Development of a Multi-Purpose Optical TPC for Neutron-Induced Reaction Studies at SARAF

summary

The gist

Optical Time Projection Chambers (OTPCs) are being developed as a multi-purpose detector optimized for precision neutron-reaction studies at SARAF to address poorly constrained cross sections in…

In short

Optical Time Projection Chambers (OTPCs) are being developed for precision neutron-reaction studies at SARAF to constrain stellar and Big Bang nucleosynthesis models. The prototype, built with Ar/CF4 gas, demonstrated electron drift velocity and light amplification. Future plans involve a larger detector capable of 3D track reconstruction using PMT signals and CMOS camera timing.

Key concepts

Optical Time Projection Chamber (OTPC)
A multi-purpose detector designed to measure the path and properties of charged particles, like alpha tracks, in a gas. It uses light produced by particle interactions to reconstruct the 3D trajectory of particles with high precision.
Charge Multiplication and Light Production
These processes occur when electrons drift through the gas under an electric field and interact with internal meshes. This interaction generates both measurable electrical charge signals and scintillation light, allowing for detailed analysis of particle energy deposition.
Event-by-Event Kinematics
The ability of the detector to record all information about a single detected event individually. This includes tracking the precise path, timing, and particle type (like alpha particles) associated with that specific interaction, which is crucial for understanding nuclear reactions.
Geant4 Simulation Framework
A computational tool used to model how neutrons interact with the detector material. This framework helps researchers predict what background noise or signal they might expect during actual experiments before running them.

Terminology used across episodes

This episode discusses

The paper

Development of a Multi-Purpose Optical TPC for Neutron-Induced Reaction Studies at SARAF · Read on arXiv

R. Felkai, M. Borysova, L. Moleri, J. Pienaar, D. Vartsky, A. Breskin,  I Mor,  L Weissmanb and S Bressler

Department of Particle Physics and Astrophysics, Weizmann Institute of Science · Soreq Nuclear Research Center

Neutron-induced reactions play a central role in stellar and Big Bang nucleosynthesis models. Yet many of the cross sections remain poorly constrained at astrophysically relevant energies. To address these needs, we are developing a multi-purpose Optical Time Projection Chamber (OTPC) optimized for precision neutron-reaction studies at the Soreq Applied Research Accelerator Facility (SARAF) upcoming high-intensity, time-of-flight neutron beam. The detector combines a drift chamber filled with CF4-based scintillating gas mixtures, fast photodetectors for prompt scintillation detection, and high-speed optical readout of avalanche-induced secondary scintillation to enable full 3D reconstruction of charged-particle tracks. A prototype system has been assembled and tested. This has enabled systematic characterization of electron drift velocity, charge and light amplification, and 2D optical imaging of alpha-particle tracks in an Ar/CF4 gas mixture. These studies guide the design of a larger, fully integrated OTPC system intended for operation at SARAF. In parallel, we are exploring advanced image sensors to further enhance tracking resolution. We report on recent progress with the prototype and outline the next steps toward commissioning the full system.

DOI: 10.22323/1.511.0423

Transcript

Introduction to the show: ident: Physics. The day in general physics: instruments, methods and results across the field.

Kai: We're looking at the paper: "Development of a Multi-Purpose Optical TPC for Neutron-Induced Reaction Studies at SARAF".

Mira: Here's the gist of the paper. Optical Time Projection Chambers (OTPCs) are being developed as a multi-purpose detector optimized for precision neutron-reaction studies at SARAF to address poorly constrained cross sections in stellar and Big Bang nucleosynthesis models The upcoming SARAFII upgrade will deliver a broad energy, intense pulsed fast-neutron beamline where an OTPC offers event-by-event kinematics and particle identification for all charged products in a single device The science scope includes neutron-induced fission followed by lighter reactions of astrophysical interest such as 7Be(n, α)α, p(n, γ)d, and 16O(n, α)13C Detector Concept and Prototype The detector concept involves a compact OTPC assembled at the Weizmann Institute to validate all subsystems including charge drift, charge multiplication and light production, light and charge readout, and 2D track imaging The baseline gas used is Ar/CF4 (95:5) at 1 bar which offers high electroluminescence yield matched to modern CMOS sensors The detector active volume is defined by a cylindrical field cage consisting of 21 FR4 rings clad on one side with a thin copper layer, resulting in an active volume of 0.4 L Charge multiplication and light production are provided by a two-step parallel-mesh multiplier made of three similar steel meshes A1, A2, and A3 The low-noise charge-sensitive preamplifier is connected to the mesh on which the electrons are collected: A1 in drift-only, A2 in a single-gap configuration, and A3 in the nominal two-gap configuration Preliminary Results Preliminary results include systematic characterization of electron drift velocity, charge and light amplification, and 2D optical imaging of alpha-particle tracks in an Ar/CF4 gas mixture The electron drift velocity was measured with the detector in drift-only mode, yielding an electron drift velocity of 80 mm/μs for a typical drift field of 200 V/cm Characterization of the scintillation performance showed that at the highest fields, the absolute yield rises faster than exponentially while the relative yield drops, indicating secondary effects start driving electrical instabilities An early look at alpha tracks captured by the CMOS sensor demonstrated a technical demonstration of synchronizing the camera with the PMT for offline analysis using camera timing output Next-generation Detector and Conclusion The next endeavor is to construct a larger detector featuring a larger drift length of about 20 cm, sized to contain 241Am alpha tracks at pressures down to 150 mbar The custom-made vessel has already been produced, and the dedicated gas system will allow mixing of up to four gases with pressure tunable from 10 mbar to 1 bar The initial campaign for commissioning will be performed with 10B targets that have already been produced A simulation framework based on Geant4 is being developed to estimate the expected neutron-induced background in different configurations Acknowledgements The research received support from the Pazy Foundation, the Minerva Foundation with funding from the Federal German Ministry for Education and Research, and the Nella and Leon Benoziyo Center for High Energy Physics Gratitude is extended to Dr.

Kai: Volker Dangendorf for providing the vacuum vessel and gas system used in these studies Support was also received from the Krenter-Perinot Center for High-Energy Particle Physics, the Shimon and Golde Picker–Weizmann Annual Grant, and the Sir Charles Clore Prize Gratitude is extended to Martin Kushner Schnur for his invaluable contribution to this research References

1: M.

Mira: Gai et al., Time Projection Chamber (TPC) detectors for nuclear astrophysics studies with gamma beams, Nucl.

Kai: Instrum.

Title and authors: Kai: So we're looking at this paper called "Development of a Multi-Purpose Optical TPC for Neutron-Induced Reaction Studies at SARAF". It sounds like they're building something pretty specific for studying how neutrons interact with stuff in stars and in the early universe, which is where those cross sections are really hard to pin down.

Mira: Yeah, that's the main motivation. They are developing this multi-purpose Optical Time Projection Chamber, or OTPC, specifically to handle the high-intensity pulsed fast neutron beam coming from SARAF II. It’s about getting event by event kinematics and particle identification for all charged products in one place.

Lev: From my side, the implication is that this device needs to be robust enough to handle those fast neutrons and produce clean signals for the experiments they are aiming for.

Kai: Right, so what they're actually doing is building a prototype at the Weizmann Institute to test all the different parts of it—the charge drift, how it multiplies charge, and how it produces light. It’s a big validation step before they get to the full scale machine.

Mira: They are using an Argon and Carbon Tetrafluoromethane mixture, Ar/CF4 at one bar pressure. That gas choice is pretty standard because it gives them a high electroluminescence yield that matches modern sensors like CMOS cameras.

Lev: And they've got this cylindrical field cage setup, ten centimeters in diameter with a five centimeter drift length, which gives them an active volume of zero point four liters <ref:2605.31382#pg2>. That size seems tailored to capture those alpha tracks they are interested in.

Kai: They also described how the charge multiplication and light production work by using a two-step parallel-mesh multiplier made of three steel meshes, labeled A1, A2, and A3. That setup is what lets them get that signal amplification going.

Mira: And they've connected a low-noise charge sensitive preamplifier to these meshes differently—A1 for drift only, A2 for a single gap configuration, and A3 in the nominal two gap configuration. It shows they are testing different ways to capture the signals.

Lev: That distinction between those configurations is important because it tells you how much noise you can suppress when you're trying to measure tiny changes in charge or light.

Kai: Now for the preliminary results, they characterized the electron drift velocity and also looked at how much charge and light amplification they get. They found an electron drift velocity of eighty millimeters per microsecond for a typical drift field of two hundred volts per centimeter.

Mira: That drift velocity measurement is key because it sets the timescale for when things happen inside the detector, which helps with timing the events. But they also noted something about the scintillation performance at high fields.

Lev: They found that at their highest fields, the absolute light yield starts rising faster than exponentially while the relative yield drops, which suggests that secondary effects are starting to drive electrical instabilities in the system. That’s a warning sign for scaling up.

Title and authors: Kai: It’s interesting because it shows that when you push the electric field too hard, things get messy electrically before you even worry about the physics of neutron reactions. They also showed an early look at alpha tracks captured by their CMOS sensor which demonstrated they can synchronize the camera with a Photomultiplier Tube for offline analysis using camera timing output.

Mira: So it’s not just a static measurement; they are trying to build a system where you can combine the PMT signals and the camera frames to reconstruct those three dee tracks, which is what’s really needed for this kind of astrophysics <ref:2605.31382#pg1>.

Lev: That combination of the timing from the PMT and the spatial information from that camera is exactly how you get that full time stamped three dee optical readout they are aiming for in their next iteration <ref:2605.31382#pg1>.

Kai: The next major step they are taking is building a larger detector, about twenty centimeters long, which will be sized to contain two hundred forty-one Americium alpha tracks at pressures down to one hundred fifty millibar. That’s a significant increase in scale and pressure capability.

Mira: They've already produced the custom vessel for this larger detector, which is good news because it means they are ready to move into the commissioning phase soon. The gas system they have allows them to mix up to four different gases and tune the pressure from ten millibar up to one bar.

Lev: Having that gas mixing capability is crucial because it opens up more options for tuning the detection characteristics, which you can adjust based on what you're trying to measure—like changing the gas mixture for better neutron rejection or light yield.

Kai: Before they start the main run, their initial commissioning campaign will use ten boron targets that they have already produced, and they are developing a simulation framework based on Geant4 to estimate what kind of neutron-induced background they should expect in different configurations.

Mira: It sounds like a very methodical approach. They aren't just hoping for the best with the data; they’re setting up simulations to predict the noise so they can filter it out later. That simulation work is really important for validating their detector design against reality.

Lev: From an error correction standpoint, building that Geant4 framework now means you’re testing your reconstruction algorithms on realistic background scenarios before you even put the whole apparatus online. That saves a lot of time when you're dealing with high-energy backgrounds from neutron sources like SARAF II.

Kai: So, to wrap up this part of the story, the development of this Multi-Purpose Optical TPC for Neutron-Induced Reaction Studies at SARAF shows they are moving past just building a basic detector and are now focusing on systematic characterization. They've measured drift velocity and seen those instabilities at high fields, which directly informs the design of their larger twenty centimeter detector.

Title and authors: Mira: And the implication for us is that this OTPC is becoming a versatile tool, not just for one specific measurement but as a general-purpose detector capable of providing event by event kinematics for all charged products in neutron experiments.

Lev: And I’d add that the next phase with the larger vessel and tunable gas systems will let them really push those performance metrics while keeping the error budget in mind, which is exactly what you need when you’re dealing with such intense beams at SARAF II.

Kai: So they are putting all these pieces together—the physics goals, the prototype testing, and the system characterization—to make sure this device is ready for its ultimate job in probing those poorly constrained cross sections in stellar and Big Bang nucleosynthesis models.

Mira: Exactly. They're creating a device that offers event by event kinematics and particle identification for all charged products in a single device, which is attractive for cross-section measurements and for background rejection, as the paper says.

Lev: And the fact that they are developing a simulation framework based on Geant4 to estimate the expected neutron-induced background means they’re already thinking about how to manage the noise overhead when you try to run this on real hardware.

Kai: So, we've seen them build the prototype, measured those drift velocities of eighty millimeters per microsecond, and they've identified that secondary effects start driving electrical instabilities at high fields. That gives them a clear path forward for building out that larger twenty centimeter detector.

Mira: And they’re planning to use that larger vessel with gas pressure tunable from ten millibar to one bar, which lets them explore different Ar/CF4 and He/CF4 mixtures for optimal performance.

Lev: That tuning capability is what makes the system flexible enough to adapt when you move from characterization mode to actual physics measurement mode.

Kai: Ultimately, they are aiming for a fully time stamped three dee optical readout in their next iteration using a Timepixthree based camera, which will be the final goal for tracking alpha tracks in three dimensional space <ref:2605.31382#pg1>.

Mira: And that combination of PMT signals and camera frames is what they need to achieve the full three dee reconstruction capability they are targeting for this kind of astrophysical science <ref:2605.31382#pg1>.

Lev: It’s a solid plan, but you have to remember that getting that high fidelity readout on real hardware at SARAF II will be the real test of whether those initial measurements hold up under the actual experimental conditions.

Kai: So, in summary, the development of this Multi-Purpose Optical TPC for Neutron-Induced Reaction Studies at SARAF is a detailed look at building a versatile tool optimized for precision neutron-reaction studies.

Mira: And it’s about creating a detector that offers event by event kinematics and particle identification for all charged products in a single device to address those hard cross sections in stellar and Big Bang nucleosynthesis models.

Lev: And the next step is taking that larger detector with its tunable gas systems and running it against actual boron targets to see how the simulations hold up.

The paper's summary: Kai: So, to recap, this paper is about building a multi-purpose Optical Time Projection Chamber for precision neutron studies at SARAF to figure out some really hard cross sections in stellar and Big Bang nucleosynthesis models.

Mira: Right, they’re making one device that can handle the whole process—from the initial neutron hitting something, through the fission reaction, all the way to identifying what comes out afterward. It’s about getting all those charged particles tracked in a single setup.

Lev: From my side, it sounds like they are trying to solve a major problem in nuclear astrophysics where we don't have enough data on how neutrons react with certain isotopes in stars or during the Big Bang.

Kai: Exactly. They’re using this OTPC to get event by event kinematics and particle identification for all those charged products, which is crucial for making sense of what’s happening inside those extreme environments.

Mira: The methodology they're using involves a specific gas mixture, Argon mixed with Carbon Tetrafluoromethane at one bar pressure, and then they use a clever setup of charge multiplication with three steel meshes to boost the signal.

Lev: And that mesh setup is key because it lets them test how the charge multiplies in different ways, which is how you get those signals back to the electronics.

Kai: They’ve done some preliminary work already, measuring things like electron drift velocity and looking at how much light and charge amplification they get in that Ar/CF4 gas mixture.

Mira: They found a drift velocity of eighty millimeters per microsecond for a two hundred volt per centimeter field, which is a solid starting point for their measurements.

Lev: But they also noted that at the highest fields, the absolute light yield starts rising faster than exponentially while the relative yield drops, which points to some electrical instabilities kicking in when you push the electric field too hard.

Kai: That’s a good warning sign because it tells them they need to be careful when scaling up this detector design for SARAF II.

Mira: They’re planning a next step where they build a much bigger version, about twenty centimeters long, designed to hold two hundred forty-one Americium alpha tracks at pressures down to one hundred fifty millibar.

Lev: That's a big jump in scale and pressure capability, which is what you need for the high-intensity beamline they have planned.

Kai: They’ve already got the custom vessel made, and they can tune the gas system to mix up to four different gases and change the pressure from ten millibar all the way up to one bar.

Mira: That tuning ability means they can really explore different Ar/CF4 and He/CF4 mixtures to see which one gives them better results for their specific physics goals.

Lev: And before they run the big experiment, they're using ten boron targets that they’ve already made, and they’re building a simulation framework based on Geant four to estimate the background noise.

Kai: That simulation work is really smart; it lets them predict what kind of noise to expect so they can design their filters and reconstruction algorithms right from the start.

Mira: The final goal for this setup is a fully time stamped three dimensional optical readout, which they plan to achieve using a Timepix three based camera in the next iteration.

Lev: That combination of signals is what gives them that full spatial information—the timing from the photodetector and the three dee coordinates from the camera—to reconstruct those alpha tracks in space.

Kai: So, it’s not just about building a detector; it’s about creating a system that offers event by event kinematics for all charged products in one device, which is what makes this OTPC so useful for their science at SARAF.

Mira: It's definitely going to be a versatile tool, and the next step with that larger vessel and the tunable gas systems will let them really push those performance metrics.

Lev: And that tuning capability is what makes the system flexible enough to adapt when you move from just testing performance to actual physics measurement mode.

Kai: So, they’re putting all these pieces together—the physics goals, the prototype testing, and the system characterization—to make sure this device is ready for its ultimate job in probing those poorly constrained cross sections in stellar and Big Bang nucleosynthesis models.

Mira: Exactly. They're creating a device that offers event by event kinematics and particle identification for all charged products in a single device to address those hard cross sections in stellar and Big Bang nucleosynthesis models.

Lev: And the fact that they are developing that Geant four simulation framework means they’re already thinking about how to manage the noise overhead when you try to run this on real hardware.

Kai: So, we've seen them build the prototype, measured those drift velocities of eighty millimeters per microsecond, and they've identified that secondary effects start driving electrical instabilities at high fields. That gives them a clear path forward for building out that larger twenty centimeter detector.

The paper's improvements: Tom: So, to wrap up what we just heard, this paper isn't just stopping at building the prototype; they are also laying out how to make it better for future use in real experiments.

Kai: Exactly. They’re not just showing us what they built at the Weizmann Institute; they’re giving us a roadmap for scaling up to SARAF II with twenty centimeters of drift length.

Mira: They are suggesting that the next version needs to be much larger, big enough to contain two hundred forty-one Americium alpha tracks at pressures as low as one hundred fifty millibar.

Lev: That’s a significant increase in scale and pressure capability, which is exactly what you need for the high-intensity beamline they have planned.

Kai: And they are confirming that the custom vessel for this larger detector has already been produced, which means they’re ready to move into the commissioning phase very soon.

Mira: They also mentioned that their dedicated gas system will allow them to mix up to four different gases and tune the pressure from ten millibar all the way up to one bar.

Lev: That tuning ability is crucial because it opens up more options for tuning the detection characteristics, which you can adjust based on what you're trying to measure.

Kai: They’re focusing on making sure they can explore different Argon and Carbon Tetrafluoromethane mixtures for optimal performance in those experiments.

Mira: And they are also developing a simulation framework based on Geant four to estimate the expected background noise in different configurations before they start the main run.

Lev: That simulation work is really smart; it lets them predict what kind of noise to expect so they can design their filters and reconstruction algorithms right from the start.

Kai: They also plan to perform an initial commissioning campaign using ten boron targets that they have already produced, which is a practical way to test the system early on.

Mira: The ultimate goal for this next iteration is a fully time stamped three dimensional optical readout, which they plan to achieve using a Timepix three based camera.

Lev: That combination of signals—the timing from the photodetector and the spatial information from that camera—is what gives them that full three dee coordinate reconstruction capability in space.

Kai: So, it’s not just about building a detector; it’s about creating a system that offers event by event kinematics for all charged products in one device, which is what makes this OTPC so useful for their science at SARAF.

Mira: It's definitely going to be a versatile tool, and the next step with that larger vessel and the tunable gas systems will let them really push those performance metrics.

Lev: And that tuning capability is what makes the system flexible enough to adapt when you move from just testing performance to actual physics measurement mode.

Kai: So, they’re putting all these pieces together—the physics goals, the prototype testing, and the system characterization—to make sure this device is ready for its ultimate job in probing those poorly constrained cross sections in stellar and Big Bang nucleosynthesis models.

Conclusion: Kai: So, to wrap up this discussion on "Development of a Multi-Purpose Optical TPC for Neutron-Induced Reaction Studies at SARAF", we’ve seen how they’re moving from a prototype to a system ready for real physics experiments.

Mira: They are creating a versatile tool, and the next step with that larger vessel and the tunable gas systems will let them really push those performance metrics.

Lev: I just want to say that their simulation work on the Geant four framework is essential because it lets them test their reconstruction algorithms against realistic background scenarios before they put everything online.

Kai: It’s a solid plan, but you have to remember that getting that high fidelity readout on real hardware at SARAF II will be the real test of whether those initial measurements hold up under the actual experimental conditions.

Mira: And the implication for us is that this OTPC is becoming a versatile tool, not just for one specific measurement but as a general-purpose detector capable of providing event by event kinematics for all charged products in neutron experiments.

Lev: And I’d add that the next phase with the larger detector and those tunable gas systems will let them really explore different Ar/CF4 and He/CF4 mixtures for optimal performance.

Kai: It’s a solid plan, but you have to remember that getting that high fidelity readout on real hardware at SARAF II will be the real test of whether those initial measurements hold up under the actual experimental conditions.

Mira: And they're creating a device that offers event by event kinematics and particle identification for all charged products in a single device to address those hard cross sections in stellar and Big Bang nucleosynthesis models.

Lev: That combination of PMT signals and camera frames is what they need to achieve the full three dee coordinate reconstruction capability they are targeting for this kind of astrophysical science.

Kai: So, we’ve seen them build the prototype, measured those drift velocities of eighty millimeters per microsecond, and they've identified that secondary effects start driving electrical instabilities at high fields. That gives them a clear path forward for building out that larger twenty centimeter detector.

Mira: It's definitely going to be a versatile tool, and the next step with that larger vessel and the tunable gas systems will let them really push those performance metrics.

Lev: I just want to say that their simulation work on the Geant four framework is essential because it lets them test their reconstruction algorithms against realistic background scenarios before they put everything online.

Kai: So, in summary, this paper details how they are developing a Multi-Purpose Optical TPC for Neutron-Induced Reaction Studies at SARAF.

Mira: It’s about creating a detector that offers event by event kinematics and particle identification for all charged products in a single device to address those hard cross sections in stellar and Big Bang nucleosynthesis models.

Lev: And the next step is taking that larger detector with its tunable gas systems and running it against actual boron targets to see how the simulations hold up.

More episodes

← Home