Absolute intensity measurement of pulsed muon beams using in-beam activation
summary
The gist
The absolute number of negative muons contained in a beam is essential for many experiments at accelerator facilities, but determining it in pulsed beams has been difficult…
In short
The study developed a method using $\beta$-delayed $\gamma$ rays from residual nuclei after muon capture to determine absolute intensity in pulsed muon beams. By measuring production branching ratios (BRs) of specific isotopes, researchers can calculate the total number of muons in the pulse, offering a practical calibration technique for beam monitors.
Key concepts
- Pulsed Muon Beam Intensity
- Determining the exact number of negative muons arriving during a short pulse. This is crucial because accelerator experiments depend on knowing this absolute intensity to correctly normalize measurements like cross-sections and detector designs.
- In-Beam Activation Method
- A technique where the muon beam itself is used as a source to induce nuclear reactions in a target material. The resulting $\beta$-delayed $\gamma$ rays are then measured to deduce the production branching ratios, which are then used to calculate the total muon number.
- Production Branching Ratio (BR)
- A measure of how frequently a specific nuclear reaction occurs when a muon captures on a target nucleus. These BRs are determined experimentally and serve as the key input for calculating the absolute intensity of the pulsed beam.
- $N_{\mu^-} = N_{\gamma}/I_{\gamma} \epsilon_{\gamma} r_{decay} bP_{cap}$
- The mathematical formula used to relate the measured $\gamma$-ray yield ($N_{\gamma}$) to the unknown total number of muons ($N_{\mu^-}$). This relationship incorporates known factors like $\gamma$-ray intensity, detection efficiency, and muon capture probability derived from atomic lifetime.
Terminology used across episodes
This episode discusses
The paper
Absolute intensity measurement of pulsed muon beams using in-beam activation · Read on arXiv
R. Mizuno, M. Niikurac, T. Matsuzakic, A. D. Hillierd, K. Ishidae, S. Kawasef, §Kawataf, §Kitafujif and D. Tomonog
Department of Physics, Graduate School of Science, The University of Tokyo · Nishina Center, RIKEN · ISIS Neutron and Muon Facility · High Energy Accelerator Research Organization (KEK) · Department of Advanced Energy Science and Engineering, Kyushu University · Research Center for Nuclear Physics, The University of Osaka
Transcript
Introduction to the show: ident: Physics. The day in general physics: instruments, methods and results across the field.
Kai: We're looking at the paper: "Absolute intensity measurement of pulsed muon beams using in-beam activation".
Mira: Here's the gist of the paper. The absolute number of negative muons contained in a beam is essential for many experiments at accelerator facilities, but determining it in pulsed beams has been difficult, particularly at high intensities The method utilizing the yield of the β delayed γ rays from the residual nuclei after the muon nuclear capture reaction has recently been developed to determine the muon number in the pulsed muon beam In particular, the in-beam activation method employs isotopes with short lifetimes, enabling the beam intensity to be measured over a short period with irradiating muon beams The determination of beam intensity is a fundamental requirement for experiments at accelerator facilities, since the absolute beam intensity directly affects the normalization of cross-section measurements and the design of detector systems For pulsed muon beams, this determination is particularly challenging due to their characteristic time structure: a large number of muons arriving periodically within a short pulse width, typically on the order of tens of nanoseconds A conventional approach to determine the pulsed muon beam intensity is direct counting using a scintillation counter This method provides a reasonable estimate when the number of muons per pulse is small, typically up to a few tens of muons per pulse
1, 2: , but becomes unreliable in modern pulsed muon facilities such as J-PARC MUSE and RAL-ISIS, where thousands of muons arrive in a pulse Experimental Setup and Methodology The experiment was conducted at Port 4 of the ISIS Neutron and Muon Source at Rutherford Appleton Laboratory (RIKEN-RAL beamline) A proton beam was accelerated to 800 MeV by the ISIS rapid cycling synchrotron, and four out of every five pulses were directed to Target Station 1 (TS1) The absolute number of muons per pulse was deduced from the charge integral of the plastic scintillator signal, which was calibrated using the known production BR of the 27Al(μ−, νμ)27Mg reaction, 9.90(33)%
7: The beam intensity was approximately 40 particles per pulse The targets were installed 1 mm downstream of the plastic scintillator The beta-delayed γ rays were measured using a germanium detector (Canberra GX5019)
14: To reduce environmental background, the plastic scintillator, target, and detector were enclosed in lead shielding Production Branching Ratio Determination The production BR was deduced following the procedure described in the previous studies
1, 7: The production BR in this study is defined as the independent production yield of a ground or isomeric state normalized by the number of muon nuclear captures Table 3 compares the present and previous values All previous values was measured using activation method The results of natZn have implications for the dominance of neutron emission channels In particular, the BR of 67,68,69Cu is attributed to neutron emissions from muonic 67,68,70Zn Deducing Muon Beam Intensity The measured production BRs can be utilized to determine the pulsed muon beam intensity The total number of muons in the pulsed beam (Nμ−) is related to the observed γ-ray yield (Nγ) by Nμ− = Nγ/Iγ εγ rdecay bPcap, (1) The muon capture probability Pcap can be derived from the lifetime of the muonic atom (τ) as Pcap = 1 − τμ+ / Q, (2) Muon beam intensity can be determined from Eq.
Kai: (1) using the above-mentioned known values together with bPcap, which is derived in the present work From a viewpoint of target preparation, P and Mn are difficult to use owing to their fragility Considering the magnitude of the BR, the muon capture probability, the practical detection efficiency of the γ-ray detector, and the absence of the target material in surrounding structures, natPd (μ−, νμx)107m,105mRh and natAg (μ−, νμx)107mPd are identified as ideal candidates for beam intensity measurement using the in-beam activation method From a practical point of view, the in-beam activation method is a useful technique for calibrating beam intensity monitoring system Owing to the absence of peak overlap with γ rays from other residual nuclei, background, or escape peaks, and the lack of any required yield correction, the reaction natAg (μ−, νμx)107mPd, with a production BR of 1.72(10)%, is shown to be useful for the calibration of muon numbers in pulses The absolute production BRs for natCu, natZn, and natAg were obtained The obtained results are consistent with the general trend of the previous studies, but the measurement of the isotopically enriched target is necessary for further discussion The method for evaluating the intensity of pulsed muon beams is also discussed, based on the measured production BR, along with previously measured values Owing to the absence of peak overlap with γ rays from other residual nuclei, background, or escape peaks, and the lack of any required yield correction, the reaction natAg (μ−, νμx)107mPd is shown to be useful for the calibration of muon numbers in pulses Candidates for Calibration The candidates identified are based on several criteria: 1.
Mira: γ-ray transitions with no overlap with natural backgrounds or escape peaks, ensuring reliable signal identification The residual isotopes with negligible or no contributions from isomeric states or other parent nuclei are preferred because the presence of multiple decay components requires solving the Bateman equations, complicating the analysis 2.
Kai: Channels with sufficiently large BRs to ensure sufficient counting statistics 3.
Title and authors: Kai: Starting with the title and authors of this paper, "Absolute intensity measurement of pulsed muon beams using in-beam activation," we see right away that the goal is to solve a specific problem: getting an absolute count of muons in a beam where the timing is very fast.
Mira: The authors are Mizunoa, Niikurac, Matsuzakic, Hillierd, Ishidae, Kawasef, Kawataf and Tomonog. They're bringing together experimental setup knowledge with theoretical understanding of these nuclear reactions.
Lev: From an engineering standpoint, I look at the authors and see they are focusing on a method that is feasible in a pulsed beam environment because it avoids needing to measure the full pulse shape directly.
Kai: It sounds like they're trying to use the physics of muon capture—the beta delayed gamma rays—as a proxy for how many muons hit the target in that short window.
Mira: That’s right. The paper sets up this framework using isotopes with short lifetimes, which is crucial because it allows them to measure the beam intensity over a very short time frame while irradiation is happening.
Lev: The real challenge they face, and what I immediately see from their setup description, is that they can't just look at one pulse; they have to manage the background contribution during the interpulse periods, which are about forty milliseconds at J-PARC MUSE and twenty milliseconds at RAL-ISIS <ref:2606.09920#pg2,at J-PARC MUSE and 20>.
Kai: So the method is designed for online monitoring right after irradiation because it bypasses that background issue during those long interpulse gaps.
Mira: They discuss the applicability of this in-beam activation for absolute measurement, and they admit upfront that their ability to do this well depends entirely on having reliable absolute production branching ratio data available.
Lev: That's the big catch, right? If you can't trust those initial BRs—which are usually measured offline—then the whole beam intensity deduction falls apart, and that's a major limitation they highlight.
Kai: So they are essentially saying this method is useful for *calibrating* intensity once you have those reference branching ratios from other studies.
Mira: Precisely. The paper notes that the choice of target material itself has practical constraints, like needing it to be thick enough to stop the muons while minimizing background noise from everything else around it.
The paper's summary: Kai: So, summarizing what the paper actually does is that they develop a technique to measure absolute muon beam intensity by exploiting the beta delayed gamma rays from residual nuclei after muon capture.
Mira: They use this yield to calculate the total number of muons in the pulse by relating it to an equation where you have the gamma ray yield and some physical constants.
Lev: The core calculation involves relating that yield to N mu minus, which is the total number of muons, using a capture probability term that they derive from the lifetime of the muonic atom.
Kai: That capture probability term, P cap, they figure out by taking the difference between two lifetimes involving the positive muon and some other state.
Mira: And then they use this derived capture probability in their main equation to solve for N mu minus using that measured gamma ray yield.
Lev: It’s a complex chain of dependencies: you need the lifetime, which depends on your assumptions about the atom's properties, and then you plug that into the final intensity calculation.
Kai: They show concrete examples with targets like natCu, natZn, and natAg in their table to illustrate how these numbers are actually measured and what kind of setup is needed.
Mira: The table shows the physical parameters for these targets, including their form size, purity level, the muon capture probability in percent, and the irradiation decay times they use for measurement.
Lev: Looking at those specific numbers—like natZn having a ninety-three point zero percent capture probability and a five h irradiation time—it gives you a clear picture of what kind of target material is needed to get good statistics quickly <ref:2606.09920#pg3>.
The paper's improvements: Kai: The paper suggests the main improvement is making this technique feasible for online monitoring by showing how it can be done promptly after irradiation, which lets us get data while the beam is still active.
Mira: They emphasize that their specific findings regarding target selection are a practical contribution—they narrow down the candidates based on criteria like peak overlap and required yield corrections.
Lev: From an engineering viewpoint, this is significant because they are identifying natAg as a strong candidate because it has no interference from other decay components or background peaks, which simplifies the measurement significantly.
Kai: They show that by using natAg's production branching ratio of one point seven two percent, you get a very useful reference point for calibrating those muon numbers in pulses without having to do complex yield corrections.
Mira: So the suggested improvement is providing a practical calibration formula that uses these measured BRs to determine the beam intensity, which is something that was previously harder to establish.
Lev: It means they are proposing a way for an AI system to perform quantitative comparisons between experimental results and theoretical models from codes like PHITS.
Kai: And they want us to use those comparisons to see where the model makes errors—specifically where it tends to overestimate channels involving charged particle emission compared to experiment.
Conclusion: Mira: To conclude, the paper "Absolute intensity measurement of pulsed muon beams using in-beam activation" provides a way forward for calibrating pulsed muon beam monitors using in-beam activation.
Lev: It establishes that the method is feasible for online monitoring, provided you have reliable absolute production branching ratio data from offline measurements to anchor your calculation.
Kai: The paper points out that they're suggesting natAg as the ideal target because it minimizes background issues during measurement, making it a strong reference point for calibration in pulses.
Mira: They summarize the implications by showing how this approach can be used to determine beam intensity using the measured production branching ratios and previously established values.
Lev: For me, what this means is that we have a method now to use these measurements for practical monitoring systems on real hardware, which helps bridge the gap between theory and experimental reality.
Kai: This paper gives us a concrete recipe for how to use in-beam activation to get those absolute muon numbers in pulses using specific targets.
Mira: It's a useful step toward making beam intensity calibration more accessible for the community by providing clear, practical candidates based on the criteria of signal quality and BR magnitude.
Lev: And ultimately, it gives us a tool that can help refine our understanding of the underlying physics by checking those model predictions against what we actually measure.
More episodes
- 2611.14082-Two atoms with strong light-induced dipolar interactions
- 2611.14040-Characterization of BNLs 20 and 30 micrometer thick LGADs for the Electron Ion Collider
- 2611.13399-Lift-element-based dynamic network of vortex gust-airfoil interactions
- 2611.13476-Hopfion Superlattices in 3D Twisted Moir'e Light Fields
- 2611.13642-Investigation of the timing performance of double-sided p-type 3D silicon sensors produced by CNM
- 2611.13830-SiPM optical readout of a PICOSEC Micromegas precise timing detector
- 2611.14152-Where are the shortest-path nodes in spatial networks?
- 2611.14219-Sub-Ice: semi-automated mapping of basal channels from ice shelf surface elevation data
- 2611.16341-SUMNO: Spatially Unrolled Multigrid Neural Operator for Fluid Flow Surrogates
- 2611.16090-Multi-UTE Myelin Fraction Mapping: Repeatability and Cross-Field-Strength Reproducibility at 1.5T and 3T