Photoneutron Yield for an Electron Beam on Tantalum and Erbium Deuteride

summary

The gist

An electron beam may be used to generate bremsstrahlung photons that go on to create photoneutrons within metals This article presents simulation results for optimizing photoneutron yield for a…

In short

The study simulated using a 10-MeV electron beam to create photoneutrons by irradiating tantalum foil followed by erbium deuteride. The optimal setup involved 1.5 mm of tantalum and a 12 cm layer of ErD3, maximizing directional neutron yield. This method is feasible for generating up to $10^{12}$ neutrons per second using a 2-mA beam.

Key concepts

Bremsstrahlung Photons
These are high-energy photons produced when the 10-MeV electron beam is slowed down or decelerated as it interacts with the metal target. These photons are the primary source that subsequently creates photoneutrons within the material layers.
Photoneutron Yield
This measures how many neutrons are produced per unit of incident electron beam energy and target material. The simulations showed that combining a specific tantalum thickness (1.5 mm) with a 12 cm layer of erbium deuteride resulted in the highest directional yield.
Directional Yield
This refers to the percentage of photoneutrons that exit the material along the same axis as they were generated. The study found that a 12 cm thickness of ErD3 provided the maximum level for this specific directional output, with an average energy near 14 keV.
ErD3 Layer Optimization
The simulation determined that a 12 cm thickness of erbium deuteride is ideal for maximizing the directional photoneutron yield. While increasing ErD3 thickness generally increases yield, this specific dimension provided the peak performance for neutrons exiting in one direction.

Terminology used across episodes

This episode discusses

The paper

Photoneutron Yield for an Electron Beam on Tantalum and Erbium Deuteride · Read on arXiv

Andrew K. Gillespie, Cuikun Lin, R. V. Duncan

Department of Physics and Astronomy, Texas Tech University

An electron beam may be used to generate bremsstrahlung photons that go on to create photoneutrons within metals. This serves as a low-energy neutron source for irradiation experiments [1-3]. In this article, we present simulation results for optimizing photoneutron yield for a 10-MeV electron beam on tantalum foil and erbium deuteride (ErD 3). The thickness of the metal layers was varied. A tantalum foil thickness of 1.5 mm resulted in the most photons reaching the second metal layer. When a second metal layer of ErD 3 was included, the photoneutron yield increased with the thickness of the secondary layer. When the electron beam was directly incident upon a layer of ErD 3, the photoneutron yield did not differ significantly from the yield when a layer of tantalum was included. The directional photoneutron yield reached a maximum level when the thickness of the ErD 3 layer was around 12 cm. About 1 neutron was generated per 10 4 source electrons. When using a 2-mA beam current, it is possible to generate up to 10 12 neutrons per second, making this combination a relatively-inexpensive neutron generator.

DOI: 10.1016/j.net.2024.03.007

Transcript

Introduction to the show: ident: Physics. The day in general physics: instruments, methods and results across the field.

Kai: We're looking at the paper: "Photoneutron Yield for an Electron Beam on Tantalum and Erbium Deuteride".

Mira: Here's the gist of the paper. An electron beam may be used to generate bremsstrahlung photons that go on to create photoneutrons within metals This article presents simulation results for optimizing photoneutron yield for a 10-MeV electron beam on tantalum foil and erbium deuteride Optimization of Material Thickness The simulations investigated the impact of varying metal layer thicknesses on the neutron generation process The study found that a tantalum foil thickness of 1.5 mm resulted in the most photons reaching the second metal layer When a second metal layer of ErD3 was included, the photoneutron yield increased with the thickness of the secondary layer The directional photoneutron yield reached a maximum level when the thickness of the ErD3 layer was around 12 cm Comparison of Target Materials The research compared the performance of different materials and beam incident configurations When a second metal layer of ErD3 was included, the photoneutron yield increased with the thickness of the secondary layer When the electron beam was directly incident upon a layer of ErD3, the photoneutron yield did not differ significantly from the yield when a layer of tantalum was included Therefore, it is not beneficial to include the tantalum layer, and instead, run the electron beam directly into the ErD3 layer to generate the most neutrons Directional Yield Analysis The study focused on maximizing neutron flux in a specific direction A smaller fraction of photoneutrons exit the layer along the same axis as the source This directional yield reaches a peak when the thickness of the ErD3 layer is around 12 cm The weighted average energy of these directional photoneutrons is near 14 keV Feasibility and Output Rates The overall simulation indicated that about 1 neutron is generated per 104 source electrons in the beam When using a 2-mA beam current, it is possible to generate up to around 1012 neutrons per second This combination makes the setup a relatively inexpensive neutron generator that could be employed in numerous applications, including fusion research The bremsstrahlung photon and photoneutron yield was simulated for a 10-MeV electron beam incident on tantalum foil and erbium deuteride A tantalum foil thickness of 1.5 mm resulted in the most photons reaching the second metal layer The directional photoneutron yield reached a maximum level when a 12 cm-thick layer of erbium deuteride was included behind the tantalum layer When using a 2-mA beam current, it is possible to generate up to 1012 neutrons per second Acknowledgements and Data The authors would like to thank Dr John Gahl at the University of Missouri for their useful discussions The data that support the findings of this study are available from the corresponding author upon reasonable request References The paper cites numerous sources regarding neutron sources, accelerator models, and material thresholds The references cover topics such as alpha neutron sources, spontaneous fission neutron sources like Cf-252, and commercially available electron generators Specific studies on photoneutron generation using electron beams on targets like Ta or W are referenced Information regarding material thresholds for high and low threshold reactions is provided in tables referencing specific nuclides like Pb, Ta, and D The simulation methodology relies on Monte Carlo n-Particle (MCNPTM 6.2) transport calculations The paper includes detailed figures illustrating the photon energy spectrum and neutron yield as a function of layer thickness Detailed information on the energy spectrum of photons reaching the tally zone is presented in Figure 6 The authors acknowledge support from NIAC Phase I contract No.

Kai: 80NSSC23K0592 and the Texas Research Incentive Program The work is supported by Texas Tech University Table Summaries Table 1 summarizes different types of neutron sources and their respective yields, including alpha, gamma, spontaneous fission, fission reactors, and accelerators Table 2 lists commercially available electron generators with their type and energy specifications Table 3 provides an overview of materials along with their corresponding high threshold reactions for neutron generation Table 4 provides an overview of materials along with their corresponding low threshold reactions, highlighting D and Be-9 The paper also references specific experimental findings related to electron beam irradiation of deuterated metals The reference list contains detailed citations for fusion reactions in deuterated metals and specific accelerator models like the TT50 RhodotronTM Figure Descriptions Figure 1 illustrates a typical design of a photoneutron generator involving an electron beam incident on tantalum, tungsten, or lead Figure 2 shows simulation sets involving only tantalum and both tantalum and erbium deuteride layers Figure 3 displays the percentage of electrons reaching the tally region behind the tantalum layer as thickness is varied Figure 4 shows the number of photons created as a function of tantalum thickness Figure 5 displays the average track length estimate for photons reaching the tally region behind the tantalum layer as thickness is varied Figure 6 displays the bremsstrahlung photon energy spectrum with varied tantalum thickness Figure 7 shows photoneutrons generated as a function of increasing ErD3 thickness and compares two beam incident scenarios Figure 8 shows the photoneutrons entering the tally zone behind the ErD3 as a function of increasing ErD3 thickness Figure 9 displays the energy spectrum of photoneutrons entering the tally zone behind the ErD3 layer of 12-cm thickness The paper includes detailed technical specifications for accelerator models such as the TT50 RhodotronTM The simulation geometry involves a disk layer of tantalum and a cylinder of erbium deuteride The study utilized one hundred million histories in their calculations for all simulations All simulations used the same 10-MeV electron beam as a planar source The paper discusses the concept that neutrons can also be generated using electrons with an energy of 10 MeV The authors note that nearly all neutrons were generated from photodissociation and only between 0.02 – 0.03% were created from (n, xn) reactions within the metals Final Synthesis The overall finding is that a 12 cm-thick layer of erbium deuteride provides the maximum directional photoneutron yield when combined with an optimally thick tantalum layer The feasibility of this setup as a relatively inexpensive neutron generator is demonstrated through the calculated production rates The combination of a 10-MeV electron beam and bremsstrahlung photons successfully generates photoneutrons in metals This method offers a viable, low-cost option for generating neutrons for applications like fusion research The bremsstrahlung photon and photoneutron yield was simulated for a 10-MeV electron beam incident on tantalum foil and erbium deuteride A tantalum foil thickness of 1.5 mm resulted in the most photons reaching the second metal layer The directional photoneutron yield reached a maximum level when a 12 cm-thick layer of erbium deuteride was included behind the tantalum layer When using a 2-mA beam current, it is possible to generate up to 1012 neutrons per second This combination makes the setup a relatively inexpensive neutron generator that could be employed in numerous applications, including fusion research References The paper cites numerous sources regarding neutron sources, accelerator models, and material thresholds The references cover topics such as alpha neutron sources, spontaneous fission neutron sources like Cf-252, and commercially available electron generators Specific studies on photoneutron generation using electron beams on targets like Ta or W are referenced Information regarding material thresholds for high and low threshold reactions is provided in tables referencing specific nuclides like Pb, Ta, and D The simulation methodology relies on Monte Carlo n-Particle (MCNPTM 6.2) transport calculations The paper includes detailed figures illustrating the photon energy spectrum and neutron yield as a function of layer thickness Detailed information on the energy spectrum of photons reaching the tally zone is presented in Figure 6 References The paper cites numerous sources regarding neutron sources, accelerator models, and material thresholds The references cover topics such as alpha neutron sources, spontaneous fission neutron sources like Cf-252, and commercially available electron generators Specific studies on photoneutron generation using electron beams on targets like Ta or W are referenced Information regarding material thresholds for high and low threshold reactions is provided in tables referencing specific nuclides like Pb, Ta, and D The simulation methodology relies on Monte Carlo n-Particle (MCNPTM 6.

Paper summary: Kai: Thinking about the title of the paper, "Photoneutron Yield for an Electron Beam on Tantalum and Erbium Deuteride," it really frames this as a focused study on a specific interaction mechanism.

Mira: It’s about what happens when you use bremsstrahlung photons generated by an electron beam to create photoneutrons within metals like tantalum and erbium deuteride.

Lev: The implications are that this method offers a viable, low-cost option for generating neutrons for applications like fusion research, which is important because those applications need a steady source of neutrons.

Kai: They’ve shown that by tuning the metal layers—finding that one point five millimeters of tantalum foil and then adding a twelve centimeter layer of ErD3—you can maximize the directional photoneutron yield <ref:2308.02629#pg1>.

Mira: The key thing they pointed out is that when you run the beam directly into the ErD3, it performs just as well as using the tantalum layer, which really simplifies how you think about setting up a practical generator.

Lev: So, for someone who only listens to this show, what this means is that we have a concrete way to generate neutrons using a relatively modest electron beam setup and specific material thicknesses.

Kai: It’s not about building the biggest source, but it’s about getting the most neutrons per unit of beam current by understanding these material thresholds and layer combinations.

Mira: They also give us a production rate for a two milliampere beam current, showing up to one thousand twelve neutrons per second, which puts this in perspective against other neutron sources they mentioned.

Lev: That's the engineering reality; it’s about feasibility at a specific output rate, not just achieving an abstract maximum yield in simulation.

Kai: So the conclusion is that this combination of a ten-MeV electron beam and bremsstrahlung photons successfully generates photoneutrons in metals, offering a low-cost path for neutron generation <ref:2308.02629#pg1,a 10-MeV electron beam>.

Conclusion: Kai: So we just looked at how they're generating photoneutrons using a ten mega electron beam on tantalum and erbium deuteride today, and now we’re getting to the conclusion part of this paper.

Mira: It’s about summarizing what they found regarding that yield optimization, really focusing on how the setup works.

Lev: They ended up figuring out that a specific thickness combination gave them the best directional output for those neutrons.

Kai: The main point here is that by tuning those material thicknesses, you can get a much better result than just throwing everything together randomly.

Mira: Right, they found that having fifteen millimeters of tantalum foil plus twelve centimeters of erbium deuteride was the sweet spot for maximizing the directional photoneutron yield.

Lev: From an engineering standpoint, that's practical because it gives you a clear target for your beamline design to aim for.

Kai: But what does this actually mean when we look at the bigger picture? It shows a path to using electron beams in metal targets to create neutrons without needing super heavy neutron sources.

Mira: Exactly. They’ve shown that this is feasible as a relatively inexpensive way to generate neutrons, which is huge for fusion research applications they mentioned.

Lev: And the rate they calculated, up to one thousand twelve neutrons per second with a two milliampere beam current, gives you a concrete performance metric you can actually plan around.

Kai: It’s less about building the world's biggest source and more about finding an efficient way to get useful neutrons using what we already have in terms of electron accelerators.

Mira: So it opens up a new avenue for fusion experiments that might be much more accessible than traditional neutron generator designs right now.

Lev: And while this is a simulation, it tells us the fundamental physics and material interactions we need to worry about when designing real hardware for this kind of source.

More episodes

← Home