belief change and spread is insufficiently integrated into computational models of belief dynamics. Second, while numerous models of belief dynamics exist, they are rarely compared because of the differences in underlying theoretical frameworks and modeling choices. Here we address these two problems by developing a Personal, Expressed, and Social Beliefs (PES) meta-model in which personal beliefs co-evolve with one's expressed beliefs and perceived beliefs of others. It formalizes many critical socio-cognitive processes including authenticity, self-reinforcement, ego projection, social influence, conformity, validity, context effects, inertia, and potential and felt dissonance. It also enables principled comparison of a wide range of existing belief-dynamics models as its nested versions, from Voter, Ising, and DeGroot models, to bounded confidence and belief network models. We show how PES can be used to compare possible mechanisms underlying pluralistic ignorance, and find that it can occur when people conform their expressed beliefs to perceived beliefs of others, in particular when they have limited expressive repertoire (e.g., like, dislike, or stay silent). Counterintuitively, pluralistic ignorance can be dissolved when everyone ego-projects their own personal beliefs onto others to the same extent. Ego-projection generates misperception only when it is heterogeneous and covaries with personal beliefs. These results yield testable hypotheses and help predict when interventions will change personal, expressed, or social beliefs.

Transcript

Introduction to the show: ident: Physics. The day in general physics: instruments, methods and results across the field.

Kai: We're looking at the paper: "The joint dynamics of Personal, Expressed and Social beliefs".

Mira: Here's the gist of the paper. Beliefs are central to individual decision-making and societal dynamics, and they are shaped through complex interactions between personal cognition and social environments <ref:2502.14362#pg2> The Personal, Expressed, and Social Beliefs (PES) meta-model represents belief dynamics through three belief types: Personal beliefs, Expressed beliefs, and Social beliefs about others (PES) <ref:2502.14362#pg2> This distinction allows the model to account for the potential misperception of others’ beliefs as well as distortions in the belief expression, and it permits the formalization of psychological processes such as ego projection, social influence, authenticity, and conformity <ref:2502.14362#pg2> The PES meta-model also encompasses many existing belief dynamics models, such as versions of the Voter, Ising, DeGroot, and bounded confidence models <ref:2502.14362#pg2> Its nested structure enables comparative analyses between different models and supports the construction of new models by recombining its components <ref:2502.14362#pg2>.

Kai: Conceptual Framework of the PES Meta-Model The PES model addresses gaps in traditional belief dynamics models by integrating personal beliefs held privately, expressed beliefs that are shared with others, and social beliefs about others’ personal beliefs <ref:2502.14362#pg2> Building on the Networks of Beliefs (NB) theory

1: , the PES model captures both the interactions within individuals’ minds and their strategic expression of beliefs in social settings <ref:2502.14362#pg2>.

Mira: The model differentiates between potential and felt dissonance, where potential dissonance refers to inconsistencies or discrepancies within one’s beliefs, while felt dissonance describes the psychological discomfort that arises from recognizing these inconsistencies <ref:2502.14362#pg2>.

Kai: Mechanisms of Belief Updating The model describes how personal beliefs are updated through dissonance with social beliefs, expressed beliefs, other personal beliefs, and past personal beliefs <ref:2502.14362#pg2>.

Paper summary: Kai: So we're looking at this paper, "The joint dynamics of Personal, Expressed and Social beliefs." It tackles how beliefs are central to decision-making and societal dynamics, showing they're shaped by complex interactions between personal thought and the social world.

Mira: Exactly. The authors are proposing a meta-model called PES, which stands for Personal, Expressed, and Social beliefs. This framework introduces three specific types of belief: what you truly believe privately, what you actually express to others, and what you think other people believe about you or them.

Lev: So the core idea here seems to be that traditional models often miss how these internal systems interact with external influences like social pressure. They suggest this PES structure lets us formalize things like ego projection, authenticity, and conformity which are hard to model together usually.

Kai: Right, so it’s not just looking at one kind of belief change, but how the personal belief interacts with the expressed and the perceived beliefs of others all at once. It claims this distinction allows for accounting for both misperceptions about what others hold and distortions in how people actually express their beliefs.

Mira: And that structure lets them formalize processes like ego projection, where you project your own beliefs onto other people, or authenticity, which is when your personal belief matches what you express. They also bring in social influence and conformity as part of this system.

Lev: I wonder how much real-world fidelity we can get with these processes when we try to run them on actual hardware for things like error correction? The overhead for modeling all these interactions sounds pretty heavy.

Kai: That’s a fair point, Lev. But what the paper does is show this PES meta-model can encompass a wide range of existing belief dynamics models, like the Voter or Ising models, and even bounded confidence models. It shows how different existing structures map onto this PES framework by setting specific alignment conditions.

Mira: So they are using this meta-model to compare these various established theories. They show how you can take fundamental models without those distinctions between belief types and map them into the PES structure by setting certain parameters, like saying the social perception always matches the expressed belief.

Lev: If we look at those mappings, it sounds like they are showing how different levels of separation between personal and expressed beliefs—say, where they assume social perception equals expressed belief—change what kind of dynamics you get. That’s useful for figuring out which assumptions are necessary for a certain outcome.

Paper summary: Kai: And then the paper actually uses this framework to look at real-world examples, like public support for climate change policies. They use it to see how individuals might strategically distort their expressed beliefs to match what they think others believe, which creates a feedback loop of misperception.

Mira: That’s interesting because they found that pluralistic ignorance, that feeling of being alone in your doubts because you don't know what others think, can actually happen when people conform their expressed beliefs to the perceived beliefs of others.

Lev: Wait, so the mechanism for misperception is actually conformity to perceived social norms rather than just everyone holding a slightly wrong personal belief? That shifts where we need to focus our error correction research.

Kai: It does. They also found a counterintuitive point: pluralistic ignorance can dissolve when everyone ego projects their own personal beliefs onto others with the same level of intensity. This suggests that if the projection is uniform, the misperception disappears even if individual beliefs are still slightly off.

Mira: So it's not just about changing one person's belief, but about how many people are projecting in a consistent way to affect the social perception, which then feeds back into their expression. It’s a collective adjustment process.

Lev: From an engineering standpoint, if we model this as an error-correction problem, it means the correction isn't just fixing individual errors; it’s managing the alignment between personal states and social states across many interacting nodes. That makes the required resources much more complex than simple local updates.

Kai: The paper does mention that they can use this to test hypotheses about when interventions will actually change personal, expressed, or social beliefs. They suggest this framework gives us a way to predict those changes by looking at the interactions between these three belief types.

Mira: So the point of it all is that by separating these three layers, we can finally get a unified way to study phenomena where misperception and distorted expression happen together in a society. It’s about understanding that interplay more thoroughly than previous models allowed.

Lev: It seems like the practical application here is helping us design better systems for influencing collective belief because now we have a model that accounts for the layers of influence involved. The limitations they mention is that the current PES model assumes a static network structure, which means it might not fully capture how connections themselves change as beliefs evolve over time.

Kai: That’s the limitation they flag. They suggest future work could integrate adaptive networks, where those connections adjust dynamically, or maybe even let the weights of social processes evolve through reinforcement learning.

Paper summary: Mira: So the PES meta-model is a very flexible tool for organizing existing theories and testing them against these complex social psychological mechanisms. It’s not just adding a new equation; it’s building a structure that can hold many different dynamics simultaneously.

Lev: It sounds like they are providing the scaffolding to compare voter models, Ising models, and bounded confidence models all under one roof, which is what we needed to see more clearly for real hardware. The appendix shows how you can reduce this back down to those simpler versions by setting specific parameters.

Kai: And that’s really neat because it lets us go from the big meta-model down to the specific dynamics we already understand well. It shows where the complexity is added when you start including all these layers of interaction like ego projection and authentic expression.

Mira: So, if you're building a new model for belief dynamics, this framework gives you a clear template for what social processes need to be included to capture things like pluralistic ignorance accurately. It’s about making sure the mathematical structure reflects the actual psychology being studied.

Lev: For those of us building error correction systems, seeing how these models map onto real hardware constraints is key. It helps us understand where the computational load really lands when you try to simulate this kind of layered belief system on a computer.

Kai: So, to wrap up, the paper "The joint dynamics of Personal, Expressed and Social beliefs" introduces the PES meta-model which separates personal, expressed, and social beliefs to formally study how they interact through processes like ego projection and conformity. It’s a tool that lets us compare existing belief models while showing how misperception can arise from strategic expression aligning with perceived norms.

Mira: The real takeaway is that we need to look beyond just one way people believe or express themselves; we have to account for the whole system where what we think, what we say, and what we think others think are all dynamically linked.

Lev: It opens up new avenues for testing interventions by predicting how changes in one layer—personal or social—will propagate through the whole structure. That predictive power is something useful when you're trying to design anything that affects collective behavior.

Kai: It’s a lot of interconnected ideas, but the paper lays out a very clear structure for thinking about belief dynamics in complex social environments.

Mira: It’s definitely a framework for organizing the huge amount of research already out there on social psychology into something more comprehensive and testable.

Conclusion: Kai: So we've been looking at how beliefs are shaped by personal thoughts and social settings through this new PES meta-model paper.

Mira: Right, so they’re proposing this Personal Expressed Social Beliefs framework to look at those complex interactions between what you think, what you say, and what others think about you.

Kai: Yeah, the authors are building a way to handle both how beliefs change internally and how those changes show up in social situations.

Mira: They formalize things like ego projection and conformity within this structure so we can finally model them together with other belief dynamics theories.

Kai: It seems like the authors are really trying to bridge that gap between just looking at one type of belief change and understanding the whole system at once.

Mira: Exactly, they're using it as a way to compare existing models like the voter or ising models against this new structure.

Kai: The main point is they can use this framework to test hypotheses about when interventions will actually change personal or social beliefs in a real setting.

Mira: It gives us a tool to look at collective misperceptions, like that climate change support example, by seeing how distorted expression and misperception feed back into each other.

Kai: And the paper points out that pluralistic ignorance can happen when people conform their expressed beliefs to what they think others believe about them.

Mira: That's a key finding, it suggests misperception isn't just about one person being wrong; it’s about how many people are adjusting their expression based on perceived social norms.

Kai: It also says that this effect can sometimes disappear if everyone projects their own personal beliefs onto others with the exact same level of intensity.

Mira: So, it suggests a collective adjustment process is happening when we see misperception in public opinion, which is something we need to keep watching as we build better models for collective behavior.

Kai: This meta-model provides a flexible structure that lets us explore belief dynamics in really messy social environments by keeping those three layers linked.

Mira: It opens up new ways to study the interplay between private thought, public expression, and social perception that previous models just couldn't handle as well.

More episodes

← Home