Isotopic effect on collisional widths and shifts of Hg clock transition induced by cold Rb atoms
summary
The gist
Isotopic effect on collisional widths and shifts of Hg clock transition induced by cold Rb atoms is studied to understand how collisions between mercury and rubidium atoms perturb an optical clock…
In short
The study investigated how changing atoms (isotopes) affects how quickly a mercury clock transition broadens and shifts when interacting with cold rubidium atoms at ultra-low temperatures (1 nK to 1 K). Findings show that isotopic pairs can have minimal effects, but shape resonances cause large variations in collisional properties. The work guides the design of experiments involving these systems.
Key concepts
- Optical Clocks
- These are highly precise atomic clocks that use specific transitions, like the forbidden 1S0–3P0 transition in mercury. They are used to test fundamental physics and achieve extremely high accuracy in measuring frequencies.
- Collisional Width and Shift
- When two atoms collide, the clock transition's energy level is slightly altered. The 'width' describes how fast this alteration happens (broadening), while the 'shift' describes where the new energy level ends up (shifting). These are key measurements in studying atomic interactions.
- Isotopic Dependence
- This refers to how the physical properties of atoms change when they have different isotopes, meaning atoms with different numbers of neutrons. The paper examines how this difference impacts the collision dynamics between mercury and rubidium.
- Shape Resonances
- These are specific energy structures in the scattering states (how atoms interact) that cause dramatic changes in collisional properties like width and shift when the colliding atoms' reduced mass is changed.
Terminology used across episodes
This episode discusses
- Isotopic effect on collisional widths and shifts of Hg clock transition induced by cold Rb atoms · Paper Radio
- CODATA Recommended Values of the Fundamental Physical Constants: 2022
The paper
Isotopic effect on collisional widths and shifts of Hg clock transition induced by cold Rb atoms · Read on arXiv
Renu Bala, *, +, Adam Linek, +, Marcin Witkowski, Piotr S. Zuchowski ̇ 1
Institute of Physics, Faculty of Physics, Astronomy and Informatics, Nicolaus Copernicus University · Joint Quantum Institute, University of Maryland and NIST
We study the isotopic dependence of collisional widths and shifts of the Hg clock transition 1 S 0 - cubed P 0 perturbed by the Rb atoms in the temperature range from 1 nK to 1 K. For this purpose, we model the Born-Oppenheimer effective interaction potential by including the leading long-range van der Waals coefficients. For elastic collisions, we show the connection between the dependence of collision line shape parameters on the reduced mass of colliding partners as well as the variation of the scattering length in the excited and ground states of the Hg-Rb system in the K temperature range. We confront the full quantum scattering calculations with a semi-classical approximation for collisional widths and shifts. We show that the shape resonances in excited and ground scattering states lead to significant variations of collisional line shape parameters with the change of the reduced mass of colliding atoms. We also indicate the possible influence of inelastic collisions, which could lead to universal behavior and significantly affect the dependence of collisional broadening and shifting on the isotopic combination of colliding atoms.
Transcript
Introduction to the show: ident: Physics. The day in general physics: instruments, methods and results across the field.
Kai: I'm Kai.
Mira: And I'm Mira, here with Lev.
Kai: We're looking at the paper: "Isotopic effect on collisional widths and shifts of Hg clock transition induced by cold Rb atoms".
Mira: Here's the gist of the paper. Isotopic effect on collisional widths and shifts of Hg clock transition induced by cold Rb atoms studies the isotopic dependence of collisional widths and shifts of the Hg clock transition 1S0–3P0 perturbed by the Rb atoms in the temperature range from 1 nK to 1 K Optical atomic clocks exhibit remarkable precision and serve as powerful tools for investigating the fundamental laws of physics Among species used in the optical atomic clocks, the alkaline-earth and alkaline-earth-like atoms are of special importance due to the presence of the forbidden 1S0–3P0 transition Having the lowest susceptibility to blackbody radiation shifts in group II, Hg is a candidate for the best optical frequency standard Additionally, Hg is attractive due to its rich isotopic diversity, which, in combination with the forbidden transitions, 1S0–3P0 and 1S0–3P2, provides an opportunity for probing new fundamental interactions like Higgs boson couplings to the electron and the up and down quarks via the King plot linearity measurement Quantum Treatment of Collisional Dynamics The quantum approach describes interactions between a clock Hg atom in either ground g (1S0) or excited e (3P0) states, and a perturbing Rb atom in its ground electronic state (2S1/2) with good approximation by spherically symmetric single potentials Vg(r) and Ve(r) Collisions can be described with a single-channel approach using one-dimensional scattering matrices Sg(l,E) and Se(l,E), where l = 0,1,2,… represents the s, p,d,… partial waves The quantum scattering cross-section σqu(E) for collisional width and shift of the clock transition is then expressed by an infinite series over partial waves The resulting collisional width Γ(E) and shift ∆(E) in the impact approximation are given by Γ(E) +i∆(E) = n hk¯/µ σqu(E) Isotopic Dependence and Resonance Structure The results show that there are some isotopic pairs for which collisional effects are minimal, making these pairs suitable for two-species atomic clocks The shape resonances in excited and ground scattering states lead to significant variations of collisional line shape parameters with the change of the reduced mass of colliding atoms For example, for the assumed specific values of C6,i and σi used in the presented calculations, the collisional width and shift corresponding to the reduced mass of 198Hg and 85Rb system are substantially large The dependence of elastic collisional widths and shifts on the reduced mass is studied at different collisional energies E/kB ranging from 1 µK to 1 K as shown in Figures.
Kai: 2 and 3 Influence of Inelastic Collisions The inelasticity of collisions caused by Penning ionization can change the isotopic variation of collisional broadening and shifting, even leading to elimination of resonances related to the excited state due to the universal behavior of such collisions The authors compare results obtained only for the elastic collisions with those from Idziaszek and Julienne model by varying probability of reduction of the outgoing scattering flux caused by Penning ionization which takes place at short range They demonstrate that the low-energy approximation given by Eqs.
Mira: (6) and (8) well reproduces the s-wave resonances at their wings for collisional energies, E/kB = 1 µK, and lower The collisional width and shift of a clock transition at ultra-low temperatures can vary by orders of magnitude and exhibit resonance structure These variations decrease at higher temperatures However, even at a temperature around 1 K, the variations remain in the order of tens of percent The paper shows that at ultra-low temperatures around 1 µK, the collisional width and shift can be accurately estimated using simple analytical expressions within the s-wave approximation along with the scattering lengths for colliding Hg and Rb atoms in the ground (1S0–2S1/2) and excited (3P0–2S1/2) state asymptote The full quantum scattering calculations of collisional width and shift, performed at a scattering energy corresponding to 1 K, agree with the classical approximation within 30% and 60%, respectively In this work, they investigate the isotopic dependence of collisional widths and shifts of the Hg clock transition 1S0–3P0, when perturbed by the Rb atoms with collisional energies E/kB in the range from 1 nK to 1 K They demonstrate the connection between the dependence of collisional line shape parameters on the reduced mass of the colliding partners, as well as the variation of the scattering length in the ground and excited state of the Hg-Rb system when elastic collisions are taken into account The collisional width and shift exhibit resonance structure and can vary by orders of magnitude at ultra-low temperatures They indicate that the inelasticity of collisions caused by Penning ionization can change the isotopic variation of collisional broadening and shifting The work provides guidance for understanding and designing experiments involving these systems Data Availability The datasets generated and analyzed during the current study are available in the open repository References The references listed cover topics such as optical clocks, atomic spectroscopy, quantum scattering theory, and related physics The references also include works on van der Waals forces and isotope shifts The paper cites numerous studies relevant to the field of atomic physics and metrology The list includes foundational texts on scattering theory and quantum mechanics The references also point to experimental setups involving cold atoms and optical lattices Acknowledgements We thank Mateusz Borkowski for the fruitful discussions The research was performed at the National Laboratory FAMO (KL FAMO) in Torun, Poland, and was supported by a subsidy from the Polish Ministry of Science and Higher Education Some of the computations reported in this work were performed using resources of the prime cluster at the Institute of Physics, NCU Funding Renu Bala, Piotr S.
Kai: Zuchowski and Roman Ciuryło acknowledge Polish National Science Centre Project No.
Paper summary: Kai: To recap where we are is that these authors investigated the isotopic effect on collisional widths and shifts of the Hg clock transition 1S0–3P0 when perturbed by cold Rb atoms in the temperature range from one nano-Kelvin to one Kelvin.
Mira: They modeled the Born-Oppenheimer effective interaction potential by including only the leading long-range van der Waals coefficients for this study.
Lev: That means they're starting with a simplified potential model, which is fine for getting the big picture, but we have to be careful about what those coefficients actually capture at these low energies.
Kai: For elastic collisions, they specifically show the connection between line shape parameters in the microkelvin temperature range and scattering lengths in both ground and excited states as a function of reduced mass of colliding Hg and Rb atoms.
Mira: They also confront their full quantum scattering calculations with a semi-classical approximation for these collisional widths and shifts.
Lev: And they found that there are some isotopic pairs for which the collisional effects are minimal, which means those pairs could be suitable for two-species atomic clocks.
Kai: But they also noted the caveat that isotopic variations of collisional broadening and shifting can change when inelastic collisions come into play, specifically mentioning Penning ionization as a source of inelasticity in this system.
Mira: They compared their results only for elastic collisions against those from an Idziaszek and Julienne model by varying probability of reduction of the outgoing scattering flux caused by Penning ionization at short range.
Lev: That comparison is key because it tests whether ignoring the inelastic part truly simplifies things, or if it hides important isotopic effects.
Mira: That's a specific energy regime where we can get an accurate estimate using simple analytical expressions involving scattering lengths for colliding Hg and Rb atoms in the ground (1S0–2S1/two) and excited (3P0–2S1/two) state asymptotes.
Lev: So the paper suggests that at ultra-low temperatures around one microKelvin, these simplified models are valid enough to guide experiment design based on those scattering lengths.
Kai: The full quantum scattering calculations performed at a scattering energy corresponding to one Kelvin agree with the classical approximation within thirty percent and sixty percent, respectively.
Mira: So, in short, this paper looks at the isotopic dependence of collisional widths and shifts of the Hg clock transition induced by cold Rb atoms across that temperature range.
Conclusion: Kai: So to wrap up on this paper "Isotopic effect on collisional widths and shifts of Hg clock transition induced by cold Rb atoms", it’s about how the isotopic dependence changes when you have collisions between mercury and rubidium in the sub-microkelvin regime.
Mira: The authors found that there's a direct link between the line shape parameters you measure at microkelvin temperatures and the scattering lengths in both ground and excited states of those colliding atoms, depending on their reduced mass.
Lev: And they pointed out that some isotopic pairs have minimal collisional effects, which is useful information for designing two-species atomic clocks.
Kai: But they also emphasized that you can't ignore the inelasticity from Penning ionization if you want to get a complete picture of how those isotopic variations evolve.
Mira: The paper shows that at ultra-low temperatures around one microKelvin, we can estimate these collisional parameters using simple analytical expressions based on scattering lengths for the ground and excited state asymptotes.
Lev: So, it provides guidance on where you can use these simplified models to get an estimate for those parameters when designing experiments.
Kai: The results show that at one Kelvin, the full quantum scattering calculations agree with the classical approximation within thirty percent and sixty percent.
Mira: That gives us a concrete measure of how well those approximations hold up in practice for these types of systems.
More episodes
- 2611.14082-Two atoms with strong light-induced dipolar interactions
- 2611.14040-Characterization of BNLs 20 and 30 micrometer thick LGADs for the Electron Ion Collider
- 2611.13399-Lift-element-based dynamic network of vortex gust-airfoil interactions
- 2611.13476-Hopfion Superlattices in 3D Twisted Moir'e Light Fields
- 2611.13642-Investigation of the timing performance of double-sided p-type 3D silicon sensors produced by CNM
- 2611.13830-SiPM optical readout of a PICOSEC Micromegas precise timing detector
- 2611.14152-Where are the shortest-path nodes in spatial networks?
- 2611.14219-Sub-Ice: semi-automated mapping of basal channels from ice shelf surface elevation data
- 2611.16341-SUMNO: Spatially Unrolled Multigrid Neural Operator for Fluid Flow Surrogates
- 2611.16090-Multi-UTE Myelin Fraction Mapping: Repeatability and Cross-Field-Strength Reproducibility at 1.5T and 3T