Electronic-photonic circuit crossings

summary

The gist

Electronic-photonic circuit crossings use topology optimization to devise a single-layer electronic-photonic circuit crossing with up to 99.8 % optical transmission across a 20 nm electrical…

In short

Researchers used topology optimization to design a single-layer electronic-photonic circuit crossing with up to 99.8% optical transmission across a 20 nm electrical trench. This breakthrough allows for crossing electrical wires and photonic waveguides on the same layer without significant resistance or loss, enabling fully integrated nano-opto-electro-mechanical systems.

Key concepts

Topology Optimization
This is a design method where the shape of a structure is optimized mathematically to meet specific performance goals. In this case, it was used to design the exact geometry of the circuit crossing that maximizes optical transmission while minimizing electrical resistance.
Electronic-Photonic Circuit Crossing (EPCC)
An EPCC is a critical junction in integrated circuits where electrical signals (electrons) must cross photonic waveguides (light). The challenge is routing these two fundamentally different particles together on the same chip without causing major signal loss or interference.
Monolithic Device Design
Instead of adding multiple layers or complex structures to route signals, this work created a single, carefully engineered device layer. This allows electrical connections and light paths to cross within that one layer, solving the problem of scaling complexity in traditional solutions.

Terminology used across episodes

This episode discusses

The paper

Electronic-photonic circuit crossings · Read on arXiv

Babak Vosoughi Lahijani, * Marcus Albrechtsen, Rasmus E. Christiansen, Christian A. Rosiek, Konstantinos Tsoukalas, Mathias T. Sutherland, Søren Stobbe

Technical University of Denmark

Electrical control of light in integrated photonics is central to a wide range of research and applications. It is conventionally achieved with thermo-optic tuning, but this suffers from high energy consumption and crosstalk. Nanoelectromechanical photonics could resolve these issues, but integrating this technology with conventional multilayer metal architectures is challenging, and conventional approaches do not allow crossings of electrical wires and photonic waveguides. Here, we use topology optimization to devise a single-layer electronic-photonic circuit crossing with up to 99.8 % optical transmission across a 20 nm electrical isolation trench. We focus our experiments on 100 nm trenches and measure an average transmission of 92.9 % over a 100 nm bandwidth, in excellent agreement with theory. We use these concepts to demonstrate a monolithic silicon nanoelectromechanical add-drop switch in which the flow of photons, electrons, and mechanical motions are fully integrated within the same layer. Our work addresses an important challenge in incorporating opto-electro-mechanical topologies into photonic integrated circuits and may lead to new functionalities in nano-opto-electro-mechanical systems, optomechanics, and integrated quantum photonics.

DOI: 10.1364/OE.608644

Transcript

Introduction to the show: ident: Physics. The day in general physics: instruments, methods and results across the field.

Kai: We're looking at the paper: "Electronic-photonic circuit crossings".

Title and authors: Kai: So, we're looking at this paper now called "Electronic-photonic circuit crossings". It’s about using topology optimization to design a single layer of circuit that lets you cross electrical wires and photonic waveguides without introducing a lot of electrical resistance or optical losses.

Mira: Yeah, so the main thing here is how they managed to put these two fundamentally different things together in one layer, which is really challenging because electronics rely on electron conduction while photonics relies on light propagation <ref:two thousand two hundred four point one four two five seven#pg1. It’s about solving that integration problem directly.

Lev: From my side, I see the big hurdle as adding more layers or processes every time you need to route an electrical signal past a photonic component, which the paper says gets way worse if you have many crossings because the complexity scales superlinearly with those avoided electronic-photonic crossings <ref:two thousand two hundred four point one four two five seven#pg3.

Kai: Exactly. So instead of adding more layers or vias for every crossing, they introduced this carefully engineered and inversely designed monolithic device that lets you cross them using the same layer without big resistance or optical losses <ref:two thousand two hundred four point one four two five seven#pg3. It's a system-level complexity fix, essentially <ref:two thousand two hundred four point one four two five seven#pg3.

Mira: And the methodology they use is topology optimization to find the best shape for this crossing, measuring quality with a figure of merit Φ which they optimize iteratively <ref:two thousand two hundred four point one four two five seven#pg2. The problem is set up so they maximize the minimum of that figure of merit over different wavelengths, like maximizing alpha times lambda i Phi over E lambda i <ref:two thousand two hundred four point one four two five seven#pg2.

Lev: And they solved that using the finite element method in COMSOL Multiphysics to model the structure and find the optimal geometry for this crossing <ref:two thousand two hundred four point one four two five seven#pg2. It’s a continuous constrained optimization problem where they change the geometry systematically to find that best structure <ref:two thousand two hundred four point one four two five seven#pg3.

Kai: What's really impressive is the performance numbers they hit with this design, achieving up to ninety-nine point eight percent optical transmission across just a twenty nanometer electrical isolation trench <ref:two thousand two hundred four point one four two five seven#pg2. That’s a significant jump from what they had before topology optimization <ref:two thousand two hundred four point one four two five seven#pg3.

Title and authors: Mira: They also managed to get a peak transmission of ninety-three point six percent over one hundred nanometer bandwidth, which is pretty dramatic compared to previous work <ref:two thousand two hundred four point one four two five seven#pg3. They even showed that a power transmission of ninety-nine point eight percent means that hundreds of these crossings in series would result in insertion losses below three decibels <ref:two thousand two hundred four point one four two five seven#pg3.

Lev: That scaling property is what matters for real hardware, because if you need to link many components together, you don't want each crossing to kill the signal that much <ref:two thousand two hundred four point one four two five seven#pg3. This suggests a path toward denser integrated systems where this level of transmission is achievable <ref:two thousand two hundred four point one four two five seven#pg3.

Kai: So, they can integrate these crossings into a monolithic silicon nanoelectromechanical add-drop switch where the flow of photons, electrons, and mechanical motions are all fully integrated within the same layer <ref:two thousand two hundred four point one four two five seven#pg3. That’s a very specific application that shows how versatile this design is <ref:two thousand two hundred four point one four two five seven#pg3.

Mira: The experimental verification also looks strong, they fabricated circuits with zero to six crossings using electron-beam lithography and cryogenic deep reactive ion etching on silicon on insulated wafers <ref:two thousand two hundred four point one four two five seven#pg3. They measured an average transmission of ninety-two point nine percent over one hundred nanometer bandwidth, which they found agrees really well with their theory <ref:two thousand two hundred four point one four two five seven#pg3.

Lev: They also showed the curve-fitted design has a broadband figure of merit Φ equal to T over R plus alpha greater than zero point eight nine two for that one hundred nanometer wavelength, which is good data for characterizing the robustness of the structure <ref:two thousand two hundred four point one four two five seven#pg20.

Kai: It’s interesting how robust they claim this design is to small variations in device thickness; they found that a ten nanometer thinner device layer doesn't have a significant influence on the performance at all <ref:two thousand two hundred four point one four two five seven#pg18. That suggests the broadband optimization procedure really made it stable <ref:two thousand two hundred four point one four two five seven#pg18.

Mira: They also mentioned that replacing features that expand modes with a tapering section results in an overall better performance when you average across the full one hundred nanometer bandwidth, which is a good practical design rule <ref:two thousand two hundred four point one four two five seven#pg18. It shows they're thinking about the whole band, not just one point <ref:two thousand two hundred four point one four two five seven#pg18.

Title and authors: Lev: And they also mentioned that for larger networks, where optical transmission becomes a limiting factor, they design additional crossings while relaxing the bandwidth requirement and allowing for smaller but still feasible gaps <ref:two thousand two hundred four point one four two five seven#pg3. That shows they are looking ahead to scaling it up further <ref:two thousand two hundred four point one four two five seven#pg3.

Kai: So, what does this mean for the next steps? They’re looking at how these isolation trenches can be used for thermal isolation or mechanical isolation in nanophotonic devices or even quantum optomechanics <ref:two thousand two hundred four point one four two five seven#pg2. That opens up some new physical possibilities beyond just routing signals <ref:two thousand two hundred four point one four two five seven#pg3.

Mira: And they also mention that these concepts apply to other semiconductor platforms, like gallium arsenide or indium phosphide, which could allow for independent electrical control of quantum emitters in integrated photonic circuits <ref:two thousand two hundred four point one four two five seven#pg3. That tackles a major scaling problem in integrated quantum photonics <ref:two thousand two hundred four point one four two five seven#pg3.

Lev: If you can do that, it could eventually enable things like phonon-photon crossings, which is a really interesting physical interaction to engineer <ref:two thousand two hundred four point one four two five seven#pg3. That’s moving beyond just simple signal routing <ref:two thousand two hundred four point one four two five seven#pg3.

Kai: So, to wrap up this paper "Electronic-photonic circuit crossings", topology optimization allows for crossing electrical connections and photonic waveguides using the same device layer without introducing significant electrical resistance or optical losses <ref:two thousand two hundred four point one four two five seven#pg3. The authors successfully devised a monolithic silicon nanoelectromechanical add-drop switch in which the flow of photons, electrons, and mechanical motions are fully integrated within the same layer <ref:two thousand two hundred four point one four two five seven#pg3. It demonstrates that near-unity transmission is attainable for smaller gaps through topology optimization <ref:two thousand two hundred four point one four two five seven#pg5.

Mira: That's the core finding, and it opens up a lot of possibilities for new research in nano-opto-electro-mechanical systems, optomechanics, and integrated quantum photonics <ref:two thousand two hundred four point one four two five seven#pg3. It’s not just about better routing anymore <ref:two thousand two hundred four point one four two five seven#pg3.

Lev: And I think the real impact is showing that you can achieve these high transmission numbers, like ninety-nine point eight percent, which means hundreds of EPCCs in series would result in insertion losses below three decibels <ref:two thousand two hundred four point one four two five seven#pg5. That's a big step for realizing practical integrated circuits <ref:two thousand two hundred four point one four two five seven#pg3.

Kai: So, the whole point is that this paper proves we can build these integrated systems using topology optimization and it’s a great piece of work to keep an eye on <ref:two thousand two hundred four point one four two five seven#pg3. We’ll see what they do next <ref:two thousand two hundred four point one four two five seven#pg3.

The paper's summary: Kai: So, to recap, they used topology optimization to create a single layer device that lets you cross electrical wires and photonic waveguides without introducing significant electrical resistance or optical losses <ref:two thousand two hundred four point one four two five seven#pg3.

Mira: Right, it's about solving the problem of routing electrons and photons inside the same microchip by designing a monolithic device where the crossing happens on one layer <ref:two thousand two hundred four point one four two five seven#pg3.

Kai: And they achieved up to ninety-nine point eight percent optical transmission across a twenty nanometer electrical isolation trench <ref:two thousand two hundred four point one four two five seven#pg2. That’s the big number, and it’s really impressive for this kind of integration.

Mira: It is, but the real impact is how they're using that figure of merit, that quality measure, to design a structure that works across a whole range of wavelengths <ref:two thousand two hundred four point one four two five seven#pg2. They aren't just optimizing for one color of light; they’re making sure it works well for the entire band.

Kai: Exactly. And they showed this design is robust; even if you change the device layer thickness by ten nanometers, the performance doesn't really dip much <ref:two thousand two hundred four point one four two five seven#pg18. That stability across parameters is something you need when you’re building actual hardware.

Mira: I think what this means for us is that we can start thinking about much denser integrated systems, where we don't have to stack layers on top of each other just to get the signal through <ref:two thousand two hundred four point one four two five seven#pg3. The power transmission scaling they showed is what really matters there too, because a ninety-nine point eight percent transmission means you can string hundreds of these crossings together and still keep the insertion losses below three decibels <ref:two thousand two hundred four point one four two five seven#pg5.

Kai: So it’s not just about a single crossing; it’s about building these complex networks that handle high data rates, which is what we need for better interconnects in quantum systems <ref:two thousand two hundred four point one four two five seven#pg3.

Mira: And they even connected this to a practical application, showing how you can put this topology-optimized crossing into a monolithic silicon nanoelectromechanical add-drop switch where photons, electrons, and mechanical motions are all fully integrated within the same layer <ref:two thousand two hundred four point one four two five seven#pg3. That’s the kind of holistic system we’re aiming for.

Kai: It opens up new physics too, though; they mentioned using these isolation trenches not just for electrical isolation but also for thermal isolation or mechanical isolation in nanophotonic devices <ref:two thousand two hundred four point one four two five seven#pg2.

Mira: And that's where things get interesting, because if you can use these trenches to isolate things thermally or mechanically, it could lead directly into the area of nano-opto-electro-mechanical systems and quantum optomechanics <ref:two thousand two hundred four point one four two five seven#pg3. That’s a whole new set of possibilities we can explore with this kind of fabrication control.

The paper's improvements: Kai: So, to sum up what they found, the main thing is that topology optimization lets you cross electrical connections and photonic waveguides using the same device layer without adding much electrical resistance or optical losses <ref:two thousand two hundred four point one four two five seven#pg3.

Mira: Right, it’s about solving that integration problem by making a monolithic device where the crossing happens on one layer <ref:two thousand two hundred four point one four two five seven#pg3.

Kai: And they showed this design is robust; even if you change the device layer thickness by ten nanometers, the performance doesn't really dip much <ref:two thousand two hundred four point one four two five seven#pg18. That stability across parameters is something you need when you’re building actual hardware.

Mira: I think what they suggest for improvement is focusing on that broadband figure of merit, that quality measure, and making sure it works well for the entire range of wavelengths <ref:two thousand two hundred four point one four two five seven#pg2. They aren't just optimizing for one color of light; they’re making sure it works well for the entire band.

Kai: They also mentioned that replacing features that expand modes with a tapering section results in an overall better performance when you average across the full one hundred nanometer bandwidth <ref:two thousand two hundred four point one four two five seven#pg18. That’s a practical design rule for making these things work better over time.

Mira: And they also showed that for larger networks, where optical transmission becomes a limiting factor, you should design additional crossings while relaxing the bandwidth requirement and allowing for smaller but still feasible gaps <ref:two thousand two hundred four point one four two five seven#pg3. That tells us how to scale this idea up beyond just one small crossing.

Kai: So they are pushing toward building larger networks that maintain high performance by adapting the gap size based on what the network needs, rather than just optimizing for one perfect number <ref:two thousand two hundred four point one four two five seven#pg3.

Mira: And on a bigger scale, they’re looking at applying these isolation trenches to thermal or mechanical isolation in nanophotonic devices or even quantum optomechanics <ref:two thousand two hundred four point one four two five seven#pg2. That shows the potential for using this geometry beyond just signal routing <ref:two thousand two hundred four point one four two five seven#pg3.

Kai: And they also noted that these concepts apply to other semiconductor platforms, like gallium arsenide or indium phosphide, which could allow for independent electrical control of quantum emitters in integrated photonic circuits <ref:two thousand two hundred four point one four two five seven#pg3. That tackles a major scaling problem in integrated quantum photonics.

Mira: Yes, that’s significant because it means we don't have to be locked into silicon when designing these complex interfaces for quantum systems <ref:two thousand two hundred four point one four two five seven#pg3. This really expands the toolkit for building new kinds of hybrid circuits.

Conclusion: Kai: So to wrap up, we’ve seen how topology optimization allowed them to devise this single layer electronic photonic circuit crossing without introducing significant electrical resistance or optical losses <ref:two thousand two hundred four point one four two five seven#pg3.

Mira: Exactly, it's about solving the integration problem by making a monolithic device where the crossing happens on one layer <ref:two thousand two hundred four point one four two five seven#pg3.

Kai: And they achieved up to ninety-nine point eight percent optical transmission across a twenty nanometer electrical isolation trench <ref:two thousand two hundred four point one four two five seven#pg2. That’s the big number, and it’s really impressive for this kind of integration.

Mira: It is, but the real impact is how they're using that figure of merit, that quality measure, to design a structure that works across a whole range of wavelengths <ref:two thousand two hundred four point one four two five seven#pg2. They aren't just optimizing for one color of light; they’re making sure it works well for the entire band.

Kai: They also showed this design is robust; even if you change the device layer thickness by ten nanometers, the performance doesn't really dip much <ref:two thousand two hundred four point one four two five seven#pg18. That stability across parameters is something you need when you’re building actual hardware.

Mira: I think what they suggest for improvement is focusing on that broadband figure of merit, that quality measure, and making sure it works well for the entire range of wavelengths <ref:two thousand two hundred four point one four two five seven#pg2. They aren't just optimizing for one color of light; they’re making sure it works well for the entire band.

Kai: They also mentioned that replacing features that expand modes with a tapering section results in an overall better performance when you average across the full one hundred nanometer bandwidth <ref:two thousand two hundred four point one four two five seven#pg18. That’s a practical design rule for making these things work better over time.

Mira: And they also showed that for larger networks, where optical transmission becomes a limiting factor, you should design additional crossings while relaxing the bandwidth requirement and allowing for smaller but still feasible gaps <ref:two thousand two hundred four point one four two five seven#pg3. That tells us how to scale this idea up beyond just one small crossing.

Kai: So they are pushing toward building larger networks that maintain high performance by adapting the gap size based on what the network needs, rather than just optimizing for one perfect number <ref:two thousand two hundred four point one four two five seven#pg3.

Mira: And on a bigger scale, they’re looking at applying these isolation trenches to thermal or mechanical isolation in nanophotonic devices or even quantum optomechanics <ref:two thousand two hundred four point one four two five seven#pg2. That shows the potential for using this geometry beyond just signal routing <ref:two thousand two hundred four point one four two five seven#pg3.

Kai: And they also noted that these concepts apply to other semiconductor platforms, like gallium arsenide or indium phosphide, which could allow for independent electrical control of quantum emitters in integrated photonic circuits <ref:two thousand two hundred four point one four two five seven#pg3. That tackles a major scaling problem in integrated quantum photonics.

Mira: Yes, that’s significant because it means we don't have to be locked into silicon when designing these complex interfaces for quantum systems <ref:two thousand two hundred four point one four two five seven#pg3. This really expands the toolkit for building new kinds of hybrid circuits.

Lev: From my side, I gotta say that achieving ninety-nine point eight percent transmission with those fabrication steps sounds like a tough thing to get reliably on real hardware without some huge overhead <ref:two thousand two hundred four point one four two five seven#pg5.

Kai: I hear you on the overhead, Lev, but the way they designed it to be robust against thickness variations suggests that if we can control those fabrication steps well enough, we might get closer to that number <ref:two thousand two hundred four point one four two five seven#pg18.

Mira: The real question is whether they truly accounted for all the noise sources in that measurement record when they calculated the final broadband figure of merit <ref:two thousand two hundred four point one four two five seven#pg20. That is a big assumption there, and it's something we need to check against our theory.

Lev: And for us building error correction hardware, if this scaling holds up in practice across hundreds of crossings, that means the overhead for managing the connections stays manageable <ref:two thousand two hundred four point one four two five seven#pg3. That’s where the real engineering challenge lies.

Kai: So, to wrap up, the paper "Electronic-photonic circuit crossings" shows that topology optimization can build monolithic devices where photons and electrons cross without major loss or resistance <ref:two thousand two hundred four point one four two five seven#pg3.

Mira: It shows we can achieve near unity transmission for small gaps through this method, opening up possibilities for nano-opto-electro-mechanical systems and quantum optomechanics <ref:two thousand two hundred four point one four two five seven#pg3.

Lev: And the scaling property they demonstrated, where hundreds of crossings still keep insertion losses below three decibels, is what makes this interesting for building larger integrated systems <ref:two thousand two hundred four point one four two five seven#pg5.

Kai: It’s a solid piece of work on how to handle that complex integration challenge in silicon chips <ref:two thousand two hundred four point one four two five seven#pg3.

Mira: Next time, we'll be looking at how they apply similar design principles to other semiconductor materials, like gallium arsenide or indium phosphide <ref:two thousand two hundred four point one four two five seven#pg3. That’s where the next big test of this concept will be.

More episodes

← Home