Does quantum mechanics apply to macroscopic objects? How to define macro?

summary

The gist

According to Quantum Mechanics a narrow wave-packet of the center of mass of any macroscopic object should spread out after some time The problem is usually waved out by assuming that due to their…

In short

The paper questions whether quantum mechanics applies to macroscopic objects due to ambiguity in defining them. It analyzes the spreading of center-of-mass wave packets, suggesting a 'super-selection rule' prevents spread out macroscopic objects from appearing. It proposes modifications like gravitational self-trapping or non-linear Schrödinger equations to reconcile quantum theory with classical macroscopic reality.

Key concepts

Macroscopic Object Definition
The paper highlights the fundamental ambiguity in defining what constitutes a 'macroscopic object' for quantum mechanics. This lack of a clear definition makes it difficult to determine if standard quantum rules apply when dealing with objects that are large enough to be classical.
Center of Mass Wave Packet Evolution
The evolution of the wave packet's width is analyzed. While free motion shows spreading, the paper finds that for finite mass, a threshold exists where the spread does not change, suggesting a limit on how much macroscopic objects can spread quantum mechanically.
Super-Selection Rule
This concept suggests an unobserved rule preventing macroscopic objects from exhibiting spread-out center of mass wave packets. The paper posits that this rule implies that a world with widely dispersed mass centers is unlikely to exist under current quantum understanding.

Terminology used across episodes

This episode discusses

The paper

Does quantum mechanics apply to macroscopic objects? How to define macro? · Read on arXiv

Institut f¨ur Theoretische Physik, Goethe-Universit¨at, Frankfurt am Main

According to Quantum Mechanics a narrow wave-packet of the center of mass of any macroscopic object should smear out after some time. The problem is usually waved out by assuming that due to their heavy masses this occurs over astronomical times. Without a clear definition of macroscopic objects this remains ambiguous. On the other hand, Quantum Mechanics allows and energetically even prefers largely smeared out c.m. states that never been seen. Why is this the real state of the world we know? Does it suggest a micro-macro threshold with different theoretical descriptions? Does offer micro-miniaturization a hope for answering these questions?

Transcript

Introduction to the show: ident: Physics. The day in general physics: instruments, methods and results across the field.

Kai: I'm Kai.

Mira: And I'm Mira, here with Lev.

Kai: We're looking at the paper: "Does quantum mechanics apply to macroscopic objects? How to define macro?".

Mira: Here's the gist of the paper. According to Quantum Mechanics a narrow wave-packet of the center of mass of any macroscopic object should spread out after some time The problem is usually waved out by assuming that due to their heavy masses this occurs over astronomical times Without a clear definition of macroscopic objects this remains ambiguous.

Kai: The Ambiguity of Macroscopic Objects One of the strange features of Quantum Mechanics is that for its formulation, one needs the classical physics that one expects to emerge as its macroscopic limit But what is the actual definition of a macroscopic object?

Mira: The basic elements are the concept of the wave function (quantum state), the Schr¨odinger equation for its evolution, the observables and the probabilistic interpretation of the measurement.

Kai: Quantum Mechanics on its own says nothing about its object or the structure of matter Evolution of Center of Mass Wave Packets The solution of the free 1D Schr¨odinger equation for an object of mass M in the form of a Gaussian wave packet (having the ideal uncertainty ∆x∆p = ħ) may represent the free motion of the c.m.

Title and authors: Kai: So we're talking about this paper now, "Does quantum mechanics apply to macroscopic objects? How to define macro?". It starts by saying that according to quantum mechanics, a narrow wave packet for the center of mass of any macroscopic object should spread out after some time.

Mira: That’s the core tension here, isn't it? They immediately point out that most people just wave this problem away by assuming that because these objects are so heavy, this spreading happens over astronomical times.

Lev: And they flag that without a clear definition of what a macroscopic object actually is, this whole discussion stays really ambiguous. It sets up a big question about the limits of quantum mechanics itself.

Kai: Right, and then they bring up the idea that quantum mechanics actually allows and even prefers largely spread out center of mass states that we haven't seen in reality. They suggest there might be some kind of micro-macro threshold where you need a different theoretical description for different scales.

Mira: It’s interesting because it challenges the idea that we are stuck between two completely separate worlds, microscopic quantum stuff and macroscopic classical stuff. This paper is looking for that middle ground or the boundary condition itself.

Lev: From an error correction standpoint, if this spreading is happening, it introduces a sort of uncertainty in the center of mass position that gets scaled by the mass and time squared term you see in their equations. That’s something we have to account for when building any real system.

Kai: Exactly, and they move quickly into some proposals for how we might fix this issue or reconcile these two descriptions. They suggest a possible gravitational self-trapping of the center of mass wave packet, which would be a non-linear modification to the Schrödinger equation.

Mira: That's an interesting direction because it suggests that gravity itself might play a role in trapping or modifying these quantum states, which is something we need to seriously consider when thinking about large systems.

Lev: I see that proposal as introducing a new layer of complexity—a non-linear equation—which would be very hard to implement on current hardware, but it’s a path forward if we want to see any kind of classical limit emerge from the quantum theory.

Kai: They also bring up the idea that some papers suggest modifying quantum mechanics because of how gravity deforms spacetime, which could affect macroscopic objects differently than they do for tiny things. This links directly into what K´arolyh´azy suggested a few years ago.

Mira: That brings us to the point about superposition, too; some researchers insist that macroscopic objects violate the superposition principle in a way that classical dynamics doesn't follow from an underlying quantum theory at all. This suggests classical physics might just be an emergent description, not something derived directly from the quantum one.

Lev: If we look at it through the lens of what runs on real hardware, violating superposition in a way that affects macroscopic systems would mean we need error correction mechanisms that are fundamentally different from what we design for microscopic particles.

Kai: So where do they land on this? They seem to lean towards the idea that classical macroscopic dynamics might not emerge directly from quantum mechanics at all. They suggest the success of quantum theory is more about simplifying isolated systems rather than having a strict vertical structure across all scales.

Mira: That’s a cautious stance, and it’s probably fair given how little we actually know about what a "macroscopic object" even means in this context. This paper forces us to confront the ambiguity right at the start of the discussion.

Lev: The limitation they point out is that there hasn't been any definitive experimental evidence yet to settle where this threshold lies, whether it’s related to mass or some other property of the object. That lack of concrete measurement is what keeps things theoretical for now.

Kai: They mention that the idea of micro-miniaturization might offer a hope for answering these questions, implying that if we can shrink things down enough, maybe we can find some clearer answers about this transition point.

Mira: It’s a very hopeful angle from the authors, but they are careful not to promise any specific technological outcome; it’s more of an invitation to explore that avenue rather than a guaranteed solution. They aren't claiming they found the answer, just pointing toward where the future research should go.

Lev: For me, what this means is that until we can build systems massive enough and controllable enough to test these ideas, we are stuck in this ambiguity. The overhead for testing these kinds of modifications would be enormous compared to current qubit control experiments.

Kai: So to wrap up on this paper, "Does quantum mechanics apply to macroscopic objects? How to define macro?", it really challenges us to think about the relationship between the microscopic and macroscopic worlds when we try to use quantum mechanics as our foundation.

Mira: It’s a paper that highlights that the definition of what we even mean by a macroscopic object is probably one of the biggest hurdles in connecting quantum theory to everything else.

Lev: And for us, it means more work on developing frameworks that can handle these scale transitions, because right now, it just looks like a very deep theoretical problem without any clear experimental roadmap.

The paper's summary: Kai: So, to recap, this paper is basically asking if quantum mechanics actually makes sense when you try to apply it to things we call macroscopic objects, because the standard math suggests those big things should spread out over time.

Mira: Yeah, and they’re not just throwing up numbers; they’re digging into the definition of what a macroscopic object is in this context. It starts by saying that without a solid definition, everything remains totally ambiguous.

Lev: From an engineering standpoint, that ambiguity means we can't even start designing the right tools because we don't know what boundary conditions to expect when we look at large systems.

Kai: Right, and they’re exploring proposals like gravitational self-trapping—a non-linear tweak to the Schrödinger equation—which would try to stop that spreading from happening in a big way.

Mira: And they’re also talking about how this might mess with the superposition principle for these large objects, which is something some theorists think should be respected if quantum mechanics is truly foundational.

Lev: If you want to run this on real hardware, those non-linear modifications introduce a huge computational overhead that we’d need to handle before we even worry about fidelity.

Kai: So the paper suggests that maybe classical physics just doesn't emerge cleanly from the underlying quantum theory in a simple way. It seems to argue that quantum mechanics might be more like a tool for isolated systems than something that describes everything at once.

Mira: Exactly, and they imply that we need to figure out if there’s any mathematical reason why the spread-out center of mass shouldn't happen, or if it’s just because we haven't found the right physics yet.

Lev: For someone focused on error correction, this means any attempt to build a quantum computer for large-scale simulations would need to account for these scale transitions in its fundamental assumptions.

Kai: It really puts us in a position where we have to decide if we are looking at the correct physical regime when we try to use quantum mechanics to describe something massive.

Mira: And the big question left is, what does this mean for our understanding of how quantum physics connects to gravity and classical reality?

The paper's improvements: Tom: So, we’re looking at how the authors suggest ways to fix these problems they found in their original work on macroscopic objects.

Kai: They propose using a non-linear modification of the Schrödinger equation, which would be something like gravitational self-trapping for the center of mass wave packet.

Mira: That’s interesting because it suggests that gravity itself could actually trap or modify these quantum states, rather than just being a background effect.

Lev: From an engineering perspective, implementing a non-linear Schrödinger equation on real hardware is tough; you'd need very complex simulation techniques just to model the system dynamics.

Kai: They also bring up ideas from other researchers, like K´arolyh´azy, suggesting that the gravitational deformation of spacetime by a body could change how quantum mechanics works for it.

Mira: And they’re pushing the idea that some papers suggest macroscopic objects violate superposition in a way that classical dynamics doesn't follow from the underlying quantum theory at all.

Lev: If you’re building an error corrector, that means you have to design your correction based on whether those large objects are obeying standard quantum rules or these modified gravity rules.

Kai: They also bring up the idea of decoherence mechanisms specifically, looking at why contact with the environment doesn't necessarily destroy superposition in linear master equations.

Mira: That’s a big assumption, though; they need to prove that the linearity holds even when you factor in these macroscopic interactions. It’s a lot of work just to justify that step.

Lev: The main limitation here, as the authors flag, is that they are proposing theoretical modifications without having any concrete experimental results yet to back up those non-linear behaviors in a real system.

Kai: So essentially, they’re suggesting ways to push the boundaries of standard quantum mechanics by bringing in gravity and non-linearity to see if we can get a better picture of the macroscopic limit.

Mira: It shifts the focus from just defining what an object is to figuring out what physical laws need to be added or modified when dealing with large systems.

Lev: For hardware development, this means we have another layer of complexity—we’d need to model not just quantum noise but also these spacetime distortions if we ever want to simulate something truly macroscopic.

Kai: It’s a lot of theoretical heavy lifting, but it shows the authors are trying to bridge that gap between the microscopic math and the big world we actually live in.

Mira: And that bridge is where a lot of our current physics is still missing some critical pieces.

Conclusion: Kai: So we’re wrapping up this look at "Does quantum mechanics apply to macroscopic objects? How to define macro?". Basically, the paper shows that we can't just assume quantum rules work for big things without some serious modification or a new definition of what 'macro' even means.

Mira: Right, and the authors suggest that maybe classical physics doesn't emerge smoothly from quantum mechanics at all, but rather through these gravitational or non-linear corrections.

Lev: It really puts the burden on us to figure out which assumptions—the standard quantum rules or these proposed gravity corrections—actually need to be true for a physical system we can build.

Kai: The main implication is that we might have to look at the connection between gravity and quantum mechanics in a way that’s much more complex than just adding them together.

Mira: It changes how we think about the fundamental structure of reality, suggesting there might be some scale-dependent behavior that standard quantum theory doesn't capture on its own.

Lev: For hardware, it means any future simulation of large systems will have to include these non-linear terms or gravitational deformations if we want to get close to the paper's proposed physics.

Kai: We’re still waiting for real experiments that can test these ideas, but this paper sets up a clearer roadmap for what kind of modifications we should be looking for in future work.

Mira: It highlights that defining the proper boundary between the quantum and classical worlds is perhaps the biggest outstanding problem in this area.

Lev: I think we need to keep pushing for error correction methods that can handle these kinds of scale-dependent corrections, because that’s where things get really messy on real hardware.

Kai: Well, that’s it for "Does quantum mechanics apply to macroscopic objects? How to define macro?". It’s a deep dive into the limits of our current quantum framework when we try to apply it beyond tiny particles.

Mira: And as always, it underscores how much more we need to understand the underlying assumptions of any theory before we can really say what it means for the world.

Lev: Next up, we’re going to look at that paper on experimental scaling of diffraction efficiency in laser-induced plasma gratings.

More episodes

← Home