New approach to approximate analytical solutions for a harmonic oscillator subject to combined linear and nonlinear damping

summary

The gist

New approach to approximate analytical solutions of a harmonic oscillator with weak to moderate nonlinear damping is introduced by developing an ansatz based on the product of a time-dependent…

In short

A new method approximates analytical solutions for a harmonic oscillator with weak to moderate nonlinear damping by using an ansatz combining a time-dependent amplitude and an oscillatory function with a different initial phase. This approach yields excellent agreement with numerical results for quadratic, Coulomb, and combined damping types across various regimes.

Key concepts

Ansatz
A chosen trial solution form for the oscillator's motion. In this paper, it is structured as the product of a time-dependent amplitude function and an oscillatory trigonometric function. This mathematical structure helps simplify the complex differential equations by making approximations about how the amplitude changes over time.
Initial Phase ($\phi$)
The starting point of the oscillation in the ansatz solution, which is intentionally set to be different from the undamped case. Determining this phase, along with the initial amplitude ($A$), is crucial for matching the physical starting conditions of the actual system and accurately describing its subsequent evolution.
Energy Dissipation Rate
The rate at which energy leaves the system due to damping forces. The method connects this rate to the power dissipated by damping forces and approximates slow changes in amplitude over time, allowing researchers to derive equations for amplitude decay based on this energy loss.
Turning Point ($t_0$)
A specific instant in time where the displacement of the oscillator reaches its maximum or minimum value before reversing direction. The improved solution for Coulomb damping specifically tracks dynamics up to this turning point, providing a more accurate description of motion near the halt.

Terminology used across episodes

This episode discusses

The paper

New approach to approximate analytical solutions for a harmonic oscillator subject to combined linear and nonlinear damping · Read on arXiv

Karlo Lelas, Robert Pezer

Faculty of Textile Technology, University of Zagreb · Department of Physical Metallurgy, Faculty of Metallurgy, University of Zagreb

We introduce a new approach to deriving approximate analytical solutions of a harmonic oscillator damped by purely nonlinear, or combinations of linear and nonlinear damping forces. Our approach is based on choosing a suitable trial solution, i.e. an ansatz, which is the product of the time-dependent amplitude and the oscillatory (trigonometric) function with a reduced frequency (due solely to linear damping) and an initial phase shift (due to both linear and nonlinear damping) compared to the undamped case. We derive the amplitude decay equation using the connection of the energy dissipation rate with the power of the total damping force. By matching our ansatz to the initial conditions, we obtain equations for its initial amplitude and initial phase. We demonstrate the validity of our approach for quadratic damping, a combination of linear and quadratic damping, and finally a combination of linear, quadratic, and Coulomb damping. For pure quadratic damping and for a combination of linear and quadratic damping, we compare our approximate analytical solutions with the corresponding numerical solutions and find that they describe the oscillator dynamics well in the regime of weak to moderately strong damping. For the combination of all three types of damping, our solutions agree well with the numerical solutions until the last half-period or the last few half-periods of the motion (primarily depending on the strength of the Coulomb damping). In addition, we show how to use our solutions to determine damping constants from given displacement vs. time data, demonstrating that they can be applied to the analysis of experiments.

Transcript

Introduction to the show: ident: Physics. The day in general physics: instruments, methods and results across the field.

Kai: We're looking at the paper: "New approach to approximate analytical solutions for a harmonic oscillator subject to combined linear and nonlinear damping".

Mira: Here's the gist of the paper. New approach to approximate analytical solutions of a harmonic oscillator with weak to moderate nonlinear damping is introduced by developing an ansatz based on the product of a time-dependent amplitude and an oscillatory function with a different initial phase compared to the undamped case The approach demonstrates excellent agreement with numerical solutions for quadratic damping, Coulomb damping, and their combinations in weak to moderately strong regimes The new method is based on choosing a suitable trial solution, i.e., an ansatz, which is the product of the timedependent amplitude and the oscillatory (trigonometric) function that has the same frequency but different initial phase compared to the undamped case The equation for amplitude decay is derived by connecting energy dissipation rate with power of total damping force and approximating slow amplitude changes over time compared to the oscillating part of the ansatz By matching the ansatz to initial conditions, equations for initial amplitude and phase are obtained The ansatz used is of the form x(t) = Af(t) cos(ω0t + φ), where A and φ are unknown constants and f(t) describes the amplitude decay Results for Damping Quadratic in Velocity For damping quadratic in velocity, the approximate solution (11) is derived as x(t) = Af(t) cos(ω0t + φ), where f(t) is obtained by solving an integral equation derived from approximating the energy dissipation rate For initial conditions (x0 > 0, v0 = 0), the amplitude A and phase φ are determined by a quadratic equation and an arctan expression The resulting solution (31) describes the dynamics for a range of damping constants where d2A0/ω0 ≲ 0.5, and it is valid even for moderately strong damping Results for Coulomb Damping For Coulomb damping, the approximate solution (11) is written as x(t) = (A − d0t) θ(t) cos(ω0t + φ), where θ(t) is a step function The approach provides an improved solution (41), which describes the dynamics up to the instant t0, corresponding to the last turning point with displacement x(t0) > µmg/k This improved solution is valid for a range of damping constant 0 < µ ≤ 0.048, i.e., for 0 < d0/(ω0A0) ≤ 0.05 Results for Combined Damping For the combination of Coulomb and quadratic damping, the approximate solution (47) provides a significantly better description of the dynamics compared to solutions obtained by approach

14: The approach is valid for damping constants µ and D such that 0 < d0/(ω0A0) ≤ 0.03 and 0 < d2A0/ω0 ≤ 0.25 hold, unless high precision at the very end of the dynamics is required The new analytical solutions provide an excellent description of the dynamics for all types of initial conditions and a wide range of damping constants The most elegant result is obtained for quadratic damping, where the initial amplitude A is easily obtained analytically by solving a simple quadratic equation For other cases, solving the quartic equation to obtain the initial amplitude A can be done numerically The approach for combined linear and nonlinear damping is expected to bring significant improvements compared to previous solutions for this combination of damping forces Acknowledgements K.L.

Kai: and R.P.

Mira: acknowledge support from the project “Implementation of cutting-edge research and its application as part of the Scientific Center of Excellence for Quantum and Complex Systems, and Representations of Lie Algebras”, Grant No.

Kai: PK.1.1.10.0004, co-financed by the European Union through the European Regional Development Fund - Competitiveness and Cohesion Programme 2021-2027 References

1: Frank S.

Title and authors: Kai: The paper's title is "New approach to approximate analytical solutions for a harmonic oscillator subject to combined linear and nonlinear damping". This tells us right away that they are trying to bridge the gap between simple, solvable models and the messy reality of systems with mixed damping.

Mira: It’s about finding an approximate solution when you have both linear, like viscous damping, and nonlinear forces involved. The implication here is that it gives us a tool to get solutions where before we might only have approximations that work for very weak damping.

Lev: So what's the actual takeaway? Does this mean we can solve problems on real hardware that currently require heavy numerical simulation? What kind of fidelity are we talking about with an analytical approximation?

Kai: The paper shows excellent agreement with numerical solutions for quadratic damping, Coulomb damping, and even combinations of those forces when they are in weak to moderately strong regimes. It’s not just a theory; they tested it against simulations.

Mira: That's the key part of what they are showing—that this method isn't just theoretical math on paper; it actually holds up against more rigorous numerical tests across different damping types.

The paper's summary: Kai: So, to summarize the core finding of this paper, they introduce an ansatz based on the product of a time-dependent amplitude and a trigonometric function with a different initial phase compared to the undamped case.

Mira: They then derive the equation governing that amplitude decay by relating it to the energy dissipation rate and approximating slow amplitude changes relative to the fast oscillatory part of their trial solution.

Lev: So, instead of just throwing in an arbitrary function for amplitude decay, they are deriving a specific form for it based on physical principles about how energy is dissipated? That sounds like a real step forward for modeling non-linear dissipation.

Kai: It’s more than just guessing; they connect the energy loss rate to the total damping force power and make an approximation that the amplitude changes slowly compared to the oscillation, which allows them to derive that specific equation for decay.

Mira: And by matching this ansatz back to the starting conditions, they get equations for that unknown initial amplitude and phase, giving them a complete picture of how the system starts behaving.

The paper's improvements: Kai: The authors highlight several improvements in this new approach. They show that for quadratic damping, they can solve for the initial amplitude A analytically by solving a simple quadratic equation.

Mira: That’s significant because finding an analytical solution is always nice, but it only works if the resulting equation is manageable, so getting that simple quadratic form for the amplitude decay is a big win.

Lev: For other damping types, they mention that solving for the initial amplitude A might require solving a quartic equation numerically instead of analytically. That adds complexity when you try to implement this on real hardware where we need fast calculations.

Kai: They also provide specific conditions for validity based on the damping constants. For instance, for quadratic damping, their solution is valid even for moderately strong damping as long as the ratio d squared A zero over omega zero is less than or equal to zero point five <ref:2512.23590#pg2>.

Mira: And they have similar constraints for Coulomb damping, where their improved solution describes the dynamics up to a specific turning point t zero which is when the displacement x(t zero) hits a certain value related to gravity and the spring constant <ref:2512.23590#pg2>.

Conclusion: Kai: So, wrapping up this paper on "New approach to approximate analytical solutions for a harmonic oscillator subject to combined linear and nonlinear damping", the main point is that this new method gives us excellent descriptions of dynamics across a wide range of damping constants for quadratic, Coulomb, and their combinations.

Mira: It’s elegant because it provides better descriptions than previous approaches, especially when we look at the combined cases like Coulomb and quadratic damping. They provide specific validity ranges based on ratios like d zero over omega zero or d squared A zero over omega zero that define where the approximations hold up <ref:2512.23590#pg2>.

Lev: From my side, what’s important is that for real hardware, you still have to solve a quartic equation numerically sometimes to get the initial amplitude, so it’s not a plug-and-play analytical solution for every single damping scenario.

Kai: It's definitely an improvement over previous methods because it gives us better descriptions for all types of initial conditions and a wider range of damping constants than what we had before. We get to see how the system behaves more realistically.

Mira: The overall implication is that this approach can bring significant improvements when modeling systems with combined linear and nonlinear damping forces, especially where you need to describe the dynamics near the end of motion accurately for things like Coulomb damping.

Lev: So, we’re looking at a better analytical tool, but it still has limits—for really high precision right at the very end of the dynamics, they flag that you might need more work. But it's a solid foundation for our simulations.

More episodes

← Home